Indo europian has sound like Bh, aspirated B which is endemic to India there are many words which can trace there origin to India.So it can be linguistically proved that Proto Indo Europian Language has origin in India
@BenLlywelyn5 сағат бұрын
Why does having that sound mean it came from India? Why could the sound have not.gone to India like it went to Spain?
@ramanv.r34229 сағат бұрын
Abrahamic religions believe in Eternal Heaven or Eternal Hell. Eternal Heaven sounds good but will be boring. And to reach that Heaven one has to be in the grave till that Judgement Day. When will that JD be no one knows. May be my understanding is wrong,
@BenLlywelyn7 сағат бұрын
Jews do not believe in eternal hell.
@centenntrucker849617 сағат бұрын
As I was falling down the rabbit hole of genealogy starting with myself, going all the way back, I ran into this dude. Interesting.
@besimcerpja4868Күн бұрын
ILLYRIAN peninsula have PELLAZGE ROOTS
@BenLlywelynКүн бұрын
We have no way of knowing if the pre-Greek people's culture of the Aegean Sea zone stretched much to the north or inland over the mountains.
@besimcerpja4868Күн бұрын
Rumania have ILLYRIAN ROOTS
@BenLlywelynКүн бұрын
But what was Illyrian?
@besimcerpja486823 сағат бұрын
@@BenLlywelyn Kërko në Google Illyrian peninsula history
What an amazing insight into languages, deeply interesting!!!!!
@BenLlywelynКүн бұрын
Thank you.
@learningoldgermaniclanguagesКүн бұрын
Great video.
@BenLlywelynКүн бұрын
Diolch = Danke
@CyberChud2077Күн бұрын
Really really good
@michaelpattison85432 күн бұрын
A fo Ben bid bont! 😅
@BenLlywelyn2 күн бұрын
Da iawn!
@christopherellis26632 күн бұрын
Frumos!
@dyffrynardudwy97292 күн бұрын
On the resilience of pre-Roman cultural and social traditions we only have archaeological evidence but throughout the period we see continued use of hillforts and hillslope enclosures with roundhouses, pit storage etc structures that show little change from pre-Roman structures. They imply the perpetuation of a family/clan hierarchical society in many areas with a caste of chiefs who would have wished to be immortalised as their ancestors had.
@BenLlywelyn2 күн бұрын
Tre'r Ceiri is one such fort, used throughout the Roman period.
@dyffrynardudwy97292 күн бұрын
Diolch yn fawr, Ben. Sadly we have very little idea of how British native people reacted to centuries of Roman rule. Presumably a patchwork pf deep Romanisation among certain social classes and occupations and geographical areas (e.g. SE Britain) but also classes and crucially areas marginal or outside of Roman rule in the west of Wales and southern Scotland where traditional social and cultural traditions were maintained. These may have been areas in which Brythonic tradition of poetry was maintained and developed by contact with Latin. Brythonic poetry may not necessarily have descended to a vernacular level but may have maintained status and traditions which flourished with the early post-Roman period of praise poetry.
@BenLlywelyn2 күн бұрын
Seems the pockets of unromanised Britain were dwindling and shrinking, and that Rome left just in time to save Welsh.
@claudiualbu27172 күн бұрын
Keep the good stuff coming, Benjamin. You have certainly been honing your skill in creating better and more immersive content.
@BenLlywelyn2 күн бұрын
Will do! Appreciated.
@astronomusedallas21522 күн бұрын
Thank you!
@ProjectMirai642 күн бұрын
Great video !
@BenLlywelyn2 күн бұрын
Thank you.
@cymro65372 күн бұрын
As a point of interest, there's now a Welsh language board game available , ' *Gêm Owain Glyndwr* ' also great for Welsh learners.⚔️🏴👍
@BenLlywelyn2 күн бұрын
Oh! Diddorol iawn. Thank you for sharing.
@soumaya2692 күн бұрын
Great video. So grateful that I’ve found your channel.❤
@DiMaggioTV3 күн бұрын
Amazing video. Thanks for providing such specialized and fascinating content. What are your thoughts on Myrddin as a historical figure and poet? Isn't he a contemporary of Taliesin?
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
There is so much nonsense to dig through around Myrddin that it is impossible to say if such a man lived. But given Irish has such a figure in the north and Myrddin Wyllt and Lailoken (a near archeotype in.Scotland), if he lived he was probanby from the Old Welsh kingdom of Stratgclyde around Glasgow.
@DiMaggioTVКүн бұрын
@@BenLlywelynThank you!
@antonyantonow81333 күн бұрын
Ich bin auch ein deutsch aus Kasachstan ,seit schon 26 Jahre lebe in der Niederlande. Schöne Grüße nach lieber Kasachstan.
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
Vielen Dank fürs Zuschauen.
@veuzou3 күн бұрын
Same thing for your anthem's little brother -ours 😁 Breizh, douar ar Sent kozh, douar ar Varzhed N'eus bro all a garan kement 'barzh ar bed Pep menez, pep traonienn, d'am c'halon zo kaer Enne kousk meur a Vreizhad taer! Brittany land of the old saints, land of the poets There's no country I love that much in the World Every mountain, every valley is dear to my heart There lies more than one fierce Breton.
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
Trugarez mat.
@scottmartin38163 күн бұрын
Diolch yn fawr for this, Ben! I've been looking forward to this one ever since you teased it. It's just the kind of motivation I need to get over these frustrating first steps in learning Welsh. Now I know have the poets of the Hengerdd to look forward to! (Mastering Modern Welsh comes first, of course.)
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
Pob lwc! Good luck! I wish you well on your journey. Keep at it.
@DWbo-r7v3 күн бұрын
Tal can also mean a piece of land. Like tal y bont
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
Cywir! Correct!
@EDDIEM0NS00N3 күн бұрын
What a Christmas treat this is Ben!! ❤ Thank you again for your work. It is very much appreciated & recognised, & as a fellow Welshman I want to wish you Nadolig Lllawen a Blwyddyn Newydd Dda it ti a dy Deulu!!🎅🏻🎄 🎉
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
Diolch yn fawr iawn. Blwyddyn newydd dda a gwyliau da iti!
@DWbo-r7v3 күн бұрын
Taliesin was definitely one of the older ones in stereotypical Welsh history Separate note: Writings from Shakespeare's era .. show that his hometown of Stratford-upon-Avon was regularly full of many Welsh speaking men uttering poetry to those who cared in the taverns
@icanthis3 күн бұрын
Hello sir how many languages do you know?
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
Able to speak. 3.
@icanthis3 күн бұрын
@BenLlywelyn Can you make Breton Lessons or more Welsh lessons
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
I don't know if I can make a living on KZbin making the channel focus on Welsh lessons.
@icanthis3 күн бұрын
@@BenLlywelyn okay i followed you and i learning Welsh language for thanks to you Also Breton
@agents46243 күн бұрын
Bahá'í
@deparagigm3 күн бұрын
You did well exposing how Islam views other faiths, but you failed to read all the scriptures in Bible where gentiles are to be regarded as nothing, and where Christians must have nothing to do with unbelievers. I think that’s unfair. Btw I’m not a Muslim.
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
Thank you.
@StriderAngel4964 күн бұрын
HI, Romanian here. We don't give that much thought and i would wager most people don't have very strong opinion regarding Semitism. I see some good things in jews, i see some good things in muslims. WHY DOES EVERYTHING NOWADAYS HAVE TO BE ABOUT RACE OR SEX OR RELIGION?!?!? People are a totality of IDEAS. You can agree with some and disagree with others... It doesn't matter the race or SEX. FFS! Stop playing the stupid lefty globalist game! Return to ideas and common sense instead of race-baiting and "gender"-baiting. Also. There's no such thing as gender. IT'S SEX! Only stupid people that don't understand anatomy, chemistry, hormones, genetics, enzymes, chromosomes, etc. can say, with a clear conscience, that man and women are the same... "educated" midwits with useless degrees in nothing... Get a degree in medicine, engineering, REAL THINGS, SCIENCE. In my opinion, someone with a degree in "feminist social studies" has no degree at all. Actually, worse, they have been dumbed down to a level lower than someone that never attended college!
@moboauto67534 күн бұрын
Who are you Ben ? Ooh i know you.. you are the friend of Jerry . What can I say good ice cream. Keep on fakein'....
There is no "situation". Please remember that Transylvania was never empty. That is a very convenient theory. There, Sarmisegetusa was located which was the capital of Dacia - the land of proto-Romanians. Nobody leaved Transylvania just to make room to Hungarians or other people. The modern Romanians didn't leave Transylvania - they've always been majority and so they are today. Yes, there have been times in history when this land was under Hungarian domination but never forever. How many provinces, kingdoms or countries in Europe and in the world have been under foreign empires or foreign countries' domination? They regained their independence and that was it - they remained with/the mother country.
@BenLlywelyn4 күн бұрын
Don't worry, I do not see it becoming part of Hungary anytime soon.
@pedrokarstguimaraes10965 күн бұрын
Gothic architecture comes from The Goths. Visigoths and Ostrogoths are the basical rulers of late medieval period.
@BenLlywelyn4 күн бұрын
Gothic architecture originated in the north of the Kngdom of France in the twelfth century.
@janferschmann4645 күн бұрын
As czechyan ve are better then rome
@Dwarpheous5 күн бұрын
In sir Gaerfyrddin. We say beth yw'r amser for whats the time. Not sure if certain dialects of welsh may be closer to Cornish than others.
@bir_cumle5 күн бұрын
The work is nice, but it's hard to understand for a half English speaker like me. Could you please add Turkish subtitles?
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
Do you know someone who will add them for me for free?
@Andy_Babb5 күн бұрын
Great channel. I’m glad I finally found it!
@BenLlywelyn4 күн бұрын
Thank you.
@DanialTarki5 күн бұрын
17:54 This one is actually about taking prisoners of war, not automatically making war on non-believers in your proximity. 18:00 Incorrect, again. This one is actually about waging war against Islam.
@BenLlywelyn3 күн бұрын
Yesterday, a man who used taqiyya to lie about his beliefs within German society, and deceive the West into thinking he was an anti-Islamacist rather than an opposing sect of it, drove into a crowd killing several and wounding over 200 people. After 14,000 terrorist attacks, the time for believing such lies is over.
@FrithonaHrududu021275 күн бұрын
Totally unrelated.... I went in front of a judge named Harry Elam a couple of times. He was actually the father of the rapper Guru from gang Starr.
@BenLlywelyn4 күн бұрын
Are you innocent?
@FrithonaHrududu021274 күн бұрын
@BenLlywelyn not usually. Although the last bid I did was 12 years but I won an appeal after 4 because the state chemist. Annie Dookhan that handled my evidence was the culprit in the largest drug lab scandal in u.s. history. At 18 we had a murder case that was clearly self defense but the state swine still felt the need to plant blood evidence, suborn perjury etc.. Sorry....
@FrithonaHrududu021274 күн бұрын
@BenLlywelyn on a linguistic note.....the only two examples I can think of where Americans use Cockney rhyming slang is in prison. BID - "I was doing a twelve year bid" I'm pretty sure it's a corruption of "bird"- birdlime- time "I was doing bird(time)"UK Also a "hit or miss" letter is a letter written in invisible ink made from piss.
@mihailvormittag62116 күн бұрын
First of all, the people of Moldova call their language Romanian and not Moldavian. And furthermore, the official alphabet in the Republic of Moldova is the Latin alphabet, just as the official language is the Romanian language. It is also officially called Romanian and not Moldovan. And besides this, the people in Moldova want to belong to the political sphere to which Romania also belongs, namely the European Union and NATO.
@BenLlywelyn5 күн бұрын
We will see where the future leads us.
@mihailvormittag62115 күн бұрын
@BenLlywelyn The future will certainly reveal itself. But your video is not about the future, it is about the present. And now, in the present, the people of Moldova call their official language Romanian, and they write in this language using the Latin alphabet. And, as recent election results have shown, they would rather want to be part of the Western influence sphere, than part of the Russian one. These are all facts, they are not hopes for the future or fairy tales?
@SheilaHorseman6 күн бұрын
I'd have to opt for Georgia, if only to mention the Dmanisi skull,1.8 million years old, probably Homo erectus :).
@SheilaHorseman6 күн бұрын
About three months ago Ancestry 'updated' DNA results, in my case this stripped away my 3% Scottish and 2% Norwegian, changing it to the pretty vague Germanic. Luckily they didn't mess with my 95% Welsh, else they would have got a very annoyed email :).
@BenLlywelyn6 күн бұрын
Cymraes!
@SheilaHorseman6 күн бұрын
You seem to assume that Palaeolithic sculptures were made by men. However, if you look downwards from the head of, for example, the Venus of Willendorf figurine, carved about 5Kya earlier than the Venus of Brassempouy, that piece, and several others, are made from the perspective of a woman. The following is paywalled but possibly accessible via an institution: Toward Decolonizing Gender Catherine Hodge McCoid, Leroy D. McDermott Published 1 June 1996 American Anthropologist
@BenLlywelyn6 күн бұрын
I tend to avoid like the plague anything combining the words decolonising and gender, as I assume it is anti-west propaganda.
@MemesForeverBoys6 күн бұрын
Romanian here,And we don't really care about one's religion/race/whatever.The Romanian mindset goes like 'do whatever,but don,t cry about it when people give you weird stares,laugh at you,or disagree with you,and do not force it upon others.For example,let's say you organise a party for your baby's circumcision.No Romanian will start yelling at you for being a Jew,but they will be like "WTF,bro?!Why...why are you cutting it off?"
@MemesForeverBoys6 күн бұрын
And yes,you are right about honesty and humour
@sergiuromeo6 күн бұрын
Numai prosti scrieti nimic nu este adevarat Geto sau Traci sunt toate hartile antice cu aceste nume Imperiul Roman a fost creat de Geto Traci 88 de Imperatori 44 sunt de origine Geto Traca un exemplu Imperatorul Galerius tata de origine Traca si mama ROMULA GETA deci Print ENEIA Tracul dupa razboiul Sparta Troia pleaca in peninsula Italica unde ia parte la fondarea Imperiului Roman de aceia se explica garda Imperiala toata era formata numai din razboinici Geti foarte inalti atletici cu un curaj esit din comun deci care Rege ar Pune garda personala sa fie formata din adversari toate limbile Latine sa trag din Romana vulgara veche nu o spun eu ci Micheal Ledwith secretar pop second “ Latin is a Romanian Language “ de mentionat Geto Traci erau stapani peste aproape toata Europa Asia Orientul Mijlociu Nord Africa Egiptul parinti primilor Faraoni sunt GETI cine sunt GETi numai poporul din Romania Geto Traci Bulgaria se Chema Tracia aici sunt ingropati toti REGI Traci sa nu uitam Scotieni si Irlandezi sunt de origine Geto Traca sunt multe similitudini in dans muzica din cimpoi portul tip fusta diferit colorate king Artur original din Romania pleaca in Bretania unde sunt razboie continuie cu Scotezi Irlandezi deci razboie Fraticide apropo de tarile Nordice Swedia Danemarca Norvegia hartile antice sunt scrise cu numele “ Nord GETLAND” cine sunt Geti numai Romanian Natiune ma opresc aici sunt multe de spus adevarul Va iesi la iveala sa nu uitam Ca Romania a avut cele mai multe razboae din lume in fiecare an sau doi ani continu toti sunt inpotriva Romanilor stim ca tigani sunt de vina avem o reputatie proasta din cauza lor
@mbavery19756 күн бұрын
Like your video. Stopped listening because of your BCE
@BenLlywelyn6 күн бұрын
Glad you liked it. I practice Judaism, so not using AD / BC. You're choice if you accept other's faiths or not.
@amywelch18946 күн бұрын
I'd say that one day the Marxists will learn what a kibbutz is, and that the early Israeli leaders were considered far-left, but that probably won't happen. Do you think the similarity between German and Jewish culture is due to being intellectual peoples?
@BenLlywelyn6 күн бұрын
I would say both that similarity is over-rated. And that it just so happened that Austrian, German, Hunagarin and Polish Jews formed the wave which eatablished a free Israel, so we think of all Jewish culture as that when it is not.
@halidunezircan65647 күн бұрын
Scheisse ist MER Zivilisation Sprache Türkisch nicht nur vor 2000 Jahren haben sie in was du jetzt EUROPA nennst auch Türkisch gesprochen bis sie mit Latein alles weg getilgt haben Julius Cäsar sein orginal Name Temuz Keser TUROVA-Orginal EUROPA-Fage Kannst Vatikan fragen was glaubst du was die verbergen.
@DoNotFear6967 күн бұрын
English is the language God communiced with Moses by the burning bush, not Hebrew!