Xinjiang "Genocide" Talk - Pivot To Peace Excerpt

An excerpt from the Pivot To Peace panel.
In this video I speak about my recent trip to Xinjiang, the greater context of the Xinjiang "genocide" narrative, and the consequences for us all.
Please check out the entire panel which includes more content from me and a speech from the brilliant Professor Ken Hammond & retired Superior Court judge Julie Tang hosted by the talented Shelia Xiao at Pivot to Peace: • Myths & Facts about ge...
If the groups being supported by the US are successful with their goals for Xinjiang, the consequences for the residents of Xinjiang will be far worse. For more context on this issue, I recommend watching my interview with an ex Al Qaeda member who was connected with and understands ETIM in great detail: • ex-Al Qaeda Member Dis...

[@DanielDumbrill]

Please consider checking out the entire panel which includes more content from me and a speech from the brilliant Professor Ken Hammond & retired Superior Court judge Julie Tang hosted by the talented Shelia Xiao at Pivot to Peace: kzbin.info/www/bejne/l17Zo3iDebGgetk

[@kckoay6211]

There is no doubt that the West is exploiting its centuries-old dominion over the English language-based media. Conspicuously, the parties with the overwhelming advantage of the media can easily manipulate public thinking. They can decide what the people should know; and what they shouldn’t know by distorting or stifling news. They can make things out of nothing by fabricating falsehoods. Like magicians, they think they can turn black into white; and white into black depending on the plots. That said, even the most “inventive” journalism will come to nothing, or will peter out without the support of facts. To quote and unquote the 16th President of the United States, Abraham Lincoln: “You can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time.”

[@kckoay6211]

But a good man like you, Daniel, is doing a wonderful job helping to debunk the misinformation and propaganda, Salute!

[@godblesstheworldwearehuman3331]

Thank you Daniel🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@JourneyDestination]

I most definitely will.

[@Shenzhou.]

Honestly speaking, China's propaganda sucks and clearly needs improvements. Many people are skeptical about Chinese news, even when supported with actual data and statistics. However, American propaganda is the best. Many people willingly believe American propaganda, even when it's unsupported by evidence.

[@wzg7508]

I never cease to be awed by Daniel's decency, intellect and eloquence. You are truly one of my most respected personalities on youtube.

[@raaid85]

I am just so angry and genuinely worried about what the US is willing to do. Its fascinating to see how all these former colonial and settler colonials states came together and can't stand the fact that a non white country is beating them without invading anyone and through a form of socialism. No way can u expect high speed rail network this extensive in a country like USA. I live in canada answer just shocked how muslims have internalized this uygur narrativem from the same folks who will never speak out for palestine

[@lovelight7427]

Thanks

[@dejavue3013]

So true. He is just brilliant

[@Shenzhou.]

Daniel's content is extremely thought-provoking and there's a lot to unpack from his words.

[@chrishannis1]

@@dejavue3013 true, he's just truly amazing and exceptional.

[@beesplaining1882]

We also learnt recently the American case against Julian Assange is based on testimony from a person who now admits to lying! Such a tapestry of lies is hard to maintain.

[@fannyalbi9040]

they jailed him based on lies. How convenient

[@beesplaining1882]

@@fannyalbi9040 they do it every day.

[@sabinereynaudsf]

What about Cheng Lei, Chen Mei, Cai Wei, Erkin Tursun, Mirkamil Ablimit etc.?

[@beesplaining1882]

@@sabinereynaudsf what about it? Both sides do it. It just that the side we're on lies and breaks international law too....the side we're responsible for!

[@sabinereynaudsf]

@@beesplaining1882 You brought it up. The case of Assange has been in the public eye for years and has been discussed for years. Imagine what would happen to Assange in China, if he published strategic information on the Chinese Military? China doesn't admit any wrong doing or negligence. And it doesn't sound like Daniel would ever admit to China lying about anything.

[@missyxixi]

Always great to hear from your point of view. You sound tired and burned out. Sometimes it does feel like coming from this perspective, it's us against the world. Thank you for doing this and putting yourself out there, Daniel. Thank you for being the voice of reason in this time of madness.

[@dingding6745]

One of these days, the US government will be made to pay for its sins in regards to all this attempt in maintain its hegemony via causing destruction and chaos around the world while using human rights as a false banner. I am really starting to hate the word ‘human rights’ because the people fighting for it doesn’t even believe in what it really should stand for.

[@therealdeal2163]

@@dingding6745" human rights" for the American empire is like " free trade " for the British empire....great sounding phrases to kill people for ...similar to " collateral damage " to hide the fact you are murdering ordinary people whilst committing war crimes.

[@Masterysky]

The "world" really is just the western world that controls all mainstream media.

[@bjkina]

@@therealdeal2163 The freedom to 'vote' (lol), but not the freedom to eat.

[@ramonng7054]

Ukraine just withdrew from the anti-China statements it has earlier supported, learning the US used them, after not protecting their gas pipeline position...

[@Chinese080808]

Can you include references? Thanks!

[@Andy-P]

Ukraine pulled its name off the list of supporting states after Chinese authorities warned Kyiv that they would block a planned shipment of at least 500,000 doses of COVID-19 vaccines to Ukraine unless it did so, said diplomats from two Western countries. The diplomats spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the matter publicly

[@jd-qb3ne]

@@Andy-P makes zero sense.....if so, once the shipment arrives, couldn't ukraine simply put their name back on the list?

[@Andy-P]

@@jd-qb3ne I guess they could if allowed. Make the UN, China & Ukraine look bad.

[@eskay2012]

Let’s prosper together. Which is the synergy of combined effort.

[@ronchow2010]

Many of us know the truth about Xinjiang. The difference here is Daniel is an excellent communicator and gets his points across very well.

[@junchengtang3733]

@Atudie Ms 西方媒体没事空出假新闻又不是一天两天了，这不是天天都在造吗？你看看现在美国人自己相不相信CNN，Fox等媒体，民主党媒体和共和党媒体还互相造假新闻呢，更何况对于敌对国家。

[@wondercat3516]

@Atudie Ms 西方媒體會沒事憑空生出假新聞已是眾所周知，你不知道？

[@mikemurray2027]

@Atudie Ms Where is the evidence? Suspicion is not enough.

[@elvis20111116]

​@Atudie Ms U.S. Admits to Using Uyghurs in Xinjiang to Destabilize China kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4aufoubnM2CaLM

[@elvis20111116]

@Atudie MsVijay Prashad: Xinjiang, Genocide, and Cold War Narratives kzbin.info/www/bejne/pHOceYWBgL97l80

[@ramonng7054]

you, sir are gifted with a logical mind and an extraordinary talent of communication...you make things so simple to understand

[@abcxyz6606]

I will never get tire of hearing factual honest commentaries and information. Thank you as always, Daniel!

[@mangosorbet768]

I don't see Daniel as a casual KZbinr anymore but true journalist. 👍

[@chenxin5664]

Yes, he has the talent to express himself well.

[@michaelhrpufnstuf1078]

Wow I couldn’t stop laughing at this. Daniel Dumbrill a Journalist hahahahahahahaha. Wow that was funny.

[@德州扒鸡]

can‘t agree more

[@darklighter064]

@@michaelhrpufnstuf1078 As dumb as his last name lol

[@NSResponder]

He is nothing of the kind.

[@3nien]

This video should be shown at the big screen in New York ‘s Time Square

[@easylover6449]

lol Can you imagine the hysteria...

[@johnc1873]

They will probably just say “China pays western faces to make up propaganda to push the non genocide of ughurs”

[@gergentanakrisse5430]

Lol 😂your words are so cute

[@terryloi6975]

Imagine the Falun Gong march into the square and yell out that he is China agent

[@ralphzoombeenie2792]

Maybe a link to your local representative.

[@Wellyyoung]

Rational, eloquent and fair analysis. Such a great communicator. Kudos to you Daniel.

[@Hello-ig1px]

i disagree with the "fair analysis" part of your comment. Daniel is not fair whatsoever. Daniel complains about racism in America and Canada after 9/11 towards muslims. Daniel says that it was racist for America's government agencies, such as the FBI, watching muslims more closely that were boarding airplanes. Daniel says that it was racist for the FBI to insert plants, undercover agents, in America's mosques to monitor muslims after 9/11. Daniel complains about how unsafe he felt in Canada and America after 9/11. The very same Daniel, says that the Uighar re-education camps are okay and they ARE ACTUAL HELPFUL for Uighars. So consider everything I just wrote and how Daniel feels it is racist for how America simply monitoring muslims after 9/11. Do you think Daniel would have the same opinions of the Uighar re-education camps if America was forcing its Muslim population to go into re-education camps? - like the difference is wild and its even more wild how Daniel refuses to mention any racism regarding the Uighar re-education camps.

[@玪玪-v2m]

Take it positively the west is making China stronger and stronger. Chinese are more united like never before. 😄😄😄🇸🇬🇨🇳🇭🇰❤👍😍

[@REDSUN-8]

@Atudie Ms 我上的三年寄宿重点高中就这样, 只是卑鄙的BBC又在使用暗色镜头😂😂一个侵略成性的国家竟然指责56个民族和平共处的国家。

[@Shenzhou.]

@Atudie Ms 老实说翻墙之后，就觉得西方媒体对中国太傲慢与偏见，而且很多美国人已经被美媒洗脑了。

[@玪玪-v2m]

@WN WN that's the past we seen enough of the western evil...

[@REDSUN-8]

@WN WN New China was created by the Communist Party. The results of a 13-year survey conducted by Harvard University showed that 93% of Chinese people are satisfied with the governance of the Communist Party. Why should we compete with political parties whose contribution to the founding of the nation is zero? What qualifications do third parties have to make irresponsible comments on China's system??

[@玪玪-v2m]

@WN WN ya elect a cabbage government so that people can do evil stuffs...

[@roberthill9946]

I am really delightfully amazed at your rare unique ability to express yourself on issues that are generally hard for most people to do or comprehend. I have never once been able to fault you for your honesty,conveying the actual facts in clear understandable preciseness. I inherently know that your views and comments are substantially correct as I live under the cloud of American influence and dominance. I am an Australian and am well aware of how stealthily America installs its control over a country and they do it so well that very few citizens are aware of any of their dominance.In Australia’s case it was easily done by creating the five eyes countries and Pine Gap. I admire the great work that you do and hope that you do not cease it for any reason.With respect,from Robert of Australia 🇦🇺.

[@4xTouring]

Well said mate. As Aussies we can be a much better society than what we are being turned into by a handful of self centered people and their media stooges. 🇦🇺

[@maxsweetman6341]

Hi Robert I’m an Aussie too and I am ashamed of the lack of any leadership or true governance in this country our pollies are all about self interest and advancement people are extremely low on their list of priorities

[@steventurner1002]

Russia Today website have just put up an article on how Bob Hawke sold Australia out to the USA. Whitlam was going to reduce or remove the USA from Australia - Recommend ready the article.

[@roberthill9946]

@@4xTouring pleasant and intelligent comment.Could I suggest you may be interested to view the Australian national archives library,where classified correspondence between the governments/intelligence of Australia/U.S.A./U,K.the Queen and palace officials, has been declassified after a period of 50years or so.Just a little amount of reading will blow you away,and you will quickly understand why we are not a far better country than we are. I feel that the only way we can become an independent sovereign country free to make our own decisions,is to divorce ourselves from five eyes/pine gap and the overwhelming dominance of America.If we did that though we would find it difficult but in the end it would be of overwhelming benefit for us.Kind regards Robert.

[@roberthill9946]

@@maxsweetman6341 Excellent comment. Could I suggest you have a look at the recent release of classified documents of correspondence between Australia/U.S.A./U.K.and the Queen and palace.You can find them easily now at the Australian national archives library where they have been held for over 50years.They will blow you away and you will realise why we are in the situation that we are. Kind regards Robert.

[@richardwhitehouse8762]

I want to thank you, Daniel, for making think about this stuff. My interest in China, other than a very broad and shallow "how did they do that?" curiosity about their economic rise, was really only piqued properly by Trump and the whole focus on Huawei. It made me wonder what on earth a company that I'd never really heard about had done or was capable of doing. So that was the start and since then I've been trying to join up the dots. It has been quite a journey and there are still way more gaps than knowledge but thanks to people like you, Daniel, I am now aware of a US funding stream called the National Endowment for Democracy and someone called Adrian Zenz. Putting those two together is a very useful place to start in relation to piecing together where the narratives about Xinjiang stem from. Then try and understand how international media works, which is that something "reported" in one country (let's a say short update piece about "disappeared" Uyghurs on BBC radio news a few days ago UK) can then inform or corroborate ideas useful to the US administration (at, say, the G7 meeting in Cornwall). It is breathtaking. I have from time to time got very anxious at the sheer amount of goading that the CPC has been subject to by the US. Take the protests in Hong Kong. I am sure that the idea was to provoke the CPC into a repeat of the Tiananmen Square catastrophe. Only it didn't happen. Instead they used the rule of law. I take comfort from this as it feels like there are safety valves within the CPC. And the more I find out about China, the more astonished I am about how it works and what it achieves. And the more tragic this whole polarisation becomes.

[@ausreir]

A concise demonstration of integrity and intelligence.

[@abdulbada1]

I just don't know why but I find your explanation very clear, simple and easy to understand. Indeed, you explain things in a systematic way. Thank you very much

[@watfordmusalla]

Link includes eye witness testimony kzbin.info/www/bejne/pKWcc42fpqdjnpI

[@NoelLee89]

Great stuff Daniel, as usual

[@JaYoeNation]

Great speech Daniel. As usual. Don’t buy into any narrative…. Just look into each point with an open mind.

[@JourneyDestination]

The world would be a much better place if people did that more often.

[@dddmiao]

@@JourneyDestination the Chinese does that a lot more than the Americans (from my 15 years of living in each country)

[@JourneyDestination]

@@dddmiao Politicians in the U.S are only concerned with attaining power by any means necessary. America doesn’t even care about its citizens, let alone those around the world.

[@shitpantsuckisaterrorist8569]

It's funny that the Anti-China Australian Boy Drew Pavlou, who claims he is a college activist who stands for "Human- Rights", the same boy who compared BLM protest and Hong Kong Riots in the same picture who is famous on Sky News, is not being vocal for Palestinians or Loochooans who are being genocide. Same for Greta Thumberg, for allowing Hinoko, Loochoo, to have their coral reef be destroyed by the Americans and Japanese Government, just to make a new US base. Why are these young "activist" so silent when it comes to Loochoo. Loochoo under occupation has both human rights and environmental violations. The activist excuse to be "unaware of the situation" is nothing but bogus. They are "Human-Rights/Enviromental Activist" for crying out loud and they have a huge platform! Loochoo has been under occupation for 200 years and having to being victim of pollution. Yet, nothing has been done or reported. Loochoo has a history of 3000 years, yet people pretend that it doesn't exist. Loochoo has a history of being a finincial and trading hub that is heavily involved of all of Asias economy, yet they are forgotton. Loochoo has also been the heart of Asia, yet they are now occupied and a illegal "country" like Taiwan stole their status and title. Why is no one saying anything about this!?! This is outrageous, it's unfair!!! How could all the fake countries gain independence but no a legitimate country like Loochoo!?!

[@shitpantsuckisaterrorist8569]

Even Loochoo/Ryukyu/Okinawa under US and Japan occupation disliked and even protest against US bases build on their land. Native Loochooans do not see China as a threat and they hate America and Japan more. Loochoo is a stretch of islands including Okinawa, and they have a history of 3000 years and 200 years under occupation by Japan and US Military. The most "well known" of Loochoo history is the Ryukyu Kingdom to the outside world. Loochoo was discovered by the Chinese during the Qin Dynasty, where the First Emperor, Qin Shi Huang, heard about an island of immortal beings. He send envoys to Loochoo the learn the ways of the local people of longlevity. However, currently now, Loochoans suffer alot worse than anyone else in the world alongside palestine and hawaii, under occupation by US Military and Japan. Loochooans are humiliated by the Japanese government for speaking in their own language. Loochooans are loosing their own homes to illegal settlers and if Loochooans resist, the Japanese soildiers will break into their homes and drag them out and kill them. American soilders occupied Loochoo by stealing land and building their base there in highly populated civilian areas. Everytime there will be frequent accidents happening with the US Airforce Jets on the island. The debris land on schools , hospitals, houses and shops. Loochooan women and juvenile girls are constantly raped by US soildiers and if Loochooan men come to protect them, the soildiers will kill the whole family, and when the soildiers return home , they are scot free. Im not joking, you can look this up. For more info, you can check out Rob Kajiwara's channel on youtube and twitter. He is a native Loochooan activist and he cover this topics on his home. Ever wonder why you don't often hear it on the news, because western media has an agenda over China than true human rights. The bases are not there only to contain China but to also contain Loochoo independence. Loochoo-US Relations shows it is at the lowest peak, alot worse than North Korea, Iran, Cuba, Venezuela, Russia, and PRC combined. It is so bad, that America will try their best to censored out all Loochooan related news or deny their existence to the world. If Loochoo is independent today, it would be a prosperous democratic republic following the Singaporean way of governance. It will also be a financial trading hub for all East Asians and Southeast Asian countries. Loochoo could have it's independence after 1945. However, America rejected the demands of the locals. Rob Kajiwara KZbin kzbin.info Rob Kajiwara twitter twitter.com/robkajiwara?s=09 Silk and Steel Podcast: History of Okinawa with Robert Kajiwara and Carl Zha kzbin.info/www/bejne/b5OafqGtpMuSfsU

[@whhusa]

My wife just went to Urumqi. I asked her about what's happening there. She looked at me as if I was nuts. lol

[@不动不静]

lol make sense. but there are too many nuts around the world especially in north America

[@elvis20111116]

@Atudie Ms This is just a problem of a certain builder, what does it have to do with the country!!

[@fhd89234n8f43n7]

I had to explain to a friend that it doesn't rain in Shanghai. I told him I went to Shanghai and didn't see any rain. BOOM! Undeniable proof!

[@mandyluo1371]

To counter western media, we need help with editing and correcting information on this Wikipedia entry… en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide

[@fhd89234n8f43n7]

@@mandyluo1371 Wow! Lots of good info there! I never knew there was a specific page on Uyghur Genocide! Good links, too: UN demands ‘unfettered access’ for China Uighur region visit. Beijing has said it would welcome UN officials to Xinjiang on the condition they stay out of its internal affairs. 🤭 www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/2/27/un-demands-unfettered-access-for-china-uighur-region-visit

[@Coumei2009]

People always say "why not allow independent journalists to visit xinjiang?" I always told them there are no such "independent journalists", especially in west media. These journalists are high-paid writers who always serve special interests. If west media really want to be "independent", they should allow people like Daniel to go with them and to see the same things, then make the consensus conclusion before publishing any report, or publish reports from both journalist and Daniel at the same time and let readers judge, otherwise, there will be never a truth from west media. I know that will never happen. The west journalists will never go with Daniel, otherwise, they will never get paid.

[@avil8686]

Kkkk, 😂 who said independent journalists not allowed?? CNN BBC Telegraph Dw 😆

[@raymondtay9442]

You are absolutely right. The Western media are masters of spin. Even truth can be distorted by telling half-truths or omitting some key facts. And some slight negativity will be blown up as though something is prevalent through the use of different words and/or context. Democracy is a good system, but for the fact that most people are not well-informed, not well-educated, or people who are emotional and easily swayed by those with glib tongues to make informed and wise decisions.

[@pooi-hoongchan8680]

Agree.

[@thetrueworld8317]

Yes, independent journalists bought at high prices by Western politicians. It is obvious that without financial support, how can those independent journalists make a living?

[@catfish9868]

Well said.

[@johnbrown40639]

Your intelligence and wisdom is truly amazing! If only 0.0001% of the western population listen to your pivot, the world will be such a better place!

[@ComradeConfucius]

Daniel Dumbrill is the West's equivalent of Kishore Mahbubani. 🙏 I don't think that there is no hope for the West - if sane minds like Mr Dumbrill prevail, the West and East can have a harmonious future together.

[@mingyuhuang8944]

Dumbrill and mahbutani are both geniuses

[@adamiskandar5107]

I think it's the ghost of their past 'crimes' that is plaguing Western leaders today. They are terrified that when they lose control of the current system, a new dominant power, in this case China, would want to exact revenge on them. They should genuinely ask themselves; why would Chinese citizens want war when they can live the good life just by working hard. The Chinese leaders have already stated that they do not want to play the role of America in the world. They prefer world peace. Why can't leaders of the West work with China to ensure world peace and stability? War is a curse on ordinary people.

[@mikemurray2027]

@@adamiskandar5107 Why can't they work with China? In short, because of imperialism. They are driven to fight each other for control of parts of the world to increase the wealth of their own rich elites. China is achieving economic strength by seeking cooperation, not war. It's a big threat to them.

[@fhd89234n8f43n7]

Sane minds with Chinese characteristics.

[@minggao8442]

Kishore Mahbubani, michael hudson, Daniel Dumbrill, Cyrus Janssen and the Grayzone guys such as Max Blumenthal are on my list of wise people.

[@trois-monts8582]

I like what Daniel mentioned about the "intellectual honesties", which are essential to all people when facing the invisible filter bubble over the media.

[@pikachus5m166]

The US certainly have the motive, means and capabilities in its attempt to maintain primacy, even as far as resorting to biowarfare, far cheaper than conventional weapons, and with the cloak of plausible deniability.

[@ckkanet]

Pro China bloggers Nathan Rich and Cyrus Jansen are on another level compared to Anti China Bloggers. Frat boy english teachers. I also like geo politics in conflict show with the 2 Doctors

[@maxsweetman6341]

Yes the doctors seem to have a well balanced view of world politics and America’s failings

[@bjkina]

Nathan and Cyrus don't really understand - good intentions, perhaps, but their lack of a deeper understanding could lead one astray. On the other hand, imo, they know a lot more than the Barrets and Blondies, who still crank out 'those strange Chinese' selfie vlogs : (

[@Shenzhou.]

Many Chinese hold optimistic attitudes and look forward to a bright future ahead. However, many Westerners are increasingly pessimistic and tend to have a gloomy outlook of the future.

[@wwbren]

Well said Daniel, you have been a beacon in the darkness.

[@Sang-Je]

America brings great shame to the word democracy. Hope for the world to overcome its tyranny one day.

[@Masterysky]

Other western nations aren't any different historically

[@WANDERER0070]

US is no democracy its Oligarchy run be richest 1%

[@sweelim5473]

Brilliant analysis and speech Daniel Dumbrill👍👍👍 many thanks for taking time to share such wisdom and thoughts with us 🌹🌹🌹

[@nileshbhattacharya2526]

If we watching any video related to Xinjiang. Then we see only negativity all because of USA and Western. In reality Muslim or other religions living in Xinjiang/ China is safest and most happiest in the world. Standard of living in Xinjiang much better than the Western.....

[@ralphzoombeenie2792]

A large delegation from Muslim nations DID visit Xinjiang and unanimously praised China's handling of the outbreak of terrorism by a small radicalized group.

[@owo5869]

Haha even the Chinese are not safe living there and you dare make such bold claim.

[@tongchen3327]

I would not make the conclusion that Muslim are happiest and safest in China. However, I would argue that their living standards are likely to be much higher than what Western media has described and represented.

[@watfordmusalla]

But there is repression the video below includes eye witness report kzbin.info/www/bejne/pKWcc42fpqdjnpI

[@owo5869]

@@tongchen3327 You see what if someone accused you of murdering a girl and hide it in your house and demanded to investigate (house). The reasonable thing will be let them in if you didn’t do it. But what if you did. Let’s see what China did. 如果有人說你殺了人藏你家冰箱裡你沒做讓他們進門調查不就好了 HM Nike and other big brands stop using Sinkiang cotton as multiple individual witnesses accused CCP of forced labor. The CCP response was: Didn’t the American had slaves for cotton? Sinkiang cotton have high quality. Over 70% percent of cotton are harvested by machine. You see the problem?

[@renochee5129]

Daniel Dunbrill my respect to you always! You should be given a title PNGO - Private Non Government Official. Speak the truth nothing but the truth!

[@seanlee3863]

Man, your real talent is how well you can articulate and it never bores me listening to you talk. You have an exceptional speech skills in explaining things and threading contents together to make it flow.

[@markrice3019]

😃Excellent Report/ Interchange/ Interview😃

[@whoami3181]

Yes, how much time, money, and efforts the US has spent on Xinjiang in trying to claims any human rights atrocities didn't have the scale to match what happened in West Bank in a period of just a couple of weeks.

[@michaeltsui1762]

Let us hope that US would change and the American people would wake up and see all those lies that their government throw at them

[@terencekwong3033]

That was amazing, can't wait to watch it again when Hua Chenying puts it up on the projector at the next presser 😆

[@drclleong]

From SG.. Once covid over will go back for vacation.. Been there 2x.

[@gergentanakrisse5430]

SG 🙋🏻‍♂️

[@不动不静]

Daniel sounds really smart and I believe he is. being with this guys will definitely bring improvement

[@susanmills3984]

Thanks so much for providing such balanced reporting about these issues. None of your observations come as a surprise to anyone who does a lot of reading, but not everyone has time and resources to do so and that makes your videoed presentations very valuable indeed.

[@klkho3713]

The world will definitely be a must better place if there are more people like you in the west, i tip my hat to you.

[@chicareili1595]

Well said, Daniel. The world should hear your voice, not voices from liars, such as Laowhy86. Keep up the good work!

[@JourneyDestination]

Another awesome and informative video, Thanks Daniel.

[@richkeenan7832]

Daniel, great talk as usual thanks. I have a couple of thoughts regarding this Xinjiang subject. Before I start, I am 100% in agreement with you, I just think this should be looked into. So firstly, on the question of "is there human rights abuses going on in Xinjiang?" One thing I think many people miss about this, is the cultural difference between China and the west. I'm NOT saying there are abuses going on, my thought is that it's just VERY easy for the west to film or photograph very ordinary things that happen in China and paint it as bad behaviour. For example, the uniforms. When the subject of forced labour comes up they often mention the uniforms the 'workers' (slaves) are forced to wear. This is clearly BS, fact is, in China people wear uniforms for all sorts of things, and in general take much more pride in their work than in the west. For example, the many many security guards in China that look like police, they're not, they just work at the shopping mall or bank, but if you thought they were police, they're everywhere. (Police state?? nope) Even the staff that stand on the platforms at metro stations, they behave like they are in the army, standing to attention, because they take their job seriously. Another thought I have re Xinjiang and the allegation of internment camps, I won't use the term the NED funded mob use. Many people including yourself have visited Xinjiang, like Jerry who has cycled thousands of miles there, and as soon as travel restrictions are over we will be going ourselves. Not to look for evidence of anything, but because we have always wanted to visit and see the amazing scenery, but rest assured I will share my experience, as I'm sure it will be a pleasant one. Anyway, what surprises me is that the forces in the west that are using this narrative to demonise China don't mention the fact that the XUAR is 4 times the size of Germany. You could go to an area that size every month for a year and never see anything, because the region is just too big. Going to the Grand Bazaar in Urumuqi and filming in the market doesn't really disprove anything. Again i'm NOT saying that these places exist, I believe the same as you, there are education centres, and an education program which is giving the people in the region an education so they can be a part of wider society instead of being so secular. I get it, I agree with what they are doing because I know the reasons for it, but I wish there was a way to show that there are no 'hidden camps' like people like ASPI constantly allege. It's like the one child policy, over here in the UK it's made out to be barbaric, but to me it was just a government taking action to stop problems occurring further down the line. Would they rather they just let all families have 3 babies and then starve? No western country has the population problems China has to deal with, and as far as I see no western country even understands China, the one thing they understand is they have to make their citizens look down on China, so they don't notice what their own governments are doing.

[@artplus3448]

@Rich Keenan - Thank you, well written article and I agree with what you said.

[@johnlockegg7095]

Many Chinese policies are pretty harsh and sometimes over the top, but they are effective. So if they look into ties between Uighurs inside XJ with foreign countries, innocent people will wrongfully fall under suspicion. But so will real terrorists or people susceptiple to terrorist propaganda be found. But is this genocide? Hell, no! It's just the West could never use the same methods, because of a different value system. About the second part, that Xinjiang is so big. You can simply travel to the locations that ASPI marked on satelite images and claimed to be "concentration camps". Many have already been debunked to be schools or factories. But you can look for yourself.

[@richkeenan7832]

@@johnlockegg7095 Indeed you can, and once travel restrictions are over we're going ourselves. There's some absolutely amazing places to see, and I'll be sure to look at some of these bogus 'camps' while I'm at it. I've met Uighurs several times, in Shanghai and other cities, even a few years ago one told me to ignore all the crap coming out of the MSM, they knew then and look what's happened.

[@dranzacspartan8002]

When the USA makes alliances with a Country, they build them free USA Supervised Military bases making the Country a Military Target. When China makes alliances with a Country, they build them a BRI (Road, Air, and/or Sea) making Trading Goods cheaper for the Country.

[@artplus3448]

@DrANZAC Spartan - What could go wrong? China is run by creatively engineers and America is run by ruthless lawyers.

[@janethankinson8849]

America & Australia’s human rights? What about Julian Assange’s and all the Aboriginal Australian children’s human rights????

[@abbotsful]

You literally used the words "what about". So, if australia's first nations people are suffering abuse it makes it ok to abuse the native people of Xinjiang? is that your logic? And, indeed, free Assange, and the Uighurs in detention, at the same time for the same reason.

[@janethankinson8849]

Really abbotsful??? Don’t try to manipulate my words. Is this your way of trying to make people look bad??? I simply reminded people of not to criticise others unless they themselves have not done any acts of what they are accusing others of. Very simple! That’s just being ‘Hypocritical’ to point the finger. Clean up our own home before lecturing others to do so.

[@abbotsful]

@@janethankinson8849 if you come to me, as you did, expressing concern about the genocide of the native people of Australia or the unlawful detainment of asylum seekers my response will not be ‘what about Hiroshima? What about Tibet??’ No, because I’m able to see that ethics are universal, not domestic. Frankly your dramatic reaction appears telling.

[@janethankinson8849]

@@abbotsful excuse you??? I did not ‘come to you’. Remember? You reacted to my comment in the first place. That’s really telling about you. Obviously I hit a nerve??? Are you attacking me because I am a women or an asian looking person??? Or are you a misogynist???

[@janethankinson8849]

@@abbotsful by the way, Hiroshima was bombed by the US. China has not attached any country in the world. Check your history. And I never mentioned anything about asylum seekers or even genocide. So again your the one assuming and delusional about what I wrote.

[@TY-ob7fz]

Thank you Daniel for your though provoking and inspirational words.

[@yqisq6966]

Oh wow at first I thought the sanction is just a part of the trade war and an attempt to disrupt the Chinese supply chain. But now after your insight it seems there could be far more synister motivation behind this.

[@jessicaw8682]

Hats off to Daniel for your great insights into the web of lies behind Xinjiang "genocide". If America really cared about human rights that much, it would have largely solved its domestic problems of racial discrimination and human rights violations, which are becoming worse.

[@bjkina]

The West doesn't care about people (slogans aside), only money (the moneyed elite) - that is the fundamental difference.

[@REDSUN-8]

The UN should investigate the human rights situation of American Indians. Why is India's population declining rapidly?

[@REDSUN-8]

@Shimmy Shai I made it very clear that American Indians

[@chrisck3405]

I am hoping that the pandemic will be easing soon so that I can take the silk road trip to Xinjiang.

[@mizuko2001]

Same here!

[@hinxlinx]

Thank you, Daniel, and not enough “thank you” to express my gratitudes for your efforts to speak out for Chinese people.

[@avil8686]

Clear and on point👍

[@kalekainxx]

How many countries that the USA has dipped their fingers in have been successful in the past 20 years?

[@itsoktolovechina]

Daniel, can you make a video of the sri lanken port?

[@normanvanrooy3113]

Thank you Daniel for doing this good work and journalism. I have learned not to believe MSM reports about anything and withhold judgment until I have a chance to listen to alternative sites such as yours and a few others.

[@pleiadesstarr453]

It's best you see and hear from all sides. 👍

[@maxsweetman6341]

Thankyou Daniel. America might not like the things you say but they need to be said Tr uth is something they find hard to absorb or spread they have been living a lie for far to long and it has hurt too many people. Americans need to stand back and take a good look at themselves maybe if they do that they will leave us all alone and sort out their many problems

[@blang7017]

I like Russia President Putin reply to a US reporter, "If you are ugly, don't blame the mirror". I could not stop laughing.

[@halfwaysleet]

This guy is most likely sponsored by the chinese communist party judging from his video history and how he constantly makes videos "exposing" youtubers that criticize the chinese communist party through digging dirt on them from 20+ years ago. All his videos follow the same pattern, its either anti US or pro China/CCP. After tribunals ruled that china is in fact genociding uyghers he stopped defending the genocide and focused on exposing these youtubers that criticize china (attacking them instead of their arguments)

[@johnli6782]

That last statement is particularly heart aching, as the mere mention of it means the circumstances that could give rise to it are palpable, yet there are gung-ho war mongers that appeared simply couldn't be stopped.

[@renochee5129]

Hope to meet up with you Daniel Dunbrill let's have a beer cheers bro. (Yam Seng!)

[@ZeroFate643]

Huge props to Prof. Hammond for speaking up on this. And you knocked it out of the park again with this guest lineup!

[@图光南岛剑种滞纳猪]

People believe in lies because they do not want to see other’s success

[@不动不静]

or they are scared because those propagandas utilize their deepest fear such as con camps, genocide, which really happened near them in history.

[@wnklee6878]

@@不动不静 Here is a docu about terrorism in Xinjiang kzbin.info/www/bejne/q2XGinhsepdqlck Hard to find and restricted by youtube

[@Shenzhou.]

It's a combination of the *Red Scare* (fear of communism) and the *Yellow Peril* (fear of Asians taking over the West) mindset that's driving the Westerners to think badly about China. Since the 19th century, Westerners have grown so throughly accustomed to the notion of Western dominance, so much such that the very thought of a non-Western, non-liberal democratic country like China eventually surpassing the United States someday in the future, is simply too frightening for many Westerners to fathom.

[@pastasoo]

When you've been on top of the world for so long, falling from such a height hurts.

[@mikemurray2027]

@@Shenzhou. You have hit the nail on the head.

[@JimmyChan9393]

Daniel, you are the man. Well said.

[@alliesteamc3546]

Thank you for your courageous commitment to truth! Your help is greatly appreciated! Many thanks!🙏

[@michael_o5746]

Thanks! Fantastic presentation!

[@longhairdolphin]

Really love him for his un bias thoughts and views. He never claimed CN is good or clean in all aspect. He only want to show us the other side of the equation especially Xinjiang related issues. Thanks.

[@SergioSammo]

China's propaganda machine is so strong internally as it is weak abroad, unfortunately. Without a radical improvement of Chinese diplomats' communication skills and better strategies against misinformation and fake news coming from the US, I fear China will be isolated in the upcoming years. One apparently small but in fact important example is the current policy towards international students applying to go study in China: there is no direct communication or official prospect on if and when foreign students will be allowed to enter in China (due to Covid-19), while all financial support for current foreign students enrolled in Chinese universities but stuck outside the country has been suspended. I talk from personal experience, as I am a student in a top level Chinese uni. Other countries are currently holding a similar stance (e.g. Australia), but their communication on the issue is so much better than China's, unfortunately, and they never stopped providing financial support for their full time students who are forced to study online due to Covid. While the appeal of Chinese universities was steadily growing in the past decade, I really think that the way the are handling this issue will be a powerful blow to their image and future ability to attract foreign students, with consequent damage to China's diplomacy and soft power. I'd be happy to be wrong, but Covid gave China's critics a very strong weapon and China is not doing the best work to deflect their attacks, in my opinion.

[@bjkina]

Yes, it is something that China does not do well. Even CGTN is wooden. But their biggest mistake would be thinking that the West is rational like themselves.

[@tonydark7626]

Well said! Lies r easy to received coz u don’t need brain to analyze it!

[@jenniferzhang864]

You are the best Daniel!

[@steventurner1002]

Aboriginal's in Australia's outback live in third world conditions - that is a fact. But the Australian Government uses the old out of sight out of mind. Or look over there (China).

[@ElCanalDelPadrino]

Amazing point of view

[@wolf-man-bear-pig-torque]

I'm kinda wondering now who the exact target audience is for this Xinjiang genocide propaganda. I read on Quora how the true target audience for HK's fiasco of 2019 was the Taiwan elections, and in a sense, it worked. So, with this Xinjiang story, there has to be something we're not seeing, like who is being influenced or would benefit from it?

[@ausreir]

Hmm...methinks its a deflection for Trump which got so out of hand, because it so inflamed the American public's imagination, that Biden had no choice but to continue. My guess is that it's primarily for domestic consumption.

[@wolf-man-bear-pig-torque]

@@ausreir hmm...there were other stories like the Covid lab leak thing that was more of a bigger thing for domestic audience. Most Americans still do not care or know enough about Xinjiang, so IMO, I don't think it's for domestic purposes. I've heard of other theories like it's to rally jihadists or disrupt the BRI programs, but if that's the case, I don't think it's working.

[@tweedy4sg]

Target audience is the western world whose market to which the bulk of China's exports go to. The hope here is to incite hate such that a voluntary boycott on Chinese' produce by ordinary people there and for western investors will shun China and have minimal or no business dealings with China. Another is the Muslim world particularly the Middle East region. US has seen how easily they can be galvanize and called into action(terror attacks) to infractions (real or perceived) towards their religion & fellow adherents, hence the strong emphasis on the word 'Muslim' it their official statements & speeches, and in narrative of their media.

[@mahbrum]

Pivot to Peace … what a great idea!!

[@bp455]

A great video, and a great call for re-thinking entrenched narratives about China. I'd like to add one more question: do the citizens of "democratic" countries know who really rule their countries? How come they vote for different candidates and parties, but the policies stay the same?Will they ever be able to influence their rulers like the Chinese citizens can influence theirs? I don't think so.

[@Lee-pf6od]

These are major issues in western politics, borne out of corruption. All political systems are vulnerable to corruption, thinking the CCP is immune is wishful thinking. It's also very hard to combat when you don't have freedom of speech. Do you agree the judiciary should be separate from the government? As I understand it, China's top judge Zhou Qiang implied it should not, which means justice is a secondary consideration. Can you tell me that will foster a corruption free leadership?

[@queenieseto9207]

What a delight to listen to a wise man talk

[@justaguy6216]

I love situation in the bookstore. Hahaha. The look of ridicule is just hilarious.

[@brianineedprep4530]

Well done. I too live in Shenzhen, and now you have me interested in visiting Xinjiang.

[@lelelelelelelelelek2936]

What a smart view !!

[@songlin1506]

Wow, it is so impressive. If it is a assignment, I believe the profesr would find it is really flawless. Amazing work!

[@unveiledeyes6558]

Keep speaking truth to power bro! You are awesome! U have interviewed people like Prof. Kishore and Max Blumenthal. May be you should talk with Chris Hedges too. Check out a recent KZbin upload by him "American Sadism". Chris is one of the few, like you, trying to speak truth to madness.

[@bjkina]

You can find that video here : www.beijingbuzzz.com/china-travel-guide-videos/the-five-eyes-psychosis-delusion-and-narcissism/ The downside of CH though is that he imagines that China must be the same in some ways without real experience and is decidedly dodgy in some of his generalisations.

[@unveiledeyes6558]

@@bjkina thx for the link, will check it out

[@unveiledeyes6558]

@@bjkina you are correct to point out inaccuracy of certain of Chris' views on China. That doesn't detract from the brilliant light he shed on the true darkness of the psychosis of America and Americans. That was wat I was trying to draw attention to. Thx very much 👍

[@jch9318]

Recently there were 40 countries that supported Canada's false claim of genocide in Xinjiang, just hopes people in those 40 countries would do what you ask and then voice out to their government to stop these fabrication of lies!

[@bv2011]

China is lucky to have you Daniel. They should give you the citizenship

[@bjkina]

Awesome - so on target and hitting all the points concisely and eloquently. I once (or twice) said Daniel is a waffler - but no more. This was perfect.

[@jelfrank286]

Where can we see Daniel’s interviews from his trip?

[@dust3955]

his youtube channel.

[@elvis20111116]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y5bdgXeaicefaac

[@revolution475]

Excellent work as always Daniel. Your delivery is impeccable. The language of human rights can be quite seductive, your level of clarity will untangle many from under the tapestry of lies told by the US and allies. The world must remember the Kuwaiti liar, she is a good precedent.

[@chrishannis1]

Well I'll be damned, Daniel's experience is a lot different from Sophia Yan's experience.

[@bjkina]

From her homepage : "Sophia regularly appears on the BBC World Service, and speaks at embassies, universities, and conferences worldwide. Prior to the Telegraph, she was a correspondent with CNBC, CNN, and Bloomberg, and has been based in Hong Kong, Washington DC, and Honolulu. She is a 2015 Abe Journalist Fellow, and currently serves on the board of the Foreign Correspondents' Club of China." Picture is clear ; )

[@dragade101]

With respects to filming in a bookstore; at least in the usa, amazon has gone into small stores that specialise in one or a few things. Say a kid's toy store. Amazon would itemise and build an inventory (at no direct cost to the shop and giving them some kind of ‘shortcut’ of doing business); then amazon carries similar or identical product and sell it to people based off of their location+interest (effectively squeezing that shop's patron base by incentivising patrons with cheaper prices). All of this is to say that the bookstore wants to protect its inventory from theft. Or that Time, one (if not the most) of the most expensive things, has gone into formulating that inventory. The owner has figured out what sells and what doesnt sell and amazon is taking it for a low low sum while gaining market traction in another sector. Just FYI.

[@xelkim9666]

It is tough having to prove oneself innocent when there are many fabricated stories made against one. Great job pointing out people could look for red flags and ask yourself again if there is any flaws in a statement/claim/evidence. 👍 thank you again Daniel

[@bjkina]

With all the 'shark jumping', they expose themselves.

[@davidkw9]

Daniel is the best... I am very convinced on whatever he reports...

[@hilarysexton1343]

Thank you Daniel. Excellent presentation. I am an Australian and suitably embarrassed by the positions taken our ignorant Prime Minister and his stupid sidekicks. I will try to vote him out next election.

[@ouronlyhome2462]

Thank you for telling the truth to the world.

[@ivanlee2861]

Daniel, you are my hero. Brave and eloquent.

[@Dovid2000]

Daniel is well-articulated, and has a God-given role in helping to explain China's case to the world. I disagree with him, however, when he insinuated in 8:39 that there are perhaps more atrocities in a single week with Israel vis-à-vis the Palestinian Arabs, when the Palestinian Arabs are those who actually rise-up against Israel, when Israel has not molested them, and then Israel is forced to defend itself.

[@MrLee4747]

D Ben, Ask yourself, will like to sacrifice your community by creating mayhem with the Bully , knowing that they gave no room for retaliation. The Palestinian got no choice, we were not there to find the truth, but it is obvious that the long suffering Arabs had no choice even with stones . What can we say on their behalf?

[@Dovid2000]

@@MrLee4747 On the contrary. The Palestinian Arabs can learn to live peaceably with Israel, just as Jews in Muslim countries learned to live peaceably with their host country. Jewish history in the Land of Israel (and which is also known as Palestine) goes back 3,500 years.

[@HKChineseCanadian]

@@Dovid2000 I have many Jewish and Muslim friends in Canada, so I have to be careful what I say. Israel has a right to defend itself but killing civilians and children is really sad. However the west doesn't make a big deal about Palestinian suffering but does about Uyghurs in Chinese reform schools.

[@Dovid2000]

@@HKChineseCanadian Well, I think that we're all saddened when innocent people (especially children) are killed in war. The Palestinian Arabs obviously didn't think about innocent Jewish men, women and children when they fired 4,700 rockets indiscriminately at Israel in 12 days of conflict. Sometimes when trying to kill the terrorists in Gaza, children were nearby and they fell in this conflict.

[@Dovid2000]

@@miachlmyersdonutz1344 It's true. They fired well-over 4,000 rockets during this last skirmish, and some of these rockets were intercepted by Israel's "Iron Dome," while others simply missed their targets and landed in open-fields. You are, obviously, uninformed, and you seem to praise ignorance.

[@kokboonshin4850]

Thank you Daniel for speaking out the truth

[@easyrecipesanddeliciousfoo2954]

😳😳😳😳😳

[@GrandeProjects]

Excellent talk, I will use this video to help me better inform people in my close circle of family and friends. I have experienced the difficulty in trying to convince people to accept even basic provable facts and information about China that is contrary to the main stream media, so my goal here is modest but still difficult.

[@Mattrsx]

Hahaha Daniel you're still so disingenuous....You specifically can't shed your bias, because that would require you to shed your entire "brand". You're mission is " how can I get my kids to be proud to be Chinese", and you've adopted a "west is bad" narrative from Max Blumenthal. Dude maybe take your dad's advice...

[@lukey08]

What kind of gibberish are you even talking about? Instead of providing factual evidence to back up your statements, you default to attacking someone's character and making assumptions about someone's motivations in life. You certainly sound a lot like someone who simply doesn't have any evidence to have a substantive argument or debate, and you are just been resentful that your own narrative and beliefs have been been undermined.

[@Sammyh54]

Do you have any legitimate arguments or facts, or are you just desperate and only capable of resorting to insults? So weak smh.

[@surajgiri4235]

Daniel you just earned one more follower here...

[@張乃方-q7k]

一個人必須要活的有良知，有人的靈性，才可以稱的上是一個真正的人，而 Daniel Dumbrill 你就是這樣的人！

[@migueldias8177]

Daniel if you started to film the books, where is that recording? Could you Share it please?

[@yingxu7908]

seventy years ago they label VietNam threat to their nation security and invaded VietNam。Since they repeatedly one after another till today they wanted to do the same thing。Most people，normal human can understand that

[@justinteh1148]

Another well argued, well reasoned and well articulated piece from Daniel. I follow all the China domiciled youtubers. I have to say I find this channel to be regularly the most well researched, substantive, cogent and persuasive.