Writing a song that goes all the way around the circle of 5ths

[@MrSamman]

You’re going to summon Jacob Collier if you go around the entire circle like that!

[@wesleyalan9179]

People hating on you, but my imagination is very good, and i can hear what it could be. Thanks.

[@natetrek]

Tot agree. Could be amazing and fresh. Here's hoping @unclejudymusing digs deeper, taps into the rich roots here and develops it into something special.

[@peterbatten596]

Awesome chord progression. But at the same time, the circle of fifths is supposed to show you (clockwise or counterclockwise) which scales and chords share the most when transitioning to (and from) different keys. But if I had to guess, that’s the point of why you made it so the irony is no accident, but to prove to people who either agree just to agree or don’t really understand its importance to the relativity…or not, that could also be the case. Either way, glad I found your channel!

[@antoinebronk2251]

People who say this isn't good, just arent into alternative music I think

[@marklohebany228]

or they can just hear the dissonance between the chords 💀💀💀

[@antoinebronk2251]

@marklohebany228 That's the point? Not all music has to be harmonious

[@marklohebany228]

@@antoinebronk2251 i agree to some extent, sure, they’re are heavily dissonant songs that sound good (like 99% of KoЯn tracks) but this guy failed to make the dissonance sound good

[@buttholesurfer1266]

nah it just sounds like garbage. nothing much to it. guy should listen to cardiacs or something

[@buttholesurfer1266]

​@@marklohebany228for me its roads girdle the globe, or maybe some later xtc stuff. partridge had a talent for writing dissonant pop. honestly a lot of popier alt bands from 90s were pretty dissonant too. this just sounds like random chords playing by chance

[@Irish_Potato_egg]

Thanks Judester, for returning to a more consistent uload schedule :]

[@schrutebuck]

This reminds me of outer wilds

[@JaffetChacon]

Going in a circle isnt an issue. It actually would work clockwise or counter. The real issue is starting at C and doing a jump over to D# or A# for example.

[@misteruncanny]

I liked it, sounded a a weird mix of los campinisos and nirvana 😭

[@liamp4032]

sounded like caca im ngl

[@natetrek]

Ugh, worst sounding circle of 5ths I've ever heard. Tot believe you when you said you never use it (I can see why). ... Might want to listen to some Bach or Handel to hear how it works and what you can do with it.

[@natetrek]

Also, I know it's a matter of taste, but what I heard just now sounds like someone randomly F*ing around. Not tasty or memorable.

[@unclejudymusic]

you look like god was just f*ing around when he designed you

[@natetrek]

Thanks, I guess. Being candid with you since we all appreciate and look for the good things music brings us. Hope you keep mastering your craft. Def would enjoy hearing a more developed version of this when it gets there. ... Maybe bookmark this for a re-listen in a few years and it will be easy to take a big step forward with it. Good luck in any case.

[@somethingsaid9058]

@@natetrekbro go to bed

[@LancelotDavis-jh1ox]

@@unclejudymusic Dang, he got you there.

[@marklohebany228]

that’s way too dissonant, my guy

[@bretmishler3435]

lol no

[@_conchobhar_]

it’s called a circle of fifths progression and it goes all the way back to bach. can’t you just come up with something oRIGiNaL, I CaNT bELieVe yOu sToLe a cHorD prOgresSioN, UNSUBBED

[@_conchobhar_]

also F#7 is not in the key of Gb. It’s still in B you are just doing the V in B. and who says F#7? guitarists make me want to kms