Except you can't think it's Stu because Tatum says Stu was with her all night. You know who the killers are so you're find clues that aren't there also.

I do think it was Stu, even if Billy was hiding waiting for Tatum to go into the garage, the killer walks back inside, which is connected to the kitchen which connects to the front hallway and the. The party room, Billy is seen outside of the house. That would mean Billy walked back inside just to walk back outside

Holy Crap! Never Noticed This. Good Eye 👍

The motivation for Billy was stupid. Did he also kill his adulterous father?

Movies aren't perfect. It's hard to tell what was intentional and what was accidental/ silly writing. But the clues here were solid.

One of my Favorite horror movies all of them, this was real cool dude, keep up the good work

Another clue mickey was obsessed with sequels.

I'm sorry but the "clue" that there's a girl on stage wearing a mask that looks similar to a ghost face mask seems like a bit of a stretch to me. The whole point of the scene is that everyone on stage is wearing a mask that looks like a ghostface mask, it just so happens that the one most similar mask, possibly the first one the prop department made, is being one worn by one of the multiple women on stage.

This video made me realize I’ve never watched a murder mystery movie with the intention of trying to figure it out.. I just watch to see what happens and the big reveal 😅 I’m sure this will change the way I watch from here on out! Awesome video!

Someone tried pointing it out in your Scream 2 breakdown, but I think you misunderstood. Your clip of a teacher at the whiteboard with the "Rules for solving a muder mystery", murder is spelled wrong.

billy killed tatum

Just say Blk ppl 😂😂

Very versatile actor

First time I watched this I was a kid and I knew pretty early that Billy was the killer… shaggy surprised me the first time I watched it but I saw it the next time…. Felt kinda dumb that I missed it 😂

I remember when this movie came out in 96... I'm Old 😱

Funny, after this movie every time there is two killers one of them is female.

Puta vídeo demorado, esse cara enrola muito

Hella excited man!

21:41 You keep saying Billy thought he was a villain in a movie. He didn't just think it. He WAS just a movie villain. So... He's right. Why is it when Deadpool breaks the fourth wall, we laugh, but when Billy thinks he's in a movie, we call him crazy?

Dewey 3rd killer theory is so awesome

Its called tact was how i knew the killers that line is a dead giveaway

Which equals more money being spent

Impossible Nancy loomis only have one kill on her name

17:25 doesn't billy kill tatum here? Not stu?

It was stu

They had a party for the whole cast and Roman was the only one not there because he was Ghostface

Is it only me who suspected the new cameraman (Joel) that Gale has of being the killer? Especially the moment when he ditches Randy, Gale and Dewey to go get donuts, and doesn't return until after Randy has been killed. Also, he wears black boots. I guess he was supposed to be a red herring 😅

If we were being realistic... that would have never happened because there is a trip for the garage door 😂 good thing it's just a movie. A month ago out of nowhere I mentioned this to my co worker and my son. For some reason in the back of my mind it was bothering me 😂🤷‍♂️ today I get on here it this came across my for you

Some of these seem legit, but others...I dunno man, they just seem like big stretches to me.

I always thought it was Stu.

That or hear me out Stu convinced her to go down there locked the door so she wouldn’t get out and since Billy wasn’t at the party till it was over kinda tells me he killed her cause if you pay close attention the door is unlocked when Billy opens it but it was locked when Tatum tried it so Stu locked her in and unlocked the door to let billy in the house (Edit: after Tatum is killed by that Ghostface he opens the door and it’s unlocked is what I mean that’s why I think it’s billy

Another point is, Tatum seems convinced its Stu in the costume. Now, as viewers, we know the ghostface costume is worn by a stunt double so we cant see anything. But Tatum is Stu's gf. In-universe, she should have a good idea of Stu's height, mannerisms, posture etc. You can easily recognize someone you intimately know in a crowd even wearing unfamiliar clothes

The bigger myster is which one of them kills who, and who is wearing the costume when

I love the look Billy gives Stu when he starts talking about how to gut someone. Like "Dude shut the fuck up. You'll blow our cover."

I have from day one said it was Stu. 🪓😺🖤💜

I've always thought it was stu because the killer was klumsy compared to the killer at the beginning of the film plus he got the idea from randy in the video store

It was definitely Billy for to me. If you listen, when Tatum throws a bottle at him, he grunts, and it sounds like Billy. Plus, Stu was busy entertaining and running the party as a distraction, and when Billy came to the front door, he smiled at Stu as if to say it was done. Definitely Billy, especially for revenge for Tatum saying things about him. Ghostface is always listening, and punishes slights.

Bc I did NOT see a single person mention this, the ghostface in the bathroom was NOT Billy or Stu, it was just a prankster

I mean he literally IS in a movie

Thank you so much for reviewing these older films! Your clear enjoyment of what you're doing makes the whole video worth warching 😊

Stu killed Tatum Billy was still on his way to the party after he killed and hung Himbry. Billy's "I've done it" look to Stu was about Himbry. That just leaves Stu until Billy got there.

WELL PLAYED

You got that Stu and Ghostface were both clumsy, but you missed the most obvious clue. There are times when Ghostface gets hurt and vocalizes pain. It's Stu's/Matthew Lillard's voice when this happens.

I can't believe this theory is actually true. No way this is it

that is soo interesting its Stu ....because of the old script ~ i always thought it was Stu tho >_<!

GUYS what if Cylia Chan is Victor Sams! Like for real I think it is her. And I totally think Eleanor killed Keith/Danny and Katherine killed Kira.

Billy did it

I think Kira wanted to die she wanted Imogene think she is dead, she wanted to protect her that way

22:41 I would move Eleneaor and Sanel to maybe, Anna to highly suspicous. Anna is avoiding question like she is hiding something protecting someone maybe Lawrence.

17:27 She could be Victor Sams