I also think buffing wood tools to have 3 digging speed would give them a small bit of usability, right now at 2 speed its barely any faster than mining with nothing

Subjectively objective 😎

Oh no NixxNikoli didn’t like my burping! Whatever shall I do???

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, I suppose. I love the art style

With every new game, your cosmetics do not carry over

Better yet, research worker cooperatives

Thank you!!!

Hey, I like copper in Minecraft! Good building block! Very cool!

It might seem that way until you consider I prefaced the entire point about survival aspects by saying it’s an entirely SUBJECTIVE point and not at all my main hook. The later points about mod support, community, and performance are my “objective” points as to why vintage story is better. It is also worth nothing that vintage story is just as open ended and just as much of a sandbox game as Minecraft and does many things BETTER such as having world edit and more customizable world generation all without mods. I think there is a HUGE misconception that Minecraft- and sandbox games in general- need to be games for EVERYONE. That is to say, they should cater to a wide range of players as to maximize how many people can enjoy it. I think this is silly and wrong. Minecraft is not for everyone and it shouldn’t be. Vintage story is not for everyone and it shouldn’t be. In order for a game to be for “everyone” it actually needs to be a game engine. Roblox, Fortnite, and even Minecraft to a much lesser extent, all attempt to accomplish this. I am not of the opinion that a sandbox game should be judged by how big of a tent it pitches, but rather how well it caters to the people in its tent. In that sense, Vintage Story does a better job catering to the people in its tent than Minecraft.

This is untrue. TFC devs are not VS devs. The VS team has hired one guy from the TFC team, however, this was years after the project started. I could be wrong, but honestly, if I see enough comments like this, I’ll just message Tyron and ask up front haha

Well. This video was never meant to “fix” Minecraft. I’m simply fixing MY personal issues with it. This obviously isn’t for new players or for everyone. That’s the beauty of Minecraft; you can make it whatever you like.

@ thanks for the response, I appreciate it. Sorry if the comment came across a little harsh, I really liked some of your ideas here. The whole upgrading hearts thing and some of your ideas for slowing crafting down for the early stages. And yes you’re absolutely right, Minecraft is for everyone, part of what makes fixing Minecraft videos so tricky is the fact that everyone comes across these things differently because the game is so open. I took a look at your ideas for crafting and thought, if I wasn’t being told this, would I be able to figure it out? I came to the conclusion that no equals bad design, I’m wrong it equals potential for good design. I think what the crafting system needs is a bit of a rework in simplicity and understanding, the concepts that you have laid out are really good. But who’s gonna figure out how to build a health potion or a sturdy stick. Though I suppose a recipe book of some kind could pretty much fix the problem, maybe a little cheaply like a bandaid but enough, I mean, that’s what modern Minecraft did to fix its problem with crafting. I think that potions, are a cool idea. As being the only way to heal; it forces players to prepare for journeys and spelunking trips. But the fact that these flowers still need to be scavenged, and as far as I know, can’t be actually grown means that even high-level players if they want to survive, they have to go around in the woods and try to find some dandelions. Also, I think the recipe for a sturdy stick should be simpler, it just seems to gate keep players through the tedium of growing wheat, the recipe should really just simply be three or more sticks. Therefore, it’s still costly and the player has to think about it but they don’t have to wait around for wheat to grow cause that’s not fun, even with bonemeal it’s just tedious. It also makes mud pretty much useless, because I believe that every item should have multiple uses and mud is just kind only used for reinforcing sticks, it’s a good use because you use sticks a lot but unless mud’s a little bit more fundamental to the game, like with some mud armor or somethin I think it should be thrown out. And that brings up the concept of food, because food isn’t used to heal, it only serves as a threat to the player and doesn’t actually make them think about what they’re eating. So what if? And get this, what if food gave you armour?? When you’re full, at least for the first few hunger points you get some armour which whittle away by half a armour point as your hunger goes down. Eating better food gets you better armour, eating cake would get you maybe two or three armour points, eating steak maybe one and a half, all the way down to the lowest quality food giving you a half and rotten flesh gives you nothing. The better the food the longer and more armour you have, the worst of food the less armour you have and less you have it. Encouraging players to think about what they eat for those bonuses. The idea is very similar to the whole regeneration speed thing already in Minecraft. If you eat steak, you regenerate faster than if you eat bread. Yes it does make the game a little easier, and if you’re against that, I totally get it. Those are just some ideas I got. Take them as you will.

I promise I won’t. I’ve gone 10 years without buying one haha, I have no reason to buy another

I think the omnimovement in theory. The maps are too small for it. Like some of the season 1 maps are a lot fucking better than the base maps