Regarding Reciting Quran For a Deceased Person | Ask Shaykh YQ

[@mohamedshaniz4168]

He has become my favorite sheikh now. I see many criticism about him but wallahi no other sheikh on internet explains religious matters as detailed as him. He doesn’t speak for himself. He speaks with dhaleel . Jazzakaallah khairan sheikh

[@googooboyy]

Alhamdulilah. He’s the most academic english speaker that spreads the knowledge academically via various sources of knowledge n lets viewers expand their perception and understanding. But still do go back to ur local sheikhs for personal or matters close to home, as YQ may not have context of every person’s situation.

[@wellwisher2673]

Daleel. Not ‘Dhaleel’ Barakallhu Feek

[@Freepalastine-c3h]

I m happy jazakallah 4m your response. I used to gift it to my grand father. but when somebody said I cannot so I stopped .then one day I competed the recitation and I didn't gift then to my surprise my grandfather came to my dream .then after waking up from dream I gifted quraan

[@Sheen023]

Are you speaking the truth?!!! 😲😲

[@danishkhan-gp9mm]

@@Sheen023 100/ true when i completed Quran and gifted om that very same night saw dream my father was standing near by and listening it that dream was one of the healing after my father death and saddness

[@Sheen023]

@@danishkhan-gp9mm ❤️

[@eddiedann6472]

Mashallah!!! So middle of the road!!! At the end of the day it impacts on the Mercy of Allah swt. Allah is the All Merciful!!! May Allah Bless the Sheik!!! 😊

[@adamharunarashid8763]

Allahu Akbar, by Allah i like listening to you over and over again may Almighty Allah bless you with more of His blessings.

[@m.h4688]

May Allah bless you with more knowledge and wisdom. Ameen

[@googooboyy]

Beautiful, succinct yet detailed and deep analysis of many heavy Ulama of past. Gifting is a good deed, so Insyaallah our Amal and generosity is accepted.

[@njj4155]

Brother thank you I was so confused .now I can recite Quran and gift it with peace ,as some group called it bedath

[@seefarkhan]

As Salaam alaikum Please pray for the magfirat of my marhoom mother Farhath Jabeen. May Allah protect her from the azab of the qabr and azab of jahannam. May Allah bless her Jannatul Firdous and guide me n my family to meet her Ameen Sum Ameen

[@hunchokimosabi6536]

Amin

[@rameesaeram6926]

My father has passed away recently.i was confused about recitation of Quran as a sadqah.Thankyou for the informative video.

[@alisara1014]

Allah yerhamo 🤲

[@alyf_lam]

SubhanAllah, mashallah Sheik. Very knowledgeable and we'll explained answer. May Allah swt. Grant you more in this life and in the ahkirah. Ameen

[@sanyaimran9375]

Love the way this is explained in detail

[@rothna9323]

May Allah SWT bless you and grant you hayaatul Tayyiba; may we continue to benefit from your knowledge, ameen. I❤❤❤

[@hilly9114]

Mate this gold May Allah increase you shaykh

[@naveenmoeed9614]

Beautiful talk Dr. Yasir, JazakAllah kher. Also, when we physically give a gift to anyone with good intention that too is believed to be rewarded by Allah SWT then His currency indeed is endless wherein alongwith the deceased if He wills he shall reward the person reciting Quran Pak for the deceased as well and Allah SWT knows best. But a beautiful practice which unfortunately is being given up by so so many households in the subcontinent :( may Allah SWT guide us.

[@Stop1war]

Love you all the from Afghanistan.

[@salmaadam4272]

Dr Yasir thanks very informative..... جزاك اللهُ خيرًا 🌷💐

[@tahirrazak9744]

Brother JazakAllah Khair for the information. I am not a scholar but I have read and heard that there is no Hadith that mentions that gifting other things than what mentioned by the prophet (PBUH) permissible for dead. We are unnecessarily complicating our religion. Why we should we go after practices for which we take 30 mins to explain, give logic and references of imams and scholars. While there is an authentic Hadith which tells us exactly what should be done for a deceased. The main objective of the Quran is to understand, follow and spread (along with Hadith) its teaching. Which we have put on side and we got into practices of gifting the reading to deceased and more. Here is an Hadith we hear in every Friday prayer’s khutba. Jabir ibn Abdullah reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, would praise Allah in his sermon, as He deserves to be praised, and then he would say, “Whomever Allah guides, no one can lead him astray. Whomever Allah sends astray, no one can guide him. The truest word is the Book of Allah and the best guidance is the guidance of Muhammad. The most evil matters in religion are those that are newly invented, for every newly invented matter is an innovation. Every innovation is misguidance, and every misguidance is in the Hellfire.” Source: Sunan al-Nasā’ī 1578 May Allah give us hidayth to understand Quaran and Sunnah and apply in our life, and do good deeds while we are alive. Aameen. JazakAllah Khair kzbin.info/www/bejne/inbbnqWmlpeGedU

[@shirazhaniff7482]

Hi

[@Siriuslyyy]

I was taught that the gift of Good deed multiplies instead of getting subtracting from my book of deeds like sheikh mentioned.

[@FarhanaFaruq]

Jazak'Allahu-khair

[@jishancontractor2460]

Every doubt covered in a single video👍

[@DrAsmaZehra]

Assalamualaikum First time I am listening to this Shaikh. Lots of References of Senior ulemas. SubhanAllah. But He Doesn't focus much on Quranic ideology and Concept. Quranic instructions are guide for life.Dear Sister please read understand and follow Quran in your daily life And Allah will showcase ur good deed to ur parents. There is nothing like good deeds for urself and some good deeds for ur parents u being good is automatically a sawabe jaariya. You observe Hijab You Abstain from lies You Be good to others.

[@hmscc763]

Very nicely and elaborately answered. Jazakallh.

[@FULAN]

The basic principle concerning that is that acts of worship are forbidden; no act of worship should be done unless there is shar’i evidence to show that it is prescribed. Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning): “And obey Allaah and the Messenger” [al-Maa’idah 5:92] The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Whoever does anything that is not in accordance with this matter of ours will have it rejected.” What is prescribed is to say du’aa’ for the deceased, and to give charity on his behalf, as Muslim (1631) narrated from Abu Hurayrah (may Allaah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “When a man dies, all his good deeds come to an end except three: ongoing charity (sadaqah jaariyah), beneficial knowledge, or a righteous son who will pray for him.” Al-Nawawi (may Allaah have mercy on him) said in Sharh Muslim: "This indicates that the reward for du’aa’ will reach the deceased, as will that of charity. *As for reading Qur’aan and giving the reward for that to the deceased*, offering prayers on his behalf, etc, *the view of al-Shaafa’i and the majority of scholars is that this does not reach the deceased.*" The fatwa of the permanent committee and of shaykh al albani makes the most sense for anyone that looks into it, based on the principle mentioned earlier. The main crux of this video revolves around whether or not it is an innovation, yet shaykh YQ never brought an example of the companions or the tabieen ever donating their recitations to the deceased.

[@RB-fr1tg]

JazakAllahu khayran Shaykhna Very poignant and beneficial insha'Allah

[@MohammedLy2023]

I really enjoyed your lecture, as always. May Allah reward you more as you continue to feed us more ilm. It's eye opening especially the last part I had issues with, ikhtilaf from ulamaas. Most of our parents are practicing, which I've come to tell myself as long as my intention is Quran for the deceased there's no need for argument/ proving your point. Allah always knows best.

[@MB-id1uh]

This is a pertinent question

[@muhammadnazim2719]

Very comprehensive. Thanks for rectifying me.

[@MohammedLy2023]

Jazakallah kheir. Very informative. I was abit confused on the deceased issue.

[@Lula2020]

Mashaallah sheikh May Allah reward you❤️

[@bilalsidiqi3782]

MashAllah, may allah reward you for your sincerity and hard work inshAllah

[@shahidahmed1956]

Very knowledgeable and informative talk which one can excercise in daily life.

[@awesome997]

Alhamdulillah, at least Shaikh Y. Qadhi finally clarify the misunderstandings. Lesson for us, students graduated from Madinah University brainwashed by some respected Salafi shakhs and they go wild to label everyone else is deviant who differ with them however, when these students do further study outside Salafi prescribed books then they realize they were in ERROR. JazakAllahu Khair Shaikh Yasir Qadhi. Wassalamu Alaikum

[@asharhashir717]

Exactly Alhamdulillah

[@saidinmas]

Let me steal your money and I shall recite Qur'an as my charity or charitable gift to you in place of your stolen money. The Salaf was never that foolish okay.

[@Pain-jw3uu]

@@saidinmas the salaf didn't have low thoughts like the example you showed.

[@saidinmas]

@Aes Oup Since when did Imam Ahmed receive wahyi from angel Gabriel lol?

[@saidinmas]

@@Pain-jw3uu Similarly, the Salaf also never showed the example of gifting the reward of reciting the Qur'an to the deceased even though the Salaf could have very easily done so, right?

[@jehanabao5443]

Mashaa Allah...very well explained ..

[@thecallertotruth1121]

JazakaAllahu khairan sheykh

[@njj4155]

Jazak Allah

[@DeenLife]

اللهم صل و سلم و بارك على سيدنا محمد ❤☝️

[@handan5710]

Great topic, thank you

[@bazeera5520]

Jizakallahul khayran

[@kamilhakak8484]

MaShaAllah!

[@teijam10]

Not disagreeing with Sh .YQ but just asking opening that door means a bad person can end up with lots of reward on the day of reckoning without ever have intended to do good ? ....

[@ahmedc3227]

The shaykh mentions the verse in the Quran that only ones own deeds can save someone. The shaykh also mentions the hadith of ones good deeds stop except for 3. So when the person gifts a deed to the dead is it the dead persons deed or the gift givers deed because there seems to be a conflict.

[@ahmedc3227]

14:25 - part of dead persons deeds 15:56 - can no longer acquire his own deeds. So is it his deeds or not? Hope someone can clarify in sha Allah

[@muh316]

The deeds going to the dead person are a gift from the person giving them. They are the good deeds that the giver has earned. My understanding is those gifted deeds will add onto the deeds of the person who has died.

[@ahmedc3227]

@@muh316 But what about the verse where only ones own deeds will be held into account and not what another person has done. If it isn’t the dead person’s deed how would it count towards their deeds according to the verse.

[@AscendedBeyond]

@@ahmedc3227 They are not mutually exclusive brother. Once you gift a good deed to someone it's theirs's so it is as if they've done it.

[@seeker5313]

- اللّهم صلّ على سيدّنا مُحمد. 💛Quran recitations if you’re interested. 🕊 💛☁️🌿 👋🧡. 🤲🏻🤲🏻💙💙 💖

[@rasimuddinmd9190]

Excellent explanation. May Allah bless you! Please visit Indian state of Manipur.

[@abdullahsiddiqui9198]

Sheikh please can u make a video on how to make a perfect ghusl?

[@nufailanoon]

There are alot of videos about this, check them

[@zannatultithi6062]

Assalamualikum May I recite regular surah Yasin , Surah mulk on behalf of my deceased family members ?

[@flowerh691]

Salam Sheikh. Can you please make a video on anthropomorphism? I find it a huge fault in the salafi/ibn taymiya path. Its a very blasphemous concept and don’t understand how its being normalised and accepted.

[@KaiStrohscher]

Do you accuse Ibn Taymiyyah of anthropomorphism?

[@faysalahmed9157]

It's not blasphemous, because ibn Taymiyyah and others 'negate' Allah is like His creation. They read out what Allah says in the Quran in regards to Allah's attribute (i.e. Allah has hands) at the same time they negate from any resemblance of His creation. In other words It's like saying we know there is a reality but we don't know what this reality looks like (He is Not like his creation - Quran) Similarly when Allah is descending - they say Allah descends in a way that befits His majesty which is unknown to us.

[@conjugatemethod]

@@KaiStrohscher it’s well known that he was an anthropomorphist.

[@KaiStrohscher]

@@conjugatemethod But it is a false accusation - false testimony. Anthropomorphism is shirk. In Taymiyyah wasn't a mushrik. He never compared Allah with a human being.

[@KaiStrohscher]

Even his enemies did not claim. He was sent to jail, but if he committed shirk, they would execute him as a mushrik.

[@harisulaminu8117]

Masha Allah!!

[@famiroonhasnally195]

Wrong! You do not give away your deeds and left with nothing. You end up with multiples of the same deeds. Allah's blessings are in multiples. You must say, " Ya Allah convey this blessing also to such and such. Allah's blessing is undivided. It doesn't diminish. Wrong advise. But if you say, " Ya Allah send this blessing to such and such" is different. Then you do for that person and would be rewarded. Make your deeds multiples. Say convey the same reward to such and such. You

[@OlsoNounas]

Answer: 6:15

[@md.omarfaruqkhan3228]

Asslamualikum, Please let me know, how can I send any question ?

[@sobiahqureshi1342]

JazakAllah Khair. How do we send questions?

[@azraa7110]

Salaam from Nottingham Uk

[@aawezkhan561]

Sheikh was the purpose of revealing the Qur'an to gift the deceased?Coz we hav a large group of people only reading for the sake of gifting the deceased.And not understanding or Following.

[@mohammedsaifb4771]

I used to read quran like this but later on I started listening to salaf, their argument seems logical... These arguments only contributes more to the confusion.

[@sheikhmd.salman9692]

Wallahi the salaf's aren't mainstream. they are here to misguide us.

[@mohammedsaifb4771]

@@sheikhmd.salman9692 I have benefitted a lot from them, the concept like even tawheed is misguided in India, people go and seek help from auliyas in grave(I used to Do that too). Bcz of wahabis I could rethink it, but they seem so ober exaggerated at times.

[@sheikhmd.salman9692]

@@mohammedsaifb4771 I can't comment on present time Auliyas ... however the traditional Auliyas were the best of men and their tasawwuf was recognized by Alems of the highest calibre. The Salafi Wahabis disregard tasawwwuf

[@Pain-jw3uu]

Always be at the middle path brother. Never go to extremes. When you study more and more from both sides you become more humble. Don't just stick to one side which is dangerous and we can see it in the salafis. The message is good but the people you know.

[@mohammedsaifb4771]

@@sheikhmd.salman9692 actually you can comment, how do we even know a person is wali of allah, we don't, will the person himself know it, allahu a'lam, Also if you study the Serra of prophet you will know among few idols placed in kaba were of pious men...initially peopel made it recognize them, they committed shirk themselves... My iman is not so strong but wallahi I fear allah enough to be scared about committing shirk by giving some twisted interpretation. Muhammed(sws) is my guide and he is enough. He never said seek help from wali

[@Freepalastine-c3h]

Is it not like someone offer me dates for iftaar. He gets my fasting reward but my reward of fasting is mine !

[@shamimhuq4141]

I feel, the sheikh is saying Quran khaani, done in the Indo Pakistani community is okay to do.

[@tayyibriaz528]

Not really

[@SafaRaghib]

He has said on a separate occasion (the video he mentioned at the start of this stream) that while he personally does not conduct such events, people should be understanding and respectful of people who do conduct Quran khaanis because, in and of itself, reciting the Quran can never be considered shirk because it is directly from Allah. Even though Quran khaanis are technically a new concept, people individually doing good deeds to benefit a deceased person was done since the time of the Prophet SAWS. So as long as both sides are respectful of the others opinion and don't shame the other opinion, especially on such tragic occasions, then we will avoid unnecessary conflict in our ummah

[@shamimhuq4141]

@@SafaRaghib my question is , that is it okay to do that? I am not saying we should shame others. Simply is it okay to engage In such rituals.

[@hamzamasud1]

@@shamimhuq4141 yes he is saying it’s ok to do. Not that you must do it

[@SafaRaghib]

@Shamim Huq I wasn't implying you were 😅, I was just summarizing his other video. In short if you don't do it, no need to start doing it, but if your family already does it then sure do it. Just try not to be strict about times and amounts eg "it must be done before three days" or "everyone has to read one para" or "we have to finish the Quran" etc because there's really no ruling for this sort of thing, just have the books out and whoever wishes to read may read as much as they want.

[@ansarak8860]

Subhan allah

[@ferhatovic86]

I dont see an issue with gifting quran readings to our deceased but what about when this is done specifically on day 7, day 40...1 year...does this become more ritualistic? I heard is that it is fine to do every now and then but becomes bidah when its organised in such a manner and i know of people to get upset with those who do not help with quran readings or kalimas for the deceased those days.

[@Siriuslyyy]

Sheikh you say it's unprecedented to prohibited this act, but you mention One of the four imams prohibiting it.

[@badboyxx99]

Mashallah. I have been taught by scholars when I was little that when a family member dies you can read Quran and gift the deceased . Or pray Yasin or any Surah form Quran and gift them. I just want to get a clarification if this is acceptable .

[@Sam-ze3vw]

Sure you can. Alhamdulillah

[@badboyxx99]

@@Sam-ze3vw I would like to know from the sheikh

[@Sam-ze3vw]

Hi, you mentioned that you learnt from Scholars and they used to do that on the deceased and so do i. what makes you think that he knows better then the Scholars

[@ashrafm7435]

In our places calling themselves as salafis telling it is better talking any other thing than reciting quran in front of mayyith no benefit to mayyith as per them

[@shahidahmed1956]

Ya shaykh. What is your opinion regarding recitation of Sura Yasin which is very common at the funerals and deceased????

[@Hippieheyhey]

Jzkk alhamdulillah. I have a very very hard time understanding those who say that reading Qur’an as a gift to the deceased is not needed/allowed/accepted. I mean, why negate the recitation of Qur’an?!

[@Freepalastine-c3h]

Can one quraan is gifted to all our deceased cousins grandfather grandmother ,uncles ?one quraan to all

[@Sb1784]

She said she can't offer anything except reading the Quran , that mean she is poor can't offer any charity or any of the other

[@sarahkim3542]

Allhamdurella

[@rizwanbislam]

If a person missed his prayer? Then can we pray?

[@sanjabegovic729]

If only children can gift parents with reading Quran, what about those that don’t have any children? I know it is opinion by some but still what would be the answer?

[@mikk3150]

You can perform good deeds on behalf of someone else, like making charitable donation in their name, reading Quran etc

[@Freepalastine-c3h]

Is it like iftaar we also get reward ?

[@sanjabegovic729]

@@Freepalastine-c3h ?

[@soheimapetersen6365]

Please explain this... one of the questions that would be ask when u in ur grave would be who was ur imam the Quran ofcourse right so tell me the quraan was send down to guide the living to benefit for the living to guide them how will it benefit the dead? If the quraan is a guide to the living

[@saeedzafar7041]

Sheikh, in one of your videos you said that you are a junior member of some Mufti board which has dozens of muftis from many countries. What is the name of this board? Is there a website for this board of muftis? Thank you.Please keep up the good work.

[@hirasheikh6201]

Question: What about the concept of a collective finishing of a good deed for the deceased or sick or a dua to be accepted? Like assigning every person a certain juz' or 10 repetitions of a certain phrase of dhikr in order to complete something?

[@bilals1279]

This is bidah we must avoid. See Sheikh Assim Hakims and Islamqa response to this.

[@AbdulMajeed-gk3vd]

Hira Sheikh Yes as long as they are reciting quran, it is allowed InshaAllah.

[@bilals1279]

@Aes Oup My friend Sheikh Assim Hakim is among those who follow the way of the salaf. He does not speak except by the Quran, Hadith, the sahabas and the rightly guided successors. Sheikh Al Islam Ibn Taymiyyah one of my heros may Allah bless him, was not a sufi please do not use this label. Study who Ibn Taymiyyah was through the giant scholars like Ibn Uthaymeen, and Ibn Baaz and not people with little knowledge.

[@فهيم-ن6و]

@Aes Oup Saudi Scholars 😂 Who think sun rotates around the earth. I've never seen a single scholar from Saudi Arabia in a debate 😂

[@فهيم-ن6و]

@Aes Oup You have literally ended his career :D

[@YouTubeYouTube-qg6vl]

People read 22 surah from 114 surah that holyQuran have in some part of the world

[@ashfakabdulla9800]

But what about giving money to imams for reciting quran for deceased

[@TheQuran-TheSunnah]

I have few questions: What about the verse of the Quran that says a person can have nothing except what he does. If gifting good deeds is like gifting money then Why Prophet peace be upon him said to his daughter Fatimah may Allah be pleased with her "ask me anything from my wealth but I can't save you from punishment of Allah" why didn't Prophet peace be upon him gift his good deeds to his daughters. Also When Prophet peace be upon him was asked that why do you worship Allah alot when Allah has forgiven all your sins? Prophet peace be upon said I want to thank Allah. He didn't say that I want to gift some of my good deeds to my family and ummah and want to thank Allah. No doubt the person who love us more than anyone is Prophet peace be upon him yet he didn't gift any good deeds. Why??? Because you can't gift good deeds.

[@kai12490]

I think gifting deeds only applies to the dead, so Fatimah wouldn't be eligible for the prophet's good deeds.

[@TheQuran-TheSunnah]

@@kai12490 you didn't understand what I said if gifting is allowed then it doesn't matter whether you gift to dead or living and if for sake of argument I agree with you then Prophet peace be upon him would have done it after her family members passed away. He didn't do for his first wife nor for his uncle Hamza may Allah be pleased with him who sacrificed his life for Islam and many more.

[@TheQuran-TheSunnah]

@Aes Oup @Aes Oup First thing is it is not Proven from Quran and Sunnah and second thing is there are scholars on other side as well who say that you can't gift your good deeds like Shaykh Albani etc. I want to know why Prophet didn't gift his good deeds to his loved ones. He used to worship Allah alot. Allah has forgiven all his sins yet he didn't gift his good deeds.

[@TheQuran-TheSunnah]

@Aes Oup Ok. So tell me which companion of Prophet did it.

[@TheQuran-TheSunnah]

@Aes Oup Why Prophet didn't gift his good deeds. He knew Allah will grant him Jannah yet he didn't gift. Why???

[@nm6823]

If we ask any question in how many days we get answer for our question?

[@shifeq9770]

Can you give reference for ibn taymyya

[@jariachin69]

So, if you gifted the quran recitation, dzikir or infaq/wakaf to your deceased family or friends, does Allah still reward you on your effort, good intention or even being a filial children or spouse?

[@mikk3150]

yes

[@saidinmas]

@@mikk3150 Since when did you receive wahyi lol.

[@mikk3150]

@@saidinmas Is there a point to this comment of yours? If you're doing a good deed and wanting to gift that reward to deceased relative, it's not going to decrease your reward in the slightest.

[@saidinmas]

@@mikk3150 Yes, there is a point that "doing a good deed and wanting to gift that reward to deceased relative, it's not going to decrease your reward in the slightest" is an innovation deserving hellfire which was never done by the Salaf even though the Salaf could have very easily done so, right?

[@mikk3150]

@@saidinmas No it isn't. You salafis brand everything bidah. Doing good deeds on behalf of the dead is proven. Charity etc Every good deed is an act of charity.

[@MK..1558]

I see the Qur'an as a book of guidance and shifa for the living not a gift for deceased

[@nourinnahar1988]

Someone please give the link of the barzakh series on what to do for the deceased?

[@truthseeker185]

kzbin.info/aero/PLYZxc42QNctVw0HhfP7N02hNlScC-3UhN Asa this is the link for the full series. 10 videos in total. Number 8 and 9 deal with what we can do for the deceased. It’s an excellent series from yq and if you have time , listen to the full series.

[@FarhanaFaruq]

​@@truthseeker185 Jazak'Allahu-khair

[@johnnyshoesofthetwo7374]

Call a spade, a spade. No point, leaving teasers and innuendos.

[@gen2208]

How to ask questions

[@asam6557]

I HAVE AN EMERGENCY CHILDREN HAVE BEEN TAKEN AWAY FROM THEIR MOTHER IN UK PLEASE HELP

[@MominurSekh-we7mc]

Assalamualaikum

[@Muriqa]

To which email should I send my question?

[@zah1238]

[e-mail]

[@rohullahosmani2287]

what about gathering and every individual get Juzz and recite it? your not steed fast on your own speech your saying a part of salaf say this and you back again say that it is the best way to follow salaf?

[@nourinnahar1988]

What about reading Quran for sick people?

[@K-balance28]

Allah bless support help forgive protect succeed uplift enhance love us all so we become sadaqa jaariya /charity for humanity human beings nature & future generations regardless race religion culture nationality colour. Ameen

[@abdullahsiddiqui9198]

السلام علیکم sheikh

[@Sb1784]

Why don't you answer straight the questions???

[@WHYISEVERYHANDLEALREADYTAKEN9]

TLDR? I have adhd😭

[@rohullahosmani2287]

Try to be short and clear to your talks

[@basirujallow7750]

I have heard that i should not trust or i should be aware of this man here YASIR QHADIR. I dont know him well and am not judging him either... All i know base on what he is saying it is all good... And i also want to put in my list of scholers that i listen to... and i need advise Regarding this since we all know that we are in a state of confusion

[@Zunaid-h4f]

Brother He is a great scholar of Al - Islam . Many other scholars wrongly accuse him of being a deviant . But If you truly see his videos , You will end up being his student . May Allah guide us to the path of ilm .

[@Sb1784]

Talking too much for answering simple question????????

[@syedmasif8873]

He is only quoting from the scholars of schools of thought. He never quoted anything from Prophet PBUH and His Companions. The opinions of the scholars of school of thought is not a valid evidence. The only acceptable evidence is Qur'an and Sunnah (Authentic Ahadith). The Prophet PBUH already mentioned a list pf permissible acts that could be done to send reward to the deceased. The Prophet PBUH said: "There is nothing by means of which one may draw close to Paradise and move far away from Hell but it has been explained to you" [As Sahiha 1803] Based on what Prophet PBUH said, anything that could lead towards paradise is explained by him, but sending the reward of Quran to deceased is not mentioned or explained by him in any authentic ahadith, hence that will be considered as innovation in Islam. Abdullah ibn Umar RA said: "Every Innovation is Misguidance, even if the people consider it to be something good" [Itiqaad Ahle Sunnah Lalikai 126, Hasan]

[@YtoV-j8q]

Where do you think that the scholars who derived these rulings from the 4 legitimate schools come from? The Torah?

[@shuhanamin677]

But isn't it a Bid'ah then?

[@relaxchill9114]

The simple answer for this question is follow The Prophet if The Prophet never done it Don’t do it simple as that.

[@muhammadnazim2719]

Very comprehensive. Thanks for rectifying me.