Women’s Education Under The Taliban with Dilly Hussain

[@Colby_0-3_IRL_and_title_fights]

If western countries are so worried about education in Afghanistan why don't they end the economic sanctions and release Afghanistan's assets so they don't need to ration public spending?

[@Tovo-XV5]

The Taliban will probably use the money for bombs and to fund terrorism in general.

[@sba9450]

❤💯

[@user-en1xu7bj1r]

Parroting talking points seems to be the go to for people of this cult.

[@tbishop4961]

Economic sanctions aren't what prevents girls from being educated 🙄

[@TimHokano]

History has already figured this out. Besides the Islamic Golden, none of Caliphate proven to be good. That’s historical facts.

[@matheen8574]

Taliban has it's downsides(like any other government) but Afghanistan is better with them than under a U.S. or secular regime.

[@peaceforhumanity1886]

You are a man right?🤦‍♂️ Afghanistan is like hell on earth for women and girls especially. Nice job Allah…the devil…

[@TimHokano]

Yes, everything has downsides, that’s why let’s focus on the ideal values. USA ideal’s value relies on pursuit of each individual happiness because that’s right given by God. Also, separation of the church so each individual is self autonomous in figuring their own happiness. I think Taliban has totally different ideal values.

[@TomassoTrekks]

@@TimHokano Lol let’s be real, America hasnt had anything to do with God for quite some time.

[@lodokali]

@@TimHokano America's ideal values is just a mask to cover their sins. Their values will never work because it wasn't meant to be used, only idolize.

[@TimHokano]

@@TomassoTrekks you are correct, but declaration of independence is still the same no matter what. That’s the core of the country. “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” Specific individuals can reject or adopt, they are in their own journey. The government should be able to protect their rights to reject or follow God or whatever their paths as long their paths don’t harm others. It is self-autonomy and self-correcting systems for each individual. In reality, government and private companies might be stepping too much in each individual rights but that is related to the implementation not the ideal values.

[@AhmadAli-ez8db]

There are several suggestions regarding why the Taliban has restricted women's education. Some political analysts argue that the ban serves as a strategic move for the Taliban to gain leverage at the negotiating table with Western countries for government recognition. Others suggest that Western countries may indirectly support this restriction, pointing to the $40 million that flows into the country to keep girls' schools closed. This closure could then be used as propaganda in the West to justify the two decades of war, loss of soldiers, and over $4 trillion in expenditures to their public. If the Taliban were to reopen girls' schools, eradicate corruption, eliminate poppy cultivation, and establish security, Western citizens might question their governments about what has been achieved over the past two decades at such a high cost. Another perspective is that the Taliban is adhering to Deobandi Fiqh. Historically, Muslim scholars in India were concerned about intermarriage, given that Muslims were a minority. As a result, they imposed restrictions on girls' education to prevent women from interacting with Hindus and potentially marrying outside the faith. These restrictions have persisted in religious texts and are still reflected in contemporary practices. Many Taliban members have received their religious education in Pakistani madrasas that primarily focus on Deobandi Fiqh. Interestingly, not all Taliban members support the ban on girls' education; some are advocating for its reversal. Abbas Stanikzai, a senior member of the Afghan Taliban and the country’s Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, has spoken out multiple times about the need to reconsider this stance and to open schools for girls as soon as possible. Allah SWT knows best!

[@sba9450]

@@AhmadAli-ez8db But definitely not the UN / US backed schools. It’s better not to rely on them and their books

[@h.parwani6521]

Im from Afghanistan. I can tell you that the women in my family are getting deeply depressed by the situation. We are not Pashtun ethnicity like the vast majority of the taliban, but Tajik, our women are allowed to get education and develope themselves. Its their right and religious obligation. Alhamdulillah my wife is a doctor and my mother an engineer, as a husband and son I have benefited so much fron strong and educated women around me. And both of them have been succesful in raising good children. The issue is not religion but culture. Why do you want to keep our women backward? If you cannot provide the logistics, then why are you in power? It shows your failure as a government. Its not only education, women cannot even go to recreation places like a park. They are basically in prison. My family has migrated to Tajikistan now as life became unbeareable for them.

[@abyrahman6610]

Stop lying!

[@sabahresearch]

I'm from Afghanistan and a small business owner . I had to let go my women employees due to unbearable restrictions put on woman by Taliban.

[@mujahidhasan118]

😂bro stop lying🤣

[@Pirustae]

I think those women around you were educated outside of Afghanistan. Or at least while the taliban weren't in power. And as a Tajik, what were you doing in Afghanistan? Why weren't you living in your home country?

[@h.parwani6521]

@@Pirustae Afghanistan is home to many ethnicities. Ethno fascists wouldnt understand that. You should live in Israel, they have your mentality.

[@sohrabkhan1186]

Hailing from tribal area, I know it first hand that taliban tolerate nothing but only their own understanding of islam.

[@tamara600]

Fatima al-Fihri established the first university in the world! A muslim woman! Beyond this, the Messenger of Allah pbuh said, “Seeking knowledge is an obligation upon every Muslim.” As such, women's education is integral to Islamic teachings and a part of our history.

[@ij4674]

Don't have to go to mixed uni s for that.

[@MUVAHHID-ILM]

@@ij4674 correct.

[@sba9450]

It is possible only when Muslims establish political economic education system , the Islamic way

[@موسى_7]

​@@sba9450 Like Iran?

[@mdaslam6337]

She never said about that. Don't do whataboutery. What Taliban did is utterly unislamic.​@@ij4674

[@therealreport2778]

Muslims should be able to criticize norms and rules that are not just. Many Muslim men and societies are not just towards women. You can say what you want, but 99 % of Muslim countries need to reform and put in place laws that protect women.

[@personalprofile1939]

Prove it

[@therealreport2778]

@@personalprofile1939 This type of tactic is beneficial? Are you really trying to say that Muslim countries protect women? I am from Iraq. There are several women, I will take one case, A Dutch journalist was taking a taxi, and she got raped by the taxi driver. What about women being raped if they go outside with no man? When you say prove it, and it is a big fact that Muslim men rape women when they go outside alone, and I have many cases in mind, do you want me to name every case? What about honor killings of women, what about social media influencers getting killed all the time for being women on social media. You are lost. And you are not honest. Prove otherwise??

[@oussamabekk1108]

​@@therealreport2778 well i live in Morroco and This doesn't happen her ... buT I don't know about Irăq .

[@therealreport2778]

@@oussamabekk1108 The problem with some muslims is that they lie about stuff like this. Like you are doing now. I now for a fact that Morocco is one of the worst places for this. Not long ago to Scandinavian girls where killed and rapped in Morocco. Stop this lying. You know full well that Morocco is even worse than Iraq on all this. In Morocco you are known criminals and have a big Salafi/wahabi problem. In Egypt women can’t go outside in fear of being rapped. Many women, journalists where rapped in the big square where all the protest happened. I think you think it is good for you to lie and act like your country is not that bad etc. Have some balls, say it like it is.

[@malazkarar1171]

I second that!

[@barrunsoleja3156]

Educated women are better informed mothers and daughters 🙏

[@noticing33]

Depends on what theyre eduacting in. Dont need all females to be doing 9 to 4 in school what so ever.

[@scaryjoker]

Not if they're educated in gender studies.

[@Aliman12pac]

Says who? Studies show that the higher a woman's education is the less her marriage will last.

[@sba9450]

Blogging Theology/ Dilly Hussein, Paul Williams. The Muslims from around : the world must invest in building schools and universities in Kabul/ Afghanistan. I hope IEA will welcome that from genuine hearts. One thing I read I remember, during occupation of Afghanistan, Taliban destroyed schools built by US , they think it as an American property, they never wanted their books ti be taught. They were not against the education but were concerned on what is taught to their children.

[@abdula16]

@@sba9450 of all the things they need, let’s invest so that women can worshipped?

[@oussamabekk1108]

​@@abdula16 What ??? We want women to educated ... not worshiped ... astaghfiruLah

[@abdula16]

@@oussamabekk1108 in this context, education is a code word for worship. N you know that.

[@3lho_salam]

I see the reasoning and logic behind the decision Afghanistan has taken considering their current economic and infrastructural state. The hypocrisy of the West is incomprehensible to say the least. There's a deeper reason why other secular counties dont endure the same level of criticism or intervention, for example North Korea.

[@Rashidiill]

What is the logic and reason can you explain here please. ?

[@3lho_salam]

@Rashidiill as Dilly mentioned, Afghanistan has endured military occupation since 1979' with 2 major superpowers that have decimated both economy and infrastructure. As a result, on top of the economic sanctions and vaccum left since the USA left, the Islamic Republic is now left to prioritize is resource to effectively rebuild from ground up. To do so, you have to prioritize your workforce while also maintaining Islamic law traditionally. As Thomas Sowell has said- "there are no solutions, just tradeoffs" when it comes to economics- and yet very applicable to reality with material and social resource.

[@Rashidiill]

@@3lho_salam They are not first time in power. This is there second time and like every other Muslim major nation they will get after women pents and what they are wearing. Country is going through major problems and they come up with let's stop women education first. Lol modern world is too complex.

[@enlightenlife2840]

That's a load of nonsense. You and i know clearly that the Taliban are a backwards militia group that simply hates women being educated and having a choice to lead their lives as they wish. The taliban will not create a prosperous society for its citizens. They've even closed down beauty salons, and women are restricted in public places such as parks.​@3lho_salam

[@sanamt4945]

The Prophets wives should be our role model, and they were active in society.

[@Kirk-d7v]

Dr Bill Warner did a podcast on women in Islam and it differs in this context.

[@proofofmyexistence2352]

They were mothers of believers. Marriage with them after the death of Prophet SW was Haram. So don't bring them to justify. May Allah give all of us hidayah and save us from the fitnah of Feminism, Liberalism and the Redpill Movement. Ameen Suma Ameen.

[@thebesttruth4659]

🇵🇰Pakistan👎 Free Balochistan😔 Pakistan stop kidnapped and killed innocent Muslim Baloch Brother Sister😔 May Allah protect innocent Muslim Brothers Sister😔in Balochistan

[@Yeniceri550]

So heartbreaking, their concern about women in Afganistan, while doing nothing to improve daily life of women from all kinds of backgrounds in their own countries..except antidepressive medication😂

[@ahmadfrhan5265]

And they were house wives not “ strong independent women “

[@mohammadomares-haqzai6628]

I admire brother Dilly's objective journalism and observations. However, in regards to these harsh policies specifically, the ban on women's education is a matter of customs and cultural practices that are found in one ethnic tradition, mainly the pashton ethnic customs which education for females is frowned upon in some cases in history even Islamic studies were not encouraged, and of course, I have to clarify that there are some exceptional people within this ethnic group. Firstly, it has got nothing to do with Islamic shari'a. Secondly, the same curriculum that female students went through, is in fact the same for male students, the only difference is that boy's and girl's schools are separated, even during the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan. Lastly, to answer brother Dilly's question why they are so persistent on this specific policy, is that one needs to understand the formation of the Taliban's government and who holds the most authority in this regime. And of course that would be none other than The Amir Haibatullah himself. This man was and is one of the most fringe and fanatical Taliban leaders -and others that are close to him- who can not and do not want to distinguish between pashton culture and Islam, which brings me back to the first point that I made. It is true that the west is using and abusing this policy to justify and intensify the sanctions on Afghanistan which in turn they are not punishing the Taliban as much as the ordinary people of Afghanistan are being punished for nothing. FYI: Before anyone attacks me I want to clarify I am a pashtun myself, so I know the cultural practices of my people very well. In addition, I am living in Afghanistan, so that means I am someone who has been through the formal education in Afghanistan. Lastly, the points that I have mentioned are my own observations and the people around me, but just like brother Dilly mentioned it is really hard to know why they are doing this because the Taliban has not provided any formal or conclusive reasoning for these sort of policies.

[@Filo-f6p]

I'm English/Irish after reading a few book on Afghanistan its people's and history I found out that it's a Pashtun traditional not to encourage womens education. I also read that Afghanistan was a 'hippy' route in the 60's, a friendly welcoming safe country to visit. I wish other countries would have left Afghanistan alone, and sanctions is a ridiculously heinous action that helps no one.

[@noticing33]

Thats not harsh

[@rhonda8822]

@@Filo-f6p In the 1960s, Afghanistan was VERY Western. That is what made it safe and made the people happy & welcoming. It's been downhill ever since.

[@oussamabekk1108]

​@@noticing33 stop lying ... no women would live there by Choice... and I'm not even à pheminist ...

[@oussamabekk1108]

​@@rhonda8822 "in 1960s" 🤣🤣🤣 why don't you tell the full story Babe ?

[@Gabriel-vg5qv]

I have been a follower of this channel for many months now. This is firrst time me commenting on any video here. I am from Affghanistan but was rraised in the west and Alhamdulillah Im a muslim, my parents thought me Islam from early age like most good muslim parents do. I am aware of the political situation in Afghanistan since my dad follows it 247 since the beginning of time. Pardon my language but all I can say is that your guest is full of sh. Imagine at the beginning of isis or daesh these kinds of people shared all kinds of propaganda encouraging and brainnwashing people to joinn ''khalifah''. When do muslims start to learn from their mistakes and STOP following blindly every single person who carries a black and white flag? The US gave the land back to the terrorist group to keep the region unstable on purpose and to not let a counntry with over 50% under age to succeed in science or anything else. Not even mentioning the natural sources in that land and its worth which wwould turn all of their 37 cities into DUBAI! Yet this guy here acting like if he is not biased yet defending people who have THEIR OWN VERSION OF ISLAM, A MADE UP ISLAM. If youre sincerely inntrested to know what is going on then watch Ahmad Massoud (the son of national hero and the current leader of resistance against the terrorist group) rrecent interviews on youtube.

[@everythingandroidois]

Lol Ahmed Massoud, Frances' puppet, Macron who hates Islam loves him though. You are full of garbage. If I told you to give Islamic reasoning you would not be able to. And ofcourse, ignore the deals with China and Iran economically occurring now cause that does not matter at all.

[@Tovo-XV5]

It's just wrong. Every female should have the right to access to education.

[@abdulrahmanabdulghani8833]

Western women were treated badly too so check the situation in Western societies before minding in a Muslim majority countries.200000 abortions in UK...just killing young lives...

[@sba9450]

@@Tovo-XV5 But not the western or UN model schools

[@scaryjoker]

They don't have the money for useless courses.

[@alvirarahman2690]

@@scaryjokerwhat about mathematics? Nutrition? Physics? Biochemistry? Are women offered these courses in Madrasa?

[@Aliman12pac]

Every woman should have access to gender studies. 😂😂😂

[@noodlelicious.]

Thank you for sharing this. This gives me comfort.

[@chuckhillier4153]

As an open-minded American, I'm interested in knowing what sanctions have been imposed by my country and what the arguments are for their removal.

[@sandgrouse5779]

Of course Taliban get upset about this subject, it is deeply embarrassing.BTW this is not feminism but humanism at stake..

[@syedatazeen]

I’m absolutely against not educating women. But here is the catch … The government that is formed in Afghanistan should be dealt with by the people of Afghanistan. The west is worried about women in Afghanistan but not about the women and children in Gaza, Sudan? Western hypocrisy is immense. The Afghani citizens should start to work together to build their own country. Yes seek the help of international groups but don’t give into western hypocrisy. Building your country doesn’t happen in one day. The Taliban needs a mindset shift. That has to happen through the citizens.

[@Warrior-NoN]

It will not happen through its citizens unless through an uprising, since the Taliban gives no regard to what the citizens thinks. They don't let people into their government who do not agree with their superstitious beliefs.

[@MerrilyMerrilyMerrily]

Discounting 50% of the intellectual power of a country is a death sentence to its prosperity and development.

[@ij4674]

@@MerrilyMerrilyMerrily It's more like 10-15% excluding medical fields. 85-90% of STEM, and other technical intellectual power is with Ms. Is it worth the cost to make it 100%? Costs like - Mixed work and education environment has caused the 20% of inf dl ty rates in almost all wstrn countries (that's the conservative estimate, there are surveys that said higher rates) Then there is decline in fertility rate, then pension funds of France, US etc which is projected to be depleted within one or two decades because the gen z and the upcoming generation won't be able to adequately provide funds to it as to keep up with the rate at which baby boomers, gen Xers etc getting old (size of gen Z population is smallest and millenials the second smallest, the upcoming generation even smaller than gen z) Then there is dual income becoming a necessity for survival. And many more things like this. Better model is needed for us. Like a standardized test that picks top % of W to medicine, education, other fml catering fields. And rest having access to part time earning opportunities through seggregated and fml only co operative society and similiar spaces.

[@abdula16]

😂 50%? U must be a woman

[@scaryjoker]

Humanity survived for 100,000 years without it.

[@Aliman12pac]

The golden age of Islam proves otherwise. Muslims have prospered and become victorious by following the Qur'an and Sunnah of the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم

[@enlightenlife2840]

​@@Aliman12pacyour very imaginative lol. The only reason they prospered was due to a liberal non conformist society 😂. Not a society like the Taliban trying to create.

[@abdinur6152]

It seems they made up their own islam, they don't follow the real islam. The prophet (SAW) ordered that every Muslim should seek education

[@moralisoppression2837]

Why didnt the prophet make university that mix women and men then ?

[@anairanzu1]

​@@moralisoppression2837The first university was started by a muslim woman

[@ice-cream313]

@moralisoppression2837 bro. In the masjid of the Prophet there was no physical wall or barrier between men and women. They just had seperate entrances. Outside the masjid men and women interacted (within limits). You find that in the seerah. It wasn't like Taliban society.

[@Rashidiill]

​@@moralisoppression2837read the Hadith when they were discussing about limits on Mehr.

[@mdaslam6337]

​@@moralisoppression2837When did the Prophet order Muslim women not to seek education?

[@tahsinislammahi7346]

In order to fulfill roles as mothers, women need education as well. Something that is not possible under what the Taliban has limited for the women.

[@ij4674]

There is not a single Wstrn cntry which have infd lt y rate lower than 20%, and whom do most of them do that with? Coworkers, and long term acquaintances, aka those who they meets or met in mixed environments. Protecting some things like this are and have to be bigger priority.

[@موسى_7]

​@@ij4674 Education has nothing to do with adultery. It's the lack of hijab which causes adultery, because when there is hijab and degradation, it's impossible for a man to become attracted to a woman who is someone else's wife (because he can't see her) and it's impossible for a woman to seek attention from men other than her husband (because she is segregated away).

[@ij4674]

@@موسى_7 We don't live in a utopia, first they will ask for this and then for the 'choice' to remove that and segregation. Even in Shanghai China, inf dlt rate went up to 20% in just two decades from low single digits in early 2000. Ones you 'modernize', put both into the work place in large enough numbers, then these things are bound to happen, within 2 or 3 generations.

[@TravelingPhilosopher]

​@@ij4674That is the fallacy of slippery slope. So they are not allowed education because they will get corrupted? What kind of thinking is this? Are they this intellectually incompetent that they won't be able to understand reality?

[@ij4674]

@@TravelingPhilosopher Slippery slope in many cases is not a fallacy but very much a reality.

[@maruf2050]

I have been taking online IELTS classes for Afgans.

[@Azhar_shaikh1]

Please tell more

[@dm_1236]

This is all because of America. America destroyed the trust of Afghanistan in medicine which is why polio is still an issue. Same thing with education.

[@harharharharharharharharha240]

Afghanistan was also affected by the soviets. Two awful nations waiting to take their piece of Afghanistan

[@موسى_7]

This is what I thought too. I think Afghan folks are afraid that education might erode their culture. You know, most Afghans are rural people, and if you know anything about rural people, it is that they are all idiots who believe in conspiracy theories, even in developed countries like the UK, USA, Germany, and the Netherlands. That's why Afghanistan has such a barbaric government: most of their population doesn't live in cities. Compare that to Iran and Türkiye, with all their technology and strong institutions, which are a result of highly urbanised societies.

[@rhonda8822]

Blame it all on your krappy allah. It's the way he wants it to be---it's his will.

[@SongsMalaysia]

There is a saying in my Malay culture "The hand that rocks the cradle is able to shake the world," telling the importance how women can change the course of the entire nation. There are studies that educated women hugely influence the children education and wellbeing. Some Muslims in certain Muslim countries have a narrow mind that educating women promotes feminism and reduce their independence on men. Many highly educated women I know, invest so much time on educating children and some of them homeschool the children because they have the knowledge far more than school teacher. While lack of resource is understandable, they must know that limiting women, will invite more feminist and liberals to influence their women the moment they have chance.

[@موسى_7]

I think people in Afghanistan don't trust education, because unlike Malaysia, Afganistan has been the target of foreign governments and NGOs promoting foreign agendas which influenced the educational sector and curriculums heavily. Malaysia, thanks to its 30% Chinese population, did not end up reliant on America for its development, because Chinese people have an economic philosophy which leads to self-sufficiency rather than reliance on unequal exchange with more powerful countries. Had it not been for Chinese Malaysians, Malaysia may have ended up like Egypt, which lacks car companies such as Proton and Perodua, and an animation industry with such studios as Monsta and Wau. The Chinese people of Malaysia imparted their ideas of economic development into the Malaysian culture, which prevented Malaysia from becoming like Indonesia, which for so long has relied on foreign companies from countries such as Japan. Indonesia is five times as large as Malaysia yet relies on Toyota instead of having its own automotive technology research and development. Malaysia is comparatively tiny yet has two car companies, Proton and Perodua, developing indigenous technology. Indonesians watch Malaysian cartoons such as Boboiboy and Ejen Ali, rather than Malaysians watching Indonesian cartoons.This is because the Malaysian government, and not the Indonesian government, has a philosophy of supporting local industries, a Chinese/Japanese/Korean economic philsophy. Afganistan, being a poor former communist country, lacks any semblance of self-sufficiency, and was always reliant entirely either on the Soviet Union or on the aid of the American government and Western NGOs.

[@springsxd]

I'm sorry brother but with all due respect, any person with his mental faculties intact and is sincere will be able to draw the correlation between degeneracy of society and this supposed "education" that these liberal western aligned "muslims" love to spout. If you prefer your women to be western educated and to dwell among na-mehram males, that's your demise and may Allah guide you, however we have seen the outcomes of the ideological injection that comes with this so called education you all love so much and there is no way we are going to expose our women to such filth. Salam

[@sweeyong7756]

Malaysia is not true islamic country with islamic laws. Sorry.

[@noticing33]

A society should not aim to put as much women into the workforce

[@Nishful5]

A big part of the reason the U.S. government supported the feminist movement from the 1960’s onwards, was because the more women joining the workforce, the more people to collect taxes from. Suddenly, half the adult population went from not paying taxes to paying taxes.

[@Obit0bi]

They cant get a mm of sunlight touch their skin when the enter outsides they cant meet doctors as there are only men Its better to live under🇮🇱than to live under these scmss

[@oussamabekk1108]

Education doesn't mean joining the work Force , education for Women is not haram , Stop making the halale Haram , Stop denying your muṣlim sisters their God given rights .

[@sharky2x2]

​​​​@@oussamabekk1108school modern education system does it been designed for that!!!, if it comes to learning yes women can have access to Islamic schools and libraries and books or online sources too, no one can deny them from '' learning'' or reading. Why are talking like the only way to learn or get knowledge only by the modern school systems?

[@abdur-rahmankhalil4957]

As an Afghan who lives in Afghanistan… I ask all influencers (Muslim and non Muslim) to be more accurate in reflecting the reality in Afghanistan, by interviewing educated people from outside the Afghan government! It is quite simple! The Afghan Government, very obviously and clearly are not allowing their Muslim Afghan critics (who live inside Afghanistan) to speak up about what the nation wants! And for you Mr dilly Husain: you repeatedly said that you just reflected the reality.. but let me ask: what is the benefit of just coming and interviewing the spokesperson of the government?! It is ok to do so but only if you balance the issue and give the chance to an educated Muslim critic to explain what we Afghan face in terms of having stable political, social and economic life.

[@Red_Lion2000]

Sexist religion.

[@gaza1677]

So what about medical studies that involve private areas are they expecting only men to do these jobs

[@TomassoTrekks]

I’m a devout Muslim and I believe in the religion, that being said they should have higher educational opportunities. But also, Afghanistan has had a really rough history so I do understand that funds are limited in which case educational resources should be shifted towards men until the society can stabilize inshallah.

[@skepticalzostrianos9875]

That is such a BS argument, if they really want to segregate the sexes they can literally just put a curtain (or put a microphone in another room) and let the women listen to the same lectures as the boys in high schools or university. No modern country ever forbade the educations of girls just because they don't have the "ressources" after their war, Libya, Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, Somalia, Mali, Palestine, etc. no one ever had this problem..exept Afghanistan for some reason? Bullshit.

[@125discipline2]

there's no higher educational opportunities for most afghan because, look at the fckng country. not even men can have the opportunities afghanistan was bombed to the stone age by the west, and the west have the audacity to slander afghanistan for their poor condition

[@anggadi1564]

Eat first

[@moralisoppression2837]

Look at country that gave women rights for education. All stray away from god

[@lanturn7874]

​@@moralisoppression2837Education is good but western education is what causes problems

[@Free_Palastine_01]

Daily Hussain Take your family to Afghanistan and live there

[@sunamoina8576]

And you keep licking what you are licking

[@humaira917]

Who is going to treat their women if women are not studying medicine? Who is going to examine their female patients-I am sure they wouldn't let male doctors do that. I wonder if any of these Talibans have actually read Quran or seerah.

[@Yeniceri550]

@@humaira917 How many female doctors did 20 years of Nato occupation with all of it's Soros funded ngo's produce?

[@IronMan-nu3rb]

It's really time for Taliban to allow Women's education. I really don't get it why stop their education?? Women are required in Police...yes in Police, in Doctor profession, Nurse, TV anchor/Reporter, Banker, Teacher, Beauty Parlor(for those who wants), in IT sector. At least these areas are Must. Rest if Talibans not allow it then Ok. I don't have much hope from them anyway. Btw do you know... America is paying almost $40 million/week to Talibs. Yes... America is paying the amount per week.

[@موسى_7]

💯

[@sba9450]

@@humaira917 Who will invest in building medical schools ? Afghan money is frozen in banks

[@skepticalzostrianos9875]

@@sba9450 Schools are already built dude, the american occupation did it. The Taliban just closed them and forbade girls education.

[@kiwidawah5976]

We will change the reality. I got 2 daughters. They are home schooled. No mix education, no higher education.

[@Free_Palastine_01]

Free Afghanistan from Taliban Terrorists.

[@pellesvansl]

If this awakens your heart it might be justified.....but Afgan women studying in th West are appreciating they are able to get an education even if they are orphans

[@alinatarasyukrussianrefuge6549]

A briton and his indian interloping in Afg affairs. A curse going back 300 years.

[@kingmaker2603]

Interesting topic. Although i do consider taliban the best muslim govt in the world by far.

[@theexotic2983]

This is a betrayal of the trust their women had in them. Knowledge is light why would you want women, the mothers of your kids to be in the darkness of ignorance? SubhanaAllah!

[@cyberyousef6405]

The problem is that most of you women say that, these stuff don’t make you learn anything, they only make you a worker to work under a boss Knowledge is light, but you realize that ignorance is subjective? You realize that what school and university teaches is mostly useless knowledge So you are an educated mother, but you are still ignorant about the deen, you are still ignorant about psychology, you are still ignorance about craftsmanship As you can see you are still an ignorant mother with your logic, the prophet used to always say “i seek refuge by allah from useless knowledge” useless knowledge is what they mostly teach at schools and universities, but they are no longer useless knowledge because they force on you a job that will use 1% of the knowledge you had, also this whole job is unnecessary for a woman anyway

[@farhalbasu6853]

A cat has got more rights than a woman in Afghanistan 😢

[@Far180021]

Brother Paul, I discovered your channel a few years ago, and since then, your content has significantly broadened my intellectual and spiritual horizons. However, seeing Taliban apologists on your platform deeply concerns me and raises serious questions about the credibility and integrity of your channel Consider, for example, Mr. Hussain’s claim that the Taliban have widespread support among the Afghan population. Yet he admits to having spoken only to Pashtuns, while overlooking the majority of Afghanistan’s people-Tajiks, Hazaras, Uzbeks, and other ethnic groups. Isn't that inherently contradictory? Ethnofascism, tribalism, and totalitarianism have no place in Islam. The Taliban, with their mix of primitive Pashtun tribal customs and Deobandi ideology imported from South Asia, neither represent the rich, traditional Islam of most people in Afghanistan nor embody the essence of true Islam. Instead, they tarnish Islam’s image on a global scale. Extremist groups like the Taliban, ISIS, Boko Haram, and their apologists should not be given a platform. It's evident from the comments that most viewers share my sentiments. I'm hopeful we won't encounter individuals similar to Dilly Hussain on your channel again

[@MansMan42069]

lol

[@موسى_7]

​@@MansMan42069 When even Iran criticises the Taliban, you have no right to defend the Taliban.

[@MansMan42069]

@@موسى_7 lol

[@cyberyousef6405]

The taliban isn’t extremist and don’t compare it to 1s1s

[@skepticalzostrianos9875]

His platform is filled with salafists who have still this gender war mindset as you can see (imported from the US mind you). It's been a while since Paul had begun inviting guests like this, I susbribed to him through one of his video about islamic philosophy but since then I feel like he did a 180 degree and know follows these extremist ideas.

[@MuhammadFarhan-v7g]

Islam zindabad

[@Noorul48]

The Taliban has dehumanised Afghan women. Anyone defending the Taliban is a disgrace.

[@YeshuaIsLord7777]

@@Noorul48 amen

[@Jareers-ef8hp]

🤣🤣🤣🤣 sure thing buddy

[@MalikLMA453]

Well they do 8 things right and 2 wrong, just like normal leaders.

[@letmetalk2240]

Israel-Hamas war should be a lesson to all Muslims on the propaganda by the Western media. Don't be too quick to judge other Muslims.

[@mantesdrekoornb794]

Well, you seem as a disgrace, because now you dehumanizing the Muslims brothers, because they are doing other things right, however taliban leadership are siding with kuffars, but one thing they fell short about women, maybe it's we that need to learn the reason, why they do what they do.

[@REwing]

All cultures take time to serve the needs of the people as history develops the nation into the next millennium. A little girl with a brilliant IQ will probably learn from her brothers!!!

[@HumanHeartIsNotJustFlesh]

Many girls dream to become a doctor. Is it haram for a girl to become doctor?

[@oussamabekk1108]

No ... but that's Pashtun culture ... they can't help but mixe Culture with islam...

[@everythingandroidois]

​​@@oussamabekk1108Doctors are fine, but what percentage of society becomes doctors? .003 percent of females? I mean let's be real here. So why push University to all when not all will use it in an islamic way or means? You just cater a small percentage. And no, Islam in no time in history has made it obligatory to seek non-Islamic education according to any classical scholar.

[@Crystalupnorth]

Reverting to Islam is almost impossible for me due to these groups like the Taliban who say their way is "true Islam". It makes me cry that they let foreign travelers (even women) come and do whatever and receive warm welcomes and gifts but don't help their community like that :( Food is important, yes, and so are jobs. More countries would help Afghanistan if they would stop being so defensive all the time and blaming everyone else for their struggles. Yes, you were occupied and are recovering from war, but so are many other countries and they used the resources given wisely to be able to thrive after the occupiers left and war ended. Women deserve more ways to help their families and, not to mention, women who have no one and cannot feed themselves or their children at all because jobs are prohibited for them. The physical and mental health will continue to suffer if you keep making mistakes like this... it's sickening. The following hadith helps me when trying to see true Islam rather than this extremist version: “Religion is easy, and no one overburdens himself in his religion but he will be unable to continue in that way. So do not be extremists, but try to be near perfection and receive the good tidings that you will be rewarded. Gain strength by worshipping in the mornings and afternoons and during the last hours of the night.” Narrated by al-Bukhaari (39) and Muslim (2816).

[@abdula16]

Umm are you suppose to be crying over this? Don’t even convert if u want to. 😂

[@موسى_7]

How silly of you to take rural barbarians so seriously that you refuse to become a Muslim. Do you think rural people whose neighbours are cows and sheep can ever be civilised under any religion? Rural people in the most civilised of countries are racists and attack immigrants, despite being drunk atheists who have no religion to teach them to hate people. If you want to see proper Islam, you need to look at more urbanised societies like Iran and Iraq and Malaysia.

[@abdula16]

@Dhxhdhdhsdh what? Who the hell the cries when people leave Islam? She needs Islam, Islam doesn’t need her. The idea that if her desires aren’t tended to, is our loss, is just absurd

[@abdula16]

@@zzzzz-w4i2t yes but what’s wrong with what is said. She wants to be worshipped or else she won’t be a Muslim. We don’t care really

[@mdaslam6337]

​@@abdula16She basically criticized tge Taliban for their unislamic ways that discourages non Muslims from accepting the Truth whole heartedly. Stop advocating for that US funded group.

[@iahmedmr]

Dilly is no shill for Afghanistan

[@generalali7609]

4:49 let the women choose. And if there is no need then she can do something else.

[@Optimismus53]

like woman in the usa right now. they were allowed to have a say on the issue of abortion😏

[@generalali7609]

@@Optimismus53 I will try to be very nice but you don’t understand anything about abortion even in the Islamic sense. Abortion is a very important part of health care, the reasons for abortion are the issues and they must be separated. Every country on earth allows abortion because the life of the mother oftentimes is at risk. The question of what is the latest an abortion should be performed is an ideological one. And all throughout the world it is different. And here is the question. If someone that’s 20 week pregnant can get one because it will save the mother’s life then that means we make a distinction to life inside the mother and life outside. Now how much of a risk should the mother’s life be at for it to be ok. Should that be put to the government or her doctor that will know her situation at the moment.

[@ahmadfrhan5265]

ZIP lit liberal you are already a Murtad

[@125discipline2]

you can not choose whatever you want, someone wants higher education, does he or his family have the capability to give him higher education? if they dont have that capability does that mean afghanistan is to blame? meanwhile america the strongest country on this planet, cant even afford free healthcare. afghanistan was bombed to the stone age by the west, and they have the audacity to slander afghanistan for their poor condition

[@tahsinislammahi7346]

​@@generalali7609but abortion is the last option that a woman should opt for. US women want to abort the fetus as soon as they become aware of unwanted pregnancy

[@onzs4542]

Mashallah brother paul 😊

[@ZiaurRahman-mp3bd]

Release the reserve of Afghanistan (9.5 billion) which was fridged by US administrastion in Federal Reserve.

[@Apsua72]

It's sounds bad about the education of girls in Afghanistan but don't forget how society in western world degenerate the more woman get education. Divorce rate, abortion, hook up culture and single motherhood is skyrocketing. Maybe they aren't that stupid and notice this and just don't want that to happen to their society. just a thought.

[@alvirarahman2690]

Why can’t girls study in girls only environments? Where do u even see the hook up culture in girls only schools colleges? Why do u straight go to the West as an example? Aren’t there schools colleges and universities for women in Qatar or Bahrain or Saudi with no hook ups or night clubs or abortions? I know why u will not look into these. Cause ur dumb arguments only work when u talk about the West.

[@kanizafsana4508]

Divorce rate ,abortion are skyrocketing ,it isn't due to girl's education.It's due to immodesty,feminism.Their religion doesn't support correct modesty.But In Islam there is strict modesty . Islam doesn't directly prohibit girl's education.Women should give their rights for education otherwise atheism and Islam phobia may grow in this Afgan society.This is the black future.And Taliban is the culprit for it but not Islam

[@alvirarahman2690]

I just wanna know what sort of courses the Madrasa offers? If they teach Islamic studies, Maths, Chemistry, Biology, Physics, Computer Science etc. then that’s pretty okay.

[@enlightenlife2840]

Not everyone is smart enough to make a living through these subjects. Some might want ro study arts, teaching, business or plumbing. You cannot control people in the name you know what's best for them.

[@everythingandroidois]

Who said Muslims need to study all these things? What percentage of the population will actually use this in their work? Or is it just to satisfy the "liberal western education superiority delusion"?

[@sksaad9589]

There is Gender-Based apartheid going in Afghanistan right now. If we justify this apartheid regime of taliban then we have no ground or base to criticise Israel for this ongoing conflict. Zionism uses Judaism and Taliban uses Islam to justify their wrongdoings.

[@abdula16]

Makes no sense

[@sksaad9589]

@@abdula16 Both uses religion to oppress people and justify apartheid. If you can't see that then you are biased.

[@gardenvariety-]

But Paul, you met with Haqiqtju, or whatever his name is, and he is against women education.

[@Yeniceri550]

Excellent

[@ice-cream313]

Thanks for discussing this. The Taliban have brought much welcome stability, but they aren't doing themselves or their people any favours by being so regressive. Islam doesn't advocate this backwardness.

[@Umar-qy3bd]

This 'regressiveness' and 'backwardness' is an oriental term, by which racist colonialists have justified occupying the countries of natives by making the excuse that they were simply 'civilizing' 'backwards cavemen'.

[@ice-cream313]

@Umar-qy3bd you may have a point racist colonialists, but it doesn't sugarcoat the fact that Taliban have chosen to be very backwards in some areas, such as women's education. Although Islam doesn't ban or restrict women's education the way Taliban do. This issue has nothing to do with racist colonialists.

[@Umar-qy3bd]

@@ice-cream313 We are reaching conclusions too fast, we don't know what their intentions are, especially with the limited resources they have. All I know is Islam does not allow mixing between men and women.

[@ice-cream313]

@@Umar-qy3bd that depends on what you mean by 'mixing'. Men and women used to interact in the time of the Prophet (saw). They didn't always segregate in every aspect of life the way some Muslims insist on today.

[@lanturn7874]

@ice-cream313 This whole 'womens education' thing is just a Trojan horse for the West, aiming to make everyone follow their way. A battle of ideologies. If they care so much about women rights, the first to be helped should be the Palestinians, but we all know the Western media went silent about that a long time ago. This shows where their criticisms are aimed at.

[@nibraszuhair]

The Taliban defeated two superpowers. They can do anything they want; it's their nation.

[@oussamabekk1108]

You would never live there ... your sister would not , you Mother wouldn't ... have sympathy for your afghani Sisters .

[@thehourglassfan3515]

No.

[@themccarthyplan2020]

The future begins in the womb🕊️🙏💚☘️

[@abdeallahbennaceur3087]

Madrassa means school in english 😅 just say school stop confusing the mass

[@oussamabekk1108]

Well by "Madrasa" He means Islamic school ...

[@enlightenlife2840]

​@@oussamabekk1108 they shouldn't use the term madrassa to mean islamic school because madrassa just means school. You can have a madrassa that teaches ballet. We need to stop using these arabic words like the way the islamophobes use it

[@petergamston1]

The primary goal of education should be to impart a capacity for critical thinking. Indoctrination is not education. The "education" the men and boys receive is probably as destructive as the education the women and girls are being denied. Religious education is extremely important but should be taught where it belongs - in the history curriculum.

[@personalprofile1939]

Every state owned education is indoctrination of what the elders think. Can you show me one country in the world that doesn't indoctrinate children?

[@petergamston1]

@@personalprofile1939 Most countries. Why do you think science is taught in laboratories rather than just from books?

[@mohdnorzaihar2632]

The reality is that each generation is definitely facing an "ageing population" so that each boys&girl has to be trained as a nurse@caretaker. That's what basic "education"really is.

[@daniellisy7161]

Leave the western perspective out if you want, but look at works of say Dr. Walked Ziad who specialises on Afganistan and you see woman education within traditional pre 20th century was very much a part of the culture. May be invite him to you podcast and have a expert on the topic.

[@phantomtr1]

Why are you guys feeding into the media, and talking about the taliban as an independent organization trying to lead a country? How have you forgotten about who created, supplied and funds them?

[@rajairfan2768]

the current taliban isnt the same as 20 years ago. whether you like it or not they are the one governing the country. they even created rehabilitation for Afghans. addicts arent as common as it was before

[@abdelhakyac7285]

You mean the good guys are the ones who subjected the country to opium culture and addiction like the british obliterated china..... and the bad guys are the ones who steal no single penny from the citizens, try the best to uplift the country, even if they are a bit extreme on women’s education over 12 years old, yes it isnt good, but anything besides that, its the most honest gvernment in the world in the last hundred years, and all their problems come from western subjugation and economic heist...... leave them 10 years, you wont reconize their country, its a simple equation, if the government dosent steal, prosperity will unevitably reign

[@alinatarasyukrussianrefuge6549]

a british guy and hs indian have joined to interlope in Afg. what else is new?

[@alinatarasyukrussianrefuge6549]

a british guy and hs indian have joined to interlope in Afg. what else is new?

[@afshanfatima5104]

How can this stance of theirs be supported in the name of religion, when the prophet (sas) said , that gaining knowledge is compulsory for all Muslims, when the first revelation given to the prophet alayhi salam is “ iqra” , in the same surah and again part of the revelation is thae ayah, “ allazi allama bil qalam ( He taught you to write with the pen). Lastly , not having girls ( who constitute half of the population) would reflect badly on the society, in terms of uneducated mothers. Lastly we as Muslims know very well , half of our deen is coming to us from our mother Ayesha who related more than 2000 hadith which constitutes the shariah. I would agree with the Taliban that the western system of education might not be the idealistic education for girls but then they should design a new Islamic curriculum which incorporates within it the best way forward for girls , where the girls emerge as proud muslimas, empowered and educated and strong mothers

[@abbadubenzwin5157]

Afghanistan Symboling is starting government in development from zero

[@hasanozgurtasci]

let afgan's leave alone..! whole world tried to changed them without success.! this is how they want to live..! accept this harsh truth!

[@Troo-lm9ht]

Dilly doesn't believe on the Quran part which says Iqra, the very first verse revealed to prophet Muhammad saw. He is a monfiq

[@Nishful5]

Don’t be a troll. He is trying to explain the situation in Afghanistan. He is not defending it or saying it is right.

[@Troo-lm9ht]

@@Nishful5 you stupids setting in a safe place with your families trying to be happy for another people to have no safety and security for themselves and their families, because a terrorist group is using the name of Islam while taking 85 million dollars from cia each single week. Grow up and have some humanity. Do your research

[@everythingandroidois]

​​@@Troo-lm9htSo "Iqra" in the Quran means going to college to study humanities and western psychology, thanks. Genius. Go back to studying islam off of AI programs rather than actual evidence and classical scholars.

[@Troo-lm9ht]

@ I might not be a genius but I know that the first University was built by a Muslim woman. West did not know anything about college or university until the crusaders saw the Muslims had Universities and went back to Europe and adopted it and developed it. And now te ro r!s ts like tban and their like minded believe that Islam doesn't encourage education. Do some research....

[@hussainalikabi6570]

Fire video

[@sba9450]

The Taliban are most scared of books( I think the western books like evolution theory)not bombs of the NATO/ west/ US

[@personalprofile1939]

I guess they are cautious of both, and rightly so. Who in his sane mind would allow his enemy to indoctrinate his own children?

[@sba9450]

@@personalprofile1939 I just remembered so I am sharing . There is a book called Funny in Farsi, that was recommended for elementary school to read, there’s a conversation between the dad and the son on pork. The father opens a can of pork meat, the son looks at it and asks him this is prohibited in our religion. The father replies 1400 years ago they didn’t know how to cure the meat , they didn’t have high temperature cooking methods. This a an example of how they try to corrupt religion in children’s minds

[@ramlafatima-ql4rs]

why is it always about girls n women when it comes to taliban......!!why is it always abt girls rights n lives....!!i never heard anything being discussed abt boys or men !! It's always always abt females.....btw not letting women or girls being educated is actually against our islam.....!

[@Nishful5]

It’s a strange (Western) obsession that the only lens that Afghanistan can be seen through is this one issue. Dilly finally says at the end of this clip that Afghans are sick of it when they have so many other problems like getting enough food, unemployment and making ends meet..

[@aaaaaaaaaaaa9023]

Bless Afghanistan. May Allah show the hypocrisy and insincerity of the west.

[@rhonda8822]

allah is not blessing anything these days relating to islam. I think allah died.

[@MasoodKhan-so9hv]

founders of feminism where influenced by Theosaphy. You know no more men and women we been fighting for too long one gender for everyone mandatory.Theosaphy teaches that Lilith was married to Adam and they where created equals, but Adam demanded control so Lilith left Adam and found Lucifer after which they fell in love. In the Jewish tradition, Lilith was the first wife of Adam (‘alayhi as’salam) but rejected by him for her too independent personality, eventually kicked out and becoming a sort of demonic figure. Gershom Scholem, the modern specialist of Kabbalah, famously defined this esoteric Jewish school as a way to attain “androgynous union,” in the sense that for Kabbalists a man who reaches the “perfect spiritual state,” that of “Adam Kadmon” or Primordial Adam, is somehow gender-less, or both genders at the same time, which thus reflects the “gender dualism” of the Tree of Life itself. This is the same beliefs of the satanic church

[@MoeedKhan1979]

other thing is why western human rights champions imposed ban on war torned afghanistan. give them thier funds and then you have a right to condemn their policies. stop bieng double standard humans.

[@MGold00]

I hear everything said about education of women. Taliban said its 3 year pause. That was 2 year ago so in a years time girls schoolingl must be reintroduced. Besides the can talk all they want saying home homeschooling and stuff. A woman to homeschool her children must be educated herself 1st.

[@HomeTravelGardenInspo]

Exactly! How can a woman who is not educated herself in either Islam , the Arabic language or main core subjects as maths, science and English, then how the hell will she be homeschooling her children. Parents in the West couldn’t even homeschool their children during lockdown, and that’s with all the tech and government support.The Taliban are just backwards minded and I’m now questioning their intentions and who’s actually behind these new Un-Islamic rules. I can see these rules spiralling out of control on local levels, and the local misogynistic men, will be taking matters into their own hands and abuse their power against women and girls. They have not helped their country by creating these stupid rules. We have seen men in these countries, take matters in their own hands, where they beat the women publicly when “they” believe the woman is going against the new laws. Utterly disgraceful behaviour, where they are using their Pashtun cultural practices and disguising it as Islam, when they are actually practicing nationalism/tribal nationalism.

[@arafatcham2306]

This is absurd, goodness gracious

[@mujahidhasan118]

1. Afghanistan is a tribals country. 2. these tribals have their won culture and tradition. 3. some of the culture and traditions are literally pagain practices. (which don't imply with Islam) 4. they justify their tribal paigan cultural/traditional practices by using and stretching meanings of Hadith and Quran. 5. also all the talibans are not the same, there are almost hundred of thousands of taliban memebers, they are from different region and from different tribal and they have different type of cultural and tradition I already said that. I heard there is a huge disagreement on different type of subjects ethics and moral between even talibans. also HOW MANY WOMEN THEY HAVE K1LL3D AND RP IN THE NAME OF WOMEN RIGHTS AND FREEDOM IN THE MIDDLE EAST. JUST LOOK AT GAZA PALESTINE. DO YOU REALLY THINK THEY HERE ABOUT WOMEN AND CHILDREN?? THE SAME THING DID IT IN IRAQ SYRIA LIBYA SOMALIA AFGHANISTAN AND LASTLY PALESTINE. DE DO NOT CARE THEY DON'T SEE US AS HUMAN BEING.

[@kadarrahmane6608]

I agree with them to be honest..

[@Wenutz]

If you agree with them muslim countries will always be abused. Look what Israel can do and muslim countries can't do anything about it. No science, no weapons, nothing.

[@Raks78]

Me too

[@Wenutz]

Muslim countries remain weak as long as people agree with u. Look how zionists are beating us around the middle east....

[@ahmadfrhan5265]

Western education is not for Muslims it leads to individualism and the priority of self over society. Women will not be moms and have proper family in western education. The priority of a woman must not be a Job and under Islamic Government, it will pay for women to be housewives and increase the salary of men to raise family. An Islami c 2 tate is ideal state

[@alkhalilquranmedia7337]

Me too

[@dinoraul119]

Not satisfied

[@AhmadSayed-n5x]

Taliban what a dodgy name

[@Nishful5]

“The Students” (“Taliban”) who are anti-education and don’t allow half their population to be students? That is funny when you think about it. Or just really sad…

[@maxmorris4562]

15:50

[@maxmorris4562]

1:08

[@Zta607]

Daily Hussain your sister is in university and you talk from your stomach

[@Dawahguy0099]

Improve your content quality man😮

[@BloggingTheology]

suggestions?

[@Dawahguy0099]

@@BloggingTheology improve your video quality(hd) ,sound clarity (good podcast sound you can improve your sound on Adobe podcast) , , and background...

[@darshanathapa99]

Dilly is silly.

[@Azhar_shaikh1]

Junaid Baghdadi R.A once said (on studying alone, male with female)? "If the student is Rabia Basri RA,the teacher is Hassan Basri RA,the place where they study is Kaaba and the subject they study is Quran,even then it is not permissible" This stopping of women's education at 16, does not in any way discredit the taliban. Heck, 20-30 years ago, 90% or maybe more women weren't educated beyond 16 yo and got married, in many countries, even in india. Let them handle this issue themselves. Its always better than nato or soviet occupation

[@hyerinmeong]

Pray for Afghanistan women 😢 #freeafghanistanwomenfromterrorist

[@buffalonewyorker257]

With the goal of a moral society and family building this makes perfect sense. Women's higher education likely leads to nothing but higher divorce rates and population decline.

[@موسى_7]

Yes, in a society where jobs are few, sexual immortality and violent crime might run rampant if men's jobs are taken by women, because that makes marriage harder and more expensive. I'm playing devil's advocate here, because I like to be sympathetic to rural barbarians because I know that we shouldn't judge them in the same way we judge city people. Having an urban mindset would destroy one's life if he was living in a cattle ranch, so we shouldn't see rural barbarism as necessarily inferior, but as a lifestyle adapted to the economic conditions of rural life. The civility of urban people compared to rural people is the reason why Egyptians and Iraqis and Turks are superior to Saudis and UAE folks.

[@buffalonewyorker257]

@@موسى_7 You know urbanization has its pros and cons. Perhaps short lived pros though. Of course it requires a higher degree of sophistication. There is evidence that urbanization along with women's education are key contributors to population decline. At least the Taliban are trying to tackle one of those issues. I have a great deal of respect for that.

[@موسى_7]

​@@buffalonewyorker257 Urbanisation doesn't have disadvantages except those created by economic mismanagement, such as air pollution and traffic congestion caused by a lack of public transportation, or dirtiness caused by poor sewer services. Urbanisation is a necessity, because it creates industry and wealth and culture, which are essential in geopolitical competition. Industry creates weapons in war and exportable goods in peacetime, money discourages people from selling their loyalty to foreign enemies, and culture protects the local ideology from foreign ideologies. Rural places only serve one purpose: making food. Perhaps you could add tourism, but food is more important. A reduced rural population is not an issue, because the best farming uses less labour and more machinery to make wheat and bread cheaper. A declining population isn't a result of urbanisation by itself, but rather by the exhaustion of economic resources in developed countries, and by capitalism which causes wealth to concentrate upwards and prevents common people from having enough stability to have children. Socialist systems can cause populations to remain stable. It is because of capitalism that Japan, South Korea, and Bulgaria have population crises. Communism in and of itself didn't cause China's one-child disaster, but rather it was poor and Draconian policy which forced families to have ojly one child. India's future problems are a result of abortion allowing parents to choose the gender of their child. This resulted in a surplus of boys and a shortage of girls.

[@buffalonewyorker257]

@@موسى_7 No urbanization does have disadvantages. It slows population growth this is taking place even in India. The reason being that child rearing becomes a financial liability as opposed to an asset whereas in rural areas the children work and contribute financially thus making them assets.

[@Troo-lm9ht]

The stupidest person award in this chat goes to buffalo. Oh sorry you are a cow. Cows don't need education

this is pure propaganda

[@shernawabkhan9441]

Well they were educated in Pakistan madrassas by Pakistan security .i dont see anyone blaming Pakistan.

[@abdullahahmad9300]

Atleast men can be men in Afghanistan You dont have to worry about Independent rich career women LOL

[@abdulmazid6051]

.

[@thebesttruth4659]

🇵🇰Pakistan👎 Free Balochistan😔 Pakistan stop kidnapped and killed innocent Muslim Baloch Brother Sister😔 May Allah protect innocent Muslim Brothers Sister😔in Balochistan

[@AI-uc1vs]

Ok…thanks for sharing ur thoughts our BJP friend

[@IronMan-nu3rb]

Oho...aa gaya Baloch Muslimo ka dost😂😂 Sale Pa.jit pehle Indian Muslimo ko respect karo. Kashmir ka occupation khatam karo fir Balochistan ka drama karna

[@thebesttruth4659]

@@AI-uc1vs Pakistan stop kidnapped and killed innocent Muslim Brothers Sister😔

[@thebesttruth4659]

@@AI-uc1vs Sunno not happy with truth

[@alinatarasyukrussianrefuge6549]

why post this here? go find support in a proper place. pkstan is a sht stain on everyone it surrounds for sure. it has no reason to even x ist.

[@YeshuaIsLord7777]

This is the real Islam. Ahumdillilah

[@jostnamane3951]

By that logic, the republic of Gilead (or handmaid's tale) is real Christianity, right?

[@YeshuaIsLord7777]

​@jostnamane3951 are you comparing a fictional place and story to an actual country in the Middle East? 😂 just a bunch of illiterate men who wish they were residing in 7th century Arabia. Stop.making excuses

[@موسى_7]

​@@jostnamane3951 The guy you're talking to is a Muslim. He said AlhamdulIllah. He probably doesn't know what Handmaid's Tale is, because only American leftists read that book. I only heard of it from Ted Ed.

[@Umar-qy3bd]

His name is Yeshua , or Jesus is "lord", he's a polythiest, he can''t be a muslim.

[@موسى_7]

​@@Umar-qy3bd Oh, he was being sarcastic

[@universal-truth-]

There are already enough female doctors, nurses and police in Afghanistan, so there is no need to waste time and effort on the entire female population unless the need arises. In addition, it is not the role of women to be providers for the family. This task is assigned to men in the Holy Quran because men are physically and mentally strong. Women were not created for physical labor like men. Because their duty is to nurture and care for children, which has a status of honor and dignity. Men are the protectors and maintainers of women, *because Allah has given the one more (strength) than the other, and because they support them from their means*. Quran 4:34

[@imir_]

"There are already enough female doctors, nurses and police in Afghanistan, so there is no need to waste time and effort on the entire female population unless the need arises." According to your logic, if you want to be an engineer and they tell you "no we have enough you'll be a farmer we need them" you'll have to become one.

[@oussamabekk1108]

It is not your Choice to make nor Taliban's , education for Women is not Haram so you have no right to take away there God given rights cause you feel like iT , that's not islam... that's just misogyny. And No , you lied there is not enough female Doctors in that country , and 0 police officers ( No problem cause women shouldn't do these dangerous jobs anyway ) But you can't Stop Women from becoming Doctors and Teachers .

[@Aliman12pac]

Well said, brother. Some people have succumbed to the dominant liberal, feminist culture of the West and take it to be precedent over the Qur'an.

[@everythingandroidois]

​@@oussamabekk1108that's a lie, we have seen female police officers with their mahrams. Also who said non-Islamic education is a God given right? It is not obligatory according to any scholar in the past, so it can be restricted according to the benefit.

[@oussamabekk1108]

@everythingandroidois At the Time of those scholars you're talking abouT there was no such thing as "education" anyway ... And When the first University in the World was created by Fatima al fahri (Muz*lim women in Morroc*o) scholars had 0 probleme with Womens getting education and higher education aslong as Shari*aa is implemented + there is no valide reason to Stop Womens from being educated . OHh and "Police womens with there mahram" is the funniest thing I heard this week 🤣🙏🙏 Thank you for making me laugh .

[@hassanmirza2392]

Shame on those who defend the primitive Taliban. Such people have no right to criticise Western hypocrisy.

[@IronMan-nu3rb]

Bro...do you know America is giving money to Taliban. Yep...$40 million/week. Yes per week.

[@Umar-qy3bd]

the propaganda has seeped into you

[@sba9450]

Propaganda war on Taliban

[@hassanmirza2392]

@@Umar-qy3bd Go and live in primitive Afghanistan then, horrible Islamists!

[@thehourglassfan3515]

@@Umar-qy3bdWhat are you talking about?

[@paulamachado2149]

Why didn't you go and live in Afghanistan, with your family, to help with the development of your country?