With You Animatic (Remembrance)

[@thelovelyistprincess4850]

I am so happy you all enjoyed the song!! It really makes me so grateful to have been apart of Remembrance and to have been able to sing this song

[@reallytryan]

broadwayjuliet _"Your voice is extremely amazing, It actually sounds like the one I am so familiar with."_

[@reginakonibennethum5613]

What inspired that you wanted you want to become a singer?

[@Ahahahah11]

Your so talented!!

[@kimcollins1743]

awwwwwwwwww and I love Zim so much

[@kimcollins1743]

@@Ahahahah11 yaaaa no gir that’s bad that’s bad

[@featherwaves25]

I love this song... it's so sad that the Princess of Love lost her love...

[@Ahahahah11]

😔

[@iceluvndiva21]

The powerful thing about this song? With a single word change it can apply to losing any loved one

[@kimcollins1743]

@@iceluvndiva21 I miss you and I love Zim so much

[@kimcollins1743]

how did you know that cadence is the Princess of love

[@ellewhite7088]

This is the MOST BEAUTIFUL song in the series so far!

[@thelovelyistprincess4850]

WOW. This randomly showed up in my recommended. I can't believe it's been so long since I sang Cadence for you Ashley! I am still in awe of how much love everyone has for this particular song. I am planning on coming back soon! :)

[@AuraNova-AshleyH]

Funny story, I was just looking at Rem songs and found your comment. You did such an amazing job with this song ugh. It's one of the best in the series.

[@hpthelonesomeartist]

YOUR SINGING IS SO HEAVENLY 😭💕 Thank you so much for contributing to the lovely Remembrance cast!

[@KenzieMayne]

To much feels I can't handle it I'm gonna go curl up cry then make a cover after I'm done crying

[@nyxsparkle5120]

I feel so bad for all of them I feel bad for twilight,cadence,and Flurry Heart

[@nickioleary8577]

3rd favorite song in Rem 1st: I Was There 2nd: Alone 3rd: With You 4th: Alone in the Universe 5th: Blame It On Me/Little Luna

[@alexisblake2634]

did you know “With You” was originally from “Ghost: The Musical”?

[@perfectmoonwarriors3410]

I know how it feels to lose ones you love. I've lost everything I love. I'm in cadnces place on this one

[@marcelloreyes7646]

This just in, multiple Bronies were found dead from "the feels" overdose.

[@mercedesstar3794]

ikr

[@DoodleHarmonyGamer]

I didn't sing it! XDD I only voice Cadence ;-; this is too beautiful!! I can't even!!! XD

[@perfectpurplesisters1387]

You voice cadence? Your cadence voice is really good awesome job :D

[@meridia288]

you're voice is just amazing!

[@DoodleHarmonyGamer]

Stephen Crossley Thanks! :3

[@DoodleHarmonyGamer]

SpiritDash Gamers and brony Thank you! :)

[@Happydancer9]

May I just say what I really like most about your voice, is that you accurately deliver Cadence's emotions with confidence.

[@sarahw152]

I find it sad because i know she's hurting but she needs to realise i know most wpuld say her daughter needs her, of course she does but Twilight needs her too because she lost her parents, brother and all her friends. Also Twilight is most likely to be afraid to love somepony if she wasn't already fearful before all the mortal ponies she cared for died. Where Cadence had the privilege to love Twilight might never have it because of the fear to the point Twilight might block it out of her heart or try to.

[@AuraNova-AshleyH]

How are those feels treating you? ;)

[@moonlite]

Not good. xD

[@Penelope123Pussycat]

I'm dying. My feels are killing me. :"(

[@rainbowharmony9694]

this is awesome and plz check out my videos

[@FlutterRoze]

I hate you Ashley why do you toy with my heart! ^^ The feeeeels

[@ConfuseTheMasses]

What did i ever do to you?

[@AliceLps]

This was so good :D

[@MrGabeanator]

Alice LPS good try great

[@indigostarspeedpaints3770]

Alice LPS I know right it's beautiful

[@kittymlp7172]

Agree

[@Violetgalaxyshimmer33]

wait, Alice LPS watches Ashley H? (pinkie squeal) :D

[@kittymlp]

Agree

[@Tonyten39]

This was BEAUTIFULLY sung. It is AMAZING! Keep up the great work everyone

[@FlutterRoze]

She did so good as Candence this song is so beautiful. Ashely you truly are amazing at what you do. You keep up the amazing work! :)

[@bluewolfdrawer2831]

5th and this song is too bootiful I cried

[@bluewolfdrawer2831]

also can we get lyrics

[@AuraNova-AshleyH]

In the description

[@lyriunaaqua4363]

+Ashley H wow who got the idea of making the princes of love lose her loved one that's really sad the animatic music song it's all perfect nearly made me cry

[@elliedaley2314]

Ashley H you are amazing with the art and songs no other words to describe how awesome you are

[@ChanelleKylie-kl4xu]

I LOVE THIS SONG😭😭😭😭😭🥺

[@KakashiHatake-bd9ji]

came back to watch the series after many many years- i only saw a few episodes that had been out when i was a little kid but didn’t keep up with the series and WOW i’m so glad i came back. i was desperate for content where cadance was. explored as a more complex (and i admit edgy) character and all i could think about was having seen this as a kid and i was so overjoyed to find and watch it all. this song in particular really stuck with me to the point i had to stop what i was doing just to come and listen to it. i’m glad i had the chance to enjoy the series and i’m especially happy to have this version of cadance stored in my brain for whenever i’m feeling especially mean and lamenting over how she deserved more as a character. The vocals for this song were lovely and really demonstrated all of the anguish, conflict, regret and denial of her character its so beautiful and i can see myself revisiting this video often 🫶

[@kikiscrapp]

Celestia! Stop getting out the onions! Celestia: But LUUNNAAAA! Me:NOO

[@SylasSilverfang]

This whole series is about losing the ones you love the most and it suddenly change your behavior and moods to a different pony than before, either depression, angry at someone so they don't want to face the facts, miserable, and doubting yourself about happen in the past.

[@scribblyarts2418]

This is the video that got me into Broadway/ musicals

[@ooni7131]

Ice bear cried. But only inside.

[@Twinklenighterstarshine]

I might cover this song. I can not stop singing it. Broadway Juliet did such a beautiful job! So did the artist, Amy-Chan!

[@princesscordeliamusic2462]

oh my gosh the feels I'm not crying *cries sweet celestia i hate feels

[@DavidLee-mz5mj]

I have only recently finished the first two episodes for this great story and I am starting to grow attached to every character all over again and I am rooting for them all.

[@ava_rules666]

Yeeahhhh, I almost cried. Lol but I didn't, i'm a heartless person xD

[@natalieoliverthedemonicshi4937]

Sadly I cried but the problem is that I'm a real demon well.. Half-demon lol its either that or I literally have legit depression

[@Twinklenighterstarshine]

I am too. But I can feel her pain

[@olvialee7221]

479: I recognize this song from the musical Ghost. Hearing Cadence sing this song, it’s perfect

[@Alex-ij1en]

I finally made a Cover of this song on my Channel, I love it so much! Thank you so much for introducing me to such a beautiful song Ashley!

[@nisa5389]

Great cover, I have to say! ;0,

[@lydiasoares88]

It doesn't show for me

[@MakoTheMink]

R.I.P. Repeat button and R.I.P. Me X3 the feels are killing me omg

[@onefaintrobin]

and R.I.P. Shining Armour

[@yhy8917]

+Loveheart 326 why say that

[@elise8337]

Amy-chan has improved so much these two years!

[@PonyFabReviews]

My tear ducts are flooding SEND HELP

[@eddiesalcido]

I REARLY CRY IN KZbin VIDEOS......I AM BLOWN AWAY ASHLEY..... *Claps slowly* BLOWN AWAY....

[@tacticalcats7722]

Beautiful singing and artwork, nice job everyone

[@theunicornsys]

Even after all these years, this song still gets me-

[@Catherine-ho1pi]

i keep telling myself 'after this i will stop' but i keep clicking the replay button this is amazing

[@Kayspnart]

Omg the singer is SPECTACULAR!!!:DDDDD

[@incitossol]

Why is the fandom so good at creating works that annihilate one's feels? But in all seriousness this is GLORIOUS.

[@andrewobrien8325]

Watching again makes me wonder why Celestia didn't make Shining Armour an alicorn? I mean he is a prince and it does seem as if Cadence's grief could have been stopped. Also I'm curious to know how he died in Remembrance's time line because that armour Cadence was wearing makes me think he died in battle or something.

[@ponyperson1740]

Yeah, maybe a battle. but the song made me CRY!!!

[@snail._.eyebrows]

he died of age I believe and he but you are right with making him a alicorn but if males cant be alicorns at least put a spell on him

[@andrewobrien8325]

moon light pony Thank you. I wouldn't want to be in Cadence or Twilight's positions. Watching my loved ones wither away and die would be more than I could stand. Although in a strange horrid irony, Twilight would also have to bear witness to any foals her friends had also dying of old age and I'm not saying that to be horrible, it's just something that occurred to me.

[@annesmith5539]

Andrew O'Brien I don't remember where I heard this, but he DID die in battle.

[@MrGabeanator]

that's what flurry believes

[@georgehansen2936]

Am not crying 😰

[@StellaCZBronies]

Wait...Shining Armor is dead??? o.O

[@spiderbite3202]

Stella_Agent_of_SHIELD yeh

[@micheleludwig338]

Sadly yes my senpai is ded

[@indigostarspeedpaints3770]

Stella_Agent_of_SHIELD yea

[@nyxsparkle5120]

Michele Ludwig He is you SENPI 😱😱😱😱😱😱

[@nyxsparkle5120]

Michele Ludwig He is your SENPIE 😱😱😱😱😱😱

[@daniissupergirl]

wow this song Is Amazing!

[@CalebBelyeu]

dispite of what almost everyone said, I think Rem 3 was a good episode with two very good songs in it, this is one of them. Keep up with the good work, Ashley! :)

[@that.onyxart]

Ahh, dem feels! I also used this song in my rp I did, looking back, I forgot how AMAZING these sad songs are!

[@delphina3449]

its such a pretty song but its so sad. : ' (

[@hooman9432]

3 years ago the song was uploaded...goshhh it still gives me feels...its soo beautiful!!!!! goshh omg 💗💗💔

[@SugarCloud]

this song made me cry XD

[@iamsherlocked7448]

I love this song, even it's so sad

[@crystallotus3422]

Not my favorite song in the series but I can appreciate how beautiful both the singing and messages are

[@kh1596]

I sing along to this song everyday and it's just beautiful

[@imaginland1596]

So beautiful... it just hits you in the fells and also makes you want to abeuse the replay button. great job ashley H! definitely my favorite song of the seres. (besides blame it on me)

[@galatoots9398]

When I hear this song, I immediately think of my dad :,) it is such a beautiful song. You got some talent Ashely H 💗💗💗

[@iceluvndiva21]

The powerful thing about this song? With a single word change it can apply to losing any loved one

[@phoenixwing5133]

THIS SONG IS AMAZING

[@LadyoftheReach]

Man this song... stunning voice so well made

[@thegrinningreaper8016]

*This definitely made me cry* Yet I keep watching it

[@georgehansen2936]

Am crying

[@RegiPVa]

this is amazing! !!! :3

[@mlpfanceline2420]

I cried. Good Song 👍

[@idkhowtospeelanonymous]

Holy sh*t (excuse language) Cadence’s singing... SO FLIPPING GOOD!

[@SuperGodzilla2]

this was a beautiful song, hit me right in the heart

[@MrGabeanator]

beautiful and heart breaking

[@ChanelleKylie-kl4xu]

Awww poor cadence she really miss her husband shining armor😥😥😭😭💔💔

[@mystirica1850]

I have seen this vid like 11 times and I just noticed that Luna appears in the begining 😂

[@AngelScribs]

YES thank you xD i guess nobody really noticed that i made her rise up the moon xD

[@chinchilla0708]

she has such a beautiful voice

[@greenightponydragon5127]

Sometimes people just take love for granted they don't know how much people want it

[@jen6790]

BEAUTIFUL!

[@harpinedoodles]

You have no idea how Manutius I've watched this! XD!!!! This should be on iTunes!

[@greenightponydragon5127]

Cadence well this cadence are same we both miss one we loved because they were our whole world and without them we just get cold and heartless 💔

[@mayapeterson3072]

I cried so hard at this. Also the first time I watched this I thought she said "you took my worth" not "you took my world"

[@jazparal]

TRULY AMAZING!!!!!!

[@FateMLP]

I cried :'( So beautiful and feelsy x3

[@NelaRarity]

Awww it is so beautiful :D ♥

[@Random_Cassie]

when you wish you had a voice like this 👌

[@snail._.eyebrows]

yeah

[@lastduet]

You put so much passion in this that I started to cry I could feel all those emotions😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@xJustineLunax6666]

So beatiful hard to really keep your tears in and the voice times 100 hard not to cry

[@veronicapineiro1881]

This is my favorite song from this series. But one day my grandma wanted me to listen to a song. I heard it and I was like why does that sound so familiar. Then she told me the name of the song and I was literally screaming because I remember it from this series

[@bella6295]

I just love this song it made me cry great work 😪😊

[@meepbeep2029]

This song masters what it feels like to lose someone, 8/10

[@theteach9117]

I love this song!

[@Simbyyyy]

You are so amazing, you're voice is so awesome Omg, the voices !!!! do the voice !!!! xD do it

[@veronicapineiro1881]

This song is so beautiful its Amazing! 😁

[@SebastianMichaelis99]

This song describes how i feel losing my grandma. She was my entire life

[@BeesMeliss]

3:31 I cry here.

[@BellaPinkSavage]

who else is crying :(

[@mimi12321-i]

It’s me💎

[@itjustcartoonlogic5087]

So sad yet such good song

[@mlpfanceline2420]

Finaly. I made a Cover out of it ^^

[@yhy8917]

i saw it, your amazing!! ❤❤❤

[@Alex-ij1en]

So did I, but yours is amazing!

[@conversepromise]

This is absolutely stunning and breathtaking. I think I've listened about 5 times now. I'd love to cover this if that's alright? I'd give proper credit of course!! You're a wonderful editor and she's an amazing singer ^.^ I couldn't top that but it's too good not to sing >.

[@lominicinfinity]

I'm not crying, you're crying.

[@supersnails17gottalent72]

This, not to late, and light of friendship are the best songs for all different reasons though. (These reason are my opinion UwU) this song is the best for its singer and music, not to late for its meaning, and light of friendship for its lyrics.

[@snowyangel9278]

:wipes tears away: I love the song. Later in the series when twilight comes to the royal wedding part, will she cry or do something like cadance cause of her brother?

[@toastthegreater]

How does she say you for such a long time when I do it I run out of breath

[@snail._.eyebrows]

its a technique so people use. I use it as well but basicly just dont let your stomach hang whole holding the note. Keep it in as long as you can or how long the note is. and then realise your stomach once you loose air

[@toastthegreater]

+moon light pony uhhhh ok

[@rainbowiris2449]

I love this song so much beautiful singing

[@aliuddinmehdunah1634]

it's amazing

[@badgirlindigo3226]

This song is really emotional

[@beatricegoodchild6232]

This made me cry, when's episode 4 out, I can't wait !!

[@mordecaipriestess8536]

I wonder if Cadence will ever get to use that spell Twilight used so she can get closure or not........... idk, could be a nice bonus video after the main story is done

[@nisa5389]

I love this song

[@karadanvers9895]

I want to help her feel better

[@LordQuackerton]

THIS WAS MY FAVORITE SONG LAST YEAR!!!!!!!!!!!! I’m just going through all of the remembrance songs reliving good memories because I’m in 8th grade and everything sucks Also I’m wondering how no one else in the castle heard her singing in her room or are they just ignoring her depression

[@user-xXC4L1B3RXx]

Not a day goes by when I don’t think about when my service animal named Gir that died in my arms at only 2 years old from a heart murmur, when I hear this song…