Пікірлер
@stevemartin7464
@stevemartin7464 2 сағат бұрын
Please remember one thing; we ALL wanted the ANC out, why? Because the ANC is fundamentally corrupt. Everyone seems to be forgetting this. Sadly we haven't got the ANC out, now the ANC wants to keep every position that can actually have any influence on how they act. They are gaslighting by blaming everything on the DA. What do you people expect the DA to do? Just go in as people who can only watch as the ANC carries on destroying the country. We should all be telling the ANC to start giving meaningful positions to the other parties. Its the ANC that is worried here and they really dont want to lose the protection of certain key portfolios. This is a fight between good in the DA and fundamentally evil and corrupt in the ANC. The DA has to win for all of us.
@haswonunion3281
@haswonunion3281 3 сағат бұрын
How hard can this be take the percentage of votes that each party got and divide the ministers positions according to that. If there a three key misisters post in the cabinet the ANC takes one and the DA the other one and then take the other parties and make them the Deputy. Say if the minster of finance is a ANC member then the Deputy is then from the DA or other smaller party. Damn these people want their cake and eat it too. That politics for you if you give a minister a task and he has ten hours to do so, he wil use nine hours to explain what he is going to do and the other one hour to explain why he didn't do the job. Damn these parties and their eggos the GNU was formed to work for the interrest of the people but now you see how greedy they are.The people are not interrested in who does what all they care about is that the person is the right person and that he/she can do the job and is not corrupt that is what we voted for. The ANC should focus on the next election so that they don't get 20% of the vote in 2026. Damn these politicians.
@boudewynwagener7653
@boudewynwagener7653 5 сағат бұрын
A man with insight. Thank you Prof
@shirenearendse9569
@shirenearendse9569 5 сағат бұрын
Neo-feudalism: G7 supports BlackRock buying up world's infrastructure, to make rich even richer. If you think privatization is good. Watch till the end
@user-sg2kw1vl4u
@user-sg2kw1vl4u 5 сағат бұрын
Ramaphosa and Mbalula are mad to hand power on a silver platter
@stevemartin7464
@stevemartin7464 2 сағат бұрын
They are corrupt thieves, so they will be very wary of handing power as you put it. Also, they are now only 40% of the voters, so they dont have real power without partners.
@gavkinn
@gavkinn 5 сағат бұрын
Ramaphosa just wanted the protection of DA so he could be President. So it's time to walk away because a zebra doesn't change its stripes.
@susaravanveenhuyzen1239
@susaravanveenhuyzen1239 6 сағат бұрын
Typical ANC! Don’t want a better RSA for everyone! They could not run the country before😮
@katyharries2526
@katyharries2526 6 сағат бұрын
Thank you forthis enlightening talk. Rev Munther gives me hopw for the region 💗🙏
@billyrajoo8076
@billyrajoo8076 6 сағат бұрын
What humans do to one of the best parties but god will judge .and the Karma will catch on😮😮😮
@P-qi6qx
@P-qi6qx 7 сағат бұрын
These Black Africans will ALWAYS REMAIN ...... SELFISH. The African is WORSE THAN the white man
@nathanthomas2267
@nathanthomas2267 7 сағат бұрын
Really R350 puts you on a better path?
@TheAppleLoadout
@TheAppleLoadout 8 сағат бұрын
Since the government represents the people, the negotiations should be televised. Then we can see what is actually going on. The media is half the problem.
@babayaga6667
@babayaga6667 7 сағат бұрын
The media IS 100% the problem
@starking26
@starking26 8 сағат бұрын
Why is media perpetuating the narrative that the ANC has complete authority to "give" power to the DA and the DA is "demanding" portfolios? Didn't the ANC only attain 40% of the national vote and did they not agree to form a coalition with the DA and smaller parties?
@janojanuary
@janojanuary 8 сағат бұрын
Minimising people need to homes, the city setting fire to these makeshift homes.
@ericschoeman6613
@ericschoeman6613 9 сағат бұрын
Nothing will change if it stays the same
@ericschoeman6613
@ericschoeman6613 9 сағат бұрын
Forget the letters do the math , first principles thinking ask ai then you could see what is fair
@basilhendricks788
@basilhendricks788 10 сағат бұрын
The white voter who keeps the white party in power ,
@user-bm3bu3pj6u
@user-bm3bu3pj6u 10 сағат бұрын
We cannot be held hostage by da you people you did not win both of we bur people thought you will solve you thing amicably now you have be ome bullies in the negotiations we cannot allow racists to dictate that zille of yours such a silly woman she thinks just because she controls her husband and her children thinks we athe same don't pick and choose cause you didn't win and it's a fact
@silaskhalishwayo
@silaskhalishwayo 11 сағат бұрын
Yo always bring out clown analysts 😂😂
@silaskhalishwayo
@silaskhalishwayo 11 сағат бұрын
Stupid analysis 😂😂😂white analysis in fact 😂😂😂it won't work South Africa is majority black people who doesn't trust white people who want apartheid and boss behaviors..White's are still racist
@BlakeCaldwell-yy2fh
@BlakeCaldwell-yy2fh 11 сағат бұрын
um um um
@user-mk9ut2bj2y
@user-mk9ut2bj2y 13 сағат бұрын
Make all the provinces independant states.
@bevturner2258
@bevturner2258 5 сағат бұрын
I also think that would be a good solution. However, you would need 2/3 majority to make that change to the constitution. Can’t see that happening…
@wouterswanepoel5753
@wouterswanepoel5753 16 сағат бұрын
The parties in the GNU represent about 72% of the votes cast, of which the DA got 22%. The DA's share, percentage wise, is therefore 30,5%. The DA, therefore, should get 30,5% of the 30 Cabinet posts, which amounts to 9 Cabinet posts. But that's just the numbers. The quality and importance of those Ministries should also be considered and that's the only thing that should be negotiated, really. The DA simply cannot settle ONLY for less important Ministries. I'd say they deserve the position of Deputy President and at least 6 important Ministries.
@MrLechesa
@MrLechesa 14 сағат бұрын
Why "important" Ministries? What gives them that entitlement??
@scroopynooperz9051
@scroopynooperz9051 11 сағат бұрын
Because Ministry of Dog Catching doesn't hold the same importance
@wouterswanepoel5753
@wouterswanepoel5753 8 сағат бұрын
@@MrLechesa 22% of the population who voted for them. It's not difficult to figure that one out.
@P-qi6qx
@P-qi6qx 7 сағат бұрын
Remember...most of these Africans IQs are not up to par. The people first, not the politician
@MrLechesa
@MrLechesa 6 сағат бұрын
@@wouterswanepoel5753 So 40% of the population voted for less important Ministries?? How does this work? Or this is a bit of that white arrogance?
@danielnel8931
@danielnel8931 17 сағат бұрын
Welcome to South Africa where It's so sad that a 🎪 circus only have 🤡clowns and no other acts.😢
@JasonOtto
@JasonOtto 19 сағат бұрын
No, its not over before it began - that's impossible. Imagine a married couple working out there differences. It's natural and inevitable. Calm down drama queens and let this work. Because otherwise what is there? F..k all.
@stevemartin7464
@stevemartin7464 2 сағат бұрын
Yes, the ANC and EFF? Or MK? we would be f'd.
@tautebellojames7661
@tautebellojames7661 Сағат бұрын
Agreed Jason they gonna make it work... I think DA is sending a strong message to the ANC but they will work this out because both don't imagine bringing either Eff nor Mk to the table.
@roscoejacobs8467
@roscoejacobs8467 19 сағат бұрын
Analyst is bias and only speaks of DA and IFP but their are 7 other parties
@bevturner2258
@bevturner2258 Сағат бұрын
Agree PA and FF+ should have been included in discussion. The other 5 parties don’t have enough votes to be included in the allocation of ministerial posts.
@roscoejacobs8467
@roscoejacobs8467 19 сағат бұрын
William Gumede, the DA will not continue with the transformative agenda should they be afforded Economic Cluster Ministerial Positions. This analysis sounds very bias
@stevemartin7464
@stevemartin7464 2 сағат бұрын
What is the "Transformative agenda" after 30 years you would think any tranforming would have happened. The only "Transformative agenda" the ANC carried out was to transform a prosperous country into a basket case.
@starthere5406
@starthere5406 19 сағат бұрын
The ANC wants to rule. They want to carry on as before. They don't care about the people, only their cadre wallets.
@sgu00dir
@sgu00dir 20 сағат бұрын
The DA will never recover from this if they mess this chance up
@stevemartin7464
@stevemartin7464 2 сағат бұрын
South Africa may never, it is that important and the ANC is desperate to stop the DA being able to fix things.
@tautebellojames7661
@tautebellojames7661 Сағат бұрын
​@@stevemartin7464What exactly is DA going to solve?
@felicitytaylor3764
@felicitytaylor3764 20 сағат бұрын
DA created 205 000 jobs in Western Cape for all nations loads of skilled and unskilled blacks employed. The rest of the provinces lost jobs As for your answer to poor sad Helen Zille can sound arrogant but what the media never showed is Helen was in a poor rural area personally where a hospital had caught fire and Helen Zille was there with people arranging to rebuild hospital but media only show stories critisizing DA. DA anti apartheid and wants to build businesses sooo then the poor skilled and un skilled will be able to find jobs and get employed and DA fixed potholes and robots etc in Tshwane DA want those cabinets to help build a better South Africa for all
@trudyneumann8945
@trudyneumann8945 17 сағат бұрын
@@felicitytaylor3764 - did a fabulous job in Escourt too.
@silaskhalishwayo
@silaskhalishwayo 11 сағат бұрын
😂😂😂😂😂DA must first fix black squatter camps and fix cape flats first 😂
@silaskhalishwayo
@silaskhalishwayo 11 сағат бұрын
Jobs are useless because tomorrow they can say you fired 😂😂😂with no land as black people we still going to suffer not job's..job's come and go
@SilentRover-lc9jk
@SilentRover-lc9jk 10 сағат бұрын
People are moving to the WC for work. Vote ANC in other provinces, but want to live in a DA area. The irony.
@DeanRoodman
@DeanRoodman 4 сағат бұрын
​@@silaskhalishwayomaybe if they stop bussing people from the other provinces to those areas the DA would be able to get some footing. Try to look at the politics and get your mind off of the racial. Poor South Africans move to the western cape because the DA is doing their job. Open your eyes.
@lester0679
@lester0679 21 сағат бұрын
DA showing their true colours with their greed. we all hoped for a new dawn and these white imperialists couldn't help themselves with outrageous demands making it about them and their white constituents and horrendous policies instead of the well being of all South Africans. They think people don't know this and they never won votes the ANC lost them.
@jancomoatshe9534
@jancomoatshe9534 22 сағат бұрын
Anc is party of looters period theirs is to steal
@JV-ow5kg
@JV-ow5kg 23 сағат бұрын
Government of No Unity = GNU
@user-vo4wq1ul9b
@user-vo4wq1ul9b 23 сағат бұрын
Come on Ramaphoza. Stop beating around the bush. It's been proven that you can't rule the country. Rather step aside. And give someone who is. Competent to do your job. It looks like you can't even chose who is comp. And who is not.
@rolivhuwathomoli225
@rolivhuwathomoli225 23 сағат бұрын
In the interest of upholding democracy, surely one might argue that the power of the executive should be shared proportional to the vote.
@kevinbromfield7595
@kevinbromfield7595 23 сағат бұрын
The ANC just wants to carry on with their corrupted ways.
@stevemartin7464
@stevemartin7464 2 сағат бұрын
Exactly someone sees it, it isnt the DA, its the ANC trying to stop them being able to stop the ANC stealing.
@johnsianyaka4866
@johnsianyaka4866 23 сағат бұрын
Nailed it Prof
@grantbarnado7007
@grantbarnado7007 23 сағат бұрын
Defending the feeding instrument at all costs.. The comes must eat???
@trudyneumann8945
@trudyneumann8945 17 сағат бұрын
@@grantbarnado7007 - thats the problem. While the rest of us starve.
@silaskhalishwayo
@silaskhalishwayo 11 сағат бұрын
Like DA in cape black areas
@grantbarnado7007
@grantbarnado7007 9 сағат бұрын
@@silaskhalishwayo you are dishonest compare western cape to other provinces
@joumaseworld
@joumaseworld 23 сағат бұрын
Majority of Africans that i have interacted with say they would rather deal with the missery of being Governed by ANC than Be Governed by Europeans ever again....Maybe the Question should be why ?? Why do people feel that way❤
@Frank_inSA
@Frank_inSA 20 сағат бұрын
Because they were brainwashed by the likes of Malema, woke Profs and the like?
@felicitytaylor3764
@felicitytaylor3764 20 сағат бұрын
DA not the old apartheid government Look at Western Cape and how it has Improved Give DA a chance the DA wants to build a better South Africa for all nations
@MrLechesa
@MrLechesa 15 сағат бұрын
The question poised is "Why". Do you know that WC also tops the stats of inequality?? It can only be descibed as economic seggragation/apartheid. ​@@felicitytaylor3764
@llewellynlamb9545
@llewellynlamb9545 9 сағат бұрын
No only Racists like yourself, DA is the multi racial party, most Black's, whites, Indians and colourds. Wake up stop looking at skin colour. Look what's best for our Country.
@GerhardtRoos
@GerhardtRoos 6 сағат бұрын
That's the biggest mistake these clowns make. The white people of South Africa are not Europeans, we are South Africans, and our loyalty is towards South Africa, to nothing else. Most of us don't even speak a European language as our home language, yet these so-called "Africans" can't look past the colour of our skins.
@lindalauragouws6424
@lindalauragouws6424 Күн бұрын
Yes
@YenneY01
@YenneY01 Күн бұрын
The anc has shown that they can't handle finances. So the DA should get it.
@JohnJonkers-xh8wq
@JohnJonkers-xh8wq Күн бұрын
But we non white also dont want the DA to govern us...Sorry
@YenneY01
@YenneY01 Күн бұрын
So you voted anc inspite of how they have destroyed our country?
@trudyneumann8945
@trudyneumann8945 Күн бұрын
The ANC worked well for you hey??
@RG-jr8ym
@RG-jr8ym Күн бұрын
you can have the MK/EFF and ANC as your government, just go live in once corner of SA far away from us sane people..and I'm also a non white person saying this.
@wadepetersen7146
@wadepetersen7146 21 сағат бұрын
He won't respond ​@@trudyneumann8945
@Frank_inSA
@Frank_inSA 20 сағат бұрын
Talk for yourself.
@Moyopheus
@Moyopheus Күн бұрын
Silly analysis not worth paying attention to. Why would the leading party jut give the DA anything they want when yheybare half the size? Or can work with the EFF who are more aligned ? DA isover playing their hand and being stupid because they are negotiating in the media and by correspondence instead of face to face. When will they learn to be humble? Get into the GNU and make progress at that starting point and if successful people will vote for you in the next election and you could take over, leaving the GNU is childish and not putting the national interest first .
@lindylambis4828
@lindylambis4828 Күн бұрын
Always great analysis. Thank You.
@steveleroux6116
@steveleroux6116 Күн бұрын
Anything is possible in a circus full of clowns in a banana republic
@silaskhalishwayo
@silaskhalishwayo 11 сағат бұрын
DA is a liked clown 😂😂😂
@GerhardtRoos
@GerhardtRoos 7 сағат бұрын
​@@silaskhalishwayo Haven't you been watching the ANC flop around like a fish out of water for the last 30 years, making one bad decision after another, and always blaming apartheid for their failures. And then you want to call the DA clowns. The voters are the biggest clowns, for electing the ANC time and again, and always expecting different results.
@danogunner
@danogunner Күн бұрын
“You can’t negotiate with terrorists”, a party that put it’s country in darkness, took literacy levels to the lowest in the world and tanked the Rand aren’t going to do what’s right for SA. Diminish your expectations. ANC: “let’s compromise, we take 100% and you take 0%… 0 is still a number, also, Apartheid so…”
@philipcowie2478
@philipcowie2478 Күн бұрын
Wow! Intelligent guest!
@CeciliaAdrio-ek5iq
@CeciliaAdrio-ek5iq Күн бұрын
Mr Gumede is a Gentleman 👍
@lemontree397
@lemontree397 Күн бұрын
When the ANC started these negotiations I honestly thought that they are finally on a road to redemption and I was hopeful that they would act in the best interests of South Africa. We have this opportunity to turn SA back from this state of mediocrity and decline, but not if we're going to have another 5 years of effectively ANC rule.
@sharkie9701
@sharkie9701 6 сағат бұрын
They still got most of the national votes. If the DA wants to run the country they must win the elections.
@peetjvv
@peetjvv Күн бұрын
As long as Ramaphosa assigns cabinet posts proportional to votes each member party received. If that means the DA gets lower tier portfolios like Sport, Arts, Culture, etc. - so be it
@stevemartin7464
@stevemartin7464 2 сағат бұрын
No, not so be it, if the DA does not get any meaningful posts, then how can they impriove the country and save it from the ANC?