When AIKIDO Meets KUNG FU (Part Two)
2:32
23 сағат бұрын
What Is KI in Aikido?
3:44
14 күн бұрын
Aikido LEG LOCKS
2:17
Ай бұрын
FIGHTING From Your BACK In AIKIDO
14:12
Learning To FIGHT With AIKIDO
8:29
How To Take A Punch 👊
11:53
3 ай бұрын
The 'Old Forms Of Aikido'
12:29
4 ай бұрын
Пікірлер
@haffoc
@haffoc 14 сағат бұрын
for the shotokan people who happen to see this video, the parry the guy is doing is found in the kata hangetsu. you can use his throw as one of your counters from this parry.
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 9 сағат бұрын
I love how various different martial arts over the years have come to the same conclusions about certain mechanics - this channel is about makign those things more obvious and giving people the choice to "borrow' things :) great comment thanks!
@Kyle-uq2gt
@Kyle-uq2gt Күн бұрын
My journey to my self thought training thank you so much 🙏
@Kyle-uq2gt
@Kyle-uq2gt Күн бұрын
Very well effective unbelievable
@Clarity2020Australia
@Clarity2020Australia 2 күн бұрын
Simple concepts well explained
@BoomBoomDeluxe
@BoomBoomDeluxe 2 күн бұрын
This has been a good series thanks for posting
@chibibatman4277
@chibibatman4277 2 күн бұрын
L'ouverture de votre école à d'autres styles est une très belle initiative. Bonne continuation
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 2 күн бұрын
@@chibibatman4277 Merci. Cette chaîne est dédiée à encourager la formation croisée dans les arts martiaux, nous pouvons tous apprendre les uns des autres !
@researchthefacts-xm2sv
@researchthefacts-xm2sv 3 күн бұрын
SENSI WHERE DO YOU TRAIN WHICH COUNTRY WHICH PLACE DATES TIMES COSTS THANK YOU PLS HELP
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 3 күн бұрын
Nick is in Auckland New Zealand
@maceyrickard6836
@maceyrickard6836 4 күн бұрын
Sayo undo took me a while there was a time though where I blundered an ikkyu in a 3man tag and pulled it off your name seems more proper
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 3 күн бұрын
Many names for this, but the underlying principles are sound and it's a very good training drill to make one move as a unified system as opposed to just throwing with the arms, it converts I to many other useful shapes too
@BoomBoomDeluxe
@BoomBoomDeluxe 6 күн бұрын
Nice ideas here
@AlphonsoFrett-xz6pi
@AlphonsoFrett-xz6pi 6 күн бұрын
Thanks for sharing your hard work
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 6 күн бұрын
A pleasure. If it makes people experiment with their training and swap ideas with other arts we have achieved something
@jgary5771
@jgary5771 10 күн бұрын
Ninja rules
@ddturnerphd
@ddturnerphd 10 күн бұрын
Aikido reconnecting with Kung Fu?
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 10 күн бұрын
Via mark Sensei, their style of jujutsu includes aspects of both
@akcortes9887
@akcortes9887 11 күн бұрын
Isso não é aikido. Na verdade o aikido puro não funciona, por isso tem que se valer de técnicas de outras artes
@BoomBoomDeluxe
@BoomBoomDeluxe 11 күн бұрын
His is how aikido was pre ww2. Why make a comment when you know nothing about the subject? If you don't like aikido go watch something else, I hope making an anonymous comment made you feel better about your own pathetic life, if only for a second
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 12 күн бұрын
Ki is the foundation of Aikido training but its not a religion. At minimum its a high level of concentration, breathing and centreing at a higher level its attempting to influence the external world
@speckles9251
@speckles9251 13 күн бұрын
From my perspective, in both knife defense techniques, the moves after the initial deflection actually moved the knife into a zone where you had no cover. I'm not sure if that would be a reliable technique in real life. The initial deflection could work. But then ...?
@angelnegrete7191
@angelnegrete7191 13 күн бұрын
I want to learn ninjitsu
@MushaShugyo369
@MushaShugyo369 14 күн бұрын
such a great perspective!
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 14 күн бұрын
I'd be interested to hear how other people in the community view the concept too?
@ddturnerphd
@ddturnerphd 14 күн бұрын
Thanks for your insights Marcus Encel sensei.
@Liminal_Ascetic
@Liminal_Ascetic 14 күн бұрын
Some interesting points and examples to consider. For some reason, I never really thought about planetary orbits in connection to Aikido, but it's an interesting image when considering how Aikido works. 🙏
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 14 күн бұрын
It's definitely a cool metaphor
@tispaccun2
@tispaccun2 15 күн бұрын
No disrespect. There are better martial arts. Be true to yourself. A black belt in Aikido wouldn't last a minute with an amateur mma fighter
@Clarity2020Australia
@Clarity2020Australia 14 күн бұрын
Lol, that us the literal definition of disrespect! Why even bother making a comment like this? You clearly know nothing about the subject matter nor the fact this channel is about all arts cross training together. If you don't like something, just be an adult and scroll past, it just makes you look like you're compensating for something
@10clapbaacs78
@10clapbaacs78 15 күн бұрын
Its like samurai nija type combat ,where did the Maori people learn this from
@sullybong
@sullybong 16 күн бұрын
Jumanji is a fire element,I know it can work while backing off but it's made as an explosive movement as if your back was against a wall. Also important to hit the butsu metsu to take away the spirit
@RetrogasmicPodcast
@RetrogasmicPodcast 16 күн бұрын
jumanji also a good board game for all the family.
@ddturnerphd
@ddturnerphd 17 күн бұрын
What about those of us without a belly button?
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 17 күн бұрын
Test tube clones like yourself can either wear a lycra morph suit or train naked
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 18 күн бұрын
hope this is useful! probably the most asked question from beginners!
@Clarity2020Australia
@Clarity2020Australia 17 күн бұрын
Always useful!
@seifallahbey583
@seifallahbey583 19 күн бұрын
Very well done, sensei... 💯💯💯
@nikosskeptikos6295
@nikosskeptikos6295 19 күн бұрын
Always funny when he breaks this out - he can still do it now, even in his 60's LOL
@matt_v2305
@matt_v2305 19 күн бұрын
Great no nonsense instruction. Love it.
@matt_v2305
@matt_v2305 19 күн бұрын
Hope there's a Part Three. 😊
@ScottPalangi
@ScottPalangi 20 күн бұрын
Why do they work in Ireland? Gravity different over there?
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 20 күн бұрын
Ireland??
@RetrogasmicPodcast
@RetrogasmicPodcast 19 күн бұрын
IRL, just in case you genuinely don't know, means "In Real Life". If you did know that, congratulations on the worst dad joke this year...
@ddturnerphd
@ddturnerphd 22 күн бұрын
Lots to consider here.
@regmullett4899
@regmullett4899 22 күн бұрын
I didnt realise backing away was illegal in judo? Or did you mean BJJ?
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 22 күн бұрын
@@regmullett4899 judo considered stalling- when you put your weight backwards, it stops the free flow of action and opportunities to throw. In BJJ the rules aren’t so strict But you will get warned if the action doesn’t keep flowing and get advantages. Subtracted that you’re not gonna get disqualified for it, but by the same token you’re not gonna get a win doing it either.
@CarlaCasteneda
@CarlaCasteneda 22 күн бұрын
I've watched this twice now and eneded up taking notes - that's always a sign of a good instructional video from my POV :)
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 22 күн бұрын
@@CarlaCasteneda thank you 🙏🏻 message anytime you have a question
@RetrogasmicPodcast
@RetrogasmicPodcast 22 күн бұрын
👍🏼👍🏼
@nikosskeptikos6295
@nikosskeptikos6295 22 күн бұрын
It's always a special camp when marcus visits, he always brings great energy and a big range of ideas with him. if you're ever in melbourne his dojo is really cool and well worth a visit.
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 22 күн бұрын
@@nikosskeptikos6295 thanks bro
@BoomBoomDeluxe
@BoomBoomDeluxe 22 күн бұрын
the headlock hip throw, a lot!
@dunkenFrancis
@dunkenFrancis 22 күн бұрын
Great session marcus!
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 22 күн бұрын
@@dunkenFrancis thanks mate. Great channel ( obviously) great opportunity
@OsRaunio
@OsRaunio 22 күн бұрын
Don't hit yokomenuchi from behind your ear, that opens you up. Strike on your central line, so your hand stays covering you in front, turn it as a side cut by turning your body. Use also the other hand to contact opponents front hand.
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 22 күн бұрын
I think I addressed that. There are short and long yokomen. It depends on the circumstances one certainly never opens up or telegraphs attack.
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 22 күн бұрын
We dropped yokem as an attack some years ago partly for that reason - NO_ONE ever strikes like that IRL, so why train it? We replaced with over hands, haymakers, crosses etc, basically variations on the angle "Yokomenuchi" supposedly teaches, and the really interesting aspect is how each strike modifies how you react and often how viable the end technique then becomes. For the purposes of a video like this I totally understand marcus keeping it "traditional" as he's basically referring to core techniques he feels "are releiable" so makes snese to keep the original shape and concept.
@OsRaunio
@OsRaunio 22 күн бұрын
@@marcusencel3528 Yes, I was expanding the idea. What I think shomen and yokomenuchi are, they are also ways to enter and deflect incoming attacks, like you did in the "slipping". Yokomen uchi can also used against haymaker or hammer fist, of course train against an actual haymaker, but has the same principles. O-sensei used shomenuchi to initiate the technique. Using yokomuchi also teaches how to turn your body and using your tegatana in techniques. It's not just judo chop on temple :)
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 22 күн бұрын
@@AIKIDOSILVERDALE certainly people wont throw yokomen unarmed but they definitely do when using weopons be it chair tire lever knife. I dont use it because other people use it. I use it because it works. I never teach defence against the haymaker because it’s a sloppy attack. and very easy to counter. If you can defend the hook, then the haymaker is easy. Yokon as an attack is excellent but like everything must be used in its place. When used incorrectly generally goes something like this. They raise their hand in range and get hit. They throw. Yokomen from in front of the opponent, instead of out the side. They attack head on with the circular attack. I think we might have done a video about this at some point
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 22 күн бұрын
@@OsRaunio yokomen can be used against anything. But like everything it has to be executed correctly at the right time. Often you see people using footwork for direct attack while throwing an elliptical yokomen- this won’t work. Also, you see them throw it from too close. It’s worth noting, there are many kinds of ways of yokomen from almost completely straight to from the side curved. It just has to follow basic principles when it’s possible to go straight you go straight, but when there’s something in the way you go around just like with a hook or roundhouse kick. When the guard is up, you need to go around it
@MisMonic
@MisMonic 22 күн бұрын
#BadNinja
@Nardocardo
@Nardocardo 25 күн бұрын
no real test, the guy cooperates and is not resistin
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 25 күн бұрын
?? It wasn't meant to BE a test! You get this is a teacher demonstrating, not a fight? Try handing someone a violin and saying "play paganinni" and see how that goes. The video is about the techniques he has found, personally, work reliably under pressure. This comes from being a finalist at the world BJJ tournament and 50 years of aikido, plus living in rough areas of Australia. It' his opinion, if you don't agree, that's fine, provide alternatives or reasons why you don't trust those particular techniques uinder pressure, but your comment makes zero sense I'm afrad.
@CFgroup1
@CFgroup1 25 күн бұрын
@@AIKIDOSILVERDALE Obviously you're demonstrating but also have your Uke resist you. Pressure test all your techniques. Try them in Judo type Randori and film it.
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 25 күн бұрын
@@CFgroup1 Again, it was a class, not training, he was talking about theoretical favourites and showing the principles, when do you ever pressure test when you're teaching unless you are specifically teaching henka from pressure testing?? You seem to be missing the point my friend.
@superfoot53
@superfoot53 25 күн бұрын
you so stupid, don't see what point.
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 25 күн бұрын
@@CFgroup1you do you ill do me. There are circumstances where that might be appropriate but not this one. Plus teaching judo is not significantly different- No teacher likes a student trying to fight in a demo😂 great way to start a fight.
@MrBluemanworld
@MrBluemanworld 25 күн бұрын
Speak for yourself, I was good at every technique
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 25 күн бұрын
@@MrBluemanworld the video isn't about being good at kata it about understanding which principles and techniques are the most reliable, as with all systems, some things work under pressure more often than others.
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 25 күн бұрын
@@MrBluemanworld i am
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 25 күн бұрын
Lol
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 25 күн бұрын
Show us
@junglejim3433
@junglejim3433 26 күн бұрын
I used to work with this big guy who liked to test me. I was 145lbs and had practiced at an Aikikai for less than a year when I threw him with Kokyu Nage. He was a fit 260lbs with a high school wrestling and football (American) background. One day he came at me, in good fun, but with a strong aggressive attack. He grabbed both my biceps and started pushing. There's no way that I could resist this guy, but with my novice Aikido technique he went flying, landing safely on a pile of broken down cardboard boxes. It convinced me that Aikido can work!
@rickdangerfield1183
@rickdangerfield1183 26 күн бұрын
👍🏼👍🏼👊🏼👊🏼
@RetrogasmicPodcast
@RetrogasmicPodcast 26 күн бұрын
A good point he makes about fights not starting when you're actually ready. it's aalways some random drunk or a crack head that suddenly appears out of bloody nowhere!
@regmullett4899
@regmullett4899 26 күн бұрын
😅😅😂😂🤣🤣
@nikosskeptikos6295
@nikosskeptikos6295 26 күн бұрын
It's interesting that when senior grades talk about "reliable techniques" it's very often the basics. That kokyu is one of the simplest ways to unbalance a person but very effective as its a whole body movement
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 26 күн бұрын
very true
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 26 күн бұрын
Basics are basics for a reason
@Clarity2020Australia
@Clarity2020Australia 26 күн бұрын
Great clip talks a lot of sense
@CarlaCasteneda
@CarlaCasteneda 26 күн бұрын
It's great to have people of marcus' experience not only in the organisation but on the channel. I hope he can make itr over to summer camp next year!
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 26 күн бұрын
totally agree. We have a similar backgroiund but often come to principles from a completely different standpoint which is always fascinating, and useful!
@marcusencel3528
@marcusencel3528 26 күн бұрын
Sure will Myself and PA ( daughter and students
@AlphonsoFrett-xz6pi
@AlphonsoFrett-xz6pi 26 күн бұрын
Unfortunately for me hard art philosophy didn't work for me when Aikido philosophy plus Bible studies did
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 26 күн бұрын
I'm glad you found something that works for you, that's all most of us can hope for!
@AlphonsoFrett-xz6pi
@AlphonsoFrett-xz6pi 26 күн бұрын
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE It's my belief the that people should learn the history of Aikido and cross train
@AlphonsoFrett-xz6pi
@AlphonsoFrett-xz6pi 26 күн бұрын
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE Aikido gets a bad deal because the philosophy is not properly explained also there should be Judo people to help with the self defense part of training to teach why the founder became a non-volant person
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 26 күн бұрын
@@AlphonsoFrett-xz6pi couldn't agree more!
@robertcurtis3807
@robertcurtis3807 27 күн бұрын
Garage Aikido.
@nikosskeptikos6295
@nikosskeptikos6295 27 күн бұрын
More like Aunkai in a kodern context. I've worked doors too and as he says this is a great mechanic for destabilising structure. JH has massive rep in NZ as one of the foremost self defence experts, he makes this stuff look easy but it's real hard to pull off.
@ClangThePodcast
@ClangThePodcast 27 күн бұрын
Was just thinking: I need a good video that reacquaints me with the basic fundamental aiki movements. Dunk to the rescue again!!!😂
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 27 күн бұрын
:😄
@VenturaIT
@VenturaIT 29 күн бұрын
if you find yourself on your back that means you weren't doing aikido... now how to do aikido without doing aikido?
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 29 күн бұрын
I hear this POV a lot - but o sensei originally (pre war) taught many ground techniques both from back, kneeling and sprawl - it's just that as the years went on and his offspring took the helm their lack of expereince meant the syllabus got reduced, sometimes dramatically. The real question i guess is do you want to not train skills you may need to survive against very common situations? In countries like NZ, where rugby is kill, a huge proportion of fights will in volve someone taking you to the ground - surely it's better to have a rounded repertoire that will serve you well than try to "not fall over"? A randoori drill we often do is 2 versus 1, with both partners 100% trying to grab the third person and pin the to the ground by any means. it's virtually impossible to stay upright. Worth thinking about if nothing else. The information is out there, why not use it?
@VenturaIT
@VenturaIT 29 күн бұрын
@@AIKIDOSILVERDALE I trained BJJ for 3 years... I just wonder what the original Aikido thought about these judo takedowns... I'm sure they had responses to them... you see O-Sensei demonstrating the defense to the double leg take down almost every time, his method was to have a strong hamni and then to deflect nage's head to the side so as to say if you stand with your feet side to side you are going to get taken down if you have a strong rooted hamni then you wont get taken down... I think I've even read that aikido had specific answers for every judo attack... but like you said they might have been lost. I know Daito and a huge curriculum and O-Sensei was originally teaching Daito-Ryu... somehow aikido has moved from actual lapel grabs to shoulder gi grabs so the reality of the choke from the lapel as been lost and then when the aikidoka gets confronted with BJJ or Judo lapel grabs most of them are confused and at a loss.
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 29 күн бұрын
@@VenturaIT Very true, there has been a terrible dilution and devolution of the art, which personally i feel HAS to be addresses to stop Aikido becoming like modern tai chi
@VenturaIT
@VenturaIT 29 күн бұрын
@@AIKIDOSILVERDALE ​ it's been confused for a long time, but being like tai chi is not bad, tai chi learned from a good teacher is deadly and will make your aikido scary deadly, 1st gen aikidoka were the only legit ones, and I don't even mean the Aikikai uchi-deshi I mean Shioda and tohei and prewar black belts when it was still Daito Ryu... the rest don't even do it the same way as O-Sensei did it, you can tell by the way irimi nage is done, if it's done like Osensei or not... but there is more to that than meets the eye... this guy does an important study on this MARIUSVL www.youtube.com/@MARIUSVL I did a few years direct online study with Stanley Pranin about this and read around as much as I could and the uchi-deshi after Tohei didn't really train with OSensei very often and didn't like to listen to him talk about ki and listen to his poetry and talks. I studied with my dad who studied under a studen of Tohei and sometimes Tohei and there is such a big difference between Aikikai and the Aikido that works. I did Aikikai for most of my adult life from age 14 and it just never worked, this is why Aikido is getting a bad name, because (and you can prove this from historical documents) the real aikido transmission was given to Tohei only but Tohei also promised OSensei to make sure his family would be financial secure, that was also Tohei's job, so Tohei gave them the name Aikido, but they aren't doing the real aikido. OSensei's son was never into Aikido, more like foreced to do it by his dad. Even Saito Sensei didn't do irimi nage like OSensei... And I apologize if you know any of these people. The real "Aikido" went with the Tohei lineage. If you want to wrestle you aren't doing Aikido, that's something else. Aikido happens on the moment of contact and then it's over, after that it's something else. If you didn't do aikido then maybe you have to do BJJ or Judo or something else. Most of Aikido is how to not get into a bad situation, so when people say what do I do when I'm hanging from a rope from a highrish building by one ankle so Im upside down and then there is an army of expert snipers pointing their guns at me from inside the building and I have a noose around my neck... how does Aikido deal with that? The real question is how to not get on your back in the first place and that's done with proper mai'ai and strong hamni and avoiding conflicts. If you see here OSensei is doing one of his last demonstrations and it's just a demonstration, not a fight or real attacks, but if you didn't really attack OSensei he would get mad a hurt you badly, his students knew to give real force. But you have to understand this is a demonstration... he shows several double leg or single leg takedown type defenses, and his technique is mostly ki based and overall he looks more like an internal Kung Fu master from China like Grand Master Huang Sheng-shyan. See how similar Aikido is to Tai Chi? kzbin.info/www/bejne/joTRhneheLZjjbc And Huang Sheng-shyan is a tai chi master who proved his skills in the ring against the Asian champion pro wrestler of the time and defeated him unanimously in each round and it was televised. So being like Tai Chi is not a big deal (the words mean same thing Ai Tai Ki Chi Do Chuan.) Have you ever been moved by real internal ki power or chi power from your teacher? Until you feel this you can't understand Aikido which is really the Japanese version of Tai Chi. kzbin.info/www/bejne/joLGo4Kja6aHsK8
@MP-db9sw
@MP-db9sw 29 күн бұрын
Ive watched these "Fix Aikido" videos up to this one. I wanted to watch them all before commenting and I dont see a pt7 so Im assuming and hoping this is the last in the series. From the perspective of someone who was in love with Aikido as a kid, who trained in it for about a year back around 2000-01 and then basically learned that as cool and fun as it was, I would be better of doing other things and moved on, who still wants Aikido to be as good as I thought it was when I didnt know any better, and who has a little over 35 yrs history in a variety of martial arts and combat sports, heres my perspective on how to fix Aikido. And Sensei, if youre reading this, I hope that I can articulate some of the things that I think youve chosen not to say, outright. From the points youve made in these videos I think a lot of this will be familiar to you, already. First thing for the Aikido community at large needs to do is attempt to collectively decide or reconcile what "Aikido" even is. Its clear that what O'Sensei was doing when he first began teaching was different from the Aikido that he was trying to leave behind him as an old man. The prevailing belief is that many or most of his early students came to him already skilled in other styles and Aikido training was "tougher" and "more martial" in the beginning. More Aiki-jujutsu than Aiki-do. This is the first part of what has to be reconciled - O'sensei changed the system deliberately over time and in the end he intended it as a means of personal development (enlightenment?) and "achieving peace". Even if the only changes you make are done with the intention to steer back towards the "tougher, more martial" version of Aikido, would it still be Aikido? Or would it be "Ueshiba Aiki-jujitsu"? Which brings up the next part of reconciling - the "cult of personality" around sensei Ueshiba. Do you think its still appropriate for new students to accept the role of being disciples of a man who theyve never met and who was dead before they were even born? Because if the answer is "yes" then there is not much "fixing" to be done. Look to the history - Ueshibas writings and interviews, speeches etc, lectures and writings of his direct students, ect - maybe start with Stanley Pranin, he covered as much of that ground as he could so you can try picking up where he left off, and just do your best to be loyal disciples. Whatever changes you make need to be from the mindset of following the path he (should I say "He"?) laid out. Or choose to drop the discipleship and decide what you want your Aikido to be, _today_ Assuming you want it to be effective as a form of self defense, how far do you want to take that approach? Is being probably able to defend yourself from a drunk throwing a haymaker good enough? Do you want the system to be competent against people who are fit and can actually fight? The flaws I see in Aikido as a fighting system are: A) Its confused about what it is. B) it is lacking in contextual understanding of what it is doing and is generally ignorant of what it will face in real life fighting, especially fighting people from other, more competent systems. C) Theres no sincere sparring A) Confusion - is it a fighting system or a philosophy or a path to "enlightenment"? Is it sword fighting or not? Is it a grappling system or not? Im gonna skip the enlightenment/philosophy part (but thats a huge aspect of the confusion I mentioned) and go to the sword thing. Every Aikidoka knows its a "sword art" but you arent using swords and somehow no one seems to think this is silly. Yea I know theres jo/bokken kata but be real - why are you training to use a sword to defend against sword attacks when neither person has a sword in their hands? Its like kids pointing their fingers at each other and yelling "BANG BANG YOURE DEAD!" thinking this will make them good both at shooting AND at karate. If youre gonna train swords then keep the swords (or sticks) but if youre going to train punches then use punches. B) Contextual understanding its own techniques and general ignorance of fighting systems. Starting with punching.Aiki punches almost always the same thing: 1) uke in fighting stance. 2) uke strikes with rear hand while stepping forward with rear foot. 3) force and bodyweight are projected into the attack to "give good energy" to Tori. In boxing this kind of strike is called a "shift" so it loosely resembles something real but in boxing its used probably less than 1% of the time and the way yall do it is completely out of context of how its used even in that 1% - so you have a thousand ways to defend these artificial "punches" that almost no one will ever actually throw at you and not one single defense against a properly thrown straight right/right cross (or "backhand" as they say across the pond). I'll condense the point down to "no one gets a black belt without two years training in boxing under a boxing coach from a gym that competes in actual, full contact boxing matches". You could condense that down to spending a few weeks looking up and practicing correct boxing techniques on youtube. Jab, straight, 1,2, and lead hook, at least. Learn how to do them correctly, and how to set them up and throw them so as to make them more likely to land. Adapt your system to actual punches instead of just doing Aikido sword strikes with a balled fist. Next is the grappling. Starting with wrist grabs. Theres tons of wrist grab defenses in Aikido but they tend to be just as out of context as the "punches" and "punch defenses". Next time you do your wrist grab stuff tell uke "let go and pull your hand back before I can do the technique". How much of what youre doing just vanishes? Try it and find out? Question: why would someone grab your wrist _and hold on to it_ long enough for you to shiho-nage? 1) because you have a knife in your hand and they know youll stab them if they let go. 2) because theyre drunk or dumb and dont know any better, 3) because thats what sensei told them to do. Of those things, only the first one makes sense to train as a martial tactic. If we just ask "why would someone grab your wrist?" then the best answer in a martial context is "because they know what theyre doing" Wrist grabs (wrist control) are a real thing in grappling systems but (unlike most Aikido) they have real meaning and real context behind them. Russian ties, 2 on 1's, "Kimura" or "Americana" ura/ude garame, wrist control and collar tie, wrist control and underhook, etc. If Judoka or wrestler grabs your wrist, that grab is just one part of a larger plan. Theyre not just generically grabbing your wrist, theyre going to do it in a particular way in accordance with the particular plan. If you do something to negate that plan, they let go and do something else. If youre training to defend against real wrist grabs then you need to understand how theyre really used. If youre grabbing each others wrists without the slightest clue of what to actually do with it once you've got it then what are you really doing? If youre defending grabs from people who dont know what theyre doing when they grab you then what are you really defending? Same for the lapel grabs. If you dont actually know what to do with someones lapel then why are you grabbing it and why do they need some technically complicated, formalized method of defending it? If youre defending something you dont understand then how do you judge the effectiveness of your defense? How do you refine it or adapt it to different circumstances? Its back to pointing your fingers and yelling "BANG!" So, no one gets a black belt without two years of Judo lol C) Sincere sparring. I know a lot of techniques can cause injury if uke resists but thats usually only after a certain point. One thing that could improve your techniques is to only do them up to the point where tori and uke agree that trying to escape would cause injury. If uke knows they wont be hurt then theyre free to let go or even really resist, at least up to that point. If tori can reach that point then everyone knows the technique worked. This one small change adds a lot of sincerity right off the bat. Also, learn some basic judo grips and throwing set ups and positions (even if you dont actually throw) and apply the aiki defenses to those. And at some point uke needs to be free to attack how they see fit. This _people sticking out their hands with a "pull my finger" grin on their face_ stuff has got to be put in check lol.
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 29 күн бұрын
It is very, very rare I agree with a log, considered comment on this channel uin entirety, but here you've basically summed up our thinking and proess over the last decade! The point about "what IS Aikido" is well made and varies so much (Ki to Yoshinkan as a random - to + example) as to be almost without definition. We adopted "Aikijutsu" after much discussion purely as a way to allow new students to realize we focus upon function. No shomen, no yokomen (as you mentioned, jab, cross, hook, over hand; all are trained on the bag and pads then trained against - many traditional techniques simply become unreliable or required adaptation to function). Re the sparring - this is a minefield buy atm we are using a 4 stage sparring system we developed, each level focussing upon a core principle, Aiki, Kuzushi, Atemi, randoori/kumite (they are shown as videos elsewhere on the channel) and this of all the "evolutions" we've i mplemented has caused the most kickback from the traditional community, which frankly i find astomnishing. Without pressure testing what you do, your technique and strategy is only theory, and without randomness, your training patterns are predicatable, unlike real life. Comment of the year - I hope you don't mind I am going to repost this in the 'Aikido - The martial Side" group on faebook, i'm sure it will stimulate more discussion.
@Laj-t9k
@Laj-t9k Ай бұрын
0:54 This reminds me of a similar technique from a Shorei-kan karate kata.
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE Ай бұрын
Interesting. Have you got a link so people can compare please?
@Laj-t9k
@Laj-t9k 29 күн бұрын
Search for "#6 kumite Rukodan."
@Laj-t9k
@Laj-t9k 29 күн бұрын
​@@AIKIDOSILVERDALEMy replies aren't being posted. It is on the atShoreikankarate channel. Two person kumite rokudan. The kata appears to include shionage in addition to the ankle pick technique.
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE
@AIKIDOSILVERDALE 29 күн бұрын
@@Laj-t9k ahh maybe YT is blocking the link, my apologies and thank you for the heads up, will go have a look shortly.