The Killer is defending the Gun!? | Garry's Mod Murder

[@Wyattporter]

we’re going on two years of “Duncan’s back!” now. may this meme live forever

[@Shikamaru747]

has it been that long? jfc time flies

[@ilyaholt8607]

But is Lewis still in Japan?

[@foxboy1985]

What? Duncan? Seeds?

[@cinderball1135]

Duncan's back??!!!

[@southlander40]

Mah boi is back!!!!

[@D0Gdidthemath]

I'm glad they're doing more of this, its fun to see the other gamemodes again

[@Nevario1]

We just need prop hunt and it'll be a return to form. LOL

[@bookswithike3256]

@@Nevario1 They did do some prop hunt recently

[@HoppingSkipper]

melonbomber in 2025 perhaps? a man can dream

[@cryptomancer.]

should have added *"murderer can throw knife"* during the intro explanation I'm glad Ravs eventually showed them

[@pachi9065]

DUNCANS BACK!

[@MisterTingles]

there's been a murrdurr

[@Philggernaut]

So, essentially, the game has three teams; Bystander, Gun, and Knife. When generating names, each team will use the same duplicate list of names, and choose the names without considering names chosen by the other teams. However, the bystander team does consider its own team members, so there will never be duplicates among them. So, if there are two people with the same name, then one of them is guaranteed to have started with a weapon, and both could have a weapon, but neither will be the same weapon. In the rare case of triplets, both weapons will be guaranteed to be among them.

[@puan1211]

Good to know, too bad they will never find this out 😢

[@isaacjhaile]

That scream from Lewis at 14:29 wilheim mk 2

[@SolstaceWinters]

6:39 - Just gonna slap on a good Zylushhhh "Raaaah!" to this comment, for posterity.

[@frog42]

I wanna see the hat films and sips in this! And maybe Simon : )

[@trevorwalker2640]

So happy to see Duncan back!!!

[@Burner_414]

Some of the first episodes of this were god tier. It’s sad that some of the members did what they did years ago

[@PreZurv]

DUNCAN IS FINALLY BACK, god I have missed him

[@cryptomancer.]

Ravs saying *I'll rip the secrets from your flesh*... I wonder how many yogs and yognau(gh)ts are left nowadays who get that reference

[@MigratoryWhimbrel]

3:50 Man, I used to watch you guys and Hatfilms play this with Sips when I was 16

[@ashzayo9181]

we need Hatfilms and Simon XD

[@harveyhandbanana]

I genuinely wonder if Ross would revert back to his true insanity

[@al145]

@@harveyhandbanana "IT'S NOT MEEE! IT'S NOT!!"

[@icelord02]

@@harveyhandbanana that would literally be perfect.

[@SolstaceWinters]

I love Hat Films, probably a bit more than I do the Yogs overall... but I feel they don't got the heart in them for the basic grind of Gmod content. It just doesn't seem to stimulate them enough.

[@MrSpannners]

​@@SolstaceWinters I think they're happy with it once in a while. But they played it so much back in the day

[@Pratalax]

"I like wind chimes, quite the opposite of murder" was that just me or have we heard that before?

[@mosark6554]

Are they really saying if someone's charging you threatening a stabbing you can't defend yourself?

[@deadersurvival4716]

What they're saying is that you have to have a reasonable belief that you're at danger from them doing it. If your mate runs at you without a weapon, it isn't self-defense. If a drunkard who can't walk threatens you, it isn't self-defense. If your mother walks at you with a kitchen knife and a plate of food, it isn't self-defense. If someone is screaming death threats at you, has a knife over their head, and is claiming to not rest until you're dead, it ***is*** self-defense.

[@longbow857]

Also there is more to self defence other then the shoot someone surely? Hard to believe for Americans maybe :P

[@mddojo]

@@deadersurvival4716 So if you're on a property with no way to leave, you know there is a murderer with a knife on the same property as you, you have somebody say they're going to stab you with a knife and the person is at you immediately after saying that, and you shoot them just as they are about to get within stabbing range. Is that self defense?

[@TomDufall]

@@deadersurvival4716 Additionally, in the UK, you're mostly not allowed to own a gun for self-defence. If you were out shooting pigeons and someone ran at you waving a knife and you shot them, that might be a decent defence. If someone broke into your house and you picked up the shotgun under the bed and shot them, there would be significant questions along the lines of "why do you have a loaded shotgun under your bed and not unloaded in a gun safe when your licence says you own it for shooting pigeons?"

[@SharpAsASpoon]

Hearing "I'll rip the secrets from your flesh" while running SM:GY was a trip

[@thegooeymanschannel7128]

6:56 whoever did that sound made me think they edited in an actual sound from Half Life 2 for a second 😂

[@Zoeythedirewolf]

6:58 that was straight up a half life 2 scream lol

[@SmashHammerVr]

It is I think, you can play audio if you dont have mic or something

[@benderong4478]

DUNCANS BACK!!!

[@TrilobiteTerror]

13:07 In America, you'd still have to prove it was reasonable to fear for your life (i.e., you saw the knife/and it was found on them). What not normal is countries that punish would-be victims for clear cases of self defense.

[@Savayan]

What! Year! Is it?!

[@JoshThompsonProductions]

This is even funnier considering this comment is a few days before the New Year 😂😂😂

[@Cody_Ramer]

Ravs plays a great murderer...

[@Ma-Giik]

hope you guys can play some prop hunt and stuff too

[@K1ngseraph]

So crazy to jump back in from time to time and see new faces. Gotta get sips again for one of these soon. Sadly can’t have the whole OG crew

[@joshualuers4491]

I’ll be honest and say I didn’t like any of the new members as an old fan when I returned after years-now I love many of them just as much. They’re great fun

[@h0wlingstar]

I don't think they know they can throw the knife. meanwhile Ravs ;)

[@nonya1366]

I think if the Yog's came back to it again, they could try Homicide [basically a more complicated version of Murder] Though Iunno if that's still a thing in gmod, maybe this was also their low energy thing. Still, fun video all the same.

[@vegladex]

I remember they did a few episodes of Homicide and I really enjoyed them! It usually just descended into kneecap-punching though. I guess they didn't like it much because there were only two or three episodes.

[@ixhilkalaskiiver792]

It's not me... IT'S NOT MEEE!!!

[@DatSheep13]

They should try Gmod: Homicide again.

[@MH-hu5pi]

We're missing Simon or Ross. Preferably both.

[@psilocyrapter]

Hi US citizen here (american if you would) most importantly in texas lewis is correct the defense holds. They charged at me and i shot them. Especially with how the US (well really the world but mostly the US) has gone insane. Like there was a dude walking up and down the road the other day popping off a .22 because he was twacked out and wanted the packages we ordered in for the niece and nephews. Had to explain to the police at work why i have a loaded gun in my truck and they understood the reasoning. Wish i could say it was better, but, it really isn't, like a powder keg really. Fun video though, miss the murder videos but TTT as heavily modded as y'all have it is still loads of fun to watch.

[@MaxTrogmore42]

I wish they'd play these games with proximity chat, it would make it way more interesting to randomly hear cries and calls as people run around

[@dannydreal8312]

Garry's mod MURDER!? 🎉🎉🎉

[@ethanrabinovich5835]

They should mod this like TTT to make it more crazy

[@PairOfCatEyes]

Y'all should play homigrad, it's really funny

[@scsc22]

Rythian loves the act like a murderer get killed and complain that he's innocent😅

[@mattmcginn8096]

Yogscast taking on police shootings, 2025 the year they go political!

[@Florian87]

And when Ravs does the same, Rhythian says Kirsty was justified in killing him

[@Forral87]

Melon Bomber when?

[@Rorymchair]

Last murder had Rythian complain about no one using the gun when he was the bystander with the gun and now he’s complaining about getting shot when he runs up to the bystander with the gun while proclaiming he’s going to stab him so I’m quite excited to see what he humourously complains about in any future murder video

[@briankale5977]

"normal countries" being thrown in there in relation to "places where you just have to get attacked and can't defend yourself" was utterly hilarious to me

[@Dxm2000andNinju]

Any intelligent attacker isn't going to give you a chance to "defend yourself", gun or no. "places where you just have to get attacked and can't defend yourself" is a lie if I've ever heard one. "Oh, I don't have a gun so I won't fight or run or call for help, just accept my fate"... really? If you have a chance to defend yourself, either the attacker didn't plan ahead, gave it to you, failed in their attack or you weren't the prime target. But the fun thing about "normal countries" is that, if the right protections are in place and the person hasn't bypassed them somehow, that person attacking you is doing so with a much less efficient means of killing, giving you *more* (despite your claims) opportunity to defend or be defended before finality.

[@puff7145]

@@Dxm2000andNinju A whole lot of words to say "if you can't run faster then just die I guess lol"

[@gakulon]

​@@Dxm2000andNinju Those countries also do something MUCH more effective at reducing ALL forms of crime: take better care of their citizens. If you think crime in the US is caused by firearms, you are quite frankly a dumbass. Economic concerns drive the majority of crime. If someone feels the need to commit a crime, society has already failed in largely preventable ways.

[@Dxm2000andNinju]

@@puff7145 Might want to work on your reading comprehension if you think I expressed or implied any of that :) And your wits, if you believe that ^^

[@benji5320]

@@Dxm2000andNinjureread what you wrote and really think about how dumb it actually is. You might also want to rethink what most “normal” countries are.

[@grapechel]

These are so nostalgic I love it Duncan's back!!! 😂

[@Wierdoandzero]

Murder? we back to 2012?

[@MrSpannners]

"No, Alfa was the one who started with the gun" *Insert Naked Gun facepalm gif*

[@ThornXVII]

I’m so glad Duncan’s back, I’ve been missing him crazy like

[@deadlydestroya]

I see Zylus' American gal is starting to influence how he thinks subconsciously. Man felt stand your ground in his soul.

[@Sorfinali]

Nilesy we also played this when we were 16. I'm sure that's why I love to see this content.

[@brandonprimeuk]

We need hatfilms to return to when ross is the murderer he can say "eat shit"

[@crocutaqueen1311]

Dark slate grey Juliet

[@Shikamaru747]

man some games just never get old eh

[@Shikamaru747]

ok technically they're old as shit but you know what I mean

[@bringmemyflail1321]

Ravs is on the roof. La la. La la la.

[@Daktangle]

9:00 What a callback to Vanilla WoW that was

[@raymondc9513]

Guys.... I can't believe it..... *Duncan's back*

[@Ovetupp]

The Hotel class needs a buff. Generates too much suspicion.

[@ShoddyDaisy]

Duncan's back??!?!?!?!!?! In the year of our Lord, 2024?!?!?!??

[@shynarcissist]

I love classic murder. I'm so glad to see these game modes back ❤

[@psychopurple]

I don't know how Rythian's first shot on Zylus at the end missed, it was square in his back and recoils to his left shoulder.

[@Coconut-219]

The 'culturally enriched' london experience

[@justinnyugen7015]

holy canoli...

[@heyojayo8642]

Of course its the beginning and Rythian is doing murders!! 😂😂😂

[@yoboyrexdykes1085]

I still watch the videos from 10 years ago some good classics

[@spacehitler4537]

They really should've moved to homigrad or homicide murder is kinda shit to watch.

[@Lynkah]

Lol. Rythian really doesn't think sometimes. He was following people stabbing them. He literally watched like a dozen items get picked up by people he then killed. Ofcourse he only found 1, he killed everyone after they picked them up every time!! most of the people he killed had picked up 2-3 in the like 10 seconds before getting stabbed by rythian. He could hear and see it almost ever time!

[@FriendlyKat]

YESSSSS! SO HAPPY TO SEE MORE OF THIS!!

[@slimebaby1211]

Hopefully Robin will appear in the next episode!

[@Lorissarusrex]

These are the absolute bestttt!!!!

[@mrtdjb]

I've miss seeing Zoe

[@Filip6754]

The last round was peak

[@justincollins4262]

After all these years

[@Splavacado.]

The fact that they joke about how to get away with murder in America is absolutely crazy Because they’re absolutely correct, unfortunately

[@professorcoms2481]

A murder in Bell End

[@Tuturial464]

Rythian Wrong, worst salty attorney

[@Caigul]

In the US depends on what state you are in

[@Ahkmedren]

omg they got duncan

[@JustVilainess]

Would love to see some gmod dodgeball :p

[@timidunderscore]

thought daltos was in this one thrice but thats just the murder player model

[@blackdragoncyrus]

I was JUST rewatching the old GMod Murder vids! =o

[@EmeraldUsakaze]

GMod Murder is always great, and I'd love to see more. But it's still not the same without Ross in it yelling EAT SHIT every five seconds as the murderer.

[@MrSpannners]

If they're going back to other old gmods, they should play Hide and Seek

[@CJMoody]

Bring back GMod Pictionary next! Better yet, start doing videos where you're building in Gary's Mod again!

[@bryalogicalgaming5817]

Classic Hotel

[@koekjekerfuffle5780]

I can just hear the echo's of Ross shouting in my head. 🔪 💩

[@LogicReel]

What year is it?

[@NCRLouTenant]

Am I early? Are they late? The world may never know

[@KingofWolvesii]

GMOD Guess Who next?

[@rubenderegge8198]

Where is Ross...

[@rocktalon2]

Duncans Back?! Man, It's crazy that we get murder more than we do Duncan.

[@southlander40]

Liked for "James Gunn" alone.

[@Aenonar]

prop hunt and murder is just nrandom fun , kinda like TTT but not quite as flexible with mods

[@caleb_dreams]

Yeah!!!

[@untetheredwolf9349]

Duncan was gone?

[@nazamroth8427]

What year is this?!

[@WittingAbyss]

MORE MURRDURR!!!!

[@jackreid6412]

Gotta play some better games yogsz

[@keeferli8692]

Make a gmod build video!

[@Wyrd-Oh]

Honestly, it's a wee bit of a dick move to keep bringing along the colourblind guy to games where calling out colours is pretty important :P

[@bledsoe60]

Dear Rythian, please stop ghosting just because you are upset. Signed, an adult

[@joelhicks5468]

lmao bang

[@drewowlstudio]

Prophunt??

[@shawnmm1]

least int prophnt

[@Hobbyrepubliken]

😱

[@ojrmk1]

"Jamesgun" - Is that a motherfucking Gundam refernce?

[@Americanbadashh]

Oh no skins for this one, aww

[@Dospe]

I wouldn't want it for murder, the anonymity of "who is who" is part of it. Plus disguising as the murderer would be much harder, if not impossible.