1938 AppleScotch Pie Recipe - Old Cookbook Show

1938 AppleScotch Pie Recipe - Old Cookbook Show
Pastry - • How To Make And Roll L... OR: • Butter Pie Crust Dough...
Filling
4 Tbsp Town Crier flour
1 ½ cups brown sugar
6-8 apples
1 cup water
2 tsp vinegar
1/8 tsp salt
2 Tbsp butter
1 tsp vanilla
Method:
Peel core and slice apples. Mix ¾ cup of the sugar, the water, and the vinegar and bring to a boil. Simmer apples in the syrup until tender. Remove apples and cool. Mix remaining sugar, flour and salt. Blend with syrup and cook until it thickens. Add butter and vanilla. Cool.
Fill a lined pastry pan with the cooled apples. Pour in applescotch mixture which has cooled. Make a lattice top for the pie and bake in a hot 425ºF oven for about 30 minutes.
We no longer do sponsorships or paid promotions of any kind; we tried it a couple of times but it never felt right. So if you want to support us, please subscribe, watch, comment and like the videos; maybe even go a step farther and recommend them to your friends and family. This channel is nothing without you our viewers! Thanks for watching the Old Cookbook Show and our Historical Cooking.
#LeGourmetTV #GlenAndFriendsCooking
Check out our Aviation and Flying Channel: / glenshangar
If you want to send cookbooks:
Glen Powell
PO BOX 99900 RE 551 379
RPO HARWOOD PLACE
AJAX
ON
Canada
L1S 0E9

[@anna9072]

When my mom was cutting up apples for a pie, she’d cut them into a pie pan, so she could easily see when she had enough for the pie. They’ll cook down, so you want to have it heaped.

[@lynnewarren8404]

What a great strategy!! Will adopt forthwith!! Thanks so much for sharing your mom’s smartness!!

[@srice6231]

Great idea!

[@susanmacdonald4288]

Simple, and great, idea!

[@tigersfan14]

Why I love this little corner of KZbin. Good suggestion comments followed by supportive replies. Rare these days.

[@themiltonguy4530]

Um Genius Level! I will do this!

[@amandahodgin9316]

Be fearless! In other words, the pie dough can sense your fear 😂!

[@gilanagelman]

Chef John fan, too?😊

[@Jaeler9]

Most food can. Oddly I don’t have a problem with pie dough. My kryptonite is cookies (mildly frustrating) and rice crispy treats (evil things), I cannot do them if I feel even slightly insecure. If I do they come out like teeth breaking hockey pucks. But give me something stupidly complex to do and I breeze through it. Point is food can most definitely smell fear. More likely your nerves work on you and you become self fulfilling prophecy but it’s not as interesting to say it that way. My advice, put on your favorite music, take a deep breath and dance in your kitchen when you start feeling stressed (before and during) by a recipe or a dish. Hard to stay stressed during dancing, even if it’s just little dancing in place that no one will see.

[@Owell85]

​@@Jaeler9I agree. Have good energy and hope for the best. 👍

[@Lumberperson]

⁠@@Jaeler9Even when I’m without fear, I have yet to make a 100% butter pie crust without it getting soggy. I can make a crust just fine with margarine, yet I can’t with butter. I won’t give up though. I think I used too much butter. And probably doesn’t help that I was using a glass dish, and a tabletop oven instead of a full sized oven 😂. I will prevail! Also, a little tip for cookies is when in doubt, add a few extra tablespoons of room temperature butter. More fat fixes everything! Except pie crust…

[@jaredmayes989]

@@gilanagelman We never let the food win

[@loriki8766]

When I make apple pies, I get a mix of apples from the farmer's market. Different apples mixed make the best pies.

[@anthonydolio8118]

Apple + butter scotch + butter pie crust = a slice of heaven. Thanks.

[@Ammoniummetavanadate]

Vanilla ice cream is a must with this. Super easy recipe, looks great

[@bierbrauer11]

I prefer a nice thick wedge of sharp cheddar! Dairy FTW

[@Stephy2185]

Yes!! Hands down my fave dessert. Apple pie and vanilla ice cream

[@adelechicken6356]

​@@bierbrauer11My mom liked hers that way, too. If a piece of pie was left after supper, we all knew not to touch it, it was mom's for right after breakfast with the cheese and an extra cup of coffee. I think this pie might be too sweet for the cheese to work it's magic? 😊

[@jessicacompton275]

I've never been so anxious for Glen to get to the finished product. This looks soooo good!

[@norahodge8825]

I agree. I think I gained 10 pounds just watching this video!

[@thelegion_within]

yep. I was waiting to see if he'd do the "I like this" reaction ;)

[@ubombogirl]

oh my wow!!! when you poured that scotch mixture over those apples...and then the finished pie...wow

[@rachelsiler7610]

My grandmother made this pie! This episode certainly brought back memories. I hope you enjoyed your time in Oshkosh for the airshow. I live about 4 blocks from the airport and it gets pretty noisy - especially when the jets are in the air.

[@heatherlowry731]

I made this pie for my family and we loved it. I just wanted to say thank you for the pie crust recipe though most. I am an experienced cook, but pie crusts have always been a bit dicey for me. Yours worked like a treat. It behaved perfectly and gave me no trouble and then it held its crispness for entire length of the pie's life--which admittedly wasn't long. The only thing I would do differently though is make sure that a tart apple like a Granny Smith or Arkansas Black is in the mix for some tartness. Loved it though. Thanks so much.

[@danapatilloytf2024]

I've been making butterscotch apple pie for about 15yrs. I make a caramel sauce pour it over my seasoned apples. I use two frozen pie crusts. I add 3tbsp of flour to my apples along with nutmeg all spice cinnamon vanilla and butter. I actually made two within the last week my family loves my pie

[@phyllisreinking4208]

That is a gorgeous pie! Much more appealing than something with a “perfect” lattice top.

[@pippin8541]

I finally got around to making this pie last weekend. I pulled it out of the oven mere minutes before we headed out for a Dungeons and Dragons session. The smell in the car was divine, and when I sliced it up during the game it vanished in a flash. As suggested, I upped the salt in the filling; ended up going to 1/2 tsp, and adding a half tsp of cinnamon, too, since making an apple pie without just didn't feel right. Thanks so much for sharing this recipe!

[@margarethutchens5463]

That looks so good. My favorite baking apple is the Jonathon but I haven't seen them in stores for a few years. I like them precisely because the are smaller and so are my hands!

[@BC25citizen]

Seven caramel apples baked in a pie 🎶 My oh my. 😋

[@loriki8766]

Glen: "...The crust is easy to roll out..." Also Glen: *Puts all his weight on the rolling pin while rolling out the crust*

[@zonacrs]

It looks perfect as is. That being said, I would be so tempted to add a shot or two of whisky and a pinch of cinnamon to the butterscotch mixture. Or apple schnapps instead of the whisky. Only one way to find out!

[@kjmwired]

Looking forward to trying this very interesting apple pie. 😊 BTW, I doubt that most folks who originally used this recipe book were using a ruler for the lattice strips. Plus I don't think I'm alone to say I love when food looks rustic & homemade. Thanks Glen. ❤😛🏖Kj in Tampa Bay 🥧

[@kjmwired]

Also, what to add that your pie was absolutely wonderful looking ❣️🤩

[@applegal3058]

Exactly, some of the best foods are rustic and made by people who just want a good wholesome meal, not a perfect-looking meal.

[@annabaker3911]

I am trying to decide to make this today. The only problem is not having the ice cream to go with it. Enjoy watching you on a continuous basis.

[@Kristie_H]

Thank you for not being “that kind of person”, it’s why I enjoy watching your videos!

[@melissahoward1019]

Looks amazing! I think I might try it without the crust as an ice cream topping. Or waffle topping. Or...

[@janabanana3396]

I cannot think of a more fantastic twist on an old favorite!

[@rabidsamfan]

I want to try this one! Might have to wait till I have someone to share it with though!

[@Rachel-rv8db]

That looks... I'm trying not to be hyperbolic and say "fantastic," but that's the only word I can think of. I really love that thickened butterscotch sauce. That puts to rest many of my fears about making a pie and having it be runny. I love this! I love to bake, but am not at all a pie maker. But I definitely want to try this. Thanks, too, Glen for always teaching us to be fearless.

[@tobysmith3351]

I've made this a couple of times now (not as pie, but as a crisp). Added more cinnamon. Now this is one of my side of fridge recipes! Thanks

[@palaceofwisdom9448]

I made butterscotch pecan ice cream just yesterday, and it would go perfectly on top of this! And as someone who recently took up baking, I can vouch that making a pie crust is very intimidating at first but gets easier each time.

[@kristalcuthill1338]

How in the world do you ever choose which recipes to try in all of these books? They must be so full of treasures!

[@kellybidwell8613]

Thank you for sharing this wonderful recipe! My dad and I used to bake on Saturday's, he taught me how to cook and bake. This brought back a lot of memories. Thank you so much 😊

[@vilee5237]

I love how you use the SWAG method (Scientific Wild A** Guess)for your brown sugar and apples, lol! That's how us old timers do it. We rarely measure anything 😊

[@renaebettenhausen3611]

Recipe book was published the year before the last time Los Angeles got hit by a tropical storm, 84 years ago

[@anthonymccarthy4164]

As a pie maker, I want people to think it's hard to make pie pastry. That's half the fun of making pies.

[@jennacomberbach9982]

If you want them straight, a quilting ruler and a knife are east to use and easy to clean.

[@itzel1735]

Or the edge of a cookie sheet and a knife or pizza wheel to get the straight line and just eyeball the width.

[@MeMe-Moi]

Ok, adding this to my list.

[@mcmd2009]

I definitely want to try making this pie. 😋

[@sbrian123]

The vinegar in the syrup you cooked the apples in might have acted on the pectin hand helped them keep their shape.

[@user-iy1yy6pl5x]

Good show as always thank you kindly. Glen it's amazing all the pounds I put on watch ing your wonderful thank you again.

[@tetchedistress]

I'm excited to try this one, butterscotch is one of my favorite flavors. Oh my goodness! Thank You!

[@gilanagelman]

Banbury Tarts! I remember those from a poem my father used to read me from a book called A Children’s Treasury. I’ve found over the years bits of info on their history, though have never seen them in a cookbook. Please consider making them!

[@virginiaf.5764]

They're like the original pop tarts, and pretty easy to make,

[@JHaven-lg7lj]

Oh my gosh, that sauce looks *amazing*

[@sandragoodman9380]

Gosh, that looks easy enough, and yummy enough, that I'll actually make it!

[@HomeTownMama]

I made this pie for American Thanksgiving and it was a huge hit! Thank you for sharing.

[@OptimusWombat]

I'm sure you could add Scotch if you really wanted to though.

[@BartFlossom]

Thank you, thank you, Thank you. I can't wait to try this for hand pies (a.k.a. empanada). I've been looking for a way to thicken the juice without the apples cooking down to mush.

[@MeMe-Moi]

My grandmother and her friends used flour, cornstarch, or Minute tapioca in pie fillings to thicken them. A 9 inch pie usually had 2-3 Tbsp of flour, 1-2 Tbsp of cornstarch, or Minute tapioca according to the package directions. The thickener was mixed with the sugar and fruit and left to stand to draw out the juices (mixing occasionally) before either being cooked on the stove before baking or being put directly into a pie crust and baked

[@karenmalmgren3238]

Made this last week. Husband loved it. Will add a little bit of apple pie spice next time I make it. I used pre-made pie crusts. Used a pastry tip to cut out wholes of the top crust then place on top instead of making a lace crust. I also used apple vinegar in recipe.

[@laurajohnson2674]

Okso i tried this recipe. I used empire apples. Maybe they are too juicy for pie because the sauce turned into soup. Even after overnight in the fridge i still have apple pie in sweet brown soup. That said, it still tastes good. Pie is, after all, a major food group. I do miss the spices but thats just my preference. Love your channel Glen and Jules is adorable as ever!

[@PhilIpp88]

That looks yummy!

[@Johnbro8]

Thanks for sharing, good idea to put the whole page of the recipe, on the video, so that you could capture the image for later. I’ve had similar success using my Nans recipe, by adding cloves to the apples (non butter scotch version), but using the same technique. I will give this a go, love your videos 👍

[@sofiaottoman]

That looks like a really yummy pie.

[@maddyf8398]

Ummm, yummy!!!

[@user-sj3rc3ux1h]

I tried this today after having it on my bucket list after watching the video when it first came out. It turned out delicious for us. I used eight Idared apples and those baked up great. I cooked the sauce longer to where it was a bit thicker since that's the way we liked it. I definitely would make it again.

[@figmo397]

My mother used to cook her apples in sugar before putting them in a pie crust because the sugar somehow protects the apple slices and keeps them from getting mushy. I don't know all the chemistry behind it, but it always worked.

[@janicegame2372]

It all depends on the type of apple, Bradley go to mush very easily even cooked in sugar!😊

[@themiltonguy4530]

@3:50 my mouth watered. This recipe pleased me.

[@lesliemoiseauthor]

This sounds and looks delicious 🎉

[@lafermenteria615]

¡¡¡Tu canal es fabuloso!!! Thanks Glen 🙌🏾🙂

[@kaitlynx1388]

This looks absolutely scrumptious. I think I would prefer to stir the cooked apples into the butterscotch mixture and then add to the pie tin but either way its a winner 🍎🍏🍎😊🍏🍎🍏

[@boogiedaddy3434]

This looks really tasty. I've never made an apple pie before and this may be my first.

[@NedFlanders612]

Made a lot of your deserts and stew. They're not too complicating and really delicious, Thank you. But I'll never try making my own Coca-Cola😅

[@susanmacdonald4288]

That pie looks wonderful...perfect for the upcoming fall season.

[@WastrelWay]

I think apples were smaller in the 1930s. Six to eight apples would be fewer apples today. That was a good explanation about the vague directions in the recipe, before kitchen scales became common. No matter how many apples you use, if it turns out OK, you got it right!

[@colleenpritchett6914]

Also almost no one used a 9-10 inch pie, they used 8 inch

[@larsen8059]

This is one fine looking pie!

[@leahrowe847]

Thanks 4 showing the recipe at the end!!

[@GlenAndFriendsCooking]

The recipe is always shown at least twice on screen and also in the description box.

[@bisexualmajima]

That looked delicious, surprised it wasn't mushy. Good job!

[@jeaniecameron295]

That sounds stunning!

[@francescarroll8977]

Yay! Pie!

[@TheCivilwargal]

I will be making this today! Thank you so much for the recipe.

[@nataliearena2241]

Looking forward to trying this

[@helenpetrie892]

Looks delicious. I find straight apple pie a bit dull, but I think the "apple scotch" sauce would make it delicious. Perhaps a dash of calvados in the sauce?

[@megwilcox2878]

Some people are pie artists, and some aren't. You and I aren't, but we don't let that stop us! Pie Good!!

[@13blackcatzzz]

Omg that looks amazing!!

[@elaine8477]

Will have to try this soon . Your Sunday show is a Sunday ritual with my first cup of coffee .

[@achevres]

Looks great. I would also add a good pinch of salt to the sauce. My favorite apple pie recipe also uses brown sugar, but not that much, lol.

[@HonicBlue]

hey Glen, long time watcher, very rare commenter. I really like what you had to say about not being afraid of pie dough. You were reading my mind right as you said it. I've watched you make pies many times, and I've been tempted to give them a try, but pie dough always seems daunting and makes me steer clear. I think it's time to just give it a go. Keep up the great work, love the channel.

[@sgmarr]

My brother brought a store pie, once. It was like this! I have not found this again. But i loved it!

[@Tee-cl6dc]

YUM I must try !!

[@caffeinatedengineer7993]

I use gravenstein apples for my apple pies. It's an heirloom apple pie variety with a PHENOMENAL apple flavor! The only downside is that the apples literally dissolve when you cook them. So you kind of end up with junky Apple sauce pie. But the taste is stunning! Out of this world! Everyone in my family loves my apples pies and want me to make them for the holidays.

[@virginiarocks]

Wow. Looks yummy

[@lornacy]

Re: the perfection of the lattice, my dad used to say, "It will all taste good!"

[@pearsrtasty3326]

i need to make this!!! we have 2 apple trees on our land not including the 3 pear trees 2 of which are asian pear trees! but the apples!! oh man there are soooo many apples and the deers keep eating them! they are kind of a granny smith type apple and wonder if those would work well? also, i am TERRIFIED of pie dough, i will be going back to your butter pie crust dough recipe and watch it and take notes! you really inspire me to "GET IN THERE". thank you so much for all your content! i just love your channel.

[@gaildunbar7186]

Looks so delicious. A scoop of vanilla ice cream with it yum 😋

[@Tensen01]

OMG I would just eat all that Applescotch with a spoon, forget about the pie. Wow.

[@aconsideredmoment]

Nice pie. Nice encouragement. :D

[@bcatbb2896]

Nice, I was just thinking of making a apple pie since we just got some apples in the house This recipe will do nicely

[@tobysmith3351]

I think this would make really good filled cookies.

[@coreymcdonald7745]

Glen's got a happy dance going on!

[@janesmith716]

That's looks really tasty!

[@kjmav10135]

Sounds like you used McIntosh. Small, keep their shape, great for pies!

[@douglasfur3808]

Hooray for pie. (I glanced at the clock when i finished watching this video and it was 3:14😊)

[@fyrekrystaal27]

When I make pie crust I have chilled everything in the freezer from the stainless steel bowl, the flour, and the butter chunks. I have been known to chill the flouur/butter mixture before adding the ice water.

[@TheDilettante]

Mmm, i would mix some homemade apple butter with the butterscotch.

[@bonnieballew7762]

When you serve the pie cut two pieces. That is supposedly makes it easier to take out the first piece.

[@wendywiese419]

Lol, you are so right...pie crust scares me. This recipe looks so good I am going to have to overcome my fear and try your wonderful butter crust. Thanks Glen. Hi Julie.

[@lynnewarren8404]

I would probably be inclined to mix the butterscotch with the apples before placing all in the crust, rather than layering. Seems like kind of a big wodge of intense sweetness separate from the fruit. Would mixing be a bad idea for some reason I’m not thinking of?

[@audreycasassa1683]

Yummmmmm!

[@old-fashionedcoughypot]

Looks good! This recipe probably could be made with pears l'll bet! Gonna try it with pears when my pear tree is ready to harvest soon.

[@violetwithey4618]

I happen to have a bottle of Calvados on hand. When I make this I'll substitute it for the vanilla.

[@WastrelWay]

Oh, come on, use the vanilla, too :-)

[@Serai3]

An easier way of making the lattice is to lay a piece of parchment on your work surface, then build the lattice on that. When it's ready, you can either slide is onto the pan or flip it carefully. Thus saving yourself a sticky task. :)

[@beangie]

I keep watching this old recipe book videos and I really love them, but, I just cant stop picturing Glen as a Canadian version of Benny Hill, waiting for the intro song to start xD

[@sandistewart3827]

Oh my Goodness! This pie was awe-----some! My "scotch" was not as thick as Glenn's at first, but it did thicken up a little more. I think that the lattice let moisture out so the Carmel would thicken up more as itbaked. Did not taste the apple cider vinager at all.

[@teleiosdawyz4044]

This would go banging with some Butter Pecan ice cream

[@fattyfat-fat6639]

Hello Glen!! What is the pot you use in this vid? I want one😊

[@richardgarrett2792]

10:55 mentions the perfect addition. Ice cream.