Lucy Thomas - Memory - Vocal Coach Reaction & Analysis

[@gotmythumbs]

If she had done this for the Voice she would have won it hands down. I'm an emotional wreck every time I watch this. In watching this again another thing I see in Lucy at this point is a incredible pure innocence she conveys to us. Amazing.

[@Robbie.Dunbar]

"Memory" was the song that led me to Lucy and my life has never been the same since. Oh and her concert? I was there and I wish you could have been there, it was a very magical night. We even got two duets with Lucy and her younger sister Martha. Everyone who was there knows they witnessed history and something very special that they will never forget. I could go on and on about that night. Hope to see you at one of Lucy's concerts one day. 🥰

[@Lobo53]

Robbie, being you're close to Lusy and family, do you know why Pie Jesu went private after being up for a few hours? I know it's on her Facebook page, but so many are missing out.

[@BlackCloud82]

Robbie, "Memory" is also the piece that drew me to Lucy. I'm constantly amazed at her talent. That video is where I came up with the description "Reach but no screech" concerning Lucy's voice because in the wide-open full-on belt she still had good pitch, her beautiful vibrato was there, and you could still plainly hear the lyrics. Many have come onboard with Lucy, just look at the views on Hallelujah. Interestingly, lots of reactors Jump on anything Lucy puts out almost immediately . I also admire your video editing on some of the Lucy videos you have created. Like many others, I hope excerpts of her concert become available.

[@fuzzyx2face]

If she comes to Toronto in Canada I’ll be there! I would love to see her live

[@pertwee9376]

Sounds like her "touch me" touched you. Me too.

[@lynneshellyattianeseattian9321]

15 yrs old, just stunning!!!

[@peggymagruder]

I absolutely love Lucy Thomas, but I must say I love you as well. I love and agree with your opinion. Your voice is angelic and pure. I wish I had a good singing voice and you were my coach, but that is not in the cards. You are also absolutely beautiful - inside and outside. I watch all your reviews. Thank you for sharing.

[@stevecoughlin9284]

Lucy's voice is one I could listen to all day.

[@MichaelBurt-qj8zy]

LUCY - YOU HELP SO MANY - THANK YOU - MICHAEL

[@MichaelBurt-qj8zy]

GREAT LUCY !!!!

[@Orti78]

It's simply unbelievable and fascinating to me how such a young teenager can have such a voice and such charisma. I discovered her about a year ago and never tire of listening to her music.

[@rolanddunk5054]

Hi,Lucy is not only brilliant at putting the correct emotion to a song she also puts her physical being into it at the same time.She will be a great musical stage actress,she brought a tear to my eye to. Thank you for you honest an favourable comments,cheers Roly🇬🇧.

[@spencerbutterbaugh6104]

Great reaction as usual. Thank you. An now we have live Lucy singing Somewhere from her concert in Manchester. Check it out. We her fans knew she could do it.

[@CrepeM191]

It always moves me that Lucy's performance can make you tear up. Same with me. I cant' even carry a tune but I knew there was something special about Lucy from the moment I saw her as a 10 year old on the beach singing Run. She always makes me smile. I also love Lucy's version of "At Last" because we really see a very different side of Lucy. I appreciate your analysis and validation.

[@TedAshton-m6l]

Phenomenal performance, breathtaking vocals. At 15 this was amazing. The astonishing thing is this young lady is getting better and better every time she sings. Great reaction.

[@michaelhingley4770]

Lucy Thomas, at the age of 15 - just one of several masterclasses from 2019. Thank you, Juliet, again, for your expert analysis of, and appreciation for, our beautiful siren!

[@kennethsorrels8850]

Great reaction and analysis as always. Well, your request for Pie Jesu has been answered. Lucy released the video on her channel today. Looks like you might have to squeeze that one into your busy schedule. Keep up the great work!

[@Some_One_One]

Linkify then!

[@HarveyShevchik-di6tx]

I dont know all the music acknowledgement of her talents. I just love listening & watching her videos She is perfection in all manners. What a talent, bless u lucy for sharing your love of music with us.

[@barrygentry5364]

So many singers are judged on their ability to hit the big notes, which Lucy can do, but it’s the softness that she brings to her music that I find so captivating. So smooth ❤

[@christopherseaborn4084]

That’s a a great comment. Her femininity and softness always shine through. It is captivating.

[@esconeskybounce3000]

What an excellent singer,,,

[@LesParker-qx9xs]

Shes soft and smooth and yet so powerful at the same time ,no one can sing like Lucy

[@LesParker-qx9xs]

Juliet you seemed to me ,that you were ready to burst into tears like i do

[@RoseIsaacs-c6d]

Great reaction to a one in a million star for a million and one reasons

[@David-gi6nv]

This was the song Lucy completely harpooned me. She had the full arsenal even at 15.

[@BlackCloud82]

Juliet, I just saw the Lucy-ism (Head-bounce) and so did you; you actually mimicked it and smiled (on "Remembered"). I don't know the original score but Lucy stretched out "ha-ppi-ness" using straight tones. I know you like to address long waits in the lyrics (in fact I think I heard you hum a little bit), but the pause here fits how she's searching memories. And Juliet -- this is one of the most animated reactions I've seen you do. Along with that, I could tell you were fighting to hold in your emotions (i heard it in your voice several times). I'm in the same boat, this one could be called a 'tear-jerker' for me. Sorry for filling up the comments, but I have so much to say about Lucy along with your reactions. Every time I watch it more stands out to me.

[@davidcokley1929]

Hi Juliet, thank you for finally reacting to this performance from Lucy. I love the way she doesn't just sing the song, she performs it. I get goose bumps every time I listen to Lucy sing this and I would love to hear her sing this again. This was this video that introduced me to Lucy back in January of 2020 and I've been hooked ever since. You have become my favorite reactor. As mentioned below, Lucy and Chris Broom have given free use of Lucy's videos on KZbin, so you won't get blocked if you don't pause. With most reactors, the pauses irritate me a little, but I've never minded your applauses because you've always given insightful and meaningful comments when you do pause. Take care.

[@GRANTTRIBECreates]

well said!

[@Guenter1953]

Lucy always hits me right in the heart. Whether she is 9, 10, 15 or now 20 years old, she has the most incredible voice and the deepest emotions at any age. This young woman is a gift from God. Today the duet "Pie Jesu" has been released. Juliet, I think you would be on the verge of tears again.

[@wilburfinnigan2142]

Guenter YES !! ! It was Juliet that made a short video on You Tube about a year ago requesting Lucy and Martha to do Pie Jesu !!! Its out and Juliet need to REACT to it ASAP !!!!

[@BattlestarDamocles]

I don't think it's on her channel yet. But maybe this week hopefully, since it's Easter.

[@wilburfinnigan2142]

@@BattlestarDamocles It was up for about a day and it disappeared !!! Who knows why, BUT Layman and Chadeo did a reaction to it and it is on their sites. Luckily i book marked it and can still see it. Might be a copy right thing ????

[@BattlestarDamocles]

@@wilburfinnigan2142 Not sure but hope it comes back up.

[@georgegliszczynski8576]

Lucy captures us as we become mesmerized by her purity, beauty, clarity and uniqueness.

[@JaapFilius]

Thank you for this wonderful reaction. Being a tenor choir singer myself (just for hobby, not professional by any means) I love these in depth reactions very much. And to let you know: this evening, well here in Europe it is evening when I write this down, (on 25-03-2024) a new "Sister Duet" is released: Pie Jesu.

[@danielbitzer652]

Me too!! I have begging on all the official site and fan pages hoping to put that concert out for sale

[@HarveyShevchik-di6tx]

Does anyone else feel like I do about lucy I would like to keep her for my very own but I realized that she is a talent that must be shared with the world. Thank you lucy.

[@wilburfinnigan2142]

Harvey they did away with "Slavery" over 150 years ago !!!! You cannot own anyone today !!!

[@johnbattles1002]

i'm a 68-year old guy, but the tears have always come each time I've watched Lucy perform this song. I greatly admire her as the wonderful young lady she is as well as a phenomenal artist! I feel the same about her younger sister Martha too. If you have not reacted to them singing duets together, you really should check out their several performances! Thank you for a great reaction and analysis!

[@anneruiz7602]

Wow Juliet!.. what a nice surprise with this reaction to the younger magnificent Lucy!… it’s so nice to get an expert’s breakdown of what Lucy is doing when she sings….thanks again and I look forward to your next reaction to Lucy. You are very much appreciated ❤

[@whatnone1020]

For whatever reason I had not heard this before. Fantastic. This really blew me away.

[@wilburfinnigan2142]

Lucy released this song Dec 27 2019 about 7 weeks before her 16th birthday !!!!! 15 years old and singing like that, This song is on my favorite list of Lucy's.....Juliet see we told you Lucy was great!!!! And Lucy and Martha just an hour ago released the VIDEO song of Pie Jesu !!!!! Yes the one YOU requested so how about a react to that ????? and don't wait 6 months,. it is a recent video and Martha is even older and Lucy goes to new heights !!! Thanks for the react to Lucy at 15 and that photo of Lucy on the premier album she was 14 !!!!

[@henkhessel3651]

Thanks for your analysis. You were talking about how remarkable she was at 15. That's why you might want to hear her at 9,10..15 to appreciate her spectacular performances at an early age here: "Rare Recordings - Lucy Thomas" (a playlist of ten special ones. The last one is Colors of the wind @ 9yo, One Day is the audition for Rosie musical @13yo which got her the contracts with Chris Broom! Run she did at 10 and later at 15! Don't know if you want to react to all of them but they may provide you with some background info. Enjoy.

[@stephen8639]

Lucy's site just posted her and Martha singing Pie Jesu.

[@mikeyitfc]

Thank you Thank you Thank you and once again Thank you i've been telling everyone who reacts to Lucy to check this song out it really shows her vocal range and capacity. She is amazing at taking older songs and making them sound better.

[@BlackCloud82]

Juliet, got to add more. as-far-as performing this piece goes, note that during the real powerful belt section she brings her hands into view on her chest adding a little more oomph to the interpretation. Even though most of her videos are busts she brings her hands into view to add meaning. Sometimes it emphasizes a first-person meaning; including herself in the lyrics. Also, nearing and on into the ending, after all that power and emotion, she collects it all into a last note or two with a very light, sweet, tone. Many times just those last two or three notes send me over the top and I'm crying again. And, Juliet, regarding you personally, your physical and facial reactions really add to your comments making them come alive. Body language (especially when your countenance is effected) can be very powerful.

[@RoseIsaacs-c6d]

This is the first song I heard of Lucy. I fell in love instantly and has been a supporter ever since. It is just magnificent.

[@christopherseaborn4084]

This young lady is the vocal phenomenon of our times. Julie Andrew’s comes to mind. That is how great a vocal talent Lucy Thomas is.

[@iancave-nu1ff]

Christopher, i believe that if Julie Andrews were to meet lucy she would, in all humility, hand over the crown,!!! Ian.

[@wilburfinnigan2142]

Chris I do believe that Lucy is better than Julie Andrews, and through the many years I have watched and admired Julie, but thee is a new Queen on the throne !! !

[@christopherseaborn4084]

@@wilburfinnigan2142 you won’t get an argument from me.

[@christopherseaborn4084]

@@iancave-nu1ff it would be appropriate recognition for Lucy to be given the nod from such a superstar of song as Julie Andrew’s.

[@pedromancenithe3rd]

Personally I don't see the comparison with Julie Andrews. Firstly Lucy's tone is completely different and Julie didn't have anywhere near the range or power of even the fifteen year old Lucy, Today Lucy is in a class of her own, either performing this song or the jazzy "At Last" or her and Martha's latest video release "Pie Jesu". Just my observation after watching Lucy since her first promotional video at the age of thirteen.

[@BattlestarDamocles]

Lucy was fifteen years old here 🙂 Same age as when she sang Starlight (another one from 'Rosie' that I'm waiting for).

[@wilburfinnigan2142]

Battlestar Damocles Memory released Dec 27 2019 just 7 weeks before Lucy's 16 birthday !!!

[@Gabriel_6910]

Lucy is incredible. She's got it all, she masters her voice like no one else, every note she sings is a moment of pure bliss, it's perfection from the beginning to the end of every song. I was lucky enough to see her in Manchester and Tokyo, and I can't wait for the London concert and all her future concerts. What's more, she's such a lovely, natural, simple, kind person. She's a gem, this singer and this girl.

[@JOEKLEMEN]

JULIET, GREAT REACTION. I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR YOUR REACTION. THIS IS THE SONG I FOUND LUCY. I WAS ONLY LOOKING UP TO SEE THE WORDS. WITH LUCY YOU DO NOT HAVE TO SEE THE WORDS YOU CAN HEAR THEM. I LIKE THE WAY YOU BREAK DOWN THE SONG. IT IS HELPFUL FOR THOSE OF US WHO ARE NOT SINGERS. LOVE YOU AND LUCY. JOE

[@StephenReynolds-jk7dv]

Thanks once more Juliet for your great reaction to Lucy. It is an incredible experience to listen to Lucy no matter what age Lucy is.

[@randysimon7363]

Lucy did not perform Memory at her recent Manchester concert. However, she did perform it in Dallas last fall and it was breathtaking.

[@colinhea]

Hi Juliet Great to see you reacting to this song Lucy was 15 here and what a beautiful job she has made of it I think its the best version ever I used to love Elaine pages version until I heard this .I still have to pinch myself when I hear Lucy sing this it is just outright beautiful always love watching your reactions to Lucy as you are one of the few reactors that know what they are talking about. I hope you manage to get to see Rosie. Thanks for your continued support for Lucy our Queen of song.

[@randysimon7363]

The first video from the Manchester concert is up: Somewhere (There’s a Place for Us).

[@Lobo53]

Great reaction and breakdown, that's why you're my favorite reactor. It's so amazing to see so much talent this young ❤️. P.S. So happy to see your surgery went well, Juliet. 🌹

[@radarstag]

Lucy and Martha have just dropped a duet of Pie jesu

[@richeswebcraft]

🙂Thanks Juliet for that analysis. It amazes me every time I see this video at how developed her voice and expression was at that young age - I've certainly not heard anyone else at the same age with that full tone quality - remarkable. Yes, I'm also looking forward to the DVD of her concert being released 🙂

[@5pmevans]

Thanks Juliet I knew you’d love this, the video was released in 2019 so Lucy was 15. Lucy just has the most perfect voice for musical theatre although she excels at every musical genre I’ve heard her try! Lucy didn’t include this in the March 5th concert but did do 15 solos and 2 duets with Martha all to absolute perfection.

[@barbaracallister8138]

Hello Juliet, what a great reaction from you on Lucy singing "Memory" as you say this was Lucy 4 or 5 years ago singing this wonderful song. This young lady is truly amazing her voice at this young age was truly something, just so beautiful , now Juliet, Lucy & Martha have just released "Pie Jesu " on KZbin within the last 30 minutes it was released for Easter, and just to say, you need to listen to "Hold On " by Lucy & Will Callan from the musical "Rosie" it is just so beauiiful to listen to/ Take care, Barbara.

[@pedromancenithe3rd]

Juliet. Heres a heads up and the one you've been waiting for. The video of Lucy and Marth performing "Pie Jesu" just this moment been put on KZbin. Enjoy

[@AndrewStritch]

i love that you are commenting on this cover. some of the greats in musical history have recorded this and Lucy is right up there with the best at only15 amazing thank you for the beautiful comments and for promoting Lucy

[@ronboyer1906]

Lucy and Martha just released the video of Pie Jesu!

[@shaunhines7883]

Omg! I almost started crying immediately.. I don't know if ill ever pinpoint why and how her voice affects me so deeply.. But she sings and my whole chest opens and my breath leaves my body and I pretty much don't breath again until i realize i havent since she started singing.. I've never been more willing to be breathless 😉 ❤🙏

[@PhyllisJarosz-p1z]

Lucy is the most gifted vocalist ! She becomes the songs she sings, just phenomenal! Thank you Julia, I look forward to your reactions! You have a beautiful voice also!

[@robertkrouse9478]

Great reaction. Enjoyed your singing too.

[@Beeper68]

Lucy just released "Pie Jesu" 2 hours ago. WOW! Would love to hear your analysis of Lucy singing "All By Myself". Love to hear your analyses because you seem got know more than the vast majority of reactors. Have you thought about having a Lucy Thomas Week, or month?

[@Boatzerama]

She is absolutely stunning singing that song👍🏼

[@glentaylor861]

Again, such a brilliant reaction to one of Lucy’s best songs. I so enjoy your singing, again superb, in order to explain what Lucy is actually doing with her voice. You and Lucy have got to meet up soon to talk about singing technique perhaps with actual singing coach. What a meeting of minds. Thank you again for a great review.

[@andreakammerer1654]

Hallo Juliet, you are always explain Lucys songs in a non technical way for us...but what everybody can hear, that Lucy is brilliant in her way she delivers each song.🎉 I still wait excited each month for a new release of her. This Lady is my daily joy....and to watch you, too❤. Have a nice eastertime, Juliet🐣🐰

[@brianchu3317]

Thank you for another fabulous reaction to Lucy. You’re one of my top music reactors. This performance is one of my favorites of Lucy’s. It really showed her immense vocal talents. I wish more people would watch this performance. It’s magic!

[@BattlestarDamocles]

My day is complete!!!! Waited for this for some time. Thank you Juliet 🙂❤

[@BattlestarDamocles]

Hope you have 'Run To You' lined up too, one of the covers Lucy did of one of Whitney Houston's songs. She speaks at the end of that one so you can hear her northern English accent. Her town is 73 miiles from mine.

[@bruceobrown534]

Hi ya Juliet - another wonderful analysis - always enjoy watching and listening to you. When Lucy hits that crescendo, it always leaves me breathless, and tears just surge out of my eyes every time I hear her perform this song. Thank you for continuing to react to Lucy and I look forward to seeing SO many more. Stay safe and healthy!

[@keithkerr6869]

That is just flat out amazing and beautiful - WOW!

[@downrigger002]

Lucy's facial expressions and body language show she is feeling the music and not just singing. This is why she captures many of us avid supporters. I keep hoping she is going to release a video of "Pie Jesu" soon as rumor going around stated.

[@stephen8639]

It released a few minutes ago.

[@wilburfinnigan2142]

downrigger Lucy and Martha just released the video and Chadeo has already reacted to it........The video is STUNNING, and both are fantastic, and Lucy taking it to new heights!!!

[@stephen8639]

@@wilburfinnigan2142 They seem to have taken it down I can't see the video on the site anymore?

[@wilburfinnigan2142]

@@stephen8639 Hmmmmmmm thats strange as I just went and checked and no I did not find the video, wonder whats going on. Layman, chadeo, and a couple of others still have the video on there site, check it out there,

[@downrigger002]

@@stephen8639 It is under "Releases" and "Beyond" album.

[@billwalker4282]

Two things" First things first. You commented in a previous reaction that you would love to here Lucy sing "Pie En Jesu". Well the video was just released!! I remember watching Lucy singing when she was fifteen (which I think Martha is now). I can't believe all that time has past. They both have progressed and matured so much. Secondly: Juliet you are so right about the depth of Lucy's low range when she sang Memory. The maturation of her voice has been phenomenal and transformed her vocal ability exponentially. She is in a class of her own. Another great reaction. From a viewer standpoint, it is so moving to witness your expressions and emotions while you work.

[@Lobo53]

I believe Martha is still 14 here 😊

[@wilburfinnigan2142]

@@Lobo53 As of March 26 2024 Martha is 14 years and 5 months, she was born Nov 4 2009.....

[@tomprater341]

Brand new Day is also magical.

[@geofftaylor7701]

Hi Juliet - the video of Pie Jesu dropped an hour ago - go get it girl.

[@ronaldmcrae4896]

If you've ever attended a showing of Cats you realize, not only is her voice beautiful but her expressions/gestures are spot on for Grizabella's feelings. This was superb!

[@iancave-nu1ff]

Hi Juliet, another great reaction, so good to see you reacting to an earlier performance by Lucy, i believe she was fifteen here. if possible you should try "She used to be mine" at age fourteen, its phenomenal how at that age she can convey such empathy ,!! also to see into the future of this wonderful artist, you simply have to react to "Run" by a ten year old Lucy, you will be amazed that all the elements that make her great today were present at such a tender age. --------------Ian.

[@estanislaolabuguen9084]

Thanks again your reacts is great comments of her prtfotmances. She is on these stuuning sounds beautiful tone quality. At this young ages unbielibable talent.

[@Siggi160]

so great beautyful reaction for 🌹 lucy 🌹 s song thank you so mutch juliett🥰❤❤💥💫🌹🌹siggi from germany

[@tomprater341]

Evergreen and 1000 years are so awesome too. This video is from 4 years ago, meaning she was 14.

[@lawrenceb5236]

Hi Juliet. You know that I love Loren Allred, especially the performance on AGT you just reacted to, and I really like Morissette, but, I have to say that Lucy is in a class by herself. Just the complete package no matter what age she is or what song she sings. You pick up all these little things that go into a performance that turn it into a spectacular experience.

[@5pmevans]

Interestingly during a Q&A session in her March 5th concert Lucy was asked which singers she admired and she said Barbara Streisand, Celine Dion and …… Loren Allred! It’s likely Lucy and Loren have met as last October they both did private concerts for the Best family in Dallas and videos of those concerts were released within a few hours of each other!

[@lawrenceb5236]

Thanks for that info, Peter. Unfortunately , I haven’t seen any videos of either of those performances yet. But I will say the Best’s have extremely good taste in music. @@5pmevans

[@briankrames1883]

OK, now that we're going back into the older Lucy gems, how about you analyzing an absolute flawless performance of "She Used to be Mine"?!! I have one word for you with this performance from Lucy: EMPATHY! She takes on the role of this waitress, faults and all, just stunning!!

[@anneruiz7602]

Yes, and the live version of her singing it at the Calon fundraiser at age 15 is absolutely awesome. It would be awesome to have Juliet react to the live version. I happen to think it is better than the studio version. The video is easily accessible on Lucy’s channel. The full video with Lucy singing 3 live songs is also easily available. At age 15, that video already shows what an accomplished and mature performer she was and it is clear she loves to perform. Just amazing!

[@kit-kretar777]

Juliet, She sings this masterfully with a voice made i Heaven. Just so powerful and beautiful. I suggested "A Whiter Shade Of Pale" to you so you could clearly see how developed and beautiful her chest voice is now. Oh and by the way, I just watched the video of "Pie Jesu" on Lucy's channel. You will LOVE it. I also really enjoy your analysis, Juliet. Every time. Kit

[@richarderamirez5909]

Her ability with the music to make the listener feel the deepest emotion..

[@dnwp7362hihi]

And now, lucy martha with Pie Jesu new song. So faster !

[@АлексейАндросов-о2л]

🎉🎉🎉🎉😊😊😊

[@TimKlepac-xm7vk]

Well done again Juliet. I really enjoy your critiques because they point out what I feel if only subconsciously. Such as your pointing out how she sung that first "happiness" in a such a way as to make it sound sad or with that note of longing in it, as well as all the other little nuances you point out. How the heck does someone that young sing a song like this with such emotional maturity and sincerity? Unbelievable. No hint of any hokiness. BTW..."jacuzzi tone", ha, love that description. Really looking forward to you doing Pie Jesu. Soon.

[@BlackCloud82]

Juoiet, thank you for finally getting to this one. This was the first Lucy video I watched and I immediately loved everything about it and became a dedicated fan and subscribed to her channel . When she got to that wide-open full-on belt I was floored. With all that power and slightly higher pitch in the belt you could still understand the lyrics, she stayed on key, and her outstanding vibrato was there. Also, even though she really pushed the third word she did not screech. I immediately began my saying of "Reach but no screech" concerning Lucy. Because of my long musical history, and having lived a long time I mentioned to you (and also commented to her on her video) about being a little conservative and not blowing out her vocal cords. On top of that, screeching hurts my ears. I've been waiting for you to get to this one for a long time. On top of that, Lucy can bring chills and open up the waterworks because of her "performing" a song, not just singing it. Sometimes I have to replay a video because the tears made it hard to see the video. I figured that it's getting a little old and dusty and might get forgotten. So once again, "Thank You". 😂😂😂

[@bruceobrown534]

Hi ya Yet Again - Lucy just released a live version of 'Somewhere' from her Manchester concert - PLEASE do a reaction!!!!!

[@fuzzyx2face]

Great reaction Lucy is my favourite singer, she’s something special

[@hermanbunandar6053]

Miss Lucy really really have s angel voice

[@edwinbarnett9032]

That is the cover photo of the Premier C.D.I have them all I have a mountain of music but all I want to listen to is Lucy Thomas Love everything she does.

[@trentnichols942]

Thank you for the excellent analysis and reaction to Lucy signing ‘Memory’ from Cats. All of your analysis has helped me to understand how vocalists achieve certain emotions beyond just the words of a song. Lucy is masterful in telling a story with words and technique. It makes her a performer in distinction to a singer alone. It is why at the Manchester live performance she needed nothing save a piano and pianist. She performed and kept everyone engaged and entertained. Singers require props, other people, costumes, etc. to accomplish that. Lucy is well on her way to being a master performer. We are all so fortunate to be able to witness it. Thank you again, Juliet for such wonderful job analyzing Lucy.

[@BlackCloud82]

Juliet, I watched this again. This time I saw how impressive her vibrato is. It shows all the way through this piece; particularly in the wide open belt section. Another reactor said 'nobody does vibrato like Lucy' and I have to agree. Even at this young she has a fantastic, even symmetrical and amazing vibrato. WOW!

[@colinhea]

Hi Juliet I have been waiting for you to react to this song.Lucy's studio version is incredible but this live version is out of this world her voice is even more mature.rich and warm .Lucy is just the best female vocalist of this era.Thanks for your professional reaction to this song.and thanks for your continued support of Lucy.❤

[@Gabriel_6910]

I love your analyses. You manage to put into words things that I feel but can't explain. And Lucy is definitely the best. No doubt in my mind. Thank you for your time.

[@Johnnygee10]

Check out her version of the classic song At Last.👌 (Etta james). Always enjoy your knowlegeable insight 😉

[@andreakammerer1654]

Yes this is stunning when Lucy Performes "At last", in this young age! She showes a coolness like an matured beautiful and classy Lady❤ Amazing girl! ❤🎉

[@jeffkerr4861]

"Stunning, beautiful, the sounds, ah the sound, perfect. This young songbird owns my heart. Like a true siren, she beckons, i listen. She shows her soul, i weep. She reaches a crescendo, I shake, i am wholly hers. See softens, I become aware. She lets me go with a smile, I know I was had. I play it again." My first comment on Lucy years ago. She was outstanding at 14, today she is sublime, tomorrow will need new words I don't know. If you want to sate your desire for some live Lucy here is a link. She performed a three song set at a small charity event, just her, a crap mic., and a backing track. No sound crew, no edits, just pure. Watch a giggly teen turn siren in seconds. Enjoy. kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaDNpqyvbcedpsk 🤠

[@Tommy-e2y]

My tears flow to this powerful and angelic performance of superb and magical perfection...

[@HopelesslyAddicted-s8o]

Great reaction Juliet! (My favorite vocal coach reactor) This has always been one of my favorite Lucy songs. Lucy is our Earth Angel! I believe Lucy was 15 at the time. When Lucy crescendos and she belts out "Trust me", I emotionally wince, visibly tremble, and whimper like a child. You absolutely have to play and react to Lucy’s breathtaking earlier performances of: “LISTEN”; kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y5eqlmuQadp_jac At only age 14, Lucy had the mature and powerful voice of an adult diva. And “I’LL NEVER LOVE AGAIN"; kzbin.info/www/bejne/apiUgqOrbr2Dgpo At only age 15, Lucy’s emotional and powerful performance was even better than the original. I promise you will be blown away. BTW, your wish has been granted. Lucy and Martha sing PIE JESU as a duet. Just gorgeous! (Although I can't seem to find it on Lucy's KZbin channel, I did view it on another reaction.) Best regards, Hopelessly Addicted in Arizona

[@5pmevans]

Juliet “ Pie Jesu” is now out on KZbin!

[@iancave-nu1ff]

Hi, listened to it last night ,but it seems to have been taken down this morning, any thoughts,?--------------Ian.

[@Trevmom1]

I just heard Barbra Streisand's version of this song yesterday and there is no comparison. Lucy just does it better! No - this wasn't one of the songs that she performed at her concert but it was still an excellent show!

[@wilburfinnigan2142]

Juliet..... Lucy Thomas just released her second video/song from her Live Manchester concert, the final song of the concert, this AM 4/16/2024, the final song from ROSIE WE CAN CHANGE THE WORLD...!!!! and she talks some at the start, Check her out and also her opening song from the same concert, SOMEWHERE.. you are behind a couple songs !!!! thanks

[@briankrames1883]

Juliet, always a pleasure to hear your analysis of the great, Miss Lucy Thomas! All I have to state is this: 3:19 on this masterpiece is what separates Lucy from the pack........'nuff said

[@stephendixon7542]

Unchained melody dropped over the weekend. Another of Lucy's miracles! See and hear now Stunning!

[@pedromancenithe3rd]

Really enjoyed your reaction to this master class performance from the young Lucy. If you think this is impressive at such a young age then take a look at the song "One Day" when she was thirteen years old and as equally jaw dropping even without full blown belts. This video is a little hard to find so I've put the link below. Just as a matter of interest, Chris Broom uses KZbin to promote Lucy's phenomenal talent and wont block these videos of hers. Chris is a shrewd guy, slowly easing Lucy into the mainstream audience leading up to "Rosie the Musical" due to open later this year. Link to "One Day" kzbin.info/www/bejne/sIi5gYGepN5snM0

[@williamowsley9771]

a soprano doing that low F is insane

[@martinfranklin8922]

Need a box of tissues listening to Lucy and I’m an old man😂❤

[@YourOnlineSingingCoach]

She has gotten me good more than once lol 😭😹

[@Some_One_One]

- 3:18-4:55 "…she's straightening out some of these notes that might've naturally moved to vibrato"