ATT 1968-1970, Model Power 1971-2014, Lionel 2014-Present.(Model Power bought out by Lionel in 2014)
@dastumer3 ай бұрын
Brian, do you have any kind of ventilation set up for the printer? Resin fume exposure is the main thing keeping me from getting a resin printer myself, and I haven't seen a real safe way to deal with that without putting the printer in a garage or something.
@6axlepwr3 ай бұрын
No special ventilation system. Just what comes with the machine. It is pretty good.
@johngauthier36013 ай бұрын
@Brian Banna with shapeways going belly up are we still able to purchase your parts? Those esu board holders for Kato units are awesome
@6axlepwr3 ай бұрын
Probably not. I am not going to go in the business of selling parts. To much work on my side. It is just a hobby for me. Not a business.
@johngauthier36013 ай бұрын
@@6axlepwrgotcha, I don’t blame ya. Any idea if anyone could pick up the file to print them?
@robertpetit573 ай бұрын
So, what happened with this build? I'm not seeing any more videos on your channel.
@6axlepwr3 ай бұрын
That model is gone. I sold it some time ago.
@wparr196913 ай бұрын
Who does your custom walkway tread? I need some decent GP7/9 Highnose and GP7/18 low-nose treadplates for Proto 2000 models
@6axlepwr3 ай бұрын
Hi Nose and low nose tread plate would be the same. Right? I would think they would. The height of the nose has nothing to do with the overall base shape. I get my etchings done at PPD Ltd in the UK.
@wparr19691Ай бұрын
@@6axlepwr The height of the nose has nothing to do with the overall base shape. It does as a Low nose the step up to the cab is more towards the cab than on a low nose. It is why you see the handrails on a high vs low nose and have a step down before you get the steps up to the locomotive. Another question I have is what program did you use to create your 3D artwork to have the etchings made and in what material and thickness did you do yours in?
@Greatdome993 ай бұрын
WTF? Where was the model??
@6axlepwr3 ай бұрын
It is still on my bench. It is summer time and modeling takes a back seat to summer events and things.
@billpavlick693 ай бұрын
Hi Brian, very informative as always. Thanks for sharing. Who do you use for photoetched parts and do you have to supply the artwork? Thanks again. Bill
@6axlepwr3 ай бұрын
I use PPD Ltd in the UK. Yes, you need to supply your own artwork.
@dwells774 ай бұрын
Hi Brian, regarding the plow, if you like, I can adjust the file for plows blade depth to make the "V" or wedge shape of the blade a bit more narrow to allow for the coupler trip pin. Let me know.🙂
@6axlepwr4 ай бұрын
That would be great. If you can do that. I sure would appreciate it.
@jrrscttktts4 ай бұрын
I just found you on line with your modeling time. I usually watch something on my iPad while I have lunch. Lunch got a little long today as I watched three episodes. You helped me with photos of of RS3 details a few years ago. Life got in the way and I have not finished yet. I am sort of doing a production line as I wound up trying to 8 RS3 at the same time. I am 86 so I don’t work all that fast any more and I am also my wife’s care giver. Any way I will following along with your RS11 project. I am also trying to learn 3D printing. Finding a lot of what you are doing very interesting. Thank you for taking the time to do the shows.
@Greatdome994 ай бұрын
4:44: The glad hand on coupler is a universal problem for many locos. Not only will the glad hand rub on pilots/plows, but glad hands on adjoining cars will hit the pilot/plow so they won't couple or will inadvertently uncoupler during slack action. So if you use magnetic uncoupling and need the glad hand, just use the longer shank Kadee coupler. It'll look a little odd for ten minutes, but after that you won't notice, and your trains will run very nicely.
@toddferguson47655 ай бұрын
Excellent information Brian. I wondered if you just considered doing the pilots as 3D prints too. It seems to me that might be a good option especially if you are planning to do a number of units. I’m considering that path for some B&LE SDs as they had an additional step versus the typical EMD locomotive of the era. Also the upper corners of the pilots were cut out as the footboards were removed and the coupler lift bars were modified to enable using them from the steps.
@6axlepwr5 ай бұрын
Hi Todd, thank you for your input. I have tried printing pilots. They tend to want to warp. I have given a lot of thought to it, but unsuccessful at keeping pilot plates flat. The RS11's already have somewhat of a step in on the pilot in relation to the bottom step.
@Vman77575 ай бұрын
Thank you for sharing. This was a good one. I'm now learning how to use Alibre. Thanks again. Drawing some shells in N scale.
@jazzlife15 ай бұрын
Glad you’re back Brian. Why don’t you cut the glad hand off the coupler?
@mickenright27215 ай бұрын
Or, use a longer-shank coupler.
@mickenright27215 ай бұрын
Or, I could watch the whole video before commenting. Oops.
@Greatdome994 ай бұрын
Some folks actually use magnetic uncoupling--lots of fun and avoids monster hands invading planet layout.
@Vman77575 ай бұрын
Hey Brian. I just got Alibre drawing program. Thanks for mentioning it. I bought it. Very easy to use. Love that it stays with your computer. Thanks again. Not to draw something to print. LOL
@thomasryan96396 ай бұрын
5:05 Nice work! Instead of throwing away those pieces that don't fit, maybe you could use them as a junk load for a gondola or flat car.
@Vman77576 ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing, Brian. Love watching your Videos. Someday I may do videos of detailing my N scale. Keep up the great work.
@johnscherer19226 ай бұрын
hey brian, i enjoy watching your stuff, am in awe of your modelling abilities, but remember, if it's not fun, what is it. and as one professor taught us, Keep It Simple Stupid. i enjoy your videos, keep up the good work. john
@hexl39746 ай бұрын
Hi Brian, Thank you so much for taking the time to talk about how you evolved your design of the air tanks. I really appreciated the techniques you covered in how you developed the tank ends and the internal supports. I really like that idea of creating tools to help clean up your end pieces so they fit flawlessly. I've been a fan of your work and again thank you for sharing your knowledge and techniques. Please keep posting your videos! Hector
@dwells776 ай бұрын
Hi Brian, the recreation of finer grilles using 3D printing is promising! I found this out when designing and printing out the replacement dynamic brake hatch for my Athearn BB GP9. The side intake grilles and exhaust fan grille on the 48" cap top rendered beautifully, better than anything I've seen that was produced by injection molding. Anyhow, nice work! Keep it up! You are inspiring and motivating me to forge ahead in my own efforts!
@MoPac-Trains6 ай бұрын
I'm looking forward to the finished ALCo RS11. The radiator fan and hold down bolts look fantastic. The etched metal and resin trucks is an interesting idea. Thanks for sharing.
@Vman77576 ай бұрын
My fingers are crossed. Trying to convert to n scale. Boy oh boy. LOL I learning to use Alibre. Are you using the Hobby Version? The $199 one time cost?
@themarkwiens6 ай бұрын
I am really curious to see how you were able to hold the sill in the mill.
@6axlepwr6 ай бұрын
Very carefully.
@themarkwiens6 ай бұрын
I'm surprised you didn't do photo-etched steps.
@6axlepwr6 ай бұрын
It is not over yet. 🙂
@Grainexpress7 ай бұрын
Your locomotive will look great weathered. Doesn’t have to be over the top but just showing some years of good use in the field. Your weathering is the absolute best! 😎
@Vman77577 ай бұрын
Thank you for sharing. You are getting beautiful detail in your parts. What draw program are you using again?
@6axlepwr7 ай бұрын
Alibre. ATOM 3D
@yoona9697 ай бұрын
I get your reticence about weathering 🤔🫤 but if I may say your past weathering projects on your locomotives are the best I have ever seen by far - they are on another level of perfection sir 🙏🏻🫣
@6axlepwr7 ай бұрын
Thank you. That is very kind of you to say.
@edcvgp97 ай бұрын
Great job as usual, can I ask where you get your photo etch work done? Thanks Ed
@6axlepwr7 ай бұрын
PPD LTD in the UK. ppdltd.com
@edcvgp96 ай бұрын
@@6axlepwrthanks Brian
@Vman77577 ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing. I'm learning a lot. and getting lots of good idea. I just have to convert it all to N scale. LOL
@yrunaked47 ай бұрын
Brian, will you be using any brass etchings? KV models has a lot of good ones for the RS series and the RS 11. Cheers Rob
@6axlepwr7 ай бұрын
Pretty much just my own. I forgot about KV Models so I just went to their web site to see if there was anything I could use. Some nice stuff, although nothing I plan on using. If I was going to use brass handrails, then there would definitely be some things I could use.
@rdgk1se30197 ай бұрын
Hi Brian, what drawing program do you use?
@6axlepwr7 ай бұрын
The company is Alibre. I use their Atom 3d. It is a basic version of their professional program. It has all I need to do what I want.
@Grainexpress7 ай бұрын
I made it this far Brian! 😉 Absolutely great work and am learning some things as we go along. I do have a question, I am looking for rear loco number boards for my old blue box GP38 wrecked loco load I am doing. So far haven’t had any luck looking online but maybe I have missed something somewhere. If I can make my own what material would you suggest? Thank you!
@6axlepwr7 ай бұрын
If you are wanting JUST something to represent the number board, then 0.005" styrene. If yo are looking for the glass number board insert. The probably train shows or contact Athearn. If you want the whole number board assembly, then probably Cannon & Co.
@Dawsonsrailfanadventures747 ай бұрын
Your fuel tank looks correct and close to scale like the Proto RS11s kato made the fuel tanks so fat
@Grainexpress7 ай бұрын
Loving it Brian! I do have a question, what glue did you use to glue the 3D printed box to the plastic frame? CA(super glue)? I assume CA works best for gluing two 3D printed pieces together? I have a loco project I am working on and want to do it right the first time. 😉 Thanks!
@6axlepwr7 ай бұрын
Yes, CA. CA is EXCELLENT for resin parts. Very strong.
@Grainexpress7 ай бұрын
It is a great morning to wake up to a Modeling Time video! Looking forward to this project. Thanks for posting Brian.
@rdgk1se30197 ай бұрын
I don't know what kind of plastic Atlas uses for their truck frames, but it is very hard............I did an RS-1 for my work train.......I removed the cast on brake cylinders and replaced them with Detail Associates parts.
@rdgk1se30197 ай бұрын
Can't beat a Kato motor, I just have to figure out how to convert 9 blue box Proto GP30's to use the Kato motors.
@hexl39747 ай бұрын
Hi Brian, any chance you might show us some of the steps you went about in designing your air tanks in CAD for your RS11 project? Thanks, Hector!
@6axlepwr7 ай бұрын
Yes, I can give you a run down of my design approach. I am working on the cylinder now so as I design it, I can think of how I want to present it.
@CNJmodeler7 ай бұрын
Great video. Is the wheel mask something you made, or can they be purchased from somewhere?
@6axlepwr7 ай бұрын
These wheel masks were made by Modelers Choice. There is another company that is making the same ones. I thought I bookmarked it, but I cannot find them. I will see if I can and post again.
@JRPaquatics10 ай бұрын
Have you ever had a Atlas/Kato C425 is producing a buzzing sound around curves? I just got one, I've taken it apart, cleaned and oiled it, and it still has the same buzzing sound coming from the wheel area i think..
@6axlepwr10 ай бұрын
The wheels would not buzz. They would squeak. If there was any buzzing, it would be coming from the motor.
@JRPaquatics10 ай бұрын
@@6axlepwr It only happens when the trucks turn on a curve, no sound when going straight. Ive disconnected the drive shaft from the motor to test if there was any sounds and there was no buzzing. Could it be 18" radius curves causing it on this model?
@6axlepwr10 ай бұрын
@@JRPaquaticsCouple things. 1. If you run the model with the shell off. Does it still buzz? If not, then possibly you have something rubbing on the inside of the shell in a turn and quite possibly it is the 18" radius curves causing the extreme swivel of the trucks to touch the shell. 2. Disconnect one drive shaft at a time and run it. See if it is in fact a drive shaft issue.
@JRPaquatics10 ай бұрын
@@6axlepwr I've done both things, ran with out the shell and one drive shaft at a time. The buzz comes from the running drive shaft. I'm wondering if the sound is coming from a gear, there is some play in the gears the connect the worm gear. I don't know if that's normal. This is my third locomotive btw so im still pretty new at knowing what's normal and what's not normal.
@FlyingCrow10 ай бұрын
I just found your channel. You do excellent work.
@ScottTaipaleRail10 ай бұрын
Are you going to finish the caboose or is that swept aside since it’s HO?
@6axlepwr10 ай бұрын
Caboose will be finished. I am currently back on my HO projects. for the caboose I have to get over my procrastination on painting all the metal hand grabs.
@Vman775711 ай бұрын
Would love to see you use the resistance soldering repairs.
@Vman775711 ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing. Did you tact the triangles with AC?
@6axlepwr11 ай бұрын
No. Liquid plastic cement.
@Vman775711 ай бұрын
Thanks. In N scale I would need to use very little. LOL
@hejdanny11 ай бұрын
Brian, I like the idea of the shorter segments.
@dwells7711 ай бұрын
Congratulations on the printer acquisition! I’m enjoying the O scale project so far and look forward to seeing the coming steps!
@154Colin11 ай бұрын
Looks good. Your eyes are going to thank you too!
@boomerdiorama11 ай бұрын
Why not do both Brian? - You can "fine scale" model and build a nice little Proto 48 (Shelf) Layout, with one short line (siding) spur, with weathered ties and scale rail @ 10' by 16" inches for running and displaying your finescale models. Imagine your beautiful sounding Geep crawling through the frog and points while shoving in a squealing Boxcar to a small two car industry with a .5 percent grade. 😁
@6axlepwr11 ай бұрын
I have been giving this a lot of thought over the last couple weeks. I have a hard time just getting to the convincing myself to build the layout. I fall heavily on the side of simply building models. I enjoy that part of it a lot.
@walongloop692211 ай бұрын
This is HO/P:87, but shows a simple shelf with under-the-layout subwoofer to enhance the sound. Sound is as directly recorded by the camera mic, but seems a lot louder in the vid than in-person. Easily scalable to P:48. Anyways just something similar to Boomer's suggestion. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i5zVimBqe7aeb9E
@walongloop692211 ай бұрын
BTW also more fun with the ProtoThrottle ;)
@154Colin11 ай бұрын
I am glad that you went to O-Scale because you are so indepth with your details that you were probably getting very frustrating. In reference to the 3-D printer, by the time you read this you’ll probably have all lot of experience already with your machine. It is quite liberating knowing that you have total control over what you design and print. I can I am so glad they are going to O-Scale.
@6axlepwr11 ай бұрын
Thank you. Everything you stated is correct. I still have to do some considerable rework, although the rework is much more manageable. With 3D printing, I can control the quality and fidelity of the parts I need. So yes. I am very happy too.
@jimmyspears537711 ай бұрын
Wow I thought I was good for rebuilding a E&C shops ho woodchip car from the 90's. Do you have any experience with working with a airslide Hopper? Tangent or Walthers? With Walthers a little more work o well love rebuilding an customizeing I model Seaboard System in ho
@6axlepwr11 ай бұрын
I do not. I think eventually I will. Your talking about the larger car. Not the 40' car. If memory serves me correct. I think there is one out at the North Carolina Museum of Transportation. A few cars down from the PS-2 I am measuring.