‘World of pain’: Environment Minister ‘tying herself in knots of secrecy’

Sky News host Danica De Giorgio says Environment Minister Tanya Plibersek is in a “world of pain”.
“She is tying herself in knots of secrecy over her decision to veto a gold mine project in regional New South Wales on Aboriginal cultural grounds,” she said.
“She maintains she can’t divulge why she came to this decision because it’s not traditional, it’s sacred - spare me the hypocrisy.”

[@kenoriel9685]

Shes a liar. A traitor and should be charged

[@nigelmorgan3449]

She a ex druggie

[@finwefingolfin7113]

or has a serious psychiatric disorder and has forgotten to take her meds

[@user-dv3rb6nl4c]

Bit harsh but I agree.

[@whiskywood182]

Totally agree. She should be charged with Treason!!.. She hates Australia and Australians

[@alibarber57]

@kenoriel9685 along with rest of them...don't forget Katie Gallagher and Wong lying to parliament...but I think that's a pre-requisite these days

[@williamhumphrey9766]

If she's an aboriginal then so am I. What crock.

[@The_Resistance_1961]

Well you almost certainly are, William. Didn't someone you know walk past an Aborigine once? That makes you three quarters Aboriginal. I'm 9 tenths myself because when my grandfather walked past an Aboriginal he said 'hello.'

[@robharris6874]

This is Albosleazys transparent government!

[@johncrow5552]

50% are female. You suprised they are not transparent?

[@jackbarnes6929]

Move over Bowen, you have competition for most incompetent minister!

[@stephensmith8300]

No that’s a bit harsh, Bowen is a giant village idiot

[@seairpierre6838]

Appalling. The most divisive government EVER, and hell bent on doing irreparable damage to reconciliation in the long term.

[@user-gu5kl4on2w]

What a farking joke Australia has become pandering to these farcical elders representing the 'native title process'! 🤬🚫🇦🇺

[@eb2505]

UN agenda to take control of our land.

[@NameChangedDueToProfanity]

Some elders literally understand the economy and are just like "yeah dig all the way to hell". Love those elders.

[@cqpacool]

Labor Party sucking up to the greens they know exactly what they are doing and have no accountability to the Australian People .

[@markpatterson2811]

Nothing to do with it , have a look what the un and EU can do if aboriginal is in any way in our constitution

[@PaulSmith-ss6zm]

💯%

[@justinfair5216]

Aunt probably walked past a few aboriginals in her day, but that's as close as I'd wager she has aboriginal blood.

[@user-dd9tc4zz8j]

It’s also turning race against race. Then again, that is Labor’s aim.

[@aeroearth]

Correct . Divide and conquer.

[@YvonneCrean]

💯👍

[@spirit210364]

Now importing terrorists, coming to a town near you

[@The_Resistance_1961]

I'm a sub-human so I'm relatively immune to human hatreds. It's only when I identify as a human that I get upset enough to roll another blunt, pour another Bourbon and Coke, call for a hoo... er, for some pizza, and have a quiet night at home.

[@gerards7075]

Labor are a joke...they have to go.

[@cqpacool]

sooner rather than later ! total embarrassment and unfit to govern even a kindergarden let alone Australia led incapably by Liar in the Lodge one term wonder blunder and his band of merry blunderers absolutley woeful since they took office one disaster after another

[@grancitodos7318]

But the brainless people will keep voting for them, and suffer the consequents, and don't understand what happened.

[@auzzieworker5183]

This is how you run a country. Into the ground.

[@davidscott5209]

The lack of honesty and transparency is a feature of this Labour government.

[@richardhewitt1648]

What a load of bollocks Tanya, you've been scammed. Just face it.

[@eb2505]

Not at all. Pilbersek is in on it. Nothing happens in politics by chance. It is a UN agenda. The aboriginal piwer brokers make the money by selling out Australia , including their own people.

[@ShaneLong-nk5cy]

Tanya should give Roy a call

[@ozzyace71]

There’s a scam definitely going on Richard, but it’s by the government! Trust none of them. The worry is they’re openly brazen about it!

[@ozzyace71]

@@richardhewitt1648 wow I’ve seen before when people claim to have their comments removed … it’s happened to me finally! Thank god we have the YT Police 👮

[@wyattfamily8997]

@@ozzyace71 It happens to me regularly so you are in good company, they hate the truth.

[@Prognosis__]

Aunty Nyree isn’t even aboriginal

[@sallycent6598]

I know probably this story is made up by the Labor. The Labor can’t be trusted.

[@troywallace322]

Failed porn stars

[@robertlarge8185]

What a shocker!

[@mikldude9376]

Ahhh yeah , but it's not about the DNA ....... It's about the spirits !!!! Jim beam, Jonny Walker , VB , Shiraz ..... It's all about the spirits mate , you get enough spirits into ya.... You can be an elder too 😊.

[@zaccat693]

Nyree is definitely a full blown weirdo with mental issues

[@petermarsh4993]

If an Anglo-Australian was hearing “voices” they would be diagnosed as having Schizophrenia and be sectioned, held in a Psychiatric Institution where they would commence Anti-Psychotic drugs and held there until their “voices” came under control. For this Indigenous Australian with the same hearing “voices” she gained notoriety and held an audience with our Environment Minister where her wishes were applied to wipe out a decision that was years in the making by sane individuals. Heaven help us when our Politicians can no longer tell the sane from the crazies.

[@TomSteindl]

@@petermarsh4993 all Liebor politicians are insane and crazy, and transparent as one inch marble

[@DOWNUNDER.]

I can hear the spirits saying "plebersek GTF OUTTA HERE, YOUR DONE"

[@mikldude9376]

Lol , if only that was so😂

[@louise7347]

Well said!

[@olddog-fv2ox]

Shes one dumb Dingo

[@johngurney1069]

So many people will agree with you, she needs to go

[@ShaneLong-nk5cy]

Funny, naughty

[@lesleecarter5615]

She will be face to face with the ancestors soon

[@conradprytz5415]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🎉🎉

[@zdenekrobes5666]

Not in Heven! My try for a spot in the hell?

[@craigwhite3724]

Are you surprised? Tin foil hats in Canberra's sacred halls soon

[@jameswestover8403]

We can only hope, the difference between "TRUTH" and a conspiracy is about 1 week..... Oh, and we can remove our tfh but you can't remove spiked proteins from your body......

[@deniseorourke7235]

😂😂😂

[@garrysecuramot]

It should be a law requiring ministers and bureaucrats to give answers.DownUnder you're 100 percent correct. I'd say this government is the least transparent in our history, apart from Andrews Victoria.

[@YvonneCrean]

Between those two the country is destroyed

[@AndrewCarthy]

I just can’t believe this, just when you thought it couldn’t get any absurd they pull this out of their never regions.

[@gregory-gm2te]

She is British with dementia

[@ShaneLong-nk5cy]

Funny, naughty

[@beauzo9965]

5150

[@user-zd8eh1zx8q]

Yeah, like Bruce Pascoe!

[@kathrynperry992]

These people are portraying themselves as Aboriginal, because they are actually non- entities.. They I need to ne censored, they're a joke....

[@rachaelcourtnell7275]

She's white!!!!

[@lesleecarter5615]

She’s a trans elder

[@omygodtwo]

@@lesleecarter5615 😂

[@user-yr4mo3iz4d]

ROy is white lol. all grifters.

[@steveelliott5156]

She's English!

[@Roger-gd8bc]

Perhaps she identifies as aboriginal.....

[@credenza1]

If Ngaire heard voices saying we should close the Sydney Harbour Bridge, would Plibersik obey? This is insane.

[@user-ub8rh5tn2e]

yes, have to , can't say, its sacred

[@EricShingles-p6q]

Time for DNA tests or our real Aboriginal Brothers and Sister will MISS out

[@1JohnnyUTAH]

Tanya would have been a Star in the TV series Prisoner.

[@andrewb2326]

Yep and that Aunty is a dead ringer for Lizzie

[@ozzyace71]

@@andrewb2326hey Lizzie was much brighter than that dame ! Great show that was

[@1JohnnyUTAH]

@@andrewb2326 😆 there a few contenders for The Freak.

[@morrisgland887]

Well … given hubbys drug past … !!

[@TomSteindl]

@@1JohnnyUTAH or the movie PYSCHO.

[@Scott-ix2cy]

This is just embarrassing on so many levels

[@ShaneLong-nk5cy]

Funny

[@origprankster]

Aunty is as first nation as I am.

[@robertlarge8185]

As First Nation as Bruce Pascoe

[@ma3stro681]

I think that crazy old woemyn needs to get back on her meds … 😵

[@toptaz15]

There was,, and never has been a "First Nation" as such. there were hundreds of different waring tribes ALL over the continent that spent most of their time killing each other,,, Hardly a "NATION" eh???

[@user-ik3bx8yf6t]

First Nations people are located in the northern hemisphere. Australia has aboriginals. 👍

[@user-yw1rp4rj4u]

Their masters must be exposed!

[@pietro4772]

I am certain the wef and the $oros clan are masterminding the traitorous clowns in government.

[@KFBbythesea]

Absolutely. These puppets are programmed, compromised, controlled thru scopolimine. The real controllers are evil.

[@uyc65cf]

Totally ridiculous

[@ma3stro681]

She’s never worked a day in a real job in her life. We must outlaw career politicians. 2 terms max, and no employment post politics for 5 years with any conflict of interest industry …

[@PaulSmith-ss6zm]

Yes

[@peterolsen9131]

so the voices in a local cat lady's head told her to stop the mine , yeah, got it , this is the level of intelligence in the albo government

[@kiqueenbees]

Well being a woman means she can abandon reason and accountablity. What has this country come to?

[@locojazzhands]

She identifies as an aboriginal elder- so she is, whether you like it or not! 🤣 How insane has this world become? It just keeps getting crazier by the minute

[@johngurney1069]

but who said she identifies as a aboriginal where is the prove,

[@locojazzhands]

@@johngurney1069 did you watch the video?

[@johngurney1069]

@@locojazzhands yes but some people will say anything

[@PaulSmith-ss6zm]

Pleppersik is full blood of the albo-riginie canbrah tribe

[@locojazzhands]

Haha @johngurney1069 @PaulSmith-ss6zm I love it 🤣

[@debcarr]

I despise politicians

[@kellyco4139]

Just another sly dodgy politician

[@boganbattalion7088]

I find it hilarious that people say Aboriginals are held back and don't have equality but in my 40yrs on this planet and as someone who grew up with Aboriginal people and surrounded myself with them my entire life I have witnessed not just a couple but several people that lie claiming to be aboriginal to reap the benefits because since I have been alive born in 84 they have always received better benefits and priority to housing plus the fact that no matter how your treating your children they will never take them from you? So who exactly is discriminated against? Remember us that are born here had no choice, we are not responsible for what happened in the past and my parents are immigrants so I don't care if you send them back but anyone born here has just as much right to this country as the aboriginal people, to say that we don't deserve rights in the only country we know and have right to be in is disgusting

[@PaulSmith-ss6zm]

100%

[@cristinahague1433]

This agenda is albos centrepiece .. he picked ut because he thought it would be an easy one... how wrong he was ..... not only did he fail in the political point scoring, he revealed just how inept and lazy he was. His judgement is non existent. His authenticity as a leader is non existent. His duty of care towards the population and social cohesion is non existent. He plays identity politics, has no idea how to run a cabinet, has no backbone and now this whole cabinet has to rely on theatrics and mind-numbingly ridiculous tactics to justify their political... NOT ECONOMICAL decisions... We don't have a parliament under albo we have a circus.

[@buddyhell7100]

Theyve done the same with our mountains. We can no longer climb them

[@evelynmcmenamin4330]

Plibersek MUST RESIGN SHE HAS MADE A MOCKERY OF PARLIAMENT

[@birgittabirgersdatter8082]

A decision that has such huge ramifications for Australian absolutely *must* be made public. Secrecy in such a case hides dishonesty, greed and corruption. Let these “secret” cultural things be known and judged on its merits or they can be just kept secret and have no impact on the wider community.

[@ozzyace71]

According to “them” they owe us nothing! We only pay their salaries so why should they be honest with us???

[@THX1138OG]

Aunty Nyree does a good Nancy Pelosi impression😂

[@Gusto0172]

😂

[@JimBob-vb8oz]

Got the DTs going

[@alwaysright3718]

yup she looked drunk...

[@hanssieburn]

Is she drunk?

[@ma3stro681]

@@alwaysright3718Hangs out with Auntie Linda … 🍾🥂🍹🍷

[@rickjohnson2165]

Does anyone remember secret women’s business when a group of aboriginal women made up stories to stop a bridge being built at Hindmarsh Island? Ask Chris Kenny about it.

[@davidlawrence8803]

She is another evil politician

[@raeleneparker4965]

Bruce Pascoe's sister - White Emu

[@lornatodd4750]

😅

[@Roger-gd8bc]

She needs help, genuine. We need to get on with rebuilding our economy, genuine.

[@UnintendedConsequences]

“Environment Minister.” FFS. It’s not a legitimate role, it’s a Cult. She’s just a state-sponsored Cult Leader.

[@louise7347]

@@UnintendedConsequences yep

[@user-im9ju4hx8s]

She’s just following the communist manifesto f….up the economy.

[@KFBbythesea]

Yes, all lucerfarian brotherhood. Pure evil. Death n sex cult.

[@maxo1124]

Tanya Plibersek would be an ideal break dancer

[@obiwon1977]

And a shit 1 at that too

[@connorduke4619]

Ancestors don't live on the physical plane though. Secondly this lady is not a registered medium that we should automatically believe. Thirdly, ancestors worth listening to would never wish lost job opportunities for their descendants.

[@chriscorrigan7420]

That old battle axe is no more Abbo than myself. Another plot by Labour to fabricate a false expense ploy. Someone will make a lot of money out of this.

[@richardbrendish5602]

Tanya is a Journeyman, that is the polite way of saying she doesn’t have a clue about anything . A tree would make more sense than Tanya . Wanted the Foreign Ministers position, but we all know why that was impossible. So they gave her second, third and fourth best to keep her employed . There , simples .

[@petergmred2005]

So if a christian says god says not to do this theyre told to shut up about spaghetti monster but when its aboriginal then we believe their spirits? Rainbow serpent wants your land!

[@1JohnnyUTAH]

Politician's faces really show their meanest features. .

[@michaelgehrmann5331]

No govt decisions should be secret.

[@user-rf5rj7ee2v]

It shows one the quality of Australian Labor politicians!

[@grahammooney7420]

enough of this madness, it's insane that one person complains and everyone else has to bend to their stupidity. That woman definitely has a roo loose in the top paddock.

[@user-dd9tc4zz8j]

Just follow the money.

[@pietro4772]

*the shekels...

[@KFBbythesea]

​@@pietro4772be careful. The jew is just a front set up by Rome. This is all lucerfarian brotherhood, the jesuits Rome. They use jew as a front so u think it's all them to create hatred towards them. Be very careful with throwing that one out there.

[@GlennClark-ke8hf]

Is there one Labor minister that is capable of doing their job? I can't believe we are paying for these useless individuals.

[@vaughancee1361]

God please bring back common sense for our country please

[@oddball3675]

In the shadows of Canberra's halls, A minister stands, but how she falls, Tanya Plibersek, caught in her game, Tying herself in knots of shame. With secrecy wrapped 'round her decree, A veto on gold, cloaked in mystery, She speaks of the sacred, the ancient, the old, But her words ring hollow, her tale half-told. On sacred grounds, she claims to stand, Yet the truth slips through her grasping hand, "Tradition," she says, "demands my silence," But all we see is cunning and violence. Danica sees through the veil so thin, A world of pain Tanya's trapped within, For in her heart, the gold does gleam, But her conscience drowned in a whispered scheme. Hypocrisy's mask, she wears it well, But in the light, the cracks do swell, The people watch, they wait, they see, Tanya’s not the hero she claims to be. So, let the truth be known and told, Not all that glitters is purest gold, For in the end, the people will rise, To see through the lies, the false disguise. OddBall

[@user-dv9ur7su2v]

My Aunty heard a voice saying parliament house is resting on her ancestors grave. She wants it removed to allow the spirits to be free to ascend to heaven.

[@yodaandthebike5839]

What a ridiculous farce.

[@greggroovy001]

Now I've heard everything!

[@Prognosis__]

Aunty Nyree is from Cornwall, UK

[@mikldude9376]

There you go , I was wunderin why her didgery had a union jack carved in to it😊.

[@richardsuter2816]

Sure as hell looks like & with Biden disease ! What a Joke !

[@pietro4772]

'Nyree' must be the progressive way of spelling Narelle or Noreen.

[@Prognosis__]

@@pietro4772 😂

[@polw3785]

Plibersek the activist. What a disgrace

[@mate8718]

Can Tanya please provide proof of this womans supernatural psychic abilities??? What a joke.

[@alexandermenzies9954]

So Aunty Nyree is hearing voices. You can just see A.Nyree is on the wave length and Aunty Tanya knows how to tune in to the same voices. Uncanny. Why bother with parliament when all we need is this double act of Australia's finest. Welcome to country.

[@eb2505]

She won’t tell you it is a UN agenda to defraud not only white Australians, but Aboriginals too - the UN wants all our land. Yet, Albo said we are a sovereign country.

[@sallycent6598]

She has to tell the truth the Labor can’t keep deceiving the Australian people.

[@homchahom4159]

@@sallycent6598yes they can and people will believe it

[@eb2505]

@@sallycent6598 They can as long as they can get away with it. I don’t see the media or the LNP investigating. All they donis talk about it.

[@mikldude9376]

​@@sallycent6598 Aw yeah but they can , and they will given the chance ! It's like the Gaza refugees, Labor was keeping it quiet until a journo stumbled across it and let the cat out of the bag . Really amusing watching Albanese in question time being asked a straight question about Gaza , he instantly started waffling on about Ukraine wasting as much time as possible until the time limit was up. He's a lying POS and should be sacked .

[@sallycent6598]

@@eb2505 Forget about the mainstream media is useless.

[@PaulJames-g1w]

Something fishy here

[@kaosthecosmicreviewer1055]

Why is the crypt keeper wearing a wig???

[@garydavo07]

The “Aunty “ woman demonstrates more intelligence than all in albo’s cabinet. Let that sink in!

[@credenza1]

Who needs the Voice when we have Ngaire? She could be installed in a curtained booth in the Parliamentary forecourt and consulted as a latter day Delphic Oracle incanting instructions from various ancestors, with whom she appears to be on familiar terms. They could roll the booth into Senate hearings and consult about all sorts of matters; foreign policy, industrial relations, defence.

[@GregMoylan-pn6sr]

Surely this whole thing is an out-of-season April Fools joke.

[@kathysmith1843]

Help us indeed

[@gordonwells1626]

What rubbish from Plibasek…anti TO’s, anti industry, anti employment, anti economic development and un-Australian.

[@beachbum433]

Shades of Hindmarsh Island Bridge "Secret Women's' Business" in South Oz...

[@magichead79]

She’s happy to drive on the roads past the mine.

[@seriousmonkey5654]

No one's Aunty or Uncle or elders. Total bullshit.

[@lesleyosborne9319]

That woman Looks WHITWR Than me.

[@Wedgetail96]

Once again, Labor exploiting all tools available to it in order to destroy rural and regional Australia 🇦🇺.

[@user-mt5ff6qd8x]

Tanya indulging in her husbands products.

[@evelyn2178]

So one person can make this decision yet 99 of the Aboriginal Council wants it to go ahead. This should be over turned and Tanya sacked. She is hearing voices in her head, needs to see a therapist. Sick of the minority getting their wish but the rest get nothing. This would create thousands of jobs, the community would flourish and houses will be built, shops and infrastructure would be beneficial. Tanya should be charged for all the money spent by the company out of her own pocket.

[@DJ99777]

Does something seem a bit off about Auntie Nyrie?

[@carllyons4903]

Aunty Nyree needs help, poor thing, mental health is a big issue in Oz 🤔

[@RobertCaines-mx3sh]

What a load of crap and these people are running the country 🤣🤣

[@WorldGoneKrazy]

Another E. Jean Carol 😂

[@tenareef]

I wonder what happens to the gold price if a large deposit is found.....hmmm🤔

[@lukeclifton4392]

And this is why Australians loose faith in the aboriginal culture and government systems. …but the Indigenous won’t call her out either!! Then they’d have to do the same for all the others… and that would deeply influence government funding and statistics!?!?

[@Brazill253]

Awful woman

[@ozzyace71]

Seems that way, but she’s just a stooge in Labour’s silly games! They probably paid her with a flaggin or two

[@Squeezmo]

DNA Test!

[@cudoit1]

What a joke! Ideological madness. Labor trying to be mates with everybody and satisfying nobody. Keep going Tanya. You and Mr Bowen are the best advert for why the next election is so important for Australia.

[@andrewrichardson1237]

Well go dig the gold up ,sounds like Australia land is for all Australians, wake up

[@russellgraham5120]

Yes serious questions to answer, ha ha ha good luck! I am a white Aboriginal and I say the mine should go ahead, the needs of the many outway the needs of the few .🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺

[@robertcatterson8835]

Another Labor master class 😂 and shaker from the gimme gimme tribe could hear ancestors saying ( i feel a thirst coming on ) and it’s the white fellas shout.💯

[@tonyscrimshaw869]

Labor are showing everyday how incompetent they are and it’s time they were removed from office

[@richardsoane6192]

And people voted for this garbage

[@alwaysright3718]

90% of Australians voted for it...

[@rob6543]

Well you can count me out of that , who is really running this bloody country

[@davidvanderklauw]

Public recorded voting would allow us to name and shame those responsible. p.s. I put Labor 2nd-last.

[@gregoryray9920]

Replace people with ignorant morons

[@ShaneLong-nk5cy]

It's bloody freezing in Blayney in the winter so go on Tanya let them get the Gold. There that makes as much sense as the other nonsense.

[@user-yw4dj5cj1i]

Someone didn’t get what they were due .

[@Iwishiwasflying]

Freedom of information on Tanya decision making and senate demanding open showing of her inept decision

[@johncavar2914]

Labor have many crooks 😮🎉

[@destinyridge]

This is why the voice would never work.

[@davidball5002]

Plibersek wants to lock us out of the bush and the ocean. She can get stuffed!

[@KFBbythesea]

Pliblier works for her lucerfarian brotherhood masters - jesuit Rome for NWO. All evil, members of sex & death cult.

[@KT-bb1tb]

If Anyone Hadn't Noticed Pliberchook was Always Useless (Robodebt).......Nothing Has Changed !

[@KFBbythesea]

She is evil. Working to destroy Australian people.

[@cristinahague1433]

Labor people don't like to be told tgat her and shorten introduced the legislation and it was below par do they... scomo had to rely on the actual public servants to get feedback but they didn't... so they thought it was a goer..

[@gregwooldridge8864]

The spirits are telling me Labor is fucked.