I OVERHAULED Survival Minecraft in 743 DAYS!

Рет қаралды 5,321

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 103

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

While I couldn’t fit all of the features into the video, just know there is a lot more than what is shown. Everything from crafting beds to new ruins and more are all being worked on. A lot of the ideas in this video are the result of the people on my little team. Their contributions to this project are fantastic and I want to give them more praise.

@AAdielP 3 ай бұрын

W video Love it!

@notLord0 3 ай бұрын

Bow rework when?

@omous7770 Ай бұрын

A little off topic, but you can make tool tips look more similar to vanilla by using the “minecraft:base_attack_speed” and “minecraft:base_attack_damage” ids for the attribute modifiers

@Iliadic 3 ай бұрын

8:16 absolutely agree. Minecraft NEEDS a varied gear system. I don't fully agree with how you implemented this all into your server, but I will definitely give the server a look when it's finalized. I, *personally*, think it feels a bit too modded, but I'll keep an open mind. I do like how you've tried to make extreme Hardcore Minecraft though.

@megalord2598 3 ай бұрын

I think this style of gameplay is not for me but I'm glad that the mc community can make whatever they want out of this game!

@DarkSlayerJ 3 ай бұрын

Normally I hate these videos. They're always like "I FIXED it, Me, my ideas, flawless, I did it! This is THE way to handle this!" and that's....missing the entire point of what Minecraft is. But you actually went out of your way to not do that, to say several times that this is YOUR idea, your approach, and everyone has something different that they might want and that not liking it is fine.

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

Honestly, making Minecraft what you want it to be is the entire point of the game. Trying to claim you’ve fixed something “objectively” is impossible in a game that is all about creating a subjective experience. You cannot please everyone. Even my original progression video- where I was very critical of Minecraft- I stated that Minecraft is about making your own experiences, though, I think some points were unjust in that video. I’m happy you liked this one! :D

@thefarlander2050 3 ай бұрын

Agreed. I try to avoid videos like that cause they sound overly harsh to the base game. Of course, Minecraft can't appeal to everyone, and you're welcome to alter the experience per your specifications. With datapacks, plugins, and mods, the process has become much easier. But for the love of all things decent, DON'T say you FIX the game by doing it. People are going to see your work the way they see vanilla Minecraft; through their own lens. Just because you think the game is perfect from your actions, not everyone will see it that way.

@NotMuch01 13 күн бұрын

He just made a vanilla plus mod, with some not so vanilla tweaks. 😐

@ninenezumi 3 ай бұрын

this project most likely will not get the attention that it deserves but please know this is an outstanding contribution to the community i am looking forward to it's release

@witherschat 3 ай бұрын

I love seeing how you've grown, from your original "Minecraft progression is awful" video to now. Seeing you show genuine understanding that Minecraft is first and foremost here for you to make it what you want is refreshing. Also, impressive work on this like what the hell?

@Iliadic 3 ай бұрын

I like doing redstone. I *need* farms to do it. If you want to do a substantial amount of redstone (I mean literally like 10 redstone projects) you need a full shulker of redstone items topped up to stacks. That is a LOT of quartz and iron. I make an iron farm also so I can trade with villagers for emeralds, but having a significant source of hoppers and pistons is almost necessary ngl.

@Azurepetalls Ай бұрын

I have a bunch of stuff to say but as a little suggestion, I think pumpkin overlays are data-driven now! With that in mind, I think giving the "spirits are judging you" overlay it's own texture would be neat, in both portraying what the overlay is and making it feel less "there's a Minecraft pumpkin on my head" like my immediate thought is something like little Don't Starve style shadows encroaching around your vision but it could be a bunch of things really. - weird Veins, chains, fire, shadowy eyes, vines, choking around the edges and where your UI is, little soul faces, just to name... well not a few but to name some ideas. - oh and If it's able to be animated that's something you could use (I don't recall if you can though)

@timelordsalad 3 күн бұрын

Generally a very cool concept. It’s not really for me but I appreciate the effort put into it. Btw, I was gonna “umm actually” your bronzes but I guess bismuth bronze is technically misnamed in real life and made from brass. Though true bronzes shouldn’t have zinc in the recipe lest it becomes a brass. That being said, I think the bronzes should have distinguished names such as Bronze and Brass versus Tin Bronze and Bismuth Bronze. You could go with Bismuth Brass too I guess but I just found the original alloys sounding clunky and/or confusing

@NT-qq9tc 3 ай бұрын

I'm genuinely proud of what we've created so far.

@crazyjack746 3 ай бұрын

9:26 this seems a lot like amber or other gems in terraria, and I love it.

@hazelr-5210 3 ай бұрын

Great vid! 1 critique: giving iron ore the chance to give no bits upon mining it feels a bit like you're punishing the player rather than making the game harder. I'm just imagining how frustrated I would be if after a while of mining I finally came across some iron and the first one I mined I got... nothing. If I hadn't just seen this I would think I had the wrong tool to get the drop and wait before mining any of the other ore until I got a higher tier pickaxe to mine them so as not to waste any. I do like the idea of having a random mechanic to the amount of drops in general though.

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

I think, and I could be wrong, using bismuth bronze ensures you’ll always get at least one iron bit. But yes, it giving zero is a little annoying and I may change it to 1-9

@dimanarinull9122 3 ай бұрын

the alloy ores from alternate stone types is a REALLY good improvement, it provides players with a less RNG based way of getting their ores. the other types of armor and tools have been showcased in the last video or most of them, but this seems to be a change from the original. would love to get those changes as a data-pack/mod/plugin outside the server, but as I'm deep in making my own game engine and been playing VintageStory(when 1.20?) alongside other games avoiding minecraft like the plague.

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

Honestly giving the alternate stone types a purpose was really fun

@witherschat 3 ай бұрын

As for feedback. If the map is 5000x5000, and made of floating islands, is there any way for the resources to regenerate? If not, the players might run into an issue quite quickly. Similarly, are the trial vaults only openable once, or does a datapack allow them to regenerate too? Where I'm getting at is, with a lot more resource scarcity, and a finite map, you might run into issues over time.

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

Yeah there’s a couple trades that address this issue. Lots of stones can be “exchanged” for a fee. It’s also easy as hell for me to add more islands. I love making them, so it’s a win-win. Perhaps I should have mentioned the world height is expanded to like 670 blocks

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

Trial spawners always regenerate, and we’ll see if vaults need to be reset. That’s what betas are for! :D

@NT-qq9tc 3 ай бұрын

Scarcity is the name of the game my friend. Be conservative. - NT_777

@danonek07 2 ай бұрын

Yk, apart of this being a nice idea, i have to disagree with overhauling aspect, there are few problems. 1. Too many tools, i know you wanted to make every tool have some purpose, but it makes it feel more grindy/complicated, dual progression point would be enough (yk, you have 2 tools that have pros and cons and are made in the similar way) 2. Resources are RNG, which made it worse than vanilla, if you have to get nuggets purely based on RNG, it's not harder, it's grindy, for me the main problem with minecraft is that there is no alternative way of obtaining those metals/resources other than mining or making auto-farm that runs 24/7 What i like in create mod for instance, is that it adds alternative way of obtaining ores by washing/sifting common materials, it's still RNG, but it's more like-able RNG that you don't need to follow, making normal ores scarce or biome-only could fix that 3. Health system is annoying, i talked few times with devs of passion projects or other stuff like that, and what was the hardest thing is to make "Hard" things, not annoying things, having 3 hearts isn't harder, it's more annoying, because normal skeleton can shoot you from kilometer with 99% precision, changing how mobs behave would be better, add some rule that they spawn in groups that make real thread, soo player need to think to defeat mob, not only have better gear If my english was bad then sorry, i believe you will consider those ideas, good luck with your project anyways

@TheGeekFactor 2 ай бұрын

There are alternatives to the RNG system. Everything that has an element of RNG has an alternative that is not RNG. Truth be told, we’ve added just a couple toolsets. It’s nothing crazy or insane. But, this is all subjective. While it may not be something you like, others may like it

@danonek07 2 ай бұрын

@@TheGeekFactor of course, only critique to make it better, still good job and i believe you will succed, good luck :}

@ethangnasher3848 3 ай бұрын

Man, now I wanna know about all of the tool and armor progression! On a side note, i feel that the chainmail aesthetic of Minecraft could get an overhaul too, looks too... Not-armor like.

@lucamayhem 3 ай бұрын

cool server, not what i would do personally, but thats okay. I like the alloys though

@TheClockmister 3 ай бұрын

Nice, I like how you gave copper a use, nerfed iron abundance, buffed iron tools and nerfed armor... I just think that adding too many ores will overcomplicate the system that is already there. Although, maybe it's necessary to create a deeper progression... Nice!

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

Copper already had a use.

@TheClockmister 2 ай бұрын

@@TheGeekFactor That is like saying that vines also have a use. You can make mossy cobblestone with it!! Like for real? YOu are going to tell me that a binocular, copper block and a brush are real uses for copper? These items are pointless for progression and are only used by creative people and people that actually care to brush an emerald out of a gravel block.

@TheGeekFactor 2 ай бұрын

Yes. Copper is a building block. Building blocks in a game where building is the primary feature??? Surely not?!

@TheClockmister 2 ай бұрын

@@TheGeekFactorAnd how does that tie into progression at all? Why would we assign any use to a material except building? Because its primary use would be fulfilled? Your video premise is: let’s overhaul systems already there. Why even bother discussing about progression expansion when you are not able to differentiate between non related progression mechanics like building and actual progression through ores & mobs. I gave a compliment about your video and you just see everything as hate. Why bother uploading if you can’t take a compliment nor constructive criticism. I was so polite. Childish

@Wily_Wendigo 3 ай бұрын

I stopped following the minecraft server cause life happened & the server got chaotic, but this is getting me interested again! Another note, if you want to heavily discourage mob spawners you can place 1 non-transparent block at build height in every single chunk. You can look into it more, but long story short X number of mob spawns happen per chunk, starting at the first y level with a valid point for a mob to spawn. By making the first y level the topmost one, a lot of those mob spawn attempts will be wasted on air blocks between build height & the islands. One thing to be careful of is the idea for mob spawns I mentioned also decreases the speed of mob spawns in general. Eventually, the mob cap will be reached, but now it will take more time for natural spawns to reach the mob cap.

@RacingGamer345 3 ай бұрын

I LOVE THIS, YOU COOKED HARD

@thepikachuboy43 Ай бұрын

Hope you don't abandon this project

@PLBBD 3 ай бұрын

Yes he uploaded the update!! Watching your features and what you created feel so satisfying to me somehow! Also it's weird that granite andesite is quartz crystals but drops ore and tuff which is lava rocks that contains minerals drops quartz but there's no infinite water source irl anyway so amazing video!!

@Pyroteknikz-z 3 ай бұрын

I think there should be a natural way to regen health, such as regaining half a heart a day or something.

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

We have an item called “dried greens” which will heal 1/2 a heart when eaten. Takes 3 seconds to eat, making it almost useless in dungeons

@Kingkitten-wm5fm 3 ай бұрын

ELSYIUM ISLES IS BACK!!!

@pineapplewhatever5906 3 ай бұрын

It's a shame you had to disable placing boats, since they can *also* be used to easily mitigate fall damage.

@thehammo9000 3 ай бұрын

7:09 I did NOT see that coming 🤣

@Woodex80085 3 ай бұрын

I think that having more players not mean that more bosses spawn might encourage cooporation better

@galdoug8918 3 ай бұрын

Someone remind me to play this when it comes out

@MorrisonScott 3 ай бұрын

🤘 Change the title to "I OVERHAULED Survival Minecraft in 743 DAYS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

@crazyjack746 3 ай бұрын

He did that

@StefanoAbruzzi 3 ай бұрын

In my opinion this feels very... Unfocused. My main criticisms are: Making raw iron harder to make doesn't make things harder, just grindier. Perhaps make them spawn only in certain biomes? Why are emeralds no longer tge main currency? If you made them as common as (IDK coal?) then people who spend alot if time mining will get monitory benifits enfesizing the "Mine" in Minecraft. Dungeons need a visual overhall, like hot damn! Even the og 2010 dungeons looked better😭 They seem fun. However could quickly get repetitive. This is more like a MMO rather than a survival overhaul. (Wait, do you still have the rule that if you help new players you get banned?)

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

I think the dungons look fine, actually.

@mrbabypark5495 3 ай бұрын

This is what I always wished minecraft would implement when I was a child.

@PalqmaYT 3 ай бұрын

With the game/server you're working on you should make food heal but all food only gives 1 saturation point and 1 food point so you are still able to heal with food but it's really annoying and you still would be able to get regen pots and stuff

@blatantexpression2599 Ай бұрын

vintage story player remakes vintage story (jokes aside, loved the vid, very much my style of progression)

@hoovR 3 ай бұрын

if not for the fact im in another continent and hemisphere, i'd give this a shot, good work

@matt9853 24 күн бұрын

That idea is great :D, could there be a data pack publicly available for everyone to play with these modifications? I'm referring specifically to the new equipment, alloy system, health and armor, etc.

@TheGeekFactor 23 күн бұрын

I’ll likely make it into a mod someday.

@bluesillybeard 3 ай бұрын

This is super cool! I think I would genuinely enjoy this.

@honeybeerose4108 3 ай бұрын

is more than 1 team able to play on the same dungeon at once

@nicholasfitzgerald5482 3 ай бұрын

Maybe a better title would be "I spent 2 YEARS overhauling survival Minecraft!"? 743 days is an amount of time that is more difficult to comprehend than just 2 years. (I was reading the description)

@Harriet-MarieHaines 3 ай бұрын

So excited to check this out!

@Marcin-rh4rr 2 ай бұрын

Ist there a chance that you will release a data pack or something with these changes?

@haseo3545 14 күн бұрын

Is there an update on this at all id love to hear more! This is very much my style of game play and how I play with my friends on small server of friends

@TheGeekFactor 14 күн бұрын

You can join the discord for updates!

@meneersnoepsnor 3 ай бұрын

Unrelated.. I think. Recently I put together multiple mods and resource packs to make Minecraft more enjoyable for myself. I love exploring big open worlds and Minecraft does fit that criteria. If the render distance was not how it was. So. Actually. Today. I got the Distant Horizons mod which completely fixes that problem. I now get to see very far and it makes picking out a destination easier + the added entertainment from amazing views is always nice. It's so much better that way because now I don't have to walk towards a direction and hope for the best. I also added many sound related mods and a 1st person body. If it was not obvious yet. The point of the pack is to make it more emersive whilst keeping it vanilla. Because I have no problem with the gameplay I just have trouble to stay focused on the game.

@PJutch 3 ай бұрын

Modpack isn't hard if you can make a crafting table from four planks (c) I know that's not fitting and irrelevant but I played a modpack where making a crafting table required a crafting table so you needed to find a crafting table generated in the world and then you had more work to do to craft basic things like furnaces and bows. Walking 1000 blocks without anything and with buffed mobs was an interesting experience) Speaking of mobs, please say me you somehow nerfed boats, trapdoors and rails. Is it even possible? I can't remember any mod doing this. And what you have done with enchantments? And villagers? And shields? Everybody is always complaining about them, it's very intersting to know what you've done. Waiting for a part 2 ;) Hm, having a custom maps also allows you to buff husks and strays for a more terraria-like progression between biomes. Have you tried it? Also I just fully understood that 8 hearts without defense is so small, like, can you even kill a wither with so little hp? Cool server, I hope it will get attention it needs)

@The_Potato10 3 ай бұрын

Is this one still running? If so how can I join?

@kristapskrumins5676 3 ай бұрын

This looks cool as hell, I've joined the server.

@kristapskrumins5676 3 ай бұрын

I agree! Wait this is my own comment oh my lord

@whit1722_playz 3 ай бұрын

Will it be bedrock/java crossplay?

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

Some of the features make it impossible to run on bedrock, from my understanding

@whit1722_playz 3 ай бұрын

@@TheGeekFactor oh ok thats sad

@kristapskrumins5676 3 ай бұрын

@@TheGeekFactor good

@haseo3545 8 күн бұрын

I want to see all tools and armors :O

@kiwiisacake 3 ай бұрын

what happened to the cauldron stuff i really liked that?

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

We are no longer using the plugin that did that. It turned out to be a buggy mess and the dev was hardly active (no offense to the dev, of course).

@kiwiisacake 3 ай бұрын

@@TheGeekFactor damn big rip

@Hyperforg 3 ай бұрын

is elysium ever gonna come back? RIP blue flower thing that give me fuck loads of hp

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

That’s what this is haha

@Hyperforg 3 ай бұрын

@@TheGeekFactor YAY

@clearededpl8937 3 ай бұрын

You have cool idea, but I never know how to progress,so I give up. No tutorials

@TheGeekFactor 3 ай бұрын

There is a guide book and a tutorial at the start of the server.

@spyro2002 2 ай бұрын

I feel like there's some hypocrisy in saying copper has a use for building but then saying andesite, diorite and granite are just clatter. If they're clatter then copper is also clatter. I also find a lot of the ways you change difficulty to be more annoying and punishing than making things genuinely harder, though you might just like it like that idk. I definitely get the vibe that you're trying to make it work in good faith though.

@TheGeekFactor 2 ай бұрын

Yeah it’s a personal preference. I find the alternate stone types often clutter up my inventory and I don’t like that. I like copper. That’s the difference. There is no hypocrisy. I just like one block over the others. It’s subjective. Any criticism of any piece of art is subjective.