【專訪】羅奇。香港。中國

Рет қаралды 39,901

Ай бұрын

美國投資銀行摩根史丹利前首席經濟學家及亞洲區主席羅奇（Stephen Roach）接受自由亞洲電台粵語組專訪，談論他對中港政治及經濟的看法。
他對中國經濟精僻的見解，對香港幾十年來深厚的感情，在一個多小時的訪問中一一道來。在整個訪問中，記者感受到羅奇對現在香港和中國局勢的憂心。他最大的心願，只是現在北京和香港政府能像朱鎔基一樣，以開放的胸襟聽取他的意見。
#羅奇 #StephenRoach
--------------------------------------------------
自由亞洲電台（Radio Free Asia）總部設在美國華盛頓，為言論自由受限的亞洲國家和地區提供完整而免費的新聞報道。致力以多媒體形式發送新聞，成為一個讓大眾獲得可靠消息的平台。
--------------------------------------------------
【官網】rfa.org/cantonese
【MeWe】mewe.com/p/自由亞洲粵語rfacantonese
【Instagram】 rfacantonese
【KZbin】 / @rfacantonese
【Facebook 臉書】 cantonese.rfa
【Twitter 推特】 rfacantonese

Пікірлер: 71

@wendylam3768 Ай бұрын

Thank you RFA❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉 Thank you Mr. Roche😍🙏 If the incumbent Bejing and HK administration would be willing to just listen to you say even just half of what you said, they still have a chance but unfortunately they won't and I miss my old HK so badly 😢😢

@scoutdandan Ай бұрын

有一個假冒 rfa youtube 頻道 www.youtube.com/@user-gf6un9rp8p 應該係 CCP 大外宣

@mayyu3012 Ай бұрын

好精彩!

@clio_nicole Ай бұрын

香港經濟靠 "金融" 及 "貿易"，輔以地產，零售及旅遊等，"金融" 及 "貿易" 靠中國經濟發展及英國留下的制度 (法制，自由及廉潔和有效的政府管冶)，這兩者 "缺一不可"，并且不是靠當權者 "口中吹出來的"，而是靠中國及香港 "主要貿易伙伴" 的看法。從97後，香港的人口結構在不斷的變化，大批大陸人移居香港，初期的大部分是較有實力的 (個人素質/視野，工作經驗，財政狀況等)，但近10幾年直到現在，當權者巧立名目，不斷從大陸輸入人口，有識之士都知這種人口輸入對香港的經濟發展基本上沒有很大的幫助而且結果是 "慘不忍睹"。因大批大陸人移居香港，并且在香港工作和生活，很自然一到長假，他們就會拖男帶女離港回大陸探親度假，再加上香港經濟不振，香港人自然不會亂使錢，對本地零售及飲食業帶來負面的影響。要吸引大陸人到香港旅遊和消費，當權者要撫心自問現在的香港和大灣區其它城市或中國其它城市 "有何不同"，俗稱 "旅遊體驗"，這些 "旅遊體驗" 也不是靠當權者 "口中吹出來的"，而是要靠消費者自己感覺出來的。移英的港人上/中/下層都有，但集中在中/下層 (不要再只說 "中產" 及誇大他們的離開對香港的經濟影響)，他們的離去對香港的經濟發展有一定的影響，但假如 "中國經濟發展" 及 "英國留下的制度" 仍存在，那麼他們的離去對香港經濟發展的影響會是 "微不足道" 的。

@scoutdandan Ай бұрын

有一個假冒 rfa youtube 頻道 www.youtube.com/@user-gf6un9rp8p 應該係 CCP 大外宣

@SO-rq3pm Ай бұрын

"移英的港人上/中/下層都有，但集中在中/下層 (不要再只說 "中產" 及誇大他們的離開對香港的經濟影響)，他們的離去對香港的經濟發展有一定的影響，但假如 "中國經濟發展" 及 "英國留下的制度" 仍存在，那麼他們的離去對香港經濟發展的影響會是 "微不足道" 的。" 中肯

@Mia-oz1iy Ай бұрын

This is such a great and fabulous interview👏👏👏👏

@KSCHU12 Ай бұрын

Thanks report and uploaded

@hinydrlee2274 Ай бұрын

Very complicated and hard geopolitical situation and calculation 🧮. Just learning English 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 terminology. Thx 🙏 Law Key 🔑 Mr 😅

@kkgglam Ай бұрын

真知灼見

@tommycheng6215 Ай бұрын

👍

@francischeng9083 Ай бұрын

多謝RFA！👍🏼👍🏼

@yewtree2552 Ай бұрын

Excellent!

@peace18888 Ай бұрын

❤❤🎉🎉

@tweetiemcable Ай бұрын

thanks for the interview. whatever the progress is hope hk is going little by little better. there are many native hkese and they need to make a life.

@michaeltham9914 Ай бұрын

Well analysis Sir 👍👍👍

@thexian 29 күн бұрын

看法很精确呀。

@amywong937 Ай бұрын

😊😊😊

@fatjean2290 Ай бұрын

Thank you RFA, thank you Mr. Roche.

@fatjean2290 Ай бұрын

Sorry, It's Mr. Roach.

@gillianlam4238 Ай бұрын

The truth nothing but the truth !!

@LL-HK Ай бұрын

Thank you RFA ~

@cheongzany6946 Ай бұрын

我甚少認真地用心看一個視頻由始至尾，這是其中之一！

@fatjean2290 Ай бұрын

Me too.

@FaiLai2044 Ай бұрын

I want to let Luo Qi know that Hong Kong is not out of control in 2019, and citizens are fighting against extremism in an orderly manner😠

@lammatt Ай бұрын

His name is Roach

@FaiLai2044 Ай бұрын

@@lammatt 👍🤗❤️🫶

@hkchow5178 Ай бұрын

香港🇭🇰靠旅遊經濟時代已經過去。未來香港需要探索新的盈利模式，以及得到國家各方面的重大支持，令到香港重新煥發東方之珠的光彩。香港永遠是世界鏈接中國的橋樑，並非創新和生產力中心。要有真正的“一國兩制”以及發達之道。否則，倒霉的還是國家。而非愛國者治港團隊。

@SunnieWoo Ай бұрын

🙏🏼👍🏻💪🏻⛽️

@akikogoldberg1524 Ай бұрын

His argument falls short to me as he discusses Chinese economy as if P.R.C. is a normal market-based free country. P.R.C. is fundamentally a Marxist-Leninist country, and you cannot discuss its economy without linking it to its political ideology and Xi Jinping’s particular emphasis on the latter. Hong Kong prospered because it had freedom and the rule of law that provided a fertile ground for investment, innovation and entrepreneurship. Those concepts are foreign to Marxism-Leninism.

@hkchow5178 Ай бұрын

香港這一關如果成功過去了，香港或迎來熱錢的春天；跟拼經濟，沒有半毛錢關係。還是要大智慧。

@raymondwong6937 Ай бұрын

❤😂🎉

@tigerhermitage3303 Ай бұрын

Stephen is a true friend of China, his words of wisdom needs to be heard by the HK Government. HK is a very free place compared to America even now, thats the honest truth.

@ILeenHo2006 Ай бұрын

讓公司輸了大錢而無法回本，導致自己沒法回鍋的深宮怨夫😂

@hkchow5178 Ай бұрын

自由亞洲不是離開香港了嗎？我很喜歡戴主持人，有的料，說話到位，控場能力很強。

@The0302441 Ай бұрын

😮😢😂

@mankoklau5157 29 күн бұрын

so no comment on ancient bandit thuggery fo the gutter oil

@SO-rq3pm Ай бұрын

Thanks for this but the interviewer spoke far too many "you know, you know, you know...". It's aching our ears.

@tedshen3085 Ай бұрын

Well say goodbye to hk ang china😊

@nickname8246 Ай бұрын

Economics cannot be separated from politics that’s why universities offer PPE degrees as Philosophy Politics and Economics. British colonial government was able to run Hong Kong with such great success because the officials came from a culture that allowed and expected constructive criticism of government policies. No such bureaucratic culture exists under the Chinese Communist Party government. Sometimes you get lucky because the leaders allowed the feedback but since they are not elected, you are stuck if an ignorant arrogant stupid person took over.

@akikogoldberg1524 Ай бұрын

Can’t agree more!

@DP-8964 Ай бұрын

Stephen Roach acted as the typical expat who cared only about the money to be made, human rights be damned!

@georginiachan8631 Ай бұрын

Thats what I feel too.

@twcybercitizen2867 Ай бұрын

「沙士」for SARS? Seriously?

@Lcx212 Ай бұрын

被綁架的人說的話

@yorkhunt1251 Ай бұрын

講緊你自己？

@jerrywong5960 Ай бұрын

大陸綁架咗不小香港人同大陸人

@wes8888 Ай бұрын

He had me until anarchy, a false and irresponsible label. Shame!

@TimiFung Ай бұрын

吓！有冇搞錯？仲係發展中嘅國家？我諗佢哋係指自己嘅腦部未發展啫係咪？ 😂

@tsunningwah3471 Ай бұрын

q e w

@enghse888 Ай бұрын

they incl him fall in love w HK cos they can earn lot of $$$$$. However, they ll speak out loud for democracy, justice or human right to CCP

@kykwan7843 Ай бұрын

常常提昔日光輝,日期訂在1997 前！無他那時是港英時代, 一切都在西方（美國）掌控年代, 大家清醒一下, 現今常常提及 G7 提及Global South 又 B & R . Global South 其實就是 G7 以前的值民地, 重提就是留戀以往,所有都是由主人所掌控, 所以從前來說,他生意一定好做, 但對他們給下的呢就祇是剩飯了, 極到不公平！分水嶺1997 ,大家要爭取保護自己, 他們就狂喊不公平！狂喊我們制度差！亂插我們甚麼沒有法治！大家不防理智些就是因為我們國家做事有原則, 公平, 公正！錢大家賺！普天下齊發展, 不能再回去值民地意識食就主子食盡！重要四處引起動亂更巧妙地將責任推給對方！故所以我們國家能令Saudia Arabia 及 Iran 重新交往！ G7 當遇到清醒的 Global South 便完全失敗, 重提自己甚麼學歷, 也無於事！ 2008年,美國喊窮, 記得雷曼事件嗎？那時大家損失多少, 就捐了多少給美國這些金融大佬！（因為以往那些世界醒來了,他們以前那套投機取巧不成了）那次成功向中國借得US$😮1萬億, 跟著就量化寬鬆, （印鈔）本來任何一國亂印鈔, 是把鈔票 devalue 的. 但因為美元是國際交易工具, 亦是貯備貨幣,最主要是石油交易貨幣, 故在每宗交易中可從兑換匯率中賺錢, 來支持美匯不致devalue. 但全世界便要代嘆通漲了！但因為狂印鈔, 大家還記得零息, 不需經銀行而直接注入市場嗎？這樣大量現鈔湧入全球市場, 導致投機活躍, 這樣他們這些金融大佬狂賺錢. 跟著俄烏戰爭, 充公俄國的美元, 歐羅. 企圖又刮一筆！但這樣便嚇怕有持美元資產,及國際貿易國家. 大家迫於無奈, 唯有找尋美元替代品. 去美元化！跟著2000年再無限量寬, 即無限量印鈔, 再把通漲推給世界(無限量通漲）來向中國求救, 但礙於做慣大佬, 不停挑撥全世界, 到處炫耀那11隻航母, 以其軟硬兼施, 以為全世界都認同大佬還很醒！大家應該醒覺此人兄唱衰香港及中國, 以1997 為分水嶺, 就足以證明他們的舊思圍！獨自全食已被陶賒！全世界不能再讓美國獨裁了！自己獨食還不能讓人活？

@mayyu3012 Ай бұрын

言不由衷