207: Was The Prophet Buried in Ayesha's Room? | Our Prophet

This episode is from Chapter 8 of Our Prophet -- the most comprehensive life story (seerah) of Prophet Muhammad (s) by Sayed Mohammed Baqer Qazwini.
View the complete Chapter 8 (His Other Wives) here:
• Chapter 8: His Other W...
Links to previous Chapters:
Chapter 1 (Prelude):
• Chapter 1: Prelude | O...
Chapter 2 (Birth to Revelation):
• Chapter 2: Birth to Re...
Chapter 3 (The Mission Begins):
• Chapter 3: The Mission...
Chapter 4 (Struggles in Mecca):
• Chapter 4: Struggles i...
Chapter 5 (Road to Medina):
• Chapter 5: Road To Med...
Chapter 6 (Foundations of Islamic State):
• Chapter 6: Foundations...
Chapter 7 (Badr & Uhud):
• Chapter 7: Badr & Uhud...
Things you'll learn in this episode of Our Prophet:
00:00 - Evidence that Prophet was not buried in Ayesha's room
03:50 - How are Prophet, Abu Bakr, and Umar buried in such a tiny space?
06:31 - Ayesha kept her hijab on out of reverence for Umar's grave
09:53 - Accounts in the past stating that Ayesha gave up her room
11:34 - Account of Ayesha's suggestion to remove Prophet's tomb's ceiling
13:56 - Why was Ayesha unaware of Prophet's burial in her room?
Join us in creating the most comprehensive life story (seerah) of Prophet Muhammad (s). Dedicate episodes in the memory of your loved ones by visiting
thaqlain.org/ourprophet.
#ProphetMuhammad #PropheticBiography #OurProphet
=============================================
► HELP US REACH 100K SUBSCRIBERS:
/ @thaqlain
► JOIN US AS KZbin MEMBER:
/ @thaqlain
► BECOME OUR PATRON:
thaqlain.org/support
► CONNECT ON WHATSAPP:
wa.link/hfcf0g
► FOLLOW US:
Facebook: / thaqlain
Instagram: / thaqlainmedia

[@Thaqlain]

Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S: I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt). II) Subscribe: Connect with us on KZbin & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/message/TAR3C325Z5LYO1 III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support

[@user-vc5kj8ct5u]

Please a lecture upload on martyrdom of prophet Muhammad ص

[@serignendiaye536]

ALLAH SWT bless you and your family and all your descendants and your ascendants and increase your science you are a blessing for Islam long to you listening to you take away stress sadness and bring joy and peace remarquable video

[@rafidhi14]

Ilahi ameen

[@rumanaadam7604]

Alhamdulıllah Rahbıl Alamın.🤲🏼 As well with you and your family Insha Allah

[@tasneembootwala8308]

May Allah swt have mercy on people of turkey and Syria.. Ya Allah swt help them Send your aid to them Ya ilaahi aameen

[@abdulwahablasisi3196]

3:20 It is quite interesting how his history gets distorted for what benefit I don't know. Can't people focus on their own shortcomings and how they'll meet their Lord, rather than looking for faults in persons that Allah Himself has showered his mercies upon.

[@Thaqlain]

We are not examining her shortcomings. The video is from a section of a series exploring why we don't take Sunnah from Ayesha. The video is based on the subsection discussing how some of the narrations narrated by Ayesha are either false or fabricated.

[@tasneembootwala8308]

Jazakallah khair Allahumma Salle ala Muhammad wa aale Muhammad

[@sayedbesmillahsultani227]

As always, well-structured and well put. Love you dear Sayed.

[@nikoutoajaisai6310]

Asalaamualaikum my brother i really enjoy how you putting the pieces together MAA Shaa Allah. I am chilled keep going

[@faizrizvi9754]

Mola salamat rakhey❤

[@naziharizvi5591]

Thank you for explaining so clearly...May Allah bless you 💐

[@rumanaadam7604]

Asalamunalıakum Alahuma sualıy ala Mohammed waalı Mohammed wa'ajılfarahum

[@teaisfantastic7136]

The hadith clearly mentioned in sahih bukhari jild 1 hadith# 513

[@muizchowdhury]

Sheikh understood your point. But according to Shia sources where did Prophet SM was buried ?

[@Thaqlain]

We will be covering it in detail when we reach the departure of the Prophet from this world.

[@mustafahasanayn5642]

Where is the house of 'Aisyah situated? if any way we can get the plan of the masjid?

[@Thaqlain]

We have covered it to a certain extent here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oZvYlXisltmUm5o

[@sonabarnes6670]

Superb, alhamdulillah. 👍

[@humblebee8334]

After burial she put up a screen in her room to divide the grave and room

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

You just ignored every point made in the video from your own sources

[@muhammadhaydar3073]

there are other reasons why it is impossible for the Prophet (sawas) to be buried in Aisha's room. Didn't the prophet (sawas) have his own house or room? Moreover, there are hadiths where the Prophet (sawas) asks that we close all the doors of all the houses which overlook the mosque except his own and that of Imam Ali (as). This proves that he had his own house and that obviously he did not spend his time with his wives, he had many other things to do. Finally, there is the fact that Imam Ali (as) says in Nahj al Balagha that the Prophet (sawas) died against his chest and it was obviously not at Aisha's house.

[@Thaqlain]

Sayed has mentioned in one of the episodes that there was a chamber between the houses of Ayesha and Lady Zahra where the Prophet used to pray sometimes.

[@user-vc5kj8ct5u]

ALLAHU AKBAR ❤❤❤❤❤

[@NP0451]

Mash'Allah

[@fidahusayn8691]

Salam Need more episodes

[@Thaqlain]

Alaykum Salaam. Your wish has been granted.

[@thelion2087]

Great a lecture Mashallah. We need more scholars like the sayed exposing the truth about the history of Sunnisim and their “teachings”

[@NadeemZaidi]

Ayesha died only two years before Karbala

[@Azadar313]

Assalamualaikum Please share the reference ✨🙏🏼 Hadith No.

[@Thaqlain]

Alaykum Salaam. For which specific narration do you need the reference for? We will InshaAllah get it from Syed.

[@ishxyzaak]

You haven't proven anything to be honest. just because Aisha was sleeping next to the prophet (peace be upon him) while he was praying forcing her to move her feet doesn't prove that the room could not have been bigger for her to sleep elsewhere or to accommodate more than 2 people at once. Now you made this entire video yet still couldn't tell us where he was buried so for that I will have to give you an f.

[@Thaqlain]

Because the topic was not where Prophet is buried. The topic was exploring the reliability of Ayesha as a hadith narrator. If the room was big enough that's really an insult to the Prophet that he is trying to pray yet a wife is being an obstacle which he has to remove every time he has to prostrate to Allah.

[@idrisraji2765]

Now make the video where the prophet is buried. Dey play. I pity you, talking bad about the wife of the prophet pbuh. It's shameful really.

[@devilhasashi8701]

​@idrisraji2765 ur believe is shameful

[@ishxyzaak]

@@Thaqlain where is he buried then? This is a genuine question

[@ibrahimharith9878]

​@@idrisraji2765you have a nice name Idris now I doubt if you know anything about prophet Idris (A.S)

[@chapabazindicator]

show some respect for her, she was the love of our prophet. Sahaba that you curs lived entire their life with Prophet side by side, fought side by side. If they were munafiq Allah would guide the prophet about them. Your jealousy and pride destroying your faith. May Allah accept us,

[@Thaqlain]

Where is the disrespect?

[@chapabazindicator]

@@Thaqlain Say Peace be upon her, after her name. May Allah guide us.

[@Thaqlain]

Peace be upon the righteous wives of the Prophet.

[@chapabazindicator]

@@Thaqlain May Allah forgive everyone of us and guide us to siratal mustaqeen. May Allah prevent us from shirk. May prevent us from doing Allah's work and let us know that only Allah has the authority of jannah/ jahannam, only he knows who deserves what. we only wrongdoer seeking his forgiveness. May Allah forgives and grants jannah to all sahabas and wives of prophet.

[@sundus2010]

You’re spreading misinformation-kindly use your skills for some Meaningful and progressive discussions .

[@Thaqlain]

The discussion here is: Is Ayesha bint Abi Bakr reliable to take Islam from? Please share what is the misinformation?

[@thecritiquer9407]

sunnis say the room was expanded latter

[@Thaqlain]

'Later' is the word to focus here

[@e.d5956]

So what???? Is that ur knowledge…..??What’s ever u said she was selected by Allah SW to be the Wife of OUR BELOVED PROPHET Sele’LLAHU ALEIHI WESELEM……. Redia’LLAHU aneha … And again Redia’LLAHU ANEHUM All Kalifates ,AbuBaker,Oumer,Ousman and Ali Ibnu’Abuthalib and so on….

[@Thaqlain]

Salaam Alaykum. Did Prophet ever specifically called these individuals whom you mentioned as Radi Allah? Or you are allowed to create innovations in religion?

[@yusufindin2017]

After listening to several videos about Ayesha (although disagree with a few while most of his arguments make sense) I'm having my second thought about Ayesha. He is speaking based on evidence.

[@mohammedeliyas6025]

You’ve called ‘Khadijah Al Kubrah’ as ‘lady’, but when you commenting about Ayesha, you’ve called ‘no-cultured’ (La-Aadabah), isn’t this something not part of akhlaq!! She’s also wife of a prophet, the way you would show respect to ‘lady’ khadijah Al Kubrah, the same way you should be maintain respect ‘Lady’ Ayesha. Please response to this if this message catches your attention, Oh respected Shaykh.

[@Thaqlain]

We use Lady with Khadijah not because she was Prophet's wife, but because of the status she had as mentioned in the following hadith: “She believed in me when no one else did, she embraced Islam when people disbelieved me; and she helped and comforted me when there was no one to lend me a helping hand.” Also, in the following hadith, “Mary, the daughter of Imran, was the best among the women (of the world of her time) and Khadijah is the best amongst the women (of this nation).” And for the fact that through her is the existence of Prophet's progeny.

[@Thaqlain]

Also, using names is not an insult. Hadith books use direct names. But yes, for Lady Khadija we use extra respect for the fact that Prophet gave her extra respect. So we are just following the Sunnah :)

[@ibrahimharith9878]

The wife of lut (A.S)and Nuh(A.S) were also the wives of the prophets are we also supposed to respect any wife of a prophet go read your sunni books stop just being a dry follower use your intellect for once

[@fadelalkarbalai9766]

Second comment 😁

[@murtazabandali5609]

Then she was stepping over the graves.

[@irshardthowfeek6190]

What are you trying to prove here please? Does it matter?

[@wazzabanzook5028]

what this proves to me is that either bhukhari has bullshit hadiths or ayesha didn't tell the truth

[@Thaqlain]

The goal that we are focusing on is the reliability of Ummul Momineen Ayesha in religious guidelines and as a narrator. We will urge you to listen to these episodes from 198 onward.

[@nikoutoajaisai6310]

I am reacting again to the comment of someone please don't pretend that you don't understand what's going on put the pieces together and deferrenciate truth from falsehood don't be pretensive .The Prophet didn't berry there ok case close.

[@syedmuslim4008]

Sahi Sitta are Books with all FABRICATED HADEES...

[@Zanskar7749]

Im feeling very sad for u I don't know where from u collecting this information ND don't know why u misguiding the people Nessceity is the need of hour when a two person live together then thier must a suitable place for them according to their capacity, Aisha is speaking about the time when they live together Prophet was died 40 year later , an area can be increase with the time of need , The Prophet ﷺ is buried in the Sacred Chamber, along with two of his most faithful companions and the first two caliphs of Islam, Abu Bakr al-Siddiq and Umar ibn al-Khattab. The Sacred Chamber was once the house (hujra) of his wife Aisha - the house in which he was staying in at the time of his physical demise. Today, it forms part of the Masjid Nabawi complex and is the most venerated tomb in the world. The graves are surrounded by several walls which have no windows or doors and thus can’t be seen still if you want to fooling the people then do conform from the place which I mentioned here

[@teaisfantastic7136]

Those hadiths are mentioned in sahih bukhari sunnis most noble book there are thousands of fabricated hadiths which we following them blindly.

[@Zanskar7749]

@Tea is Fantastic he is narrating the hadith in different perspectives whole of his content is based on differences it simply seem he want to create chaos

[@teaisfantastic7136]

@@Zanskar7749 the hadith is mentioned in sahih bukhari jild#1 hadith#513 you can check it for yourself

[@Zanskar7749]

@@semakulaatibu4564 Almighty said in Quran discuss the similarities and hold the rope of Allah and his Rasool

[@adamnouri23]

@@semakulaatibu4564 The holy Quran by itself is not enough. Why !? Because, it has to be interpreted and explained. Many aayahs / verses are clear. Any one can understand them . However : so many others are more or less complicated. One aayah can take you days ,, maybe longer ,, of search in order to realize why the was revealed ,, when it was revealed ,, whom it was about ,, where ,, how ,, Ali ibn Abi Talib had his own copy of the holy Quran ,, maybe double in size . Because, it contained the Quranic text that we all know and recite. It had also the interpretive or explanatory text. Both texts go hand in hand. When Imam Ali presented his copy of the holy Quran, Omar along with Abu Bakr and the rest of their government team rejected it. Why they rejected Imam Ali's copy of the holy Quran explained and interpreted !!! Because, they did not want it. Because, it was not going to support their political standpoint. They wanted their own way of dealing with the holy Quran. A quranic interpretation that supports them against him. That is basically the whole point of having two different versions of Islam. One is called sunni and the other is the Ahlilbayt way of Islam ; the original Islam.

[@behuman3801]

Fear Allah Dare you say anything about our mother The Qibla must be in perpendicular position to our mother’s sleeping position think! Secondly once she said something she said it Our mother in favor of whom Allah Revealed verses I am shocked that Muslims would say things about Ayesha RadiAllahu Anha So this is what some Shia’s say I am shocked Even three people and more can lie in a small room When you die you are buried in sleeping position And why don’t you want to accept when it is said We don’t know how homes were built Houses may be big Individual quarters maybe in them And who are we talking about Our Prophet Peace be upon him and his closest companions As it is the earth expands for them Why are you spoiling you Akhirah Imagine how in fire you will burn for mocking our mother If don’t know then the least you could do is be quiet I can hear in your audience someone laughing May Allah’s Curse be in those who mock Ayesha Radi Allahu Anhu And May the punishment come now on them now So then they will know Ameen Ameen

[@Thaqlain]

We understand that these things are new for you. Still, we hope you realize that it is these narrations from Ummul Momineen Ayesha that we have people like Salman Rushdie mocking the Prophet. Also, the title Ummul Momineen has been examined in detail in the previous episode.

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

Why are you getting all emotional & outraged for? They are your hadith. 1) You think it okay stick your feet out when someone goes into sajood? They plain truth is it is very disrespectful act to do when someone is praying. 2) The excuse of qibla is so bad. The toes face qibla like the face when sleeping. That isn't same someone put their feet where you do sajood. If she sleeping her feet be on the bed not moving back & forward where he was praying. 3) If you didn't get all emotional you would understand that. He made an excuse for her actions the room was too small. 4) she literally not you mother. She didn't give birth to you. Watch other video on Ayesha being mother of believer. 5) You are shocked well it is your sahih hadiths. Why are you shocked 6) You claim she praised in the Quran she rebuked in the Quran according to one of your sahih hadiths from Umar. 7) One person laughed you judge all from it. One laugh all you hatred comes out. 8) you claimed the room could be big but didn't address none of points why it wasn't. 9) you claim 3 people can be buried in a small room. Are you just going to walk all over them. 10) She wasn't awakened by someone digging in her room. Contradiction after contradiction. You response emotional. How dare your hadiths be quoted

[@ishxyzaak]

@@Thaqlain you haven't proven anything to be honest. just because Aisha was sleeping next to the prophet (peace be upon him) while he was praying forcing her to move her feet doesn't prove that the room could not have been bigger for her to sleep elsewhere or to accommodate more than 2 people at once. Now you made this entire video yet still couldn't tell us where he was buried so for that I will have to give you an f.

[@Thaqlain]

@Muslim Ahmed we have already responded to your comment.

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

@@ishxyzaak To be honest 🤣😂😆 You couldn't be honest to save your life. Listen to your excuses. Do you know anyone so disrespectful to put their feet in the face of someone praying! You are contradicting yourself here. You claim the room is big enough but she putting her feet in his face. You use an excuse of her sleeping. She narrates the Hadith! Really deep sleep that. How about she moved those feet out of his face & showed just a bit of respect. Rather than boast of what she did. You are in blind denial here so many holes in these terrible excuses. We know where he is buried. It was Imam Ali who buried him while your heros went to usurp his rights. That video is coming 👊

[@syedmuslim4008]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Ayesha SLEEPS with three GRAVES...

[@abdulkassmabdulhamid6218]

For a nice laugh....watch this joker :)

[@Thaqlain]

Sure. But there is no photo in your display picture.

[@whitesimurgh6363]

May Allah punish you for your aggressions towards the holy religion of Islam, to all shias.. ❤️

[@Thaqlain]

Can you please share where is the aggression?

[@sadik6490]

May Allah curse the speaker

[@adamnouri23]

Allah Almighty definitely knows on whom His curse befall.

[@sadik6490]

@@adamnouri23 rest assured.. Quran provides evidence for our Mother’s purity … our Prophet pbuh declared that She is the one He loves the most..anyone speaks ill let alone accusing her for heinous attributes.. they will get full compensation for their crime InshaAllah .. again May Allah curse the criminals whose hearts are so audacious.

[@fromthefareast6724]

@Sadik, well Allah swt spoken about her in Qur'an. [66:5] Maybe, his Lord, if he divorce you, will give him in your place wives better than you, submissive, faithful, obedient, penitent, adorers, fasters, widows and virgins.

[@adamnouri23]

Allah's curse be on the transgressors. Who do think the first one that incited people to kill Othman. " أقتلوا نعثل فقد كفر . O people ,, kill Othman. For he became disbeliever ". !? Then, she left Medinah to Mecca for ,, Othman got killed. Aisha heard about it. She asked : " who is the new calif ? " . They told her : " Ali ibn Abi Talib ". She slammed one hand with the other and said : " poor Othman ,, he got killed wrongfully ,, we want to punish his killers ". A man told her : " yesterday, you said kill him and today you want revenge for him ! ". She said : " my say today is better than my say yesterday ". """ holy Aisha !! In fact, she was wishing that her cousin and long time admirer Talha would be the next calif. So, she would be the next " queen of sheebah ". Well ,, she got disappointed big time. She became furious, agitated and eager to fight Ali ibn Abi Talib. In her way to the city of Basrah, she married herself to talha. She led a huge army. The battle of al-jamal left no less than fifteen thousand dead in both sides of the war ,, how many injured men and how many widows and orphans

[@thelordknows]

​@sadik6490 The prophet never told this rather he upset with her for taking secrets of the holy Prophet to his other wives. Also a wife doesn't lie about her husband when she is on her monthly cycle. She said in your own books that the prophet used to be intimate with her while on her period. This is nonsense as we are prohibited of saying these things. This is called decency. Why didn't other wives of the prophet say anything like that like Khadija, Zaynab, Mariyya, Safiyya, Juwayriyya. This is because they were decent wives and kept these things to themselves not fabricating it, thinking they are her favourites.

[@thepharmacistclinic4498]

Nothing proved. If Prophet wasn’t burried with her, then how her command matters when Hasan Ibn Ali RA Was burried.

[@Thaqlain]

Exactly! Why did the Governor of Medina follow her command when it wasn't her room and even if it was, according to Sunni jurisprudence, the Prophet never leaves an inheritance. At the end of the day, it was the Prophet's room, so all Muslims should have access to it.

[@thepharmacistclinic4498]

When there are so many wives of Prophet, including outspoken (according to you)Hafsa RA. Why is she so dominant and prominent figure? As per sunni and shia literature she is not the supporter of Muawaiya, though she is against him. Moreover, my second question is Asma Bint Umais is present in Lady Fatima’s funeral, but at that period she is in Nikkah with Abu Bakr RA. How is it possible, if someone’s wife is performing some special task during mid night and her husband isn’t aware.

[@Thaqlain]

We have covered the overall role of Ayesha in great detail in this series. As for Asma's role in the funeral, we'll ask the scholars whether it was Asma bint Umais or some other Asma.