Зачем нужен Сократический диалог и демонстрация

Беседа с Юрием Ветютневым - философом, 13 лет практикует метод Сократического диалога. Рассказываем, как метод помогает в жизни, а также Юрий говорит с одним из участников и объясняет, как задавать вопросы.
Мы делаем группы по Сократическому диалогу для бизнеса со старейшими практиками этого метода в России - Юрием Ветютнем и Андреем Макаровым.
Сократический диалог - это основа мышления и коммуникации. Навыки помогают быстрее и дешевле решать бизнес-задачи для предпринимателей, коучей, трекеров, менеджеров, терапетов (помогающие практики начинают круче помогать и растить чек). Если хотите прокачаться, как специалист, то это мета-навык.
Тут больше видео от Юрия Юрьевича: / @tishetishe_club
Здесь о нас почитать: annmiro.notion...
А тут следить за интересными мыслями: t.me/iamsocrates
А записаться в группу на месяц или на полное занятие можно у Платона: t.me/iamplato

[@YURMAIL]

Возникает вопрос - зачем всё это?

[@Ravidin]

Интересная беседа. Спасибо)

[@podidogadaysya]

🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 02:29 🎙️ The presenter encourages active participation and questions from the audience during the presentation. 03:11 🧑‍🏫 The speaker, along with Yuri, has experience in practicing Socratic dialogue and aims to share its benefits with others. 04:22 📚 The origin of the practical philosophy of Socratic dialogue is described, starting from France and leading to Russia. 08:23 🤔 Questions help identify and understand the real problem, preventing the substitution of genuine issues with unrelated solutions. 09:59 💡 It's essential to use questions to discover the nature of a problem and select the appropriate method or solution rather than relying on what is familiar. 11:19 🍲 The analogy of eating soup with a fork or spoon emphasizes the importance of using the right tool (question) to deal with a particular problem effectively. 12:31 💡 By using questions, problems can be identified, named, and turned into understood problems with solutions. 16:04 🧠 Socratic dialogue leads to frequent insights and everyday discoveries, making it a valuable method for both philosophy and practical problem-solving. 16:46 🧙 Socratic dialogues keep philosophical inquiry and problem-solving exciting by allowing new ideas and meanings to emerge effortlessly. 19:18 🎓 The approach to teaching is centered on the principle of maximum experience, allowing participants to dive deep into topics that concern them, practice skills, and gain insight. 22:14 👥 Encouraging criticism and constructive feedback enhances the quality of group discussions and problem-solving. 32:50 🚦 In Socratic dialogue, pausing and contemplating the purpose (or goal) behind your actions can be valuable, even though it might seem like a delay. 34:20 🤔 Reflecting on the reason for your actions and temporarily pausing can help ensure that your efforts are directed effectively. 35:43 🧠 Recognizing and challenging presuppositions, like the belief that stopping is negative, can lead to a more nuanced understanding of your actions. 38:25 🤩 Embracing the uncertainty of a question, without rushing to answer it, can be a valuable experience, and not knowing everything can be a beautiful aspect of exploration and learning. 44:33 🧩 In some cases, the desire for a complete answer may stem from a reluctance to accept uncertainty and not necessarily a belief in an all-encompassing response. 45:48 💡 Artur's hesitation to accept the answer that he works for money may stem from a desire for a more comprehensive and abstract explanation of his motivations. 47:30 🤔 Some people may hesitate to acknowledge that they work for money due to societal pressures or a conflict between financial gain and self-realization. 50:09 🧩 The response "for money" may be seen as too specific, and Artur might be seeking a fuller, more comprehensive response, even though it's not required for understanding. 52:48 🧠 The primary goal of a Socratic dialogue isn't to find a direct answer to an initial question, such as one's true motivation. Instead, it aims to problematize, identify contradictions, and explore underlying issues. 54:21 💡 To resolve a problem, you must first appreciate and love the problem itself, and the process of examining it is more valuable than the solution. 55:32 🏠 Trying to see a problem from different angles is useful, but to do that, you need to understand what the problem is in the first place. 56:33 🤯 Socratic dialogues often employ the technique of "conceptualization," where complex ideas are condensed into single words to facilitate discussion and exploration. 58:00 🤯 In a Socratic dialogue, summarizing or condensing complex thoughts into a single word can help explore the underlying issues. For Arthur, "satisfaction" emerged as a summary of what previously inspired him. 59:15 🧐 Various hypotheses are proposed to understand Arthur's motivation, including the idea that he might not consciously realize he's working for money. 01:00:43 🎯 When setting goals, simpler ones are often easier to formulate, but Arthur's desire for complexity and the need to include many elements in one goal can create challenges. 01:03:19 🤔 The dialogue demonstrates the use of problematization and conceptualization to understand Arthur's situation, connecting the initial question of his motivations with his inherent maximization tendencies. 01:04:28 🤔 In Socratic dialogues, the original question asked by a person may not be the most important. It often comes from their perspective and beliefs. The goal is to explore unexamined aspects and discover hidden problems. 01:05:09 🤯 Understanding why someone is asking a question and what their goal is can be more enlightening than directly answering their question. 01:08:44 🧐 People have known problems and unknown problems. It's useful to address both, even if the original question isn't the most critical issue. 01:09:36 🧭 Socratic dialogue aims to open up new perspectives and understand unknown problems, rather than just providing straightforward answers. 01:13:35 🛠️ Socratic dialogue relies on various tools, such as problem identification, problematization, and conceptualization, to facilitate meaningful conversations and insights. 01:15:18 🤔 A key part of Socratic dialogue involves questioning and delving into the respondent's desires and conflicts, which might not be apparent in their initial questions. 01:15:47 🌟 Conceptualization in Socratic dialogue means simplifying complex situations into concise terminology that can serve as a foundation for further discussion. 01:19:07 💬 Analyzing one sentence or phrase from a person can provide valuable insights into their mental landscape and thought processes, assisting in understanding how they perceive their situation. 01:20:33 🧠 The primary goal of Socratic dialogue is to uncover a person's mental structure, including their desires, motivations, and thought patterns. 01:21:14 🤯 Consultants should not assume they've fulfilled a client's request based on their explicit statements; there may be unspoken or hidden aspects to their needs that must be uncovered. 01:23:20 ❓ It's essential to question assumptions about blame and the necessity of action in client interactions, as these can be subjective and require further exploration. 01:25:57 🧐 Verification is a powerful technique in Socratic dialogue where hypotheses emerging during the conversation need to be promptly checked. Making errors during verification is relatively low risk. 01:28:05 📅 Consider joining a trial session to explore and practice the Socratic dialogue method. Different facilitators have their unique approaches, and you can find what suits you best. 01:30:06 🕵️‍♂️ Socratic questioning can help individuals delve deeper into their beliefs and thought processes to find greater clarity and understanding. 01:31:16 🤔 Socratic dialogue can uncover the underlying motivations and perspectives behind a wide range of questions, helping to reach a profound understanding. 01:31:29 🤔 Socratic dialogue doesn't have a clear endpoint; it's an ongoing process of exploration. The emphasis is on gaining insights rather than achieving a finite result. 01:34:38 🧘 Socratic dialogue is akin to the practice of the "dead samurai" principle, where one approaches discussions with a clear mind and focuses on reasoning rather than emotions. 01:35:30 🎯 The outcomes of Socratic dialogue can be measured in the context of specific sessions or series of sessions with clients. It often involves identifying key issues and working on them incrementally. There is no ultimate endpoint, but rather intermediate results. 01:36:24 ⚔️ The concept of the "dead samurai" in Socratic dialogue is akin to entering discussions with a clear and rational mind, free from personal biases and emotions, focusing on pure reasoning. 01:36:56 💡 Embracing the "dead samurai" philosophy, where one approaches death with rationality and without fear, is a key concept in Socratic dialogue. Death can be seen as something indifferent, and this mindset allows for more profound discussions. 01:40:13 🧐 Socratic dialogue differs from tracking in that it encourages clients to find and legitimize their own problems through questioning, making the process more client-driven and the issues more genuine. 01:42:06 💡 In Socratic dialogue, focusing on a specific, practical goal can limit the exploration of broader philosophical questions. However, having a clear mission or goal is important for the context in which Socratic dialogue is being used. 01:43:58 🔄 Reconnecting with the mission or goal at the end of the process helps evaluate the impact of the dialogue and how it contributes to the overall objective. 01:45:17 👥 Socratic dialogue is about collective thinking and reflection on a subject, making it a versatile tool that can be applied to various areas such as business, personal issues, philosophy, and more. 01:46:44 🧒 Socratic dialogue can be particularly effective with children, as they are often more open to engaging in the process and can benefit from the self-reflection it encourages. 01:47:19 🤔 Socratic dialogue principles can be applied to self-reflection by simulating internal dialogues, questioning, and hypothesis testing to enhance self-awareness and decision-making. 01:50:23 👥 Socratic dialogue helps improve self-control over subconscious processes and elevates the level of self-awareness, contributing to better emotional management and life quality. Made with HARPA AI