Why Jack Frost Doesn’t Have His Memories | Rise of The Guardians: Discovering DreamWorks

SUBSCRIBE: tinyurl.com/hfq...
DONATE ON PATREON: / wotsovideos
Isaac looks into the backstory of Jack Frost to determine why he didn’t have his memories at the beginning of Rise of the Guardians.
VIDEOS SUGGESTED:
Why Is Jack Frost Such A Powerful Guardian (Nighlight): • Why Is Jack Frost Such...
Pitch Black’s Backstory: Becoming the Nightmare King: • Pitch Black’s Backstor...
MOVIE LINK:
Rise of the Guardians: amzn.to/2Le93ul
STORYBOOK & NOVEL LINKS:
Jack Frost: The End Becomes The Beginning: amzn.to/2RtQ4Bx
The Guardians Collection: amzn.to/2Lc5THy
The Man in the Moon: amzn.to/2QNzkov
The Sandman: The Story of Sanderson Mansnoozie: amzn.to/2LcFDNo
RESOURCES:
riseoftheguard...
riseoftheguard...
riseoftheguard...
riseoftheguard...
When Jack Frost awakens and rises out of the icy lake he was dormant within he knew very little about who he was. The Man in the Moon told him his name and he quickly discovered his magical ice abilities, but who he fundamentally was could not be understood. For hundreds of years, he couldn’t recall his purpose and didn’t even realize he had a life before being Jack Frost. For some reason the memories of his prior life, which established who he was, were lost even though all of the other Guardians minds remained in tact through their transformation. What was so different about Jack’s life or evolution that made him forget?
I post every Tuesday and Thursday, so check back then for more Disney, Pixar, Harry Potter, Star Wars and movie videos! If you have any questions about the Disney universe that you would want answered in a video, please ask away in the comment section!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
THANKS TO MY PATRONS WHO SPONSORED THIS VIDEO!
Ann Richardson, Austin Burress, Eva Bailey, Julia Kendall, Karina Santiago, Lea Bose, Rachael McIntosh, Redbandit, Stephanus Surjaputra, Victoria Hanger & Zachary Levine
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FOLLOW ME!
MERCH STORE ➜ wotsostore.com
PATREON ➜ / wotsovideos
TWITTER ➜ / mrisaaccarlson
FACEBOOK ➜ / mrisaaccarlson
INSTAGRAM ➜ / mrisaaccarlson
GOOGLE PLUS➜ plus.google.co...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I do not own the rights to Disney or any of the branding associated to the franchise. Discovering Disney is meant for educational purposes which does not take away from the original works, but instead helps build understanding on the cinematic universe. Some links on this page are affiliate links.
#DreamWorks #RiseoftheGuardians #Wotso #WotsoVideos #Theory #JackFrost

[@IsaacCarlson]

Guys... I'm going to Disney World next week! Make to sure to follow along on my journey on my Instagram @WotsoVideos ! Also, if you happen to be in the parks and see me feel free to come and say hi! I'd love to meet you fun people. Have a magical day!

[@animehq9767]

But why did the other guardians forget about jack Frost

[@dashoflynxrunningwiththefl4703]

Could you do a vid of the origin of the sandman and how he was able to live after is "death"

[@simonacannizzo1074]

Hope you have fun and that we meet some day! I'll be in FL next month.

[@UriaKongOfficial]

Congrats!

[@2000VictoriaVlogs]

I hope you have fun on your trip! Toy Story Land is super cool looking, and you can see some of what they are building of galaxy's edge (the star wars area). Also there's a cool museum, of sorts, in Hollywood Studios about Disney animation and the creation of the parks.

[@yamisart]

I've always found it weird how cool Jack was with the fact that he had drowned, never got to see his little sister again and that she died hundreds of years ago.

[@Munchkin.Of.Pern09]

...I always thought that it was because he had hypothermia, and thus amnesia Also, I think that the movie is probably a separate continuity

[@danielelijahtolentino7029]

Nope

[@russiau.s.a363]

same XD

[@iceluvndiva21]

Honestly that's a bit easier to understand and thus retain that every person has the potential to be a guardian but it has to be nurtured and maintained.

[@Terzo6666]

Plus he died

[@reggielacey2235]

@@russiau.s.a363 they are different

[@faith4disney]

The Dreamworks movie is completely different than the books! They are not to be combined. They are two different universes! The author, William Joyce, has said this multiple times. That's why everyone is getting confused.

[@icelily270]

Everything makes so much more sense now. Trying to put the two together was just hurting my head.

[@harmonetheanimationaddict4419]

Even if it's not film canon, it still is a good story.

[@faith4disney]

@@harmonetheanimationaddict4419 Definitely! I think the books are way better than the movie!

[@harmonetheanimationaddict4419]

@@faith4disney I didn't mean it like that. I still think the movie background is good too.

[@flowerbloom5782]

Thxs for pointing that out cause there were some parts that I was confused about like the serpent and the lake. The movie didn't show any serpent. So let me see if I understood this, in the movie , Jack Frost was once human and then became a guardian meanwhile in the book he was actually a nightlight then became Jack Frost.

[@atzirisaucedo]

I think we need more on Jack's memories. For example, he got his memories back from when he was human, but if he just showed up out of no where and the family welcomed him, where did the teeth even come from? And why do we only see the sister in the movie?

[@GleamDragon21]

Because the movie and books aren't in the same canon

[@maverickdarkrath4780]

Perhaps man on moon did some alterations I'm the background to insure Jack's new life seemed legit, fake theeth and all and erasing memories

[@jonalex9002]

And how to explain the 300 year later?

[@ellafrost999]

Through all of this, how did the Guardians or Katherine not recognize Nightlight’s slow transformation into Jack Frost??? The guardians don’t seem to recognize Jack as anything aside from a mischievous winter spirit. Tooth even mentioned having Jack’s human teeth.

[@onevoice2993]

Yeah, the origins and explanations from the books obviously don't fit with the movie.

[@JustASunflowerSeeD]

The books and the film are 2 separated worlds. The film has a lot of different things in it.

[@elisabethdavid3926]

I thought about this as well. If he was nightlight he could not have been a little boy who lost his baby teeth.

[@sagegabriella2093]

cause Nightlight looked completely different to Jack Frost

[@sagegabriella2093]

also all of jacks memories are from his teen or young adult years not childhood. and his memories may have been altered by the Man in the Moon so that he could become more of his own person instead of Nightlight

[@yukamahachy23]

This could just be me but I kind of feel like Jack Frost and Jamie could be relatives. I know he has been like this for over 300 years, but they have such a strong connection and Jamie looks like Jacks' sister.

[@Paichan13]

I personally prefer the movie version of events when it comes to Jack. There's something so simple and yet so powerful about a brother saving his sister and dying in the attempt. It's a huge impact and something that I could easily see happening in real-world events. Having this whole complex thing with him remembering who/what he was and having his powers to me just...blows it all out of proportion? Why couldn't he have completely forgotten everything already? Lost his powers, truly become human? I love the books, but I think this was done poorly, and Joyce (yes I know the universes are different) could have kept this defining moment the same.

[@phantomprism7659]

Agree completely! The idea of night light is better for a separate character. Maybe Jack could in a way be connected to Night Light but not the same person. I much prefer the idea that Jack was just a regular human who became a winter spirit snd gaurdian through his sacrifice. So much more meaningful

[@miner0326]

I never knew Jack Frost had a life _BEFORE_ his life before he was a guardian.

[@queendsheena1]

Damn this revelation was dark. Jack Frost sacrificed everything for those he loved.

[@dabatchofchoco.chipcookies1601]

I'm waiting for a sequel

[@penny1545]

Well if they are going to make a sequel prepare to see the Guardians being accompanied by the Minions. Because now Illumination Animation oversees now Dreamworks!

[@lifeisalie5236]

Penny Oof that’s gonna be a really bad crossover

[@flowerbloom5782]

Same. I hope it explains why he lost his memories and who the man in the moon is. While this video gives me an idea, I don't think it's a valid explanation since the book and the movie are seperate stories so the reason for why Jack forgot his memories is different too.

[@fantasticnerd7978]

We really need it

[@LetsWIN.]

I am still waiting after this years

[@kiratheusagiisworkshop5266]

His story is kind of sad! He lived to protect, no matter the cost. He tried to live but eventually his enemies kept catching up to him so he had to erase himself to protect those he cared about. I do hope he get's to remember who he trult is in the movies!

[@thevictorianghost8222]

I had a really weird question pop into my brain recently, but wondered if you might be interested? Did the King and Queen give Rapunzel a name before she was captured by Gothel? (Maybe the TV show answered that question, I don't know, I don't watch it, but if so, please tell me!)

[@SzaraWilk]

Rapunzel wasn't a Newborn when she was captured.

[@R_candy]

Koszmarek he asks if her real parents named her already before she got kidnapped

[@SzaraWilk]

@@R_candy i know but i think this could be clue.

[@thevictorianghost8222]

@@SzaraWilk Exactly! Besides, it wouldn't make any sense for Gothel to keep Princess Rapunzel's name... Rapunzel! Too easily identifiable.

[@chelseashamim9148]

Why would she tell repunzel her true birthday?

[@segevstormlord3713]

It strikes me as amazingly tragic that Jack gave up EVERYTHING to be human...and had that taken away before he, let alone his adopted siblings, could grow up much at all. How little time he would have had for his reward even if he'd had a full life, compared to his immortal existence before. And even that was cut short, taken away. His poor family, too, to lose him so soon after adopting him. To have just enough time to come to love him, only to lose him. His selfless sacrifice wasn't so selfless as he thought; did he really not realize the pain he'd cause them? Losing his siblings would have devastated them; losing him surely did, too. It's little wonder he still had so much to learn in wisdom, even leaving aside lack of knowledge, even after re-awakening.

[@friendlytiger6023]

Yeah, that's not scientific enough for me. This is my theory. In the film, when Jack fell through the ice and died, his neurons froze, causing his memories to freeze with his brain. When the man in the moon brought him back to life, his brain thawed but his memories stayed frozen. *I hope this made sense to you* Plz reply to me. No one ever does 😭

[@jaytoplay0]

I love that theory

[@lexalina132]

I think you're on the right track, but not quite there: when someone drowns, their brain is deprived of oxygen, which can then cause damage to the brain. I think Jack suffers brain damage due to drowning as a human boy, which effected his memory. Much less magical than frozen memories but the most likely cause in my opinion :(

[@Lame2882]

This wasn't really a theory video, the events he described actually happened in the book the movie was based on.

[@plaguedoctor981yt8]

That’s what I always believed

[@DrowsyKodi]

Just cause you use the word neurons doesn’t make it scientific

[@silverstarlightproductions1292]

This is incredible! Dreamworks needs to do a sequel with Jack Frost remembering his past before he was taken by his human family! I'm ESPECIALLY intrigued by the Katharine story! That definitely needs to be explored! Thank you so much, Isaac, for answering this question that has been on my mind for so long!

[@koffee8743]

Lauren Brown kzbin.info/www/bejne/pKqUYZdvl7aqnJo My friend made a fan made sequel trailer you can go check it out

[@ChibiCherub]

dreamworks kinda messed up continuity with this movie like its just too different too connect them

[@kristatipton91]

Can you do a video on Jack Frost parents when he was a human boy? We don't know much about them.

[@jasondelcid3287]

When I first watched this movie I remember that there was something missing. That there was something more to the movie than I thought, and, I'm glad that I was right. I'm so glad I found this channel.

[@codywolfwestern2476]

Why isn't there a movie based on the books and not the one Dreamworks showed us???

[@silversamurai0267]

The DreamWorks movie is a possible future of a book series that wasn't anywhere near over when the movie was made. And the author only decided to make Jack Frost a thing in his books after he saw the popularity of the character in the movie. In other words, as amazing as the books are, the DreamWorks movie wasn't TRYING to be the books. It's just a potential future to a story that is still being molded and changing, depending on the author's whims. Similar to Game of Thrones. Dont look down on what we have, just because you feel it could have been better. For when it was made and what it is, its phenomenal.

[@codywolfwestern2476]

@@silversamurai0267 I'm not looking down on it I love ROTG just the way it is I just wish to see a movie based on the books.

[@trappersshadow9751]

Idk

[@katluvver123]

DreamWorks is also unsure if they want to pursue more movies. ROTG is seen as a cursed movie because it was the first in a series of movies produced that year that flopped. Although the DVD sold more than any of those other movies they are reluctant to pursue more movies. They intended to eventually get into the books through more movies but because the box office flopped and other movies followed this possibility make take a bit. William Joyce, the writer of the books and for those who remember the show, Rolli-Polli-Olli, has been in a constant negotiation last I heard but I'm not up to date. The cult following is larger than it was and to be honest the movies that flopped, ROTG included, deserved better advertising. I only knew about it because I didn't skip over the KZbin ad at the time. Jack Frost didn't become a character until William Joyce realized the popularity and potential as well as how people compared him to Nightlight. People wanted a book so it could be canon and he obliged and it was released a few months ago. He is pursuing, at the minimum, a TV show because of the cult following. This is all I know thus far but, I'm sure there is more info by now.

[@rayzersun6705]

Because there are a ton of books that have their own idea of the Guardians plus Jack Frost/Nightlight. For example: The one i heard was that Nightlight was MIM's (Man In the Moon) caretaker and when MIM's parents perished by the hands of Pitch, Nightlight drew a diamond sword to Pitch's heart and both of them were sent to the darkest caves of the earth. Idk abt wat happened to Pitch Black but, when MIM finally became an adult, he finally found Nightlight (now Jack Frost) trapped in a frozen lake and brought him back to life. Although he was alive, he did not remember his past life. There are also many different legends, myths, etc. depicting Jack Frost as an immortal, never aging, boy, with snow/ice powers.

[@troperhghar9898]

My question is how did Jack change clothes as a ghost

[@randomhuman2245]

✨Movie Magic✨

[@nkbujvytcygvujno6006]

I think he has control of his form to some degree. At least his clothes, anyway.

[@FaisalAli-og1pq]

0

[@FaisalAli-og1pq]

Mov

[@kylarobinson6898]

He probably took some from someone or just made some Idk

[@NicolePaler]

more about jack frost and the guardians pleaseeeeeee

[@ravenclawfairy3648]

I love your Jack Frost videos! 💙💙

[@dragonbrony3987]

I need to find this book!! I don't care that I pretty much know the story now, I must find it! Awesome video, dude! And have fun at Disney World! I haven't been there since I was around 10 or so, so I don't know how much change there has been to the parks, but I remember it being super fun!

[@faith4disney]

It's on amazon, be sure to read the others before!

[@arielnatalene3006]

The thought of Tooth collecting Jack's teeth since he's a child and have a crush on him a decades later still creeps me out

[@iB0NKERS]

I think I’m gonna watch this movie again. 💙 I love it so much and I love Jack. I especially like how they made it so that even in a time of crisis, he kept calm and presented a playful persona in order to keep his sister calm and save her.

[@michaelbrent1536]

DreamWorks is reeling got to make a series of rise of the guardians because how Train Your Dragon Is wildly popular. And as soon as frozen rolls around in November you know people are gonna forget about Movie when it hit theaters!!!!

[@rebeccabasta3629]

Why do I feel that Jack frost would be such a slytherin? Just me? Ok sorry. Great video! I had this question after u posted Jack Frost story. Thank man!

[@digifreak90]

I'm not sure I'd put him as a Slytherin, as the main defining trait of Slytherins is ambition, which he doesn't show much of. Thinking about it, I personally would place him as a Gryffindor, and not just because he's a hero. When you get down to it, the very center of his being as a Guardian is Fun, literally laughing in the face of fear, which I consider to be almost synonymous with Bravery.

[@PHOENIX-wr9ob]

I wonder how many theories there are about Jack Frost and Elsa being related or dating, could you maybe make one Wotso.

[@aprilroche3390]

o.m.g i wood love to see that one Wotso , it is so Gorgeous and beautiful .

[@Maria-dm7qo]

Omg i would love to see that.

[@eleanormellor7905]

That needs to happen! I don't care if it's not canon, but I'm making a shipchild OC.

[@galaxyunknown2599]

That complicated

[@sawsamuelsanhnit6097]

Well I have a theory for that= No.1-Elsa is the Fifth Spirit And Jack Frost is Fifth Guardian. No.2-They both have Sisters and their name is Anna (Which they love the most). No.3-They both wanted there past memories. No.4-Their both enemy is Fear. No.5-They are both Ice Users. No.6-They Both have Four Letter names Like =J-A-C-K and E-L-S-A No.7-Jack should be call Spirit because You can't see him until you believe in him and Elsa Should be called Guardian because she take care of the elements in Enchanted Forest. No.?-They are Single.........But I won't count that. No.8-They are both legends such as Elsa is the Ice Queen and Jack Frost is.......... Jack Frost in their past In 18th and 19th centurys.When Other Ice Users Don't have Legends at this century.

[@sierralovat5498]

man you are so animated and lively. Keep doing what you love bro, stay awesome

[@slyviacooper]

Have a safe and fun trip. I enjoy all of your videos.

[@olgui023]

I’m loving the recent videos of ROTG! It’s such an underrated movie/book series. These make me really happy :)

[@ghostreyn]

Please do explore the rest of the guardians! I would love to watch those!

[@spadegirl12]

Was anyone else trying to name as many DvD's as they could? Another great video! You managed to tell another interesting backstory without unnecessary rehashing of information from your other video. Keep going because you are awesome!!!

[@ajwillustratorauthor]

That's the craziest back story ever! DreamWorks needs to make a prequel about Jack being nightlight and him having adventures with the man in the moon. Maybe that's why the Man in the Moon chose Jack because he was his old guardian.

[@georgethehernandez]

So much Jack Frost knowledge, so much revealed, oh my gawd!

[@ki-janamoore195]

Someone in the comments said that the creators stated that the books and movie are within separate universes. Going off of that, I always believed that (in the movie) because the rest of the Guardians were always magical creatures, they never lost their memories. But because Jack was previously a human before dying, his transformation caused him to lose his.

[@dominickcolamestaiii5507]

I'm not saying your wrong but this fells like a theory

[@misscelinateloexplica]

Wow! This story is beautiful!

[@emsy8408]

So interesting I hope to see more Jack Frost soon. I love your videos and would love more on Jack Frost, so far it is fascinating⭐️

[@Finn-fm5cx]

i can’t believe my question was seen and it’s great to finally have an answer ! can’t wait till i can get the books 😁😁

[@madnessarcade7447]

Issac new theory why does fairy godmother look young in descendants

[@faith4disney]

Bad casting.

[@marcylynn3703]

Because her daughter is a teenager in the movie and because fairies age slower than humans. She could be hundreds of years old (just guessing)

[@Max-hb6sp]

It’s a movie

[@miner0326]

Because, even if it's Disney, it isn't the same as the movies where the characters come from.

[@madnessarcade7447]

@@miner0326 wrong actually descendants is confirmed canon my dude

[@belovedandchampion]

So... Jack fell in love with Katherine... where have I heard that before? *newsies soundtrack starts playing*

[@faith4disney]

You just made my day. 😂😂

[@samuelvine]

Yes! Thank you! Please do more and more Rise of the Guardians videos!

[@user-nt6ts9pq5o]

I'm going to make up for all the people who didn't put a star so 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 there you go 154 stars

[@d.b1]

⭐️

[@_insertversehere_]

🌟

[@johngreen8344]

🌟🌟🌟🌟

[@emeraldhead3238]

Rontom bear ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

[@galaxyunknown2599]

I give 200 star

[@lauralshobbies2710]

I have never clicked on a video so quickly.

[@akwyld2545]

Ur such an insightful details videos.....please do more JF videos as ur predictions of a sequel is to be made 😁

[@BlueKoinu]

I really enjoyed this video! Thank you for the great upload and discussion!

[@nightfall1786]

⭐️ as much as I support Jack’s decision to find his dream family...I feel bad for Catherine.

[@galaxyunknown2599]

So he's adopted by overland family

[@ethenallen1388]

I greatly preferred the idea that the Guardians all began life as humans and were chosen and empowered by the Moon based on their actions and merits. Hearing that they were born as immensely powerful supernatural beings is somewhat disappointing.

[@laurazhang6437]

I love your videos so much u are amazing with all your theory's

[@rosebookfan7677]

I’m a fan of your videos so much! Could you do an intel on Jack Frost/Nightlight & Katherine/Mother Goose’s love Story? From the guardians of childhood??? After watching your vids on Rise of the guardians I was immediately hooked & looked up more about it & I was completely captivated by the relationship between Jack Frost/Nightlight & Katherine/Mother Goose🥰

[@cassyluvsanchez4005]

I have a question why doesn't Princess Anna doesn't have any powers? Oh and how did the Tooth Fairy get her powers?

[@kaiseremotion854]

1) iirc the prophecy mentioned only one would have the curse. 2) idk personally

[@annad.352]

Because Anna belongs to rule arendille..

[@jettash0720]

Back before Jack got his own book, I always had the theory that he didn't have his memories simply because he died and the other Guardians didn't.

[@Zufallige.Eidechse.auf.Felsen]

The books came before the movies

[@sweetpea2604]

Thanks to theses theories I really want to see the movie again ❤️💚💙

[@sewntolife]

A star emoji. (I don't have one)

[@shortbean0]

I wish I had as much dedication as you to research and find all this stuff.

[@faith4disney]

All you have to do read the books. He's literally stating what happens in the book.

[@shortbean0]

@@faith4disney Still too much. :(

[@shortbean0]

@@faith4disney Unfortunately, I don't have that time in my life right now.

[@507dannyfe]

Thankyou so much for this.🙂

[@doctordark5352]

Letting go means for me at least to come to the realization that some people are meant to be part of your history not your destiny

[@happyfellowship4291]

Isaac makes me smile every time I watch his videos :) Edit: wait, is that Figment on your shelf?? Represent!!

[@marquin7672]

This is amazing Isaac! Thank you for filling us with the story! Love DreamWorks!

[@anamiosonami]

I want to read William Joyce's books so much. They seem so interesting, I've always been in love with the characters ever since I watched the movie when I was younger and I want to know the full story of each of them. I can't though. My parents won't let me buy them (because well, they ARE children's books and there's so many of them) and I can't buy them myself

[@lunamoon4062]

You could try various librarys

[@anamiosonami]

Luna Moon Yeah, my anxiety will not allow me to go in one

[@lunamoon4062]

@@anamiosonami I know the feeling

[@bonedaddyshonestreviews6933]

@@anamiosonami Maybe you'll have no choice but to wait to purchase the books yourself until you get older and have a place of your own that your parents would have no say in what you own. I know it might be hard to wait, but you know the old saying, "patience is a virtue". I'm almost 36 myself, and sometimes I still have a hard time with patience. I dunno how old you are, but sometimes the only thing you can do in some situations, especially with things you want, you have no other choice but to wait. It sucks, but you gotta learn, that's just life, and just how it goes.

[@RavenStorm1031]

can i just say i love your videos man keep them up!!

[@SilverSkyCloud]

probably wont get seen but any theory ideas for the black cauldron? its a hugely underrated disney movie

[@sy01mamabear83]

Whoa! I didn't read that there was so much more to the story! Mind blown!

[@sydneyhobbs9817]

I get that the books and movie are different universes, but I’d still like a video for the movie. Cause some of this doesn’t translate over. And I love the movie. Even just some speculating on how the movie verse might be similar to the books off screen. Was Jack found by his family? Was he reborn? His baby teeth? His frost powers?

[@Quorented]

I'm guessing the powers they have is determined by how they died . Jackfrost drowned by frozen Lake . Sandman suffocated by sand. Bunny suffocated by earth: so potentially a miner Santa. Maybe died in a factory accident. Tooth fairy maybe attacked by wild animals so died by wolf fangs

[@raqmeneses]

I was always wondering this!

[@katemichael4002]

This was a great video!

[@pai009]

I'm not sure if its been said, but I really hope Jack gets all his memories back. I haven't read the last 2 books, but I really hoped, through the other books, that Kathrine and Nightlight would eventually get together. I think having him get all his memories back and finding Kathrine again would bring the story full circle, and let him know who and what he truly is now that he's not a human yet not a night light either. This with him keeping his fun-loving and courageous nature, because that's some of the reasons why Kathrine loved him.

[@armoredwings4182]

This seems so needlessly complicated

[@ZeldaWolf2000]

Here's a Jack Frost related question that I would like answered. If Pitch knew about Jack Frost before he showed up, why did he not attack him right away, before he knew the Guardians, to get rid of him? Like, if we're just going by the movie, and he only knew Frost as this mischievous kid, then fine, but going by what you're saying, Pitch knew of Jack, and of his true identity and powers, Long before the movie started, so how come Pitch doesn't do anything about it? If he knew about Jack's powers before the movie, he could've gotten rid of him right away before he teamed up with the guardians and became much more powerful. Jack didn't know how strong he really was, so he couldn't use his powers at full capacity, therefore, he would've been an easy target. Just saying, if Pitch had attacked Frost before the start of the movie, he would've won.

[@lingmaymarcano539]

ZeldaWolf2000 well Jack was not the same person he was when Pitch knew him. When Pitch knew him he was Nightlight not Jack Frost. He does not remember being Nightlight only Jack Frost and his appearance probably changed after all of those years being frozen under water and in the pictures shown of Nightlight he does not look like the Jack Frost we all know and love. What I’m trying to say is that Pitch and also the Guardians, do not recognize him.

[@yormpbirdhouse4407]

In the beginning of the movie, Jack’s eyebrows were lighter. Then in the scenes to come his eyebrows got darker. His real power is the power of eyebrows.

[@snaketooth0943]

I thought the moon took his memories away so he would focus on having fun like he was meant to rather than go out looking for his family.

[@tiffanypersaud3518]

Such a beautiful story. Jack’s trauma he suffered felt so real. (I think the movies are deviating a lot from the books though offering is a different story, which is not a bad thing either.)

[@whateverandwhenever5650]

I hope they make another movie where all this is revealed

[@peaceblossomvalentin667]

You're so cool. I wish there were more guys like you. 😊

[@chrys.k.mwarriorsofpiathos1501]

I absolutely love this I'd love more stories on Jack Frost. ⭐

[@castielwinchester6222]

I believe if rise of the guardians had a sequal.. It would have been the most beautiful and powerful story of all time.. ❤️

[@NerdyBlue]

I always love and find in very interesting as well from when I was a kid I hope when you get the time you can explore the other guardians Love your channel and really appreciate it Thank you

[@borahearttt5060]

How did PJ Mask get their powers? LOVE YOU AND YOUR VIDEOS💜💜

[@kayahigham8568]

Follow your dreams! Always follow your dreams! ⭐⭐⭐⭐

[@Maria-dm7qo]

Wow so that's how all happen 😢😭 it's just too Beautiful , hey wastso can you make a Theory about how Jack Frost and Elsa became so popular so Beautiful love Cupole as Jelsa I'm a huge Jelsa Fan.

[@sawsamuelsanhnit6097]

Well Me to My friend.

[@Zufallige.Eidechse.auf.Felsen]

I hate the ship. (My opinion) there is just to many problems with it.

[@sawsamuelsanhnit6097]

Well I have the theory About that Mister No.1-Elsa And Jack Frost are both Ice Users. No.2-Their both have sisters which is Anna and Emma(Which They love the most). No.3-Their both enemy is Fear. No.4-Their name have both 4 letters like=J-A-C-K and E-L-S-A. No.5-Their both Fifth which Elsa is Fifth Spirit and Jack Frost is Fifth Guardian. No.6 They Both wanted the Lost Memories. No.7 They are both Legends Which Elsa is the Ice Queen in the past and Jack Frost is Grandpa Jack or Frost in the past. No.?-Their Singles..............But I won't count that. No.8- Interestingly North who is the Santa Claus in the Rise of the Guardians, Before he became Guardian. I Read it from the book that Isaac read. He witness something very special. He Went to the Enchanted Forest and saw the Spirits Which is crazy. Because the Enchanted Forest and Spirits are only in Frozen 2 and Disney. But that was told in the Rise of the Guardian and DreamWorks. Now that's Crazy!No.9-Their the only Ice Users Who was freeze to dead and came back to life. What a Big Coincidences!!! Thank you for reading To be honest I have more theories about that.

[@Maria-dm7qo]

@@sawsamuelsanhnit6097 you are 1000% So True all the way !👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@sawsamuelsanhnit6097]

Your Welcome Mister If you want more I have more Theorys

[@marissahilsenrath4029]

If I fell in icy water that would happen to me memory loss until I remember

[@penny1545]

His origin story in the books reminds me a little bit of Ariel in the Little Mermaid. Which means from a simple contact with humans they were both to scrap their established lives and to start a new one.

[@williowoffire]

Can you do a backstory for the other guardians?

[@janicewood887]

Can you do a theory about Jack knows Bert (Jake is from Mary Poppins Returns )

[@harmonyv9365]

Kida from Atlantis the lost empire

[@kaylab9779]

Am I the only one who wonders how his memory ended up in that tooth. He didn't loss any teeth after falling in the lake. And if he did I don't think he took the time to put it under a pillow.

[@veronicanaumov2981]

Jack Frost’s story is so sad 😭

[@carolcarlson6125]

Interesting video, Isaac! Have a great time at Disney!!!

[@OzzyDrixClay]

To fallow your dreams you have to leave people you love behind. Wasn't that the reasoning behind Ernesto Delcruz

[@ycp4425]

Dude I love Jack Frost and I’m very conflicted wether should I keep watching the video or read the books 😭😭😭

[@pinkjt34]

I love watching your videos. You ALWAYS look like you enjoy what you do.

[@nightridersnation6977]

i can't get enough of your videos! ❄🌑

[@mouche_pie]

Jack Frost reminds me of Hueningkai so much! Hueningkai will be a good cast if they will have a live-action for this

[@MelodyofTime]

Amazing vid

[@smithsoniansmith2433]

Shadow: this reminds about my old friend of mine...

[@kimberlyarrington5721]

Do you think he hit his head on the Ice when he fell through it for the reason he can't remember .

[@marthabobthebuilder2669]

I like how you actually explain it and not just say something about it ⭐️

[@Sam-does-uke-stuff]

My question has always been: how ong was jack under the ice? Like Isaac said, by the time Jack came out of the ice, it had already frozen over. His family wasn't there. There was no one mourning his "death". So how long had he be supposedly "dead"?

[@clarenceorozco5300]

I think you underestimated how fast water can freeze.... like i seen water freeze in less than a hour