Yellowstone Fans Shook By the 1883 Finale Tribute

[@niemoikein4330]

What I loved most about 1883 was the poetic storytelling. I am a grown man and happy I’ve been watching this show alone so no one could see my tears. It was a beautiful journey with a very sad ending.

[@Lisa-tt9hm]

Every time I watch it 😂

[@sfirf]

4:51 ​@@Lisa-tt9hm

[@notta3d]

Just watched all 10 this weekend. I'm not joking when I say I'm a grown ass man and I was balling my eyes out. At one point I almost had to turn it off in the last episode knowing what was coming.

[@noomwa]

Hell, I was straight ugly crying. Beautifully acted and wonderful story telling. Gut wrenching as much as it was hopeful.

[@danroffee4904]

Remind me not to get to attached to the oldest child of whoever starts the TV series 1932

[@TasteofCountryMusic]

No joke!

[@Diddley_Squat]

Haha

[@Benellismama]

I totally agree

[@jaminegender5748]

Yep the curse is real. Lol

[@Ideo7Z]

Annnnd it happened lol. 1923 The tradition continues... It's like the oldest Dutton kid is Kenny from South Park reincarnated.

[@DrumLord316]

Out of all the prequel shows possible, an 80s/90s show with Lucas as young JD is what I want the most

[@Rambaldichick]

YES!!! I want more Josh Lucas as JD. Thank you for mentioning it.!👍

[@Benellismama]

I agree 💯

[@Diddley_Squat]

Same.

[@bencjr]

watching Elsa die, emotional almost destroyed me. I lost a daughter yrs ago. that was brutal.

[@Fishbabies]

J B, I'm so very sorry to hear you've lost a daughter. I hope her memories warm your heart!! ❤️🙏

[@bencjr]

@@Fishbabies thank you

[@standartenfuhrerhanslanda343]

So sorry for your loss. My daughter beat cancer and any scenes depicting a father losing a daughter kill me inside. This show hit a nerve. I can’t imagine your pain.

[@nancysmith1596]

Yes I did to I lost a daughter and granddaughter.

[@MegaBpop]

Ma’m I am deeply sorry. I have seen my mom burry two of her sons. I will keep you in prayers for comfort and peace.

[@tommywilliams5140]

Oh little Elsa. What a sad ending. Felt a tear roll down my cheek

[@nikeisagreekgoddess4135]

In Season 4, Beth is back home after the terrorist attempt against her life. She is in the porch, with a shotgun and just blew the shit out of a wind chime. The scene then shows a bird that was singing and captured Beth's attention. The little rascal read the room and took off, to which Beth replied "Smart bird". I'm just saying dude...lol

[@Pop_Shepski]

You thinkin Beth is gone this season?

[@shaun.yasalonis]

This is a great example of why I love rewatching shows & movies! I jumped out of my seat pointing like ELSA! when I watched this again after 1883 lol

[@jacquelinestump8607]

She was excellent actress she had me crying I wished I could’ve seen her grow more. This was a excellent story

[@flashtech6492]

has to be one of the Best Westerns I've ever seen...and the girl that played Elsa she is Fantastic..!!!

[@lisajohn1426]

I was hysterical 😢 I know it's a show..but I was a mess😊

[@katmurphy9225]

If you watch the episode when they all go to watch Jimmy ride, John says the correct line about “ that’s thing about problems, they will still be problems tomorrow” ( not sure if I quoted it exactly) to the lady governor. I recognize it bc I watch the Yellowstone episode when they had a marathon and later that night watched 1883 with the line and thought “ how cool they put a saying from Yellowstone and now it is not just a John saying but a Dutton family saying.

[@bowtoyoursensei554]

There are several instances where that happens. I won't be surprised if it happens again in1923. Family sayings get passed down through generations just like everything else.

[@meganconnell-cox6425]

If you remember, in Yellowstone, one of the last episodes (the one they are pushing the cattle for the branding and Summer is left on the ranch to walk it/discover it/learn about it) and Monica keeps showing up in different spots to encourage/teach her....when Summer discovers the family cemetery, the first gravestone is that of Elsa. She remarks on the age of the ranch/time the family has owned the land and we see the gravestone marking.

[@meganconnell-cox6425]

✌

[@MegaBpop]

Yep x season 5 episode 6. Thank You for the tip.

[@pambarlow3945]

I have never been as angry at the ending of any TV show as the 1883. Elsa was one of the most unique characters. The young woman who played her did it to perfection. You need to figure out a way to bring her back.

[@ARCtrooperblueleader]

I’m right there with you.

[@Rambaldichick]

I totally understand. I was angry too. I think I just stopped crying a couple days ago. I do feel a lot better though, now that I know it was a limited series. I would've been pissed if there was a season 2 of 1883. Now, it's like, Here. This is a story about an extraordinary young woman (played by an extraordinary young woman). This is how she lived. This is how she loved and this is how she died. It's actually kinda beautiful. What I'd like, is for Taylor Sheridan to maybe show flashbacks in the new spinoff 1932. So, we can see more of James and Margaret (Tim and Faith) and how the ranch came to be. But it's still a different show. 1883 was Elsa's story. It simply couldn't continue without her. Just my opinion.❤️

[@paulmoss7940]

@Josh Traffanstedt yup, was easy to see she was dead from that wound.

[@357clinger]

@Josh Traffanstedt There’s also Dream Sequences. So?

[@deebee4575]

But the show is over. How would they bring her back?

[@frankfarlner9360]

Wow, Taylor Sheridan just pointed out James Dutton was John Dutton great great great grandfather. So the lines has to rest with the one and only SPENCER!!!! YEAH!!!🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@Rambaldichick]

I love it when Taylor Sheridan intentionally draws parallels between the two shows. I have never gotten chills during a TV show the way I did at the end of episode 8 of 1883 when Elsa says "And God is the land." Remembering Beth saying the same thing in Season 3.....chills.

[@Ace1King1]

chills spills and daffodils

[@Diddley_Squat]

Should have had the cook make it to the Dutton ranch, and 9ne of his family members could have been the livestock agent.

[@jackkarns2484]

In 1923, Episode 1, I recall the lead sheep farmer also saying that the land belongs to God, not man. He addressed this remark to Jacob Dutton as the locusts & drought had resulted in both cattle and sheep owners looking for new grass land to use or lease.

[@meganconnell-cox6425]

watch 1923 and the Native girl at the end of episode 4, I think it is, when she does what she does to the evil nun....chilling parrellelism

[@rfwomon]

Nice job. I just watch and let the feelings wash over me. And have my own opinions, that could change if I am reminded of something else. I just love Yellowstone, love 1883 more, and probably will love the new episodes and shows better. I love Wind River. I love, love, love, Woman Walks Ahead. Graham Green has been an idol to be for decades, along with Tantoo Cardinal. Discovering Michael Greyeyes on WWA was a treat. Gil Birmingham always surprises. Mo Brings Plenty is a new addiction. Seeing Native peoples on screen, reading Alexi Sherman and Louis Erdrich and other Native writers over the years just fills in a world that seemed so false as we learned it. Coming upon the Rumble, The Indians Thank you Kevin Costner for trusting your visions and being such a fine actor and showing the works a Whitney in the magnificent Bodyguard.

[@williamcabell142]

When is the 6’s going to be aired? That’s the one I am looking forward to.

[@Diddley_Squat]

It's just gonna be the gay cop from sons of anarchy crackin jokes for 12 episodes straight.

[@susanshaw7592]

Great cast chemistry

[@bigheadrhino]

I feel like 1883 to 1923 skips over the most interesting part of the history which is how the Ranch got so big. 1903 with a young Jacob Dutton anyone?

[@commonsenseisntcommon1776]

Elsa is gorgeous! Such a sad ending!

[@patriciaray7472]

Where to get her hat. I like it

[@Paulg13456]

Sorry for your loss.

[@danroffee4904]

Also, the Dutton family tends to have strong-willed daughters that fall in love her daddy's hired-hand cowboys, think and act outside lady-like norms.

[@Diddley_Squat]

Beth will die from being shot in the liver by Jamie.

[@ronniebots9225]

@@Diddley_Squat if that means beth will oblitterate Jamie first like Elsa did with the Indians, then its fine and poetic.

[@natahsasaez9100]

Yep u gave me the chills like really

[@leonnamarie1717]

also when lee died the bird that landed by him was yellow, I'm sure its just a coincidence but sam called elsa lighting with the yellow hair, so it just makes me think that the bird was elsa

[@markneal5673]

Taylor worked on Sons of Anarchy. They used birds in it also and also there was death involved.

[@vlofvl]

Why is there nothing marking Elsa’s resting place, it seems a family like the Duttons would have cherished and respected their family graves throughout each generation

[@Pop_Shepski]

They did. Just older clips of the gravesite are different names because the writing hadn’t come into itself yet

[@TheRedWolf43]

“It’s like poetry, it rhymes” George Lucus on writing Star Wars and the prequels

[@larrywiggin3489]

At 81 years that was a gut punch, must be getting soft in my old age, that young lady has played the part to perfection, I don’t like sad endings, but that’s life especially these days!

[@357clinger]

Think it’s well established that James is John (Kevin Costner’s) Dutton Great Grandfather. But who’s James’s father & mother? Orphan is the only possibility And I was surprised nobody picked up on Yellowstone that his dying father said he missed his brother and mother! Probably just like real life today that people don’t listen to our elderly or blame dementia and are ignored ! Personally I found 1883 had more than a little of “Lonesome Dove “ inspiration and storyline and just straight up plagiarism And it’s based on the true story of the real men who drove cattle from Texas to Montana! And they really filmed In all the locations and without green screens! Wish I knew how to put together a comparison video together though someone will And it will always be my favourite western and series 💜💜💜

[@melissamci5592]

Great great great grandfather

[@Diddley_Squat]

James is John Dutton father, and also john duttons great great great grandfather. I'm sure he's related to a couple more john Duttons somewhere

[@Benellismama]

James and Margaret have John. John married Emma who have Jack. Jack married Elizabeth who have John Sr John Sr who married and has our John Dutton. John marries Evelyn who has Kayce. Kayce married Monica and have Tate. Tate is the 7th generation.

[@jamesknox7171]

Something I just realized that you didn't point out is that both Elsa and Lee were killed at the hands of an Indian.

[@romy4858]

Sorry I couldn’t make out Elsa was saying before she died. Could someone please tell what did she say. My hearing is not so great

[@donaldrainer7974]

Again, in the interview with Taylor Sheridan, he says that James is John's (Keven Kostner) Great-Great-Great Grandfather. Yet in, what I believe to be, a decent Family Tree that shows James to be John's Great-Great-Grandfather. Making Tate the 7th Generation of the Dutton's if James is considered Generation 1. Thoughts?

[@thesir1237]

With 1923 currently airing, it's been pretty much stated that it goes James - John Sr - Jack - John 2 - John 3 (Kevin Costner) - Kayce - Tate

[@meganconnell-cox6425]

The character played by James Badge Dale (in 1923) is the same character that Audie Rick played in 1883. According to his timeline he would be 45. His character fits that timeline. Spencer is James's other son. He's the WWI vet hunting in Africa. He was the younger son in that flashback on Yellowstone when James comes home, has been shot, and dies. Spencer looked to be about 6 years old. That would mean he was born in 1887. That would make him about 35-36 years old. Here's what we learned (in Elsa’s narrative in the first episode of 1923): Margaret wrote to Jacob (Tim McGraw’s older brother) for help after James died. A year later, when Jacob arrives in Montana, he finds her dead. He said he got to Montana in 1894. In the narration, Elsa says that of Margaret and James' three children, only one would live to see their own children. That only one carried on the family name. And that would be John (James Badge Dale), the father of Jack (the nephew on 1923 that Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren are caring for) who is the one getting married (to Elizabeth). Jack eventually becomes Kevin Costner's grandfather. Which means the Dabney Coleman character will be Jack's son. 1. James 4. John II (Dabney Coleman) 2. John 5. John III (Kevin Costner) 3. Jack 6. Kayce 7. Tate: Half Native American and a member of the Broken Rock tribe. Thus, fulfilling Spotted Eagle's prophecy that in 7 generations the Native Americans would own the land again.

[@Ashley_e]

@@meganconnell-cox6425 because the cast has been begging to know the family line, there seems to be a swerve coming. Spencer’s child being Kevin’s grandfather would be super interesting. May be a family secret.

[@JTWaylon]

John Dutton tells Carter and the Buffalo Valley on his ranch that his great grandfather in 1889 told the United States Army they were not there. He then said that his great grandfather and his grandpa push them into the national park. I’m taking that as James Dutton Tim McGraw‘s character is another reason to show that that’s his great grandfather. Tate is the seventh generation.

[@Benellismama]

I agree

[@Pop_Shepski]

John Sr is actually his great grandfather and James is Great Great

[@Benellismama]

Would love to see a series with the origins of OUR Yellowstone family

[@welldang6448]

I don't think Kayce's vision was about the end of the Duttons but the end of him and Jaime. The chief's claim comes true, but Tate is still a Dutton.

[@mikehaynia4776]

What if Elsa is there? What if Elsa is buried perpendicular to the gap in the trees behind them? That space lines up perfectly with the space between her family.

[@nicolina1026]

You can see her gravestone in season 5 episode 6 and again in 1923.

[@audreyamedei]

Amazing insight.

[@Lisa-tt9hm]

It was common to lose children during this time period.

[@cindybogart6062]

I can’t follow this show when it changes around so much.

[@courtney5150]

Elsa says smart bird when she dies. Beth says smart bird just after she shoots the wind chime and sits down and a bird lands near her while still holding a shot gun

[@fazefarcry]

Now that I saw season five of Yellowstone, it is stated that John Dutton‘s brother was still born

[@ronniebots9225]

not sillborn but a weak heart. he lived for 18 hours on his mothers chest. He stated so that he had a brother for 18 hours and they could not help him and layed him on his mothers chest then the doctors hoped and the family prayed.

[@pgrgr3443]

I was hoping Elsa dying wasn’t true & was a bad nightmare

[@SFDearing1]

The circling birds were buzzards Billie Dukes...not hawks. Buzzards always portend death.

[@John-ev3rm]

Words, words, words, the simple fact of the matter is that Sheridan screwed up killing off the main protagonist regardless of his reasons just like Game of Thrones did killing off the Dragon Queen or how Titanic did killing off Jack Dawson, or Saving Private Ryan killing off Tom Hanks. Fans never like these surprises yet idiot movie makers still do it to make some bizarre and estranging philosophical point, but when most fans don't like it, it's just bad writing plain and simple.

[@romy4858]

Wait for the rain to soften the earth, I just thought that was so small

[@patrickkelly9721]

It's a TV show, not a documentary.

[@xsammyx101x]

Lee was missing from all the Dutton family photos throughout the Yellowstone series.

[@jessedavis7555]

Lee deserved more airtime

[@tinytinytimyall]

Why does the intro guitar strum sound like it was sampled from Diablo?

[@JEWELALEE]

I was upset that there was no indication of where Mom and her son were.

[@coryveach9242]

And they both say let’s seat A while when they get to the cemetery

[@jakeg7472]

What does kacey even say?? I’ve watched 30 times can’t even tell what he says

[@JTWaylon]

He said: I saw the end of us...

[@katgibson3711]

Uhm...Dave Annable (It's not pronounced anna-bell, it's anna-bull) was on Brother's and Sister's for like 5 seasons.

[@gerald2074]

It's a good story line. A lot can be done with it

[@epo1980]

No. The story is perfect this way. This is not 'Dallas'...

[@kenn1936]

I noticed the birds appearing at the death of Elsa and at the other scene.

[@kimmiesmith7618]

And has no one take notice that it's the same tree that each family member are laid to rest under.

[@mikeh7153]

I don't think Elsa is dead. John Dutton said his family is buried on his ranch starting in 1886 with his great x3 Grandfather.

[@tjjordan4207]

What if the prophecy of the land being taken back is hinting that Tate will end up getting the land, as he is part Indian, and uniting both the Duttons and the Reservation together.

[@Diddley_Squat]

He won't unite, he'll give the land to the tribe.

[@jackkarns2484]

Interesting thought.

[@carryoncrimecarryoncrime2458]

You are wrong about the generations if James is the first of the generation the little boy John is the second John Dutton senior is the third John Dutton would be the 4th kayce Dutton would be the 5th and taped Dutton would be the 6th so until take or one of the other grandchildren has a child the 7th generation has not been born

[@kellynoble-putt4134]

Not quite Between James son John and John Sr (Dabney Coleman) is Jack Dutton (see 1923 show). So Tate is 7th generation: James, John, Jack, John, John, Kayce, Tate

[@kathyrogowski1512]

The ranch goes to Tate and Tate is 7th generation

[@kjiggidy5719]

He’s the eighth generation…..Taylor, if not writers, have already said that Kayce is the seventh generation so….

[@drebelanski7869]

@@kjiggidy5719 Tate is also half Native. If It goes to him then they have gotten the land back.

[@lindamountford4668]

There is a new baby too

[@franztonl]

Tate is only the 5th generation: James Dutton > John Dutton I > John Dutton II > John Dutton III > Kacey > Tate

[@zatrixwarrior9022]

i thought Johns father said "I miss your Mother"? not brother....

[@lindadunn5707]

I meant 1883 not the other year I wrote sorry folks, I better get it right or I might get shot up my backside lol 😆 love you all millions ❤ 😘 💕 on this film its just bloody amazing well done you all over & out your Vivid fan Linda again xxx

[@billmadison2032]

First things first I want to see Yellowstone continue without Kevin Costner. That being said I'm all for seeing something in the mid 20th century with John taking over

[@pixie2714]

Annable was on Brothers & Sisters for 5 seasons😂

[@nicholastanton8404]

Really... She must have been very young. I need to go check that out. Not sure I watched all the seasons of that show.

[@PatriciaM64]

Elsa is now with Ennis!

[@heatherday6765]

1883 was messed up when they killed off Elsa and Shea. The entire series was good up until the very last episode. Taylor could have wrote it in such a way that he could have added a second season. However, he claims he thought Paramount only wanted one season. Why would a network want a SERIES with only one season? Why make it a series then? Just do a movie🤷🏼‍♀️

[@mcsniper77]

I only get great grandfather. James, John, John jr.,John III. What am I missing?

[@benjaminlopez2159]

I need to know too, I don't understand why great great great grandfather, I only get to great great

[@Diddley_Squat]

Its a big family with a lot of people over several generations. Seems john is a family name

[@rogercarvalho2675]

I believe there is a Jack Dutton in between.

[@imscanon]

Wait, if the two Duttons died in 1860, how are they buried at the ranch they didn't have until 1883? Did they go dig them up and bring them to Wyoming?

[@dave8059]

Elsa was a main character and the narrator for the series. There was no need to kill her off!!! Bad decision Taylor! Bad! Bad! Bad! I'm done with the series.....and so are many that I know!

[@sheilakapp2843]

I know like the saying the problems will still be there .so is the saying do not say never or done coz you mite see that the new coming will shine just as brite and you see why it ended as such . Them you and the others who just want every thing go there way have to eat there words . Like life to me yea it sucks when someone dies we wish some how they come back . But it’s dose not work that way in the movies it can but really we’re dose the show go to then . And my opinion pure poop that’s were . Yes and mini generations ahead a family Denton has a daughter that’s just lacquer a replica that mite fly and really be good and Realistic entertaining and all that good stuff good memories are made of thank you for this 1883 Yellowstone 666-1932 all that jazz thank you thank you thank you I love it

[@hadanuff730]

1883 was 10 episodes. Elsa made it to the end. There was never going to be a Season 2.

[@ChristianCMC]

Second best TV series ever IMO. Breaking Bad is number one.

[@icarus_falling]

Lee was long dead by the time his brother brought his body back to his father. Atleast I thought so

[@tren380]

We see Elsa die in the opening of episode 1.

[@robertwilliams9753]

Not die just arrow shot through gut

[@gc5921]

Anyone realize that if the mother didn't tell Elsa to put her dress on, she would have had that Indian vest on and probably would not have been attacked? Mother got her daughter killed. Nice job Faith (Hill)!

[@ashleyvirgosflame21]

How can you disagree with the creator of the show about the 7th generation 😂😂😂🤦🏽‍♀️it's his show so Tate it is.

[@benotafraid9875]

Those aren't hawks. Those are vultures

[@blcarcher6964]

Load the show and I love the hypocrisy of Tim McGraw with his anti gun View when hes right around shooting everybody

[@theunknownuser9609]

When you don't know the difference between fiction and reality:

[@blcarcher6964]

@@theunknownuser9609 I spent 8 years in special operations I think I know how a weapon's work to don't work play or no play you don't point a gun especially when you're anti gun you're trying to take guns away from me my family and my French go spit

[@blcarcher6964]

@@theunknownuser9609 I think if you're anti gun that means you're anti gun on a movie screen or offscreen you don't know what teenagers watching that show and think it's OK to point shoot weapons at people Is anybody else to own a gun he sucked us right he poor folks the minority we can't have guns we can't go shoot guns we can't do anything with guns but if you're a movie star how you can blow people away but tender no pretend It's wrong you don't ever never point a gun at something you aint willing to destroy.

[@theunknownuser9609]

@@blcarcher6964 What the fuck are you even talking about. You do know it's a TV Show, right? Tim Mcgraw is playing a role. The guns are not real. The deads are not real.

[@theunknownuser9609]

@@blcarcher6964 So by your logic if an actor plays a rapist then he must be a rape supporter

[@doylehurst9930]

I think Mr Coleman says I miss your mother not brother

[@laurieteeple361]

Wondering if Helen Mirren's character is John Sr.'s mother and if John the 3rd ( Kevin Costner) his Mother's story will be hilighted soon and we can understand more about Dabney Coleman and what present John Dutton's life was like.

[@skeena59]

He says both actually.

[@danielnordeen8410]

Those are not hawks but Buzzurds

[@ghostfox8550]

In 7 generations.. if you are going by lineage.. means that Kayce's son Tate taking over would fulfill the prophecy

[@lindadunn5707]

It's just not fair that here in the UK we are not able to watch yellowstone or 1863 please can someone get them on CD collection for all us half yanks half britts to watch it please 🙏 we beg you ! I only watch the yankee channels over here as the britts just suck @ acting & really don't know what a western or cowboy film is all about ! The sole, the grit , the action, the great actors, please if I wasn't disabled & to sick to come home to the USA to come over & binge out on the whole series I would be out there like a shot ! Lots of love to you all & hope you enjoyed yourself with Tim Mcgraw & his wife faith my favourite singers of all time country music, well let's hope Tim & faith get there cuddles back on in the bedroom now they deserve a break & hopefully right more music for us all to enjoy , god bless you all your Vivid fan Linda 😘

[@croftrn]

I am in England, and I have watched all the episodes of all three compilations.... If you have amazon prime, you can get them via paramount plus....

[@kevmwash]

So tate will die later in the future with no children..? 🙄🙄 Going by your logic.. 🤔🤔Monica is pregnant..

[@samdaggett1480]

I think it’s pretty stupid you think all that is a coincidence. He’s the writer for all of it, of course there’s going to be similar lines to reference his other stuff. Kinda helps tie things together. Could’ve been a saying that they said over the generations considering they all had their own problems with people around them. And as far as I’m concerned finding a spot to burry there kid could also be a tradition. Stupid you think it’s all just one big coincidence

[@joycestreetman4526]

JACKS

[@williamcabell142]

Did she die...do we know that for sure?

[@lindamountford4668]

Spencer ??? WHO are his parents

[@stephaniehildebrand4072]

Spencer's parents are James and Margaret

[@jimgrif5998]

Those are buzzards, not hawks.

[@pumpkin1603]

Tate is half native american so maybe that's how

[@stephaniejaniczekssmugglerscan]

Uhm Jacob must be the outlier then

[@mikecrocker6842]

Lol that's not hawks. That's buzzards. Hawks don't pack. Buzzards do when feeding. Sorry. U got that one wrong.

[@joycehwys]

That sequel was the best behind Yellowstone. The young girl was excellent in the part as well as Faith Hill and Tim McGraw

[@jmorrison146]

Who are the illiterates that write these headlines?

[@Head-ck4hu]

I have a solution/problem with the 7th generation prophecy because Tate is a Native American. So if he owns it. They have gotten it back.

[@kylemc8851]

In 7 generations my family will rise up and comment on stupid shit like this!

[@Ace1King1]

You're quite an optimist thinking we'll still be around in seven generations.

[@chriscasterbassmaster]

Lee is not oldest, Jamie is.

[@tinaharlow]

Jamie is adopted.

[@skeena59]

There is a scene with Lee and young John and Jaimie. Lee calls Jaimie little brother.

[@brendajennings9162]

I hated that their daughter was killed off in the show !THAT SHOULD NEVER HAVE HAPPENED!!!!!

[@victoriaaguilar266]

If your going to make a period movie make it accurate. From the farmers wife and daughter expertly herding cattle and cutting cattle (which takes special horses) to the dress and hairdos of the women. It was all wrong. I got tired of it and moved on I didn’t finish the series

[@suepotts5429]

There aren't enough generations in between for James Dutton and the current John Dutton for James to be his great great great grandfather. I love Taylor Sheridan, but I am not buying that comment.

[@theredlineguy3105]

Easily. That’s not even an issue

[@davidjessee7701]

Really? I have a picture of 5 generations. My Grandmother ,mother ,myself, my daughter, and my granddaughters.. my grandmother died at 85 on my granddaughters 1st birthday

[@suepotts5429]

@@davidjessee7701 not saying it is never possible, but with the information available James Dutton would more likely be Tate's great great great grandfather. Of course I may not have all the information

[@Benellismama]

James and Margaret have John. John married Emma who have Jack. Jack married Elizabeth who have John Sr John Sr who married and has our John Dutton. John marries Evelyn who has Kayce. Kayce married Monica and have Tate. Tate is the 7th generation. .

[@suepotts5429]

@@Benellismama Jack was the missing piece when I made this comment. Got it now.

[@lschadler]

Elsa with her black eyebrows was most disappointing. The actress did ok but come on, really? Taylor should have gotten a true blond to be his ‘ lightning’ girl. Beth is awesome and can’t wait to see her next moves on Yellowstone since Costner is again putting us to sleep.

[@kjiggidy5719]

Bruh if you that uncomfortable with how things in the show are then stop watching. Beth is annoying at this point and is willing to ruin the lives of innocent people just to get what she wants and protect her family. Even John is against her actions because they reflect and make situations worse for some other people (innocent at least) and tends to be reckless, that’s why she ended up getting beaten and bruised by those guys in S2, she couldn’t keep her damn mouth shut. She’s lucky Ripp was there but he won’t always be there to save her if another situation like that occurs. Beth is literally ruining the show in my opinion.

[@katecart8790]

I really disliked 1883. Really disliked it. I don't plan on watching 1932. I don't find the Dutton's past very interesting and cannot stand the endless narration. Waiting for next season of Yellowstone.

[@kjiggidy5719]

Oh well, the shows will go on with or without your approval

[@BookMaven9]

This was way better than Yellowstone. Beautifully done.

[@abrunone]

Maybe Taylor Sheridan just isn’t that creative and writes the same dialogue and plot lines because it’s all he knows?

[@andysnooks8198]

He just writes about death