WINNER: How 100 Slices of Plywood Won Me the Battle

[@nikxohs3925]

what did you restore??? you just clean and paint

[@ziggy2652]

Would sure love to see your cleaning of a tool look that good 😁

[@nikxohs3925]

@@ziggy2652 tools are for work , not decoration

[@ziggy2652]

@nik xohs true but the tool was not working properly before he "cleaned it"

[@nikxohs3925]

@@ziggy2652 yes clean it

[@karthikaple4618]

😊 😊😊

[@misterpatina]

sweet!

[@NTRprojects]

Thank you. that was really a lot of fun and your result is of exceptional quality. I think its so awesome how different both turned out

[@auChevalierRed]

@@NTRprojects I'm glad you both agree. Wt's whhat makes your two channels special to me is how you both propose quality craftsmanship, respect for the piece you are restoring,, a friendly environment and your two distinct ways though do show through every time. That was why I had suggested ending you both an identical item to restore. You could use your creativity and preferred future uses to show two different, yet equally worthwhile results. So many channels are plain in that respect. Your channels aren't devoid of personality in the background, without you harassing your viewers with 3 quarters of the video about your digestive system or your nail polish.

[@-Deena.]

Mister P! You let yourself down and you let me down. You need to go away and have a long hard think! I mean, leaving the horrible letters on the cheap new bolts! Shame! However Dr. B, whilst it blew Mr P. out of the water, that pinstriping was shockingly shoddy. Conclusion: Room for improvement but Dr B slam dunks it. Rematch. Best of three! 🧡

[@On_fire_send_help]

I mean im all for constructive criticism, but thats a bit harsh doncha think?

[@-Deena.]

@@On_fire_send_help Just teasing the guys 😁🧡

[@Drowronin]

The real winner is the viewer.

[@smashyrashy]

There are no winners among people who watch youtube all the time

[@vonHannersdorf]

Exactly! Mister Patina and Dr. Beer has awesome skills and beautiful videos so we viewers are blessed with their work. And true winners!

[@BB_Chaptsick]

Both were very impressive video to watch. I agree.

[@TapscottJ]

Well stated!!!

[@Psammead21]

Deep, profound and accurate 👌

[@Bazza.baz224]

I watched Mr Patina's first and thought "no way will Dr Beer beat that". Was I wrong! Yours was on another level 🏆

[@condar419]

I love that you two are having this friendly competition. Excellent job, I love the 'herringbone' effect of the wooden pieces. I've watched both videos, so I'm off to vote now.

[@mookystank]

This is great. I came here from Mister Patina and having seen references to you and comments from you in his videos. The fact that you guys are friends in real life and interact in real life and through these videos is very cool. You two have provided hours of entertainment for me and your videos help me mentally. Thank you both so much.

[@Spinatbroetchen]

This is a really hard choice. Both of you are true masters with a lot of love for detail and a great craftsmanship. Thank you for your videos.

[@patv6897]

J'ai attendu la bière pendant 20 minutes 😊, j'ai mangé le pan-bagnat de la base sans boire, heureusement il y avait de la bonne huile d'olive 😂 ! J'ai un peu regretté de ne pas voir le détail de fabrication de l'étiquette 😢 . J'ai terminé le visionnage en me disant "décidément ce gars est un champion de la restauration, on le savait déjà mais il s'améliore toujours" Merci encore et bravo pour ce splendide résultat fonctionnel. Patrick

[@NTRprojects]

Oh Patrick, merci beaucoup pour cette histoire et ce feed-back :)

[@alexdeleon7135]

This has to be the best restoration you've ever done on this channel! This shear was revived from the dead! The mounting table had your own style in design. It gives the finished project its own individuality. This was outstanding!

[@delhog6161]

I remember this comparison you had and I knew you would win because you take it to another level. The other chap does a great job of restoring things but you always go the extra mile by making your restoration better than it was when new.🇬🇧👍

[@shedmanx3640]

You both have done excellent work. Your genius move in repurposing old packing crates into that stunning wooden base wins my vote. 😍

[@raimundweinstein7690]

Ihre Restaurierungsarbeiten sind in jeglicher Hinsicht außergewöhnlich. Die Videos sind von toller Qualität. Es macht Freude diese Arbeiten online verfolgen zu können

[@andyweberg2928]

Excellent work!! I'm a big fan of the cold blueing- that tipped my vote to your side on the battle :) The yellow pinstripe paint needed to be a bit thicker for a better coating but I appreciated the style! Double points for repurposing the ply for the handle and secondary base, very resourceful! MORE BATTLES!

[@davesmith5656]

Love the way you restored that old wooden shipping crate! It look better than it was originally! Two restoration projects, one for the cutter, and one for the shipping crate!!

[@Anmobgoccult20]

Well done, without words, for such precise work and craftsmanship, the great German quality, one can only bow down, respect from old BG.

[@edconway9072]

Mr. P ran into a buzz saw in this challenge. You took each and every step to the next level. The handle was the best example, the herringbone pattern was centered on the handle, the holes were right down the centerline and the screw slots aligned with the centerline. Masterful work sir, makes me -round to be a patron. Thanks, Ed

[@okieproperty9141]

I love the look and especially the base you made. You took the time to make it versatile and UN-complicated. Your work is very good and I enjoyed the video. What you did made it go over the top compared to Mr. Patina. Although Mr. Patina made it simple yet elegant in doing. Loved both. For showmanship, you win. For being competitive and simple, he does. thanks to you both.

[@PROUDLY_LEBANESE]

Excellent work, a real pleasure to contemplate these restorations. 👏👏👏👏👏👏Greetings from Argentina.

[@engineeringtheapocalypse]

One of your best yet (and that's saying something). Clear vision on the looks and functionality restored. Hats off!

[@Vickie-Bligh]

Dr B., this was fun to watch and that you were in 'competition with Mr P made it even more so. Nicely restored and very well filmed. Thanks for sharing.

[@jeffbaranowski6695]

Most excellent! You both did amazing jobs. Sorry, but I have to give it to Mister Patina. I feel he stayed truer to "restoration" without additions or modifications.

[@righteothenable]

Beautiful restore, as always. It is so soothing watching your videos. The attention to detail, the craftsmanship, the care for the project itself.

[@StealthDonut1]

The work here is beyond gorgeous. You did everything required for a great showdown, plus you included a delicious beer review! Next up, you guys should get together and do a collaboration on a single BIG project together! I salute you, Dr. Beer!

[@bobvalli9430]

The way you constructed the base was unbelievable. WOW!!!!! It had such a dimensional appearance. Again, all I can say is....WOW!!!!

[@peterhobson3262]

Having watched both videos I'm giving my vote to you, Dr. Beer. The shears were similar but not identical. I feel you got the more difficult shear to restore. You both did good restorations of the shears. However you made two mounts, one for mounting on a work table and the wooden mount, which was excellent. You also made a very nice wooden handle. Mr. Patina didn't make mounts or a handle. You did pin striping on the body, which matched the pin striping on the original. Plus, of course, you evaluated a beer.

[@jean-baptistegaridel8787]

My son and I are huge fan of restoration videos and this event was great. We've voted for you because of your attention to detail and the extra mile you went. Fantastic work !

[@Zaphods-Third-Arm]

For me you are the winner. The metallic paint and stripe matched the original, the base and handle were an incredible addition to what would be expected as a standard. Superb.

[@davidcoats1037]

Stunning restoration. Brilliant editing! Stop motion animation is always appreciated. Cool addition with the wood reclamation. 😃👍🏼

[@nathanhunt54]

This was a great idea! Friend amongst friend having fun doing what they love. This has to be one the toughest decisions I've had to make in a while. Mr. Patina was definitely up to challenge though with his magic tricks (snapping fingers and prep work magically being done!)... But beer... And wood workery was an equally impressive touch! I have voted, but my hat is tipped to the both of you! Well played, fellas! 🥂

[@jfleser88]

The zinc plating of the hardware was sublime and mesmerizing. Nice work. I choose your work because of your skill and editing skill.

[@troyboy4345]

This is the winner 100% ! .... Superb attention to detail with outstanding touches added.

[@yanniskolymvanos537]

Wow!! That wooden base is so trippy!! Lovely stuff as usual

[@tobiaslindstrom660]

Congratulations. You are the winner. And you got me as a new subscriber. ✌️

[@NTRprojects]

Welcome to the channel Tobias and thank you

[@jamescraig5421]

Excellent Restoration Bro. Fit for another 50years great job Bro.👌➕

[@alexanderalbach468]

Ach, einfach immer wieder schön jemanden zuzusehen, der ne Ahnung von dem hat, was er tut ❤

[@garymucher4082]

Very nicely done. Amazing how precise one of those metal cutters can cut things. Once you use one, you can't figure out how you did without one all the years. Thumbs Up for sure...

[@johnbradford9235]

Great job Dr. Beer 👏👏👏. Love the touch of versatility with the table or vice mounting 👍👍👍, and the wood pattern you created. Thank you very much 🙏. 😎

[@tomrailton9201]

Thanks

[@assessor1276]

Beautiful - absolutely perfect.

[@jaajar]

Mr Patina's restoration was good but you win 🙂 Especially liked the scrapwood mosaic base you made. Beautiful and a little bit of 3d effect too.

[@terrynicholls601]

I believe you just took the honours, sir! Lovely job.

[@pamelabraman7217]

😊 very nice, love the addition of the wood grip, so much more comfortable for the user. Bonus points for the wood joining. Loved both videos, but I vote for you on the win. 👍

[@chrisross-smith4358]

That is a work of art, no wonder you won. That wooden base looks 3d, amazing effect. Great effort well done sir...😊 👍

[@jaimegomezgarcia7599]

Great work! The basis is excellent work. You can see that it has been a considerable amount of work. Now, time to watch the Mister Patina's video.

[@Paperghost]

Now thats what I call a restoration. Wonderful job.

[@jasoncdebussy]

You have transformed a forgotten tool into a thing of real beauty! Great work 👍

[@GeorgeLowrey]

You've outdone yourself! Beautiful restoration!

[@djevo3441]

Amazing job my friend congratulations 👏👏👏👏🎉👏

[@widowmakerdesign]

You’re just showing off! I’m surprised you didn’t carve a groove and inlay gold instead of the yellow pinstripe🤣🤣 Beautiful job!

[@xabierqataquapit7202]

Entry: 4/6 - tasty on first look but not sensational Aftertaste: 6/6 - enjoyed the iron filings Body: 6/6 - loved the body work and woodworking Colour: 8/6 - perfect pinstripping Bitterness: 4/6 - pleasant sand blasting Acidity: 5/6 - loved the zinc plating and cold blueing Fizz: 8/6 - after so many hours of work on the craftsman part ... it was very refreshing to watch 41/42 .... Rank # 1 / 2 ... Definitely would watch again

[@NTRprojects]

What a fizzy and refreshing Feedback. Thanks a lot

[@saskia4139]

This is an overwhelming Renovation! The device looks like new - with the wooden base maybe even better - and works perfectly. You have a lot of attention to detail. A wonderful video! Thank you!

[@midei]

Tough decision. You both are very good. But that wooden base made my mind! I have enjoyed the battle enormously, anyway. Please do more like this one! Thank you very much.

[@petat13]

Thanks so much. I enjoyed both restorations. It’s interesting to see how differently you both approach the same task. Lovely result at the end. The base and handle are quite special and add a finesse to the over all finish.

[@vinceianni4026]

Hello Mister Patina beautiful restoration beautifully restored well done

[@newcomerjason7791]

I watched both restorations....both Mr Patina and yourself did incredible work....but your wood working puts yours over the top. It's an incredible detail to add.

[@ROGUPA]

Gorgeous finished restoration, so hard to choose a winner. The level of detail is insane. My vote is for you.

[@rb962]

I am unable to choose a definitive winner in the competition because you both showcased your amazing talent as craftsmen. You did an awesome job and having the rivalry was great fun for me as the viewer.😊

[@rickmiller4202]

Liked the Bob Ross reference with the, ' happy little accident', line. That base is phenomenal. Seen from the right angle it has a 3-D look, like a huge stairway. Greatly pronounced during the oiling. Very well done.

[@oleque1]

You nailed it. Great job!

[@Aquadus214]

Watched this after mr.patina. Nothing to compare. Both were greatly skilled in their craft. My respect to both of them. 😊

[@terminalpsychosis8022]

Absolutely gorgeous. That woodworking especially. The handle was the perfect, finishing touch. And the machine will work for decades more now.

[@FuturePrison]

Awesome restoration!. Your videos are also going from strength to strength. And although I haven't watched MrPatina's video yet, I already don't want to have to choose!!! 😁

[@baxojayz]

Nice job. I bet it looks better than it did new! Works GREAT!

[@robertbeer2584]

Epic job my brother from across the pond, I wont reveal my vote but the stundent has learned well!!!!

[@TheDragonNinjaLord]

That's such a cool blue! I love your color choices pretty often. :D

[@renedufaux6141]

Magnifique travail , la base en bois collé est une idée géniale . BRAVO .🖕🖕

[@philipB31]

Nice work - I can’t imagine you aren’t pleased with the result.

[@billdooling5859]

You win. Both were dope but yours was above and beyond. No bias, i came here as a mister patina fan

[@1958PI]

Since last time I saw your channel you pimped up your workshop! New tools, all clean and tidy! Love that. Restoration is perfect and also how you did the video was a new level. keep on truckin'!

[@chubbyschoices9701]

You win...that wood handle is beautiful...nice work dude

[@willhayden4311]

Watched both. You win as far as I'm concerned! Nice job.

[@NeedsMoreBirds]

This is beautiful! I think you outdid Mister Patina on this one.

[@chriswareham]

Off to watch Mr Patina's video, but you've set a high bar with your one! One of things I love about these kinds of restorations is the reuse of things in a "disposable" age, and the upcycling of the wood was an excellent example of this.

[@madkingragnarok]

Now we need the trifecta. Mister Patina, Not Terrible Restorations, and my mechanics

[@NTRprojects]

Okay, you ask him 😜

[@fasteddy07]

Excellent renovation! 💪

[@georgebrown8312]

Magnificent job you did restoring the metal cutting shears to working order. It looks much better and it works like a charm too. Excellent work.

[@sharonlaster2767]

OMG! Your woodwork is awesome! Steller use of a packing box! Oh! Your metal sheer restoration was excellent, too. 😄

[@vijaynaik7739]

What a competition, both are as good as other, superb sir. What a restoration beauty.

[@kyfho47]

Now THAT was a beautiful restoration. Well done!

[@rogerpatrongonzalez5800]

I enjoyed both videos a lot👍👏👍👏👍👏👍👏👍👏

[@davegregory6245]

That wooden base is really special, you should be very proud of both the restoration as a whole and your woodworking skills! 👍🏻

[@cantinetormanshow3757]

i watched both the two videos, and for me you are the winner.

[@shawnstamp1635]

I totally agree the viewers won here. You both put your own twist on the details. Well done.

[@paulsweeney5642]

It’s all fantastic but that wood looks amazing. Off to watch Mr P now.

[@jeremysueur8117]

Beautifull. Really really beautifull 👍🏻 good job

[@netrhyda8761]

Very enjoyable to watch! And the end product is excellent!

[@doriWyo]

So close. But I like the wood work you did. One vote for you!

[@thepagan5432]

I enjoyed watching both restorations.

[@Susied7]

Beautiful work.

[@nobuckle40]

Since it's a contest and we are the judges, I have created categories by which each restoration is to be judged. The categories are Disassembly, Cleaning and Rust Removal, Hardware and Casting Improvement, Paint Preparation, Painting, Originality, Re-assembly, and Operation. Each category has a scale of 1-5 (1 is lowest score, 5 is highest score) for a possible total of 40 points. Disassembly - 5 Cleaning and Rust Removal - 5 Hardware and Casting Improvement - 5 Paint Preparation - 5 Painting - 3 (The pin striping was thin and uneven) Originality - 5 (does not include the new mounting base) Re-assembly - 5 Operation - 5 TOTAL = 38 Your restoration turned out beautifully! You went above and beyond by paying careful attention to the details. I feel that the paint you chose to use was as close to the original as possible. Very nicely done.

[@NTRprojects]

Haha what a nice idea of you. You yourself went above and beyond with this Feedback. Much appreciated how much thought you put into this

[@nobuckle40]

@@NTRprojects I sort of patterned the idea the same way you rate the beers that you try. 😁

[@zorrosoberon]

The winner of this wonderful contest IS US; THE VIEWERS, HOLY S**T YOU'RE EXCEPTIONALLY GOOD!!! Thanks for sharing blessings.

[@TheGJ1973]

Wow!!! It’s probably 100% better than it ever was 😀👌🏼

[@JKAW]

I really enjoyed the editing of this video, keep up the good work

[@Psammead21]

I can't split you boys. I said it before the challenge videos were released. But I've at last had the chance to watch both and I've cast my votes. May the best man win ⚔🛠

[@Psammead21]

Ooh, and I forgot to say that my OCD once again says "Hi and much respect!!" to yours 👌👋xx

[@Mlenski_restorations]

Looks perfect. I am going to watch the second competitor's work. Great idea.

[@foxwhiskey]

Watched again. Same result. Can't be done better ! Respect !😊

[@lesliebryce6074]

Wow, amazing work, time, material costs and craftsmanship. I am so impressed…oh, and also the amazing video and editing. All this from a novice metal worker. 🎉

[@arteceleste9591]

Impecable!!! El mejor de todos los restauradores!! Se nota el Amor que le pone! Éxitos!

[@Sjels17]

Well done! The perfect color, the pinstripe, the wooden stand and handle look really original and it looks to be working very smooth! I’m off to mr patinas now

[@davesmith5656]

Both are outstanding! The two machines are not exactly the same. The end result function is the essential thing. For function, Dr. Beer hand sanded the blades, removing less metal, and did not use shims. Was that a difference in the blades, one set more worn than the other?? Both cut metal as required. For paint, Dr. Beer wins, for more thought, and I happen to love that look and color. For the base and handle ... WOW! And interchangeable two bases are better than one. (The parts about nickel plating bolts, then turning, confused me. Mr. Patina was less complicated, but the video progress was clearer.) In this competition, Dr. Beer! But what about the next one?? Different skills?? Who will win that??

[@NTRprojects]

Hey dave thank you for the outstanding Feedback. I have to ask, since youre the second one to think that i turned the screws after plating. I did not Do so. Maybe the chapter headline was confusing. I first sandblasted, then sanded and turned, then plated

[@NTRprojects]

And as im writing i realize that i gave the impression that the sandblasting step Was already the zinc plated parts

[@NTRprojects]

I will add a comment to clarify in the subtitles

[@NTRprojects]

Added two subtitles at 7:42 maybe that clarifies

[@davesmith5656]

@@NTRprojects --- Yes, at 7:46 the red chapter heading say "Zinc Plating" (and "Chapter 3"). I thought, "Oh, OK, those are zinc plated parts". That's just my bad, being so used to consumer items in stores, advertising campaigns, and so forth. People who know nothing about engines will buy a car for the upholstery and the paint color. I have not ever seen freshly sand blasted parts in real life, nor freshly zinc plated parts. "First I sandblasted the parts as well" clarifies it. P.S. You guys didn't have "Who buys the beer" bet on this, did you?? Edit added: "Chapter 3: Preparations for Zinc Plating" (or, "Sandblasting"), then at 10:35 "Ready for Zinc Plating", would have been unmistakable, but most apparently understood it the way you presented it.