1GD vs 1KD by PRADO SPECIALIST & owner/driver of both - 1kd-ftv vs 1gd-ftv

NO CASH FOR COMMENT HERE
And WHAT WOULD I know?
Owning, driving Prados for years
Fourby4diesel

[@Simon_R]

Thanks for the videos! I'm not trying to disagree with your assessment, but just to say the new 1GD really is better. We've done 11,000km in our Nov 2020 1GD mostly up in north west Australia. So mostly driving at 110km/h and regularly overtaking big road trains and caravans etc. Just got back from a 400km trip this morning and it will go from 100-110km/h to well over that very easily when you overtake. It builds speed quickly. I can't compare to the 1KD as I've never driven one but it's much more punchy than the 2019 Hilux we had previously. The torque converter locks up well and ATF temps sit at 88-89 degrees (coolant 85-86 degrees) when cruising at 110. It's an absolutely stock vehicle though, so if we do add bullbar etc I'm not saying I wouldn't mind a higher capacity engine, but they definitely seem to have fixed a few things compared to the previous 1GD. Also my MaxPro floor mats arrived today and I just fitted them. Thanks for the recommendation, very happy with them!

[@miked2604]

100 percent!

[@mathysdupreez602]

I find this interesting. Ive owned two Hiluxes with 1KD’s - one manual one auto. And also two N80 Hiluxes with the 1GD - both 130kW and 150kW variants (both Autos). In my experience both versions of the 1GD pulled stronger and were more fuel efficient than the 1KD versions. 1GD makes more power and torque everywhere compared to 1 KD. Maybe the differences you feel are due more to gearbox mapping than the engine?

[@1975Cervo]

Anthony do yourself a favour and drive the new one Mine pulls like a train and I was shocked when the throttle controller went on Same hill with the new one blows the doors off my old 1kd and hold gears up most inclines without gearing down Definitely an upgrade in every way so far for me

[@benjaminprince6424]

Interesting, I have been playing with the idea of an N80 lux (utes are my style) and with the re-map toyota themselves gave them has peaked my interest, driven my mothers 2015 fortuner a few times and yeah seemed laggy and sluggish and surprised my n70 felt better particularly with weight from mods and muddies (no tune)

[@phillipsampson4001]

Couldn’t agree more. The company I work for use both Prado land cruisers and Hilux 2 & 4WD configurations. I waited quite some time before taking the plunge in purchasing my 2015 N70 SR5. After driving many different models it was a no brainer. The 1KD FTV has more torque where I need it to be. Slightly less efficient, but I know beyond the doubt it was the right choice. As always, top upload. Keep on keeping on. 🤘

[@amitshrestha2499]

Thanks for sharing for 1kd-ftv . I am driving from last 3 year and change turbo,, having small were and tear of oil leak but its good to drive.

[@torpedo6738]

Is the engine that bad , i hear many complaints

[@imanenigma3348]

Interesting thoughts mate. Will be keeping my December 2009 Hilux 1KD I have owned since new, now 177ks. Just had 180k service @Toyota here in Newcastle, mentioned I wanted a engine diagnostic scan and check oil pick up. Oil pick up all ok but no scan. Told car needs to be cold and will take an hour and a half and asked me why I wanted it done. I tried to explain I wanted to prevent any future engine issues as I want to keep vehicle but it was like talking to a brick wall. Wish there was someone close with your knowledge AND attention to detail.

[@snowjack13]

Just some info for the “numbers” the 1kd makes the numbers earlier in the rev range then the 1gd... the manufacturer gives “peak” numbers, therefore when you compare apples to apples with the same numbers, the 1kd will feel much better making more power down low where it really matters...

[@alexsodhi]

I have noticed they really sorted the auto trans as well. It locks up very well

[@mugget]

That’s what I was thinking. And much narrower spread of power on the 1GD won’t help in the driveability department either.

[@gavinspring1350]

That's why I own and love my 4.0 V6 Kakadu 5 speed averaging 13.5L/100. And goes nearly as good as my previous LX470. Probably should of kept the LX...A very comfy and lovely vehicle to drive too.

[@TheJoker-qn6vw]

You just answered my question...I was pondering on whether i should get a "modern" 4.0 prado or get a used "old" but well maintained Lexus Lx470...and from this comment I'll stick to the latter. Those vehicles are just timeless, hardly and very comfortable.

[@mvubu6823]

@@TheJoker-qn6vw what did you get yourself?

[@rubigor]

Agree with you I test drove a 2021 Prado a couple of weeks ago & found my 3.0 1kd much better to drive.

[@trevorli6602]

Completely agreed. Drive 16 3.0 and a 22 prado. The previous model with 1KD is much more smoother than the new one. I always feel dry and power with the new one especially going up hills

[@alexsodhi]

I have new Hilux with power upgrade. after a 2016 hilux for 4 years. i can definitely say the new one is a big improvement. But not sure if the improvement is felt as much in the prado.

[@HORTOJM]

Agreed Alex, noticeable difference with new Hilux engine. Maybe the Prado is the issue. .Weight, diff ratio, Tyre size, Auto trans, so many variables. BTW, I read somewhere that there were a number of modification to the new 1GD FTV. They didn't list a remap in the list.... Mine tows my 2100Kg boat much better than the previous Hilux. newsroom.toyota.eu/new-hilux---a-more-powerful-engine-for-a-striking-design/

[@leonardbevitt7830]

I had a 2010 hilux for 10 years.. was a great vehicle.. brought a 2021 hilux rugged x.. the power difference is massive.. the new vehicle does have a lot more toque going up the same hills holds gears much better.. time will tell

[@markymark3308]

Geez talk about a winge, try a throttle controller, it is not a remap or a chip, but it will make a difference. Try one size down in tyres, or buy the latest version with the awesome new engine. I think we all get you point you have been making. Put your big boy pants on and stop winging about it. The latest 1GD is a big improvement with lots of upgrades, not just a remap. Keep it real Anth, please!

[@paulmaxwell8191]

You are the Best was going to buy New GD but will buy older one ❤

[@mdbacolod]

I would be interested to see what the actual dyno figures would show, same dyno on the same day. Both 1gd and 1kd torque and power figures.

[@Gemini_0815]

I own a 19MY 1GD Prado, and I’m fine with its performance. That said, I’ve got a manual. And it’s my „slow“ car - if I’m in a hurry, I got a passenger car for that. But sure it would be nice to have all in one. A fast SUV which is also capable off road. Eventually that leads to a Land Rover New Defender.

[@Harpoika]

I have a feeling that it's just a feeling. If it performs better by numbers the worse "feel" of the 1gd might be just from the fact that it feels different than a 1kd driver is used to. I'm only speculating but thia kind of biases are tricky to control. I'm driving 1gd with AT so I might be biased too.

[@pauls4708]

i like the 1gd in my fortuner. I have a bullbar and run all terrains

[@MakaveliTheDon7]

What do you guys think about the 0w20 oil Toyota is using now. 2024 Hilux is using this I’m worried should I be ?

[@marcsacco2538]

I have a 18 gxl prado with the 1GD I’ve put 100 thousand kms on and I can positively say the engine is gutless I towed a 2t excavator on the hume with my 1kd hilux and it then with the prado, the 1kd killed the 1GD and the prado is the stock the hilux is lifted with all the fruit and mud tires

[@andrewmcdougall976]

Love your work Anthony!

[@16missedcalls56]

Spoke too soon at 1:20 they’re in the 70 series now and outperforming 1vd cruisers from initial comparisons

[@Fourby4Diesel]

No mate didn’t speak too soon. They’re still an underside four cylinder. You can go get one if you want. 😁

[@mohamedalihebboul2214]

I am going to change my 2009 hilux vigo with a 2010 Prado soon and I hope it will be a good deal, cause 400.000 km and no problems with my Hilux. Thanks for the vid and keep going mate.

[@cheyenneharper7650]

2019 1gd is not the same with 2021 1 gd?

[@patrolturbodiesel]

I priced a brand new one last year but got the opportunity on a low milage short wheel base 1kd. Glad I bought it over the new one!

[@MagicNash89]

Isnt rhe 1kd much less reliable than the typical land cruiser engines?

[@adriankiraly5172]

.... I don't believe the "small" engine theory: how can 250 cc make such a difference. It is something else... Ranger 2.0, Isuzu 1.9....they are EVERYWHERE...

[@lylethompson2453]

How do you no when to chang drive belt tensioner.in the 1kd looks like a big job

[@miquelanesto1762]

So the 1gd feels similar to the 2kdftv non intercooled from a hilux.

[@bjbuckley6108]

I agree I have one there so gutless

[@sad_clown]

So why did you buy it if it feels all doughy on acceleration? I test drove one and thought it felt crap too, which is why I didn’t buy the thing

[@bluedunn374]

Talking up your old cars to increase their resale, it’s a good trick.

[@Fourby4Diesel]

Knumb nuts, I’m not selling the old car. I’ll sell the new ones again & again as demonstrated 😉😂😂😉✌️

[@geoffj3191]

New injectors at 100k seems a bit extreme.

[@tom6549]

Probably more to do with the age of them rather than klms

[@andrewmcdougall976]

Replaced due to age, early 2010 150 😀

[@petovenspierre-louis6505]

Hello, I have a 2009 Land Cruiser Prado with a 1GD-FTV petrol. I am thinking to swap to a diesel 1KD-FTV engine. Are the footprints the same? Will I need any other parts except the engine and transmission? Thank you.

[@Ikram_ridez]

Don't replace!!

[@fl7645]

Simply there is no comparison , 1 GD for far a much better than the weak 1Kd

[@Ali.s_garage]

Hello guys I have a 2014 Hilux UK version with 1 KD I just changed it's coolant only has 80k on the clock my heat is working fine and engine lowered it's coolant level after one day of replacing the coolant I topped it up again about 2 or 1 inches above the Full mark but since then it never lowered the coolant level I also once let it idle with the cap off for 30 minutes all I saw was coolant rising and over flowing but got no bubbles I drove it for an hour on variable speeds and Let it idle for half an hour too temp gauge always where it should be so should I worry about anything else? Or is my vehicle ok and fine

[@brandancastle8337]

There was probably still some air in the cooling system should be no problem at all

[@angyp74]

Would love to hear your thoughts on the latest Prado. I had 2007 120 and replaced it with 2018 150 yeah it's gutless but I don't push it hard. I am generally interested in getting the best economy out of it. Thought the new one would be more economical, but in reality, there's little difference. Would love to know the physical differences between the 18 and 21 if it's just the map of the engine and transmission then Toyota should be able to retrofit it.

[@NUGGETFPV]

My 09 1kd pulls harder then our companies brand new 2021 hilux's, all 3 that i have driven at work are crap verry disappointing

[@paullubcke8554]

Is it the trans that is killing the new motor.know someone who upgraded from a 5spd mux to the 6spd and we're towing a big van early one was impressive new one overheated trans towing and Isuzu couldn't fix it.

[@jeremym105]

Wondering if your views have changed since this video when comparing the 1kd-ftv vs 1gd-ftv ?

[@Andrew-1974]

Sell it PLEASE!! Buy a LC200. ANY land cruiser with a 4 cylinder is gutless in my opinion. Also, I know for a fact, the 1gd in a Hilux blows away any auto or manual 1kd Hilux. Prado is a poor mans Landcruiser, compared to the real land cruiser, in my opinion

[@mugget]

If they cost the same to buy and run I’m sure most of us would. 😅