Thankyou for accurately depicting the latest t and b and rap via the chimps lololo

Yes indeed you two shouldn't have a talk

Still cant do hands

BRAVO! A true masterpiece of an exposé on the current and promising state of AI-assisted music composition.

take this down, gross taste

cool, atmospheric and vintage, just the way I love it.

Wow. Music is hard, man. Even music that is as boring as Bach. ;-)

First robot president? There already was one - Joe Biden

Did ChatGPT spend billions of dollars to do this? DeepSeek will achieve it with less money! But none of them will come close to the real Bach!

We're living in hell .... welcome... you're going to be here for a while.....,

Not critiquing the final result, but the video itself is a masterpiece. Bravo! 👏

fun but it makes no sense : humanity will never come back to barocco time so it's just a style exercice without any musical function in our society like a kappel meister in the past

Very bad, not even coming near to Bach

1:20 Did you just go from Wagner to Jonny Greenwood? 😂💀

Claude wins the day!

It will be even better once you specify how many fingers there are on a human hand.

i love ai generated slop

And more importantly…who cares?

Sorry composers out there, but now your career will depend on how skillful you are in using AI, even if you reject the idea with all your soul...

If you understand music and culture in a deep way you’d realise this is a futile task that benefits no one. Even in 60,000 years’ time this will still be impossible- as this or any other AI simply did not live in C.17/18th Germany, did not have 20 children, did not go blind in middle age, did not beat up bassoon players for messing up concerts, did not have any data whatsoever about anything after 1750 - oh and also string quartets were not a thing in Bach’s time. Stop wasting your time

Too much talk, not enough music.

Bach is overrated snobbish crap. Almost anything before the 1800s is just ugly noise by cavemen. Bach enjoyers have the exact same quality and quantity of brain cells as Taylor Swift and Lil Nas enjoyers.

Pas très convaincant. L’inspiration est encore très loin d’être numérisable. 😉

No way! Even the horizontal parts are not in Bach's manner, not to mention his famous dissonant chords and philosophical rethorics. Poor attempt by far...

Nice! The music isn't amazing (maybe just yet) but I loved the style of the video. Very cool! Thanks!

Wow this sucked. Terrible waste of time

These pieces in non way resemble the genius of Bach. Let real musicians make music and let IA wash and iron our clothes.

Voicemessage jingles 😊

The music is shit. What a waste of so many people's time and attention. The descriptions and commentary on the quality of the music and the experience listening to it, is BS. I'm not sure if it is BS to get more attention, more success, or a result of terrible education and taste in music, but it's super-bizarre to have those words associated with these aesthetically and expressively crappy and ugly results. Maybe a joke, mocking how musically shitty these results are? HOWEVER!!!!! The first thing I heard was not bad! Which, given the accelerating progress in these AI models is just the tiny seed of things to come, is dis-CONCERT-ing (haha) at the very least). Terrifying to me, a genius musician who knows the language of Bach well. Thank you so much for putting this out there. Using a language model to compose music. Wow.

I like the guy in the phone booth

menyedihkan kamu AI

This is for AIs.

Refreshingly bad! Every bit as stilted and lifeless as I would hope my AI competition would be. But how to explain the comparative brilliance of Udio and the like?

Sounds just like something a machine would produce.

Really enjoyed that -- keep up the great work! I appreciate that you're honest about who's currently putting all the generated pieces together, but soon for sure these tools will be full-on producers, too, only under our creative direction. All the other 'work' will be done by the tools. Would you consider this to be a new genre/type of movie? If not, how would you categorize it? Cheers and thanks!

Your knowledge of Baroque Music Theory is partly to blame. Next time, collaborate with someone or something which can do better than just parrot the basics. Also, the Melodic Theory is flawed if it doesn't contain or embody the Celestial Mechanics Model of Tension Tones. Don't worry, ChatGPT hasn't a hope here, because there isn't a large enough Corpus for it to engorge which will engage with this obscure analogy. For that you need a real composer.

After seeing God's giraffe Satan tries and makes the hyena.

Hahaha garbage!

No. This is very bad music. IA can do popular music but can't compose like the greatest.

No way... Yet. But be sure it will come close in the future.

I should point out that context is always essential, and part of Bachs extraordinary genius resides in the simple fact that he had to work hard within the context of an extremely grounded reality. Everything about his working life and (what little we know about) his personal life continually presented him with the genuine, whether the solitude of the composer's desk, the death of a wife or child, the disciplines of the most exacting performance, and all the profound joys of being a creative channel. AI , in my view, is the antithesis of a genuine life, a technology that distances us from the most essential aspects of the very humanity that is not only essential to genuine greatness, but our survival as a species. Like a digital "organ" in a church, it's value is in the quality of it's deceptions, and if we do not pause and profoundly consider our pursuit of enchanting illusions, we are in for genuine sufferings.

Terrible 😂😢

This shows that AI in the field of music composition is still far, far behind.

yeah nah

Market is destroyed , everybody wanna be a producer , everybody knows what happens when supplies overpasses demand ! very few pay attention on the content and it's message.

This is painful. You have a lot of work to do. This sounds like middle school music students learning to use midi software.

99.9% droning narration, 0.1% music.

Haha. Yep. Key of ‘F’.

Not convinced at all.

Your voice cloned bot needs work. Doesn't sound like previous videos