Great information as always. Especially with noting how the katas show this information but as me & a friend were practicing over the weekend, the understanding or examination of those details are sadly not emphasized in the teaching for some. Which is problematic & has led to a bunch of misunderstandings for Karate.
@JDosTecladosКүн бұрын
Sensei iain, could you please make a video explaning the bunkai of the pinan nidan(heian shodan) from kyodo 7(Fisrt age uke) until kyodo 21(last shuto uke)? Like, one video explaning the age ukes, other, the gedan barai and oi suki(four moves), the three oisukis, and the last four moves, the four shuto uke. Oss
@3PillersКүн бұрын
👍
@bajuszpal172Күн бұрын
Soryym Sir, Katas are still helpful for beginners to put techniques of fighting into a meaningful structure. Statics and dynamics (Your preference, I mean)are seldom taught together.Paul,69
@practicalkatabunkaiКүн бұрын
I’m not sure I follow what you’re saying, or maybe you don’t understand my position? I think kata is useful for everyone (not just beginners) and they provide a holistic set of combative methods in a structured way. While the kata freezes key postures that we should hit in movement (in order to make it the message clear), we should never hold a position in combat (the map is not the territory). As I tell my students, “There are only two things still in a fight: unconscious people and people who are about to be unconscious”. The past masters were clear on this point. It’s a while since this footage was filmed, but I recall I mentioned what Funakoshi, Nakasone, etc said on this point. It should be understood in this way.
@bajuszpal172Күн бұрын
Sorry Sir, five minutes lost to beginners, but good idea in explaining attacking by retracting first leg and then stepping slantly outside while performing a block or slash on the opponentś front hand, and simultaneousl attacking his torso with the rear hand. Diagonal movements ar more commong in real fights., could hsve slso beren emphassized. Best regards. Paul, 69
@ralphmetten2344Күн бұрын
Those nuts grabbing stories are epic 😂😂😂😂
@practicalkatabunkaiКүн бұрын
If people read the comments before watching ... then this comment is going to make them want to watch :-)
@bajuszpal172Күн бұрын
Many thanks, excellent methodology. Was Master motobu retreating at all?Paul.69
@practicalkatabunkaiКүн бұрын
Defensively, not once in any of his 12 drills (as the series will show). He encourages gaining active control and causing damage before escaping.
@engwannabeincan7383Күн бұрын
Thank you for the latest part of this series. I can see the kata gradually coming together. I really like how practical these self defence techniques are, and the fun way you explain them. Thank you again for sharing. Anyone who has attended one of your seminars is very lucky! You explain everything so well. I look forward to the next part!
@practicalkatabunkaiКүн бұрын
Glad you like them!
@rynoerasmus7869Күн бұрын
This is brilliant! Thanks again Iain!
@marcilianoribeiro9671Күн бұрын
Great Master!!!
@MarshOakDojoTimPruittКүн бұрын
thanks Iain
@calubrasКүн бұрын
Thanks sensei!
@dermotrooney9584Күн бұрын
Lovely! I'm trying to remember the advert that said "It ain't easy being squeezy", without Google.
@josefranciscocrispo61812 күн бұрын
Excelente!!!
@cahallo59642 күн бұрын
That Kimura story was hilarious.
@cmdrjontomasson55102 күн бұрын
My eyes are watering thinking about how part 4 is going to start.
@theaikidoka2 күн бұрын
I had the distinct pleasure of attending one of your seminars Iain, and personally I have found that what sets you apart is your ability to 'ground' your information in examples and in theory. You don't tell stories because you like the sound of your own voice, you do it because it makes what you teach all the more memorable. Thanks for this series, it's really good stuff.
@michakasprzak68692 күн бұрын
You've got to have balls to train martial arts. Not cause it requires that much bravery. Simply, your enemy has to have something to grab.
@PsycheSnacks6572 күн бұрын
Yes!!! thank you
@ThePNWRiderWA2 күн бұрын
Thank you for doing all these videos. So many people are just focused on MMA as the B all and all. They seem to forget when karate was developed. It was not a sport. It was a life and death struggle. It can be as effective today as it was so many centuries ago when properly applied.
@GermanSausagesAreTheWurstКүн бұрын
MMA is just another Fad, like Kungfu in the 70s and Ninjutsu in the 90s. It's lasting a little longer than those other fads, but it's still a fad.
@dermotrooney9584Күн бұрын
Once the kinks are ironed out. But I guess that's all part of the fun really - working out that twisty double block combo is really a throw. 😊
@theaikidokaКүн бұрын
@@GermanSausagesAreTheWurst I don't know if I would call it a fad as such - we have had competitive combat sports for literally thousands of years. If you mean the specific rule-set that makes MMA different to boxing or jousting etc, then you are probably right - MMA makes for fairly well-rounded fighters so it's a popular branch of combat sports to study, but it isn't the only one.
@dwightdhansen2 күн бұрын
I'm thinking of the Isshin Ryu "Wansu Dump" Ok, so I reach in, seize the groin, and then throw them over my shoulder? 😵💫 Do I restomp it after they're on the ground?
@theaikidoka2 күн бұрын
WWMKD (What Would Master Ken Do)?
@cameronkacena1972 күн бұрын
Always restomp.
@timothymarshall23652 күн бұрын
Always restomp!
@dermotrooney9584Күн бұрын
Always restomp. 😊
@RaulBaudin-uf3ey2 күн бұрын
Tremendas clases esto para la calle esta bueno
@williamwatson-t7h3 күн бұрын
well said sir thank you. can you do a video where you employ a cover and stomp or knee strike?
@Shaolinkempotc3 күн бұрын
What do you think about the idea of moving in is necessary when the encounter is unavoidable. Creating distance in a self defense situation can be looked at as more escaping. Escaping is excellent if possible. Close in fighting can create the situation for one to escape but self defense that is unavoidable may imho, require closing the distance and fighting very very close.
@chrishansen93795 күн бұрын
Ian is like the karate teacher I wished I had 35 years ago.
@superkickjoyboy72545 күн бұрын
Sensei great breakdown as always! A lot of the fighting elements can also be applied to other kata which is great to see and as always thank you for what you do sir!
@farleysmoke51305 күн бұрын
Awesome. Thank you.
@matthewbaumann6307 күн бұрын
Are you interpreting the lunge punch after the double rib strike as a double leg takedown?
@Porch.monkey.slayer7 күн бұрын
Hops !! ❤
@YoukaiSlayer128 күн бұрын
Great video especially on highlighting the taking away of options.
@shambolicentity8 күн бұрын
I'm very much enjoying the series so far - hanging out for the next videos!
@practicalkatabunkaiКүн бұрын
Glad to hear it!
@josefranciscocrispo61818 күн бұрын
Excelente!
@josefranciscocrispo61818 күн бұрын
Excelente!
@C5films8 күн бұрын
Love this dude. Love training with him. If I could, I'd train all the time with him.
@PsycheSnacks6578 күн бұрын
Perfect!
@MarshOakDojoTimPruitt8 күн бұрын
thanks Iain
@Lyonband8 күн бұрын
Thank you - awesome material
@Vincentorix8 күн бұрын
Kata, as a freeze frame of the application makes Kata and Bunkia more sense to me now. Thanks Sensei.
@dermotrooney95848 күн бұрын
Love the "is that alright?" shirt.
@dermotrooney95848 күн бұрын
Lovely stuff, once again.
@GermanSausagesAreTheWurst8 күн бұрын
Ian is one KZbinr who always gets a Like even before I watch. His content is always Top Notch.
@MarshOakDojoTimPruitt8 күн бұрын
thanks Iain !!!
@flashrun60938 күн бұрын
Opened hand Sochin.
@adam281719 күн бұрын
Keep them coming!!!
@adam281719 күн бұрын
Fantastic 😮 Haven’t looked at karate since I was a kid doing Ishin Ryu. But these breakdowns are awesome.
@GermanSausagesAreTheWurst8 күн бұрын
Same here, only I was in Goju Ryu and Hapkido. I do mostly Tai Chi these days, but these principles really adapt well with anything.
@roloduarte31009 күн бұрын
Awesome!
@ThePNWRiderWA9 күн бұрын
So many good ideas and revelations. Since an increasing number of attacks involve weapons , could you do a video on unarmed defense against weapons ? I would agree run away but at )9 with bad knees I am not fast.
@practicalkatabunkai9 күн бұрын
Thank you! There are videos on weapons in my app … but I have made the decision not to share that side of things publicly as it is prone to misunderstanding based on preexisting assumptions that people may have. I am happy to teach it in person, and share with people who are more familiar with the wider methodology, and hence how weapons fit into that, but I don’t share the physical drills outside of that. There are enough misunderstandings already and I don’t want to inadvertently add to that. There is a video I will be sharing in the future (sometime next year) on escape and how to practise it; which looks at the issue of the physical act of running and the role it plays (less than most initially think). Again, that’s already in the app. However, I thought that one is important and hence it’s one of the few app videos I will also be sharing here. Thanks for all the support!
@engwannabeincan73839 күн бұрын
Great second part Sensei Ian, very well explained. I am really enjoying these sequences. Thank you again.
@engwannabeincan738314 күн бұрын
Great first video Sensei Ian, so practical. I can’t wait for the next part of this self defence technique. Practising self defence techniques on your own is hard, so I really look forward to learning the kata you put together from Motobu’s 12 techniques. Thank you again for sharing your experience with us.
@kwasinski214 күн бұрын
Best explanation I have ever seen in my life. Thanks.