Why isn't my sourdough SOUR?!?
9:00
Sourdough Starter - Part 3
24:18
3 жыл бұрын
Sourdough Starter, part 2
19:49
4 жыл бұрын
Пікірлер
@b8hovenusa
@b8hovenusa 13 сағат бұрын
Come on give me a break. This is for people that stay home all day. This is rocket science to make a starter. I'd rather buy it. Bread is easy to make but the starter is a pain in the neck.
@rls2229
@rls2229 15 сағат бұрын
I would love to make my own sourdough crackers I can sneak some good seeds into (hemp, flax, millet maybe?).....hope you can share a video on sourdough crackers!
@JJ_In_AR
@JJ_In_AR 16 сағат бұрын
🎉🎉CONGRATULATIONS!!!🎉🎉
@honeylady108
@honeylady108 17 сағат бұрын
Can I use the Pullman loaf pan for this recipe? I ordered the pan from your link in the SD sandwich loaf video, made that recipe and baked in Pullman--it turned out so delicious! Thanks!
@karenhuber4995
@karenhuber4995 18 сағат бұрын
You are a gem, Ben! Looking forward to learning more from you.
@debsnew1
@debsnew1 19 сағат бұрын
My oven is slow. It took about 25 minutes to reach temperature… so at the 45 minute mark it is not brown at all. How much longer should I leave it in the oven covered?
@bvi1998
@bvi1998 19 сағат бұрын
I started raising my bread too late this morning. I used the refrigerator starter which means that I should let it rise for 12 hours. That means it will be almost midnight before I can put it on the pan to rise. can I let it rise longer, or longer in the loaf pan and bake it in the early morning?
@engelman59
@engelman59 20 сағат бұрын
My bread is tasting great but it is spreading in the Le creuset but not rising like it should. It has more than doubled before I transfer to the Le creuset. Please advise.
@hardijw
@hardijw 22 сағат бұрын
Hey Ben, quick question as a beginner - how do I use your recipe to get the more traditional loaf shape (to fit in the toaster) and with the dutch oven? I have the oval banneton which i was planning to use for proofing. Do I just mix the dough and leave it in the fridge (and oval banneton) to ferment? Thanks!
@cliffcox7643
@cliffcox7643 Күн бұрын
Now when I see these vids, I have to say, all my problems and solutions began and ended with the starter.. Once you have a good starter, you can do no wrong.
@eneder1
@eneder1 Күн бұрын
I just found you, a friend recommended you! You talk about buttermilk but I’m wondering if I can substitute with almond milk??
@LoriHarris-zr8rz
@LoriHarris-zr8rz Күн бұрын
Thank you for this video! I am on day 3 of the process. The starter is bubbly and has doubled. There is a layer of liquid at the bottom of the jar. Should I do something about this liquid?
@barbaratells1285
@barbaratells1285 2 күн бұрын
Congratulations 🎉Ben !!!! Wow 🤩 cool history on your cooking 🧑‍🍳 life and thanks for the best Pumpkin 🎃 muffin recipe 😊 Thank you so much for not including those pesky endorsements 🎉 😊 I truly appreciate your sourdough recipes and your scientific knowledge makes your channel all the more fun to watch and learn from! 🎉🎉🎉
@krushmoto1
@krushmoto1 2 күн бұрын
First time trying a sourdough starter and finally after a few days i have bubbles but now it's separated. I'm guessing flour has settled to the bottom, yellowish liquid in middle and frothy bubbly foam on top. Can't find anything where it separates like this. What should i do? Stir, dump half and feed or wait? Thanks in advance.
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
Follow the method! Wait 7 days, then begin the feeding cycles.
@jomi4us
@jomi4us 2 күн бұрын
I once made a sourdough starter from organic grapes, and it resulted super sour bread without good rise of the dough. I was so confused, and discarded the starter at the end. Lol
@cid7017
@cid7017 2 күн бұрын
I started a new starter with your instructions on a Tuesday. I was trying to let it sit for a week until the next Tuesday to feed it again but it’s now Sunday and I noticed what looks like white coloured mold on top! On previous days I noted yellow discolouration at the top, as well as a hooch separation in the middle. Ignored it because I heard that this is all fine. It may still be fine but the mold and discolouration is making me nervous now. What should I do?? Any tips would be greatly appreciated! Thank you
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
Mold isn't good. If you definitely have mold in your starter, you should toss it. You can try starting again, adding 2 drops of vinegar to the mix. (No more.) But if you get mold on that attempt, as well, it means you have a mold colony in your home, and it's going to be hard to get a starter going without it molding. In that case, buy a mature starter online or adopt one from a local Facebook sourdough group.
@cindystutts3477
@cindystutts3477 2 күн бұрын
Yeah! I cannot wait for the travel videos! I also love morels ❤
@saffrondavis960
@saffrondavis960 2 күн бұрын
Wow I never knew I could turn down the power on my Microwave. Great tip.😀😀😀
@batista1260
@batista1260 2 күн бұрын
IT WORKS!!! Try and try this recipe a few times and it will come out better each and every time. I had to fold my bread at 12hrs then at around hour 20th and did a shape fold before letting it rest to bake. I will try again with one fold before baking and sealing it well. Overall, great great bread recipe and instructions.
@user-fg3sl8sk1t
@user-fg3sl8sk1t 2 күн бұрын
Can this be done in a glass dish, with a lid, in the oven?
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
Yes
@myahhofer3616
@myahhofer3616 2 күн бұрын
Is it in the fridge rising or room temperature
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek 2 күн бұрын
Room temperature on the countertop. I have many videos that describe how to make this bread from start to finish.
@kali4664
@kali4664 2 күн бұрын
Love it!!! Can't wait to try the cheddar jalapeno sourdough.. one of my favourite flavour combinations! I'd love to see you make a wholegrain/multigrain sourdough with inclusions similar to the ones you mentioned at 1:22 (buckwheat, barley, oats). Thanks again, Ben!
@hollyhurley7789
@hollyhurley7789 2 күн бұрын
Congratulations on your silver button! I can't wait to see what you show us next.
@austinarsenault408
@austinarsenault408 2 күн бұрын
Could you post a sourdough bagel recipe?
@dave_artkowsky
@dave_artkowsky 2 күн бұрын
PIZZA!!!🍕
@shereestrickland4803
@shereestrickland4803 2 күн бұрын
I've tried to make it twice. It's really stinky after a couple days and has a liquidy bottom. What am I doing wrong?
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek 2 күн бұрын
Nothing is wrong! You're doing it right. Keep going
@user-jx4bn1xy5z
@user-jx4bn1xy5z 2 күн бұрын
Love you energy and watching your videos! Thanks for keeping ads out of your videos.
@haylinmilsam
@haylinmilsam 3 күн бұрын
Well, how cool! Congratulations, Ben! I am among those subscribers who will tune in to anything and everything you post! Thanks for your hard work!
@dicktracy2109
@dicktracy2109 3 күн бұрын
What if my starter is 1:1 1/2:2? Can I use it in this recipe? How can I adjust it?
@Prof.DianeC.Snyder
@Prof.DianeC.Snyder 3 күн бұрын
Is it possible to bake these puppies in the rings vs. frying. Many thanks
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
It's POSSIBLE, but you won't get the lovely crust on the bottom and top. Try 375F for 20 minutes. You want the internal temp to be over 195F.
@TheExcitedSoutherner
@TheExcitedSoutherner 3 күн бұрын
Will this work with Fairlife (ultrafiltered) milk? It’s lower sugar than normal milk. Thanks in advance!
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
With less sugar to ferment than regular milk, I can't tell you what you'll end up with. It certainly WILL ferment whatever sugar exists. Maybe it will be enough to acidify and thicken the milk. Give it a try!
@TheExcitedSoutherner
@TheExcitedSoutherner Күн бұрын
@@ultimatefoodgeek Thanks for the reply! I just realized my jug was whole buttermilk, not the low-fat kind…should I still try anyway? Or should I just wait until I have the low-fat kind to replenish? I wouldn’t mind the weird glue tube texture as long as it tastes right, since I’ll be using it mostly for baking. Thanks again Ben!
@markzanetti6228
@markzanetti6228 3 күн бұрын
I've probably watched 100 or more KZbin videos over the years on making sourdough bread. your explanations, tips and abbreviated techniques puts you at the top of the class. I only have one complaint and that is your lighting in your kitchen makes watching this video torture. I was looking for my sunglasses. I know videography and baking are two different skills, but you really need to invest in some better lighting, equipment or something.
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek 3 күн бұрын
My more recent videos have proper production quality. This video is being remade soon with animation, time lapse, etc.
@Yahwertle
@Yahwertle 3 күн бұрын
We love you Ben
@richardlighthill3228
@richardlighthill3228 3 күн бұрын
Congratuations, Ben ! 100k ! Whoohoo! I think I have finally conquered the "Ben Starr Easy Sourdough Bread". Living at 4300 ft elevation (high desert in southeastern AZ) has made this a challenge, especially with a home gas oven which struggles to get to 450*F. Looking forward to your new "season" !
@MsNahlikMath
@MsNahlikMath 3 күн бұрын
Can you do this with frozen garlic cloves?
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
Yes. But the freezing process does destroy the integrity of the cloves, so don't expect proper, whole cloves after cooking. They will be mushy and falling apart. Still delicious, just not presentable as perfect, whole cloves.
@gardengirl217
@gardengirl217 3 күн бұрын
Congrats Ben, that's great! Looking forward to any and all future videos you do!
@tjmkjohnson8988
@tjmkjohnson8988 3 күн бұрын
Another question, if its been 18 hours and the starved sourdough dough needs more time to rise, did you put it back in the fridge or did you leave it on the counter for the rest of the time to reach a total of 48 hours?
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
If you haven't doubled in 18 hours, leave the dough at room temp until it DOES double. Then shape. You may need to extend your second rise a bit if it takes longer than 24 hours to double.
@cathypiscitello3369
@cathypiscitello3369 3 күн бұрын
Thank you. Ben we all love you the ones that have chosen The BS style for sourdough bread. Making my first loaf tomorrow. I'm really, really looking forward to Sourdough pizza.Thanks again
@simplybeautifulsourdough8920
@simplybeautifulsourdough8920 3 күн бұрын
Whoo hoo! CONGRATULATIONS on 100k!! 🥳🎉 (And yes, lots of people get that far, but it's still special.) Looking forward to what you have coming up for us!!
@lorisober5000
@lorisober5000 3 күн бұрын
I am going to try this they look so good. Do you have a recipe for sourdough bagels?
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
Coming!
@lisatapper4548
@lisatapper4548 4 күн бұрын
Love the content and love learning
@claudettedemello7891
@claudettedemello7891 4 күн бұрын
Hi Ben, love your informative videos. Am new to sourdough and live in a hot country. Could you please share your room temperature in your videos, cos it is definitely way different from mine. Thank you.
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
My room temp is typically 72-78F (22-26C). If your room temps are hotter, expect shorter rise times, especially on the second rise before baking.
@claudettedemello7891
@claudettedemello7891 Күн бұрын
Thank you so much.
@paulaa.7798
@paulaa.7798 4 күн бұрын
Could you make a bread out of this English muffin recipe?
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
No, this batter has very little strength (extremely high hydration) and it could not support itself as a loaf of bread.
@miraconley
@miraconley 4 күн бұрын
I think my starter is slightly overhydrated because I started with one recipie and then switched to another and then another. I have a bunch of starter collected and I don't want to throw it out and start over. How can I tell if I'm right? If I'm right, how can I correct? Should I just start over? 😞Here are my symptoms: my dough is a little too sticky, and it doesn't hold shape. It flattens way more than it should. Like a slighly deflated baloon. Tastes great, but not easier to work with and not as high as it should be.
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
Yes, you are overhydrated. If you are determined not to discard any, you'll have to stumble your way to a stiffer hydration level on your recipes. Add an extra couple of ounces of flour, and if the dough is still sticky after the first rise, knead in more flour until the dough is stiff enough to properly shape. And be sure, when you get low on starter, to follow the feeding protocol in this video at the 6 minute mark, to get back to a proper hydration level.
@user-qx8yl5bs8o
@user-qx8yl5bs8o 4 күн бұрын
We all love you, Ben! I appreciate all of the things you share with us!! Thank you so much!
@KathyAbline
@KathyAbline 4 күн бұрын
Sourdough focaccia please!
@KK-lw7oc
@KK-lw7oc 4 күн бұрын
I just made my own starter, and want to make a bread. Can I use the active new starter in this recipe? Thanks!
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
Yes, but your rise times may be shorter. If your dough doubles in 12 hours or less, reduce the second rise to only 60 mins. If the dough doubles in 8 hour or less, shape it within 12 hours of mixing, and reduce the second rise to 45 minutes. If it takes you LONGER than 12 hours to double, follow the recipe.
@KK-lw7oc
@KK-lw7oc Күн бұрын
@@ultimatefoodgeek Thank you! I did make it and it worked! It looked beautiful. However, it was a little ( just a little) doughy / gummy inside, but that was due to my impatience of cutting into it to early. I waited, but it was still warm when I cut in. Or because my starter is new. (I read a new starter may cause this). Can't wait to bake it again. Thanks for your help and guidance! Love the videos!
@stonerscravings
@stonerscravings 4 күн бұрын
I can’t wait for your new content. Making your 10 minute sourdough now ❤
@weegie2818
@weegie2818 4 күн бұрын
Id rather see your kitchen as is.No need to haul anything out of it. Just saying.
@MDunn-sm6ud
@MDunn-sm6ud 4 күн бұрын
Can you use the powdered buttermilk?
@ultimatefoodgeek
@ultimatefoodgeek Күн бұрын
Yes!