10 Most Common Weak Hadith

[@AhmadPhilips]

List of the top 10 fabricated or weak hadith. 10. Allah told the angels to destroy a city, because the people were doing bad deeds. The angel says, "oh Allah one of your worshipers is there in that city. He never disobeyed you once." Allah responds, "Flip the town on him" or "start with him because he didn't show his displeasure for those sinners even once." 9. the prophet pbuh said: "Whoever tells the people Ramadan is here first, the hellfire is forbidden from them. 8. Narrations about the age of Khadijah RA when she married the Prophet PBUH. 7. Revelation temporarily stopped early in the Prophet PBUH's prophethood, and the Prophet PBUH would climb a mountain and want to throw himself off. An angel would come to stop him from doing so. 6. A Jewish woman used to throw trash in front of the house of the Prophet PBUH everyday. One day she stopped doing it, and the Prophet checked on her to see how she was. She was sick, and she asked how did you know I was sick, and he responded, "the trash stopped." 5. There was a battle where the Sahabah were trying to get into a fortress. They couldn't and started to use the miswak to brush their teeth, and the inhabitants of the fortress thought, the sahaba were sharpening their teeth to eat them, so they gave up. 4. Ali RA was in a battle fighting one of the mushrikeen. He was able to overpower him and was about to kill him. The mushrik spat in his face, and Ali walked away because it would have been out of personal anger, and not sincerity. So then the mushrik accepted Islam. 3. Omar RA one day laughed then cried. They asked why. He laughed because in the time of jahiliyah I used to make idols out of dates, then when I got hungry one day I ate it. He then explained he cried, because again in the time of jahiliyah he was burying his daughter alive and she was rubbing the dirt out of my beard, then I completely buried her. 2. The differing among my Ummah is a mercy. 1. Seek knowledge even if its in China

[@MonProo]

May Allah bless you for summarising. Allahumma amin

[@mohammedsalimahmed5230]

Jazakallah

[@yusradaniels4152]

Shukran for this. May you blessed, insha-Allah

[@cowdyimammurrahtabari973]

Sharpening teeth with miswak?? 🤔

[@mahnooramin8685]

Number 6 was a part of our Islamic studies curriculum from what I remember (Pakistan)

[@hamzahgoodson9616]

😳😯 What is so dangerous about these ahadith is that they are so believable and they often come from those whom we trust the most. SubhanAllah

[@TheBomshot]

Yeah like the books of Muhaditheen رحم الله تعالى

[@a.n4524]

TheBomshot What does that even mean?

[@shefhenko]

@@TheQuranExplainsItself you might aswell disregard history then. As history is just written records of events....Better yet, disregard your mother as your mother. Because without a shadow of a doubt, the only reason you believe your mother is your mother, is because you were told she is your mother. I.e. it was REPORTED to you from an authentic source that your mother, is your mother. You did not do any DNA testing to prove to yourself she is your mother. So now, I want you to go to this woman, whom you have called mother all your life, and look her in the eyes and tell her, you don't believe she is your mother. Then when she asks why, give her a valid reason for her to do a DNA test to prove she is your biological mother. If she is dead, I'm sorry. But now, you'll have to do some research to find out if she was actually your mother. Let me guess, you're going to collect narrations from people that were around during the time of your birth, and you will listen to their version of events and see if all those reports can confirm to one rational story. Then you can confidently say that your mother is your mother...hmm, this process sounds a lot like hadith science! Btw, NOT ALL HADITH ARE SAHIH. just like how you wouldn't accept a random guy saying you were born on a Sunday, when in reality you may have been born on a Monday. And no hadith scholar ever said hadith is true, hadith science filters out true statements of the prophet into many categories like strong, weak etc. It even distinguishes reporters are liars, or accepted/trustworthy etc etc.

[@shirkisdisgusting2371]

@@TheQuranExplainsItself no, DNA test is not enough. Because for that, you have to trust the doctors who are doing it and take their testimony. So you have to do the test yourself. But even then, you are again, relying on scientists who made this DNA test methodology. So you have to go to the very beginning and verify that DNA tests actually work

[@shirkisdisgusting2371]

@@TheQuranExplainsItself nah nah. Hadiths were preserved in the same way as Quran, transmitted to us in the same method( which you called gossip right now) and by the same people. If you follow one, reject the others, then basically you're following your desires

[@friskypony7436]

Omg... Subhanallah!! The story with the Jewish lady is printed in textbooks even! I've studied it when I went to madrasas! And that Khadija(R) was 40! Nobody even questions that! It's like common knowledge. Never thought that these could be fabricated. Subhanallah. Jazakallahu Khair for opening our eyes!

[@911mossadvanbomberplotaipa8]

Liberalism is symptom, cause is bida, solution is Sunna! in 1680 Uthmanis were at peak but exiled salafis & then sufi bida them divided until they were sick man of europe, infiltrated by tyt to secularism, while Salafis build a sharia nation, Saud in laws are Bani Tamim, in hadith hard on dajjal! Quran 24:55 ties Tawhid to safety! Even today Salafi lands despite flaws are safe, while in sufi and shi'a high grave worship lands get colonized. We must worship Allah alone and learn Manhaj Salaf, to build our din as thats what pillars do! Our 5 pillars are outward symbols that refute the other religions, like in bible Ibrahim and Jesus did Sujud, Israel built a kaba in genesis 28, Isaiah 6 :6 they kissed stones for forgiveness etc. Even in hinduism, the final avatar Khalki is Narashamsa or praiseworhty which translates to Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him and describes him uniquely as born in sanctuary or haram and went above the heavens like miraj and received revelation in a cave like surah Alaq etc. 6 pillars of Iman to guide other Muslim sects! Like Asharis error on Allah's Sifat, all 4 mathhabs and 6 hadith imams were Athari. This also lead to sufis miusing hadith of dreams to pass bad fatwas against Quran 5.3. Ashari errors opened sufi errors in hadith dreams to think they can change and divide the religion away from Quran and Sunnah! & lead to sufi grave worship similar to the shi'a who deny the Sahab or Quran they compiled! 5 pillars of sharia to guide society as physical proof for the liberals! 1. din - atheism built 0 civilizations! Allah made us needy pairs (Quran 36 :36) to show He is 1, ( Quran 112 :1) and not 3 or more. 2. Life - Eat halal and tyyib and do wudu! Ibn Taymiyyah said all deviant groups including karijis have non Muslims behind them, today is no different. cia backed iran in 79 who took in exiled alquida! 3. Mind - Islam is preserved and teaches to verify info. Even Sci-ence method is based on. 4. Family - ppl aren't born Qom Lot, Modesty and nikah are basis of society, we learn Taqwa and modesty in Ramadan! 5. Money - Zakat balances wealth, we don't squander it, Quran 2 :275 etc.

[@crafterianinks7219]

Oi read the given links the 40 age doesn't seem fabricated , it's stronger than other narrations that's what it says

[@helsharidy123]

This is really good. Please make more.

[@ALLAHSHAHAADA]

Hatem Elsharidy please do, it’s very very important for us. DjazakAllahu Khairan both of your!

[@kfgqpctranslations3192]

Especially the incident of the cave. Where the spider built a web and the bird layed a couple of eggs

[@kfgqpctranslations3192]

@Cooper Theodore Yeah nice try phishing. It's obvious you're lying. Fear Allah and stop

[@kfgqpctranslations3192]

@Mathew Sullivan Using multiple accounts huh? classic. Phishing is also classic, what will you do when 2fa is on?

[@albarshafqat7443]

SubhanAllah, I think this was the kicker for me to legitimately start studying my deen. Jazakallah khair brother

[@micoberss5579]

The age of khadija. That one I didn't know

[@ALLAHSHAHAADA]

Micober Ss i know now why some sheikhs are saying that they believed that our mother was 25 years old because there’s different ages

[@kfgqpctranslations3192]

I have another one for you. The incident of the cave. Where the spider built a web and the bird layed a couple of eggs

[@Life-bt9yo]

This is so scary. I've heard all of these used by speakers and scholars in their speeches and we've blindly requoted. I feel sad that half of what i know may be inauthentic. I've learnt it's best to just keep quiet

[@AbdallahEsa]

Weak hadith should not be conflated with the fabrications. The only weak hadith that should be warned against are the very weak ahadith. Hadith da'if (with the exception of very weak hadith) in general according to the muhaddithin can be used for targhib(encouragements) and tarhib(warnings) and fada'il (virtues/merits).

[@TimIsACoach]

yes! not discussing this distinction was a major and dangerous flaw in this video!

[@TheBomshot]

Exactly! he is saying these hadith are weak and fabricated ... Some of these Hadith are in Kitab u Sitah And then these guys will use weak and fabricated Hadith in their Aqeeda. May Allah guide these dudes Amin

[@aninfinitelyvixxedvip6]

But if it´s weak it´s weak and it shoudl be stated. I want to know if it´s false, cuz i don´t want to quote the prophet saw wrongly. I wish there was more of these kind of videoa.

[@mohammadquraishi3924]

Based on my understanding, we should not label weak hadith as fabricated hadith. Allah Subhanahu Wa Talaa knows best. May Allah Subhanahu Wa Talaa guide all of us to the right path! Amin!

[@imransajad8164]

Weak Hadith is not the same as a fabricated Hadith. Fabricated means it’s a definite lie whereas weak suggests that it has some weakness in it but we can’t say for sure that it is not from the prophet. So the danger is you could say the prophet did not say this because it’s weak but there is a possibility that it was from the prophet and so in saying this you have inadvertently attributed a lie to the prophet.

[@DRALI-ig9jz]

8:34 ... I never knew that ... great video guys, I learned so much and from now on I will educate myself more .. it is a shame that I am a Saudi Muslim and I do not know a lot about Hadith ... thank you guys for this video and please keep up the good work may Allah bless you

[@wanderingwonderer5442]

May Allah protect the ummah from MBS.

[@Ahmed-pl2gb]

Akhi where in saudi

[@maryam9996]

I’m so annoyed the KZbin algorithm decided to show me this just now😂 alhamdullilah for this

[@wanderingwonderer5442]

*Summary of the ten weak/fabricated ahadith:* 1. 'Seek knowledge even unto China.' 2. 'Differences in the ummah is a mercy.' 3. Umar (r.a.) in the days of jahiliyyah (pre-Islam). 4. Ali (r.a.) in battle not killing a mushrik after being spat on. 5. Sahabah appearing to 'sharpen' teeth with miswak. 6. Old lady throwing rubbish at the Prophet (s.a.w.). 7. When revelation stopped and the Prophet (s.a.w.) is said to have 'wanted to commit suicide'. 8. Age of Khadijah (r.a.) 9. Hellfire being forbidden to the first person telling others about Ramadan. 10. Pious worshipper being destroyed along with the sinners.

[@abdoulazizdabo9064]

Brother Saajid you’re really doing a great job for this religion. I felt even ashamed on us so call born Muslim but but don’t take action to help this beautiful Deen. May Allah forgive us.

[@juliankelley6253]

May Allah reward you brothers for your efforts. Next, you should do a video explaining why these hadeeth are weak and/or fabricated. Even if it may offend some viewers and may Allah reward you for your detailed honesty. بارك الله فيكم

[@TimIsACoach]

an explanation is drastically needed! there is a huge difference between weak and fabrication in hadith. plus how that is then used in fiqh. and not every scholar would agree with these categorizations either. for example #2 is ranked as hasan by some or attributed to Imam Malik.

[@mohafizgh]

Subhaana Allaah --- Astagfirullaah I wish the program never stopped on the 10 Ahaadith

[@maverick_13]

SubhanAllah... I believed 4 of the 10 fabricated Hadith... Don't stop this series, please make the continuation of this topic. We people of the subcontinent are a huge target of weak Hadith and innovation. (PS: It would be very helpful if InshaAllah you make a video of 10 most widespread innovation.)

[@Kenan_369]

Nr.1 sahih bukhari nr.2 sahih muslim nr.3 official history nr.4 nasa‘s CGI nr.5 The Bible. and so on…

[@BlueEagle0264]

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله. جزاكم الله خيرا. Please, brothers, do more like this video.

[@mewzi]

Especially the incident of the cave. Where the spider built a web and the bird layed a couple of eggs

[@aliaub75]

Subhan Allah. The fact that we know which hadiths are weak or fabricated is proof of the preservation and purity of hadiths. Our duty as muslims is to study and check the authenticity of each hadith before we believe in it.

[@zcs7676]

It would be good if these hadeeth were referenced and you could mention where they are narrated

[@azizeya7807]

Subhanallah I've come across every single one of these hadiths and much more but Alhamdulillah there are sincere brothers and sisters doing a great job exposing this kind of baseless hadiths

[@sufyanalthawri1257]

Very nice video. Knowing the weak/fabricated hadith is very important, would have been better if the brother stated the references from where those week hadith came from.

[@sajjadmehmood2943]

21 Tips To Help Erase Sins - Prophet Muhammed ﷺ 1) Repenting 2) Performing Prayer 3) Performing Wudhu (ablution) 4) Attending the Jumu'ah Salah (Friday Prayer) 5) Waiting for Prayer 6) Doing good deeds 7) Performing Umrah and Hajj 8) Saying ‘Ameen’ after the Imam 9) Calling out Adhaan 10) Walking to the Prayer Place 11) Giving charity 12) Asking forgiveness from others on wronging them 13) Reciting Salawaat (Blessings) on Prophet Muhammad ﷺ 14) Being kind to animals 15) Praising Allah after Eating Food 16) Removing Obstacles from the Road or Way 17) Hide Other’s faults and sins 18) Observing Patience during Hard Times 19) Making some dhikr 20) Saying ‘Subhan-Allah’ 100 times 21) The best duaa for seeking forgiveness is to say : “Allahuma Anta Rabbi, la ilaha illa Anta, khalaqtani wa ana ‘abduka, wa ana ‘ala ‘ahdika wa wa'dika mastata'tu, a'udhu bika min sharri ma sana'tu, abu'u laka bini'matika ‘alayya, wa abu'u laka bidhanbi faghfir li, fa innahu la yaghfirudh-dhunuba illa Anta.” (O Allah! You are my Lord. There is no god except You. You have created, I am Your slave, I hold to Your Covenant as far as I can. I seek refuge in You from the evil of what I have done. I acknowledge the favours that You have bestowed upon me and I confess my sins. Pardon me, for none but You has the power to pardon).

[@sondrameyer2816]

It's important that fiction not been woven in with the truth of Islam and it's teachings. I've heard at least three of these stories from respected Imams. Thank you for your efforts.

[@khadra5217]

Thanks alot brother,May Allah keep us you and reward Jannah 🤲 You really teaching us alot🌹

[@data_analyst7944]

The lies which are attributed To Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.S) in subcontinent i.e India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and srilanka are That Prophet (S.A.W.S) HAS Ilm-e-ghaib and he had no shadow.

[@MuhammadSalman7236]

Very problematic. People here in Pakistan still try to argue that both of these are true.

[@aboutthat1440]

I have heard or read about 5 or 6 of those. The one about Ali RA. I heard It was Umar RA. There are others I found out later that were supposed to be weak. Like The Hadith claiming that the prophet SAW said even if you give me the sun and the moon in my hands I won't stop preaching this message. That I read is weak but the Hadith where the prophet SAW says about catching the rays of the sun isn't considered dais like the sun and moon Hadith. I would like more stuff like this on your channel. Good stuff to learn this way.

[@baseeraslam436]

Barakallahu feek, very beneficial video, looking forward to watching more of these!

[@lujainot5495]

That’s weird because some of those stories i was taught in school in islamic education

[@marlobarksdale2424]

what does that tell you about the state of Islamic education in our era

[@netummah]

Jazakallahu Khair for the interesting video. But please note there is a difference between fabricated hadith (mawdu') and weak (dai'f) hadith. Fabricated hadith is when a narrator in the chain is known to be a fabricator whereas when it comes to weak hadith a narrator in the chain can be known as negligent, an open sinner etc. We don't take fabricated hadith of course, but some scholars have allowed the use and practice of weak hadith as long as it does contradict strong hadith and of course the Quran. I think its wrong to use the words fabricated and weak interchangeably.

[@sherryidibo2304]

Thanks for sharing this.. I was looking for these kind of topic.

[@ahamilton3435]

MashaAllah, may Allah Subhanahuawa'ala continue to guide and protect you, to guide others to learn and gain knowledge from you inshaAllah. Please make dua for the uma inshaAllah

[@haroonical]

Can we have details of the 'Authentic Hadeeth Foundation'? JazaakAllah Khair..

[@SamYuri]

نسأل الله لك الثبات ... Keep up bro

[@maazsayyad5623]

10,6,5,4,3,2,1 Thank you for correcting and informing about all these weak and fabricated hadith. Most of these I've heard from people of tableeghi jamat and they read it from the book "fazail e amal".

[@Glory.Be.To.Allah_swt]

Heard of the ones about Khadijah, the Jewish woman, Ali, Umar, seek knowledge even to China.. but the one popularly used by non Muslims to criticise Islam is the one about the Prophet being suicidal. I’m so glad this is a weak Hadith 😊

[@bahasaarab4046]

It would be nice if he told us WHY these are weak. Instead we are expected to take this knowledge because "you said so"

[@yahya2925]

chains of narration

[@bahasaarab4046]

@@yahya2925 Of course. But I mean it would be nice if he was more specific, because there can be various reasons why a chain is weak. But i understand it's just a "bite size" video for the short attention spans of modern day people

[@yahya2925]

@@bahasaarab4046 Think about it this way. The reason the bible is so corrupted is due to the fact that it was compiled with hadith, sayings and actions/examples. Everyone had input good or bad. That's why hadith is so complicated. The Qur'an was wayyy ahead of it's time to avoid this issue. MashAllah, Allah (SWT) Made the hadith and Qur'an seperate. This is why we Muslims go by the Qur'an first and foremost.

[@Star_of_the_new_moon]

Wow thanks for bringing these up i didn't know many of these to be fabricated or weak

[@moonraker008]

Hi That miswak story is from Tabligee Jamaat.

[@TheBomshot]

There is ijma amongst the Ulima of Ahlul Sunnah wal Jamat that you can use week hadith for Fadhail (virtues) Even ibn Tamiyya says you can use Daeef Hadith for Fadhail

[@TheBomshot]

Also he is saying that some of these are fabricated and then saying theyre week.. Make it clear are they Daeef or Mawdu' ?

[@TheBomshot]

Can you please explain the difference between Daeef and Maudu' Because he seems to have confused the 2 as one in the same... These hadith are actually in famous Muhadith books and have only been refuted by new groups and scholars where as the Salaf have preserved these Hadith and even memorized them. Malik bin Dinar, Imam Ahmed Hambal, Baihaqi, At-Tabarani This is a new thing that you are bringing into the religion. I wrather follow the Mistakes of the Salaf than the corrections of the new groups.

[@kidsmama6908]

Ameen to the Dua.. JazakaAllah for this video.. Its an eye opener.. SubhanAllah

[@Abdul_Ahad_Urban_Revert]

Subhan'Allah imagine how many times we have narrated the fake story about the old.lady throwing dirt on Rasulullah SAW... May Allah forgive us, this makes me really scared of using Ahadith just left right and center.

[@slaveofallah73645443]

Jazakallahukhair, good video. What about the fabricated hadith of the shadateen? For example one popular hadith says when Allah blew life into Adam (as), the first thing Adam saw was the throne of Allah with the shahada written on it "La illah ha illallah wa ashhadu anna Muhammadan rasulillah" - many types of fabricated hadith like these that get passed around cause great fitna.

[@Safiyah-wk2ln]

So can it be even said that khajida ra was even older then the prophet because if the hadiths claiming 25-30+age all have same level of weak authenticity can the statement the prophet married an older women then him be even said Subhanallah

[@MrRaiders209]

SubhanAllah, I hear some of these hadiths brought up by Christians at Hyde Park during their debates w/ the Muslim brothers, and they do a good job refuting them. Alhumdulilah for guidance. May Allah (swt) keep us guided, aameen.

[@stonerosesuk]

Loved the bullet point style presentation.

[@bogarde]

Allah informs us in the Quran about the reliability of the prophets. But Allah does not inform us about the reliability of the Hadith writers. So we can never know whether these writers can be trusted. Therefore I only accept the word of Allah, because only Allah I trust. And Allah guides me through the Quran.

[@no1x830]

I know your hadith begins with Khadijah's(RA) age but what about Ayeesha (RA)? I know outs mostly agreed upon that she was a pree teen when she got married to Prophet (SAW) BUT I red in I think in wikipedia that she was got married to Prophet (SAW) when she was around 16 or 17 narrated by one of her sister!? A comment on that please.......

[@husnaneali2510]

Please do more of these weak & fabricated hadiths. I would like to learn more of these. Is there a website to get a list of weak and fabricated hadiths?

[@look4yourself650]

Brother there are books of this kind, even whole volumes written by scholars - but in Arabic and languages like Urdu and so on. There are some short books translated into english as well, like 500 famous weak Hadith, 200 weak hadith etc. Here is a book about 100 Farbricated Hadith www.kalamullah.com/Books/100%20Fabricated%20Hadith.pdf

[@AbuIbrahim40]

@@look4yourself650 jazak Allah

[@M.Kamraan]

@@look4yourself650Jazakallah brother

[@swatisquantum]

10 - never heard 9 - never heard 8 - yes heard she was in her 40s didnt know it wasn’t true. 7 - never heard it 6 - heard this many times!! 5 - never heard it 4- never heard it 3- never heard it 2- never heard it 1- never heard it

[@amimush4296]

I think you should explain methodology too. How the gradings are done?

[@sukainatoujammeh7697]

May Allah reward you both for this clarification...🙌🏼

[@mohammadamanghauri]

The first one that you’ve discussed is similar to the one I heard from Dr. Israr Ahmed and he was major in the dawah scene here in the Indian subcontinent. I believed it to be true. Thanks again Saajid brother

[@Omar-Asim]

This video is a great service, thank you and may Allah reward you with good. I would like to add one more that is very popular too, and that is "Paradise is under the feet of mothers."

[@realme12824]

That particular wording may not be available in the books currently available to us but the scholars said its meaning is preserved in another hadeeth: الْزَمْ رِجْلَهَا فَثَمَّ الْجَنَّةُ sunnah.com/urn/1328870

[@hollaifyahearme5771]

It is actually a sahih authentic hadith. sunnah.com/nasai/25/20 : It was narrated from Mu'awiyah bin Jahimah As-Sulami, that Jahimah came to the Prophet (ﷺ) and said: "O Messenger of Allah! I want to go out and fight (in Jihad) and I have come to ask your advice." He said: "Do you have a mother?" He said: "Yes." He said: "Then stay with her, for Paradise is beneath her feet." أَخْبَرَنَا عَبْدُ الْوَهَّابِ بْنُ عَبْدِ الْحَكَمِ الْوَرَّاقُ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا حَجَّاجٌ، عَنِ ابْنِ جُرَيْجٍ، قَالَ أَخْبَرَنِي مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ طَلْحَةَ، - وَهُوَ ابْنُ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ عَبْدِ الرَّحْمَنِ - عَنْ أَبِيهِ، طَلْحَةَ عَنْ مُعَاوِيَةَ بْنِ جَاهِمَةَ السُّلَمِيِّ، أَنَّ جَاهِمَةَ، جَاءَ إِلَى النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم فَقَالَ يَا رَسُولَ اللَّهِ أَرَدْتُ أَنْ أَغْزُوَ وَقَدْ جِئْتُ أَسْتَشِيرُكَ ‏.‏ فَقَالَ ‏"‏ هَلْ لَكَ مِنْ أُمٍّ ‏"‏ ‏.‏ قَالَ نَعَمْ ‏.‏ قَالَ ‏"‏ فَالْزَمْهَا فَإِنَّ الْجَنَّةَ تَحْتَ رِجْلَيْهَا ‏"‏ ‏.‏ Grade: Sahih (Darussalam) Reference : Sunan an-Nasa'i 3104 In-book reference : Book 25, Hadith 20 English translation : Vol. 1, Book 25, Hadith 3106 I think the one that is weak mentions that Paradise is AT your mother's feet. And Allaah knows best.

[@Omar-Asim]

@@hollaifyahearme5771 Pay attention to the wording I wrote, "Paradise is under the feet of mothers." this is not Sahih. The Prophet ﷺ was speaking about the companion's mother, not all mothers generally. I got this info from Hadith Disciple. And Allah knows best.

[@umar_mitchell]

Can you please share the reasons these narrations are not authentic? And can you share where it seems these narrations came from? Because some will argue that these Hadith or narrations occur in books and so we have no level of knowledge to speak on them if others greater in knowledge may have been the ones who wrote them.

[@Frankenshein]

These are great for like common misconceptions useful for the youth

[@fahimal9417]

In my school (year 6 or 7), we were taught the age of Khadijah (radiallahu anha) was 40 as a fact by the teacher of the Islamic studies. Also number 6 and number 1. But I never heard or read about the other Hadiths that were mentioned here. Please make more videos on this topic. May Allah Subhanuwatala bless you for sharing your knowledge. Ameen

[@DanishKhan-sh5tl]

We can never extract theology ie Aqueeda from Da'if hadith cause we're really sure whether Prophet Muhammad Pbuh said it not. There are around 35-40 reasons for its non application. Maybe over 40. Guys, read I what imam muslim said about da'if hadith. See Sahih Muslim and read its intro as well as its first chapter. I'm not being extreme but it's correct to stick to Quran and only the Authentic hadiths. Cause the risk of otherwise is not worth. Imam Bukhari, Imam Muslim, Imam Tirmidhi, Abu Dawud, AL-Nasa, Ibn Majah with great caliber work so strict for authenticity. Can we outdo them.

[@MrSongib]

So what is the reason then we still use some of the Weak Hadith and Why we recorded it and why did some Ulama still use it?

[@M.Kamraan]

The reason is mostly because they blind follow their teachers and elders, without establishing if what they were taught is factual

[@Zati.N.]

The beginning is so funny!

[@thesyriantriozat6135]

i've heard 5 of those ahadith, subana allah. this is an extremely important topic to bring to Muslims' attention. thanks alot

[@bibipat1405]

There is difference between "weak hadith and lies".

[@ocerco93]

What about fabricated ''authentic" hadith ? they are the ones we need to adress the most, weak hadith its directly in the bin ! there's a lot of hadith generally that we not sure its from the prophet, or fabricated

[@forgetfulstranger]

Authentic is authentic, it's true and corroborated by many reports of the hadith. As far as I understand.

[@HenryTownsmyth]

May Allah reward you brother but first 6 minutes could be removed or made shorter for keeping the video to the point and short. And about the age of Khadija RA, Sheikh Yasir Qadhi did mention that there are some evidences suggesting she was 28 or older but not younger. The evidence is from historic events happening around Prophet Mohammad pbuh and more. Please refer to this video kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y3bbc4SFbNh0jbs So this brother saying that we have no idea about her age is probably not entirely correct. This creates a problem for me to entirely dismiss some of these so-called "weak narrations" because some evidence might be there but brother is completely dismissing them.

[@strivinglad8749]

15:35 that's my fav hadith! Smh! Jazakallahu khair fr making me aware

[@far8]

11. 9 out of 10 rizq (sustenance) comes from business is also dhaif 12. another hadith about rizq. “Four things that stop the Rizq (sustenance): sleeping in the morning”: it was narrated from ‘Uthman ibn ‘Affan (may Allah be pleased with him) from the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) that he said: “Sleeping in the morning prevents some provision.” This was narrated by Abu Na’eem in al-Hilyah, 9/251, but it is a very weak hadeeth. See: al-Silsilah al-Da’eefah by al-Shaykh al-Albani (may Allah have mercy on him), 3019. And it was narrated with the words: “Do not sleep and miss seeking your provision between Fajr (early morning) prayer and sunrise.” This is also very weak. See al-Da’eefah, 6991. With regard to the phrase “Four things increase provision,” in which regular charity is included: something similar was narrated by al-Daylami in Musnad al-Firdaws (1/47), with the wording: “Seek help with provision by means of charity.” But this is a da’eef hadeeth. See: Da’eef al-Jami’, 818, by al-Shaykh al-Albani.

[@omarfutbol6320]

Great vid as always brother

[@ifzalahmed]

Asalaam alaikum. Which scholars have graded these hadith? Whose aqeedah are you following? Also weak hadith does not negate them it only adds to the deen... Just because it's weak does not mean its thrown away or disregarded.

[@theresonlyonegodalwadood8285]

Masha allah may Allah reward you I didn't know some of this hadith was fabricated

[@TheBomshot]

They didn't even point out which ones are fabricated in which ones are week cuz a lot of them are only week and they can still be used and they were used by the early Generations

[@TheBomshot]

Whoever this guy is is trying to say that some of the weak ones are actually fabricated when in fact they're not

[@margoalam1545]

Now I understand that proper education is needed to understand the real islam. Nowadays all the youtube video's are for entertainment. I won't listen to those KZbin Imams anymore but look for reliable sources.

[@faizalikudus4113]

Ustaz saajid the way you pronounce Subhan Allah is so beautiful and soothing,I pray to Allah SWT that one day you'll be standing giving dakwah like the late Ahmed deedat and Dr zakir Naik InsyaAllah..

[@bloggerblogger3780]

The "weak" hadith number 7 regarding the Prophet S.A.W. attempting to commit suicide and being stopped by Jibreel, spoken about from around 9:00 can be found in Sahih al-Bukhari volume 9 Hadith 111. www.alim.org/library/hadith/SHB/111/9 The story can also be found in many books of Seerah including At-Tabari and Ibn Ishaq. What is the evidence that this hadith is weak, and was Imam Bukhari wrong for including this Hadith in his Sahih?

[@sikandar08]

If i'm in a lecture that quotes one of these for example, what would be a recommended course of action? I assume to tell the speaker after the talk?

[@Onemessagefoundationismyfav]

How about we Publish a book on fabricated and week Hadith? And list them all with explanation! InshaAllah Please go ahead with GOFUNDME.

[@look4yourself650]

Brother there are already books of this kind, even whole volumes written by scholars - but in Arabic and languages like Urdu and so on. There are some short books translated into english as well, like 500 famous weak Hadith, 200 weak hadith etc. Here is a book about 100 Farbricated Hadith www.kalamullah.com/Books/100%20Fabricated%20Hadith.pdf

[@Onemessagefoundationismyfav]

Look4 Yourself - JazakAllah Brother! I had no idea that it existed.

[@look4yourself650]

@@Onemessagefoundationismyfav Wa iyyak brother, may Allah bless you.

[@rajababy2009]

@@Onemessagefoundationismyfav The Hadith Wroters Like Imam Bukhari , imam Muslim they all work on those hadith and make them listed as Strong , very Strong , Weak and fabricated .... Later on many Scholars work on it ...and Scrutinize the hadith on the basis of their Knowledge and in 21st century the famouse name is Sheikh Albani and He wrote books about Authentic and weak ahdith .... So it requires study which these brothers did in Madina University

[@arabiclive007]

Mashallah I have heard all of these hadiths I used to think these hadiths were authentic. Keep up the good work

[@khidrrr]

Me, to all 'ahadith' after No. 5: *SHOOKETH*

[@usamahphilips8897]

Jazaakallahu khayran, I didn't know about 10, 8, 6, and 4 being fabricated.

[@AhmadPhilips]

I didn't know about 10, 8, 7, 6, 4, and 1 being fabricated. That's a lot! haha

[@MixtureGuy]

Summary of "10 Most Common Weak Hadith": 10. The supposed hadīth where Allāh tells the angles to destroy a city and, they, the angels, state that a worshiper lives there. Then, Allāh commands to begin the destruction with him. (6:00). 09. "Whoever tells other people that Ramadan is here first, then hellfire is forbidden for him." (Fabricated hadith.) (7:15). 08. No authentic narrations state the age of Khadīja (ra) to be forty (40) at the time of her marriage to the Prophet (saws); different ages-25, 28, 35, 40, and others-are all mentioned. (7:42). 07. The story about the Prophet (saws) trying to throw himself off a cliff after revelation stopped for a brief period and an angel telling him not to do so. (8:50). 06. The story about the Jewish individual who would throw trash at the Prophet's (saws) doorstep and could not one day due to falling ill. The Prophet (saws) visited the individual and seeing the Prophet's (saws) character, the individual accepted Islam. (Fabricated story.) (9:55). 05. The story where the companions could not penetrate an enemy fortress; hence, they remained outside and began using the miswak. Misunderstanding the companions' action, the fortress dwellers thought the companions would eat them; hence, they let them in. (Fabricated story.) (10:57). 04. The story where Ali (ra) was about to kill a man, and the man spat on Ali's (ra) face, which caused him (ra) to walk away because he did not want to kill out of anger rather than sincerity. (12:28). 03. The story about Umar (ra) burying his daughter(s) alive before Islam. (Fabricated story.) (15:07). 02. "The differing among my ummah is a mercy." (Fabricated hadith.) (16:22). 01. "Seek Knowledge even if you have to go as far as China." (Fabricated hadith.) (17:43).

[@cookiedough9832]

Subhan Allah very informative brothers. Jazak Allah hu khair!!

[@fidelcatsro6948]

Marvellous episode!

[@yassinbana9427]

السلام عليكم “Everything has a heart, and the heart of the Qur’aan is Ya-Seen; whoever reads it, it is as if he has read the Qur’aan ten times.” This is a weak Hadith!

[@dudeawasome2818]

Masha allah may Allah reward you BROTHER I didn't know some of this hadith was fabricated

[@Diamondraw4Real]

10, 9 I never heard at all. 8 is surprising though :( But this proves that we don't know for sure how old many ppl in those days were. Even Aisha RA said, she was 9 or 10 when she consummated her marriage, according to the hadiths. But some ppl mention that Asma, RA, was 10 yrs older than Aisha, RA, where do they get that? No 4, I've never heard that one either. I guess, don't take hadiths from just anybody online best lesson learned. This type of DEBUNKING video is very important! Thank you so much.

[@Muwaaaahid]

We should take note that the majority of ahadith today which are extremely weak (da'eef jiddan) or fabricated (mawdoo') seem to share a common theme which is to nurture a defeatist mentality into the hearts and minds of ignorant Muslims and to establish the false notion that cowardice, fear & weakness are signs of patience, humbleness and taqwa when in reality, this could not be any further from the truth. How can anyone believe that the Sahaba would allow the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) to be oppressed by a Jewish neighbour continuously without any consequence ?.. How can anyone believe that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) would tiptoe around whilst crouched forward with his hands behind his back, starring at the ground, apparently to show 'humbleness' when 'Ali (radiAllahu anhu) narrated that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) would lean forward as if going down a decline when he walked, meaning that prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) would walk in a courages manner whilst pushing his feet hard into the Earth in a powerful manner. How can anyone believe that the Muslim sitting in the comfort of his own home, performing 'Jihad Al-Nafs' by avoiding eye contact with the news lady on TV be greater and more beloved to Allah than the Muslim who has left his wealth and family behind in order to defend and assist the oppressed Muslims via Jihad fisabilillah ? How can anyone truly believe that in all the battles, the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) would only use his sword to block any strikes but would never actually strike or kill anyone himself, despite the Sahaba narrating: "When the battle grew fierce. By Allah, we would seek protection by his side, and the bravest among us was he who confronted the onslaught and it was the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ)." [Sahih Muslim 1776] The fabricated concept of 'turn the other cheek' does not exist in Islam yet has sadly found its way into the hearts of many Muslims and sadly even our jum'uah khutbas. This humiliating defeated mentality will sadly continue to grow and spread if the Mashaykh do not take action and begin teaching the Muslim's about the status & honour which Islam gives to a person, about what al wala wal bara actually means, its importance and how it should be implemented etc. "Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah ; and those with him are forceful/severe against the disbelievers, merciful among themselves." [Surat Al-Fath 48:29]

[@mfrmfr05]

Thanks for clearing doubts about hadis.Please give us more of this.

[@faizanali383]

Some of these unauthentic Ahadeeth were included in our Islamic Studies course in high school. It is almost shocking to learn that these are unauthentic.

[@Theonewhodanceswithwolves]

Please post the chapters of the hadiths and well, then explain why these hadiths are comsidered to be so weak.

[@MohOz]

brother we need two levels up - Is it fabricated, weak etc and what makes its weak with some backing of scholars of Hadith like Albani. Excellent video. Jazak Allah khair. we need part 2.

[@deadsmile2011]

Since the isnad theory adopted by Imam Bukhari and other hadith imams has failed in the censorship of hadith, it is a great task for us to re-filter the authentic hadiths, using the Quranic balance.

[@taibjaulim1]

Assalamualaikum brother. I have a questions about gusul is confusing me a bit. Allah knows my intentions. Allah taught us how to make gusul in the Quran " if you're in a state of janaba, take a bath." Plain and simple. I love that. I'm sure i read how our prophet did gusul was known through a well known Shahaba asked our mother Aisha and other wife as well,How our prophet pbuh performs gusul, i know the details and I'm sure you too knows. My questions is why the Shahaba didn't ask our prophet directly that would more appropriate, and respectful. instead he goes to Muhammad pbuh wife for a delicate question like that . That is bothering me a lot I'm not of those who reject hadith but i don't follow it blindly either.that's why i seek clarification. Now I'm thinking maybe the shahaba asked her because after Muhammad pbuh pass away, but it doesn't make sense because how the shahaba who report that hadith was performing gusul while our prophet was alive and among them. Please brother i you could answer my question I'll really appreciate. Peace be with you.

[@look4yourself650]

Walaikum assalam brother, You actually made curious statement: "'Im not of those who reject hadith but i don't follow it blindly either". As far as I know, accepting or rejecting a Hadith has primarily nothing to do with the content of the Hadith, but with the chain of narration. If the chain of narration is sound, then the matn (content) is looked at according to the Usool laid down by the Muhadditheen, extrapolated from the Quran and the Sunnah. Just picking and choosing based on whatever feels right or not is not something one cannot utilize, since feelings and intellect vary from one person to another. (Maybe see: islamqa.info/en/answers/604/justification-for-following-the-sunnah and islamqa.info/en/answers/115125/ruling-on-one-who-rejects-a-saheeh-hadith) And the Hadith you are talking about are in Sahih Bukhari and Muslim, narrated from Aisha radiallahu anha and Maimuna radiallahu anha, wives of the Prophets ﷺ, which are authentic by consensus of the Muslim Ummah. Generally, I do not think that you should bother with questions, such as why did they not ask the Prophet ﷺ directly and so on, since: 1) You do not know whether they asked him directly or not. Actually, there is evidence that some of the Sahaba asked him ﷺ directly as well (see point 3). 2) It should not make a difference, since there is no shyness in getting knowledge, as Aisha radiallahu anha stated: The best of the women are the women of the Ansar. Shyness would not prevent them from inquiring about religion and from acquiring deep understanding in it. (Abu Dawud 316, also see Muslim 322) 3) An Ansari woman asked the Prophet (ﷺ) how to take a bath after finishing from the menses. He replied, "Take a piece a cloth perfumed with musk and clean the private parts with it thrice." The Prophet (ﷺ) felt shy and turned his face. So I pulled her to me and told her what the Prophet (ﷺ) meant. (Bukhari 315) Other narrations have that the Ansari woman asked how to clean herself with the cloth, so the Prophet (ﷺ) observed: "Praise be to Allah, she should cleanse herself." and he felt shy to go into details. Then Aisha pulled her to herself and told her to remove the traces of blood with it. In the same narration she asked him about the ghusl after sexual intercourse. The Hadith states: She then further asked about bathing after sexual intercourse. He (the Prophet ﷺ) said: She should take water and cleanse herself well or complete the ablution and then (pour water) on her head and rub it till it reaches the roots of the hair (of her) head and then pour water on her. On that 'A'isha said: How good are the women of Ansar (helpers) that their shyness does not prevent them from learning religion. (Muslim 332) So the Prophet ﷺ told the Sahabia how to perform Ghusl himself, but you notice how shy the Prophet was. That is nothing curious, since he ﷺ said: Faith (Belief) consists of more than sixty branches. And Haya (shyness, bashfulness etc.) is a part of faith. (Bukhari 9) And the male Sahabas knew full well that the Prophet ﷺ had this much shyness. Also, sometimes the Sahabas would get shy asking about a specific matter as well, as can be seen in various Hadith. 4) There is nothing wrong with someone with less knowledge asking someone with more knowledge about something, especially of that someone is at the position of your mother(!) and has the best knowledge about something - since the person has seen the process with their own two eyes or knows about it better than others, because the Prophet ﷺ could talk freely to her about it without feeling too shy. Abu Musa al-Ash'ari narrates: There cropped up a difference of opinion between a group of Muhajirs and the Ansar...I got up (and went) to 'A'isha and sought her permission and it was granted, and I said to her: 0 Mother, or Mother of the Faithful, I want to ask you about a matter on which I feel shy. She said: Don't feel shy of asking me about a thing which you can ask your mother, who gave you birth, for I am too your mother. Upon this I said: What makes a bath obligatory for a person? And she replied...(see Sahih Muslim 349) Scholars mention one of the benefits of the Prophet marrying Aisha radiallahu anha at a young age or having many wives is, that much needed information that is normally related just between the two spouses in the house could be disseminated through them being many, and living a long life. So a core part of a Muslims life - the married life and rulings and Sunnan regarding it - could be related to the Muslims. And having a false notion of shyness and what is appropriate or not, could lead to many problems, for example what happens in many countries in which people think it is too inapproriate to ask about matter concerning married life and so they commit major sins in Islam, only because they were to shy to ask whether this was permissible or not! Finally it was a duty upon the wives of the Prophet ﷺ to disseminate such information to the people, as Allah told them to remember whatever of the Quran and the Sunnah was mentioned in their houses: And remember what is recited in your houses of the verses of Allah and wisdom. Indeed, Allah is ever Subtle and Acquainted [with all things]. (33:34) I hope that this answers your question, and be peace and blessings upon the Prophet ﷺ, his household, his companions and whoever follows them in good. Assalamu Alaikum wa rahmatullah.

[@pedrosanchez455]

There is also a fabricated hadith, which I heard in a khutba once, in which the imam said:' the fasting of Ramadan will stay between the heaven and earth until Zakaat al-Fitr has been given.' This is fabricated.

[@dilxaz820]

The ages of khadija our mother may Allah be pleased with her as I learned and studied from Islamic books she was about 40 years old also she had been married couple of times before marrying our prophet pbuh ... however jazakh Allah khair my brother sajaj may Allah grant you jannah

[@AQDCKSA]

Jazakallahu khairan. Perhaps you can continue this series. There are Islamic Studies curriculums using weak hadeeth! Please ask about the story of the spider and the web and the dove and nest that were suddenly built to cover the Prophet salallahu alaihi wa sallam and Abu Bakr radhiallahu anhun in the cave.

[@muaadhibnjabal7956]

Best way to understand is she was older than Rasul-Allah PBUH in age, to show nothing wrong with marrying a women older than you.

[@fire.smok3]

This is a very educational video, thank you

[@abdelmadjidn9466]

القصة التي رواها أن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم كان يريد الانتحار أصلا ليس بحديث إنما ذكرها البخاري في صحيحه من زيادة الزهري و ليست حديث ضعيف كما قال الأخ الفاضل

[@slickperspective]

Another weak hadith that a lot of Asian Muslims use is, it is said Prophet Muhammad (salallahu alaihi wasssalam) said _"Seek more knowledge until China"._ Travel agents often use this too.

[@omaralyafai2368]

I never thought the prophet pbuh said that difference of opinion is a mercy. The only time I have every heard such a statement was when the abbasid caliph came to imam malik (rh) and stated he wanted his madhab to be the legislated madhab of the caliphate then imam malik refused and said difference of opinion is a mercy. That's the only time I ever heard that.

[@MsJuweyria]

The Jewish person with trash, the lone pious man in the destroyed city, Omar RA burying his daughter, and Khedija RA’s age are the ones I have heard so many times subhanAllah. I have also heard some bring some weak ahadith and they say ‘I know this Hadith is weak but we are just taking the message’ or something to that effect- is that ever ok ?

[@MichiPurrs]

Jazakhumullahu khairun SubhanAllah :) So enlightening