2024 BMW 5 Series Review // Trading Sport for Luxury?

[@noob.168]

No acoustic glass??? Even the Camry and Sonata have acoustic windshield and front side windows available.

[@arslan479]

It’s so good you are reviewing the germans. They are mad for these in the UK. As a Lexus fan i know you will compare them objectively. I personally don’t think this 5 series will age well.

[@danielshahbaz5017]

I'm a big Lexus fan, but they do not offer a sedan anything like this. When the GS was discontinued, it did a lot of damage to Lexus midsize sport sedan segment. IF Lexus brought back the GS to battle these 5 series, that would be a dream come true. I rather have the new BMW 2024 540 version of this car than any current Lexus sedan.

[@ryans7097]

Knew some of those buildings looked familiar… used to live down there. Looking forward to reviews on the new x3 when that comes out. Thanks for the review!

[@electrikoptik]

If a 4 cylinder 5-series is all you can afford, then you shouldn't be buying a 5-series. But keeping up with the Jones is one helluva drug.

[@CzarPharo]

Which one should someone be able to afford in your opinion?

[@l.seventh7954]

By itself, the 530i is decent, but imo the base 5 series should be a 535i with the B58 producing around 300hp. B48 is a great engine, but a mid-size luxury sedan would be much better suited for a more powerful base engine. This car’s B48 variant is great for the base US 3 series, but for a base 5, a detuned B58 would be much better.

[@faheemabbas3965]

Many people want BMW to go out of business. But then I remember that we need competition in the luxury auto space. But then I remember that “luxury” cars are starting to become not worth it with the exception of some Lexuses. But then I remember that German luxury cars being unreliable makes German cars not exist to me. But then…

[@mrgurulittle7000]

But then I remember how ugly BMWs are. And then I remember how much better an Acura and Lexus looks.

[@blackjack21477]

Lexus has no place in luxury in today’s market. Have you seen their latest products?! They’re Toyota + now. The don’t even have differentiating designs anymore. This is coming from someone who used to love lexus but not so much anymore. Kinda gets old to wait and wait and wait for them to release a product that caters to a younger demographic who isnt won over with the bare minimum. BMW on the other hand, they kicking ass but cost cutting is starting to affect them to

[@mrgurulittle7000]

@@blackjack21477You obviously don’t appreciate the subtle details of Lexus that makes them luxury. BMW cuts costs mechanically left and right with plastic oil pans, hoses, engine casings, etc. But Lexus is mechanically solid but not quite as nice with the interior in some cases. Lexus is definitely more worthy of luxury than BMW because Lexus cuts costs bits that don’t affect reliability like BMW does. BMW is a cheap car mechanically with all the gimmicks to make it look better than a Lexus. That’s the difference I’d say

[@Mylifeislegendary982vd3-vl]

​@@blackjack21477 new Lexus products are world class luxury vehicles and good as any Mercedes BMW Audi and more. Every single Lexus is miles different from any Toyota from every level. these days I am not surprised to see nonsense and invalid comments like you have posted.

[@Mylifeislegendary982vd3-vl]

​@@mrgurulittle7000 agree people have gone nuts These days in social media. Sometimes I think people don't have eyes anyone

[@MrBigBoy4Life]

Geez! $70K for a 4 banger?

[@electrikoptik]

Especially crazy that the 4 banger 530i starts at 57K. Who tf would option a 530i to 70k? I would just get the 540i without options at the starting price of 64K and call it a day.

[@witsendcottage595]

A sucker is born every minute

[@KirkKreifels]

This.

[@PatrickWallNeo]

This used to be M5 money.

[@Dillingham-]

$75k if it says ‘Land Cruiser’

[@Rissybear]

I have always liked BMW but haven’t owned one past 1 year. X3 M40i… what are your thoughts on reliability on of the X3/X4.. BMW SUVs? I definitely don’t like the new look of the 2025 X3.. this 5 series looks great.. I think BMW is leaning towards luxury, if someone wants a bit more connection to the road you gotta go Porsche 😊

[@PaulTC97]

If you want a fun "light" sporty reliable SUV get a BMW X3 with the B58 engine or get a used Porsche Macan 252hp (reliable VW/audi engine) and get an ECU tune if you feel like its not powerful enough. The base Macan is very reliable, tunable, parts are cheap, it has the famous Porsche PDK gearbox and it handles better than the V6 Macans. BMW X3 and Porsche Macan are the best handling mid size SUVs.

[@KuyaArbee]

if it's that B48 engine VARIANT! that 4 cylinder is still a very good engine! the 5 series is brilliant! not everyone wants to LEASE the highest trim or specs....

[@KirkKreifels]

Good engine. Just inadequate for this car's price imo.

[@stea2494]

I love my bmw x5 compared to my old lexus rx loaded with tech and luxuries

[@barron204]

I wanted to be more impressed by a new BMW. Sales of the 5 have been so low over the past 10/15 years in my country BMW now only sell the I5 electric M60.

[@noahkim8377]

Kirk! How is the new 530i compared to is500 or is350? Are the Is brothers sportier/more powerful than this 4 cylinder beemer?

[@KirkKreifels]

Is is a 3/4 series rival. This is an ES rival, sort of.

[@ToddRGuy]

@@KirkKreifelsExcept for the fact that Lexus engines are sleepy, anemic dogs and they no longer offer a 6 cylinder. Hard pass.

[@Mylifeislegendary982vd3-vl]

New E CLASS 👑👑 is very much the class leader in it's segment but new 5 series is Also brilliant and legendary has always.

[@jsz2619]

They still haven't fixed the asphalt at the north end of Vanderbilt Dr. at Bonita Beach Rd.

[@ToddRGuy]

Great review! Couldn’t find a 540 optioned the way I want it, so I ordered a 2025. You’re definitely right about the contrast between the B58 and the B48; like night and day.

[@ericgonzalez3897]

Money to burn? Sure, go for it. Otherwise, 3 series would be a nice choice. And the back taillights are Accord like.

[@serbzero]

Wait... so not only Asian (Korean, Japanese) rides channel? what happened? :)

[@KirkKreifels]

It's mostly Asian autos but they don't exist in a bubble and need to be compared with all cars. Honestly I'd take a TLX type S over this 530i, ES 350 too. Need to try the 540i still.

[@Netachi]

@@KirkKreifels The variety is appreciated. Please continue Kirk!

[@alengreen589]

in Germany it´s only a premium Car and in the US a high and Luxury Car, it´s weird 😅

[@ludovicdjomo8909]

It is because it is a German car. In the same way, Ford and Jeep are considered luxury in Europe, whereas Ford is a mainstream brand in the US.

[@alengreen589]

@@ludovicdjomo8909 Ford is far away to be premium or luxury in the EU and for Jeep only the big SUV´s are premium the smaller one´s are mainstream.

[@jamesshepherd8565]

These German car companies have started to cut so many corners. The new e class doesn't come standard with rear seat air vents.

[@dsdddsd4543we]

How do you feel about this 5 Series vs Current Gen Lexus ES F Sport?

[@KirkKreifels]

ES is a better buy.

[@twistedsneaks1932]

E39 530i also hid the exhaust like that, just not dual

[@avdp9095]

Like every new Bmw, step back regarding quality, materials and paint job, unfortunatly....much critics in Europe at the moment

[@clbernier2]

Is this your first time in a BMW? You complained about so many things that would go away if you actually got to know the car or knew BMWs. That small EV is to make the Stop/Start seamless and unnoticeable. It’s good enough for the Autobahn!!!!!

[@GordonPotter]

I would end up using voice controls to get through the HVAC process. E.G. "Cabin temp 72 degrees." It does have voice commands I assume.

[@BJ-sb9rk]

Dang doesn’t even have sun shades for the price smh

[@amode8761]

Rear legroom is very poor for something near 5 metres long… the benefits of FWD set up makes a lot of sense after seeing how much you get in the 5 series… my parents have the recently replaced Camry and it feels limo like in leg room. I wonder if a A6 would be more FWD legroom or RWD

[@mrgurulittle7000]

Kirk, do Volkswagens next.👍

[@subieasunayuuki]

I'm not really a fan of BMWs new design era 😢 The last gen 5 series was the last proper 5 series. Along with the last gen M5

[@JoeySavage]

this base car comes with dubs aka 20 inch rims most cars come with 15 to 18 inch rims omg

[@jazzbeau507]

Great that BMW said hello to Kirk with the honks.

[@jr1885]

The car honked because it auto locks when you walk away. Normally it just beeps. The double honk means I locked but you left me running.

[@AbronHawkins]

BMW: The Ultimate Money Pit Machine

[@witsendcottage595]

B M W. Bowel Movement Works

[@takaradope]

Honestly get a tlx type s or an es over this

[@KirkKreifels]

Yes I agree. G80 too.

[@anjdog2003]

Other BMW's to get for the same price or less, no thank you

[@MR3DDev]

I love japanese cars, but the tech on these bimmers has no equal. On another note I still dont get why sunroof is standard on luxury car, that makes the car be super hot during most part of the year

[@saranrathakrish8468]

Is the inline 6 version available in Canada

[@paulnetter4323]

No, it's not.

[@stuartfisher1640]

Beautiful vehicle but has a questionable reliability history

[@Gadfly2025]

BMW has substantially improved to top. MB has gone way down

[@LeoTheShortGuy]

Awesome

[@saranrathakrish8468]

I can’t find the 540i on the Canadian website

[@jamesshepherd8565]

Blame climate activists

[@MichaelAllen-td1uu]

No map pockets? No maps either. Went the way of the CD player.

[@oneblach]

So this a $70k mid size sedan and you still have to crawl in the the back seat and shove your feet under the front seat. Absolutely abhorrent. Now I know why Camry and Accord are so popular.

[@blackjack21477]

Bruhhh try the 540i. It makes such a difference. WHY ISNT BMW PROMOTING IT

[@jamesshepherd8565]

Climate activists

[@paulhenry913]

This or the new e-class?

[@Mylifeislegendary982vd3-vl]

New E class

[@jamesshepherd8565]

Neither. The new e class has major software issues. And this is a cheaply made toy.

[@will.davlin]

Wool socks to bed = most vivid dreams possible🟣🟤

[@chibbyylol]

What in the world

[@Ohv111]

Comfy

[@gamelauncher9821]

I'm getting a 4cyl for that cost I getting the 6cyl

[@loki_wolff]

Not huge on that futuristic electrified look. I'd be more into an electrified car looking normal.

[@deluxelex9056]

$70k for 4 cylinders and 255 hp 🤣🤣🤣

[@nebojsavojvodic6781]

For 75k I'd get a ES300h as a daily and a Miata for fun. This is ridiculously overpriced

[@rrcbiker]

70k without ventilated seats? no thank you

[@mj28inpa]

It’s ridiculous that they put 4cyl in that car.. what a disappointment and a waste of money..

[@user-iz3gv5vo6b]

The standard front end looks much better. Too much money for a 4 banger with questionable reliability, and large future maintenance costs.

[@davidxavier1396]

This thing is WAY WAY WAY OVER PRICED by about $20k

[@lchanceiv]

Beautiful exterior and hideous interior. The exact opposite of Mercedes

[@KirkKreifels]

I'm not the biggest fan of Mercedes interiors or exteriors.