Kimblee vs Scar

[@78453ful]

一期「ああ。覚えてますよ、『その傷』」 原作「ええ。覚えてますよ、『その顔』」 似たような台詞だが、同時に一期と二期のキンブリーの違いが顕著に現れてるよな

[@珠奼頽縷]

ナスの森 どういう違い？

[@KT-nx3mq]

1期は爆弾魔で2期は美学を持ってるよね

[@破壊神だぶるぜぇーた]

褸鵄黼閼 一期はただのクズ

[@jacktheripper8679]

1期はオリジナル 2期は原作再現ってとこかな、 因みにキンブリーは一度顔を見たらしっかりと覚えるという天才ですw

[@1218-q9o]

確か旧の放映時点じゃキンブリーは原作の方だと名前だけ出てた程度だったから、中身は完全にオリジナルなキャラとして登場させたと、どっかで見たような。

[@joer8954]

Pretty fucking crazy how Scar basically just liquifies all those chimeras like he’s simply swatting away bugs, fma 2003 was brutal.

[@フェイスタオル-w4u]

軍服を着崩す、チンピラみたいな見た目でも敬語で話す。かっこいいな。

[@nenekokuroneko]

こっちのキンブリーは原作とは反対の虚無主義なんだが、これはこれでいいのよね。一期にあってる。

[@Phoenix0F8]

0:30 Kimblee's reaction to his impending fate is about the same as a normal person would have to burning their toast in the morning

[@Perkyguy]

" Category Comedy"

[@Siegberg91]

It is if you are Kimblee

[@eradict]

@@Siegberg91 He's Greed. See the name?

[@eradict]

@Uriel Carlos what's this, double bot?

[@prachetasnayse9709]

It’s really good abridged material

[@TheDeadpools1]

I like that it was kimblee who made scar’s scar (I know in brotherhood he was also the responsible but here it shows how he plays with his victims and deliberately made the scar )

[@xochiltmorenodawkins2589]

yess

[@123account3]

キンブリーの時のちょっと低めのうえだゆうじさんの声がめちゃくちゃ好き 他は低音か可愛い声が多いけど、もっとこのくらいの声聞きたい

[@dante22723]

Kimblee in 2003 is so one dimensional when compared to brotherhoods kimblee

[@jesterfromthecave6691]

His design is way more badass though. They just didn’t have as big a reason to focus on him in 2003

[@kefkapalazzo1]

I mean yeah I think he’s just as cool though. Sometimes simplicity can trump trump complexity. And besides, I like complete psychopaths in fiction. They’re a wild card

[@Onigirli]

2003 Kimblee deserves some credit for turning Al into a fucking bomb

[@craigyoung2261]

It is possible to over-egg the pudding. Complexity for the sake of it is just bad story telling.

[@kdragonballz]

Dante D'amiko what was so complex about brotherhood envy both killed for the eultz

[@Homeofking]

これもだけど原作であってもおかしくない展開を結構やってんだよな1期は

[@RoesRoyal]

あれ？2期でこの声「大好きっす……ボイン！！」とか言ってなかった？

[@PianoChannel_Sakana]

ほんとだwwwww ここで言われるまで全く気付かなかった………！

[@warrior4408]

しかしキンブリーといい平穏な暮らしがしたい人といいなぜ爆発する能力を持ってる奴はサイコパスなんだよ…… まあキンブリーは別格だけど

[@The_BEST_Rookie_Cop]

0:01(Kimblee)" Are all of you going to run like cowards?" 1:46 *starts running from Scar*

[@roudoku7956]

二期も一期も恵まれた作品だよなぁ

[@gascougascounizat8961]

I much prefers the Brotherhood Jolf.J.Kimblee

[@joeystrike]

@Maruigi17 LMAO

[@seiraj.loyard3331]

Hemm

[@kyleh1494]

*Solf

[@danielbrown8071]

皮肉にもキンブリーの人間爆弾理論のおかけでエドワードはグリードとスロウスを倒すことができた。

[@tarotanaka8428]

1期のキンブリーは徹頭徹尾悪役で素晴らしいね 2期みたいな上品さは欠片もない、まさしく外道 1期の雰囲気に合ってる

[@ダイパキッズ皆56し]

taro tanaka こういうＴＨＥ悪党って感じのキャラってファンつくよね

[@Stone-Henge]

中途半端に良い奴やるとダメになるもんなぁ

[@orechan_black]

二期ンブリーは芯を通した良い悪役で、一期ンブリーは最後の最後まで爆弾狂なの好き

[@sbh5954]

福神漬けー シャア・アズナブル的なね

[@1218-q9o]

@@ダイパキッズ皆56し 同じ土6で言うところのサーシェスみたいな

[@bluesky5103]

あぁ^～いい感触だ(脚フェチ)

[@弾球目次録]

一期のキンブリー、カスだけど好き スカーはぬーべーの声だな　笑

[@とっとこハス太郎-t7n]

あ～たがら腕もお揃いで右側なのか

[@プリンライス]

オレもうえだゆうじさんのキンブリーが好きだわ

[@ad9834]

何だかんだ、一期の方がシックな雰囲気で好きだったな。ドイツに行く劇場版も。

[@EvilRyuGuy]

I don't know. He did much better here against Scar than in their Brotherhood train fight, and Scar didn't even have the stone absorption advantage there.

[@Sunaki1000]

He was years in Prison

[@jacksons6377]

He had a philosopher’s stone

[@thelaughingman6975]

Scar is physically more capable and the dude kept up with Wrath in Brotherhood. Even though he was weak from Buccaneer, they said that he still seemed impossible to defeat but Scar kept up. So I would like to say that Scar in Brotherhood is stronger than this one. Also the fight in Brotherhood was on a train.

[@whichDude]

@@thelaughingman6975 Legit. Bradley straight up speed blitzs a melee specialist like Lan Fan were she couldn't even react to it. Ling and Scar were only characters shown that could successfully react and deflect attacks from him. Brotherhood Scar could probably beat every 2003 character except maybe Pride and Lust. We never see Pride go all out, and 2003 Lust seemed pretty good at combat.

[@manofwisdom000]

@@whichDude Physical development is not character development.

[@kristinaxfrost]

Scar looks so much younger in the 2003 anime than Scar in the manga + 2009 anime! (sorry, stating the obvious ^^)

[@mrcocoloco7200]

There is no need to apologize.

[@PoptartIsBallin]

Nah Manga/Brotherhood Scar looks fuckin yolked

[@spaceocean2530]

He is younger actually. In Brotherhood, Scar was an adult when the Ishvalan genocide happened. He was also a protector, so to speak. Scar in this series was about Edward's age, and very clearly a civilian. Thats why he has a different body type than Scar from brotherhood.

[@Mickey-js9qx]

In my opinion he looks better younger

[@equivalentexchangeisalie5726]

@@spaceocean2530 He wasn't Edward's age. Ed was 15, Scar is mid 20s. At least a 10 year age difference

[@llccvv]

アルただの足手まといじゃね

[@take81019]

1期は等価交換の否定。 原作は等価交換の肯定。

[@danielbrown8071]

一期は毎回毎回OPで等価交換の原則を説いてたのに最後に否定するって深い！

[@jppcouto]

the 2 versions are masterpieces

[@papermachete8071]

True

[@dilucktick4]

Sim

[@MadnessXMedia]

Agreed

[@MaxFalange]

no

[@MaxFalange]

@Lexie Dreemurr ok

[@girazyo]

1期は並行世界の概念があるから面白い

[@友輝-j9d]

スカーの声は置鮎龍太郎さんが 合いすぎてる

[@なにはともあれ-c4g]

キンブリーのこえかっこええ、、、

[@sufiblacksongkok]

At this point of the series, Scar and Alphonse came a long way from just being a refugee, a soul-knight and a prisoner...

[@Grudgebearer47]

For some reason, Japan was brave to air this episode in a timeslot geared to kids.

[@djordjecalosevic9044]

How didn't Kimble noticed giant transmutation cirlce he was standing on?

[@BardockSkywalker]

It's Called Anime Logic

[@snowlover1037]

Or he never focused looking at the ground

[@cosmicfeargarou4592]

You dont look at ground when your opponent is Scar.

[@user-wk6tp1og3l]

@@cosmicfeargarou4592 yeah or else he might make ur head-asplode

[@mouadchaglalchimistefullme6116]

Bradley say to him to just kill edward if he try to stop the transmutation lmao

[@はいはいつよいつよい]

やっぱ一期の方がダークファンタジーっぽくて好きだ。 暗い話は一期、ギャグとか少年漫画的なノリは原作が良い

[@5秒で描ける先輩]

00:40 やはり貴様カッ↑で声出して笑ったww

[@torreyance2468]

damn it alfonse you cost scar his arm with all that talking and getting in the way.

[@K.1003battery]

2:12 キンブリー「スカーおらんやん、どこいったん？」

[@uta1449]

一期やと何かスカーとアル仲良かったよな

[@toro19870519]

同じ「弟」って立場が強調されてましたね

[@キングうさぎ]

@@toro19870519 「弟」という立場を強調するために、スカーは原作よりも若くてイケメンにキャラデザインされたって聞いた

[@toro19870519]

@@キングうさぎ しっかりとコンセプトが練られてたんですね。 じぶんも兄弟の1番下なんで、一期のスカーにはなんだか惹かれるところがありました。

[@キングうさぎ]

@@toro19870519 ですね！一期のスカーが最期につぶやいた「エルリック兄弟は互いが互いのために生きている、俺も兄さんに愛していると言いたかった」という言葉が個人的にとても印象に残っています。

[@魔神王-f3y]

1期も原作もどっちも面白かったな〜

[@キングうさぎ]

うえだゆうじの演技がいい

[@You-Tube-n5k]

This is a hot take, but I honestly really like 2003 Kimblee (kimbley). Despite being less of a fleshed out character than his Mangahood version, I honestly really felt his presence here since he had a bit more to do in the story. Super intimidating.

[@manofwisdom000]

He went out pathetically in the mangahood version though.

[@キョン-u8d]

キンブリーの髪型ええ感じやんけ

[@理性のトビラ]

キョン 分かる(っ´ω`c)

[@_nameno7052]

せや、真似したろ！ 「」

[@志々雄真実-t8j]

理想と現実の違い って感じがするぜ 理想の結末が二期 現実の結末が一期 戦い方も一期は実に現実味を帯びた立ち回りで 走り方や臨場感もリアルな現実の味がするが, 二期はまさに王道漫画の味がするからな キンブリーは死に方は一期がリアルだな 二期のセリムの精神世界で死霊の渦に去るのも良いが一期が俺は気に入ったぜ♪

[@razk3l]

This series was not for the faint of heart

[@ロイS]

2:58国家錬金術師がこんなチープな罠にかかるか？

[@GORIP4N]

スカーの声優は置鮎さんのが好き

[@けるく-g2r]

正直触覚気になりすぎてたから一期ンブリー結構好きだわ

[@stellarcane1988]

Kowai

[@happy-make-8865]

イチキップリンみたい

[@堕天の王-z1j]

やっぱ、おもろいで！こうしてみると、ハガレンって結構古いアニメなんやなぁ

[@sousiminasiro6951]

堕天の王 こっち旧アニメの方だしね

[@kinngu1997]

このハガレン小さい頃見たからほぼ記憶にないけど、これはなんか覚えてる

[@chi__gyu_ham]

グルメ細胞活性化しそうな声やな

[@消えない炎の快男児]

釘パンチ出しそうな声してますね。

[@バインド耐性]

なんかナイフとフォークをギャリギャリしそうな人ですよね

[@茶カテキン-j3p]

2:07なんか草

[@くまじ-p7u]

まさかキンブリーのうえださん、2期でハボックさん演るとは。

[@edl4767]

Best versions of Kimblee and Scar imo

[@子宮マルクス経済学者]

赤石取り込んで悶えてる時にトドメ刺せば勝てたのにね

[@japarevoltado1779]

A masterpiece indeed. I like the two versions. They are both perfect. For me,indeed.😊❤❤❤

[@おあ-s4h]

キンブリーがハボックにしか見えない(笑)

[@コゲミンコゲテルト]

トリコさんなにしてるんだ

[@争いよ止まれ]

？？？「コマツゥ！」

[@桂田冬彦]

今の夕方の地上波では放送できないなあ

[@kkazaki23]

1期のスカーとキンブリーの顔好き

[@芹-i8z]

ハボックとは全然声音が違うけど同じ人だなと分かるのがすごい、ブロだなという感じ

[@マメ-f1m]

1期キンブリー、2期のハボックと同じ声優なんだね

[@Slime_ZundaMochi]

古い方のハガレンってキャラクターの顔立ちが全体的にシュッとしてるよね

[@xxxsuisenxxx47]

わかる 新は全体的にふっくらしたキャラデザ こっちの方がハガレンぽい

[@user-bq3id8dz5m]

@@xxxsuisenxxx47 原作ではどちらかと言えば顔丸いけど

[@user-fr5tn5ml6i]

こっちの方が大人っぽい感じはある

[@yg-rc5rm]

5:00 吉良吉影で草ww

[@teddie.647]

Ngl this is one of the best fights from the 2003 anime

[@JonP1245]

Nah Ed vs greed for me

[@鈴乃音-i2n]

このキンブリー、NARUTOの干柿鬼鮫とダブるww

[@背猫]

2:09 ここのカメラワークなんかおもろい

[@danielbrown8071]

わかる！ 小学生の時見たけど今でも記憶に残ってる。

[@JeeReeAnimation]

From the placement of the blood, and from how all that blood shoots out, it's safe to assume that Scar spattered Kimblee's freakin' heart! Talk about brutal!

[@The_BEST_Rookie_Cop]

Well I mean Scar does blow peoples brains to bits lol

[@abandonallhope.1040]

How the hell did he survive something like that?

[@SolidSnake240]

I love that we got a prolonged fight between them in FMA 2003. I love both versions but i wanted to see them actually fight in Brotherhood.

[@psychee1]

I saw fma before fmaB and while I think that Brotherhood is better in Most ways there are a few things I liked better in fma. Greed in the first series was awesome from start to finish. In Brotherhood it took awhile for him to become as awesome. Lust was more interesting in fma, Greed's crew got more screentime and Bradley revealed his eye much later which resulted in one hell of a WTF moment. Generally though, Brotherhood felt better.

[@dud9895]

I agree.

[@BigBoss-uq2do]

Fma is for adults. Brotherhood is geared more towards children.

[@manolgeorgiev9664]

@@BigBoss-uq2do laughs (maniacally) in Scar's backstory portrayal from FmaB.

[@dotkor2023]

Big Boss crybaby

[@dashman8499]

Manol Georgiev bro you havent seen 2003 then. It’s basically the same backstory but dialed to 11.

[@ringhonecatman8122]

正直原作準拠の2作目の大団円にする為に敵らしくなくなったキンブリーより　こっちの最後まで敵らしかったこっちのキンブリーの方が良い

[@mayamendez9250]

0:01 I can imagine as Kimblee says this, one village turns around and says in a sarcastic tone: “HUH, that’s strange! Everybody seems to be running away from a powerful, murder hungry psychopath tearing apart our village! GEE, it’s almost as if we all WANT TO F@CKING LIVE!!” Kimblee: 😐

[@falexie7802]

LOL

[@tungochuy]

Alphonso: "I'm empty but not worthless" Then proves to Kimblee otherwise It's so frustrating that the author makes Alphonso a total useless character every time he enters the scene in this version 😫

[@foopshrine6786]

Kimbley reminds me of Joker

[@mrcocoloco7200]

How?

[@miyo4344]

これスカーの勝ち扱いでいいんか？それとも両者痛み分けか？

[@ykhior841]

Kimblee is yoshikage kira in disguise

[@kingleoric3799]

He did not cut women hands XD

[@ahmedramadanov8989]

KILLER QUEEN HAS ALREADY TOUCHED YOUR LEGS! BITEZ ZA DUSTO

[@ゆざ-t8u]

鬼の手vs二重の極み

[@鬼だぞ]

今って旧（これ）見れないの？

[@Ferdinand1012]

I prefer this version rather than FMAB. Both are good, but I believe that in this version all have better character development.

[@manofwisdom000]

And the energy, the tone, the vibe, the explanation about the origins and weakness of the homunculi, the power source of alchemy, and the other side of the gate are all way better than Brotherhood. Brotherhood only handled Kimblee (except his death) and Bradley better.

[@fluffyisyermom7631]

I think the only problem i had with this kimblee is for no discernible reason he could survive for about a minute with his heart blown out. But other than that, it shows us that even if you're idealistic like al and want to save people from themselves, we humans are like the horse. The one you can bring to a river but one you can't make drink. This version is more brutal and closer to how characters with super natural powers would act in real life. And scars redemption in 2003 was much better. Though he wasn't nice or kind like Ed and al, he feels more fleshed out and human here.

[@manofwisdom000]

And at his dying moments, he saved Al and the townsfolk of Lior and also basically gave the Elrics what they’ve been searching for all along.

[@私が来た-o4r]

ハボック少尉！？お前いつからタイマンでスカーと戦えるようになったんだ！？ え？あれがキンブリー？ ……えぇ....(困惑)

[@ぶいぶチャンネル]

緋月流狼 そうですよ

[@ib4599]

キンブリーは2期派、スカーは一期派

[@yusukesakurai_dw]

声優の話かww

[@星海ソラ]

この後アルは、スカーが錬成した賢者の石と魂が融合してしまうんだよな

[@我衆院信志]

スカーが同じ弟としてアルフォンスと仲良くてつい助けちゃうのめっちゃすき

[@ニャン太郎-e9t]

そして後のマスタングの部下か

[@alex133gmai]

I love the 2 versions 😍🥰

[@waywai7530]

スカーに関しては１期の方がかっこいいな ２期はちょっとごつい(笑)

[@サキちゃん-f8m]

Way Wai 原作ではリンがまだ出てきてなかったので、ライバル役としてスカーが選ばれ、二枚目になったそうです。

[@hisakosudou7113]

この時2004年の出来事である。　キンブリーのキャラ絵全然違うけど

[@PanicByNumbers]

3:37 that's why we can't stop this Al. Thanks for making things worse.

[@サキちゃん-f8m]

スカー、いつものように頭グシャってやればよかったのに。

[@jordonvazquez7620]

Ryotaro Okiayu was amazing as scar.

[@Avabruck]

First version is more drama and story oriented. Brotherhood is more action oriented. Whatever you prefer. Personally I prefer the first version of the anime a thousand times compared to Brotherhood. Actually, the explanation for Homunculi in this one, really gives each individual Homunculus a true reason and deeper background, instead of being generic-bad-ass villains like they were in Brotherhood. Besides, if you're talking about fights, the ones here are just more realistic, less bullshit.

[@kasa5089]

1期キンブリー →人体を含むあらゆる物質を、空気中の酸素を触媒とする爆発物に変える。 2期キンブリー →砂ぼこりをつくる。 これに関しては1期の設定の方が圧倒的に有能

[@マサムネ-i9x]

一二三孝則丸 2期というか原作のキンブリーの爆発ってなんか殺傷力微妙な時も多かったしな

[@danielbrown8071]

皮肉にもキンブリーの技がエドワード対グリード、スロウスの戦いに生かされるっていうね。

[@Flashlover96]

I remember I used to HATE Kimblee bcuz he betrayed Greed n so I'd replay this part over n over just cuz I loved seeing Kimblee dieing n being in pain but then I saw fmab n I was like "OMGOSH IS THAT KIMBLEE HES SO AWSOME!!" so now that I watch this I almost feel bad for him......almost

[@fatimamona2297]

Almost..

[@マンキャンディ]

10連釘パンチすれば良いのに

[@invaderzgr]

Kimblee is my favorite anime villain ever. Mostly for what he does in the manga and Brotherhood, but he still kicks ass here.

[@adrianblade5145]

05:59 famous Yamcha pose

[@kayakugohan350]

キンブリーは1期の方が好きだな

[@Key_51cm_cannon]

何かキンブリー漫画と大分違くない？

[@hararin]

1期はアニオリだから原作とは違う

[@名無しのナプホ]

なんか絵が違う 昔の？

[@獄卒メズ]

名無しのナプホ 2003年版じゃない？声うえだゆうじだし

[@EdwardElric001]

旧鋼のクズキンブリーも好き。旧鋼の賢者の石を錬成した傷の男も好き。

[@Rohnon]

wow, I can't remember that scene at all

[@mikay7866]

You probably watched Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood and not the alternative FMA.

[@krishmidha1037]

@@mikay7866 nah I doubt he would confuse brotherhood kimblee with abominational design kimblee.

[@starsparklemonkey3390]

They make Al extra dumb to almost poke fun at the "Kill no one" principle.

[@garrywhite13371337]

Yep thats what happens when u dont double tap your enemies

[@jovianigonzales3507]

Stupid Alphonse trying to interfere... And you turn into a time bomb