1965 - When Pakistan's Liberals Went Right Wing

War can have strange effects on people. As this archival dive into now obscure and forgotten songs proves, it can even shake the most committed of radicals. Jaun Eliya, Inayat Husain Bhatti, even Habib Jalib were swayed by the atmosphere generated by the Indo-Pak war of 1965.
What this video does most is prove through solid evidence that the ideas we unthinkingly ascribe to just one man (General Zia-ul-Haq) always formed a solid basis of the Pakistani identity. These ideas had common sanction among people, many of which are supremacist, xenophobic and downright appalling.

[@aghataha6854]

A well-crafted presentation on the extremist mindset that still persists in Pakistan reveals how it ultimately leads society to ruin. Our minorities do not feel safe and are compelled to live under strict restrictions, unable to practice their religion freely. The establishment of Pakistan has, at times, promoted an extremist mindset to serve its own interests, preventing the emergence of a unified nation. Although such issues are rarely discussed Thumbs up for your exceptional work in presenting these critical issues.❤

[@azarkamal4477]

At least Pakistanis but their hitlers & mussolinis behind bars and even hang then unlike the indian union where they become PM , CM and supported by Sopranos & Corleonis... From U.P bihar all the way down to deccan your union is run by racketeers. Go fix your own crap before snickering at others.

[@ijaz4272]

If esteblishing islamic system is what you call extremism who cares!!!! I don't want Pakistani women walking half naked, sleeping around, and talking about their body counts. If that's your freedom and modern civilization, then take it with you to Amazon Jungle and live there like animals...

[@thinkingloud1988]

Idealism often turns into fascism when it finds the opportunity to be worshipped

[@irtazaaliarab944]

Plz can u elaborate

[@PankajKumar-t2d2e]

First time visited your channel and I liked your great work..keep it up.. huge of love from India ❤

[@SHIVAMYadav-pw5uz]

Never seen such a thought provking critical explanation by any indian or Pakistani......😊🙏

[@shantanubhatt6576]

Nice to see few persons from pakistan actually challenging the most problematic thing in pakistan, 'religious obsession'.

[@jamshedfbc]

Some educationists, otherwise open-minded, supported Objectives Resolution. They later became vice chancellors of Karachi University.

[@atifhussain3409]

Mind blowing content ! Ashamed of our ancestors Thank you for such effort

[@suvendukumarnath7941]

Thank you the new generation of pakistan who could understand that hindus india wee never your enemies it was the fault of your government and people

[@FaiziTimber]

​​​@@suvendukumarnath7941 as an Indian Muslim please don't Lynch us. And destroy our homes with buldozers Also I want to add Pakistan was RSS project.indian muslims were always against partition

[@Kasheerscenic]

Ashamed by their freedom

[@fizashaikh3985]

Great observation and analysis! you are absolutely right, its like they only seek out information that aligns with their beliefs rest is conspiracy.

[@AmirAnsari-et9tn]

Any pop-up country tries to make up a glorious past, an ideology, an identity, a creator (Baba) and many more things.

[@faizaziz289]

are u a qadiayan

[@abdurrehman9940]

Incredibly intelligent and enlightening talk - objective and dispassionate analysis.

[@asadnawaz1597]

Kudos to you, ma'am. Such intellectual honestly is rare in Pakistan.

[@Gendpvats]

It is an encouraging sign that realistic reasoning is growing in Pak youth.

[@RukhsanaElahi-w8e]

I am Pakistani ❤but yeh wale love Pakistan songs main ny nhi sune thy.thanks dear❤

[@himanshu9962]

Really well researched content. Kudos.

[@ismailrahman1203]

Brilliant propaganda, but as MLK said “The arc of the moral universe is long but it bends towards justice” I would like to add that “it bends towards truth and justice”

[@ChefbyMistake]

اتنا سچ ہضم نہیں ہوتا ہم سب سے۔

[@SurajSharma-be2kd]

A very well researched video and one of the best 👍. Congratulations from India.

[@uzmaasher97]

Good work 👍👍👍from where you get all this material 😅

[@JangBahadur-zn1ft]

Madam, Really Brilliant, as usual. Thank you. The Army establishment has destroyed Pakistan to its core, and now these changes in the constitution proposed will have a disastrous effect. The Army establishment wants more and more powers, almost wanting to be Almighty of Pakistan. It is unfortunate for 70 years the real back door control is only with the army top bosses at Pindi. This army establishment is the only danger for long term survival of Pakistan. The Pindi GHQ game of the generals must fail. Madam you must also make a video on the agenda of China's larger game, supported by Army Generals which is so bad for Balochistan. I was watching the video on "ZRUMBESH " channel of youtube, the proceedings currently going on at the Balochistan International Conference in Geneva Switzerland. Ones heart pains to see the innocent and helpless baloch people and how pakistan army establishment has really violated and treated them badly.

[@gulgu2465]

کمال کی ریسرچ ہے۔ آفریں آفریں ،👍

[@santoshagarkar6760]

One of the best video i ever seen 👍 Religion couldn't built the Nation Pakistan is best example for the world.

[@ghalib9]

Your research and content is absolutely incredible.

[@zulfiqargilani8293]

My compliments on a thoughtful discussion of an important matter. However, underlying religious jingoism is the psychology of intolerance and militarism, that is authoritarianism.

[@ultranoobpromaxInfinity]

Wow such a well researched video with outstanding presentation skills........you girl you rock.......

[@irtazaaliarab944]

Muslim league it self is not a secular name how can it demand a secular state its a joke pakistan inception is based upon religious idelogy

[@azarkamal4477]

Christian Democrats have been secular in Europe for a long time. The very idea if Bharat is inspired from religion and hence BJP or its sister organisations cannot be secular either.

[@MurtazaDot]

Madam Jab mulk Islam k Naam pe wajood main aaya na k secularism ya Kisi qoom k Naam pe to promote bi Islami nazarye ko hi kare ga nake secularism Medam masla tab aaya jab zia jese shakas Pakistan ko firqa wariyat ko promot kia

[@interlaced_maniac]

this is exactly what ive said whenever my friends and I would debate about this (prior to the may 9th protests) and back when the military was praised (as a result of this brainwashing) they called me unpatriotic and an idiot, well looks like we got the last laugh now that they've finally woklen up to the reality of pakistan

[@1979jlr]

Very good research and interesting information

[@ravigoswami637]

Main aap ke sabhi videos dekh raha hu.. Aap toh eye opening videos banati hai.. Mujhe aap ka style bohat pasand hai.. Mujhe aap ki sabhi baatein samjh mein aa jati hai.. ✌✌👍👍👍👍

[@PankajKumar-t2d2e]

Who started the 1965 war and what were its consequences!!! Syed Muzammil shah has briefly explained.. Must watch his video

[@saapitkaaliya6768]

Hindus ke 3 type ke khane hote h 1 . Satvik 2. Rajasik 3. Tamsik 1. Fully vegetarian mind and body ko control m rakhne and higher education ke liye 2 . Minimum meat 🍖 consumer 3 . Fully non vegetarian

[@97765]

Thanks for the information. But criticism of others' culture should never be appreciated. Even a Muslim can be a vegetarian by choice. 8:42

[@SAMSAMMY837]

I laughed so hard after listening those song. No wonder Pakistan’s current state 😂😃. Keep going 😂.

[@hassaanwaheed-t9j]

If you are laughing then you have fever 🤒of hate and extrimism

[@chandreshmehta2399]

I don't understand why other islamic nations like Turkey and " Stan" nations don't that much coherent to Islam. I suppose the converts are more aggressive than original Muslims.

[@1979jlr]

I think its the problem only of Pakistan who think that they are thekedaars of islam😅

[@PunjabiMunda313-d5]

Lindu kotidiya Khaaar Jaa

[@azarkamal4477]

They are also converts. And you don't follow the religion of your ancestors either or you won't be so toxic.

[@jamshedfbc]

❤ Excellent content. That's what KZbin is for ❤❤❤

[@stdew07]

Another informative video. Thanks.

[@aliadilawan2555]

میڈم یہ بات ریاستی نظریے کی حد تک ٹھیک ہے مگر عام عوام ضیاء دور سے پہلے اور خصوصاً افغان وار سے پہلے بہت حد تک موڈریٹ تھے۔ ہمارے بڑے بھی جو باتیں اپنی بچپن کی بتاتے ہیں اس میں پردہ بے حیائی وغیرہ کا کانسیپٹ آج سے مختلف تھا

[@feminustani]

ایسا ہی ہے۔ سوشل لبرلزم ایک چیز ہے اور سوچ کا لبرلزم ایک اور چیز۔ میرا ماننا ہے کہ عوام کی سوچ کا تعلق صرف براہراست ضیا سے ہی نہیں ہے۔ اس کی اور بھی وجوہات ہیں جن میں سے پرائیویٹیزیشن اور امیگریشن دو بڑی وجویات ہیں۔

[@aliadilawan2555]

آپی صرف ضیاء کو مورد الزام اکثریت ٹھہراتی بھی نہیں ہے لیکن یہ بھی حقیقت ہے کہ رائے عامہ کو ہموار کرنے میں ضیا کا بہت ہاتھ تھا بہر حال۔ ​@@feminustani

[@TheLowsofSolipsism]

Liberal lifestyle doesn't mean liberalism. A Muslim pork and alcohol drinking person would just hate Hindus, Shia, Ahmedi, jews, feminists, their daughter marrying a non Muslim, atheists etc. A practicing muslim man could think Ahmedi deserves equal rights and rights to worship in any mosque and he's more Liberal than a person like zulfiqar Ali button or ayub khan.

[@wasifmumtaz9661]

فنکار تو فنکار ہوتا ہے۔ گانے کے بول کُچھ بھی ہوں اُس کا کام تو لے کاری اور ترنُم سے ادائیگی ہے۔ جنگ میں عوام اور فوج کو یک جان کرنے کے لئے پاکستان میں عوامی سے زیادہ مذہبی جذبات کو ہی ذیادہ اجاگر کیا جاتا رہا ہے۔ کُچھ شاعری یقیناً غیر معیاری اور سطحی تھی لیکن شاید پروڈیوسرز روزانہ کی بنیاد پر ترانے تخلیق کرتے ہوئے کُچھ جذباتی ہوگئے تھے۔ خاص طور پر 71 میں کُچھ بہت ہی غیر معقول شاعری پر مبنی ترانے پیش کئے گئے۔

[@ansar68pk]

ستر اور اسی کی دہائی میں پاکستان کی لیبر کلاس اور مڈل کلاس نے عرب ممالک کی تیل کی آمدنی پر ابھرتی ہوئی معیشتوں کا روزگار کے سلسلے میں رخ کیا اور وہاں سے فارن ایکسچینج کے ساتھ ساتھ ایک خاص مذہبی سوچ بھی واپس لائی جسے موڈریٹ ہر گز نہیں کہا جا سکتا۔ اسی دور میں ضیا مارشل لاء، ایرانی انقلاب اور سوویت یونین کا افغانستان پر حملہ، گویا اس مذہبی سوچ کے بڑھاوے کے لئے سٹیٹ سپانسرڈ catalyst بن گئے۔

[@tarunupadhyay2219]

Brilliantly made.

[@Adam-xh3pq]

0:18 Islamic secularism 😂and this aunty is feminist 😅i don't stop laughing when Pakistani says Islamic Republic islami zamuriyat inse jyada iq level to Afghanistan k logo ka hai jo Islam k according chala rha hai aur ye banana republic bane hue hai 😂

[@yasirurooj8749]

Tu ja ar Afghanistan ke pichwaray mei guss ja

[@gargi96]

You are in my top three to five young Pakistani content producers. Great respect for your intellectual beauty and otherwise, lekin aaj baalon kaa apnei kya kar dalaa. Baherhaal, bahut badhai itna accha aur saccha content produce karnei waastei. 🎉

[@MrITvideo]

WoW...I am impressed being Pakistani I didn't know this part of history which true and directly related to the turmoils that we have in the country now.

[@FunnySchnauzer-xb7ji]

مائی فکر نہ کریں جس طرح تمھاری نظر میں پچھلے لوگوں کی سوچ اور نظریات غلط تھے اسی طرح پچاس سال بعد کے لوگ آپ کی سوچ پر ہنسیں گے بلکہ مذاق اڑائیں گے جس طرح بنگلہ دیشی لوگ آ ج پھر متحدہ پاکستان کو ہی ا چھا سمجھنے لگے ہیں

[@user-in6hk9fd7l]

Thanks for showing true history of Pakistan before 1965 itni nafrat kis liye .

[@aaziz1271]

How do you parse out the unadulterated local culture vs military establishment sponsored songs designed to shore up anti-India /pro-war sentiments ? I hope you are familiar with ispr’s constant propaganda to influence average Joe Pakistanis.

[@coolmaan4434]

یہ اب بھی ہو رہا ھے ۔جب عوام جاھل ہونگے تو ایسے ہی ہوتا رے گا

[@pradeepmarwah4643]

No of countries in Asia is very soon going to increase by 2.

[@adeessiddiqii3845]

پاکستان کی تاریخ کو ایک نئے پہلو سے دیکھا

[@aamirsaeed6927]

Islam is the inspiration in battle in every Muslim countries.

[@PakistaniKitaabghar]

اچھا موضوع چنا اپ نے بڑا دلچسپ ویڈیو اور محنت کی ہے ا اگرچہ ضیا نے پھر قوانین میں جو مذہب کا ترکہ لگایا شاید لوگ اس پر زیادہ فوکس کرتے ہیں

[@azarkamal4477]

With the exception of Benjamin Sisters song, I've never heard these songs since childhood on TV or radio. In fact you've missed out some of the popular songs, which too have mild religious themes but not so blatant as the clips put up by you. No idea which grave you dug them out from.

[@manohardas9177]

Pakistan ka bharat se imanwala aur kafir wala problem hain bharat iss soch se kafi upper nikal chuka Hain

[@SaifRaa]

Thanks for introducing some og songs

[@asadaziz6429]

Appriciate your courage to touch the sensetive issue . Agreed the Hate against all the non muslims particularly Hindu faith peoples is the foundation of Pakistan. The leadership before separation from India presented a theory that the Hindu faith peoples are responsible for all the problems of muslims of India and causes of poverty in muslims of India and lack of education in the muslims of India are responsible of Hindus of India. The muslim leader ship present a theory of superiorty in the minds of muslims of India on basis of Islam and degrade the peoples of Hindi faith and but not degrade the Christian peoples on basis of religion because the British rullers were belongs from Chrustian religion . The hate emotions are very effective to unite the peoples of certain group on basis of religion and German rullet Hitler used Hate on basis of race and Hitlet target Hews and blame that the Jews are responsible of problems if German nation similarly the Muslim leadership before targeted Hibdus are responsible of all the problems of Muslins of India. The muslim leadership presented a solution for all the muslims of India to separate some part of India which will become Heaven automaticially without any efforts . The muslims of India were believed this theory that only separated some part from Indis will become Heaven and then we will no work in this Heaven and only enjoys in this Heaven. Thanks.

[@ravigoswami637]

Aap ka naya video kab aayega??

[@saeedsabirali97-mc9hm]

Very interesting video also informative.

[@djawalikar2006]

you are a very bold and a very serious researcher. Keep it up. Regards.

[@takeabreath2412]

Well if it weren't for Islam Pakistan wouldn't be an independent nation, literally the only reason it is separate from India is religion so not much room for secularism here..

[@007chanakya4]

Well done! Great content, thank you!

[@zandanshah]

Pakistan has two types of Islam, one comes from Arabistan the other modified Rev02 is called Punjabi Islam.

[@PunjabiMunda313-d5]

Dor Yaddi diya

[@Kasheerscenic]

Pakistan is not islamic country

[@DarkEdgeMedia007]

It’s more pakhtoon madersa culture

[@biswajitchowdhury9056]

Your content can open the eyes of many in Pakistan and tell our current political leaders in India - that such a bold introspective content is unthinkable in India of today! Hats off to you for self-introspective content 🎉

[@dharmeshparikh7837]

Then you are not listening to right critics, my man. 😂😂 there are so many youtubers who are gaining millions of views just after few hrs criticizing current political leaders of India especially pm.

[@sharjeeljawaid]

It was hollow jingoism

[@bodhisattva6308]

The Islam of Aligarh deobandi clique transported to Punjab and look what has happened. Sir Syed himself became a kaffir in eyes of ulema

[@afrozqazi8356]

I know many people won't like my comment creation of Pakistan was a big mistake.

[@bechansingh1560]

It was a blessing for India as we don't need people who have more loyalty for foreign land than their motherland and plunders as heroes not sons of soil.

[@1979jlr]

@@bechansingh1560 infact they don’t have nation first idea thats why they lack nationalism

[@SurajSharma-be2kd]

You are absolutely right.British plan of creating a buffer zone to keep Soviets away resulted in creation of Pakistan

[@takeabreath2412]

2:22 Absolute banger by Bhatti sab 😂

[@anarchicdrifter]

diligent & insightful research.... and charming as ever :)

[@khalidiqbal3078]

The singer of “La Saif Illa Zulfiqaar” at 4:56 Is, I think, Habib Wali Muhammad; active on PTV in 1970’s. So, it may well be “Zulfiqaar” has double meaning here! By the way, he had a MBA from Syracuse University, New York

[@karama709]

Excellent Analysis

[@ravigoswami637]

Pakistan mein aap jaise log bhi hai..?

[@arpitvakilna7125]

Madam narrative building essentially ek legitimisation process hai jise apne wajood ko banaye rakhne ke liye aur apni karastaaniyon ko bechne ke iraade se carefully design aur paida kiya jata hai. agar bharat ke naam par koi dushman hi nahi hoga to phir aap apne aggressive stance ko justify kaise karenge apni awaam ki nazron me? jab 1965 mulk ko apne baashindo ki taraf zyaada tawaajo deni chahiye thi tab ye log jung ke haalaat khade kar rahe the. tab na to pakistan aur na hi hindustan ki awaam na jung koi jung chahti thi na usse jude huye jaan-o-maal ke nuksaan bhugatna chahte the. abhi abhi to ghulaami se azaad huye the hum sab. magar inke siyaasat exclusionary rahi dono taraf ki jise inki daleelon se justify kiya ja sake dono mulkon ke siyaasat danon ko ek common enemy ki sakht zaroorat thi tabhi jisse ki ek police state ya yun kahe ki security-obsessed state khada kiya ja sake us dushman ko khatma karne ke liye. aur jab aisa state ban gaya to inhone dushman ka khatma karen se zyaada apni hi awaam ka khaatma karna shuru kar diya. badi ajeeb dynamics hai siyaasat ki jahan apke apne hi apke dushman ban jate hai, gair mulk ke log to bas ek bahaana bhar hai. aaj bhi yahi chal raha hai, Russia ne Ukraine aggression ke liye kya bahana parosa Russians ko - unhe Ukraine me basey huye Neo-Nazis ko khatma karna hai. tha koi clear-cut course of action unke paas in so-called neo-nazis ko identify aur eliminate karne ka? nahi. ulta woh saare hi Ukrainians ko target banate gaye jinme masoom bacche bhi shamil the. is had tak gir jate hai siyaasatdaan apnni siyaasat aur wajood ko bachane ke liye. ab tak international law itna mature nahi hua in baarikiyon ko address aur accommodate karne ke liye. har koi apni apni amnesia se guzar raha hai. sab kuchh tareekh me pehle bhi ho chuka hai magar usse seekhe kuchh nahi, usi tareekh ko dohraya ja raha hai. is neend me chalna kehte hai. aur daawe enlightened state ke karenge.

[@user-in6hk9fd7l]

U pls make regular videos

[@habibmohana9142]

Bitter truth

[@rivaholdings4070]

Still kashmir you not got in 1965 war. Why you celebrate defence day

[@ikhlaquechan7463]

You are so brave!

[@xxzwq]

Madam copyright nai ata? you should be careful miss

[@feminustani]

Interestingly, I didn’t even get a copyright flag on any of the songs on this one because most songs are obscure and were released by PTV rather than a recording company.

[@ziarehman4421]

Good informative video.

[@bharatpandit4796]

Very interesting!

[@daulathaldea6147]

What a great piece of research mam. Keep it up

[@izharkarim3537]

Wonderfull songs, always enjoyed😊

[@zealpanchal7224]

that's what happening here in india today.

[@BalochistanNewsExclusive-go8xg]

Excellent

[@bilalbajwa]

ضیا نے آ کر قانون میں ایسی تبدیلیاں کی جو انسانی حقوق کے خلاف ورزیاں تھی۔ اور اسلام کو بھی بدنام کیا۔ ورنہ مذہبی انداز کے ملی نغمے بنانے سے کسی کو کیا نقصان پہنچ سکتا ہے؟

[@samirsyed2859]

First time seeing this material

[@yawariqbal7774]

Fantastic presentation.

[@aaqibsohail9243]

Great work!!!!

[@ShivamKumar-pw4ur]

Yahi karan hai jo aaj pakistan bheak mang Raha hai

[@usamamuhammad1087]

Before & after everything : we are muslims : Alhamdulillah ( may u call it jingoism, fascim or any other thing )

[@MuhammadAhmad-mm8pd]

"Ram Douhai" is an exclamatory phrase in Hindi to draw the attention of other towards some calamity or accident. Does Mam have a new one? War is a brutal activity that we humans have been carrying out since the time immemorial. You don't have right to prove the Indians' infallibility in regard to all Indo-Pak conflicts. Did India not fight against the Chinese after all they were Marxist? Did the Indians not create Tamil Tigers to destabilize its neighbour Sari Lanka this Buddhist majority country is not a Jihadist state. What about Bhutan and Sikkim?

[@kumarashura6621]

Your facts aren't accurate my boy

[@patriot512]

Great work 👏 👍

[@anuragg-p8k]

Sach to bol raha he koi

[@ravigoswami637]

Agar aap video na banati toh humhe yeh fact pata hi nahi chalta...

[@RamsarangangwarSaran-ou1fj]

Khair jon eliya Sahib aap se aishi umeed n thi,ab aap ka ye najriya sahi hai to phir vo najriya jisme aap ne jhoota pyaar dikahya hindustan ke liye kitna sach tha

[@abhisheksinghyadav1112]

Adam seeker Urdu youtube channel debate

[@r.k3261]

Science journey youtube channel debate 😂

[@SamiQadir-g8s]

بھائی islamic Awakening ڈیبیٹ 😂​@@r.k3261

[@UnitedKashmirNews455]

❤❤❤👍👍👍 Love you a lot.

[@shahidnadeem3209]

جھوٹ کا کچھا چٹھا کھول کر رکھ دیا.. 🎉

[@ammararoob6006]

Zia ka kirdaar sirf ye tha "Avengers!!!!!assemble"

[@feminustani]

😭 too good

[@ismailrahman1203]

Thanks for exposing the lies and deceit

[@Faisuov]

Wow ma'am kya research ki hai hats off🫡🫡🫡

[@javedmumtaz5197]

کم از کم پاکستان میں ہر کسی کو اپنی مرضی کا کھانا کھانے کی تو اجازت ہے۔ ورنہ بھارت میں گائے کے گوشت کھانے کے شک پر بھی قتل کر دیا جاتاہے ۔ ہاں البتہ گائے کے گوشت کو ایکسپورٹ کرکے پیسہ کمانے کی اجازت ہے۔ یہ ہے سیکولر بھارت۔

[@terasoft-official]

Amazing work

[@malikfarooq2366]

Jangi taranay isitarah k hotay hain jangon me shadi k geet ni gaye jatay lekin aap isbaat ko ni samaj saken *

[@atiqlashari8152]

آپ ٹھیک کہہ رہی ہیں لیکن کیا یہ سب امریکی ایجنڈے پر نہیں ہوا۔ کیا آپ اس کی تردید کریں گی۔ اور اگر کریں گی تو کیا اس پہ ڈیبیٹ کر سکیں گی۔