I read kurdish version that was translated from german.

This is so good...Please keep up with these content💛

that was good

Certinly my first thought upon hearing this news was of this masterful work!

This a fantastic mini doc. Absolutely incredible.

Remember Killing Commendatore: We'll all live on the moon, someday 🫡

Richtig gute Zusammenfassung, sehr schöne passende Bilder und Musik. Wuchtig, aber nicht erdrückend 😊 Bin zufällig auf deinen Channel gestoßen, weil ich eine Zusammenfassung gesucht habe. Deine war nicht nur die ansehnlichste und am besten zu hörende, sondern auch spannendste! Weiter so. Hab ein Abo da gelassen 😊

Always start with A Wild Sheep Chase.

Looking forward to reading it in translation/language! 💜✨️

Wow wow wow! That's sooo amazing! Can't wait to read the book! My already famous books of Murakami are 'Kafka on the shore', '1Q84', & 'Norwegian Wood'. I also loved 'The Wind up bird chronicles'! I am so excited to win this giveaway! Love you for making this review!

I'm so exited to read a new book by murakami

I’m crying ❤

This looks incredible

Eagerly waiting for the book 😊

Amazing review❤Can't wait to read.

What a great review, love this video! 😍

Can’t wait to read it🎉❤ Love your review!!

Thanks for the great review! Wish i could get this book one day.

Thank you for the review. It's going to be such a great book. I'm a big fan of Murakami writing, I have read only two of his books 'Norwegian Wood' and 'The Wind-up Bird Chronicle'. Can't wait to read this book. Please send it to me as books are costly here in India, can't afford to buy them. I will be always grateful 🙏

Excited about this book, thankyou for the giveaway.. Didnt watch this review fully, will comeback after reading the piece :⁠-⁠) @ankiiiith

I should be the lucky winner because Murakami’s books have been a source of deep inspiration and introspection for me, and The City and Its Uncertain Walls feels like a continuation of that transformative journey. As someone who not only loves to read but also shares that love through my Instagram page, where I combine my passion for literature, animals, and nature, winning this book would allow me to dive into Murakami’s world and spread the beauty of his words to a larger audience. This isn’t just about owning another book-it’s about connecting with a story that will resonate with my soul and sharing that connection with others. I believe this book is destined to find a reader who will cherish every page, and I hope to be that reader!

salih abi i only listened to your podcasts AND NOW THIS VIDEO IS SO ADORABLE with the background especially !

Wanna read it so much!❤ thank you for the review

Thank you for the review….I want to read it SO bad… Greaaaaat job….

Thanks😊

Great review, can’t wait for the book.

I am waiting for this book

Your review offers a thoughtful perspective on the book, highlighting key elements with clarity.

Your review offers a thoughtful perspective on the book, highlighting key elements with clarity.

Def looking forward to reading this. I cannot watch the video before I read it!

So cool this is ❤

Thank you very much for the review!!! ✨✨✨

😲 wow

Xenia_and_me here. Leaving a comment for the giveaway. Love your posts.

Brilliant Thank you

returning to the video again to jot down recommendations. I would also add Chungking Express - I recently watched it and total Murakami vibes.

I've almost finished reading this book again. Such a great story, but a lot to unpack. You've done such a good job capturing the dreamy almost nightmarish vibe of the novel. I'm glad that you had Murakami's work, specifically Wind-Up Bird, to give you comfort in those hard times (I know he's got me through a few myself). You should be really proud of this video. Appreciate what we have while we have it-I can't think of a more profound lesson that we need to be reminded of constantly.

One of the only things I can say for sure is that Fukada Eri does connect Aomame and Tengo. Murakami is careful to avoid any fact to confirm any interventions of the little people but it appears that the Little People creating the Air Chyrsalis causes Fukaeri to run away from Sakigake, which sets into motions the events that bring Tengo and Aomame together. She was only able to escape because of the dohta and, as Tengo wonders, we can 't say which is the "real" Eri. Did the maza or the dohta escape? Because we cannot see the other one, we only meet one, we can never confirm. Similar to how we are not sure to the extent by which 1Q84 is different than the original world because we hardly see the world before Aomame's departure from it. Many distorted perceptions, and unrealized connections, and unexplained coincidences. They all dissolve by the end to give way to the resolution of the star-crossed lovers narrative arc but hardly though logic. Moreso plot points just faded away until they were so distant they were no longer important. Partially because they did not lead anywhere and partially because other things materialize in their place. By the end everything wraps up. Not so much nicely as succinctly, as if there were no ways left to draw it out any longer.

Just finished the book, It's a great video!

This is my favorite of his novels out of the 8 I've read. Like what you described in the video, I read it at just the right time. I picked it up on a trip in the mountains, and was reading it during a time of a big life change. The way music and painting plays such a big role in this book was another big factor of why it affected me so.

But you can’t have “many” cats if you don’t get rid of them constantly😢 Even if you have 2 or 3 cats their average life is 12-15 years so they would have those 2 or 3 cats the whole Murakami’s childhood years. Even if they disappear or die by accident in the most cases it’s owners’ fault. So sadly I guess they weren’t the best cat owners so maybe he still feels sorry deep down for that

This book was harder for me to read as well. I love Murakami but I found this to be unnecessarily complex and even a bit wordy as if he was trying to show off his literary ability. However there was a mesmerizing melancholy to this story that still captivates me. I love how you captured this in video. I’d loved to see a video about the ending.

Awesome , thanks for the review! I was thinking it was a sequel to Hard Boiled Wonderland, and I didn't really have a problem with it. But your review definitely makes me want to get it now! Thanks for this.

hardboiled wonderland was the first murakami book i've ever read. is this good? i didn't like killing commendatore that much in the end

I’m really enjoying it so far! I think it’s one of his most romantic

Hard-boiled Wonderland is my absolute favorite novel by Haruki Murakami. So I was excited to know we would return to that world. I can't wait to dive into this. Even if ( or maybe specially because) it isn't a direct sequel.

Very comprehensive and beautiful video ❤❤❤

I don't need any more reasons to read it. 🤣🤣🤣🤣 I appreciate the video, though.

❤❤❤

i love your video essay ❤