Wind Energy In India Is Powering Over 1M Homes, But At What Cost? | Power To The People

[@Nmax]

India will keep developing wind power CNA can take the cost and stuff it

[@major2707]

😁💯

[@happymelon7129]

🤣🤣🤣"But At What Cost? " So CNN , BBC

[@ytorganicman]

Wind turbine is expensive to build and expensive to maintain.

[@kamals6624]

Yes sir😢😢

[@Nmax]

@@ytorganicman thus it requires sustained investment plus keeping all the stakeholders in confidence (local people, farmers, fishermen, businesses etc..) and working to mitigate environmental impact

[@hemantsarthak]

@@Nmax That sustained investiment should be invested in thorium reactors, much better for India and cheaper in the long term as well. Wind turbines maybe somewhat cheap to install but are not cheap to run, and would require battery storage which we don't have to be reliable. look at germany energy cost and carbon footprint and France energy cost and carbon footprint.

[@Padmini1712]

​@@ytorganicmanThey should have done a Research before installing this Wastwd effort.

[@jianyang6281]

you are an Asian media, stop using "But at what cost" narrative. Be Singapore, dont be Ligapore.

[@BlackHawkTejas]

They are called chinese media mouthpiece for no wrong reason!

[@rajx7120]

Same thing when done in China, will be celebrated by this channel. No tears on land and ecology there. China mines a lot of rare earths, by causing massive pollution. So many buildings demolished due to real estate crisis, ehich cause dust pollution. Don't talk about that. Suddenly, you are worried about us.

[@wretfsfvd]

@TechnoFrong it is not a western media this channel is from Hong Kong

[@user-wo1c4ar]

​@@wretfsfvdfrom Singapore

[@abhinaysingh8306]

true

[@naturalselection1203]

​@wretfsfvd this is Singaporean, and they target Chiba too.

[@SpiritsBB]

Only negatives? WION and that First Post or whatever have all that covered on a daily basis. Not to mention BBC and American news. I mean, just turn on youtube and it's there. Do you really want more?

[@tedchandran]

Jai Hind. We Indians have vast green resources especially Solar, Wind, Hydro, Wave and thorium etc. to develop our Green economy

[@hemantsarthak]

Thorium and waves are the only good option solar, wind and hyrdo are just to space consuming or/and lack energy density and reliability needed to make them work in a cost effective manner, look at germany their energy costs and reliability issues vs France, India should follow frances path.

[@alileevil]

This documentary could have been done in 12 minutes.

[@Padmini1712]

Mayb, 5 minutes ---🤓🤓🤓. Such a BORE. Keep Fast Forwarding😮😅

[@Xx-he9qe]

Ridiculous “at what cost” propaganda wording. PAP is ruling singapore since its inception, but at what cost?

[@lourdesjohn261]

PAP is ruling Singapore like a dictator for 50years,but at what cost?

[@funfun9360]

Every village in South India should have at least 5 wind mills to produce electricity Locally.

[@major2707]

Money?

[@KGopidas]

Every house to have cent percent rooftop potential realisation in 5 years

[@sume151]

Solar is better suited...

[@bagithraj93]

Wind mill is best suited for windy areas whether south or North of India

[@KGopidas]

@@bagithraj93 they do not exist, so the current site

[@prashanthalex7702]

This place is a very beautiful Green area however the video has been purposely showcased blurred & of low quality to show this a mid income area...

[@kollywoodkingss5304]

bad photography

[@arunpanat8157]

Yes . Possible .

[@bisyguy]

It's biggest in Asia And just 18 km from my home 🥰

[@කොස්තාපල්සුසිරිපාල]

😊😊

[@කොස්තාපල්සුසිරිපාල]

100km from my home

[@sourovdas7883]

@@කොස්තාපල්සුසිරිපාල 🤗

[@sidharthgokul1889]

Google shows that the biggest wind farm in asia is in Gujarat

[@rushikesh3443]

2000 km from my home 😁😁

[@deepakprabhu22]

We don't need lectures from Chinese or Western media about our energy choices. India is charting its own course, balancing economic growth with environmental responsibility. Our wind energy expansion is just one part of a broader strategy to transform our energy landscape.

[@zzgreyhat3886]

15% of singapore population are tamil

[@rajasingammuthusamy959]

Land can be rented out on a fixed price long-term contract basis and can continue work on the land for cash crops or animal husbandry. Under an official land caveat, and this land cannot be sold.

[@senthilkumarsenthilkumar1955]

We proud of our Tamilnadu

[@praneethjayasimha5943]

be proud of india, not just tn

[@YOUTUBE_AMERICA]

Lol largest green energy set up in north

[@striker44]

​@@KZbin_AMERICAwith tax collected from the south. Lol😂

[@YOUTUBE_AMERICA]

@@striker44 it was made by andani pvt company Anyways you are Tamil how will you know Even UP surpass you in GDP 😭

[@RRaajaaR]

​@@KZbin_AMERICA UP surpassed TN in GDP 😂😂😂😂 wake up man. What's UP population and TN population?

[@bobafett5757]

*Need CNA to release documentary on elderly dying alone in SG and theres 2 part of it*

[@yvrvijay]

Wind power has benefitted a lot of local industries in the belt from Madurai to Kanyakumari and the textile industry in and around Coimbatore

[@GunjanJo]

"at what cost?" So wokist. West lectures to reduce carbon emissions and then counts the cost !

[@rajahua6268]

Congratulation Alex. Your family will appreciate your decision.

[@exploringvibesplus78]

Singapore loves made in Chinese products which have less garrenty nor warrenty......

[@zzgreyhat3886]

😂😂😂15percent of Singapore population are Tamil people

[@KishanKumar-qz1kt]

At what cost? This term is imported from the west😂😂😂

[@zzgreyhat3886]

15 percent of Singapore population are Tamil people😂

[@sethusrm]

My hometown❤️🔥... ARALVAIMOZHI

[@srinivasnirmalkumaravula7829]

If people working for these wind mills companies are provided with English & other language soft skills then also get opportunities to work overseas windmills companies all over the world their salaries will be much more at present what they are earning here

[@adityagajjar3118]

A propoganda channel

[@Uxbeu7188ch2b]

Any other channels to recommend? Thanks.

[@jaik9321]

Good 🎉🎉,we need more such across the nation

[@lourdesjohn261]

I have notice this in all foreign media,every positive development news about India is shown in a negative light.i find this very disturbing.😂

[@arkrishnan]

No farmer should sell his land . Land should only be leased based on current land value . The lease amount should be increased with land value increases. This will protect farmers and give them perennial income. TN Govt. could do lot more to save citizens. Even now TN government should revoke the land sales to wind farm companies and convert it to lease based on current value.

[@Mihirpatel6162]

These NOODLES are writing “AS WHAT COST” as if they are bearing it 😅😂

[@striker44]

CNA - Cost Not Applicable. CNA put a brown filter on the video. 🇸🇬 Singapore was built by the tamils under chinese lordship while displacing the malays - at what cost?

[@raguram1934]

why your video quality is so poor in this video. To show it is dusty and poor right

[@homehome1472]

Very informative and good project done by Tamilnadu Government 😊

[@muthukumars7426]

I started my work journey in Rs windtech ❤❤

[@RanjithRanjith-rc9qy]

Tamilnadu❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@reganjoans]

That architect guy should not stay dump, he should lease his land direct to the holders. These are illegally bought by these agents and transfered under lease to the investor. He should negoitate the deal direct and can even use the land below to farm. Don't get fooled by kathadi brokers!!

[@GeorgeMcphillips-i6t]

1 wind mill for 300 homes and no heavy industry wow that will work wonders and they only last 15 to 20 years

[@truthalonetriumphs6572]

Singapore is a wasteland. Every inch of it.

[@FutureAITrend]

couldn't understand the motive of the video also it could have been completed in 10min

[@prabakaranraju5618]

Not to sell the land go for renting to wind owners

[@dhanaagilan9908]

Lease

[@prabakaranraju5618]

Clean energy is good for country,allow to convert all lands here,law must be flexible

[@Grasshopper143]

my village aralvoimozhi

[@kanank13]

Pure air has no price. Well said. Not every bit of land needs to be destroyed to make ways for new energy source. The coconut grove is so wonderful look at and needs to be enjoyed every day of the year. He can nicely make that into a camping site or for daily business events or even a wedding event while preserveing the way it is now. he can even let schools bring their children and create awareness of beautiful places of nature.

[@thebestevertherewas]

will you pay the man more than the companies will ?

[@kanank13]

@@thebestevertherewas the property is a priceless master piece. it is worth preserving the way it is and the owner should monetize the property by making use of my suggestions.

[@skellurip]

why there is a need to buy all the land? just rent some part of it for long term and keep the rest of the land productive

[@wretfsfvd]

how truck and crane can run on crop field without damaging farmer can demand more compensation if something happen to their farm by company. sometime this compensation is more then total value of all crops in field.

[@viki19910]

These are not crop field ​@@wretfsfvd

[@Chockalingam-zc2he]

Aralvaimozhi wind pass is world second in wind potential but turbulence point is higher than other pass, non conventional tech is respectively higher

[@gktytykl1331]

something wrong with CNA

[@gdgobi7330]

In the 90s if you got 14 lakhs, he could have bought more than 20-25 Acres. But he just used it to spend.

[@historybuff-p6x]

at 28:46 he says if he hadn't sold to the wind farm he could sell the land now for higher price. how is that the fault of wind farms. he needed money then and he needs it now. his story is sad and life didnt improve for him. but what we don't see is the added growth in the town for others due to more electricity. so the qn is not "at what cost" but should be if the benefits outweigh .... i think he would be in this problem even if there was no wind power, the land price would not have risen so much, in which case he would not regret so much, but still wouldnt benefit him any.

[@Dubukku]

This is one reason why TN has no power shortage.

[@aleksanderkuncwicz7277]

Solar energy would be good in India the middle east.

[@dk-ln6om]

We have humangus solar parks too

[@arjunraj823]

India have the largest solar park in the world not China.

[@Being_Human_Karthick]

Why didn't the Government own the land and place wind turbines 😅

[@darshan5726]

lol what the hell did i just watch

[@utkarshmishra-fo5ub]

instead of these turbines, we can have solar panel grid tied to towers ... quite efficient than these

[@KGopidas]

Is there any effort to augment the capacity? It was introduced to sabotage the kudankukam nuclear power plant

[@Zo-hc2fn]

something is definitely wrong with classic wind turbines, let's please have something new : a vertical axis wind turbine (spinning like a carousel) this wind turbine would look exactly like a tree, I call it : e-tree, the trunk of the e-tree is brown, the spinning sails (blades) are green, and finally attached to the trunk of the e-tree are features of : wifi/mobile network, light and power outlet, to charge a car for example

[@yvrvijay]

Next burst of growth here would be due to repowering

[@mcastillano7109]

An eye sore?

[@youxkio]

The companies interested in installing wind turbines purchase the land???? In my country, they pay rent to the landowners. The money is not much but interesting offer and does not stop landowners from tilling the land. Purchasing famers' lands will cause a real estate bubble and increase farm produce prices. Companies renting a small spot to the original landowners where the wind turbine is installed would be the right solution. Everyone would be happy.

[@amrithMilW]

This place no much agriculture and land are cheap

[@youxkio]

@@amrithMilW Yes, but then what happens to the owners? do they purchase land somewhere else? You know this growth of land value may end in a bubble and only increases agro produce prices. Meanwhile India is growing its demographic population. Seems a bad mixture going on there. Look what happened in china with property development. I know it is a different case because it is not apartments, but in India's case is land. I love wind turbines and new renewables but I think there could be better solutions for property owners.

[@BlackHawkTejas]

​​@@youxkioThis channel is funding propaganda against India & nothing else! They just cherry pick things & twist the narrative. The even color graded the video to make the area look bad In India also companies rent land! Basing your whole opinion about a country based on a propaganda news channel is something else!!

[@truthalonetriumphs6572]

What cost?

[@shivarma9658]

Stopping somthing from flowing cant be renewable

[@harrissumali5698]

Can India reduces noises of turbine blades,under 50 decibells,thx for reduce carbon polutions

[@major2707]

Lol

[@darshan5726]

lmmao

[@aleenaprasannan2146]

If you think the cartoonish fake sound they edited in is actually heard in the location for real, you are sadly mistaken. You are probably the exact kind of person they were baiting with the addition of that fake sound. This place is a common rest stop for a lot of long distance bus travelers, the only thing you can hear there is the wind itself. Whatever sound the wind turbines make are barely even audible.

[@muhamadkamali7037]

👍👍

[@aleenaprasannan2146]

What was the need to edit in that cartoonishly artificial fake swishing sound? Was the peaceful nature of a rural town in India so unsettling to this channel that they has to add in some kind of noise artificially? Even the editing itself is so low effort, its not even in sync with the visual of the wind turbines in most of the frames?

[@hilwaamanamankiyar-pp5bf]

MEALS

[@Philip-x3d]

Hope the wind blows EVERY DAY so they actually GET some energy ?

[@12villages]

Why cant we build turbine pillars inside cities? 🤔

[@major2707]

😁

[@arunkumaras5109]

What is the point of this documentary… ???? . That you should not have wind generated power…. ? Could the authors explain?

[@SomraEkka-xe8bo]

Poor undereducated people... Just need to rent a piece of the land... why to sell land... Birla, Ramco, Pandian these are MNC's now you will be evicted landless labourers in your own country. Pathetic!

[@the3rdEye2187]

What's the motive behind this almost black-white-ish colour grading of the whole video? Propaganda perhaps?

[@bisyguy]

Very kowest wages getting locals

[@guangjiang647]

the windturbo is small

[@dk-ln6om]

Like your eyes ? 😂

[@guangjiang647]

@@dk-ln6om I'm not a glass heart. I'm so aggressive

[@oldlee2706]

Only means government is earning the money and people suffer

[@Shady689]

Work for the government, you'll get paid

[@oldlee2706]

@@Shady689 even police is going to change to foreign talents already..

[@major2707]

​@@oldlee2706😁

[@HardcorePanda]

Very clean air for pooing outdoors. saaar pl, how do do do

[@PrakharChauhan-t1x]

Alwar crying useless newspaper

[@beyondyun5628]

hahaha，but at what cost？

[@liar-liar]

India must send this technology to Israel other than sending weapons to IDF

[@NCM-xy8ow]

Much of the tech is from China . 😂

[@reganjoans]

This is not indian technology its from Dutch. India got nothing to export apart from ores by your gujarati traitors to china!!

[@xijinpig8982]

​@@NCM-xy8ow Like Covid?

[@NCM-xy8ow]

@@xijinpig8982 no.endian. wind turbines. Duh. Harder to make than cow p/iss you are used to

[@major2707]

No profit... India always send weapons to allies...

[@Stevexnycautomotive]

😂

[@Padmini1712]

One of the most Boring Documentaries, I have seen. I give 0/100 to the CNA Insiders😂😊

[@oldlee2706]

Green scam

[@beyondfossil]

Let's all just keep burning' dat dinosaur juice like there's no tomorrow. 🦖 💧 🛢️

[@NY-op9tf]

@@beyondfossil crude oil is not Dinosaur juice just so you know its from the Flora millions of years ago

[@oldlee2706]

@@beyondfossil let just be stupid to pay for the scam

[@beyondfossil]

@@oldlee2706 How so?

[@oldlee2706]

@@beyondfossil Anything green is cost saving, anything expensive is not green.

[@hassanj1861]

This looks poorly built. Knowing Indian craft and engineering it will be a disaster.

[@major2707]

Disaster for outsiders

[@kkrkkr3531]

First 100 ynits is free in tamilnadu is wat my experience. In chennai its free

[@huiyu5518]

噪音大，居民区这么近 ，吵死人