Great review. It's definitely given me pause, as I've been itching to purchase this version for a while. I never considered the replayability, though. Dang. Indecision is my kryptonite. Thank you for sharing your thoughts. Happy Gaming!
@MerlinsManorКүн бұрын
Thanks. I played it through and then sold it. That is always a possibility.
@Ian-R-Wilz2 күн бұрын
4 crossovers with my top 10 on my channel.
@MerlinsManor2 күн бұрын
Cool!
@Stranzua5 күн бұрын
This game sounds great but I'm starting to believe games should move away from using dice. The luck of the roll just leaves too much to chance.
@cafecomescrita8 күн бұрын
Very cool video, helped a lot.
@MerlinsManor8 күн бұрын
Thanks!
@Ian-R-Wilz9 күн бұрын
There are definitely going to be some big time crossovers with my list that will get posted next week on our channel. I think there will be some crossover with my wife's list as well.
@MerlinsManor9 күн бұрын
Then you, sir, have great taste in board games!
@kanedafx9 күн бұрын
Glad you enjoyed Harvest! -Trey
@MerlinsManor9 күн бұрын
Thanks for checking out my video!
@bsz925611 күн бұрын
Natural resources only give points when surronded. Just 1 point here.
@MerlinsManor9 күн бұрын
"Natural Resources: Players earn 1 VP for every visible Natural Resource that is adjacent to at least one piece placed on their map."
@edoardom367713 күн бұрын
This video was just what I needed! I couldn't find anybody else reviewing each card! Great production!
@MerlinsManor13 күн бұрын
Thanks!
@Marroway13 күн бұрын
Don't you have to be on spaces marked with the landmark symbol to collect a landmark? Also why did you not hike with the robohiker as the left side of the card marked that it hiked
@MerlinsManor13 күн бұрын
I am not quite sure what you are asking. Are you talking about destination cards? And if so what do you mean by spaces marked with the Landmark symbol? Are you talking about the card icon on the hiking area that starts on day 5? If so, those are not there for when you can play a destination card, but for when the new color cards come out. If not, can you elaborate further? And as far as the second question I would need to know where in the video you are referencing to have an idea of what was going on.
@JacobRamirez-li9dt15 күн бұрын
Tiny Epic Gloomhaven ;-)
@MerlinsManor15 күн бұрын
Yes... I thought about calling it that :)
@Mattsmindmeld16 күн бұрын
I got this because I have tried gloomhaven but felt it was a bit much for me and really enjoy this bite sized scenarios that are quick and easy to set up. Great review!
@MerlinsManor16 күн бұрын
Thanks!
@snackplaylove16 күн бұрын
I’ve had to resist this one so many times - thanks for the overview!
@MerlinsManor16 күн бұрын
You're welcome.
@theselfishmeme_2318 күн бұрын
When you place the first ocean for the bot, you didn't count the standalone ocean space with 2 plants on the right. Is it because it's on the map edge or you just overlooked that one?
@MerlinsManor18 күн бұрын
Good catch. I just overlooked that space.
@JacobRamirez-li9dt19 күн бұрын
3:14 - No taksies-backsies! 😜
@Mattsmindmeld21 күн бұрын
Thank you for actually explaining the leveling system.
@MerlinsManor21 күн бұрын
You're welcome.
@JacobRamirez-li9dt22 күн бұрын
Do you think an expansion with more cards and tiles would fix the replayability problem?
@MerlinsManor22 күн бұрын
It would. And if they added more lessons, they could use a module system like the original game or just say take out X amount of lessons. I'd also like to see Oshax if they wouldn't unbalance the game too much (maybe make them cost a fish to take).
@eledv452125 күн бұрын
Very cool video! We do have some games in common that we both play a lot (Cascadia, Wingspan, the Isle of Cats). I played Terraforming Mars Ares Expedition a few days ago but I didn't quite love it, it felt a bit repetitive at the end with me doing the same 2 phases over and over (Action and Production). Maybe cause it was the easiest difficulty. I also got the expansion since I'd heard it's better for solo but I still haven't played it. Also, I saw you have Dorfromantik Sakura behind you, I got it but haven't played it yet, how is it? Thank you and Merry Christmas
@MerlinsManor25 күн бұрын
Terraforming Mars Ares Expedition is a game where the beginning focuses alot on building an engine through green and blue cards with red event cards scattered here and there and then by the end you really need to try to milk the benefits of the engine you built primarily through Actions and production (especially for the solo). Most of the fun comes in the engine building and then I personally find the overpowered ending rewarding from a well-built engine. Dorf Romantik is fun. It gives vibes similar to Cascadia when it comes to the matching of landscapes on tiles, but with the challenge being trying to fulfill tasks through matching certain amounts of terrain in groups. The game doesn't really have a win/ loss condition, but rather you unlock more challenges as you go... and the better you do the quicker you unlock new things.
@eledv452122 күн бұрын
@@MerlinsManor Thank you for the detailed explanation!
@rowanash537827 күн бұрын
I was playing The Happy Trails Horror box while I was listening to this video and actually managed to win as Laurie on turn 3 by finding the axe, taking a hit early, and then finishing him off via Retaliate.
@MerlinsManor26 күн бұрын
That sounds almost too good to be true. Guessing you found the axe on turn 2. What attacks did you do? I'm guessing mostly double successes too.
@MCJesse-hu4ru29 күн бұрын
Fun idea for a video. My top plays are: 1. Terraforming mars -189 2. Splendor-88 3. Catan -75 4. Azul- 73 5. First Martian- 61 (almost exclusively solo)
@MerlinsManor29 күн бұрын
Another TM lover I see. And I am glad you liked this video idea. I thought about doing one at the start of the year that is most played games in 2024, but concerned it might be too close in time to this video... but I did look at my list and there were only a few crossovers with my overall plays list, so it may still work.
@tmills1565Ай бұрын
Great video! Super cool
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thank you very much!
@blitz3391Ай бұрын
It's important indeed to emphasis the fact that victims are your currency. Both as a distraction, but also as a power-up. I ran a game last night where i had terrible luck; Laury's weapon was burnt with the normal bow because of the Fire card , and the terror deck was almost exclusively Hans' actions. As a result, we ran out of victims quickly, before i could even trigger my power, but i also ran out of terror deck, which means the final card enters play, and i'm the only one left. After just 2 turns , Hans was moving 3 per boot and stabbing for 4, twice (because of course he did). I died in one turn as soon as he caught me. Sometimes, your game will be unwinnable from the start.
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
I sometimes use victims as shields towards the end of the game. Works like an extra Guard.
@gottimightyАй бұрын
@31:56 châteauma player should have sold goods when placing goats on county card which would have given him a silver coin totaling 3. He then would have spent 2 in black depot leaving him with 1. Also @47:40 you never replaced the county card when it was completed and played it twice😂
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
oops
@PablowingUrMindАй бұрын
Do you have the Giants expansion for Three Dragon Ante? Would be interested on the review with vs without expansion.
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
I have had the expansion for so long, but have not tried it yet. My friend has the expansion too, but we keep neglecting to learn it and add it. We keep saying we need to try it, but just don't.
@eledv4521Ай бұрын
- Vadoran Garden I actually got thanks to your playthrough, love it! - Also love Isle of Cats Explore and Draw, so much that I actually got the boats expansion - Cartographers love it, both the physical version and the one on Android - Diced Veggies seems fun, I saw on bgg it's possible to play solo, did you ever play it solo? - Welcome to... I have all the variants and also Welcome to the Moon, love it Another great list, thank you!
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thanks. I am glad you enjoyed Vadoran Gardens. I have not played Diced Veggies solo. I seldom play solo modes that don't come with the original game... though if I am not mistaken Diced Veggies is at least an official solo mode, so I really should try it sometime. Does it require anything extra?
@eledv4521Ай бұрын
@@MerlinsManor I haven't tried it as I donìt own the boardgame but I know it's indeed an official solo mode as you said and it doesn't require anything extra. Also, it's BYOS. Maybe someday!
@eledv4521Ай бұрын
- Love Trailblazers! Even though I'm so bad at it haha - Also love One Deck Dungeon but I've only ever played it on Steam. I may buy the physical version at some point. Great video for gifts ideas by the way!
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thanks. I am terrible at Trailblazers too.
@eledv4521Ай бұрын
@@MerlinsManor Haha glad I'm not the only one! And I haven't even started with the objectives.
@benf5287Ай бұрын
Great video... Thank you for the thorough walk through!
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thank‐you!
@earthling-adАй бұрын
I played final girl for the first time last night. I was so close to beating Hans. Saved 5 hostages with Reiko early on and brought him down to 2 health but some extremely unlucky rolling lost me the game. Looking forward to trying again this weekend.
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Good luck.
@CumberlandKing461Ай бұрын
Very informative video! I was curious about the board game as I've only played the video game. I'm also a little disappointed to here how Frost and Wrath work, especially Wrath. I love using Wrath and the risk and reward it carries.
@lassebrun84Ай бұрын
Du you know if it wil get translated like all the other stuff
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
I don't know as I have no connection with the company.
@BoxedMeeplesАй бұрын
Do you feel this is the Feature Film that feels most unique?
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Probably between this one and the Organism... both feel very unique. Also, I would say overall Season 2 feature films feel more unique than Season 1. Each feature film has some standout mechanisms that set them apart from others.
@BoxedMeeplesАй бұрын
Its so great to see the minis in this ! Really enjoyed this, and now going to have to look and see which other Final Girl expansions youve played!
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
I've posted videos for all of Season 2, North Pole Nightmare, plus Maple Lane, Creech Manor, and Terror From Above. My earlier videos had pretty terrible camera angles.
@MistyCozyGamingАй бұрын
Thanks for sharing. What is the green box you have you eggs in? Do you have a link?
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
They are Stonemaier egg trays that came with Wingspan. Stonemaier now sells them on their webstore as part of a tray variety pack. I just repurpased them from Wingspan since I have the nesting box now for Wingspan. Link: store.stonemaiergames.com/products/tray-variety-pack
@MistyCozyGamingАй бұрын
@MerlinsManor thanks
@philomorph7Ай бұрын
Oh man, Planning just gives you extra dice? I thought it gave you x number of automatic successes in lieu of rolling on your next check. Now it seems too expensive for what you get. Also one important note - spending cards for time has to happen *before* the action phase ends - you can't do it during the prep phase. So be sure to plan ahead for that before you play a card that could instantly end your action phase.
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
It's occasionally good for when you really need 2 successes... while it doesn't guarantee it, it makes it more likely. Also makes the cards with 3 success more viable. It is a bit overpriced thougalsot also works well with Heather's ability where each 5 or 6 rolled does a damage.
@paulsalomon27Ай бұрын
Thanks for playing and posting!
@markaceramos4498Ай бұрын
You sir got my subscription. I like your straight and very informative way of teaching. No unnecessary shenanigans at all. Keep it up! Thank you so much for posting this video.
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thanks!
@travisnaganuma2542Ай бұрын
I’m confused. So if maniacs have a move of one and an attack of one does that basically override the blood lust tracker chart for the ratchet lady? I saw you moved to maniacs in the first round of the game into a room with a victim but the victim didn’t die. I assumed it was because you were using the tracker and no one had been killed yet? When does the rule of maniacs have a move of one and a attack of one come into play?
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
The move of 1 and attack of 1 is the amount of movement and damage they do per boot and per knife icon. Since their innate action each round (found next to the "M" on the killer board) just includes the boot, they only move and they do not attack. If I had drawn a terror card with a knife icon, then they would have attacked with a damage of 1 (per knife icon). Also note that some terror cards say "Ratchet Lady only," and in those cases you would not apply the action to the minions. Alternately, Ratchet Lady only has an attack icon for her innate ability, and so she does not move unless a terror card tells her to, but she will attack in her space if there is anyone there before drawing a terror card.
@travisnaganuma2542Ай бұрын
@@MerlinsManor oh thank you. That definitely helps clarify
@ralfn9629Ай бұрын
Great list again (with one exception - see below). Love SI, Isle of Cats, Ark Nova and your comments on Everdell are spot on. Final Girl, the -haven games and TM are also in my top 10, Wingspan is one of my favorite games of all time. And here I disagree on Wyrmspam. Wingspan is great especially for the over 500 different bird species and counting with 3 more expansions to come. That makes this game great vs. yet another fantasy-themed game I couldn't care less. Other games in my top 25 would be Scythe, Robinson Crusoe, City of the Great Machine, Star Wars Armada, Frostpunk, 7th Citadel, Root and Go (my number 0, as no other board game can compete with this one!).
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Have you played Wyrmspan? And is it just the theme that turns you off from it? I think they also innovated the gameplay and added extra depth of strategy. I still really enjoy Wingspan (obviously as it was on the list), but I like what Wyrmspan added outside of the theme too.
@ralfn9629Ай бұрын
@@MerlinsManor Yes the theme is a turn off for me. The art looks cute though. No, I haven't played it but watched a lot of videos and reviews. The big added mechanic of the guild track looks great, but I don't need it. Criticism of the dice for Wingspan I find flat out wrong, as I love the bird feeder mechanic. I feel the mechanic to first build the cave in order to seat your dragon is a bit clunky; but again, I haven't played Wyrmspam. Anyway, I think I will be happy to cherish Wingspan forever and don't need the other, which is 95% the same game.
@ralfn9629Ай бұрын
Nice list. I love Creatures Comforts and Meadow, including the Downstream expansion. I only got Harmonies a few days ago, not played yet. I was very interested in your comment about Dinosaur World vs Dinogenics. Hmm, I need to look into this one, but c do I need both??
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
I personally plan to get rid of Dinosaur World because I much prefer Dinogenics. They do play very differently though, so there could be room for both.
@BirdsOnBoard112Ай бұрын
Great top 10! 🎉 I'm very much aligned to your choices! 😁 Keep up the great work 🍻
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thanks!
@lastchairbender7450Ай бұрын
Great video! Super informative!
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thanks! I really enjoyed putting this one together.
@WhereMyMeepsAtАй бұрын
Great list! Especially the first 8 for me. Love the quick explanations. Subbed!
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thanks!
@JJ_TheGreatАй бұрын
22:44 However, I also find that the drafting mechanism slows down the game, as each player has to read each card to make a selection - and some players (like myself) are slow readers.
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Once you've learned many of the cards, it doesn't take too long, especially since most of what you need to look at is symbology. I find it worth the extra time personally to mitigate the luck and with how it helps to build synergy, but perfectly understand how some would prefer to skip drafting to speed up the game.
@donnakeferlis1649Ай бұрын
I have everything except 10 & 1. 9-2 are perfection!!!
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
You have great taste in games! 😀
@randothomas3733Ай бұрын
Managing 2 characters in Gloomhaven would fuse my brain. I tend to get analysis paralysis when I have to select cards for just 1. Beside that, great list.
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thanks!
@TheKruegerKnowsАй бұрын
Great Video! Thanks
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thanks.
@ObzedeezyАй бұрын
Discovered your channel recently through your Final Girl strategy tips video and have been watching your playthroughs as well (hoping that game will make the Top 10 😉) Just wanted to say I appreciate your approach of keeping ratings consistent over time rather than basing your list on recency bias. A game good enough to earn a 10 ought to rank appropriately high year over year 👍
@MerlinsManorАй бұрын
Thanks for watching my videos, and I'm glad you appreciate my approach. It seems many allow older games they ranked 10 out of 10 drop off (which is fine as it is their list)... there are just games that I've really loved that stop getting the plays once I have experienced all the content that I still feel belong with the rest of the 10's or 9.5's. And, you'll just have to tune in and see if Final Girl makes my top 10.
@eledv45212 ай бұрын
Thanks for the list, looking forward to watching the top 10! From your list I played: - Harmonies - The Lord of The Rings: Duel for Middle Earth (which I believe is a reimplementation of 7 Wonders Duel) - Welcome to the Moon (only played the first two missions, I need to continue! Too many games to play haha)
@MerlinsManor2 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching. I just got Lord of the Rings Duel (and it is a reimplementation of 7 Wonders Duel, but it does look quite different mechanically as well). Technically, it is a gift for my wife for Christmas, but I might just let her have it early so we can play it... lol.
@eledv4521Ай бұрын
@@MerlinsManor Haha, I'm sure she wouldn't mind!!
@eledv45212 ай бұрын
I love this game! Thanks for the playthrough and what a good score! I played with the official BYOS at first but now I'm playing the scenarios found on BGG and that's more appealing to me, I'm currently at scenario 5 or 6.
@MerlinsManor2 ай бұрын
I thought I heard there were scenarios. I need to check those out because I much prefer scenarios to BYOS.
@donnakeferlis16492 ай бұрын
Love this game, especially solo. Gotta admit, I'm gonna fast forward to see how many suns you got. You did better than I ever managed! I need more practice. This game fooled me with its cuteness, it's more thinky than I anticipated!
@MerlinsManor2 ай бұрын
I feel like I score so few Suns for what the game expects you to be able to do with the chart. I really don't know what is considered a good score for this game.
@TheAntiSanta2 ай бұрын
My advice would be to Cheat. Only draw a final health token for your Final Girl from the three that give you health. Look through all the Killer and Location's Terror Cards, and don't include the really nasty ones in your Shuffling (especially Minor Dark Powers). Hide any Dark Powers and Finales you don't ever want to face. Start a game with the contents of your Final Girl's Secret Envelope. Use as many Ultimate Dice as you like. Threat 4's as successes. Go wild. No one can stop you. And then when you start getting tired of winning all the time, stop cheating. And then flip that board over to Extreme Horror Mode. And then finally, start cheating in the Killer's favor. Only use the Terror Cards and Finales and Dark Powers that make the game harder.