2024 BMW X5 xDrive40i Vs. 2024 Lexus RX 500h F-Sport - Sporty & Sophisticated Luxury Rivals!

Both the #BMWX5 and #LexusRX are two of the most popular luxury SUV's in America and both have a long lineage that dates back to 1999 and 2000. The #Lexus has always been the more reliable comfort oriented model, while #BMW has always been the sportier option. However, the #LexusRX500h wants to attract a younger buyer who would otherwise get the #X5, so has Lexus managed to catch its more athletic German rival?
We're also on:
Instagram: / redline_reviews
Facebook: / liketheredline
Twitter: / tweettheredline

[@theredline]

Happy Monday guys! We hope you all had a wonderful weekend. While Lexus may always seem outclassed next to a BMW, the latest RX 500h F-Sport Performance has the BMW X5 centered in its crosshairs and while the two may not seem like natural rivals, the specs show both to be quite similar on paper. Which one would you choose for yourself? Let us know below!

[@naveenthemachine]

Nope. The RX is still outclassed. Not just by the x5 but just about any other competitor in the segment you can think of. Lexus can redesign their entire portfolio of cars 500 times and it’ll still fail miserably to compete with the current generation competition If they want to compete they have to make an exclusive RWD platform but we know that’ll never happen as Lexus is trying to go out of business

[@CarGeek360]

Like naveenthemachine said, the X5 is far superior to the RX, I liked the last gen RX but the new one is not it

[@naveenthemachine]

@@CarGeek360 the last gen was nicer but that’s all it really had tbh. The rest of the RX was well below par vs other competitors And this new one is even worse

[@CarGeek360]

@@naveenthemachine the last gen RX was nice but after 2020 it felt dated, idec about the interior of the new gen RX bc the exterior is SO ugly

[@naveenthemachine]

@@CarGeek360 I think the RX now has the worst interior in the class. Hyundai Kia Mazda etc do a better job at interior

[@scriptozavr]

I was considering these two, I did a test drive of the RX and it was good, but then I drove the X5 and immediately fell in love with it and put an order for it!

[@CarGeek360]

The X5 is incredible, my dad is going to order one with all the options later this summer

[@gosman949]

you can not order a RX because they are selling everything the dealers can get. Ordering a BMW would be a nice add but shows they are not as popular!

[@Natethegreat200c]

@@gosman949because every biased “trusted” outlet tells people to buy a Lexus. If those fake news outlets never existed and people were left to their own devices I don’t think Lexus cars would be as popular as they are. Popular or not, they are terrible cars for the money.

[@olympbarca3313]

​​@@CarGeek360the x5 40i I guess

[@AgonxOC]

@@gosman949What a nonsense comment. The X5 sells like hot cakes and often times you DO have to order one to get what you want in options. The X5 is the BEST selling LUXURY SUV in the market.

[@blazinmark1]

As an owner of literally both. I own a 2024 X5 50e and we returned my wife's Q5 lease and opted for the 2024 Lexus RX350. I can honestly say for 99% of the population the RX is plenty of car. I wanted the X5 M60i, but was told I had to build one, so I opted for the X5 50e. Both amazing vehicles.

[@MilesAnastasios87]

Thing is, the actual owners of a Lexus RX are very happy with their vehicle and the ones who have never driven it, say it's no good 😅

[@gosman949]

@@MilesAnastasios87 yep- Blazmark has more money than sense!

[@twfinc6855]

@@MilesAnastasios87 I love my RX500h.. its fantastic, quiet, refined, quick when needed.. perfect for me, but I would take a X5 50e over it for sure !! but also a lot more $$$, not sure why reviewer is comparing the X5 and RX.. X3 seems more same size as RX.

[@michaels7984]

​@twfinc6855 they are both two row, mid size suvs, x3 is a compact suv.

[@primetime1507]

As an owner of both, BMWs are great when the warranty is active, but mechanical nightmares once expired. For that reason, Lexus all day!

[@chibonics101]

This video feels like it was taylor-made for me. Great job!

[@brenrob7403]

Spot on! Exactly the comparison I was looking for!!

[@dstevens518]

Good comparison. All the years of experience has you at the point where you can seemingly knock out a detailed, relevant, and unbiased look at both, and give us viewers an accurate take on what we can expect. If I had more money than I knew what to do with, I'd go BMW. Otherwise, I doubt I'd feel shortchanged with the Lexus.

[@johndiaz4663]

People will just right away to BMW which yes BMW is much better driving etc etc but long term the Lexus will hold it value more and be more reliable

[@Inlitener]

Lexus lost me when they lost the V6! Save the V6's! ✊

[@ChrisMa-ls1bj]

it's slow V6. That's why they get rid of V6 on RX500.

[@michaelpluznick]

Very good review. Answered all my questions and easy to understand! In all the videos the interior looks amazing.

[@tantikhan7193]

Being drive German made cars for quite long times, as getting older i need the suv which give me peace of mind and low maintenance cost to travel anywhere.... so i choose Lexus to suit my purpose BMW Look aggressive Excellent drive perf High maintenance cost Lexus Look exlusive Nice to drive & good perf Refine & comfort Less maintenance cost

[@karacha]

Nice review, enjoyed it very much! Lexus is a nice car, but in this comparison it doesn't look that great. X5 looks better/more modern inside and out, the engine and the transmission are top notch. Basically, it's a "nice car vs the best SUV in the segment" video. BMW wins it handily, they are on a mission lately.

[@peterj5751]

Until the warranty runs out and then BMW provides a different type of excitement.

[@jazperlit1156]

25 years in a row, Lexus RX holds the crown for being the best selling Luxury SUV and with this new generation, there’s no way any other car could compete cuz that RX 500H F Sport is pure perfection. What a Beauty! Lexus, The relentless pursuit of perfection. #Lexus👑

[@fenglin6095]

In Australia, Rx is way behind X5. X5 always top selling in its class.

[@DeputyDog-mh1yo]

The Lexus gives me peace of mind, the Bimmer gives my mechanic a Caribbean holiday.

[@kristians2704]

the X5 is very reliable

[@kobedabest]

Tell that to the 100k recall Toyota just did. 😅

[@AgonxOC]

I can tell you are stuck in some alternate world. The X5 is extremely reliable as with most modern BMWs dating back a decade. That is why BMW has been topping the reliability charts.

[@DeputyDog-mh1yo]

@@AgonxOCBMW has improved, but Lexus is still #1

[@AgonxOC]

@@DeputyDog-mh1yo not for this luxury SUV market the X5 takes the win, CR says so.

[@alzinifelshoni2602]

I like both vehicles. You can already find both 2024 models, slightly used, for around $60k, which is the route I would take.

[@freshcobangladesh1934]

You are really really the best car reviewer I ever seen! So thorough. You did not miss anything.

[@SS1LE_Urien]

Right as I'm eyeing this exact X5 trim this video comes out.... Thank you

[@MyThemeParkFanatic]

You won’t be disappointed, but once you get one, it’s hard to ever go to anything else. 👍

[@prose7909]

I got one a month ago and I’m absolutely loving it!!!

[@dtay8913]

I like the design inside and out a lot more on the BMW

[@PRS-dk4mz]

I test drive both. While I really wanted to love the Lexus, I couldn’t come away, objectively and subjectively picking it over the X5. I ended up buying the X5 X40i with the M Sport package. You do end up paying more, but the BMW is a whole league better especially when you move up a bit in trim and options. BMW has figured out this X5 formula for daily driving and utility.

[@douglaszaflow9859]

Just test drove the RX350 today, it was very sluggish, no fun at all. Will drive the 500 tomorrow, it should be a lot better. X5 is a better lease option for me!

[@Abavyy]

@@douglaszaflow9859how did it go

[@twfinc6855]

as owner of 2023 RX500h, i agree.. but the X5 is quite a big bigger not sure why they are comparing them in the review.. In canada the RX cost me 83k... the X5 I was looking at was $106k.. big difference but it was nicer in most ways. I just like the nimble aspect of the RX size etc.. and its big enough for me

[@CarGeek360]

Oh you chose the best option, my dad is getting the same car with all the options later this year (best SUV under $90k imo, GLE is the worst)

[@alilove3109]

Totally agree!

[@Niles-Guy]

Wish you added the GLE & MDX too for a four way comparison

[@DeeeBeee123]

No. Too many at once

[@normt430]

More RDX category in size. But the 2019 Acura is long in the tooth today and more premium than luxury.

[@electrikoptik]

The BMW you lease. The Lexus you buy.

[@naveenthemachine]

No now the bmw you buy. Lexus has problems with their turbo engines

[@starbai3619]

Welcome to 2024. Where Lexus has more trouble these days than (B58 equipped) BMWs. Dead serious in this comparison your statement should be the exact opposite.

[@CarGeek360]

Nope, newer BMWs are reliable if you avoid the V8s and PHEVs

[@G-Rated]

@@starbai3619 they’re brainwashed sheep that have been conditioned to believe and push that Japanese propaganda bs regardless of the actual real world reliability. 🤡

[@grand__tour]

@@starbai3619 you don't mean all Lexus models, because I doubt engines like 2gr-fks will have more issues than b58.

[@Numberone292]

Imagine if you will, a trip to a local hospital carrying your love one in your arms It’s 3am, and the temperatures have dropped to 13 degrees Fahrenheit You have these two cars in your driveway The hospital is 4 hours away Which one would you trust more?

[@dailyrant4068]

What a weird question. No one ever thinks like this

[@scooter5940]

4 hours away? Call medivac for a helicopter. Buy the BMW.

[@heemie16]

@@dailyrant4068😂

[@scottsong20]

You buy a Lexus, you lease a BMW

[@wjoseph-rx9mj]

Same here

[@pete23234]

@@wjoseph-rx9mj I bought both...2020 rx450h and then i bought recently the 2024 X50e lol

[@gosman949]

@@pete23234 haha some people have more money than sense!

[@pete23234]

@@gosman949 BMW is now ranked 2nd behind Toyota in reliability. I also had a 2014 3 series for 10 years and it never gave me any problems...

[@justSTUMBLEDupon]

@@pete23234how’s it going? lol

[@ThePrevious1234]

I honestly don’t think Lexus or BMW is targeting the same buyer. Target market is very different between both cars; this isn’t to say people wouldn’t cross shop them but I think the person buying either vehicle will have very, very different preferences. At the end of the day, both are amazing choices. I’m a die hard Lexus fan but I think I would go with the BMW depending on how a test drive goes. I’ve long admired the X5 as a favourite in the BMW lineup.

[@Sam-og4nq]

Great video as always. I have RX500h, but thinking about switching to 50e. How’s cabin noise if you compare these cars? When you drive on highway, which one is more quiet?

[@Ryan2022]

Stay away from plug-in hybrid you’re not impressing anyone by the way

[@jeffsena9140]

You said “the BMW is not the M sport version “ many times! You should have compared an M Sport version. I have one for $2,300 you get bigger brakes,adaptive suspension, sportier exterior and interior design to mention just a few. It drives and handles well, is fast and gets good fuel economy for a big SAV. You get free maintenance for three years and reliability has improved tremendously according to CR. What’s not to like except maybe price. Skip the executive package and ventilated seats and you’re in the Mid $70’s price wise. More utility, faster and sportier. BMW is the winner!

[@AgonxOC]

The Luxury and M-sport X5 get the same brakes. The bigger brakes on the M-sport are an option, unless that was changed in the last two years and I was not aware. The regular car also has adaptive suspension and BMW offered a deal to activate it (to change the modes) via connected store a while back. I like the ventilated seats in mine. I also like the merino leather and massaging seats.

[@xavierrobinson200]

BMW X5 is the best in class. Imo

[@CarGeek360]

And that’s why my dad is ordering one soon 😊

[@ebenoit72]

Agreed!

[@DeeeBeee123]

They're overrated, they ride sporty not smooth. There are too many on the road.

[@AgonxOC]

@@DeeeBeee123another nonsense comment. X5 are the best selling luxury SUV in the market. Despite the high price tag, they sell like hot cakes. They ride quite smooth (I own an M-Sport with adaptive M-Suspension and it’s not far off the air suspension offered in the model, that’s how smooth it is) and the suspension can be change at the click of a button to make it firm and sporty. I can tell you have NEVER driven one of these based on your false narrative.

[@CarGeek360]

@@DeeeBeee123 this is such a lie, my dad and I test drove 2 2024 X5s and a 2025 X5, all of them rode incredibly smooth, my dad will be ordering his own 2025 X5 later this summer, it’s an impressive SUV

[@aqibjaved1508]

Are you going to post a separate review of the bmw x5? Please please do

[@theredline]

Yup!! It will post later this week! Stay tuned! 😊

[@anthonybrown7726]

Spot On reviews! Summary is BMW you Lease and Lexus you Buy!😊

[@Santi17466]

Lexus definitely takes the interior when it comes to the screens integration. . The BMW screens looks like an afterthought and literally looks what Mercedes was doing 10 years ago.

[@petegalindez9961]

Can’t go wrong with either. Loved my X5. Now own the 500h. Get the 450h for the plug. X5 needs an outside refresh. As long as they leave off the beaver teef grill. I followed exactly what you recommended. I leased the X5 but now want a car to keep a long time with low maintenance, so bought the 500h. Spot on.

[@zzhong23]

Excellent comparison. However, I would take poor man X5 CX70 over these two. The best bang for the buck.

[@jansingh9680]

Great comparison review and very comprehensive indeed, also a very fair and unbiased review.

[@vladovsiannikov1059]

Nothing to compare. I owned both, currently driving the X5. Lexus not even close

[@MilesAnastasios87]

Both great luxury SUVs! Bmw better in performance/driving. Lexus better on build quality, hybrid system, reliability, economy, offroading, resale price - and its still quick and handles great. For me the Lexus wins

[@kristians2704]

i’d say the phev x5 beats any lexus hybrid system and also the RX offroading?

[@MilesAnastasios87]

@@kristians2704 the plug in hybrid combined with the Lexus hybrid in 450h is better, sorry. Yes Toyota has strong tradition in off-roading, see videos the RX is very good also

[@WYLNXCA]

@@kristians2704 lol imagine saying BMW has better hybrid when they only started making them recently, whereas Toyota created hybrid. Every other brands are copycat to Toyota. If ya dont even know any history, Toyota built its first car as a hybrid in the prius, when no other brands had it. Just imagine saying BMW hybrids are better. Pathetic and funny.

[@kristians2704]

@@WYLNXCA i mean supercars also just started making hybrid systems, so you’re saying toyotas hybrids are better than a ferrari 296 gtb system?

[@WYLNXCA]

@@kristians2704 you gonna understand good hybrid means efficient, reliable, doesn’t equal to how powerful and reliable it is. In our day to day driving cars, we focus on if the battery is reliable, soft, quiet, efficient. That is what we are looking at. I would say, yes, Toyota hybrids are better, at the end of the day, every other brands are copy cats. Toyota has a copyright on their transitional hybrid system, meaning other brands have to make their own. That is why, Toyota hybrids sell the best.

[@xxavyerm9649]

I much prefer the Lexus RX, as the other will visit the mechanic shop more often, with a plethora of issues.

[@olympbarca3313]

Definitely you didn't heard about b58 engine

[@AgonxOC]

False news. None of my BMWs see mechanics aside from the normal services. One has nearly 200K. BMW I6 are the best engines in the market. And the ZF transmission is amazing, so much so that Ford and Chevy tried to mimic it with their 10 speed and have been failing miserably!

[@tayoanchor]

Nope mate…my BMW has been incredibly reliable. No issues other than normal stuff like tyres and servicing

[@sergiogarcia9822]

You are totally wrong, BMW is top 3 in reliability and top 1 in premium SUV segment with the X5 and X6, I personally own an X5 and an M340i as well as an M240i before these two, never had a single issue in any.

[@Ryan2022]

@@olympbarca3313 Toyota bots never do any research. They just mindlessly parrot that anything other than a Toyota product will be broken down on the side of the road after 3000 miles Toyota Botsa unreasonable ridiculous people.

[@rydog75]

Great review. Minor correction - the Lexus has leather, not sensatec. And the big screen is an option. The standard screen is like 9” and looks ridiculous.

[@Gladiator1972]

I compared both but it was the X5 with M sport package with adds not only cosmetic touches but also the adaptive suspension. I went with the X5 in the end because of the entire package, it's the best blend of anything you're looking for in a midsize SUV. It's more a driver vehicle than the Lexus, gets great MPG, and overall looks better IMO, especially with the black 22" wheels.

[@Ryan2022]

And cost $10,000 more

[@Gladiator1972]

@@Ryan2022 No one is paying MSRP on the X5.

[@Ryan2022]

@@Gladiator1972 what are they paying then?

[@Gladiator1972]

@@Ryan2022I paid about 10% under MSRP

[@Gladiator1972]

@@Ryan2022 between 7-10% under

[@LaszloGaspar-s3x]

BMW👑

[@SME5724]

They’re both beautiful… that Lexus in that color looks amazing though

[@JoJoHartt]

That Lexus RX will outlast the next three generations of X5! 💯💯💯

[@19ld]

This video is all I needed today… I have a 2022 X5 and love it.. my wife wants the arc for fuel economy… I’m thorn between the 500h F Sport and the 350h ( really for fuel economy) it seems that the 500h would make me miss my BMW than the 350h

[@sergeihanush2262]

mpg on BMW is same as on 2016 rav4, just on regular. But still considering the HP output it crazy efficient engine

[@AgonxOC]

The BMW inline 6 has been this reliable since the N55. It is impressive and the B58 (highly underrated engine in the sense of power generation) get great MPG. I can get in the high 20, low 30s with my G05 X5. The X5 also tows like mad! In the US is rated to 7200LBS, but in Europe is actually 7700 LBS (Due to different trailer rules in the US vs Europe).

[@sethbartholomew]

Really wish Lexus would cut the BS and further their partnership with BMW and put the B58 in the RX and make it a F sport option, maybe the NX as well. They’re trying to add more power and sportiness while maintaining efficiency and they’re doing a terrible job going to inventing a new wheel route while BMW is perfecting it. The power and efficiency of the B58 is unparalleled. More horsepower, better MPG, bigger gas tank for more range.

[@duanen2337]

Lexus all day, I'm all about reliability.

[@kobedabest]

Then why Lexus? Toyota just did a 100k recall on lexus and Toyota. 😅

[@lionintu]

​@@kobedabestwhat was the recall? Engine?

[@naveenthemachine]

@@lionintuyeah the engine. Supposedly metal shavings can get in the engine. Theres no fix

[@kobedabest]

​@lionintu The V6 turbos are literally blowing up. And the new Tacoma is having transmission issues. Over 100k cars are being recall

[@lionintu]

Omg

[@RellupNorth]

Nah BMW sweeps the segment. Only the Genesis can compete or the Porsche imho

[@matthewgrayson8]

The bmw is just on another level. The Lexus is nice but not top tier nice and refined.

[@uzairahmed8260]

Though I prefer Lexus (sedans, especially the es 350h) over any other car, I think the bmw looks much better than the RX on the outside, and better on the inside as well.

[@donkalil4853]

Great comparison! It confirms my recent purchase of a 2025 X5 40XI with the "M" package. In terms of pricing, I was able to negotiate just under 10% off MSRP. I did stay with standard, 20" rims as I did not want to deal with swapping out tires for summer/winter driving with the upgraded rims, plus the added expense of another set of rims/tires for winter driving. I didn't test drive the Lexus as "mama" wasn't thrilled with the styling, particularly the large front grill. The X5 interior screams luxury and comfort. The driving and handling---incomparable.

[@jakeclayson7647]

Great review video. Thank you!

[@oligi2002]

The b58 engine is very very reliable, so much so that the Toyota supra uses the exact same engine. Goes to show how past reputations can bite you later on.

[@naveenthemachine]

Lexus reputation is finished. They’re history.

[@austin.2716]

@@naveenthemachineReally? Sure, Toyota/Lexus quality isn’t what it used to be and the gap between Toyota and Lexus cars is shrinking, with Toyota cars catching up to Lexus in terms of how well equiped they are and all that, but here in Australia, there’s only 1 major recall relating to the engine for Lexus cars (Lexus LX). And that’s a grand total of 184 affected cars I believe. I am not sure about the US and Canada but I’ll speak for what I see in my country. Considering there were around 1000ish sales of the Lexus LX last year here in Australia, that 184 isn’t that many. You can’t knock the whole brand over a few models having problems mate. Toyota/Lexus cars overall aren’t perfect but they aren’t terrible to the point I wouldn’t buy one. Try and be a bit more objective and feel free to tell me all the numbers for the US market. Oh and try not to sound 9 years old when you do so.

[@tinhinnh]

@@austin.2716hes a troll dont waste your breath

[@austin.2716]

@@tinhinnh He’s failed to answer one of my questions on another video too. I know he’s a certified clown but it’s still fun to troll him back 😂.

[@tinhinnh]

@@austin.2716ok 😂

[@hugdeath929]

I think the time where Lexus was ultra luxurious has long passed. It looks like they have more legroom and less cargo room (which is usually my preference) than the BMW. The Lexus presents as a much better value and has that Toyota reliability and longevity backing. The BMW looks more premium inside but at that price point I feel like it should absolutely come with cooled rear seats. I think non black/gray interiors inherently make a vehicle look more premium. Does anyone know why BMW hates reclining 2nd row seats? I think they’re both overpriced. There are some non “luxury” vehicles out there that give you the bulk of what you get in these vehicles for a good bit less 💰. Very strong video SB. Thanks for letting us ride along with you.

[@naveenthemachine]

The bmw is expensive but you clearly see where your money went. Not so with the Lexus. Besides Toyota’s having turbo problems. Cooled rear seats is nice but that doesn’t change how it performs or drives

[@jraheemjefcoat429]

Cooled rear seats are available in other markets.

[@cooljool1]

@@naveenthemachine certainly not in the second row seats

[@gregorytrane7828]

Good job on both comparisons! If you take the BMW extended warranty then it would be a no brainer to pick the BMW for cache, looks and sportiness that few SUV's can best in it's current production.

[@scooter5940]

These cars are targeted at two different buyers - a driving experience is not just based on specs. I realize some people cross shop them, but If you seriously think these models are comparable, save yourself some money and buy the Lexus, because you won’t realize what you just missed out on. That’s not a slam on Lexus buyers. It’s just that the priorities of people who buy this brand are very different from BMW buyers.

[@Ryan2022]

People cross shop whatever they want what rules have you set down in your head I’ve looked at both of these cars. My priority is to get a great looking great driving midsize SUV. I haven’t decided. I’m still gonna look at the Mercedes GLE Am I allowed to cross shop that?

[@scooter5940]

@@Ryan2022 yes, I give you special permission. Styling is a big deal and it’s totally subjective. “Great driving” also can mean different things to different people, though it tends to mean something else to automotive enthusiasts and that’s where Lexus falls short. All three are great vehicles and I suspect you will love whichever one you buy.

[@geocape7060]

Are the new BMW x5's more reliable than they were in past years?

[@Truck_OFF]

NO!bmw are junk

[@Ryan2022]

The motor is bulletproof. The backseat is a joke compared to the Lexus.

[@daletroy3348]

In Australia BMW is $167,000($112,000 usd) Lexus $138,000 ($92,000usd) we pay quite a substantial luxury car tax .🤷🏻‍♂️

[@Ryan2022]

Australians are some of the nicest people I’ve ever met you also let your government run all over you and then have the nerve to criticize other countries

[@VincentGota-l7b]

Can never compare bmw to a Toyota. As long as I have money to buy either of the 2 , I will choose bmw. SIMPLE! If I don’t have money then I will buy my 320d and still be smiling!

[@josephfamilyrocks]

Same

[@petewick8627]

This is where Lexus fanboys say “yeah but it’s reliable

[@naveenthemachine]

Yup. Lexus fanboys will use the excuse “it has the best quality in the world 😱 and it’s instantly bulletproof and reliable to the point where I can burn it with fire and it’ll still run as if nothing happened 😱😲”😆

[@G-Rated]

They’re the reason Lexus has fallen off so badly and barely even care to give a real effort in either segment. Their fanboys.

[@random-videos]

Yea, the “reliability”. I had to change the whole RX tranny… paid $10k. And had to come in and readjust 3 times before it worked correctly.

[@jr1885]

That’s sad at this point. The Lexus price is way too much just for it to be just reliable…

[@gerry9306]

I'll take the RX thank you very much 👍

[@portknoxxa]

I'd skip both and go with a X3 M40i

[@cthis4786]

That car appeals to a smaller crowd who want sportiness, most people want a cushy ride for their SUV's

[@naveenthemachine]

@@cthis4786but oddly thr x3 is similar in size to an RX

[@gosman949]

@@naveenthemachine due for a change next year so I wouldn't touch a x3 at this time.

[@davidalenick1246]

@@gosman949that might be a good reason to get one. IDrive 7 is arguable the best.

[@paulbugoni2846]

@@davidalenick1246 Exactly.

[@myronyoshioka8742]

We did test drive the X5 and noticed a lot of wheel noise when going over bumps in the road. It was very distracting, noisy and uncomfortable. Is this normal? Was surprised at how unrefined it was for such an expensive vehicle. Is this normal?

[@luisantoniosblog.gonzalez9315]

Great video, excellent review, everything was perfect, thank you, I have always watched your videos and appreciate your point of view. Greetings from Mexico.

[@CallumScottieCambell]

I buy my cars, so I'd not consider a bmw over the long term. Lexus is the my most reliable car maker on the planet

[@kromahj]

That BMW have the B58 engine . That one of the best and reliable engines. Same engine Toyota use in the Supra.

[@CallumScottieCambell]

@@kromahj Yes, this engine is good 👍

[@planetfabulous5833]

I'd skip both of these and get the best handling SUV available - a Porsche Macan GTS. It's a beast!

[@veasnayong3456]

Thanks for review bong srey. Happy pride!🌈🏳️‍🌈

[@georgedoolittle7574]

Tesla still pressuring the entire automotive segment and dominates "sport class" to the extent to which Model X sales be had of course. Is interesting that BMW and Lexus have never done better since Tesla came along tho.

[@GautamAtri]

Is this a base model vs the top model? What's going on here?

[@daniel0703]

Because these two don’t really compare. A fair comparison would be the Lexus RX500h vs the BMW X3M40i. The X5 is a tier out two above the RX in every way.

[@pm512]

Yeah, but at about 70000 or a hundred thousand miles you might as well take your entire bank account and give it to the BMW dealership. That Lexus is still going to be a rock

[@StatnikVitalii]

I like BMW but this Lexus is super attractive and offers many interesting features like digital rear view mirror and cooling and heating rear seats those are so important to me. Plus it’s just 4 cylinders vs 6 cylinders in BMW but HP and 0-60 almost the same 😮

[@ag4eng]

The RX 500h has the Hybrid Max engine, which is very powerful and sips fuel. The design of the X5 in that color is really nice, but it’s a shame BMW can’t redo their interior control layout and bring back dials and knobs.

[@Hercegovac.1]

BMW of course 💪

[@CarGeek360]

Oh for sure, I liked the last gen RX but the new one is very ugly AND A 4 CYLINDER

[@Motorheaddoc]

The BMW wins in driving dynamics and power. BMW has always underrated their engines.

[@naveenthemachine]

And it wins in ride comfort and luxury and tech and practicality and reliability So it’s practically perfect

[@jazperlit1156]

No comparison here. Lexus is King, truly the greatest luxury brand ever created. The most reliable, indestructible, highest resale value, superior luxury, unsurpassed technology, mesmerizing beauty. There’s a reason why Lexus owners are the most satisfied luxury vehicle owners. Not to mention, it has the most beautiful name of all cars. Truly a relentless pursuit of perfection! #LEXUS👑

[@shanewilfon6860]

He sure likes head to head😂😂😂

[@Quietmedows02]

Lol

[@daniel0703]

Grow up

[@therealonyebuchi]

I would choose the Lexus because of the build quality and the reliability ❤

[@naveenthemachine]

Right…😂 taking an interior filled with injection molded plastics hard plastics no wood trim no leather dash or doors or airbag cover and sticking a Lexus logo on it suddenly makes the interior the best build quality 😲😱😆 That’s just not how anything works pal

[@cablebrain9691]

I don’t think you should bother with the brake-torquing 0 to 60 test when comparing vehicles. Who does that in real-world driving? I may have done it a few times when I was 17 or 18, to do burnouts, but that’s it. The Lexus actually had a better time in the non-brake-torquing test, 5.5 for the Lexus, versus 5.8 for the BMW, albeit with the BMW going slightly uphill. You had stated that the BMW was quicker, which is sort of misleading.

[@epcdasilent]

First place 114k units sold vs second place 72k units sold. I think the market has spoken as to which one is the most preferable luxury mid-size SUV. Despite the huge margin, 2nd place is not bad... How many did Genesis GV80 sell? like 5? ouch. And out of those 5, 3 catches fire on their engines. 😱😢🤣

[@naveenthemachine]

Just because an RX outsells a gv80 or x5 doesn’t mean the RX is more luxurious or better to drive than an x5 or gv80

[@epcdasilent]

@@naveenthemachine You are not completely wrong, but buying a car isnt just about driving dynamic or luxury, its the full package. And the market has decided the RX has the most complete package by sale numbers. Can’t really argue sale numbers when thats what every car manufacturers aim for.

[@naveenthemachine]

@@epcdasilent it’s not like only the RX offers the complete package while everyone else doesn’t. That’s just not the reality

[@TheBrudol]

​@@naveenthemachineyour opinion means as much as any random person on the street, no matter how hard you try. Sales figures are clear, RX is more popular/preferred. You can try bending reality but facts are facts (vs. your personal opinion).

[@nullravager]

hard rage bait

[@ixnooky]

The wife has a 2023 RX350. I just bought a 2025 BMW X5 40i. I have to say I like the X5 better in almost every category so far, but it suits my driving style. The RX350 is nice, quiet and comfortable, but not sporty, the F Sport package is just a trim and doesn't actually make it sporty. She gets many comments on the copper crest color, I get comments about the carbon black exterior. BMW's 6 cylinder engine is actually quite reliable, and the Lexus should be even more so. The bottom line is the BMEW is more of a driver's machine, the RX more sedate then sporty.

[@kobedabest]

Usually, I would say a Toyota will last longer, but the new-generation BMW engines are lasting longer than all the new Toyota turbo engines. There was a 100k recall on all their V6 turbos. So, glad my Supra was made by BMW, now I'll know it will outlast all the new Toyota. 🤣

[@pbergn]

Sofyan, you haven't mentioned the seat comfort extensively. From my last test drive experience, the Lexus RX F-Sport model seats were very narrow and had more aggressive bolstering -- uncomfortable, while BMW's seats were OK in non-M Sport rendition (although both have synthetic leather at that price(!)). Another huge usability issue is the middle console in X5 that sticks out too far back, thus making the rear middle seat quite uncomfortable, eating up the legroom, despite having a low tunnel hump... Another thing I remember after test driving both the vehicles is that Lexus was more agile and easy to maneuver, whereas BMW was more difficult to drive in narrow spaces or over frequent curves due to all that torque pushing on the rear wheels... Overall, I think - yes - these vehicles are comparable; Lexus has more comfort and utility, while BMW has better handling and more power -- drives sportier... Reliability-wise I think now both Lexus and BMW are almost on the same level after adding these many electronic components and adding turbo engines... I would not really call out Lexus on reliability any longer.... Overall Lexus maintenance is cheaper, I agree -- maybe not the reliability, but the cost of ownership... One thing that gets me with BMW's in general is how the interior is apportioned vs exterior size; given the size of X5 one would have expected more passenger room, but even something like Honda CR-V has comparable amount of passenger space and cargo... Another pet peeve of mine with specifically X5's is the dual split tail-gate -- why? I find it annoying that one must open two parts, and the cargo organizer in BMW not the best one either... In general, I found it was much easier to drive the Lexus than the BMW due to its shorter hood, shorter wheel base, and more intuitive controls, although the transmission felt jerky in Lexus and super smooth in BMW, especially going uphill...

[@m271-c1h]

Which one has the best lease deal? That's the one I'm getting.

[@twfinc6855]

fyi in Canada, RX tops out at $84,000... X5 BASE MODEL starts at $89,000... why are we comparing them?

[@SME5724]

Ugh … because they’re similar in price 😅

[@Ryan2022]

Because people cross up them all the time and who cares about what happens in Canada get rid of that stupid Prime Minister get Stephen Harper back and then we can talk

[@박동석-u7u]

bmw x5 all the way

[@cristisun184]

Maybe the best SUVs on the market.I believe that the BMW win in details witch are mostly small but seems to be everywhere where Lexus wins in it's historical trust as top premium reliable car.But as many US comments say and I agree that BMW is to lease and RX is to own.

[@jrcorpuz51]

Well done! Thanks!

[@jetfixer3207]

My 2024 X5 xDrive 40i "M Sport" is terrific, but to be brutally honest... I really LIKE it a lot, but I don't LOVE it. I shopped around quite a bit (Audi, Volvo & others) but these two were available from dealerships under the same parent company. The Lexus had a $1500 price bump, the BMW was straight MSRP. This, plus fuel economy AND straight up power made me buy the BMW. I'm currently undecided as to how long I'll keep it.

[@jdmoney1000]

What don't you love about the X5???

[@jetfixer3207]

It runs and drives great (Despite currently carrying 2 open recalls) but BMW's "tech choices" really confuse me. For example: Being a retired aircraft mechanic, I'm a "gauge guy" but in the X5, other than water temperature, there are NO gauges either visible, or even available anywhere. Second, for radio volume, there is a knob right below the panel, and buttons on the steering wheel, and yet, they added an extra feature where you can twirl your finger at the face of the radio to change volume (which only works occasionally) WHY? Third, I really enjoy the rearview mirror camera I've had in other vehicles, but despite all the other tech, BMW doesn't even offer it as an option. Fourth, I'm an older guy (62) and being less flexible than I once was, unless I perform a "swim maneuver" I hit my head on the door opening every time I get in the thing. On a crossover? I have a few other items, but this is just hitting some of the big ones for me. If none of these seems like a big deal to you, I think you'd probably like it a lot. Speaking only for myself, once they finally sort out the recalls, I'll probably replace it.

[@shawnharris7747]

I'm bmw all day I don't keep cars long so who cares if it doesn't last over 5 years 😂

[@gosman949]

I can get a used 2023 RX500h for a pretty good price. I heard the 500h had a few problems last year? Did they fix them?

[@Methylphenidate2803]

They didn’t have any issues.

[@pklemm1]

They are fixed

[@gosman949]

@@pklemm1 what was the problem?

[@pklemm1]

@@gosman949 transmission. It was fixed by late spring 2023

[@gosman949]

@@pklemm1 I have the chance to buy a used one from 2023. What was the problem with the transmission?

[@moseswonganichipeta1166]

I love Lexus but I will never choose that Lexus over x5 any x5 thank you

[@DRayL_]

IMO, everything about the BMW is better. Exterior design is much better looking. The wheels looks much better. I appreciate the BODY colored side mirrors over the cheap-out black side mirrors. The interior of the BMW is more refined looking. The seats look more comfortable. I can't afford either of them, but if I could, I'd get the BMW. Love the paint color.

[@michaels7984]

You can knock lexus for a lot of things, but their seats are usually extremely comfortable.

[@DRayL_]

@@michaels7984 Oh, I bet they are. I'd love to have a car with that level of comfort. I don't hate the Lexus.

[@pete23234]

@@DRayL_ I have had both and the BMW comfort seats are actually slight better imo

[@DRayL_]

@@pete23234 Thanks for the input! 🙂

[@chasevisions]

Excellent excellence excellent review!

[@hugdeath929]

Although the BMW ‘looks’ bigger the rear seat room looks tighter and not as comfortable. There’s less knee/legroom and the rear seats don’t recline. That’s a huge miss for my needs. I’m caught up in that I like the dynamics of BMW but I’m not a fan of their packaging and lack of comfort considerations in their design.

[@TheLOL4DUDE]

Hi! Apart from the great video with top notch quality, my question would be a little more personal. I have an X5 40i X-Line, identical to the one in the video with the only difference being the wheels (22' on mine) and the interior colour. Now my question is: Why does my car have a 4 exhaust system? I see the tested X5 has 2 big exhausts while mine has 4, how is that possible? It's not about the exterior side, i'm talking abouth the exhaust itself.. wtf? Also, the trunk is totally different! Mine has an automatized cover which retracts and extends itself as you open/close the trunk. Also, you don't have to hide it away somewhere, it just goes under the floor automatically with a press of a button. The trunk itself misses some alu-rubber stripes that make it look a lot better and help keeping the suitcase in place (it just sticks on the rubber and doesn't slide around). While the trunk of my X5 looks a lot better, the exhaust part worries me cause it's a hardware of the car itself. Any opinions?

[@Ryan2022]

Why did they replace the nice dashboard from your 2022 with that cheap looking screen that they have on the 2024 model?

[@scratchpar1710]

Which car holds it value better?

[@pablo.blanchett]

Lexus dug

[@keithrodes]

This is a tough choice!!! I love them both.

[@gatgolf]

is the lexus a plug in?

[@Ryan2022]

No, thank God

[@geovannivarela6932]

Im gonna buy my next vehicle and im leaning towards the Lexus. Thanks again Soyfan @redlinereviews

[@beri232]

I’d go X5 all… day…. long…. That new Lexus powertrain sucks! May as well get the performance of the BMW if they’re both going to be shop-princesses!

[@CarGeek360]

RX can’t compare to X5 😂

[@jay198827]

I drove the 2024 x5 and it definitely impressed me. For it to be the base model it was quick enough and felt very sporty. I think it comes with a lot for the 70k starting price.

[@scholz222]

BMW achieves better real world MPG and doesnt need a true hybrid setup. The 48v is just for smooth start stop.

[@victorbeasley7031]

Hi Sofyan, which one would you buy?😅

[@theredline]

We’d lease the BMW and dump it after the lease is over. We’d buy the Lexus and feel more peace of mind after the warranty runs out.

[@petewick8627]

Hey there Sofyan, there has been a lot of talk regarding reliability issues with the new RX. Wondering what you have heard?

[@olympbarca3313]

​@theredline I can tell you that you can buy this X5 without problem because the engine is reliable unlike theirV8

[@pbergn]

@@theredline That is not the answer Victor was probably looking for. If given a choice, you'd most likely lease the X5, then jump to another model (more powerful one -- either BMW or other German brand) in 3 years. I seriously doubt that Sofyan, you, would settle for the RX in any trim...

[@CarGeek360]

Literally isn’t a comparison, the X5 is SO MUCH BETTER, don’t know why anyone would choose the RX over it

[@naveenthemachine]

Because the shoppers don’t know what real luxury is

[@doswatch]

@@naveenthemachine - loser naveen's here, attendance marked! Naveen shits on every lexus RX video..

[@ag4eng]

Prices are similar, but different categories as the X5 platform is much heavier. 500h power output makes it a great daily driver. Not grandma’s RX.

[@CarGeek360]

@@ag4eng X5 is still infinitely superior

[@CarGeek360]

@@naveenthemachine everything else aside, at least the X5 isn’t terribly ugly, that alone is enough of a reason to choose it over the RX