2023 LOW BUY INTRO: How I'm keeping my makeup spending intentional (+ spreadsheet template!)

[@whataboute]

I was so invested in the beauty world that I bought soooo much without even realising it. Now I have this hudge collection of old makeup. When I think about all the money I kinda lost in a way it makes me sad...so I love content like this, seeing older makeup, be mindfull of what you buy, lots of numbers, low buys and using up makeup. It's what we all need

[@mmmkk987]

I feel like a lot of people are in the same place.. if you're not careful, the beauty space on KZbin can cause to make impulse purchases without thinking it through which is why I love content like this

[@palettesandpans]

I'm so with you and identify with your experience wholeheartedly. When all you see are creators reviewing new makeup (whether they purchased it or got it in PR), it can really normalise always shopping to have something new in your collection at all times, which is completely unrealistic and excessive

[@sueda1tr]

There is a satisfaction of seeing people use up what they have to be honest. I do not watch all the review videos unless there is a product something I have on my mind and then I binge watch videos about that product to see how it is. I want to watch a channel that helps me see different ways to use up what I have and keep me motivated to not fall in to the trap of consumerism. Thank you for creating videos like this!

[@EarthlyBeauty]

Yes, I totally agree with you. It is so satisfying when influencers completely use up what they purchase because that is what I like to do with my products. And you don't see it often now because influencers are just buying buying buying, reviewing once and never using again, it is so wasteful and frustrating.

[@amandasjoberg463]

Yeah I'm the same!

[@Denise-ki9ii]

It’s good to see your confidence in your mindful shopping evolve over the years…I remember you saying in an older video that you used to feel you needed to fill the gaps in colours in your lipstick collection but then realised there was a reason why you would buy new colours then not wear them much…you felt they did not suit you. It will be interesting to see how you approach what colours you pick going forward.

[@kalilili]

I'm basically always on a low buy because of the circumstances of my life and also personality traits and attitude towards spending money. But I loooooove seeing youtubers I love also live this way because I just feel so justified in my ways lmao!

[@kittenskneadingcompanions]

Personally I did a cleanup of my subscriptions on KZbin channels and categories. In the beauty category I unsubscribed to ones that had overly large collections and or pushed toward more buying and over consumption. To help myself in my decisions. I kept ones that inspired me to have a curated collection, mindful spending and or inspired me in a positive way. I can count those on 1 hand. I kinda looked at every category of channels this way. A personal decision to help me mentally and track what I'm my mind is consuming.

[@amandasjoberg463]

I need to clean up my subscriptions too but I have like hundrads (I don't dare to check)! For that reason my subscriptions no longer align with what I like watching and so I never click on the subscriptions tab, and only look at the homepage recommendations lol (edit : the people I watch regularly show up there anyways!)

[@Nicole-rx2fx]

I really like this thoughtful method of limiting purchases based on how much makeup you tend to use up in a year. Like you mentioned as well, impulse purchases decrease and you have to think about what enters your collection.

[@lainelee3632]

Your channel along with Rebecca Morgan and Swarna Ripari are the only beauty channels I enjoy watching regularly because of your focus on responsible makeup enjoyment. I like how you all geek out on counting makeup products, how much you spend, panning items and teaching us ways to be creative in using makeup. All these are more fun to watch, for those of us who are tired of buying, spending, then dumping, wasting things. Just like another commenter, I only search and watch reviews when I'm buying something new (very rarely) and need to know what ppl's thoughts are, otherwise the constant new makeup is just overwhelming to watch. My own experience have taught me that I never ever pan/finish lipsticks, blushes and eyeshadow pallettes so I've not owned any blushes now, using my lip products as blushes so I can also finish my lipstick (yes, only one) for the first time in my life 😅. This year I have panning goals and no buying except to replace. Do keep being you.

[@Jennifer_Ann]

I’m on a replacement only no-buy for makeup this year. It’s going well so far. I’m also trying to only buy 60 fashion items this year (clothing and accessories). Your iHerb ad came on after this video, how funny

[@MeetRaspberry]

I really enjoyed your past inventory videos & "what did I purchase this quarter" videos. I hope you include that segment in your make up spending or quarterly inventory updates. Really enjoy your low-buy + using what you have videos!

[@mariar3715]

I love this idea of putting a cap on categories for a low buy. It really makes a low buy approachable and to be very mindful of purchases.

[@petra1995]

Woah. During this video I decided to give myself a cap (maybe about 10 products total) throughout the year, not counting replacements of things I only have one of.

[@petra1995]

I bought 24 items in 2022 apparently (I keep a list, but I hadn't thought to count the items on the list). 84 in 2021 holy moly. I think I can cut last years in half and buy 12 (not counting mascara and other 1-to-1 replacements)!

[@7777bookterra]

Im loving how everyone is doing their no buy/low buy videos now its some of my fave content especially yours and when it comes to beauty/skincare etc... for my low buy wise im doing 10 orders/package wise in all areas my problem as im already fairly curated with smaller collections is to have a realistic amount of online orders and just be careful... also I got all the things I wanted dolls,board games,skincare,makeup etc... now is the time/year to enjoy them!

[@rmb.artistry]

Your background is so nice✨✨ love how the vase arrangement turned out

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Thank you!! I’m really happy with it too!

[@SarahJo]

Okay before I watch this: Your makeup looks especially beautiful today!

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Thank you Sarah!!

[@Gnv-q2m]

@@SarahRoseBeauty your skin is flawless

[@makeup_clau]

You look so pretty here! I mean, you always do, but I love the color of that top on you and that makeup 😍

[@flawedfabulous]

Great low buy ideas, I'm really trying to just be mindful and look within my collection first. Like I don't want to keep decluttering and then buying. You're for sure being reasonable with your goals

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

I totally know the struggle!! It's hard to focus on your collection when there's so much new makeup launching all the time!

[@SarahJo]

I think this sounds like a fun project! I'm not 100% sure what my yearly project is going to be, but I decided to do a no-buy for the first two months of the year (with some exceptions I decided on before), and then I'll go from there. I'm thinking of doing like no-buys with one allowed "shopping day" a month. That way if I really want something I can still get it, but I have to wait until that day to make a purchase that way I know I truly want the thing. I did that pretty successfully for a couple months last year.

[@pajamamama5965]

Good for you! I hope you have success with this mindful spending plan. I have quite a few blushes. I use them everyday on my cheeks, my nose and my hairline. The main reason is because my summer shades are different than my winter shades so I really only use them half a year and I like to have a pink, purple, Dusty Rose, terracotta, and Peach shades for each season plus I keep one in my purse. So that means I have at least 11 and those are just the powders not counting creams. I guess I don't need to buy any blush for a long time LOL

[@kirahavird9087]

Sarah, I am relatively new to your channel and enjoy your content. I know many people don't care to see makeup tutorials done anymore but I still LIVE for them!!! If you don't mind, please do a few for us that still enjoy tutorials. 😊

[@mamabear8373]

One of the most helpful things I've had done that has helped me buy and want way less makeup was a color analysis. I started with my clothes and then incorporated it to my makeup. It took away the desire to want it all, because I could see that if it wasn't cool toned it was not for me. It also has helped me downsize my collection and eliminate what doesn't suit me best.

[@wendyraye]

I’ve been saying I’m going to do this for at least 3 years now, but with inflation I think I’m going to stick to it. Still getting sucked into Ulta half off! I don’t need another blush, highlighter, bronzer, or eyeshadow palette for the rest of my life.

[@freckledklutz]

I love the brown top with your makeup look its stunning! And I am on a low buy as well. I don't have a number limit so much as I have a rule of 1 in 1 out to keep myself accountable. I am also on a fragrance and foundation no buy till I use two of each up to stop myself from being impulsive. I have brought in one concealer so far that's it. And I relate so much to your blush number - I am panning a blush and have found that I need to finish one so I can see the number drop but also the satisfaction is so good for finishing things.

[@jessicalevy2415]

I really love videos where you talk through your process of deciding what to buy. It’s really helpful to listen to someone with similar values explain their thought process.

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

I will have to do more of those in 2023!❤️

[@dubsbeautydiary]

I love the limits you set for yourself and I also love that you’re forgiving. It’s not the end of the world if you buy 4 shadow sticks vs 3. Thanks for sharing your goals!

[@dubsbeautydiary]

Also I love your eye look in this video! Your eyes look so big and beautiful!!

[@aizkirad3251]

I don't know if this has already been mentionned in that GRWM about low consumption but I kinda wanted to share an idea/opinion. I think another important part about this "consumerism" (to me) is that i feel like this low buy targets mostly the purchase of new items (and PR would fall into the same type of consumerism) and not second hand make up. I would really love to see a video about no-buy groups, how do they work, how it can be a way to potentially explore new makeup without supporting the brands directly (might not be possible for an "influencer" since the brand is still blasted on the packaging but still) or creating new demand and still having the benefit of lesser cost. Is there a "safe" way to purchase second hand makeup ? Is it always a bit of a gamble because you never really know (maybe it's a bit of a touchy subject to make recommendations, i really don't know) ? Maybe something to explore if you find it interesting !

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Yes!! I’m thinking about doing a video trying secondhand makeup!

[@EarthlyBeauty]

@@SarahRoseBeauty I would love this, I've been wanting to look into it but don't know where to go.

[@amandajollylines]

First of all, this eyeshadow on you: Amazing. hahaha. Could the blue of your eyes pop more? I think not. lol. Second of all: Love this way of thinking about how you want to intake product this year. I look forward to hearing how you think about what you're bringing in, whether this ends up feeling limiting or freeing, etc. And thirdly: Reviews really aren't why I come to your channel (though I do love your opinions). Actually, that parenthetical IS one of the reasons I love coming to your channel, and it's actually watching your feelings and opinions evolve and change the more you use products you already own. I mean, I think that's the relatable journey most of us go through. I love seeing you rediscover things, or change what feels like "you", or get into a groove with certain products. Also, the amount of times that I've felt better about my own rollercoaster relationship with something because you've said, "I used to think I LOVED this, but NOW?" haha. Too many to count. So yes, love this thinking and this direction! :D

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Oh thank you!!🥹 I often worry that people get bored of me using the same products over and over 😅 but this comment was very reassuring! ❤️ and oh yes I am all too familiar with the roller coaster of relationships with products lol

[@EarthlyBeauty]

I have been watching a lot of Emily Noels old videos from like 10 years ago and she did a lot of tips and tricks videos for different parts of your makeup routine like applying mascara and lipliner tips etc... I would love to see more of this on your channel. I know you already do your 'how to use products in different ways' videos which I loved! And I want more! Even if you haven't tried the tips before, trying them with us and learning together is always fun like in your 'trying different techniques' videos :) Maybe color theory or how to coordinate your eyeshadow to your blush and lip color would be fun too because not everyone has an eye for that right off the bat and might need help.

[@cheyreimer7770]

I loved hearing your mindset about consuming, and you're absolutely right. I have other channels that I go to for reviews, especially for comparisons, because those are people that are trying so many things that come out and explaining nuanced differences between products (I'm thinking of Kackie especially). But I can't always watch those videos, because it can be overwhelming and sometimes even stressful, so your channel is one that I go to for easy watching. I still take note of your opinion on products and have often bought (or avoided) products because of your recommendation, but that's not the main reason I'm here. It's a place where I can go to listen to someone talk about makeup and enjoy makeup without feeling like I need to buy anything new.

[@ksanela]

love your content because you aren't always reviewing and trying to sell me new stuff...I learn about new makeup against my will by watching 99% of makeup content on YT or TikTok so seeing you reuse stuff that's no longer super new is refreshing

[@SReid111]

Absolutely adore the colours used in your make up today. Im INSPIRED to adapt this for my skin tone for work tomorrow! Beautiful!

[@kodysmama]

Thanks Sarah….I needed to hear this. Last year I really got into makeup and started enjoying it and bought way too much!!! As a stay at home Mom I don’t get to wear it all that often. I have multiples and multiples of each category. I would watch everyone’s review videos & go buy all the new items & I have collected way too much. This year, I am on an absolute NO BUY!!!

[@rosieauger]

I love your channel for these types of videos! Curating your collection, using what you have, overview of trends in your collection ^_^ ❤

[@amandabaker7735]

This is perfect! I'm going on a journey to minimize and spend less. Makeup is something I seem to collect. I'm going to go a step farther and cap what I own. In order to do this I need to know how long it takes to use up products if I truly use it daily, which is my project this year! Great video and thank you for the spreadsheet

[@Emma-ws5wq]

Highly recommend the r.e.m beauty lipsticks! I have both a skinny and a shorter tubed one, but both are soft, satin formulas. Drive in Movie is a perfect rose pink (I am very pale) and Twisted is a great neutral red. Also my best nude is Revlon Mink (slightly cool toned). 💛

[@evelinagutauskaite2657]

I don't have a lot of makeup (below 30 products), but I am going on a replacement only no buy, because even though I wear makeup everyday I am very lighthanded on my makeup and only use up below 5 products in a year, so increasing the number of products that I have would only mean that more of my makeup would go bad

[@maru45382]

Awesome system for a low buy, good luck! The background looks great with the decorations on the shelf.👏🏽😊

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Thank you Maru!!❤

[@alexandravoicu6]

It’s always a pleasure watching your videos ❤ you are one of the most genuine people I follow and I actually enjoy all of your content, so thank you very much for the work you put into it!

[@ursulahansen7478]

I absolutely love this so much!!!! Thank you for inspiring me to add some categories to my own makeup inventory. I want be mindful as well with spending and using what I have. And what I bring into my collection.

[@BeautyAndTheFrizz]

Hi there! New here! Totally understand the feeling of not wanting to review and also wanting to really enjoy your collection. I loved hearing about your no buy rules and love that many content creators are heading in a similar direction!

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Ahhh I recently discovered your channel too and have been loving your videos! And yeah, it can get really overwhelming to have to buy things for review especially as a small channel 😭

[@claudiaprandelli7141]

I LOVE THIS SPREADSHEET!! I’ve downloaded immediately.. I’ve created mine this year for both skincare and makeup as this year I’m in a low buy.. I’m also checking all my empties vs expenses, and I’m so happy that I can follow your journey with your spreadsheet too ❤️❤️

[@MoonlitSunflower]

I've decided to do a replacement no buy for makeup until Black Friday sales. It might be tough, but I did it for about 3 months last year. It's not no, just not right now. I dont have a cap set or budget yet for the Black Friday sales but eventually I'll decide what is appropriate.

[@jolanda.c]

I splurged around black friday and need to use and declutter first. So I allow myself to get something as a Valentine gift, a Birthdaygift, motherdaygift and souvenir for myself. But for the rest I'm only allowing myself to rebuy empties in beauty, skincare, bodycare, haircare until next Black friday. And then I give myself a budget to splurge.

[@anniehansen1185]

Your makeup looks beautiful!! ☺️

[@mariaalvarez3525]

this is a super pretty makeup look!

[@estherbraun3479]

Loved the video! And this lipstick color suits you perfectly!

[@sashaasashaa]

Was about to buy makeup and your video distracted me! Thanks for all the mindful shopping content💕

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

❤️❤️❤️

[@UnpurrfectRobyn]

Thank you for sharing your spreadsheet! I think it'll really help me to keep track of what I have and what I'm buying! I decluttered a ton of really old makeup during the pandemic and really built up my collection in the last year or so, so I'm definitely on a low buy this year. I will replace things as I run out and be very intentional about any additional purchases. PS Your kitty meowing in the video was cute and relatable to this fellow cat mom (I have 2!).

[@GillenMeg]

Ooo, I might have to use that spreadsheet! For the past two years, I've allowed myself to buy one palette a month, if that - last year I only ended up buying two. I had a "one in, one out" policy for the rest of the categories in my collection. I want to try new brands, though, so I'm thinking it makes more sense to set a cap for each category this year, too. Thanks for always being inspiring, Sarah! ✨

[@taramisu9978]

I think a purchase cap is a great idea! I have a yearly budget amount but maybe I will incorporate some sort of cap in there too. Thanks for sharing, great video!

[@OneandaHalfReviews]

Good luck! I love watching these videos! I am doing something similar I've got some categories that are no buy for 6 months and others just being mindful so I don't put pressure on myself as I'm not worried too much about growing my collection but I'm focusing this year on my older products and I've set my goals based on how many products I want to use up and project panning this year. Going to see how this goes for 6months maybe the year than change my rules if I find I'm spending too much. I love seeing everyone's versions, it's so inspiring 💞💞

[@shellierichards7128]

Any suggestions for using all the TONS of samples? I try to declutter and "project pan" this items also. Sometimes I'll use travel sizes up before buying another full size skincare.

[@Randilynn66]

Love your eye look. Stunning.

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Thank you!!❤

[@meloncreamy1100]

I like your lip color so much!

[@meloncreamy1100]

Also like your low buy idea so much!

[@scentedbeauty]

Thanks for sharing your template!! So helpful!! I come to your channel for you so whatever you want to film, I’ll watch 💖

[@jacquiking]

I love this idea! 😊

[@sydneyrrobertson]

If you pick up some other powder blush colors to try, I would reccommend Peach Primrose in the Flower Beauty Flower Pots blush. I know you love Sweet Pea already. The warm peachy orange color is my favorite! I was thinking it would look really nice with this eye look too!

[@basswoodbeauty]

I love this strategy! Also your makeup in this video is gorgeous 😍

[@ameenaola8872]

How about calling it an allowance instead of a limit? It feels more positive in a way. I'm putting myself on a 6 month no buy for colored cosmetics (so eyeshadow, lipstick and blush). Wish me luck! I really want to concentrate on finishing up some things.

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Ohh I like "allowance" better!! And good luck on your no buy; you got this! 👏

[@MarthaBlaire]

Thanks so much for sharing that document! It's inspired me to write down my low buy rules!

[@amandasjoberg463]

Loove spreadsheets 😍😍 Also, the key for my successful low-buy is to not think about makeup that much! I know this is not an option for you as this is your job, but it works for me as a "normal" consumer. (I now realize that I actually bought NO makeup last year! Unintentionally! Has never happened before 😯 wait no, 1 lip gloss! )I tend to stick to a product that works for me, use it up (which takes like 3 years for a foundation 😆, then maybe try something new after much research, or buy the same if I still love it, not just like it. Btw know any ggood concealers? I'm looking!)

[@_corrine12_]

I'm saving to buy a tiny house, so I am on a no buy!

[@Yvette.T]

Hard and fast rules/restrictions don't really work for me either 🤪 This sounds like a great plan for 2023. I'm sure you'll stick to these numbers with no problems 🥰 BTW: This whole look is 😍🤩

[@meghannpalmer7417]

I’ll be low buy on skincare😂. Gotta use this stuff up. Then I’ll permit myself to buy more and what I feel are products working for my skin

[@marianne6373]

You can do sort of reviews without buying anything new. Like top five or top ten products. Also, as someone who doesn’t follow trends religiously, I don’t care if you don’t review the latest viral hype. I would be just as interested in a more random product you tried and loved.

[@Emma-ws5wq]

These are the best videos! Especially when there's a lot of swatching too.

[@sunshinegirl2015]

Ooh yes or more in-depth review/how to use this product well on a product you've used consistently over a greater amount of time.

[@BelleStreetBoyz]

I'm kind of in a similar place as you with lip products - I'm on a strict low buy, but I desperately need a bit of a refresh in the lip category. Hunting for nudes that work for me is so stressful, though.. 🤦🏻‍♀️ I'm considering just making an appointment at the Bite Beauty Lip Lab and having one custom made. Even though it costs more upfront, I wouldn't be surprised if it's cheaper in the long run when I buy so many lipsticks hunting for "the perfect one." Thanks for sharing, Sarah! 😸💜🌷

[@meghannpalmer7417]

I thought Bite beauty went out of business?

[@BelleStreetBoyz]

@@meghannpalmer7417 They don't have their makeup line anymore, but their Lip Lab locations are still open! I think the brand pretty much just shifted their focus toward expanding their Lip Labs. They've opened several more locations in the past couple years. ☺️

[@Erismire1]

❤

[@7777bookterra]

The only collection im not happy with is my nail polish collection as it was non existent but, I wanna be careful there to and not be like I have none time to get 100 lol

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Haha nail polish is such a tough one!! I’m always tempted whenever I see a color I don’t have 😅

[@joaovermelho0084]

FIRST