XG - Winter Without You MV + Shooting Star - The First Take! REACTION!

Enquiries - [e-mail]
Below is the link to my reaction spreadsheet where you can request a reaction and find everything I have reacted to:
linktr.ee/melaniereacts
Join me on Twitter:
melaniereactsyt
#xgreaction #xgshootingstar #xgwinterwithoutyou
XG - WINTER WITHOUT YOU (Official Music Video) - • XG - WINTER WITHOUT YO...
XG - WINTER WITHOUT YOU / THE FIRST TAKE - • XG - WINTER WITHOUT YO...
XG - SHOOTING STAR / THE FIRST TAKE - • XG - SHOOTING STAR / T...

[@ductdang]

Chisa Yelling - recreates a scene from Love Letter (1995) Japanese movie where characters husband is lost and never found in a snowstorm in the mountains. She goes there to yell out to him "How are you?". She replies to the echo. "I'm doing fine.", knowing the echo is the only response she will ever get. Girls crying - they surprise each of them with a video message from their family who they really have not seen for 5+ years during their training. This XG original song is a unique Christmas gift to us.

[@melaniereacts]

Omg wow 😭😭😭

[@lenanicole2837]

They showed the behind the scenes in Both but they showed it even more and their personalities in general more in the XG Days #23 Vlog and I know you said you want to know their personalities more cause you don't really know them so if you only have time for one that's the one for sure, it was so cute I ended up watching it twice lol they also just performed this on It's Live with a really beautiful live band arrangement as well TT

[@melaniereacts]

Will check it out for sure 🥰

[@jofx1027]

XG got the whole R&B playbook on lock. YES. Maya's vocal run floored me too -- this girl really is an ace. The vocal flex in this one is INSANE - even from the rapline. Their harmonies are so beautiful. The early 2000 R&B Nostalgia hits a homerun on this one. XG's competition is XG themselves. As usual thanks for the mad love for XG.

[@jramos0010]

I think the Chisa look was a gift to reactors because many of them were saying that she sounded like Ariana Grande when they reacted to the MV

[@jellyshen]

yes cocona got a cold there❤

[@melaniereacts]

And still sounds incredible 🥰

[@OleDirtyBastard68]

This isn't even fair anymore. They pummel us into complete submission with their vocals.

[@melaniereacts]

Agreeeeee 😭😍

[@D.N.A.23]

They dropped wwy live band 😊🎉🎉

[@melaniereacts]

Omg did they???? Can’t wait to watch 😍

[@D.N.A.23]

@@melaniereacts enjoy XG , Merry X-Mas girl

[@X-popJunkie]

They had shown the girls seeing their parents lol! { 4:17 } and that’s just Coco’s tone 😭 she has a very deep soothing voice!

[@pedrorcardo]

10:15 If this was filmed during the Showcase period in Japan, Cocona was sick those days (due to tonsillitis). I noticed her voice was a bit nasal during the show, and then, a few days later, she mentioned she had lost her voice 2 days before the showcase. Despite that, she was still able to perform, and she did amazingly well ♥

[@530MAIDU]

Lots of Green Tea 🍵 helps me. 🙆🏻‍♀️🎄❄️⛄️🐺

[@ariusbudiman7105]

5:31 You have to watch from 'XG - WINTER WITHOUT YOU MV Behind The Scenes' there's their parents message.

[@melaniereacts]

Definitely will 🥰

[@knkweb]

First Take Performance is a Japan Programme. Studio version! Amazing! XG super talented and they’re super gorgeous!! 💕💕🎁💝🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵

[@Huge_XG-Xpop_Stan]

Thank you for this!!🫰🐺🫶The dips Harvey makes during her first part and the slight changes that were made during the live per. are so MAGNIFICENT! 🫠 The Shooting Star TFT per. was also fantastic! They truly never miss; it's actually a bit scary at this point, lol! They also just performed on It's Live (Band Ver.) if you want to check that out as well. Happy Holidays!🎄🎁🎅

[@bisco5051]

ココナちゃんは、風邪を引いてましたが、この皆んなの歌声は本当に素晴らしいです。 今回はMAYAちゃんとチサちゃんのボーカルに驚かされました。😊

[@melaniereacts]

❤️❤️❤️

[@synxx3922]

I have been waiting for your reaction to xg so much. 🤗 First of all thx for reacting and posting this wonderful Video 👍☺️. I love Chisa’s Voice soooo much and in the First take auf the Song Winter without u- She surprises me with her tone and technique, the way she sings blows me away. I didn't think she would be responsible for so much of the high notes in the background... she's great and she doesn't stop..😱🫠🫠 Wooooooow Chiiiiiiiiiisaaaaaaa 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@melaniereacts]

Agree!! She slayed 😍😍😍

[@ductdang]

Parents -> Behind The Scenes yup!

[@SantaCIausX]

WWY is 🔝🥇📀 Winter Song 2023. Please react to WWY Band LIVE Concert at it's Live (released today).🫶🏻🫰🏻 Merry Christmas!🎄🎅🏻❄️🎄🎅🏻❄️

[@melaniereacts]

Will do 🥰

[@530MAIDU]

Welcome back Melanie. That sounds like so much fun to be with the Filipino Alphaz. I admire the Filipino culture and they’re love for great music. I love SB19 🇵🇭too. You’re right XG never misses. Yes 👍🏽 Cocona sounded like she was enduring a “cold” on their First Take….but if they’re scheduled…then the show must go on. They always look so pretty and stylish. Great Reaction. Merry Christmas 🎁 2023’. 🙋🏻‍♀️🎄❄️⛄️🐺

[@jellyshen]

Merry Christmas🫎🎄✨💖❄️🥰

[@melaniereacts]

Merry Christmas to you too 🥰

[@user-wq9cw5bu6i]

どちらの曲もどこか古き良きR&Bの雰囲気を感じながら聴いています😁XGちゃんたちの歌声、ラップ、ハーモニー、すべてが素晴らしいです💫

[@46288328]

good point, very nostalgic.

[@samhue4194]

They are unreal

[@melaniereacts]

They are 🥰

[@zeronyne]

You might want to jump into the Winter Without You First Take and the Live band version that have both just dropped.

[@melaniereacts]

I did the winter without you first take in this reaction ❤️

[@mauriceharris1527]

FYI; They show that part from the spaceship monitor in the behind the scenes MV. It's so sad😭 and this song is so beautiful 😊💗👍

[@MarkCalica]

That’s Chisarina Grande lol. I loved the F1rst Take version. And they just released the It’s Live performance and that one has a different feel to it. Love all versions of WWY. Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year Mel🎄🎉

[@anan1004]

XG is so amazing ❤

[@Neige700]

Such a beautiful song ❤

[@NemesisN4Sir]

Another wonderful reaction cause you never disappoint. Did anyone ever tell you that Yuna from ITZY resemble you alot because it does and she is my bias BTW. Happy holiday to you.

[@BrettMurphynorthps]

Melanie!!!! ♥🥰

[@blackpinkmedia6687]

Wow... Love XG Now and Forever.

[@MAQ14]

Filo in aussie here! love the XG content

[@pattydicarlo1811]

ALPHAZ ON DECK❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@snkrrrrr]

Their parent's messages were shown in the XG DAYS #23 Vlog and it was sweet and emotional as you can imagine but unfortunately the English subtitles are a little messed up during the part where the messages are shown :/ I mean you can still get the general gist of what they're saying and what's going on though. I still recommend watching it though so this song can hit you even more, it's also nice to see their personalities during the vlogs.

[@melaniereacts]

Thanks for the info 😘

[@lufffyypiratekingg]

Yes Cocona is sick but she still slayed.

[@Lycaonightley]

10:20 you’re right she wasn’t fully recovered from tonsillitis when they recorded this

[@razw8200]

I love this song....another one i would like to recommend is JEON SOMI x BIG Naughty ‘Ex-Mas’ SPECIAL. I'm sure you'll love it

[@user-fu7de8nh1f]

この素晴らしい歌声とハーモニーの心地良さには誰しもが心を奪われますよね… ｡ﾟ(ﾟ´Д｀ﾟ)ﾟ｡｡ﾟ(ﾟ´Д｀ﾟ)ﾟ｡

[@Dont_LookAt-My-Name]

This song has made me realize just how much I miss that 90s/2000s R&B Christmas vibe! They really took me back to when the holidays and the music were actually enjoyable!

[@VirgoRose-bk9sw]

Finally someone else noticed. thought its just me, but yeah, i also thought cocona might be sick here. She doesnt sound like that on its live's shooting star. Nevertheless, still so good!

[@mauriceharris1527]

That's COCONA 'S natural singing voice. She can sing higher though. A prime example is on the NEW DANCE song.

[@melaniereacts]

I was talking about her being a little sick, not the tone of her voice. I think someone said she was actually sick. Her voice is so beautiful though 🥰

[@user-maghiro]

👍🔥🔥🔥✨💫☃️🎄

[@GKFF9872]

I’ve literally never encountered a group where I know all the lyrics to all the songs that they’ve done, right down to the butchering any Japanese or Korean lines that crop up.