It kind of confuses me why Gordon of all characters is upset Edward is leaving. If anything, I think Thomas should be the one who is upset. Edward was basically like a father to him in the adventure begins. To see him feel nothing about Edward leaving is questionable.

I wish they kicked thomas and Percy and just move them to Farquhar sheds

Do you know what Forever and Ever reminds me of, Ralph throwing a big fat whiny tantrum after not getting to buy the wheel for the sugar rush arcade game in Ralph Wrecks the Internet!

I don’t understand why Gordon’s Hit Era/Season 13 incarnation is in the Loathsome Characters wiki!

This might just be the worst episode of the entire show in the fact it's so bad I can't even laugh at it Every other episode is just boring or has slight flaws that bring it down but this takes the bloody cake Also, 3:58, Skarloey screams AT THE TOP OF HIS LUNGS for Rusty to get out of the way saying that he can't stop Rusty literally stops on the middle of the line.. like, why?? Everyone's lost their damn minds I swear

Bth i understand gordon here he got a point of just henry going away for no reason ,but edward i understand he had to just be closer to branch but like henry???

I really hate how The Narrow Guage Engines (Besides Sir Handel, (For some reason), Duncan and Fearless Freddie.) acted like they're in Primary Grades in the hit era. Especially Skarloey and Rheneas, when they should be the old wise engines.

This episode could've worked better if it took place between "Thomas breals the rules" and "Dirty Objects"

Forever thankful for thomas wood spencer💯

I agree with you, also, I don't buy that the puppet show is a heavy train

5:26 nope i can actually spot it actually 5 miles away (seriously)

Honestly im happy they never tried to add the miniature engines in the model series I DONT WANNA KNOW WHAT HIT WOULD HAVE MADE THEM

Suggestion: Buffer Bother: The worst Bill and Ben episode

3:14 Not the take-along toy!

In s5, s6, s7, and the HIT era, the Skarloey line also has many different locations that aren’t based on the Talyllyn.

The only 2 episodes from S12 that I fw are James works it out Best Friends I find James works it out a bit hilarious especially in the UK Dub😂😂😂 Bc of Angelis Narration and the way he would yell his lines for James and Percy

Can you please do “Thomas Makes A Mistake” as the worst THOMAS episode?

I totally agree with you 100% that this is Skarloey's worst episode in the whole series. But in defense of the HIT era, there may have been one or two times where Skarloey was actually protrayed in character, like in S9's "The Magic Lamp" where he told the other NG engines the story of Proteus and his magic lamp. And at least Skarloey wasn't a reckless, cheeky idiot in S7's "The Old Bridge", which is one of my favorite classic episodes 👍 🚂

Toby also deserves to have his original model series bell sound back, much larger roles, and go back to his wise and confident self

1:09 Did they say “push”?

Let’s make a deputation on our behalf for the original shoe to continue

2:49 can someone translate this part because I don’t bloody understand anything about Morse code

Skarloey then repents for his sins

Can’t wait for “The Voices: The WORST Duke Episode”

Episode where Sharon really crossed the line with Skarloey big time.

Aye man, just became a viewer on your channel and This series you're doing is very funny and entertaining!! I hope you keep doing more of these!!

might I suggest duncan’s worst episode? the episode episode is trusty rusty, the overall story is fine but the main issue with it is that duncan for some reason goes back to being biased against diesels despite overcoming that prejudice long ago.

1:16 no actually it was the old bridge that started it all.

Why was Season 12 so rushed!? Even as a kid I didn't find this season that good! Except for James' and Emily's 😥

6:27 then just watch heave ho Thomas, James works it out, Gordon takes a shortcut, Percy and the bandstand, and excellent Emily, those episodes are pretty fire.

I still think Skarloey is my favorite character, but god the HiT era fucked him up BADLY!!!

1:33 "Replaced with this wimpy little ass-" Got me rolling on the floor lmao

Great pick. I'm not sure which i find worse "Push Me Pull You" or Skarloey The Brave

I think Thomas’ worst episode is easily Too Loud Thomas. It’s boring, annoying and frustrating cause it involves John Hasler doing the worst singing despite Thomas singing many times before.

1:28 he changed his ways kinda

If I had push me pull you my way I would add Bertram as the main character instead of Skarloey because he hadn't been seen since season 5. You see in this rewrite when he was given the puppet show special by Mr Percival But when all the engines ask him If you would like some help he denies this because he thinks he can do it on his own until when he became a runaway he learns that Getting your friends to help you is better than doing it by yourself. So what do you think of this rewrite do you like it or do you not.

I think Skarloey and Rheneas accidentally takes drugs last night so that why they are stupid childs.....

Old Mc.Pinchy.......had a god.....damn.....plan. XD

This would've been a MUCH better episode had you made one change. Replace Skarloey with Duncan.

Every time I look at this episode or notice it, Skarloey Has the weirdest face in the entire Season

Yeah, HIT Basically Made Emily A Total Karen

Season 12 is absolute dogshit and is by far my least favorite season out of the entire show 😃👍 3:46 they did technically, too hot for Thomas.

OH NO! AN INCOMING RUNAWAY TRAIN! I BETTER STOP! -Rusty's braincells during this episode

For your question regarding rolling stock made to transport ice cream, there are refrigerated boxcars/vans built to carry perishable items like fruit, meat, etc., so ice cream being transported by train isn't really one of those far-fetched ideas the writers from that era came up with. What's strange about ice cream being transported in the Thomas & Friends show is they have ice cream vans shown in episodes before, such as "Too Hot for Thomas". I know the modelers have never made ice cream vans for the narrow gauge engines, but still, they would've use refrigerated vans instead of flatbeds to carry the ice cream.

WE WERE WAITING FOR THIS.

What's the Worst Sir Handel Episode?

Anyone remember when TankEngine JonJon reviewed this?

I thought it was going to be skarloey the brave or wharf and peace

Season 12 could have been a highly impressive and memorable hybrid season. It could have worked. But due to factors like Sharon Miller it never did. And became one of the series’s worsts (I also had the Trackmaster Skarloey’s Puppet Show Special set, completely unaware at the time that the episode was horrible. Or even existed.)

the fact this is the last model series skarloey railway episode is sickening.