THE FIRST TAKE: XG - SHOOTING STAR + WINTER WITHOUT YOU Reaction ll I NEARLY CRIED

[@DukeTDang]

So glad you didn’t miss this one, best version of Winter Without You

[@nicoscarlet]

cant agree less

[@saskoreacts]

I'm ascending every single time Hinata is singing "as long as I am with my baby, please hurry up". And the way they transformed this Winter/Holiday song into something you can vibe to all year long is crazy..

[@megsyy0101]

yesss i was like babe im here

[@megsyy0101]

i cried listening to the song the first time, then i watched behind the scene i cried harder, i watched the vlog i cried again

[@MarkCalica]

This version is definitely my favorite since it’s raw and the layering and harmonies have more organic feel to it. Like what that other guy said, I listen to this more than the single version. It’s that good. I especially love Amy’s part and her harmonies. The end acapella is just the cherry on top since the studio version fades out. I wish they focused a bit more on Jurin cause she did a lot of mid-low harmonies throughout. I love her tone as well. They all did amazing and that’s why I’m in love with this song

[@DukeTDang]

Winter Without You also a good grieving and loss song….

[@tracisr]

This version of winter without you gives me goosebumps and makes me tear up every time! Love you nails how they look like malachite btw!!!!

[@rd1012]

Yes Em it was phenomenal!!! Its a song whose year round... the vibes... slay!!!

[@calvinmitchell1274]

XG💗

[@ellai_playz6587]

Check the version of "winter without you" on "its live"

[@andrew097]

Its about two weeks since I listened . It's better then I member. An amazing collection of voices. Juria and Chisa are voices of their generation. The styling was amazing too. I thought Chisa was as beautiful as Audrey Hepburn in Breakfast at Tiffany's.

[@pattydicarlo1811]

ALPHAZ ON DECK❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@jellyshen]

Love your reaction Emily❤❤😊

[@nicoscarlet]

This song also my current fav from XG

[@1viewer1]

This is just the super group!

[@robertstewart3325]

My major problem with First Take 'Winter Without you' is I Only want to hear this version now. The fact that their vocal layering is almost better in a live one take atmosphere is actually kind of gross. Like we would have LOVED it even if one of you was slightly low or slightly too high but no you go and make the song better and I can't even add it to a music playlist?!

[@MarkCalica]

💯this version definitely kills

[@nicoscarlet]

ikr right. I keep comparing the MV with the FT version

[@Sumo1-p8e]

This to me is like Whitney Houston x7 good! Everyone of them is just phenomenal!

[@ryu_yamayama]

全員が上手いって凄い

[@酔ってるなジジィ]

えっ‼︎コレ原曲と思ってしまう程の『XG』ちゃん達の歌声… アレンジを加えたこちらの方がある意味良かったりする… (*´ω｀*)

[@daggerSLADE]

But have you heard the rock version of shooting star? Only on fan cam from the current tour

[@Tiffii.official]

Please check out XG VOX 6 Losing You cover

[@GooGoo_Taro]

💗🔥Nice!🔥💗