YT48 Surah Al-Kahf (Surah 18): Did God Order Al Khidr to Kill a Young Boy? by Dr. Hany Atchan

[@geraldetienne1500]

"So we desired that 'their' lord give 'them'...Who's the 'their' or the 'them' that 'we' is referring to. You skipped over that part. If the parents are part of the 'we' shouldn't it say 'our' lord give 'us'? Please explain some more...

[@MarvelousQuran]

Great Question... See Verse 7:129: Moses is talking, but uses "Your lord" instead of "our lord." This "splitting" is a part of the locution of the Israelite community of which Moses was part. ANd this "splitting" is common throughout the Quran. Regards

[@astroflyinsights]

Their because it's their son.

[@Diamondraw4Real]

"Their" would be the parents just bc they are the ones who will get another child. They, all 3 in the group (if that's the meaning of "we") could desire that Allah gives the couple ("them") another child. Problem is I don't know Arabic grammar but it still seems to make logical sense. Maybe the Arabic needs more of an indepth study.

[@openreviews1209]

@@astroflyinsights yes

[@polashquadhi2330]

@@MarvelousQuran It's like an Army Officer is telling the soldiers, ''Oh soldiers,Your King has asked you to do this do that today. So we (alltogather) going to obey our King''. The wise man killed the Young Man with his parents. But the next child of parents were givent to the couple by their lord. The Wise Man wasn't part of this next child though the lord is also his lord. It was the parents and their lord, in fact everyone's lord who would give them the next child.

[@yasfi5196]

This channel really deserves 1 million subscribers.. Please keep on with your projects, and upload more often. Can't wait for another discoveries. Jazakallah

[@MarvelousQuran]

Wow, thank you! Plz spread the word. We have a lot of work to do. Regards

[@shahidachoudhury6925]

@@MarvelousQuran Yes, you and we have to.

[@abbynas9508]

rightly so brother, just watched two videos and am wowed, may Allah bless you and enlighten you more....

[@elfstar1313]

Yes, you are right that the word “we” “feared” could not be Allah included. As Allah is All Knowing (certainty), why would Allah need to be doubtful with “we feared” - answer is staring in our face.

[@rahmat9094]

SubhanAllah. May Allah reward you n increase u in guidance n protection dear sir.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Same to you

[@alhassani626]

@@MarvelousQuran Your view is also held by some of the Mutazila.

[@MarvelousQuran]

@Abdullah Rifat Muntasir You say: "Your view is also held by some of the Mutazila"... NOT TRUE!. The Mu3tazila did not have a Quranic methodology, extracted from within the Quran... They used "reason" as their primary guide. We do NOT accept reason as the primary guide.

[@sultanmahmood6396]

Jazakalla Dr Hany Atchan, and may Allahh Ta'ala bless you for your efforts explaining the fallacy of Tafseers.

[@sultana1486]

Shukran Dr. Atchan! I have always thought that translations of Allah SWT's words are too mundane and based on our understanding of Arabic but understanding Allah's words must be preceded by a serious attempt to understand Allah SWT. Your theory of Abrahamic locution makes a lot of sense!!

[@dr.mobarakali255]

Jazakum Allahu Khairan Shaikh. Very interesting revisit of this particular incident in the Glorious Qur'an. Allahumma Salli Ala Muhammad Wa Ale Muhammad.

[@MarvelousQuran]

You too bro

[@Globaltryk]

Thank you for doing these vids. I truly appreciate them :)

[@QuestionMark_119]

Thank you for the works you do and immense wisdom you bring to the viewers . Been following for last few years and enjoy all your explanations. Selam alaikhum from Florida

[@farouksheik7055]

Alhumdolillah.. Just discovered your channel. Really informative. My Lord, increase me in beneficial knowledge.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Thanks and welcome Please Sub, Like, and share. There is a lot more to come insha Allahh

[@drmdzakariahmdali6677]

Alhamdulillah. Very coherent and relevan interpretation.

[@sheikhrishad879]

Thanks for this informative and impactful video Dr. Hany. Whenver I read about Al-Khidr in tafseer, I questioned the arbitrariness involved in this incidence. In some books of tafseer, it is also said that Al-Khidr is an angel in the form of man. And this has given legitimacy for so many sufi orders across India for performing corrupt, malicious and forbidden practices in Islam. But now, Alhumdulillah, I have got my doubts cleared. Thanks.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@user-ff4zd7lh3q]

This is something I struggled with, Jzk for explanation!

[@SarveshTalekar77]

Salaamun Alaykum reading these comments feels so good Alhamdullilah

[@kaulathmohammed325]

Beautiful explanation.may Allah guide all of us Ameen

[@Abu-Hudhud]

Baarak Allahu feek Dr Hany. I read these verses many times but today I understood the real meaning of it.

[@MarvelousQuran]

You too bro

[@syarzasterisk]

You are doing an excellent job, I must thank you for explaining this to us

[@MarvelousQuran]

You are very welcome. Plz keep watching and spread the word. Regards

[@Diamondraw4Real]

@@MarvelousQuran I'm sharing to my friends inshaAllah. Not convinced but you brought up some interesting points.

[@gabiebachmat1811]

Beautfully explained!!, Allah does not fear and desire! Humans do! Allah is MAGNIFICENT!!!!!

[@selimcaliskan3866]

I'm afraid this explanation is incomplete. There's still missing information. The boy has had to do something that calls for execution. Leading your own parents astray is not a punishable crime of that caliber. Or is it?

[@MarvelousQuran]

@ Selim Caliskan Why the young man was murdered will be discussed in a later segment. The point of this segment was only: Did God order the killing? The answer is: No!

[@ainaltair3217]

wow! this is such an eye opener....have marked it in one the English translation of the Quran that I have

[@MesataKefe]

Selamunaleik Dr. Hany you made laugh so much!!! How we blindly ignored this simple question for thousand yrs. May Allah bless you more! !@

[@healthyforpurpose1898]

Subhanallah great explanation thanks you so much

[@peerallyshakeel8586]

May Allah give you long life to continue on the true path. Should translate in shaa ALLAH in French. May Allah give you the tools to do it very soon in shaa ALLAH

[@astroflyinsights]

This was my understanding when I first read the story with no preconceived notions.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Wonderful. Keep connecting with others in As-Sarh

[@ummerfarooq5383]

The arabic word خشْي refers to a type of fear, but when its written as خشِينا it refers to a feeling of being belittled and the hope of not being underestimated. And that which remains knows

[@hakimhazig]

Masha'Allah great content and to you're releasing these twice a day! Alhamdulillah.

[@MarvelousQuran]

More to come Insha Allah

[@nazneenbanu9644]

In number 4 (Justification), if the term 'we' is for the knowledgeable man and two parents, who is meant with the word 'them' (make them suffer)? If it means the parents, it seems to me that sentence is not correct. Please reply.

[@ShafilAhmed-li4do]

Good point. May Allah bless you

[@mohamedamin1411]

I love your explanation....May Allah give your more knowledge....jazzakallahu hairan

[@MarvelousQuran]

Thanks and welcome. Please subscribe, like, and spread the word. Regards

[@adnanadill]

The verse did not said how He ki lled the boy?? 18;74/80 So the boy died because of his just presence...... And use of plural form as فَخَشِينَا and فَأَرَدْنَا Means along with Khidr there was an invisible entity with him. وَأَمَّا الْغُلَامُ فَكَانَ أَبَوَاهُ مُؤْمِنَيْنِ فَخَشِينَا أَن يُرْهِقَهُمَا طُغْيَانًا وَكُفْرًا ‎﴿٨٠﴾ And the Gulam His parents are Momins thus we were afraid (Khidr and Angle) disgrace his parents and became rebel and disbeliever 17;80 It means he did not stran gled or shot or Stab bed the boy, but he has angle force with him that does taking of soul as Allah SWT regularly collect the souls of Humans.. And the boy which was not of Paradise became boy of paradise by their action.. ‏ فَأَرَدْنَا أَن يُبْدِلَهُمَا رَبُّهُمَا خَيْرًا مِّنْهُ زَكَاةً وَأَقْرَبَ رُحْمًا ‎﴿٨١﴾‏ Thus we (khidr and Angle) decided their lord replace him by one who is better than him and eligible for mercy. 18;81 The moral of the story is that if our children died in childhood that is better for them and for us as Allah Knows the best

[@abdulrahmanhassan1918]

SubhanaAllah. An eye opener channel. glad to come across this channel

[@HaiderAli-lh4qk]

Sir, U cleared one of the questions i had on my mind for a long time ! thanks

[@MarvelousQuran]

Glad to hear that

[@o___a_s_i_f]

Its only simple when allah allows it to be ! Best example . Alhamdulillah!

[@drimtiazahmed]

its an excellent explanation .WE feared THEIR LORD part is what i liked most .May Allahtallaha lead us to true goal.

[@kayc.8283]

I always kind of wondered if the son was maybe still pre puberty, so in this case, Allah wanted to spare the parents of the pain of his future rebellion knowing that he would burn in hell. So I always kind of thought the son being killed was a kind of bittersweet type of mercy for his own benefit in the future, as some parents on yawm al Qiyamah will most likely wish that their kids had been killed at a young age so they can escape the torment of their rebellion. Idk. Just my 2 cents.

[@kenkaneki9138]

I also understood it that way of course i read without tafsir so my knowledge is limited.

[@halimjaffar]

if this happened today...that knowledgeable man could go to prison...especially with that reasoning..😃

[@msc.fahmdyar1483]

Thank you brother for excellent explanation.

[@VigilanteMian]

Brother, this story may well have happened after Musa (peace be upon him) had already crossed the red sea with the children of Israel and the Pharaoh (Ramses II) had already been dead. Since these stories had to do with showing knowledge that Musa (peace be upon him) would not be able to cope up with killing an evil young man does not require much knowledge. It could be that Allah gave this man (Al Khidr) some knowledge of the future. Allah knows best.

[@MarvelousQuran]

You are correct. Moses is telling the story after crossing the sea, but the events are about what happened when he was young, before he left to Madyan. Great observation. Regards

[@ЕрболЕрбол-ф4г]

@@MarvelousQuran , what is the lesson to obtain from this story? Moses had these 3 situations happened in his life: He was thrown into the river. He killed a man. He helped young women. What is the point to repeat this situations in this story?

[@adrianabonitaaziz]

As Salamu Aleikum. This is very interesting . I've always wondered who are the " WE" in this Sura.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Salamun Alaykum

[@mhussain1618]

"WE" refers to the parents and the knowledgeable Man.

[@sarathkumarneelakannan1887]

We is plural of respect. Not plural of numbers. The knowledgeable man talking about himself in the honor ‘we’ islamqa.info/en/answers/606/the-meaning-of-the-pronoun-we-as-used-in-the-quran I initially thought this man got some brain. He is newbie to linguistic. He is misleading people...

[@parrotboypirate7357]

@@naza3086 dont push religion

[@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306]

@@naza3086 Show me in Quran where covering hair is mandatory

[@aluminaterock660]

Quran does not mention Dajjal but Prophet PBUH has spoken about it !!!

[@Sam-cz2bz]

Wow! Subha Allah, this brother has given a very clear analysis based clear evidence and interpretation. But I'm still surprised it want noticed by our earlier scholars and sheikhs.

[@MarvelousQuran]

We have a lot of work to do. Regards

[@shareefind]

Mr. Hany is going on wrong path, we already having people who tried to prove that they are more knowledgeable than previous Ulema, In India/Pakistan there are few people have done this, they want to interpret the Quran as they want based on logic and language, the end result was they cannot define the “Salah” and they created their own Salah, and many more deviation from the path of Aslaaf. These sort of people like Mr. Hany should be dealt with strict scrutiny. This is not new way of taught processing , people have done this before Mr. Hany and they fall

[@MarvelousQuran]

Wow. Sir: Are you so certain that you have seen a "guaranteed ticket to Jannah" for the people you follow? And how do you plan to deal with Mr. Hany?

[@xeedsenterprise505]

Dr Hany comes forward with the surah & ayah. The translation. What about you? You only claimed so and so, without any proof of any ayah ( ayat in Malay). See Al Furqan 52.

[@adnanadill]

Khidr AS and his 3 actions. 1) Accept little loss in starting, to save yourself from big loss later, as holing the boat. 2) Ki ll the evil in it first stages, before it develops and harms you in future. 3) Take precautionary measure before; so that it keeps you save in future, as building wall on treasure or property.

[@batul6771]

جزاك الله خير الجزاء . وجعلك على الصراط المستقيم واطال الله في عمرك . تحياتي لك

[@ilyassayed466]

Thanks doctor, you unlocked for me the puzzle of the boy murdered by 'we' with which I struggle for past 20 years.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306]

Thank you for this video well explained All praise and glory belong to God

[@MarvelousQuran]

You are welcome

[@ahmedazharanyl8903]

Could "we" mean khidhr's wish to abide by God's will and not even in speaking, remove or separate himself from God's will as he would ultimately commit this act without question? Seeing as God ordered him to do so. To which he in conversation rationalises by saying "we" meaning God inspired him to do this act but to bring this to fruition his human self would receive the order as a concern or a fear that he needed to act on to obey God. So this does not express that God feared or had concern but that he felt the need/concern/fear as per God's will for him to commit this necessary act.

[@ayoub7209]

The art of explanation 👏👏👏

[@DaNyAaLcEc]

So Allah tells us that his parents were believers and then tells us that they hired a hit man to kill their son and this was somehow a person given Knowledge above Moses which Moses needed to learn from...? Is that coherent?

[@mojahstreet4150]

Thank you Doctor.. Many people miss that.. May the creator of the universe bless you..

[@MarvelousQuran]

Welcome. May Allahh guide the believers, you and I among them insha Allahh

[@mojahstreet4150]

@@MarvelousQuran in sha Allah.. Aminnn...

[@khairilanwar-mr3ec]

Yeah...good lesson..i learned it...👍👍👍🙋‍♂️🇲🇾

[@danihassanart2573]

Subhan ALLAH.... any book or tafseer you have authored sir?? please write one so it will be a light for Ummah. insha ALLAH

[@MarvelousQuran]

Working on one. Insha Allahh will be available in the coming year, God willing. I need your duaa and your support. Please keep watching and spread the word. Regards

[@danihassanart2573]

@@MarvelousQuran insha ALLAH.. much awaited.

[@edkideys8953]

Why is this story even mentioned in the Quran? What is the moral or lessons to be learned from this story?

[@baharefitrat1529]

I am so happy and sad at the same time, I should have found this channel long ago ,,,

[@declassifiedMalaysia]

My new favourite channel. InshaAllah

[@MarvelousQuran]

Honor to hear from people like yourself. Regards

[@abdulhamid2784]

Hellooo My Brother Hj Hany keep the good work .Allah Almighty will help you in this world and the Hereafter.Mashallah

[@MarvelousQuran]

Many many thanks bro. Regards

[@ghazii1243]

Thank you sir, please continue so we can benefit from your knowledge ve jazak Allah u khayra

[@MarvelousQuran]

Thank you, I will insha Allahh

[@Lightbulb909]

I literally found your channel a few hours ago. I have a feeling that this is going to be a profound channel for me to learn from. For years I’ve referred to this account about God having knowledge of the future and killing the boy, not young man, and this video has shown me I’ve been gravely mistaken.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Welcome aboard

[@muhammadmujahidzakaria2602]

Still doesn't explain why one 'whom We had granted Our mercy and whom We had given knowledge of Our own' carrying out the killing. The only conclusion is that his actions are sanctioned by Allah, adhering to some kind of knowledge unknown to Moses, or even us all

[@MarvelousQuran]

We granted him knowledge does not mean he was perfect. The only perfect one is Allahh. Didn't the Quran lament Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) in some verses? Humans make mistakes, period! Didn't the prophet state the same about the fallibility of humans in a famous hadeeth??? However, in matters of scriptures, Messengers (I mean carriers of divine scripture) are Ma3sumoon (protected from mistakes). Regards

[@muhammadmujahidzakaria2602]

@@MarvelousQuran alright probably a good reasoning. So what kind of message is Allah trying to convey via this ayah, assuming that ur reasoning is true?

[@MarvelousQuran]

Ahhhh... Now you are asking with an open mind... Great! When we discuss the story of Mussa, you will see the whole picture insha Allahh... Keep watching Closeness to Allahh requires time and patience. It also requires intellectual discipline and the methodology of the Quran... Regards

[@PakTasliman]

a beautiful explanation.

[@aryanafares1834]

Salam alaikum, can you make a video about the people who worshipped the Cow(sura albaqara) Traditional understanding is that the ones who didnt worship the cow were to kill the ones who did. But to be honest I don't understand that.

[@muhammadislaam9911]

This explanation raises many questions and increases confusion, if this was the case then why Musa alaihi Salaam complained. All humans are under Sharia law would this be allowed with out a trial. According to other similar stories in Quran this knowledgeable person was not a human he was a angel obedient to Allah. This story is revealed by Allah Almighty in His last testament to demonstrate how he runs the affairs of the world. The lesson and the guidance for us is if something tragic happens there is something good and better for us hidden init that we cannot perceive and prevents greater loss.That we should be patient and put trust in Allah.

[@MarvelousQuran]

My brother! You are making so many assumptions on the basis that the story that the books of Tafseer told us was correct! It was not! We will have a chance to explain more in the new future insha Allahh

[@muhammadislaam9911]

@@MarvelousQuran This explanation is not based on any of the Tafsirs. It is based on Bani Israel and Musa alaihi Salaam stories mentioned many times in Quran. As everybody knows Bani Israel were persecuted by Ale Firoun. Bani Israel complained to Musa alaihi Salaam he advised establish Salat be patient and pray to Allah Almighty. Allah All-Wise assured Musa alaihi Salaam by demonstrating how he runs world's affairs and there is a wisdom and something good behind every unfortunate event. Similar to Hazrat Ibrahim alaihi Salaam in Surah Al-Baqrah were Allah demonstrates how he will bring dead to alive by four different birds. Also in same Surah Hazrat Uzair alaihi Salaam when he passes by a destroyed town. If one keeps whole of Quran specially stories of Bani Israel the purpose behind this story comes clear. Furthermore this angel did not eat or offered food to Musa alaihi Salaam and his companion. All other explanations don't clear all confusions and further raise many questions. Jewish narrations are misleading. Jazakallah khairan.

[@galib31]

When i was child my parents give me book titled by stories of prophets. There i found Kijir killed a boy, not a young man. Whatever that was misinterpreted. And that time & later whenever i recalled this story i was slightly confused that how could a child be accused for crime & moreover he even had not committed that crime. Thank you very much. Thank you very much.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Glad that we are helping in alleviating childhood trauma :). Thank you

[@anggasugih5303]

جزاكم الله أحسن الجزاء... from indonesia

[@MarvelousQuran]

You too . Thank you

[@bjjblackbelt1814]

And Allah said in Sura nisaa, whoever opposes the messenger after the guidance has been made clear upon them, and he takes a path other than the believers, we turn him to he has turned to and we throw him in hell... The believers here are the first believers, the companions of the prophet

[@MarvelousQuran]

@BJJ Black Belt You added "The believers here are the first believers, the companions of the prophet", as a condition that Allahh did not specify in the original aya...This is the fault in the argument that Imam Ash-Shaafi3i gave when he was cornered into coming up with a Quranic justification for Ijmaa3.... The Quran did not include this condition! And therefore, you conclude that only those people who were with the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) were "Mu'minum" believers, and others are not!!! But you forget another aya (4:94): Don't not say to anyone who offers you peace "You are not a believer!" Your argument is the way of those who want to fragment the Quran الذين جعلوا القرءان عضين Wake up my brother (I am assuming that you are a Muslim)... This channel will help you and help the Ummah

[@bjjblackbelt1814]

The basic and fundamental message Allah sent down to his prophets is tawheed. That is worshipping Allah alone without associating partners with him and knowledge of Allah’s names and attributes

[@itjalal]

Hmmm 🤔🤔 I am not convinced actually!! You are basically saying that in the first and third cases (the fishermen and the wall) God gave the 'knowledgeable man' some kind of knowledge, But in the second case he suddenly acted by himself!? And this particular case includes a murder of a young man!! And even if the young man was bad, does that considered a justification for killing him? And wasn't it better to try to convince him to right path instead of taking his life? And to prove your point you assumed that the man somehow knew the parents of the victim!! and lastly, how about "and I didn't do this upon my command" which refers to what happened in the three cases of course? Who's command is that?

[@MarvelousQuran]

Please watch it again because you may have missed some points. regards

[@MarvelousQuran]

@ FiZzY WiZzY LeMoN SqUeEzY These questions were answered in the video. Please watch it in full This video was NOT trying to explain the whole story in Surah Al-Kahf. It was only trying to answer one specific question: Did God order the knowledgeable man to kill a boy? A corollary was that most interpreters missed an important grammatical clue that clears this question totally... The rest of the story will become clearer when we discuss the story of Moussa insha Allahh. It was only a 16 minute video! And there is much we need to explain about the methodology and the Abrahamic locution before we can address the full story of Moussa. Regards

[@OmarAbdulMalikDHEdMPASPACPAPro]

What a profound explanation, mash'Allah! JazakhAllahKhair! I just subscribed! "Ameen" to your dua' at the end.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Welcome aboard!

[@hanaatc]

Macha'allah great content and explenation may god protect you

[@MarvelousQuran]

Thank you very much. Regards

[@dafitrasusanto]

glad to see your channel, keep your work and dont feel tire if our brother give you many stamp.hope Allah give us the right path..

[@MarvelousQuran]

Much appreciated. Plz sub, Like, and share. Regards

[@dafitrasusanto]

@@MarvelousQuran i have sub and like, thx

[@knightowl787]

Thank you for clearing up this issue. Very nice.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Glad it was helpful!

[@cidsignor6047]

Narrated Ubai bin Ka`b: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Once the Prophet (ﷺ) Moses stood up and addressed Bani Israel. He was asked, "Who is the most learned man amongst the people. He said, "I am the most learned." Allah admonished Moses as he did not attribute absolute knowledge to Him (Allah). So Allah inspired to him "At the junction of the two seas there is a slave amongst my slaves who is more learned than you." Moses said, "O my Lord! How can I meet him?" Allah said: Take a fish in a large basket (and proceed) and you will find him at the place where you will lose the fish. So Moses set out along with his (servant) boy, Yusha` bin Noon and carried a fish in a large basket till they reached a rock, where they laid their heads (i.e. lay down) and slept. The fish came out of the basket and it took its way into the sea as in a tunnel. So it was an amazing thing for both Moses and his (servant) boy. They proceeded for the rest of that night and the following day. When the day broke, Moses said to his (servant) boy: "Bring us our early meal. No doubt, we have suffered much fatigue in this journey." Moses did not get tired till he passed the place about which he was told. There the (servant) boy told Moses, "Do you remember when we betook ourselves to the rock, I indeed forgot the fish." Moses remarked, "That is what we have been seeking. So they went back retracing their footsteps, till they reached the rock. There they saw a man covered with a garment (or covering himself with his own garment). Moses greeted him. Al-Khadir replied saying, "How do people greet each other in your land?" Moses said, "I am Moses." He asked, "The Moses of Bani Israel?" Moses replied in the affirmative and added, "May I follow you so that you teach me of that knowledge which you have been taught." Al-Khadir replied, "Verily! You will not be able to remain patient with me, O Moses! I have some of the knowledge of Allah which He has taught me and which you do not know, while you have some knowledge which Allah has taught you which I do not know." Moses said, "Allah willing, you will find me patient and I will disobey no order of yours. So both of them set out walking along the seashore, as they did not have a boat. In the meantime a boat passed by them and they requested the crew of the boat to take them on board. The crew recognized Al-Khadir and took them on board without fare. Then a sparrow came and stood on the edge of the boat and dipped its beak once or twice in the sea. Al-Khadir said: "O Moses! My knowledge and your knowledge have not decreased Allah's knowledge except as much as this sparrow has decreased the water of the sea with its beak." Al- Khadir went to one of the planks of the boat and plucked it out. Moses said, "These people gave us a free lift but you have broken their boat and scuttled it so as to drown its people." Al-Khadir replied, "Didn't I tell you that you will not be able to remain patient with me." Moses said, "Call me not to account for what I forgot." The first (excuse) of Moses was that he had forgotten. Then they proceeded further and found a boy playing with other boys. Al-Khadir took hold of the boy's head from the top and plucked it out with his hands (i.e. killed him). Moses said, "Have you killed an innocent soul who has killed none." Al-Khadir replied, "Did I not tell you that you cannot remain patient with me?" Then they both proceeded till when they came to the people of a town, they asked them for food, but they refused to entertain them. Then they found there a wall on the point of collapsing. Al-Khadir repaired it with his own hands. Moses said, "If you had wished, surely you could have taken wages for it." Al-Khadir replied, "This is the parting between you and me." The Prophet added, "May Allah be Merciful to Moses! Would that he could have been more patient to learn more about his story with Al-Khadir."

[@MarvelousQuran]

I am aware of such Myths and made-up concoctions. Please watch the video carefully so that you see the evidence for yourself. Concoctions could not have possibly come from Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) as I demonstrated in the video. Regards

[@fauzulazmi8209]

so the hadist is fake?

[@wajahpertiwi8990]

its the most make sense explanation i've ever heard about 'killing-the-boy' ... thanks ...

[@MarvelousQuran]

Welcome

[@bjjblackbelt1814]

Another point. Allah said, and we have sent to you (Mohamed) to the thikr (koran) so that you may explain to people what has been sent down to them and so they may think. Koran 16:44 The prophet discharged the trust and explained the Koran to his companions. And they discharged the trust and transmitted what they learned to the ppl. And those righteous ppl afterwards did the same

[@MarvelousQuran]

Your translation is inaccurate. Insha Allahh you will keep watching with open mind. Regards

[@A6A114]

سلام عليكم - الحمد لله - السيد/ دكتور هاني.

[@meelash1]

من قال في القرآن برأيه فليتبوء مقعده من النار. You are misdaaq of this statement unless you immediately repent. You are preparing for yourself a bed of fire.

[@akhalif579]

Insha allah baraka allahu fik. I understood very clearly. Thanks.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Glad to hear that. Thank you

[@jamilhassan5059]

To me, why didn't anyone see this when it's staring in your face? It's a test for me as to my relationship with Allah. It's close to Kiamat, thus the secrets are revealed one by one.

[@leandrojulian7155]

Very good interpretation and conclusion

[@MarvelousQuran]

We knew you would like it. Alhamdulillah

[@bikkohoro8448]

Subhaan`Allah, my brain just boosted with vitamins.

[@justfun9971]

Zulkarnain and story of lot , can you make video on it

[@MarvelousQuran]

Insha Allah.

[@mfayeeg]

Salam, Excellent finding. 100% agreed. If you are going to do a video on Zulkarnain, I humbly request you to contact me once. I have the highly valuable details. InsyaAllah would like to share.

[@faizannadir1623]

If we means parents and 'the knowledge man' Then why does it say 'And we desired that their lord give them(parents) instead of him(young man) one who us better in purity, and nearer in mercy.' I am a bit confused why it says 'their lord', shouldn't it be 'our lord.' Since both the parents and 'The knowledge man' are believers.

[@mfayeeg]

@@faizannadir1623 I thought the same but my gut feeling says that why the "knowledgeable person" said "their" lord instead of "our" lord is because he was speaking to Musa PBUH at which time he knew Musa yet to attain the prophethood or yet to believe in the same lord that he was referring to hence he excluded "Musa" in the speech.

[@al-ayattv8559]

Alhamdulillah again!!!

[@anjinganjingan1764]

The problem is, if we interpret that "we" in the verse is "Al-Khdir" and the parents, it simply contradicts with the next verse which says "and I did not do this upon my own command". I still believe that Allah told "Al-Khidr" to kill that young man to teach Musa a.s about Ba'da.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Please watch it again, and read the top comment in the comment stream

[@quadir777]

Salamun alaikum The way you explain is awesome..Mashaallah

[@MarvelousQuran]

Salamun Alaykum... Thank you so much 🙂

[@billi16]

I have a question,why do we have to take the meaning of the word killed literally...what if the word killed means to "kill" as in to get rid of the rebellious behavior and the disbelieving tendency and the young man would stop being rebellious and would be a believer again hence be like a "new transformed son" to the parents.

[@shoaibahmed5635]

Keep it up marvelous Koran I know you deserve more subscribers but it takes time to make people rational most of people are traditionalist.

[@moedot7]

Salaamun Alaykum. The fact that they also attributed 'fear' to Allah is absolutely insane!

[@raniramo]

Thank you Dr. Hany. One question. After your explanation, I find it hard to relate his other doing like breaking the ship and rebuilding a wall to this matter in this specific aya. In his other doing, he seems like he did good deeds. Can you please explain that too?

[@MarvelousQuran]

Insha Allahh we will have a special segment in the future for the full story of Mussa, including this story in Surah Al-Kahf. There are many other concepts that we need to explore before we can present this story I hope you remain patient because we are revealing the concepts in a sequence to build on such concepts, one at a time. Regards

[@raniramo]

@@MarvelousQuran thank you. Insha Allah Patience we shall have

[@AbbaJifarTube]

I think we feared refers to indirectly people of that region and Khadir acting behalf of them guided by Allah

[@furqaanthe-criterion9021]

Absolutely logical explanation

[@MarvelousQuran]

Glad it was helpful! Plz spread the word. Regards

[@drkhan5501]

With a lot of gymnastics and sweating, you jumped over "their" and "them" in the sentences to deduce what you have assumed at the outset.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Plz check the comments. The answer is provided in detail. Regarding the gymnastics, I hope that you focus on the evidence... In any case check out Verse 7:129... If you know any Arabic, and if you claim to follow the manner of our beloved Prophet (PBUH), I expect an apology. May Allahh forgive you Regards

[@amjadsaleem1270]

The conversation is taking place between the person (I'll call him Khidhr although I know he is not named) and Moses(AS) Khidher is telling Moses(AS) that we desired (i.e Khidher and the man's parents) that their Lord replaces for those two (here plural term used for two is Yabdilahumah) better in purity and nearer in Mercy. Using their Lord is not problematic.

[@aq_ahmed]

Either you did not listen carefully or your heart is sealed.

[@MarvelousQuran]

@ the legend We used the name "the knowledgeable man". We did not reject it. We also explained that "I did not do it of my own command" applies only to the last incident... ANd by the way: It is not a wall. We never said it was a wall... Jidaar indicates something else as we will see in a future segment. Thank you

[@utaraselatan4910]

I said to Ibn `Abbas, "Nauf Al-Bikali claims that Moses, the companion of Al-Khadir was not the Moses of the children of Israel" Ibn `Abbas said, "The enemy of Allah (Nauf) told a lie." The name of Khidr appeared in Bukhari in Book of Tafsir.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Plz watch a few more videos. Things will become clearer insha Allahh

[@zahidulislamimran5664]

Shubhan-Allah thank you for sharing this

[@MarvelousQuran]

welcome

[@KK3ClanProject]

how is it justified to help others kill their son?

[@md.nazimkhan5731]

thanks for this informative video.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@yettymualim713]

InsyaAllah I am able to explain who the knowledgeable man was. Biidznillah.

[@chinsoonho1855]

Salamun Alaikum. I have always loved the story about Moses and the MAN WITH NO NAME. The fishermen must have been upset when they could not go out to catch fish but what the fishermen did not know was that the BAD thing that happened was actually a GOOD thing as their lives were saved. The orphans was arranged by GOD to inherit what their father had hidden in the Wall that was able to fall down. Their father must have asked GOD to safeguard his gift to his children as the people in that town were evil and did not even offer food nor drink to Moses and the MAN WITH NO NAME. Previously I had trouble about the Young Man being killed until YOU DR HANY pointed out that "WE" was the parents of the youth and the MAN WITH NO NAME. I have previously thought that "WE" was GOD and the MAN WITH NO NAME. Thank you very much. Yes indeed. There are many cases where the parents sometimes wish that their child was never born or how some parents wished that their child die... Example where the child grows up to be a gambler and borrows money from loan sharks and the parents time and again have to bail their child out of these type of problems. Excellent Video. May the Good Lord look after you and may you have long life Sir. And thank you once again for such an enlightening video on the MAN WITH NO NAME.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@aq_ahmed]

Very plausible interpretation. When ever I read or hear these verses on the killing of the innocent boy, it scared the hell out of me. Now I know. The fact that the parents and the man plotted the killing because of his ungodly behaviour make sense.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@MarvelousQuran]

(You changed your screen name to Sword of Allah)

[@aq_ahmed]

@@MarvelousQuran yes Dr. I changed name and picture😁

[@wahebtoodayan8088]

Dr Hany, l think you are suggesting that it was right to kill that person? Please let us know what is the lesson or purpose of the story ?

[@MarvelousQuran]

You are thinking wrong! Stating that a murder took place DOES NOT MEAN I AM CONDONING IT!

[@salahudeenm.s.6775]

Your efforts are appreciated. The youth was murdered not by single man but a group of men of the town including the man khilir.we desired means the murdrers desired .Allah knows.

[@MarvelousQuran]

In surah al-Kahf, it clearly refers to one person doing the killing, not a group

[@aminahbergliotrolsdorph7557]

سلام عليكم.. Allah Is Able to Create As He Want.. So.. Obviously its a message here. Also Its Matters we don't understand but Trust Allah..