Why the Tarnished vs Thor is not a debate

Thor from Gow faces a warm up
store.playstation.com/#!/tid=...

[@DarthVader-xh3mo]

I think the Tarnished poses a problem with the ability to come back over & over again at a site of grace. But the God of Thunder is still taking the W. GOW Thor single-handedly brought the giants close to extinction, hit a world encircling serpent so hard it was sent *back in time* & went toe to toe with Kratos himself. I think Thor alone could solo the whole roster of Elden Ring

[@enol1466]

I mean tarnished beats all those bosses and gods cuz its a video game. You have to kill them. The tarnished dies and loses a ton

[@godskingchampion2730]

yeah same applies to dying

[@MikeL-eo9lp]

Thor solos the verse with ease

[@edwardconner3335]

This depends entirely on the tarnished in question. If it's a parry god that has full spell slots and all spells then scarlet rot destroys Thor. tarnished gets back up & keeps applying rot & poison untill dumpfuck dies. Nothing Thor can do will effect the rot which devours one's mind first the physical rot is manifestation of the damage done to the mind.

[@godskingchampion2730]

All of that is cap,if you watch the vid and actually you would have to proof that rot could effect somebody thats way higher than the tarnished.Thor is Low complex multiversal to mid.Thats higher than anything the tarnished has faced and rot couldnt hurt him physically or mentally as its a magical disease and not a mind hack.Which even if it was,Thor has shown argubale broly level matter of deflecting things that arent strong as him.

[@Darkslayers_son]

I also believe Thor would win, but I feel like a ton of fromsoft fans really hype up Tarnished, overrated at this point

[@comedygold6249]

Tarnished can use scarlet rot or black flames, if it isn't a game, i think he can make the damage on thor stack over multiple retrys

[@jacobjohnson9245]

Hey man. We can't hear you over the game audio

[@godskingchampion2730]

I didnt know it was that lound and it sounds alright to me but i can see if i can chnage it.

[@lennonrivers4750]

that gameplay volume too loud

[@dellmaxson2184]

1: You are correct Thor obviously wins, Thor literally hits the tarnished so hard that he breaks their concept of time directly to the jaw, killing tarnished immediately. 2: While Thor is one of the strongest gods in the G.O.W verse, saying the norses' cosmology is greater than the greek is absolute madness. Now, before you said this, you tried to cover yourself by saying, "Thor is obviously not greater than all the greek gods. I'd be crazy to say that". But all the higher tiers in greece are either able to control concepts & domains or just outright over power them. Fates, Kronos, Atlas, Zues, Ares, Hades, all other primordials. The only norse that can do this is Odin, Freya, Thor, Sigrid & (maybe heimdall).

[@godskingchampion2730]

Ok.. but how does that not proof what I'm saying is correct? Like I meant on a universe bigger than a another not necessarily greater.I know the Greek gods are stronger and their Pantheon is greater but for the case of their cosmology being bigger or Greater.Thats not about power scaling

[@cvqtkokaradjov828]

No hate but tarnished has malenia blossom (I think that was the name of the flower incantation from malenia) which can and has made a country into a wasteland. Thor will have less tolerants against that shit than anybody in er simply cause it is a illness which he has no contact with, so I thing he will take it a lot worse than radahn for example(I like this thor to btw )

[@godskingchampion2730]

Thor has never shown the capability to be hurt by a disease of magic or anything like scarlet rot if they are not strong as him or stronger.In this video i showned thor is stronger and faster.So even if you think he could do the same thing as jorms poison is,he would still kill the tarnished and take it with his endurance like jorms poison.And thats if he hit thor with it.

[@edwardconner3335]

​@@godskingchampion2730scarlet rot is not poison but the gift of an outer god. Nothing in existence is immune to the rot it's very clearly implied that even Marika feared the rot. And what the fuck is bullshit about poison. Thor is never stated or shown to have any resistance to poison. In fact multiple Norse myths rely on him being poisoned so scarlet rot wins. Thor is stupid enough to tank the rot as a challenge. Plus if we actually apply what the spells would do logically to physics than a lot of spells simply could not be countered. Thor is hilariously overpowered compared to most but the weapons & powers the tarnished has access to are broken on a good day. And why the fuck do you think death effects wouldn't kill Thor it's the hammer the can manipulate life not the god. Hence his death in game.

[@godskingchampion2730]

First of all i didnt say it was a poison. SecondThor is not dumb ehough to just let something hit him.This being in full fight mode and not being cocky,and even if he did,he would instant kill him. Three:It and other spells coulndt because thor is way stronger and faster.So it wouldnt matter. Four:I never said thor was inmune to poison,were also talking about gow,not norse myth.He was theorytically poisoned by the axe of kratos. Five:He has shown way bettter strength to defy all that your saying. Six:In the elden ring verse maybe thats the case but not in others and if anything thor would just instant kill the tarnished. Seven:You would have to proof that just because it comes from a outer god that marika feared it and for why.Not just implying that because of that.She should stand to Queen marika. Eight:Also why are you cursing? lol If you tryna debate any of this let me know your discord.But no hax from tarnished should hurt thor or hit him.

[@edwardconner3335]

@@godskingchampion2730 I guess I'll just have to agree to disagree. I like the vid but completely disagree. No ranged attacks should work for either parties in this. Feats for both put them well above FTL. As far as experience gos we know that the tarnished has at least over 5,000+ years of basically constant war under their belt if you choose. In any event they would destroy whatever world they fought on. Anything less would pretty much guarantee Thor's death.

[@godskingchampion2730]

Thats so dumb.Like respectfully,I have never seen the tarnished have that much experience,so show a scan.Two Thor is older and has been fighting way longer than the tarnished.Thor is infinte speed by being higher than almost every god of the aesir in power and speed.He scales to kratos.He is way higher with damn near killing him and outspeeding him and making him aruably inmmesurable to irrelvant.Thor has Mljnoir,that defeats anything that they have.Are you trying to debate on discord or do you just disagree?