It should be absolutely mandatory that anyone involved in even the most tangential way, in advising on, or setting economic policy... should have him/herself run a profitable business. I guarantee that Ms. Kelton hasn't operated even a lemonade stand in 4th grade. MMT is utter nonsense, and it makes perfect sense that this woman served as Bernie Sanders' "economic advisor"... holy god, we need some adults on the room.
@PuntedKitten18 күн бұрын
This has aged like milk.
@paulsaragosa37123 күн бұрын
Chill y will y cartoons classic movie 🎬 🎞 🎥 🎦 📽 go to the store and buys some penny candy 🍬 butter scotch candy 🍬 😋 mmmmm good 👍
@paulsaragosa37123 күн бұрын
Im hooked on phonics Ohno batman were in a jam yah tada hahaha bad Colby cheese 🧀 and it's not cho cheese okay 🧀 now play with monopoly or your own big wheels outside
@TheRantingRoosterАй бұрын
But the "intrest" is never created so the debt can never be repaid.
@Rob-fx2dw2 ай бұрын
More misrepresentation by Kelton - Savings in a bank are Not non interest bearing deposits - They are interest bearing deposits. Government bonds may be interest bearing but the interest is paid by those in the economy. Besides that the most wealth do not buy government bonds because as one of the wealthest investors in the U.S. over the past 60 years, Warren Buffett, pointed out they are a bad investment over time and a sure way to losing money. High-grade bonds, he said, can increase the risk of an investment portfolio as inflation eats away at the return.
@Rob-fx2dw2 ай бұрын
More fraudulent representation by Kelton about the deficits that the federal government creates. The reality is deficits are a debt for the private sector to pay for. The idea of government spending $100 and taxing out $90 does not leave $10 in the private sector of the economy. It leaves $10 of money and another debt of $10 to be paid back in the future by the taxpayer because all of the deficits are funded by debt and those debts mature which requires the private sector of the economy to pay them off.
@s.d.crockett4862 ай бұрын
Nevermind inflation:) and if you are lower income and don’t own bonds- you are still in a very bad position.
@Anrirua2 ай бұрын
This one is some onion. MaGic Money Tree Monkeybrain Maths Troll
@annalisavajda2522 ай бұрын
Well there have always been tactics to denounce and deter reporting on the topic so calling Robyn "privileged" is just another one any of the girls that were white and reported rape and were ignored feel "privileged" I doubt it. Ronan Farrow too was stalked and harassed to keep from telling his story but maybe were he not already from a famous family and "privileged" the story would have been suppressed as it was by others before him. Reporting about police failings is awkward too ask anyone that ever wanted to file a complaint against them personally and Tommy Robinson to some extent again white male was disregarded as racist in the UK. People need to change their perceptions of violence generally if they will change them about sexual violence ever. This is the metoo era but it's the MGTOW era too guys want to be openly mysoginstic so maybe there will be more Incel men and more introverted women wanting less to do with them. A woman can go many years without a terrible experience but it only takes one to change her attitude or traumatize her.
@ImNotHereToArgueFacts2 ай бұрын
What a buffoon
@prebenpetersen59823 ай бұрын
Waaaaauw, the economic genius Kelton. She has to pay the whole deficit herself
@rokleskovec44103 ай бұрын
Yes quotas are super. Somehow we must find jobs for blind, disabled,........ and woman. Thank you for making woman permanently unequal.
@goodfriend64283 ай бұрын
Godless Marxism again recast into nothing. Note, a laborer is worthy of his hire. Value is not printable. BLOOD, TEARS, TOIL, and SWEAT. That is Value, EARNED, cemented, planted into God's ever-expanding, ever-growing REALITY. Like Marx, you may have had a glimpse into God and MANKIND’S actual REALITY, but it is terribly warped. One may not reconstruct a dinosaur from its toenail. Nothing meant in disrespect of your personal dignity. However, yours is a philosophy, hardly a science, cosmically unreal. Bernie Sanders' Marxist unreality serves his personal grifting well, but not humanity. That should have been a warning.
@billthompson50933 ай бұрын
Kelton is criminally idiotic pushing this woke stupidity. This policy accelerates stealing peoples money and give it to the powerful.
@zacharylynn14273 ай бұрын
So then why pay taxes at if if printing money to build deficits work? Absurd. Amazing people in the comments buy this garbage.
@johntaylor24473 ай бұрын
This woman is full of shiz
@AS-hv2ux3 ай бұрын
Voltaire in 1729 “PAPER MONEY EVENTUALLY RETURNS TO ITS INTRINSIC VALUE - ZERO”
@johnthornton77633 ай бұрын
Any questons why our currency has been destroyed?
@typeviic14 ай бұрын
You cant have GOP and DEM (establishment neocons/neoliberals) forever wars, conducting coups to overthrow democratically elected governments, bloated military spending, US military bases all over the globe, and never ending billions for Israel without MMT. Thats why we have it, so the GOP/Dem deep state thugs can continue the above.
@jeffwyrwa28234 ай бұрын
Lady, you are delusional!!! You need to get off the air!!!! According to your logic, you should loan me all the money I want and I’ll put it to good use and there will be benefits and I’ll never pay you back, but there will be benefits! Just not for you who loaned me the money. Bullshit!!!!!!!!
@paulginsberg69424 ай бұрын
An apologist who should not be taken seriously.
@LukeDickerson19934 ай бұрын
1:51 "a gov deficit simply means that the gov is spending more dollars into the economy than it is subtracting away, mainly by taxing". The austrian rebuttle is that the money the gov spends in the economy is spent on goods and services, produced by gov workers jobs. The good and services are whats valueable, not the fiat money. The larger the percent of society working for the gov there is, the less goods and services will be produced by the people, for the people, and the more will be produced for the governments programs. Im not an anarchist and i agree some programs are neccessary, companies should be regulated, ect. But for programs to be approved they should pass an approval to raise taxes, instead of lying to the people about what real taxes are by combining them with inflation caused by a debt all governments around the world, will never be able to pay off, even in peacetime. The interest rate on bonds vastly underperforms the rate of growth of the money supply, and will perform worse than hard assets.
@oldreprobate2748Ай бұрын
Agreed, and would suggest that there not be a privileged class who pays little to none back into the overall general welfare. Many of tjem receive tax returns in the over the million dollar range. The economic theory in practice over the past 54 years is Milton Friedmans trickle-down economics, which is flawed in that it relies on the ethics of those who gain the most financially to redistribute the nation's wealth. Hasn't worked out that way in the least, it has only served to consolidate the nation's wealth to the top, where it's retained by some one to three thousand individuals out of our 330 million population. Recommend reading as to why the trickle-down theory was adopted by and put into practice by Ronald Reagan is available on the internet, search for the Lewis Powell Memo. Then search for what's behind Citizens United. And perhaps Congressional insider trading. I think you'll see the connections that have led up to March 2024. The application of commonsense needs be, moving forward.
@ssm594 ай бұрын
Due to people being people the Cantillion Effect will always drive the value of the extra dollars to those closest to the place the money is printed. Dr. Kelton's ideas may work if we are on an island with a completely closed economy. As soon as we have to interact with others who are concerned with the value represented by the currency, deficits matter. That is why over production of currency always collapses a society.
@Anrirua2 ай бұрын
She's as thick as a bucket of rocks..MMT is a walled garden false paradigm. A mental virus. Gold is the cure
@ScottBrown-zz4sk4 ай бұрын
Replace her with a black or Hispanic woman.
@imthinking97604 ай бұрын
She falsely asserts that a central planner can decide better than individuals what is best for the individual, that people who don't own inflation protected assets will receive a benefit from inflated currencies, and that governments are extremely inefficient at using and distributing money. Any government money that is created from government increasing the money supply doesn't create more goods and services, it only reallocates the money to different sources. Interest paid out from the gov't reduces the amount from their budget they can spend on tangible services and increases the amount paid to holders of gov't debt. Overzealous spending by gov't has always ended up sinking a civilization
@hyperrealhank3 ай бұрын
typical right wing / libertarian trash talking point
@Cybertron824Ай бұрын
@@hyperrealhank At least offer a rebuttal.
@sdnalyam4 ай бұрын
Majority of Western governments have very poor money skills. Only Switzerland and especially Singapore have been prudent with taxpayers money.
@larryhenry97244 ай бұрын
I think Dr Felton would do herself some good by going back and rereading the writings of Milton Friedman. She is living in a make belive utopia that does not exist. Intellectuals like her will drive us to the next great depression. She also gave away her political leanings with her example of “green” infrastructure spending by government.
@dockjm13 күн бұрын
Larryhenry... LOVED Milt F. Simple, straightforward, basic logic. Not condescending but hit nail on head every time! Brilliant. You give this woman FAR too much credit suggesting that she RE-read Friedman. There's no way she could possibly have digested his work... AND then come up with this utter nonsense.
@MengerMania4 ай бұрын
MMT consists of intellectual garbage. Those who advocate it base their ideas on two fundamental logic flaws: 1) They do not understand the role of money, which acts as a medium of INDIRECT exchange, and 2) They do not understand the source and measure of value, which exists only as the subjective preferences of individuals. The many other errors in this "theory" do not matter if they do not resolve these two flaws.
@J_D284 ай бұрын
Rubbish. Alfredo Pareto was correct when he said that 80% of the wealth always end up in the top 20%. Always.
@miketracy92564 ай бұрын
Borrowing never leads to good outcomes and our insane 34 trillion-dollar spending and borrowing, which is 30 trillion dollars more than we had just 20 years ago, is the real reason for our high inflation. It is not complicate, and anyone who knows simple economics, knows that the law of supply and demand cannot be broken without negative consequences.
@anthmancuso64294 ай бұрын
These women are wrong.
@anthmancuso64294 ай бұрын
It is not possible to issue debt without increasing interest rates. That hurts everyone.
@erickborling13024 ай бұрын
I am seriously offended that the MMT crowd disappeared in 2020. We are betrayed by those who actually nailed the teachings of Jesus.
@ddhqj20234 ай бұрын
I'm not sure exactly what you mean but I'd be interested in hearing what you've got to say.
@erickborling13024 ай бұрын
Oh boy the "debt" concept is so idiotic. When you play monopoly is the currency issuer in debt? It's a damn mirage! which is nothing but a mirror image of all the money not collected in taxes. Lets get rid of the debt so there's no money in the economy. Might as well just set the welcome mat for whomever wants to invade and conquer America.
@erickborling13024 ай бұрын
Our biggest debt is to the earth. To whom do we owe our lives and hopes?
@jaykay51424 ай бұрын
As long as any new dollars created are equally distributed to each citizen i think it could work. The issue seems to be when the government both creates money AND decides how it's spent. That virtually guarantees corruption at the highest level
@erickborling13024 ай бұрын
But that is how it always is. America offers vastly more public welfare to the rich, and your comment assumes this is "the state of nature."
@ddhqj20234 ай бұрын
Who else is going to decide how the money the government has, is spent? You? Only you? In fact, often the people do 'help' government decide by virtue of our calls and emails to our MP's. When I communicate to my MP that I can't get a job because who will look after my two kids while I work, and then he/she tells the feds this is a problem in their community and then the feds decide that they need to start a new program for $10 a day child care......or when every student you've heard of complains that they can't afford to live AND pay back their student loans and then the feds start providing INTEREST FREE student loans......to a degree that is the people helping government decide how to spend the money they create. Unless that government is a Conservative government who have a history of voting NO on those sorts of programs that aid the people. Like last year, Poilievre voted NO nine times out of 12 on affordable housing bills! www.reddit.com/r/canadahousing/comments/16cmutl/no_current_mp_has_voted_against_affordable/
@user-tk9fe5ot6h5 ай бұрын
Makes about as much sense as 2+2=7
@metalrooves36515 ай бұрын
she is only thinking about how spending helps the economy ! The other side is not addressed here! IF THIS is true,the feds can just WASTE MONEY...NO LIMIT!...the present 'Build bck better"is not free money!,,HOW CAN WE GET ANYTHING FREE!?...and it makes contractors,insurers ,suppliers RICH as there is little competition as theres so much work............the only way we pay for govt waste is through inflation! hurting the poor and making the stockmarket rise as theres plenty of money to steal with high prices......l cant believe there is a simpleton out there getting a salary(large,lm sure) to say this !!
@sgrant395 ай бұрын
She’s a complete idiot. A total Moran. The depth of her stupidity is awesome. She actually things government spending ids efficient and thus, the more you spend the more efficient and the greater benefit. Amazing.
@6brman2245 ай бұрын
Word soup. Lies, damn lies and statistics.
@junkjunk24935 ай бұрын
bullshit dont drink this koolaid dont eat this kookie cookie
@josephloughrey34345 ай бұрын
Anytime you see the "institute for gender and the economy" you should pretty much get you BS detector turned on.
@junkjunk24935 ай бұрын
... right
@Rob-fx2dw2 ай бұрын
Yes. More like the institute for stupidity multiplied.
@Valicroix5 ай бұрын
What she is saying about bonds is only sort of true if only citizens can buy bonds. But that's not true. A lot of bonds are held by foreign countries such as Japan and China. MMT is the Laffer curve of the left and is just as big a load of nonsense. Before you ask, yes I have a degree in economics to go along with the one I have in mathematics.
@sigi96695 ай бұрын
I'm not an economist. I've merely listened to and read a lot of economists on both sides of the MMT debate. To my limited understanding, there appear to be some massive, and obvious, holes in the theory. In your opinion, is there any legitimate merit here by which an economist might take this seriously? Or is it really just a ploy to have governments give even more money to the social class to which many of these (prominent) economists may well belong themselves?
@Valicroix5 ай бұрын
@@sigi9669 That's a very good question. I think that a country, if it was willing to deal with any resulting inflation, could print up money for a one time investment such as fixing crumbling infrastructure. But MMT as an ongoing economic policy I think is just delusional.
@professorbland5 ай бұрын
MMT is best used to understand a floating exchange rate currency, not as a prescription to cure society's ills. It concentrates power in the hands of the government for good or ill.
@timhowell69295 ай бұрын
Power in give and not people is a really bad idea if you’re one of the people. History bears that out clearly.
@redjetsen10025 ай бұрын
Building a lazy corrupt society one brainwash at a time.
@richardhoner78425 ай бұрын
She appears to be making a career out of pushing ideas that most economists think are wrong.
@timhowell69295 ай бұрын
I totally agree. Just mindless Drivel.
@erickborling13024 ай бұрын
THINK HARDER grasshopper. Put every fed chair on the witness stand and they will give Kelton/MMT an unopposed victory. Doubt it? When America needs to finance anything, there is really no obstacle, and the republicans know this but they pretend you're right so they can again manufacture poverty.
@ddhqj20234 ай бұрын
Maybe the point is, that like everything else in the world, as time passes, new understandings begin to take shape. Especially as we can look back and see the results of decisions made in the past. Like remember when Japans economy blew up years ago? Well because they are a country that prints it's own currency, they decided to just run with the deficit ball and they still have a country that is doing well despite having a very high deficit. The reason Greece ran into trouble a few years back was that they don't have their own currency. They are tied to the Euro and didn't have the option of printing money that Japan, the USA, Canada and others have.
@richardhoner78424 ай бұрын
@@ddhqj2023 I don't there is any country that has had its government spend and tax the nation into greater prosperity. Can deficit spending keep a country afloat? Sure. Just like I can pay my bills by increasing my credit card debt. IMHO "printing" currency doesn't increase national wealth.