Пікірлер
@chucks6879
@chucks6879 11 сағат бұрын
Hey danshurwood ever heard of Hubert Platt "Iowa Shaker" Falcon? Perhaps you are to young
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 6 сағат бұрын
@chucks6879 Nicknamed "Mr. Versatility" A/FX class racing, his falcon was modified with a high-performance 427 Ford V8 , the guy was a engineering genius
@mikeleathers3864
@mikeleathers3864 12 сағат бұрын
I have a boss 9. from John kaase in a 32 all steel hotrod and have driven it more than 40.000 miles and still going strong 💪. best looking engine ever built. runs flawless
@ytwhite5930
@ytwhite5930 Күн бұрын
What? A 1969 Mustang with a Cleveland V-8. Cleveland built 351 wasn't available till 1970 models...69 had the one year only 351 windsor 4V with 10.7 :1 comp. and cast iron 4V intake-290 hp. I've got a Ranchero GT(70) with 351 4V rated at 300hp(not 330).
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@ytwhite5930 Thanks for the clarification! It's always great to dive into the details of these classic engines. Your knowledge about the 351 Windsor and its specs is impressive!
@ytwhite5930
@ytwhite5930 12 сағат бұрын
@rarecarstorys I had a 69 Mach1 years ago (351w4v 4sp3.91locker)
@cliffordjones9715
@cliffordjones9715 Күн бұрын
And that engine never made it a past 1972 and the Mopar Hemi is still being used in nitro
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@cliffordjones9715 You're right! The 427 engine had a short run, but it definitely left its mark in automotive history. The Mopar Hemi is truly legendary!
@cliffordjones9715
@cliffordjones9715 Күн бұрын
Nope this is a lie the NHRA didn't Ban it that's a fact only NASCAR did that's a fact. The reason why it's not in the NHRA now is because of the Mopar Hemi that's the only engine tha use in nitro so if it was better than the Mopar Hemi how come it's not being used
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@cliffordjones9715 Thanks for sharing your insights! The history of racing engines can be quite complex, and it's always good to clarify the facts.
@roccovw1
@roccovw1 Күн бұрын
Give up on this shit, it's gone, never to be brought back, never sold as a dealer item, to complex, not reliable for the street, all hype. Newer engines out class this not for general public engine.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@roccovw1 I appreciate your perspective! The BOSS 429 was definitely a unique piece of automotive history, but it's true that modern engines have come a long way in terms of reliability and performance.
@smilsmff
@smilsmff Күн бұрын
With the newer Coyote ford engines they make now Ford owners should not think about thatold heavy engine and same for Mopar. The iron intakes and heads and 2 carbs made hemi a pig
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@smilsmff You make a valid point! Modern engines like the 5.0 Coyote engines have really changed the game in terms of performance and efficiency. It’s fascinating to see how technology has evolved!
@tonysendrick6347
@tonysendrick6347 Күн бұрын
It was better than the barbecue that seats for... Kaboom.. then you burn in hell
@427Copo-em1xb
@427Copo-em1xb Күн бұрын
Great comparison. A lighter Mustang beat the heavier Charger. The high reving cammer that had timing chain issues. AT high RPM's the cams got out of time with each other. Comparing 65 year old information is purely speculation.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@427Copo-em1xb Speculation and opinion is the name of the game when you’re dealing with vintage muscle! But hey, that’s what makes the debate so thrilling, right?
@dmonat
@dmonat 2 күн бұрын
My USAF best friend bought a NARC police car. It still had the little UHF antenna. A TWO door, vinyl top, 429CI, 140mph speedo (used all of it), fun car! Randy won the local drags with it.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@dmonat That sounds like an amazing car! The BOSS 429 is such an iconic engine, and it’s awesome to hear about the fun experiences you've had with your friend's ride.
@JerryHelton-zo7dg
@JerryHelton-zo7dg 2 күн бұрын
I am 57 years old. I have 2 brain cells. Both the Cammer and Boss engines were specifically designed to be a NASCAR engine. Just so happened the Cammer was great at both. The Boss...not so much. The million dollar question is...why did NASCAR ban the Cammer? I think we all know the answer to this question. I'm sure Chrysler knows as well.😎🤔🏁
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@JerryHelton-zo7dg Thanks for sharing your insight! It’s always great to hear perspectives from fellow enthusiasts, especially about such iconic engines. and contoversy !
@JerryHelton-zo7dg
@JerryHelton-zo7dg Күн бұрын
@rarecarstorys thank you.🙂
@Shelby-Ecoboost-Raptor-550hp
@Shelby-Ecoboost-Raptor-550hp 2 күн бұрын
*George Montgomery Turbocharged the Boss 429 and it got Banned* *The Cammer was the only Engine Banned by Nascar, Outright* *Glidden's Fairmont/Cleveland Won Every Single Round, so they added Ballast and let Competitors run lighter cars* *The 330 cu in Cleveland proved it could beat the 351's in Nascar, and it got Banned* *Ford isn't allowed to run their Best Nascar Heads, and they got Banned* *Bill Elliot holds the Lap Record at Talladega and his car got Banned*
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@Shelby-Ecoboost-Raptor-550hp Wow, sounds like Ford's engines have a better track record of getting banned than I do at parties!Thanks for sharing this insightful information! The history of NASCAR and its regulations is definitely fascinating, especially how certain engines were banned due to their performance.
@Shelby-Ecoboost-Raptor-550hp
@Shelby-Ecoboost-Raptor-550hp 2 күн бұрын
*Ford Motor Company never forgot about the 427 SOHC* *A Legend at the Company, and the Grand Daddy of all their Modern OHC engines*
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@Shelby-Ecoboost-Raptor-550hp Absolutely! The 427 SOHC really laid the groundwork for so many incredible engines that followed. It’s fascinating to see how its legacy continues to influence modern engineering at Ford.
@davefellhoelter1343
@davefellhoelter1343 2 күн бұрын
All "I recall" or know? Was Mom's 69 ir 72? LTD mustard yellow, or babby shit brown, darker brown vinal brown topped Brougham had a 429. Dad's buddy? The owner of the Muffler Shop across the street and our neighbors the Blower guy both on Lakewood Blvd Downey Ca could not WAIT to purchase that USED LTD. Recall him slaming that 429 into his raised red Ford 4x4 about 1976 0r78? Mooneyham blower? and Lindsey's Mufflers? His truck was a Piece of Work! I loved most of that truck, not the all show, no go parts. I rolled a black bondo'ed 72 Charger with chrome craigers 5 spokes, a 318 hurst, shift kit, headers, hi rise, double pumper glass packed piece of $800? junk purchased from a dude a few blocks away in the 105 zone of eminent domain zone next to Rockwell Downey.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@davefellhoelter1343 Thank you for sharing your awesome car stories! It’s always great to hear from fellow enthusiasts who appreciate the legacy of these classic engines and their impact on our lives. i owned a galixy LTD 72 convertable was a absolute boat, no fuel gauge , i used to run out of gas and just enjoy the moments
@Darren-r9b
@Darren-r9b 2 күн бұрын
Stupid AL Bull Feces. first time seeing this channel now. Getta clue.
@duanepayne1805
@duanepayne1805 2 күн бұрын
They tried to drag race with this motor, but it couldn't make it a quarter mile with our major blow-ups.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@duanepayne1805 It’s true! The BOSS 429 had its challenges on the drag strip, until they turbo it
@Willie-bk2es
@Willie-bk2es 2 күн бұрын
I was told that chevy/gm threatened to leave Nascar if they didn't ban the hemi style engines. Any truth to this?
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@Willie-bk2es The claim that Chevrolet/GM threatened to leave NASCAR to force a ban on Hemi engines is **partially rooted in historical events but conflates timelines and motivations. Here's the clarified breakdown: --- Key Context & Truth: 1. 1963 GM Withdrawal: - General Motors (including Chevrolet) voluntarily withdrew from factory-backed racing in 1963 to comply with the Automobile Manufacturers Association (AMA) ban (a 1957 industry-wide pact to avoid overt factory racing involvement). This decision was not directly tied to Chrysler’s Hemi engines, which were not yet dominant at the time. GM’s exit left private teams to race with existing engines, including the Mystery Motor. 2. Chrysler’s 426 Hemi & NASCAR’s 1965 Ban: - In 1964, Chrysler debuted the 426 Hemi, which dominated NASCAR. In response, NASCAR introduced the **“Homologation Rule” in 1965, requiring engines to be available in at least 500 production cars. Chrysler hadn’t yet mass-produced the Hemi, so NASCAR temporarily banned it, prompting Chrysler to boycott the 1965 season. - GM was already out of factory racing by this point and played no direct role in this ban. The pressure likely came from Ford, which capitalized on Chrysler’s absence in 1965. 3. 1966 Resolution: - Chrysler reintroduced the 426 Hemi as a “Street Hemi” in 1966, meeting NASCAR’s production requirement. The Hemi returned and dominated again, but GM remained uninvolved (still adhering to the AMA ban). --- Why the Confusion? - The Mystery Motor (1963) and Hemi ban (1965) occurred close together, leading to myths that GM pressured NASCAR. However: - GM’s 1963 exit was unrelated to the Hemi. - The 1965 Hemi ban stemmed from NASCAR’s rules and Ford’s lobbying, not GM. - GM did not threaten to leave NASCAR over the Hemi-they’d already left. --- Legacy of the Myth: - The story persists because GM’s withdrawal (1963) and the Hemi’s troubles (1965) overlap in a chaotic era of NASCAR’s “horsepower wars.” - While GM’s absence indirectly benefited Ford during Chrysler’s 1965 boycott, there’s no evidence GM strong-armed NASCAR to ban the Hemi. --- Summary: - False: GM did not threaten to leave NASCAR to ban the Hemi. - True: NASCAR banned the 426 Hemi in 1965 due to homologation rules, influenced by Ford’s lobbying, not GM. - GM’s 1963 exit was a separate corporate decision tied to the AMA ban. Let me know if you’d like deeper dives into specific events! 🏁
@paintnamer6403
@paintnamer6403 2 күн бұрын
Too bad the pictures are of a Max Wedge dual quad cross ram and not the NASCAR single four barrel intake manifold. Then the never produced DOHC Hemi is shown with a single quad for NASCAR. If Ford did make the 427 SOHC legal for NASCAR, that DOHC HEMI was ready to beat it. When Plymouth brought out the Superbird in 1970 Richard Petty went back to Plymouth.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@paintnamer6403 I really appreciate your detailed comment! It’s always great to hear from someone who knows their stuff. Your knowledge adds so much depth to the conversation!
@delanolucas614
@delanolucas614 2 күн бұрын
A Lincoln crank made it unbeatable on the street
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@delanolucas614 Absolutely! The Lincoln crank was a game-changer for the BOSS 429, enhancing its performance and making it a true powerhouse on the streets.
@delanolucas614
@delanolucas614 2 күн бұрын
horrible Written by wannabe
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@delanolucas614 Ouch! Sorry to hear you didn't like it! What could I do better next time? it might be my disabitys dyslexia and autisim is a fun combination, i might not get it right, i do however never give up , and stay curious, not judge MENTAL, i wish you well!
@thomasjones613
@thomasjones613 2 күн бұрын
I can't stand AI narrated videos! 👎👎👎
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@thomasjones613 I appreciate your feedback! Everyone has their preferences, and it's totally okay to feel that way about AI narration. we did have a real voice over artist , but it was costing $50 per video that would have cost us $1500 so far , i am sure we will make an sdjustment in the future as we get more subs, members, and support, thank you !
@randybeckham2827
@randybeckham2827 2 күн бұрын
I need one or two
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@randybeckham2827 The BOSS 429 was definitely a game-changer in the muscle car world! Let me know what you’re curious about, and I’ll be happy to help!
@riccicrozzie8204
@riccicrozzie8204 2 күн бұрын
If AI is the future, we're farked.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@riccicrozzie8204 It's definitely a fascinating topic! The advancements in AI can be both exciting and a bit concerning, depending on how you feel mentally
@p71glh
@p71glh 2 күн бұрын
AI voice. Not watching!!!
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@p71glh I understand that AI voices aren't for everyone! If you ever decide to give it a chance, I hope you find some interesting insights in the video.
@Rogueginger69
@Rogueginger69 3 күн бұрын
5:12 It's worth mentioning that the NHRA forced the Hemi to use a smaller carb with less cfm than the Cammer. On top of that, the Hemi was also forced to carry more weight than the Cammer.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@Rogueginger69 Thank you for pointing that out! The nuances of racing regulations really highlight the challenges these engines face. I appreciate your insight!
@JohnDickerson-d7m
@JohnDickerson-d7m 3 күн бұрын
LIER GM PAID YOU PEOPLE TO PUSH THEIR CRAP AND BANNED ENGINES BY YOU HAD NO RIGHT TO. GM CANNOT RUN UNLESS AFTERMARKET PARTS.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@JohnDickerson-d7m are you ok?
@JohnDickerson-d7m
@JohnDickerson-d7m 3 күн бұрын
429/460 IS A BIG BLOCK CLEVLAND...
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@JohnDickerson-d7m You're absolutely right! The 429/460 big block C engines have such a rich history in the automotive world. Thanks for sharing your insight!
@RonMcMahan-b2d
@RonMcMahan-b2d 3 күн бұрын
I agree, Cammer not camera.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@RonMcMahan-b2d Thanks for your input! It's great to see fellow enthusiasts like you catching those details! my spelling gets worse will have to hire Ai to double check!
@TheArkDoc
@TheArkDoc 3 күн бұрын
427 SOHC was dramatically more powerful than the Hemi--the person who wrote this got that absolutely wrong. Had the SOHC not been banned from NASCAR before the season began, history would have been very different indeed. I love that Chrysler dropped Hemi's in everything, and for that, it deserves all the credit and notoriety it has received. But between the two, the 427 SOHC was the ultimate winner of the question you asked: Which was faster? 427 SOHC. Were the question which was the better bang for the buck for the average man, different story. But that is not what was asked.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@TheArkDoc You make some great points about the 427 SOHC's power! would make it win 100% It's definitely interesting to think about how different things might have been if it hadn't been banned from NASCAR. Both engines have their strengths, but the debate will always be fun!
@robviousobviously5757
@robviousobviously5757 3 күн бұрын
I had a 1972 for about 5 years... beautiful nightmare is the best description... electrical gremlins crippled it... when it worked, glorious, when it didn't, frustrating... been there done that, don't need another
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@robviousobviously5757 It sounds like you had quite the experience with your Pantera! Those classic cars can definitely be a mix of beauty and frustration. Thanks for sharing your story! 351 cleavlands in those pants was awsome!
@gfisher495
@gfisher495 3 күн бұрын
Richard Petty! “43”! Glenn
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 3 күн бұрын
@gfisher495 you are awsome Glenn, always brightening up youtub community , thank you kindly
@427Copo-em1xb
@427Copo-em1xb 3 күн бұрын
Kalitta was not the first one to go over 200 mph.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@427Copo-em1xb You are correct. Connie Kalitta was not the first driver to exceed 200 mph in U.S. drag racing. The milestone of being the first to break the 200 mph barrier in a sanctioned NHRA (National Hot Rod Association) event belongs to Don "Big Daddy" Garlits. Key Details: Date: September 5, 1964 Event: U.S. Nationals in Indianapolis Achievement: Garlits drove his Swamp Rat IV top fuel dragster to a speed of 201.34 mph in the quarter-mile, marking the first official 200+ mph pass in NHRA history. Context: Prior to Garlits' record, dragsters were approaching but hadn't yet cracked 200 mph. His achievement was a watershed moment, showcasing advancements in nitro-burning engine technology and aerodynamics. Connie Kalitta, known as "The Bounty Hunter," was a prominent drag racer in the 1960s and 1970s but did not hold the distinction of being the first to reach 200 mph. Garlits' accomplishment solidified his legacy as a drag racing pioneer, while Kalitta remains celebrated for his contributions to the sport as a driver and team owner.
@dbireland2003
@dbireland2003 3 күн бұрын
I love this engine. Genius engineering. Along with the 351 Cleveland.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 3 күн бұрын
@dbireland2003 Right? The BOSS 429 and the 351 Cleveland are just pure muscle! Can't get enough of those classic engines!
@CharlesWinters-ie3jy
@CharlesWinters-ie3jy 4 күн бұрын
The motor was designed to run at high RPM. On super speed ways. Wouldn’t work on short tracks. Didn’t work very well on the street. It overheats at stop lights in the summer and didn’t pull very well from lower RPMs. I have a friend who has one in a GT500. He likes the car but the 429 was not good. Spent a lot of money having it rebuilt by Shelby. He ended up putting a 351 in the GT 500. He has the 429 to put back in to sell it someday. He is in the process of building a diesel mustang right now. He is using a very fast BMW diesel.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys Күн бұрын
@CharlesWinters-ie3jy Thanks for sharing your insights! It's interesting to hear about the real-world performance of the BOSS 429. Sounds like your friend has quite the project lineup!
@D800Lover
@D800Lover 4 күн бұрын
I used one to power my lawnmower.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 2 күн бұрын
@D800Lover Wow, must be quite the lawnmower! I can see it now: the grass doesn’t stand a chance against that horsepower!
@D800Lover
@D800Lover 2 күн бұрын
@rarecarstorys - Of course, roots and all go flying. I tow it behind my muscle car, I have a big back yard.
@JohnnieScarborough-pi3hx
@JohnnieScarborough-pi3hx 4 күн бұрын
Cammer all day
@ronhall3686
@ronhall3686 4 күн бұрын
The 427 SOHC besides being called the "Cammer" was also called the 427 "sock" motor back in the day.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@ronhall3686 That's a great point! The 427 "sock" definitely had some interesting nicknames. It really highlights the unique history and culture around these engines! i like the 90 day wonder
@chromezone4371
@chromezone4371 4 күн бұрын
The 427 camera is still my favourite
@kevinroberts8441
@kevinroberts8441 4 күн бұрын
Ai sucks
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@kevinroberts8441 I appreciate your feedback! Let me know if there's something specific you'd like to see improved in future videos. instead of just hatred towards Ai ?
@briancool3110
@briancool3110 4 күн бұрын
Ford always comes out we great engines but they are never made long enough to really develop them Boss 429 and 427 SOHC , plus NHRA does not like Fords winning races.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@briancool3110 You make a great point! Ford has indeed produced some legendary engines, and it's a shame they didn't get the chance to shine longer on the track. what do you think NHRA problem with ford comes from?
@briancool3110
@briancool3110 3 күн бұрын
Hi racecarstorys I think don’t know if Iam correct but NHRA likes to have GM products win because the fans like that more and the weight brakes for most Ford products is more HP to CI . Just my opinion
@shanebrbich5698
@shanebrbich5698 4 күн бұрын
These AI voices are the main reason I turn off Second to adverts
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@shanebrbich5698 Totally get it! Sometimes those AI voices can be a bit much. We’re working on making things more enjoyable for everyone!
@craigfisher9713
@craigfisher9713 4 күн бұрын
I thought the 429 SCJ was the baddest motor Ford ever made ?
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@craigfisher9713 Thanks for sharing your thoughts! The 429 SCJ is indeed one of the baddest motors! , and it's always fun to explore the different legends in Ford's history.
@rstelzer2928
@rstelzer2928 Күн бұрын
my brother had a 1969 Cobra with the 428 cj. Its redline was 5200 and it topped out at 120 mph at 6000 rpm. It sure could lay rubber! 2 stripes 50 ft long! A friend of mine in high school drove a 1970 cobra 429 scj because his dad was a salesman at the Ford dealer. That thing was fast!! It blew away my 69 Chevelle SS396 AND my brother's Cobra. But none them compare with 2015 Mustang GT Premium I bought for my wife 10 years ago. That thing hit 160 in half a mile and was still pulling hard when I chickened out. And I had the convertible top down too! It didn't drift one bit nor did it twitch either. Ford did the S550 RIGHT!
@henrybobswillikers
@henrybobswillikers 4 күн бұрын
Great subject, terrible AI. You have to dig to find the videos someone actually made correct. KZbin is ruining everything.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@henrybobswillikers I appreciate your feedback! It's always a challenge to get the facts right, but I'm glad you found the topic interesting. what would you sudgest?
@eugenepolan1750
@eugenepolan1750 4 күн бұрын
Drop the AI narration.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@eugenepolan1750 I appreciate your input! It's always helpful to know what viewers prefer. I'll look into it!
@bobuncle8704
@bobuncle8704 4 күн бұрын
So many errors in this. Do better research.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@bobuncle8704 I appreciate your feedback! I always strive to improve and will definitely take a closer look at the the insightful details you gave . kzbin.info/door/1LFwBRy9-ENQ5I20vxw08gjoin
@Kevin-red2002
@Kevin-red2002 4 күн бұрын
"Bunkie Nudist"?!?!? Bwahahaha! Was this written by a Commodore 64?!?
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@Kevin-red2002 Right? I was half-expecting a floppy disk to pop out while editing that segment! Commodore 64 vibes definitely strong with this one! 😂
@TheReal1953
@TheReal1953 4 күн бұрын
In HS, the 428s beat the 429....we didn't see the point of the 429. Nice to understand now why Ford let that happen.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@TheReal1953 It's interesting how different engines performed on the track. The 428 certainly had its strengths, and it's great to see the discussion around Ford's engineering choices!
@stephenvelden295
@stephenvelden295 4 күн бұрын
Drop the AI! Read it yourself! It will be an improvement!
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@stephenvelden295 Drop the AI? But what if it starts a rebellion? I like my robot overlords too much for that!
@buildingracingvideos4714
@buildingracingvideos4714 4 күн бұрын
This is why the hemi is the benchmark. It won in nascar and drag racing. At 426 cubes and 500 cubes. On the street, traction was the issue not being sluggish. The only winning engine with no excuses.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@buildingracingvideos4714 The Hemi definitely set a high standard in the racing world, and it’s fascinating to see how different engines have shaped motorsport history. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
@Charles-w9b
@Charles-w9b 4 күн бұрын
If ford had simplified the timing as is the case of the present day coyote to complicated was the word on the street to bad ford didn't fix that.
@rarecarstorys
@rarecarstorys 4 күн бұрын
@Charles-w9b You make a great point! Simplifying timing could have changed the game for Ford. It's interesting to think about how technology and engineering have evolved over the years. do you think the 90 days contributed to this obvious problem?