25 Years Of Kargil War | Was It Failure Of Generals? Kargil Vijay Diwas | Ex Maj Manish Bhatnagar

Welcome to another special episode of Mor Talks, where we dive deep into pivotal moments in history with esteemed guests. Today, on the occasion of Kargil Vijay Diwas, we commemorate the 25th anniversary of the Kargil War, a significant event in India's military history. Our special guest for this episode is Ex-Major Manish Bhatnagar, who will share his insights and expertise on this crucial topic.
The Kargil War, fought between India and Pakistan in 1999, was a conflict that tested the mettle of the Indian Armed Forces and showcased the bravery and resilience of our soldiers. This episode aims to dissect the war from multiple perspectives, including the strategic decisions, the ground realities, and the leadership during the conflict.
Key points we will cover in this episode include:
*1. The Genesis of the Kargil Conflict:*
Understanding the geopolitical and strategic landscape that led to the Kargil War.
The initial intelligence and reconnaissance failures that allowed Pakistani forces to infiltrate Indian territory.
*2. The Tactical and Strategic Challenges:*
The terrain and weather conditions that made the conflict uniquely challenging.
The logistical and operational hurdles faced by the Indian Army.
*3. Leadership and Decision-Making:*
Analyzing the role of the military leadership during the conflict.
Was the Kargil War a failure of the generals? A critical examination of the decisions made at the highest levels of command.
*4. Stories of Valor and Sacrifice:*
Honoring the brave soldiers who fought and laid down their lives for the nation.
Personal anecdotes and stories from the battlefield, shared by Ex-Major Manish Bhatnagar.
*5. Lessons Learned and the Way Forward:*
Reflecting on the strategic and tactical lessons learned from the Kargil War.
How these lessons have shaped the modernization and preparedness of the Indian Armed Forces.
*6. Kargil Vijay Diwas:*
The significance of Kargil Vijay Diwas and how it is commemorated across the nation.
The message of resilience and patriotism that this day symbolizes for all Indians.
Ex-Major Manish Bhatnagar, with his extensive experience and firsthand knowledge, provides a unique and in-depth perspective on these topics. His analysis helps us understand the complexities of the Kargil War and the leadership dynamics involved.
Join us in this thought-provoking discussion as we pay tribute to the heroes of the Kargil War and gain a deeper understanding of this critical chapter in our history. Don't forget to like, share, and subscribe to Mor Talks for more insightful episodes. Share your thoughts and questions in the comments below, and let's honor the legacy of our brave soldiers together.
#KargilWar #KargilVijayDiwas #25YearsOfKargilWar #IndianArmy #MorTalks #ExMajManishBhatnagar #MilitaryHistory #India #Patriotism #WarHeroes #Leadership #StrategicAnalysis

[@umeshverma7552]

छोटे भाई मेजर मनीष भटनागर को दिल से सैल्यूट है। फोन का कोर्ट मार्शल करने वाले जिद्दी अधिकारियों को नर्क में भी जगह नहीं मिलेगी। ब्रिगेडियर देवेंद्र साहब और कैप्टन चीमा को भी दिल से सैल्यूट है।

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, Jai Hind

[@Rakuro60]

भारतीय सेना मे यह परंपरा रही है कि युध्द मे साहस तथा वीरता के उच्च कीर्तिमान स्थापना करनेवालो तथा उच्चाधिकारियों को जमीनी हकीकत बतानेवालो का सम्मान करना तो दूर उन्हें कोर्ट मार्शल कर प्रताड़ित कर सेना से बर्खास्त किया गया। ब्रिग्रेडियर देवीन्दर सिंह, मेजर भटनागर, मेजर अस्थाना जैसे बहादुर अफसरो, JCO's तथा जवानो की कहानियां जनता के सामने आनी चाहिए ताकि वो समाज मे सिर उठाकर जी सके।

[@radhakrishnannair2676]

Aa

[@sanjeebchaudhury701]

Maj (bravest) Manish Bhatnagar we are proud of you and shame to all Generals who never bite the bullet and for their own reason sacrificed all brave soldiers 😢😢😢

[@whitelotus2960]

They bit the bullets in their younger days otherwise they wouldn't be promoted. Promotions aren't that easy in the fauj so don't live in a fantasy world.

[@ShRao-sh3ou]

P

[@Dadasahab1234]

​@@whitelotus2960Those who perform get promoted, non performer s always cry foul.

[@sanjeebchaudhury701]

@@Dadasahab1234 respected Bro, how did you know that performance is the only criteria for promotion in army,specialy in india? If you are convinced then Maj Gen Saugat singh would have been promoted to Field Marshall for his massive heroic performance.

[@sanjeebchaudhury701]

@@whitelotus2960 please note it down the then Generals were mostly inducted in army after 1970.And most of them never faced Kargil like situation.

[@dostoevsky90]

Carrie (Brig Cariappa)sir rocks.. i also pray that he becomes a general.. thank you Yash sir and Bhatnagar sir for a wonderful dialogue🫡🫡… i just wanted to add why Carrie sir is so good human being…. In this fast paced world many even if they are good by nature dont have the time and patience to listen to your problems in life or help you in your darkest moments in life… Carrie sir was, is and will always be an exception and not only he gives a patient hearing but also picks you up from those dark times and re-orients your life … in a way he is not just a great soldier and an officer but an awesome human being… he himself has gone through a lot of hardships in his life.. so maybe he understands all of us…that is why, it is necessary that such great professional soldiers and Empathetic Human beings rise higher in ranks in the Army…May God’s blessings be always with him🙏🙏🫡

[@sharadtandon4624]

Very much true story

[@ltcolsuunilnarula7497]

Great Effort Gen Mor. Happy to See Maj Manish speak his Heart Out. However, the Nation must Celebrate the VICTORY - VIJAY DIWAS in honour of those who laid down their Lives and/or still carry the Scars of Kargil on their Mind Body & Soul ❤

[@yashmor8439]

Jai Hind 🇮🇳, best wishes on Kargil Vijay Diwas.

[@AloofManish]

Major Manish Bhatnagar! Our Nation is proud of you. Your achievements and contributions are immensely valuable to us.🫡🖖. Thanks a lot 🙏

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, Jai Hind

[@onlineeducation1618]

I work in private industry where 'Networking' is such a bad concept that less capable people are promoted. So sorry to see that our army is also like that. So sad that for Kargil, no general was punished.

[@santoshagrawal7417]

Salute to Shri Bhatnagar Sir for his positive attitude towards nation

[@yashmor8439]

Thanks, Jai Hind

[@Chen-gl9hm]

Very few people have guts to talk on this matter. I must appreciate you effort.

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, truth is must in service of nation, Jai hind

[@bhupindersingh3588]

Kudos to Major Bhatnagar and thanks to General Mor for opening our eyes again. Jai Hind 🫡

[@yashmor8439]

Thanks a ton, Jai Hind

[@uchatila1053]

Sad reality of our nation.............it took 25 long years to recognize the efforts of BRIG DEVENDER SINGH.....SHER SHAH OF INDIA!!!

[@shantanusapru]

Maj Manish Bhatnagar - a REAL Indian hero!!

[@PatilBhau17]

“A patriot must always be ready to defend his country against his government.” ― Edward Abbey

[@uchatila1053]

Major Manish Bhatnagar sir is very decorated and very Brave man...opening all India's eye's!!! Thanks so much Major Manish Sir!!!

[@ramanathanbalasiva3438]

Thanks sir, by bringing major Manish sir you have done a great job it was great to hear from major Manish.

[@yashmor8439]

Welcome, such stories of our real heroes must be brought out in the public domain. Jai Hind

[@uchatila1053]

Two Legends talking to one another...............Thanks GEN More for inviting Major Bhatnagar Sir........really appreciate Bhatnagar sir to educate all of us and to help this nation.

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you very much, Jai hind

[@umeshverma7552]

जिन सच्चे अधिकारियों की उपेक्षा की गई है उन्हें सम्मानित करना चाहिए ।

[@yashmor8439]

Thank You, Jai Hind

[@uchatila1053]

We succeeded in Kargil because of honest officers with likes of Brig Devender Singh Ji....Major Manish Bhatnagar Ji's...............and we failed the same war due to high headedness of Generals sitting in AC rooms!!!

[@ManSingh-h8j]

At this outset I would like to appreciate the discussion of Gen Mor and Maj Bhatnagar to show the reality of Senior Commandership and the some brave soldiers crushed for their sacrifice. I being an exservicemen also passed through the same way . Thanks and Jai hind.

[@rajbazal3786]

I couldn't stop tears after listening this real picture of warriors during War

[@yashmor8439]

Agree with you 😢

[@souviksanyal1220]

It is an excellent discussion. You have unfolded various untold history about which the entire nation was not aware. I think Part-II of this discussion will be telecasted soon.

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, Jai Hind

[@JayantaBhadra-in9zw]

Sir, Major Saab ke sath bahoot na insafi hua . Major Saab ek para commando tha aur champion ka champion.We all salute you alongwith you.

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, Jai Hind

[@mohindersingh8802]

Maj Bhatnagar sir yeh hamare bharat ki sena ka durbhagya hai k aap jaise officers ka court marshal kar diya lekin aap ko sun kar bahut accha lagaa Aap bahut bahadur officer hai Thanks to gen Yash sir

[@yashmor8439]

Jai Hind, thank you for your encouraging words

[@alex_2020]

People like Major (R) Bhatnagar & Brigadier (R) Devender Singh, should be the future defense minister of India. Major General (R) Yash Mor is also a person worthy of such honor!

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, however no such intentions from my side!

[@ananths8828]

Thanks for this enlightening discussion sir. Respect to major saab

[@ShivKanbargimath]

We have always failed to learn from our past . I hope such interviews do wake up the conscience of all concerned. Grateful to bring out this in the public domain

[@yashmor8439]

Agree with you, we don't learn from past mistakes. Such interviews are an effort to unravel the truth behind the Kargil conflict. Thanks for your positive response, finally national interest is supreme. Jai Hind

[@banwarilal6089]

भटनागर जी आपके द्वारा अपना कर्तव्य सही तरीके से निभाने की संतुष्टी आप के लिए सर्वोच्च उपहार है l यदि आप के द्वारा दी गई ground information का सदुपयोग हो गया होता तो भारत माता के बलिदानी सपूत के प्राण नहीं जाते l आपके बिना बयान दिये परिस्थितियो ने आप को निर्दोष सिद्ध किया l सत्यमेव जयतेl परमात्मा लापरवाह अधिकारि यो को कभी क्षमा नहीं करेगा l

[@acsmntsu9786]

I must say a very well conducted interview and Ex Maj Bhatnagar, despite all the wrong done to him was very positive and gave very good suggestions and his concerns even today are very genuine

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, Jai Hind

[@satishparit3605]

Excellent interview, excellent podcast,super super super

[@rationalclinicalmedicine9732]

Salute to major bhatnagar for his sacrifice and selfless service.

[@uchatila1053]

Liked the video before even watching as i know......its going to be great watching two Legends!!!!

[@chandraravish]

Kudos to General Mor for bringing Manish sir, after brigadier Devender Singh.. It was a very good interview. Now, you should try to call General Budhwar, or CO of 16 Grenadiers, or CO of Mahar battalion, or Brigadier Surinder Singh.. We should listen to these alternative voices

[@sitim5479]

The most unfortunate thing is that we thought our military is an exception and that these things happen only in public sector / private sector civilian world. If we keep promoting non / less deserving candidates over the deserving/ experienced ones, it would ultimately hurt the interests of our nation in all walks of life. Was shocked to see the similarities with our public sector organisations. Keep up the good work Major Manish , best wishes 👍🏻💐

[@deepakbharadwaj5590]

Fantastic talk Mor sahab. I read about Maj Manish Bhatnagar a few weeks back and also saw an interview on the same topic.I always had exactly the same questions in mind as to apart from Lt Gen YK Joshi no other CO from the Kargil war grew to the upper echelons of the armed forces, i am a civilian and i dont have full knowledge of these things, mine is just a ring side view. I have interviews of Brig Kushal Thakur, Brig Davinder Singh and the kind of passion that exhibited. Its a complete loss for the forces and the country. The over emphasis on intelligence failure in Kargil is just a cloak that hides the murky truth. Its obvious that we did not learn any thing from any of our wars or major skirmishes , that includes the heavy loss of lives in Galwan clash, again it was blamed on Intelligence failure. The only thing that we seem to learn ( as civilians) is the exemplary quality of the foot soldier and the front line officers. Knowing how opaque the system is, these details will never come out. Thanks for bringing another fabulous talk

[@tat5721]

Yes sir ur right no officer participated during op vijay was seen above brigadier rank....even the decorated ones.....I have seen this....

[@ghanvedsingh8946]

Lalchi logon ka ek hi dharah hai desh jaye bhaad me paisa bnayen desh bhagti ki aad me

[@meesalachandrasekharrao3733]

Sir, ek bar Brig Surendra Singh sir, then 121 Brigade commander ka interview forecast kijiye sir

[@aryanpandita5908]

One of the best videos I have seen sir , the bravest of the brave , one of the very few officers who have the courage to speak the truth , sir please bring him again for more podcasts in the future.

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you very much, yes i will have another podcast with him on popular demand. jai Hind

[@Ashish-u1v]

Thanks Gen Mor for coming out with such a nice podcast and heartiest salute to Major Bhatnagar. You are true sons of soil. Jai Hind. Jai Bharat Army

[@yashmor8439]

Jai Hind, thank you very much.

[@anandsinghmehra8188]

सर जय हिंद, आपका मेजर भटनागर वाला एपिसोड देखकर बहुत अच्छा लगा ।इस कार्यक्रम के लिए आपको बहुत बहुत धन्यावाद । सर ऐसे आफिसरों के और एपिसोड लाकर सच्चाई सामने लायें । और इस विषय में हिंदी भाषा में कोई किताबें हों तो मुझे अवगत कराने का प्रयास करेगे ।एक बार फिर आपको धन्यवाद ।

[@yashmor8439]

Jai Hind, thank you very much

[@dssaharan]

Sir please use 50% hindi

[@wandererwarrior]

This is your most interesting podcast Gen Mor, I personally have believed all these years that had it not been for our young officers, Jawans and on ground commanders, our Generals, Budhwar, Krishanpal and Malik had been personally responsible for the massacare

[@yashmor8439]

No doubts

[@wandererwarrior]

@@yashmor8439 its so heartning to recieve your response, i look forward to your podcast on Dokhlam and how it shaped the infamous Indo-chinese conflict where we lost our 35 brave soldiers.

[@uchatila1053]

Blunders of intelligence and more than that high headedness of courtary of Generals!!!

[@kanvaljitsingh6912]

Excellent podcast. I too conducted a commemorative event at my University for Kargil Divas. Salute to our heroes.

[@yashmor8439]

thank you, jai Hind

[@kailashchauhan4494]

Jai hind sir, Manish sir is a true military leader

[@narendrawaldia2984]

Jai hind sir. I salute you.

[@yashmor8439]

Jai Hind, thank you very much

[@dayasharma3382]

It's a very very painful where top leadership blame towards juniors instead of accepting their own errors

[@uchatila1053]

If possible, please do Part2 with Major Bhatnagar ji again...............what a great discussion this was...............Forgotten Hero seen is the day made!!!

[@abhishekkumar-yu7fh]

As a civilians i feel energise n happy that army have such good officers n also thise who are not in the podcast.. having said so how agniveer can provide justice to this system at todays time, isn't it by doing agniveer system v ve repeated much more grave issue than even kargil. Although kargil story moved me. God bless all n may wisdom prevails

[@b.p.481]

Ur achievements, courage and love for the country at such a young age tell the whole story what must hpnd on that day when u wr asked to climb down. A big salute to u Major Bhatnagar sir❤ And the book is not available on Amazon, plz share the link.

[@utpaldatta1967]

An interesting and revealing conversation indicates that we must honor intelligence reports from the lowest link in the chain, which is always crucial for reaching the root cause.

[@chandrank2117]

Thank you very much Maj Gen Yash sir and Manish Sir for opening the hidden story of Kargil war eventhough at the belated stage. Expect more such stories

[@cdmuleys]

Mor Sir, I would request you to plz invite Brig. Surinder Singh so that we get to understand his side. Also, would be great to listen to Capt. Cheema who won point 5770.

[@jagdishkumar4419]

Sir Please have interview of Brig Suriender Singh to know what is happening on the ground.soldiers were falling and 15 Corps GOC was playing Golf. Let the nation know

[@randhawaz1]

Brig Surinder Singh died in 2021.

[@AkashSingh-kb5vf]

​@@randhawaz1 Who told you that?

[@vimalpatel861]

We are fortunate that we have Like Major Manish bhatnagar Army jounier officer. After fighting heavy with enemies still He is dismissed from army. But there is no any regerat about army in his eyes.

[@yashmor8439]

He is a solid officer, highly unfortunate that he got dismissed from service. Jai Hind

[@AKS-yi2qj]

One of the finest narration I have ever seen on Kargil war. Please keep this endeavour and spread the truth as much as possible. Best of luck to all of you great guys

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you very much, Jai Hind

[@rajeshchalva3201]

There is a very big problem with us. We don’t want to see reality and shy away from uncomfortable truth. We see everyday lot of such things. I am sure there will be awakening someday

[@nareshsobti4554]

Sir pls give my best wishes to Major Manish Bhatnagar .... nice to listen other part of story... sir he is so highly charged even he was wrongly convicted and court martial....it will be great if I once talk to him

[@yashmor8439]

Like a true officer, he moved on in life and showed no negativity towards the army. that is his character., Jai Hind

[@Rajpuri25]

Dear sir kargil diwas ki shubhkamnaye,, we love you respect you a lot and eatire our brave armed forces ....jai hind jai bharat

[@yashmor8439]

jai Hind, Happy Kargil Diwas

[@KapilKumar-sr3pg]

@Manish Bhatnagar : Each word is True

[@sdatta7754]

Hat's off to a true war hero, Major Manish Bhatnagar ! 🫡 Who pointed a finger, where the hapless late Saurav Kalia and his men couldn't ! 🙏🏻

[@mohmadjawad5260]

We are proud of our brave soldiers and brave officers who sacrificed their lives to save our land. jai Hind

[@GambhirSingh-x1b]

Major manish sahab asli warriour hai

[@thesciencebeyond]

Appkey prashansa purn shabdo key liye hardik dhanyawaad. Yeh mere aarmy jeevan kee sabse badee kamaee hai. Thanks once again.

[@MukeshKumar-nd4gb]

What a podcast, what a podcast, thanks Gen sahab, new generation ko sachai se rubru karwane ke liye. Ye ek case study hai, ye reality hai young officer ke junun , jajbe,josh ki. Thanks a lot. Hum apke podcast ka besabri se intezar karte rahate hain. Weldon & keep it up sir.

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you very much, lot of truth of the Kargil conflict now coming out. Nation above everything else. Jai Hind

[@vikrumjaitly]

I must say, you are a brave soldier Major Manish!👍

[@GurmukhSingh-oo4vu]

🙏🥇🥇🌟🌟🇮🇳🇮🇳RESPECTED SIR🇮🇳🌟🌟 YASH MOR SIR 🇮🇳🇮🇳🌟🌟🥇🥇NATIONAL HERO KARGIL WAR SIR SALUTE ALL OFFICERS INDIAN ARMY OFFICERS SPECIAL WIN PROUD OF INDIA SIR JAI HIND BEST WISHES GURU JI GOD BLESS SIR 🇮🇳🇮🇳🌟🌟🥇🥇🙏

[@yashmor8439]

Jai Hind, thanks for your support and encouragement sir

[@majorsinghuppal3218]

Respected Mor sahib ..why can't Bhatnagar be not reinstated in Army

[@nareshkumarsinha2195]

Eye opener General Mor. It is known to all informed that the Kargil war was ill conceived and fought with poor planning. But we did not know that the better battle hardened planners and strategists were sidelined by the so called hierarchical superiority. Reforms based on experience and honest feedback in every sector is the key to achieving excellence. Though, it is generally ignored in every sector basically borne out of the self centred approach and vested interests of a selected few which ofcourse comes at a cost to the nation but if it happens in armed forces, it does not only prevent you from bringing in improvement in the learning system to achieve excellence but also results in preventable loss of precious human lives of that number which we saw in the Kargil war. Good to see you people taking pains for the course correction. Loopholes in the form of vested interest need to be identified and sidelined in the better interest of 'Ma Bharti' and at the same time officers like Brigadier Davinder Singh and Major Manish Bhatnagar are not made to suffer. Such reforms are necessary to keep the morale of the armed forces high. I am sure your efforts will bring in some positive outcomes in the times to come. Bravo.

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you very much for your positive response, I always have believed that nation above everything else. Jai Hind

[@chandraunni7067]

Great Interview. Having served in the sector I could visualise what was being narrated. It is sad such brave Officer became a victim of circumstances.

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you very much for your response. Jai Hind thank you for your service. Which year was that and with which unit?

[@RockingRaghv]

Please have a podcast with Brig. Surendra Singh also, as he has been fighting for his honour for the past 25 years.

[@rahulrawat-xp2nf]

Good to know military has honest and brave sons like these two

[@saapntamang2356]

मेजर मनीष भटनागर साहब मेरे पलटन 1/11जी आर पालमपुर की छाऊनी मे नए नए आए थे। जवान ऑफिसर जोश से भरी हुई, मिलनसार, हंसमुख, दिलदार, किसी से कोई शिकायत, ना किसी का शिकायत। ऑफिसर, जेसीओ और जवान सब के साथ दोस्ताना संबंध थे। मेरे पलटन मे तीन साल सेवा करने के बाद 5 पारा एसएफ मे ज्वाइन किया। कारगिल की लड़ाई में यालदोर,,(द्रास सेक्टर) उनसे अन्तिम मुलाकात हुई थी जब वह अपनी कंपनी को लेकर ऊपर चढ़ाई कर रहे थे। उनके साथ जो नाइंसाफी हुईं है वह बेहद अफसोस है। ऊपर वाले ऑफिसर ने अपनी नौकरी बचाने के चक्कर मे मेजर भटनागर साहब को बलि का बनाया। जय गोरख जय भारत मेजर भटनागर साहब।

[@Bhama-f8x]

जय भारत जय हिंद की सेना। सेना के अनुशासन को ध्यान में रखते हुए भी अपनी बात और सत्य को आपने उत्तम तरीके से सामने रखा। जय हिंद

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you for your feedback. Jai Hind

[@AjayLakhanpal-xm9mm]

Major Saab thank you for your service from FLORIDA, USA. Saw your podcast on Vaad also. Truth can never be hidden. Coming from a military family, I would have pissed my pants just on the words COURT MARTIAL. But you proved yourself and you did not go into anonymity “yaar mera court martial ho gaya”. Yet you love the fauj from the bottom of your heart and you are helping us improve. Since you were commishened in 1/11 GR which I will command in my next life, this is my dream. Saab chodnu naa!!!

[@thesciencebeyond]

Thanks indeed for your heartfelt comment. Deshbhakts like your good self are treasures of Bharat Mata. Jai Mahakali Aaayo Gorkhali. Har Har Mahadev. The former is war cry of 1/11 GR and the latter of 5 PARA (Special Forces).

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, Jai Hind

[@RAJKUMAR-ui8wo]

Kargil victory was a classic case of exceptional bravery. But intelligence failure to ascertain moves OF adversary made THE SOLDIER to pay dearlly for the lapse.thanks very much.

[@rohankapila9741]

If you listen to the interview, it was not intelligence failure, it was failure of generals who for some reason did work up on the inputs provided by the intelligence

[@hukmaram5810]

Intelligence failure nhi tha bhai.. General's ki nakami rahi..ye Gen mehangi whisky peene or young lady offrs ke saath hi busy rahte hen..

[@mahendrapalsingh1851]

Jai Hind to Gen Mor sahab n Bhatnagar sir, I understand Bhatnagar sirs problem, kyonki me bhi 1990 me Ist glacier se utara tha, tub mentally n physically rest chahta tha, vo mujhe mila peace posting, jai Hind ex Hav MP Singh

[@yashmor8439]

Jai Hind, thanks for your message.

[@hemantsolanki3676]

Siachen Glacier ke posts ke Baray main Jyada batav

[@harikajigurung4038]

Big salute,bar bar sunne ka man karta hai.Thanks for giving us real story.Hamein sadeo chokanna rahna hoga Internally & externally.I had also participated & experienced the Kargil war.Jai Hind Jai bharat.great great Maj Bhatnagar sir.

[@yashmor8439]

Thank You very much, jai Hind

[@birbahadursingh42]

One of the best officer i have seen during my army carrier

[@colonelgoel]

Wish Major Bhatnagar spoke in Hindi. Gen Mor Sir, your voice is sharp and crystal clear unlike Major bhatnagar, whose voice sounds garbled. Wish the whole interview was clearly heard n understood a your voice is General Mor Sir. Kindest regards

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, jai Hind

[@colonelgoel]

@@yashmor8439 JAI HIND and RAM RAM Sir

[@surajtiwari2191]

This is the best video, Jai hind to Manish Sir,and thank you so much Mor Sir,jo apne Asli kahani ko samne laya .

[@ashwanirazdan3401]

Caption of this video is correct becoz of inefficient generals we lost lot of personals in Kargil which could hv been averted

[@arunmarwaha6724]

Major Manish Bhatnagar My Salutes To You Sir. ❤❤❤

[@gyanpodcastradio]

Major manish is the best leader . Present army chief ko unki uniform baa izzat lautana chahiye . He is best officer

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, Jai Hind

[@anmollatiyan3430]

Salute Major Manish

[@satinderkalsivlogs1492]

Great coverage Maj Gen Dr. Mor. Your POD Cast will definately force army seniors in improving system. Hope politicians too will think their role. Keep it up. Jai Hind

[@lakhvindersingh8990]

A Great Great video ,Thanks Sir by the depth of my heart,waheguru aap dono ko hmesha khush rkhe

[@yashmor8439]

Jai Hind, thank you sir

[@gaurishankarpandey62]

If possible there must be a re-enquiry about major Bhatnagar, so he can live with the glory and pride

[@surindertalwar1932]

Sir this episode of the podcast is an eyeopener.

[@TXSrinis]

Absolutely unconscionable that competent, brave officers were victimized and worse, punished, while higher-ups apparently were found to be either incompetent at best or negligent/complicit at worst! Terribly disappointing that COAS as the ultimate authority did nothing to hold himself and his staff officers accountable. Instead, brave lives were needlessly sacrificed. In any other country, an After Action Review would have been conducted to unearth facts and learn from serious lapses. Truly feel for these brave officers - they gave their all and received nothing in return! Shocking that the Court Martial proceeded with Maj. Bhatnagar’s dishonorable discharge despite facts supporting the contrary - i.e., supporting his contentions.

[@Bhama-f8x]

True and well said. Any right thinking alert Desh Bhakt would agree.

[@ankitrai5810]

I wish your guidance and teaching makes me reach to peak of my potential.. Happy guru purnima sir ..❤❤

[@prasnair72]

Thank you for this interview. Can you please also interview Brig. Surinder Singh?

[@ashokcarrol6279]

Gen Malik knew everything. His DGMO and staff had up to date info of daily skirmishes from Oct to May where the army was loosing officers and Jawans daily . Gen Malik briefed the Netas and babus and in Jan gave a presentation to navy in navy war room . The political dispensation headed by Pm Vajpayee his drunken partner Brijesh Mishra and a bum Chief of RAW were not bothered . To keep their political bosses happy the finance babus and mod did not bother and to get the chief away from their backs sent him on a useless trip to Poland and Czech Republic . Accountability of the defense secy and his minions including financial advisors should have been fixed as he is responsible for the defense of the nation . Incompetent generals the Div Cdr , corp Cdr and the army Cdr should have been replaced by the previous Gens who had served in the area . The nations higher defense organisation failed and was disgraced but saved by the young officers and ranks . Gen Malik Should have taken responsibility for the loss of lives and taken premature retirement to atone for the sins committed during his watch .

[@VermaRajinder]

Absolutely --- 👌👌👌 #89-90 it stated from Uri #91-92 Gulmarg - KaziNag Dhar #93 Kupwara Sector #94 95 Doda Kishtwar #96 97 Rajouri Ab kya bacha tha ??? Even a blind man given a Good Situation Update Map would have seen the Drift .... But Padmanabhan(then the most experienced 3* General had moved to Southern Command for a well earned, Chief in the Making Break and Khanna from Pune replaced him in Udhampur .... The Corp Cdr & COS in Srinagar too was just in !!!

[@RohitSingh-ux8bz]

Great hai Major saheb.❤

[@KrishanRawat-u9c]

Jai hind sahab, Only you have this courage, hats off to you sahab,you are now a distinct officer in my view sahab. Jai hind sahab

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you, Jai Hind

[@KrishanRawat-u9c]

​​​@@yashmor8439Jai hind sahab pls part 2 bhi lao sahab. Hum jaise apko or bhatnagar sahab jaise military geniuses ko or sunana chahtey hai. Jai hind sahab

[@yashmor8439]

@@KrishanRawat-u9c ok, we will bring part 2 later

[@BahoranLalYadav]

I salute to the major Manish bhatnagar, Dil se. Jai hind.

[@yashmor8439]

Jai Hind

[@vishalsonawane4795]

Jai hind gen mor sir apke sare podcast se bhot info milti hai jai hind ❤

[@yashmor8439]

jai Hind, thank you very much, effort is to bring good content, educational and inspiring

[@akghoshghosh5150]

I want to congratulate our Generals, Chief and PM Bajpeyi for sacrificing more then 560 Brave Soldiers who were sons, brothers, husbands and fathers. Why such Generals and PM were not condemned and punished. .

[@krishanlal423]

My salute to Maj Bhatnager

[@raghavendrasharma7184]

Great Soldier...Salute

[@sandeepgopalan4934]

It's a horrible reality mistake of General but innocent and Officers paid with their blood.

[@SanjayaGoswamy]

Gen Mor Sir was not aware wrt Maj Bhatnagar, though I was at Drass n Maskoh during Op Vijay as anchor OP. It's really saddening to see the actual reality and sad ending of unsung heroes. Kudos to you to have bring out the truth.

[@yashmor8439]

Thank you. Many such stories are about brave young officers. The truth about Kargil has just started to unravel.

[@SanjayaGoswamy]

Thx Sir​@@yashmor8439

[@hemantsolanki3676]

Anchor means?

[@SanjayaGoswamy]

Anchor Op means controlling the entire fire units ie guns in that area. It was 120mm Mors, 160 mm Mors, LFG, IFG, 130mm, 155 mm Bofors and MBRL Rkts. (Approx 150 guns and a Rocket Battery) ​@@hemantsolanki3676

[@मेवाड़ीमाटी]

Jai hind major sir ....army me kuch officer rank ke log bahut hi corruption or party or connection ke base pe pramotion le lete or lekin ache imandar officer ko preshan kiya jata h

[@chanderpradhan7385]

JAI HIND SIR ..CUDOS TO YOU SIR FOR BRINGING MAJ BHATNAGAR .

[@SahilSharma-ge3vn]

I wish k main kabhi aap se mil paun Manish sir.. salute sir

[@bhushanjadhav8640]

Mor sir! Thanks alot for major bhatnagar's interview! people know to second side of war as in blunder of few generals!

[@patriotindian3759]

Agree with Major Manish. Chronology of events should be studied and analysed.