20/11/24 They lied, were angry!

[@sandymcghee3328]

Another great video the people are behind you and all the other farmers mr. P. We need a another General Election 👍👍👍

[@kennethcoates2077]

Yes Ian ,I totally agree with every word you said no one would have voted for Labour if they had told the country what they were intending to do.

[@erikklein-x6u]

No Government has a right to make a decision like that! The least that they have an obligation,or right to do is to put the proposal to a National referendum

[@Sooty]

The only time this Government will listen is when we have another General Election, and they get kicked out of No.10 😊

[@erikklein-x6u]

You need to sign the petition for a new election,and make sure that at least 50 million people in England sign it also to liberate yourselves from the Labour Party disaster!

[@davidarmstrong1452]

1.5 million signed so far

[@andrewdalziel4006]

The numbers are rising by around 1500 per minute

[@markc2107]

Well said Ian 👍🏻💯come on everyone Support the British farmers 🇬🇧💯🙂👍🏻

[@lauriepearce8266]

Well spoken Ian . That came from the heart as well !!

[@sarahmanning5769]

Unfortunately, it will definitely have fallen on deaf ears. MPs do a very good job of pretending that they care. They don't.

[@ericwatt1447]

Well said about giving the tax payers money away

[@irvenrathburn9421]

Good talk MR, P leave farmers alone they have enough to worry about.

[@bobuncle8704]

Well said. Agree 100% I find it interest your PM was off galavanting around the world, just like our PM was during the trucker strike. Running away with their tail between their legs.

[@simonlichcaterpillarpower]

Hello Farmer P, nice Video good info!!!!!😉👌👍💪

[@anniedd3316]

Well said totally agree with all you say

[@NiftyMCD_Australia]

Well said.

[@Robertbarlow802]

Absolutely right in all you say, my fear I’m afraid Labour will not give a dam, and plough through for want of a bad phrase.

[@NorfolkandGood66]

The points you made to your MP make absolute sense Ian. The government simply want to shaft farmers! Hopefully they have listened but I somewhat doubt it.

[@cameronmorton6756]

Watched on Sunday morning. I echo the comments made by all. Its a shame you wern't able to attend the rally, Through your channel and recommendations, I follow, Tom, Ollie, Wardy and Charlotte, and others. Having seen their vlogs of the event, It made me v emotional, which is a rare occurrence. As a non farmer (have worked on farms in past), It is a striking reaction for me. I hope the government see sense, and farmers don't have to escalate their action in response. I back you all the way! ❤🙏

[@FarmerP]

Thank you Cameron.

[@jimpolk]

Thought about you guys and followed the events of the day as best I could from over here. Proud of y'all taking the stand. I know they haven't given you a choice. Hope it makes a difference. NO FARMS NO FOOD!

[@johngraham6181]

Your MP is a politician. He is accomplished at sounding like he is listening but then does bugger all. If you catch them having a drink in the bar later you would see an arrogant attitude that reflects their true view of you,. Been there and got the t-shirt! MPs are generally personable. This is how they get elected. Their spads (that is the guy making notes) are simply note takers and usually hefted to the Party they support.

[@hels2608]

I would hope he would be personable given that he was a GP for nearly 30 years 😂

[@FarmerP]

@@johngraham6181 I don’t think Simon is your typical career politician John. I recon he’s a genuine chap who wants to do a good job, he’s just been tempted by the dark side a bit. 👍🏼

[@johngraham6181]

@@FarmerP Best of luck. There are good ones out there. Problem is that they are few and far between! Once in Parliament they have ways and means. A committee here and foreign trip there, As long as you are singing from their hymn sheet. This lot seem worse than the SNP we have up here and that is saying something.

[@MrDbone75]

A very good Sunday evening to you all

[@MichaelBradley-j6z]

Was reading today that the government are sending £536 million to Africa and Asia to help farmers I thought that was a big kick in the bollocks to British farmers . It's all about land grabbing for there rich buddys hopefully someone will listen to the farmers as we can't survive with out you guys and thank you for all you do .

[@johngraham6181]

I will leave a caveat to money to Africa, Asia and Brazil. I cannot think the Labour Party has had time to put this is place and I vaguely remember it as part of COP26 with the Conservatives. Foreign and Commonwealth Office have Billions to give away each year and right now carbon and net zero tops the list. Starmer took 430 uncivil servants with him to COP29. The big difference was the conservatives did not announce this 'tractor tax' a few days after the exchequer picked our pockets! Starmer and Reeves did and that is unforgiveable. One fact I know is the Exchequer and any Government Dept has spreadsheets of BIG ideas. Each new Minister that arrives is presented these ideas as must do projects. Most Ministers take one look, say that is going to bin my popularity and tells them to can it. Reeves and Starmer are not that bright. They said whooppee we can really do something exciting and all the work is in place so it can happen NOW. Most civil servants take an eon to get any plan past the first hurdle. Problem with the new Labour Government they have a problem making a U turn. They think it would make them look foolish. Note to PM and his Chancellor: You look pretty foolish to most of us right now! Apart from being the worst liars in Westminster and that takes some doing!

[@chrispenn715]

I agree entirely with your view on how unjust these budget changes are to family farms. I think the reality is that Labour doesn't see farmers as their people: they assume farmers vote conservative. Individual Labour MPs have no influence in this. Best hope for farmers is to stay alive long enough for a change of government and hope Tories undo this.....

[@charleshart6992]

Excellent video Ian!

[@HughzieTube]

Have you seen the petition calling for another General Election? 1,384,158 signatures and counting up by the second! Got half a million in less than 24 hours!

[@FarmerP]

@@HughzieTube Signed it while sitting on the loo this morning Hugh 😄👍🏼

[@hels2608]

It'll be about as useful as the 6 million who signed the petition for a new referendum on EU membership.

[@johnrobinson5056]

The double can tax was in fact due to be imposed by the last government who dropped it following representations by the NFU and CLA, this lot have just sneakily revived it. Perhaps they could advise where I can find a multi purpose car that will take the family out safely when necessary, have off road capability,carry two working dogs in a secure box,a tonne of animal feed of building materials or 50 fencing stakes, none of it will fit in a family saloon, hatchback or estate car. You've seen mine Ian and being retired didn't even get the vat back, but it's the best vehicle available for our needs.

[@johngraham6181]

See my reply to Michael Bradley. Another idea dusted off the shelf and presented to the Chancellor as an action ready proposal. No need to speak with NFU, CLA or indeed the manufacturers, Already compliance to Net Zero means most double cab pickups are underpowered. Only the new Ford Ranger, VW Amarock and Grenadier will pull the skin off a rice pudding. I did see a post that stated this was being shelved but cannot confirm that.

[@kevinable3661]

Well said Farmer P.

[@DodgyFPV]

Lets just hope he wasn't performing lip service to appease.

[@normandagger7542]

My thoughts are with you, keep teling it as it is.

[@trevorsidley7697]

The rally is just the beginning. Important to dig in for a long haul and maintain public support. Farmers can be very determined, you don't give up t the first storm or snow. Together we can win.

[@chriseccles1454]

🎉🎉Well said 😊😊My MP was Rees Mogg now 2 jobs Dan Norris.😢

[@jamesthompson8865]

Politicians what did we expect only in it for themselves, they don't give a shi........

[@ianhaggart1438]

Nice vid Ian.. glad you were able to get to London... stay safe 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@roberthiggins6401]

Don't accept any compromise to farmers. Investors are a different story unless they're farming it. If you give an inch they'll take a mile.

[@christopherforster6555]

Hopefully this tax thing will never happen this government is diabolical.

[@Dore60]

Well said Ian 👍

[@Cameron-ev7rc]

They lied 🤥 about it. Ian you must be mistaken. Salt of the earth these politicians. What’s that old analogy towards politicians Don’t vote for them it just encourages Them. 🤷‍♂️🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@gerry6612]

I'm not a farmer but I stand with all farmers large or small

[@tinagibbs618]

We i mean all of us need our Farmers. The labour government have not thought this through. Shame on them.

[@FarmerP]

@@tinagibbs618 As far as I’m aware, they consulted no one except a couple of accountants who think food is made in the superstore.

[@ekhaat]

Tax the income, not the property that might not even make an income.

[@robertallardice8119]

Richard Murphy will explain the inheritance tax!

[@CHEEKYMONKEY2647]

im voting the PM out, he hasnt done anything that he claimed the party would do...

[@peterlockyer1348]

very good video as always 👍❤😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@dbg9226]

I did see yesterday that the chancellor had not even told defra about their plan

[@CharlesYeo-qs6nb]

She is married to the head of operations at DEFRA 😂😂😂😂😂

[@hughhead9079]

Keep the pressure up to change Labour leadership's priorities. Your MP is powerless in a partisan system otherwise.

[@FarmerP]

@@hughhead9079 He admitted as such, but did offer to write a letter to the treasury with our concerns, I’m not sure if he heard me when I asked for a copy.

[@marionstephen4972]

We are with all the way hope they change there minds I would like see them work a farm

[@bobcrawford2105]

No Labour M P will go against Starmer because if they do he kicks them out end of. Need new government who understand farming and worldwide issues

[@colinmaynard2879]

Thanks. I’m with you.

[@FarmerP]

@@colinmaynard2879 Thank you Colin. 🙂👍🏼

[@colinmaynard2879]

@@FarmerPYou’re welcome. I can’t believe how rushed this first budget was. It is our fault, we were so fed up with the Tory government. We voted the Labour Party in on the vaguest manifesto I’ve seen. There was little we can hold them to. I’m sure they decided that there were fewer farmers than pensioners to pick on. I had little understanding of how farms worked until Lockdown and subscribing to 5 or 6 channels. It was “fun” to watch Clarkson learn what your vlogs had shown me. Are they wanting to raise funds on agricultural land, and end up owning it. It should be taxed on change out of farming use (and Solar Farms don’t count) or on sale outside a family, in which case the purchaser should pay the tax due. This could also reduce the land values.

[@FarmerP]

@@colinmaynard2879 There are many ways the treasury could raise the same revenue Colin, and vastly more if they were smart about it, I sense a wee bit of anti landowner (let’s stick it to them) vendetta in the air.

[@christophergreen1459]

Merry Christmas to all your family

[@paulellison1316]

totally agree Ian . but off the subject that new light fitting is hanging down tut tut electrician😱

[@FarmerP]

@@paulellison1316 That’s one of the old fittings Paul.

[@paulellison1316]

@FarmerP my apologies, I thought they were new, my mistake tut tut silly paul 🤣

[@tarzansnuts4503]

Too political for me atm. I liked being part of the EU, I also believe in fair taxes for all, if that means things change, then so be it.

[@FarmerP]

@@tarzansnuts4503 Nothing wrong with fair taxes, unless they result in negative results. Tax on profit is fine, vat on fuel, machinary, inputs, even labour. But robbing the land of its caretakers, leaving it vulnerable to industry, housing or investors with no interest in food production, that’s bad for everyone. The EU had its uses, and I think it will again, once they have recovered from the bruising. Leaving was never going to be pain free, we have to go through the decade of punishment first to make sure no one follows us.

[@tarzansnuts4503]

@@FarmerP let me clarify fair taxes. land owners whether it’s farms or estates, hotels, or households, should all pay equally. The majority of the farms in my area have been split up, some are hobby farms, no more than a few acres, but still worth millions, a lot of farmland has been built on, all within green belt. All tax loopholes need to be closed, so the ones that can afford high priced accountants to “strategically invest” their clients money to reduce their tax burden, no longer applies. We give huge tax breaks to businesses outside our country, in hope to generate investment. If we are worth investing in, there would be no need for tax incentives. The government needs money coming in so it can give subsidies, to help businesses like yourselves or your Dads. The landscape of this country is forever changing, politicians like to call it evolving, I’m not sure I agree with that. Do I think it’s harsh bringing in a tax like this for farmers our age, hell yes. On a purely business front. You have an opportunity with your KZbin channel to earn some serious money, just by asking people to hit the like button and subscribe(Tom Pemberton) but you have stated on many occasions you’re not doing it for those reasons. KZbin bubbles, burst so make hay while the sunshine’s. Like I said too political atm, I know I’m going to get haters.

[@FarmerP]

@ The income generated from You tube has made a big difference to us and our small farm, I have invested almost all of it back into buildings and equipment, it’s been a very welcome and unexpected bonus to keeping a daily diary, many other folks have cottoned on to it and are now joining the community, it’s become a diversification. I agree taxes must be levied but not from spite or malice, and not to cover the waste generated by many of our public services or foreign policies. The rich man with a nice house and twenty acres that produces nothing will escape this new tax, the multi millionaire who bought land to escape inheritance tax can afford clever accountants and advisors to avoid a lot of it. The back bone food producing farmer is stuck clearly in the middle. If the government want to squeeze a bit out of the big wealthy tax dodging investors they can be my guest, but to target the man who actually feeds them in a way that forces him to become less viable. Why?

[@alexkennedy119]

Great video mr p

[@nancysmith-baker1813]

Farmer P look upbon other channels on Clarkston speech and others . I Charlot caight it well . Funky Farmer tryed but was to far away and you could not hear well . I listened to the ehole speech of the one you caught . Really hit home . I cannt find the words more often now adays . Its just different. I read all your ansrr on yestarday Vidio . They good andwers to thoughts . The lies I hear in the states are astounding . Good luck . A very serious time and strange . Take care . Thankyou for gour vidio and thought s . Ive learned alot from you and Richard Best to you both ..

[@harrie1976]

Why not put a old peace of plastic draine pipe over the insulation around the waterside so the cattle.can not destroy it.

[@farmlad1883]

I was thinking some wire mesh might stop the cattle from chewing it

[@CliveReeves-li1qz]

All fairness Ian the working class are being taxed way to much to pay for theses that chose not to not work

[@FarmerP]

@@CliveReeves-li1qz It’s true Clive. BPS will clout all small business, on top of higher wages and NI, the working man who Starmer thinks he’s helping will be unemployed next April.

[@marcusbarnard]

No tax ever on farmers

[@FarmerP]

@@marcusbarnard I don’t mind paying my bit towards looking after our country, just tax me on my profits, not my shop floor. Tax my children if they sell the farm when I’m gone, they at least have the choice, and I would rather they kept it anyway.

[@fredharrowven1040]

Hi Ian, There is a lot I don’t agree with you and there is a lot I do agree with, So I am just going to say the best of luck in your quest .⭐️⭐️👍👍👌🎅🎅

[@FarmerP]

@@fredharrowven1040 It would be a dull world if we all agreed on everything Fred, the trick is being able to listen to argument with an open mind, and try to see the other point of view. 🙂

[@fredharrowven1040]

My trouble is I get to wound up them trying to to take your money and them taking our £300 heating allowance.

[@FarmerP]

@ Fred, Mrs P said go and talk to your local Citizens advice bureau, depending on your circumstances there are other sources of winter heating funding available, it may be a little bit of paper shuffling but it’s definitely worth a punt 🙂👍🏼

[@fredharrowven1040]

Thank you very much for the info Ian and thank you MRS P.

[@paulhunt1836]

Great video ian why the government didn't tell there mp's is because they didn't want a retaliation from I did like sandy from px farms interviews from nigal farage & the libdem chap

[@russellpetrie119]

cant find the words probabley despare and anger what a surprise that starmer wasnt there

[@Smartinweldingandfabricating]

Well Spoken Ian that came frome the hart and I’ve growing up in the countryside all may life a rawnd farms and give a famer a hand wen he Ned’s it

[@keithsimpson8335]

To talk in detail about farming tax to a non-farmer, is like talking about quantum physics. We have a Chancellor and Treasury who haven't a clue, after all it isn't their money, but they're happy to give it away for another country's projects.

[@GlenGear-fs2dk]

another great video

[@denzel0197]

It’s just came to light that they are sending £500 million to foreign farmers 16:26

[@robwillcox2307]

More double standards and lies. Already signed the petition.

[@russellpetrie119]

theres a petition on starmer aperantley

[@erikklein-x6u]

500 years is a long time! Who knows what type of farming may exist,or even be allowed by then?

[@roberthiggins6401]

Why does the nfu never have the comments switched on? My council have their comments switched off too Mevagissey they don't want to listen, they want to know what you'll ask before their meetings and the answer you get is lame to say the least, plus you don't get a chance to come back to that answer. To say they're transparent is an understatement. They talk about things they have no clue about a typical question was about agriculture and the answer was trees for Christ sake.

[@alanhall1219]

Would you vote for them next time round

[@norriestewart4333]

With all you famers all the way 100%. The way the current petition is getting signed up I think Labour could be out before long and no one to blame but themselves. 1,513,363 signatures and counting.

[@FarmerP]

@@norriestewart4333 I have a feeling that Mr Westwoods petition will shout a lot louder than 40’000 angry farmers, just wish I had thought of it. 🙂

[@mandypaul7263]

That made sence

[@s.m.1959]

Granted, I'm not really part of the farming community, but, the whole concept of inheritance tax just seems so mind-boggingly ludicrous... Not just to farmers, but everyone really. Maybe I'm getting that wrong, but basically you pay tax when you buy the land, you pay tax for when you build on it, you continue to pay tax if you choose to create a business on it (maybe not on the land itself, but I'm sure there's at least some sort of tax to pay), and after you die there's still more tax to pay if you choose to pass the whole thing on to children or ... whoever, really? Like I said, ludicrous. Though, I'm sorry to say, but I'm not all that surprised that promises were broken by some just so they could get their way - I mean, that's really not exactly unheard of in the world of politics. Its just that its not often this immediately and blatantly obvious... for you and everyone else in the same/similar position I really hope they'll find a way to work things out!

[@russellpetrie119]

its the usaul shit they go after the taxpayer not the tax avoiders

[@davidkellet1006]

We were in peppercorn rent my uncle baught land sold it to pay family out died at 65 my aunt sold up for partly converted to houses 3 people's ashes are scattered in pasture my money went on my house rent so I'm still poor retired farmer

[@matthewmackrill3026]

Nobody in the farming community can get their heads around this, it just doesn’t make sense..

[@PaulMonaghan-w3m]

It does make sense . when you know where to look . Check out agenda 30 . He a Evil puppet is starmer along with billionaires and banking and W.E.F . KZbin or web search W.E.F . Agenda 30

[@andywarrington4738]

why did Starmer have talks with blackrock and Gates recently ? why has blackrock got massive financial interest in Ukraine land ? , why are farmers being taxed out of farming ? see the connection?

[@SeanOliver-vl3db]

It’s okay having an asset and it doesn’t matter how much it is worth ,be it £5 an acre or £50000 an acre. It’s worth nothing in cash terms until you sell it. I

[@russellpetrie119]

put 5p on the pound capitol gains tax to everyone shouldnt be felt scrap in heritance tax altogether we pay enough while alive

[@peacelily1564]

Why do you need to be looked after? Why do you need to be lorded over? Why do people need politico's on the public dole (tax paid) who don't seem to know what is going on, yet the politico's are expected to support political party policy blindfolded.

[@scottkrieger4701]

Whats your plan for the old tires.

[@FarmerP]

@@scottkrieger4701 Facebook market place or eBay probably.

[@michaelking9254]

I noticed there were a lot of police lining the street too. They obviously thought you lot were going to riot or something. They just don’t get it do they.

[@FarmerP]

@@michaelking9254 Apparently the MET would happily host us again. 🙂👍🏼

[@gilliantovey1014]

@@FarmerPOlly (Ollyblogs) was in contact with the Met a lot during the build up to the protest and he said a number of times how helpful they were and that they seemed keen to do the best they could so that the farmers were close to Westminster and were visible.

[@firan67]

👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@bobpage8100]

Hi Ian. sorry but I seem to have missed a week or soon video prior to the trip to London .Have you had aproblem. I see this morning 20/11. that the wall barriers are in Confused. Bob

[@FarmerP]

Dont worry Bob, you will be going back to the start of that week tomorrow. I let the protest videos jump the queue before they became old news.

[@bobpage8100]

@@FarmerP I did wonder thanks for taking the time to reply I look forward to breakfast tomorrow to see the next instalment

[@MickHodgson-h1n]

Inheritance Tax as a tax as always bothered me. You build up a business (not just in farming) with bank loans, no assistance from the Government of the day except possibly some form of grant, then when you wish to pass it on the Government suddenly demand a percentage ??

[@FarmerP]

I think its an abhorrent tax Mick, Almost a punishment for doing well and saving for the next generation.

[@jeremiahkearney5191]

Of course paying tax when of if it’s sold makes sense, also I would say the threshold should be on agriculture value or average return value over the past three or even five years, that makes allowances for losses due to climate etc. These people don’t know the risks farmers take each decision and almost every day. I sure hope this mess will be sorted out very soon. Keep the chin up and best wishes.

[@FarmerP]

@@jeremiahkearney5191 They rushed into a wall of imagined numbers Jeremiah, and hit another wall of very unhappy farmers. They bought the fan, we will supply the 💩

[@scottkrieger4701]

Why can't it be the same as it is or less ?

[@2626stephen]

Looking like some of the labour gang don't know what's happening. 5million sounds a better big number. I had never heard of the limits to inheritance tax until I had to sort out my mams estate, just under the threshold said the solicitor 😢. Will it be sorted ? It needs to

[@greggroome2791]

🙏🙏👍👍👌👌💪💪🇮🇪🇮🇪

[@MalcTyler]

Hi Ian i did ask if you have emptied the roller of water but you may have missed it 😅

[@FarmerP]

@@MalcTyler Not yet, it’s on my to do list. 🙂👍🏼

[@daveschwerdtfeger7842]

👋😊

[@craigdoig9486]

21:26 great content again

[@Kieran1995]

have i missed a bunch of uploads??

[@FarmerP]

@@Kieran1995 No Kieran. I let the protest videos jump the queue, They are already old news after a couple of days, if I leave them ten days, folks will be all protested out 🙂👍🏼😄

[@jonb3311]

Bottom line - did you vote for Labour? Have you ever voted Labour?

[@FarmerP]

@@jonb3311 No, Never have, never will. I believe in reward for hard work, ingenuity and perseverance, not expecting the state to do it all for me. I have never drawn a benefit, except sick pay when I broke my left leg when I was 18. I have never been unemployed, Everything we have was built by the money we earned. I owe nobody anything, except the mortgage for my home, which I should complete by the time I’m 65. And I did it all while paying the tax man his pound of flesh. 🙂👍🏼

[@jonb3311]

@@FarmerP So what do you and the other tory voters expect from the current government - the one you will never support? It's boot on the other foot time. We've had 14 years of corrupt tory government, making millions for their mates, like Clarkson and Dyson. BTW, I've worked on farms, been treated like shit, watched the owners do f'all, other than make sure they got their pound of flesh out of us who did the work. All of them having had their farms handed down to them. One of the farms is now a golf course, another gravel workings.

[@redhat4249]

under false pretenses

[@mandypaul7263]

What you on about! biscuit is a service dog to you and same as alot of other farners dogs , they keep you company when you spend long hours alone in a tractor far from anyone .they love you when your having abad day . Farmers dogs that stick by their owner for no real obvious reason other than keeping each other company , helping to keep depression away . Biscuit is your service dog.bet you feel abit down when she chooses to stay indoors in front if a fire . You dont need proof to say she is your service dog as there is no such thing as anydog can be one .yes there is proof if a dog has been specially trained 😮but that is just proof they been trained . You trained your dog . . My dog goes everywhere who's to say shes not.

[@russellpetrie119]

does that mean doublecabs are exemp of vat now? thats a 20 percent saving

[@FarmerP]

Not exempt, you can claim the vat back if you are vat registered and pay less if you call it your company (Farm) car. Lots of city folks use the loophole for tax avoidance but the chancellor has tarred us all with the same brush.

[@russellpetrie119]

@@FarmerP i dont get why there claiming a crew cab pickup is a family car sureley they would be void of vat its like rob peter to pay paul

[@Fopprax]

[@graygray7228]

👍

[@buza1300]

😎💙👍

[@michaelstaunton1632]

👍👍👍🇮🇪

[@johnm7354]

😀

[@pwmoorejr]

were angry is spelled we're angry. Missed the apostrophe.

[@FarmerP]

@@pwmoorejr You got the message though. 🙂👍🏼

[@erikklein-x6u]

You could have lied and said that Biskit was your emotional support pet

[@FarmerP]

@@erikklein-x6u While she growls at everyone. 🐶😄