Пікірлер
@quattrocity9620
@quattrocity9620 Сағат бұрын
Kickstarter is supposed to be for startups, not companies that already have money to take presales. It's in the name. They seem to be using Kickstarter exactly as intended.
@yasafvolinsky7427
@yasafvolinsky7427 7 сағат бұрын
i think you ended up doing them a service. i would invest in this, warts and all - if i have the spare money
@brozadude
@brozadude 9 сағат бұрын
I watched their side of the story and quite frankly I think you haven't been completely fair or transparent. This isn't a final product and kickstarter backers can cancel their pledge until the last moment free of charge. I think delaying the video a bit so that they could address their issues is only reasonable.
@riakata
@riakata 9 сағат бұрын
I think the mfg neglected to warn you of the dust hazard and their response to all the comments about said hazard just shows how lax their safety cluture is. Obviously if you have a clean filter and do everything perfectly little dust will escape but no one is perfect a user will ineventably drop the fragile box breaking it or drop the cake with the two scope thing and spread massive amounts of dust that will instantly clog that tiny supposedly hepa rated fan thing.
@DuceDesigns
@DuceDesigns 9 сағат бұрын
Thank you for your honest review of -Theranos- Micronics, you've likely saved me 3+ grand.
@riakata
@riakata 9 сағат бұрын
Ironically none of the reviewers mentioned the true scale of the safety hazard and cleaning requirements to have one of these. In previous work Ive seen sls printer areas and even with "turnkey" million dollar systems with dust extractors and downdraft tables and cleaning staff you can still find a thin film of powder always that you just keep cleaning off constantly.
@TheGremalin
@TheGremalin 10 сағат бұрын
If you really wanted to love it, that would mean giving tech support proper time and response. Seems like you wanted to love getting the video out more than you wanted to love the product.
@riakata
@riakata 10 сағат бұрын
You have to remember micronics wants to sell as many as possible so... Safety who cares about sufficient local exhaust. Also they gave all the KZbinrs kn95 masks that likely are not fit tested so they all got a bit of cancer dust that will be in all their studios long term since every sifter bin leaked basically. If I was a KZbinr that trusted their instructions and read about the actual hazards I would actually take them to small claims court.
@0Asterite0
@0Asterite0 10 сағат бұрын
Yep, all empty promises and false hype. Will not be buying
@hallcrash
@hallcrash 14 сағат бұрын
How did they remove the powder after testing but before they shipped it?
@riakata
@riakata 10 сағат бұрын
They probably used a different bin and called that "tested"
@avaviel
@avaviel 14 сағат бұрын
kzbin.info/www/bejne/gHe3inyof5x0fNk They made a response, and after seeing the unhidden messages that Scotty censored...
@riakata
@riakata 10 сағат бұрын
The mfg is still downplaying the safety and did admit to asking for a delay and then lying on why they did that. They are being unethical people will get lung cancer from this it's insane. All the reviewers got the same kn95 looking mask yet now they say n95. And their engineering controls and fume extractor are woefully janky.
@ClayMann
@ClayMann 16 сағат бұрын
First of all I somehow missed being subbed to this channel despite knowing the other. I was confused but the name is just one letter different. Anyway no worries I'm subbed to both now. Now this machine. Its times like this I learn a lot about the channels I'm watching. Those that just ignore all the issues and either take the money or the free hardware and those like this one that tell you this is not ready. As exciting as it is to see this kind of printing technology come down an order of magnitude in price. I don't believe this is the company to do it. They are too under funded and trying to do too much. That's just my opinion. I hope to be proved wrong. Them have a great first run with everything fixed. I hope even more they are still around for a V2 as I'd be very interested in seeing that. But I'm out as far as this one goes and I'm exactly the kind of person that would buy this. A real shame.
@-B_S-
@-B_S- 16 сағат бұрын
I would love to see the like to dislike ratio
@Cosmicfude
@Cosmicfude 16 сағат бұрын
5k likes, 206 dislikes as of posting this comment
@cybersuperspy
@cybersuperspy 16 сағат бұрын
Why didn't they supply ready installed? It seems cumbersome to get it right in the fast place and a risk of something going wrong.
@c9k
@c9k 16 сағат бұрын
This didn't age well in the face of their response buddy, you did them dirty. Take this down.
@Cosmicfude
@Cosmicfude 16 сағат бұрын
Micronics is very unprofessional, they need a PR team not the founder on screen talking about this
@benjaelee
@benjaelee 15 сағат бұрын
@@Cosmicfude bro what? you dont need a pr team, especially not for a startup. hearing things from the founder is way more professional than having someone else deal with your problems
@riakata
@riakata 10 сағат бұрын
That is insane the printer didn't work out of the box the safety hazards are still being downplayed people are literally going to get lung cancer from this laizefair attitude the mfg is doing the bare minimum in their minds which is way below actual safety.
@lugui
@lugui 19 сағат бұрын
I hope you address their reply, because you didn't seemed very transparent on your video, unlike them.
@Cosmicfude
@Cosmicfude 16 сағат бұрын
I mean he probably didn't want to post private communications. However it seems that the Micronics guys had their feelings hurt and it shows in their communication. They are a company and they need to act professionally. My issue is that just because you worked real hard on a project for years doesn't mean that someone who had issues with your product, means their opinion is invalid because of it. Micronics needs to hire a PR team and learn to correctly address problems when they arise. Hell they didn't even address Scotty's issues until the end of the video. I get it it's only a couple of people working on this project but you can't let personal feelings get in the way when you represent a company that is trying to bring a product to market. Also in the screenshot I saw on their video are not professional at all, and asking a reviewer to delay a "bad" review is always going to look bad on the company IMO.
@avaviel
@avaviel 14 сағат бұрын
He does well on drama. I've noticed that about older videos.
@riakata
@riakata 10 сағат бұрын
The mfg is being non transparent they say the powder can't explode or catch fire and you read formlabs sls printer which uses essentially the same powder and they have a totally integrated cleaning station and still say a fire or explosion can occur if you don't follow the extremely detailed documentation properly. Miconics doesn't seem to think it's even dangerous in any way.
@lugui
@lugui 7 сағат бұрын
@@avaviel true.. this is the only reason I watched the video, to see if the accusations where real.. and look at us now.. engaging! praise the algorithm!!
@lugui
@lugui 7 сағат бұрын
"They are a company and they need to act professionally." They are also, 2 guys. 2 very real and briliant guys doing their best. at their scale, a review like that could kill their whole operation which is directly aimed at making a industry grade quality product for the consumer market at a _consumer market_ price tag. So far, to me it looks they did all they could to fix the problems caused by shipping and got a killing bad review for something that is only tangentially on their control. I hope they get to find a way to inprove their shipping process because the product is good when not damaged!
@andresaristi5646
@andresaristi5646 20 сағат бұрын
What part of beta or prototype isn't clear for this guy? You dont deserve this testing unit
@TouchofDepth
@TouchofDepth 19 сағат бұрын
um... he definitely did a fair review of this machine... you and micronics are too emotional for serious business.
@Cosmicfude
@Cosmicfude 16 сағат бұрын
@@TouchofDepth Based
@riakata
@riakata 10 сағат бұрын
They sent it to him so it was their choice.
@pauls8771
@pauls8771 21 сағат бұрын
I'm reminded of the final lines of Anton Ego in Ratatouille - it's safe and easy for critics to trash on the hard work that others extend to them from the safety of behind their own writing desks - it's easier to tear people down and negative reviews get more views. But remember this is the work of two guys out of their garages and bedrooms, and to produce a product as professional as this, even with it's rough edges, deserves far more credit and respect than you seem to be willing to lend them. Honesty isn't a shield for you to shit on people's hard work without acknowledgment.
@riakata
@riakata 10 сағат бұрын
The product is dangerous the mfg doesn't make it clear enough that inert powders are still hazardous. People will get lung cancer using this long term it's insanely unethical marketing they are pushing on their KZbin. I think the product is a good idea but they are being very non transparent and are still downplaying safety issues.
@chazhaze1580
@chazhaze1580 21 сағат бұрын
Garbage
@Cosmicfude
@Cosmicfude 16 сағат бұрын
Such a way with words.
@SmokyFrosty
@SmokyFrosty Күн бұрын
Scotty, Kickstarter really is for exactly this, if not worse. An idea is Kickstarter. It's not amazon, your not buying a product. Your investing into an idea. You are a beta tester, that means there WILL be problems which is exactly what you got so... What's the problem. I belive Micronics have been more than transparent and really didn't need to be at all. Hopefully you guys get it together.
@riakata
@riakata 10 сағат бұрын
They have not been. They literally said the powder is safe the fan is ""hepa"" while neglecting the fact it is all very poorly designed for dust containment and people will get lung cancer or give everyone some cancer by trying to wash the parts in water instead of getting a sandblaster.
@patrickl9930
@patrickl9930 Күн бұрын
Their response video tells a tale of a rushed review and a KZbin pulled in many directions. It would be good to see this resolved in a nice way!
@riakata
@riakata 10 сағат бұрын
The micronics product is not safe the dust handling system is beyond jank and will cause lung cancer. Inert powders cause cancer because your body can't digest inert powders. The nylon is also flammable unlike what they claim.
@The_Privateer
@The_Privateer Күн бұрын
And this is why you only throw money at kickstarter projects that you could afford to just burn.
@Cosmicfude
@Cosmicfude 16 сағат бұрын
Couldn't agree more. Kickstarter has always been a shithole of products that take decades to come to market.
@ChuckThree
@ChuckThree Күн бұрын
Great hit piece 👏👏👍
@NautilusTSG
@NautilusTSG Күн бұрын
This review is a hitjob.
@georgemathieson6097
@georgemathieson6097 Күн бұрын
after watching micronics' new video on this matter, I'm leaning more to their side than yours - mostly because of their true transparency
@jamess5872
@jamess5872 Күн бұрын
Scott's concern isn't invalid, he might have approached it with a bit more patience but overall it was a healthy exchange.
@georgemathieson6097
@georgemathieson6097 Күн бұрын
@@jamess5872 it seems to me as though he had pre-existing stresses and this unfortunately compounded on top of them - which lead to his misinterpretation of microtronics' intentions
@XecularOfficial
@XecularOfficial Күн бұрын
@@jamess5872 That depends on which concern. His concerns regarding the kickstarter were entirely invalid, because he is incorrectly implying that releasing his video after the beginning of the kickstarter would be meaningfully harmful to people backing the project. He also treats the unit he received like it's meant to be a fully complete product when it is very clearly an early pre-production unit meant for testing purposes. Micronics even says in their campaign video that they just finished their R&D phase and are ready to move towards production, which is exactly where reliability or logistics issues like are usually worked out
@georgemathieson6097
@georgemathieson6097 Күн бұрын
@@jamess5872 I've just realised that my response from earlier has been removed. It roughly read "it seems as though he had pre-existing stresses which were unfortunately compounded by this - explaining his potential misunderstanding of microtronics' intentions"; the fact that my comment was removed speaks volumes.
@kyledavis417
@kyledavis417 21 сағат бұрын
Definitely lost some respect for him after watching the response video
@exgodstatus
@exgodstatus Күн бұрын
The transparency and discussion of how difficult it is to actually be transparent in how much of a let down this has been is extremely refreshing. The entire Micronics project seems to be attempting to contain how frankly amateur it is at its core in a post-bambu market where products are expected to be professional and coherent at every level. I'm still hopeful that they will find their footing and, if nothing else, demonstrate the viability of affordable desktop SLS in the consumer 3d printer market. Thank you, Scotty!
@XecularOfficial
@XecularOfficial Күн бұрын
I don't think less experienced users dependent on highly polished products are the target market for this printer. Given that it currently has an msrp of over 4k USD, this is very much within the range of prosumers to small businesses. The issues this printer has also aren't all that uncommon for SLS printers that cost more than ten times as much, so people should really be tempering their expectations according to what is standard for SLS, not what they are used to with FDM and Resin. Micronics has said themselves that this isn't supposed to be a bambu you can stick in your bedroom and run next to you. Much like printing with PEEK or carbon fiber, SLS is an industrial process that requires working with hazardous materials. Anyone who buys this printer without aware of this has nobody to blame but themselves for failing to do any research on what they were investing in
@a1hamer
@a1hamer Күн бұрын
When i see this sls thing i remembered the first cardboard fff 3d printer from ultimaker
@jonmayer
@jonmayer Күн бұрын
Thank you for this honest review!! I'm starting to see these reviews pop up and this video was great until the end. The company is not ready for release and they are not prepared to make the changes needed. I hope others are as transparent as you and maybe they can get this into a great product.
@MrSirclint
@MrSirclint Күн бұрын
Not prepared? The addressed all of it in their most recent video
@semibbc
@semibbc 20 сағат бұрын
Theyre a kickstarter... ofcourse theyre not ready. Thats the point of sending test units
@tiborsliva
@tiborsliva Күн бұрын
I would like to see more reviews like this for Kickstarter projects because everything that I bought on kickstarter it disappointed me.
@genin69
@genin69 Күн бұрын
If this is a beta testing machine I think their problem was to allow people who want to test their machines to make a video of it. Creality did that too often and the units that arr shipped are actually good but most of the reviews are on the beta or alpha version which had bugs which I think hurt sales.
@Gearshock
@Gearshock Күн бұрын
Their behavior dissuaded me from their printer. I would've loved one of these and wouldn't have cared about them taking time to work through the issues. But to shove out something bad and try to cover up instead of offering transparency on the issues is really irresponsible and comes across as cash grabbing instead of being intent on making a solid product. There is so much they could do differently to make this ok and not let these issues stop them. Thanks for keeping us informed, it does look like a cool printer, but if they can't own up to where things are wrong and do better to address them I'm going to avoid Micronics. Amazing how a little humility would save them so much trouble.
@MrSirclint
@MrSirclint Күн бұрын
It's a beta test. Not released
@Gearshock
@Gearshock 23 сағат бұрын
@@MrSirclint I'm aware.
@BackwoodsTinkerer
@BackwoodsTinkerer 22 сағат бұрын
They actually did. Try watching their response video. Scotty did them dirty and failed to mention they were trying to get him replacement parts and he has since ghosted them.
@MrSirclint
@MrSirclint 22 сағат бұрын
@@Gearshock obviously not since you made this post.
@Gearshock
@Gearshock 21 сағат бұрын
@@MrSirclint Whatever you have to convince yourself of. idc
@onikiristudios
@onikiristudios Күн бұрын
this whole experience looked like a NIGHTMARE. It's such cool technology for us to have access to at home, but manufacturers seemingly just aren't testing their products enough...
@JofJaf
@JofJaf Күн бұрын
I was completely open to buying a beta unit with issues, that's the price of being on the cutting edge. What is a dealbreaker is their attitude with you. Trying to hide the issues and not owning it. Thanks for being honest. Hopefully they receive the feedback: it's not the issues the problem, it's how a company deals with it. This ain't it. I was about to put my money down before watching this video. Thank you for being honest with us!
@Tynted
@Tynted 21 сағат бұрын
I was in your boat when I watched this video, but Micronics has now released a response video addressing this situation and showing conversations that occurred between the two of them. I would recommend watching that and seeing it from their perspective too. I think they are acting appropriately and Scotty was rather unfair to them with in this video.
@TouchofDepth
@TouchofDepth 19 сағат бұрын
@@Tynted they did an ok response but they are still being dodgy .. read the whole conversation that they shared, it starts off with them apologizing for getting emotional.. if thats how they handle business, things will not go well
@riakata
@riakata 9 сағат бұрын
​@@Tyntedthey are openly lying in their response video about factual things like nylon powder is flammable and dust explosion hazard. So they can't be trusted at all. Users will get lung cancer long after they run away into the wind.
@KJMcLaws
@KJMcLaws Күн бұрын
I hope they can get the issues sorted out and get the money they need. I want that concept as a machine. I'm not going to back it and be a guinea pig for an unfinished product.
@ananabushusheh3472
@ananabushusheh3472 Күн бұрын
Powder likes to clump and is hard to move if its full of moisture heating the powder to get rid of unwanted moisture should make this more reliable.
@Zachary3DPrints
@Zachary3DPrints Күн бұрын
Great and honest review video! If they ask to review a printer, they also need to expect negative feedback or else it's just a promotion video and that is usually not the purpose of a review. I surprised that you have 2 channels... and both I wasn't subscribed to, but now I am! We have met at RMRRF this year
@bartoszswieciak8341
@bartoszswieciak8341 2 күн бұрын
While, I fully agree that this machine is not in a state that is acceptable to sell now, I also don't fully understand your point, isn't Kickstarter ment to get cash to "finish" a project? This feels like the perfect place for that project to get money to fix problems that make it unacceptable now and later ship a finished project. For me kickstarter was always like a early-access is to games. They beeing agressive to you and asking you for your printer back is a redflag tho.
@semibbc
@semibbc Күн бұрын
You should check out Microns video they made today
@riakata
@riakata 10 сағат бұрын
​@@semibbcyeah their video just painted them in the let's bend the truth and lie department about powder safety and n95 being overkill. People are going to get lung cancer from this. Micro plastic pollution will jump in waste water from misuse of the powder.
@TomDouglass-cm9tu
@TomDouglass-cm9tu 2 күн бұрын
Good job, That Print is way too much work for the size of the print.
@tomstern1681
@tomstern1681 2 күн бұрын
We know we can trust you
@erikm9768
@erikm9768 2 күн бұрын
I love honest youtubers, you are so few , most reviewers are easily corrupted unfortunately. If you stay honest and transparent you will be very successful!
@NordicSpartan
@NordicSpartan 2 күн бұрын
I've been following Micronics with great anticipation, and must say I'm very disheartened by their conduct here. I really hope they get through their difficulties without devaluing their brand and potential. At the same time I really applaud your integrity and fair review, thank you!
@semibbc
@semibbc Күн бұрын
You should check out Microns video they made today
@Cosmicfude
@Cosmicfude 17 сағат бұрын
@@semibbc I mean I read their responses to Scotty and it still seems like they were not fully acting professional toward him. I get it they have sunk a lot of time into this project but asking a person who they sent a "beta unit" to test, then asking him to delay a negative review of the unit is always in my eyes a bad look. They seemed very butt hurt still and need to hire a PR team to deal with issues like this. Any company I see that asks a reviewer to delay or postpone a review due to bad feedback will always look bad in my eyes. I'm am glad they are fixing the issues but they didn't even address the "drama" until the end of the video. I still feel that all parties could have handled this better IMO.
@erikm9768
@erikm9768 2 күн бұрын
I want to thank you for making a fully transparent review with your honest thoughts, I appreciate you have integrity to tell us the unsweetened story, its the right thing to do when people are about to spend several thousand of hard earned ones. Have liked and subscribed!
@Tynted
@Tynted 21 сағат бұрын
Micronics made a response to this video sharing their side of the story, I'd recommend watching that. Scotty was a kinda unfair to them IMO
@JH-zo5gk
@JH-zo5gk 2 күн бұрын
My favorite part is the environmental disaster every time you need to get your print out.
@JH-zo5gk
@JH-zo5gk 2 күн бұрын
Im excited to see what sort of trouble people can get them selfs into with microscopic plastic powders.
@MrBaskins2010
@MrBaskins2010 2 күн бұрын
clicked this video at 2am, dozed off and woke up to what sounded like the CIA defusing an explosive on a Nokia phone. 3d printing content has come a long way
@Gravity_Fish
@Gravity_Fish 2 күн бұрын
saw that printed bin and thought "Hmm, that looks brittle" heard it was meant to be shaken "Oh, yeah that bin is gonna break" bin broke. not surprised. thanks for calling them on their shit. Printer looks like itll be good when its done. Its not done yet...
@semibbc
@semibbc Күн бұрын
its obvious its not done... its a kickstarter. The whole point is to get more investments to MAKE it better
@robb233
@robb233 2 күн бұрын
From what I've learned elsewhere people are WILDLY UNDERESTIMATING the safety protocols needed. ie: Full respirators, anti-static shop vacs etc should be standard from those who work with these processes professionally. Please be careful.
@krollmond7544
@krollmond7544 3 күн бұрын
People think Bambu was raising the bar, but all i see is rushed products from Elegoo, Prusa and now this. Hell even Bambu had to do a recall lol. I hope companies seriously take their time with stuff like this, in the meantime hopefully a certain community can learn to shut up...
@nickrudd2568
@nickrudd2568 3 күн бұрын
Honesty IS the only policy at the end of the day. Im always honest about a few different Chinese 3D printer manufactures, If their stuffs a pain, IT SHOULDNT BE! I get so much back lash from the geniuses who claim theirs run faultlessly, "Come set mine up" is my answer to them... They never do. Ive had pros in shops set stuff up thats out of my ability and they go wrong in days, some times minutes. If they put the time into firmware for those not so clued who their advertising hooked in it would help but most never get back to you and they hate you being honest.
@rudolfaeschlimann6959
@rudolfaeschlimann6959 3 күн бұрын
very respectable review, thank you! I wish them all the best with their product none the less
@grokfro
@grokfro 3 күн бұрын
I don't understand the desire to want to see people who have repeatedly demonstrated to you that they are dishonest to succeed. Everything in this story screams that you are being overly generous in your take. We can all hope the idea that hobby grade sls can come to fruition but not by emboldening dishonest people. They may have started out with a noble cause but the result is still leaving a black mark when done like this.
@TinTalon
@TinTalon 3 күн бұрын
Wow. You were in a tough spot, but I believe you might the right call! They are not ready. I get they need money but how many people won’t see this video and know the full truth and back a product the honestly at this point might not come to fruition. I agree the idea and the concept is cool but it’s not ready. I have backed projects before, but never came to because the problems became too hard for the vendor to sort and so we all got burnt because as you know, Kickstarter is a gamble. Hope for the best but don’t expect a refund. Thank you for the honest review and thank you for not withholding your video and letting us know everything about this printer. I will not be backing at this time but will be following the project.
@Tynted
@Tynted 21 сағат бұрын
Micronics made a response to this video showing their side of the story, I'd recommend watching it. I think Scotty was kinda unfair to them TBH
@TinTalon
@TinTalon 16 сағат бұрын
@@Tynted A video response or a comment? Not sure it will change my mind at all but I will watch/read it through. I have been following the project for a while and still think they are rushing it. They need to be not like everyone else and put out a product that isn’t finished and promised to finish it later. it would be nice for once if somebody would do a polished product that was ready for the market and consumers. I understand there will always be outliers.