lol they should have just extended service with existing rolling stock. What a dumb move by metrolink
@bhuddy18322 күн бұрын
The failure to provide timely connections and less competitive transfer times is a huge problem, as was predicted, by a number of planners. More frequent ML connections are needed. The comments about the safety of H2 vehicles are just plain amazingly ignorant and false.
@chrisdoutre1012 күн бұрын
Good video, interesting information. But your pronunciation of San Bernadino is completely indecipherable. Same thing with "Arrow". Certainly the closed captions had no idea what you were saying. I worked it out, but it might be worth rerecording at some point.
@dwells772 күн бұрын
What a beautiful shot! Awesome videography!
@gbunny64gbunny3 күн бұрын
Last year, I had to go out to Redlands for a business trip. Would arrive there at night. Looking at Google Street view, the Redlands stations looked to be out in the middle of nowhere where I did not want to be at 8 PM. So instead, I exited the Metrolink at San Bernardino downtown, even though I had purchased a Redlands ticket. That downtown station is certainly not very charming at night either, but I just took an Uber to my destination in Redlands instead of taking the Arrow line. They should have just extended the Metrolink.
@msgproductions35154 күн бұрын
That depends if the Redlands line is set up to handle a Metrolink train. You've got to consider that the Metrolink trains are probably much heavier. Did they engineer the route for heavier trains? What about that bridge they had to replace? Also look at the length of Metrolink. I know they would definitely block University Street at the crossing when stopped at University of Redlands station. I sometimes have to drive that way to get to work and that would suck to have to wait for the passengers to load and unload all while holding up vehicle traffic at the crossing.
@bhuddy18322 күн бұрын
Yes, it runs conventional commuter service today.
@trainguy1104 күн бұрын
It’s illegal to have two 2105’s in California. There’s only one 2105, and that is the one and only “North County Transit District Coast Express Rail SDNX/NCTC Electro-Motive Diesel F40PHM-2C Locomotive”. My hero. 🥲
@LDTV22OfficialChannel4 күн бұрын
What you said was literally what I initially thought because Arrow is simply just a filler
@U.C.11804 күн бұрын
It’s like they want the subway/railway system to fail because it cuts into their wallet. If more people uses a train the less people are driving meaning less fuel consumption.
@powgames5 күн бұрын
The proper choice would be to buy more of these trains, add carriages with toilets and just use them for the whole line to LA. Although we all know that aint happening, so what has to happen is advertisement and dedicated transfers as part of the schedule. And maybe an overhaul to the station signage or even the whole layout, dont know exactly whats going on there.
@powgames5 күн бұрын
The proper choice would be to buy more of these trains, add carriages with toilets and just use them for the whole line to LA. Although we all know that aint happening, so what has to happen is advertisement and dedicated transfers as part of the schedule. And maybe an overhaul to the station signage or even the whole layout, dont know exactly whats going on there.
@atsf855sanbernardinocounty855 күн бұрын
Bring back classic 1910s 1920s early 1930s ATSF heavyweight pullman passenger trains and bring all 1910s 1920s early 1930s ATSF Heavyweight Pullman Cars that do formerly ran ATSF Redlands Branch and today’s BNSF freight service back into former ATSF Redlands Branch
@guretsugu6 күн бұрын
One more you missed: VTA Orange line extension (Eastridge to BART regional connector) broke ground this year in San Jose, planned completion in 2028. I desperately hope Dreamstar becomes a reality, but a 2025 launch is laughable. Even all of the info tabs on their website are still blank.
@Kletterhaus6 күн бұрын
These connections should never ever be longer than 3 to 5 minutes. That they design infrastructure that does not enable that seems ridiculous to me.
@bhuddy18322 күн бұрын
Yep, and we know that, which is all the more disappointing.
@joeyscleaninglady28777 күн бұрын
they need to increase frequency between IE and Orange County that is where the traffic is not between redlands and san bernardino. There should be lines running every 20 mins between i.e. and oc to reduce 91 freeway congestion.
@telescope4977 күн бұрын
As a long time native californian, urban planning in this unorganized, high tax, low services blue state, is a disaster. A pure disaster.
@RealRailJunkie7 күн бұрын
👍🏼
@MirzaAhmed897 күн бұрын
They should extend the A Line to Ontario Airport.
@MirzaAhmed898 күн бұрын
4:35 you mean DMUs? The line isn't electrified.
@everything.trains7 күн бұрын
Yes, my apologies for that.
@bhuddy18322 күн бұрын
Hydrogen fuel cell ZEMU's (Zero Emissions Multiple Unit) are what will be introduced to service this year.
@bhuddy18322 күн бұрын
@everything.trains I would be very happy to give you my short lecture on cost/benefit analysis and cost effectiveness, that I used to give to the USC transportation planning students, for free. You make some good points on the relationships of things like the tradeoff between frequency of service, wait/transfer times, and poor ridership. It's just too bad that you don't take more time to study and research things like the cost benefit tradeoffs on various air quality technologies.
@donstarr72618 күн бұрын
Waste of money!! And its another HERZOG, CONTRACTOR for Metrolink. The conductor's are idiots and tards from railcar cleaning businesses and treat passengers like criminal suspects
@totsm238 күн бұрын
Hydrogen is not typically greener. Green hydrogen (ie: generated using renewables) is very expensive, and regular hydrogen (usually a by product of petroleum refining), while cheaper than green hydrogen, is vastly more expensive than diesel, and only serves to move emissions to the refinery and not the locomotive. Metrolink's baffling refusal to even consider electrification leads to these dead end experiments.
@bhuddy18322 күн бұрын
Utter and complete nonsense. But exactly the line of propaganda being spread by the contractor's lobbying the air agencies to "mandate" only costly electrification schemes as the only "zero" emission option to line their own pockets with taxpayer money. Sunline Transit was already running hydrogen fuel cell vehicles and using hythane (hydrogen blended up to 20% with hydrogen) to replace CNG made from water with off peak wind energy in transit buses and fuel cell vehicles in 2003. Why should taxpayers spend up to $25 million per mile to wire up the Arrow, when there is a cheaper zero emissions technology that is less costly?
@franciscocontreras52768 күн бұрын
Should have extended it. I take this quarterly and the transfer is so annoying.
@algperezjr86398 күн бұрын
Metrolink should extend to Redlands. Use Arrow trains to connect to San Bernardino Airport and Ontario Airport on the side on its own tracks to make it convenient for riders who will take flights out of those airports.
@supertec20238 күн бұрын
I've seen that train go by many times on test drives and I've never seen more than maybe one or two people on it
@todddammit46289 күн бұрын
IMO the answer is the A Line. Somehow that needs to push through that mess in San Bernadino and get to Redlands.
@todddammit46289 күн бұрын
Could the DMU's double as street cars? I'm wondering if down the road there'd be an appetite for that in various parts of Redlands and San Bernardino. Otherwise, yeah, I'd say just extend Metrolink. I'm guessing they'll eventually electrify the whole line anyway so the diesel issue is temporary.
@adolfochaveziii95399 күн бұрын
They should use the extension line to further extend it to Palm Springs, with stops in Calimesa-Yucaipa, Beaumont (by Oak Valley Parkway and 10 freeway or 10 and 60 Freeway interchange), Banning, Morongo Casino, Palm Springs International Airport, and Coachella off Indio Blvd. between Clinton and Monroe.
@todddammit46289 күн бұрын
They should, but it might cost billions just for the land and imminent domain fights.
@Naund329 күн бұрын
In regards to your point about noise levels. DMU and Metrolink locomotives use combustion which generate noise levels that an EMU or ZMU won't. Additionally the US rules regarding train horn use apply to all trains, these rules also inform the use of bells. With the successful use of DMU/EMU's globally I don't see the equipment as the issue (they should've ordered FLIRTs with toilets)I think the problems as with all public infrastructure are more political. Just look at how we arrived at a line called Arrow, or all the things cities/voters don't want in their neighborhoods (noise, no overhead power, station location). The hydrogen fuel concern seem to be an overreaction, we have hydrogen fuel cell vehicles on our roads and I've not heard of anyone stopping hundreds of behind a Hyundai Nexo or Toyota Mirai.
@normbroel46339 күн бұрын
The arrow should be extended south to Riverside where there is a deficiency of service
@1AngryPanda9 күн бұрын
Im not from the area but that a link functions well, it have to be linked in the first place. Use the arrow as low speed train who have a good conection to a faster train ar both ends and somewhere in the middle would help alot. So people can take the faster train until the middle or end and then switch to the arrow to get to the station who is close to the destination. It should be possibel to create a direct connection at sfations with seperate tracks for both lines. So the artow can arrive bevor the fast train and leave after it. Anything in this direction would significant push the usage of the arrow.
@expojam147310 күн бұрын
A solution to the stopping and not picking up anyone is to do what switzerland does for less-dense routes. There’s a request-stop button on the platform that signals to the driver that there are passengers to pick up. If it’s not pressed, no need to stop!
@DavidPalmer70711 күн бұрын
8:05: SMART’s new Petaluma North Station also opens in 2025.
@chaws31411 күн бұрын
I have lived in Santa Clarita my whole life and remember my mom and I having to use the Metrolink for over a year after this earthquake to go to work in Burbank.
@DesertTony9226412 күн бұрын
Extend your heavy rail metro link for direct service
@sardu5512 күн бұрын
Something commuter related from San Diego to LV, northern AZ or points south thru Yuma. Opening up the last great undeveloped area in the lower southwest. And, can I go from Tustin, CA into LV or Yuma?
@roachtoasties12 күн бұрын
I have more of a chance of winning the Powerball jackpot, twice, than the Brightline project from Las Vegas being completed in 2028.
@metrorailinlosangelesprodu440712 күн бұрын
Good Video . Love the history
@everything.trains11 күн бұрын
Thank you!
@qjtvaddict12 күн бұрын
These are DMUs and they are more reliable than existing fleet on metrolink
@qjtvaddict12 күн бұрын
The extension of the metrolink would still require the Redlands infrastructure as the route was washed out decades ago otherwise no extension of metrolink
@Vektab12 күн бұрын
1. Why no electrification of the line? Let me guess, too expensive? 2. Why do American trains look like ugly boxes? Haven't we learned to build sleek and curvy-looking trains like they have in Europe or Asia? I mean, the train looks like it's transporting prisoners, not commuters.
@apilgrim871512 күн бұрын
Sounds like the two completions in the year were the Aviation station in LA and the Copper Line in San Diego. Everything else is 2025 or sometime in the future.
@lyndakorner238312 күн бұрын
Ill-informed people spreading misinformation is the Internet. Because of constraints in Measure I and in the laws of the Cities of Redlands and San Bernardino, the project could not purchase enough trainsets to provide, in the initial phase, 15-minute headways, which are necessary for any high-quality transitway and for transit-oriented development. Change the laws in order to increase the service frequency.
@bhuddy18322 күн бұрын
The hydrogen fearmongering really showed a real lack of knowledge and repeated falsehoods currently being peddled by lobbyists for the contractors who want the air agency to "mandate" only expensive railroad electrification schemes to benefit themselves, that he's repeating as "fact". Otherwise, I think he raised a number of good points about the ridership issues.
@barbarakilpatrick385912 күн бұрын
Real Royalty⭐️
@walawala-fo7ds13 күн бұрын
slow at grade and infrequent. surprise nobody rides it? LA continues to spend money on slow at grade systems that nobody rides. There is no need for loud horns or bells when you have no crossings.
@TheWebber3413 күн бұрын
Minor mistake-No SB Line grade separations are planned. The Hellman Ave and Archibald Ave upgrades are mainly just medians to prevent drivers from going around the crossing gates
@mx33813 күн бұрын
Hydrogen trains are running just fine and passed all safety regulations here in Germany, why would the US be an exception?
@bhuddy18322 күн бұрын
Yeah, he seems to be repeating the fearmongering being spread the lobbyists for the contractors who are pushing for the air agencies to "mandate" costly electrification construction schemes to force agencies like this to spend up to $25 million per mile on needless electrification when there are cheaper zero emissions alternatives like H2 fuel cells.