संवाद # 126: Biggest fake narratives of Kashmir busted by Colonel Ajay Raina

[@adeepmalmotra9972]

My grandfather enlisted in Maharaj's Army back in 1944 when he was just 14 years old. He used to recount to us that, at that time, his uniform was too large for his frame, and his shoes were bigger than his feet. He actively participated in both the 1948 and 1965 Indo-Pak wars. After Nehru's decision to halt the 1948 war, some of our soldiers, who had already advanced near Muzaffarabad, had to remain in Pakistan, and my grandfather was among them. He spent a month there, and during this time, he was declared deceased. However, my great grandmother had a strong belief that he was still alive, and remarkably, her instincts proved correct. Subsequently, he became part of the Indian Army following J&K's merger with India. His views were similar to this officer, and, being a Dogra, I possess deeper insights into the on-ground realities.

[@aggarwalkaoor9002]

🙏👍

[@piyaraypandita9347]

सच्चाइयों पर आधारित बात चीत तथ्यों के साथ रखने के लिए बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद और आशा करते हैं आप आगे भी ऐसे ही सकारात्मक सोच और असली सत्य को अधिक से अधिक लोगों को अवगत करते रहे गे।

[@giansingh8771]

Col Raina, excellent

[@Tammy.Maverick]

Arihant bhai .. This one of the underrated podcast channel. Your own knowledge and conduct of the podcast is truly amazing.. 😄 Col Raina has uncovered quite a many fallacies that we all were thinking to be true. Thanks for the educational and thought provoking podcast 👌🙏

[@srinivasuluchitimalla5552]

😅😅😅😅..❤..❤....❤.❤..❤❤w

[@monicapilani6265]

Such a wonderful and clear discussion. Hats off to Col. Raina who has done such deep research

[@KG-bw1wr]

I am a Kashmiri pandit myself and what saddens me is the current state of Hindu youth especially in my own state, be it a dogra or kashmiri. During my childhood i once had to wait for my father near Rajinder Park which made me curious to read about who this man was and I was amazed and disheartened to realize that very few of my classmates knew about him. Somehow i got one copy of the order by Maharaja Hari Singh which Colonel Raina talked about (Last man standing) and i swear before man and god, I had goosebumps while reading that.

[@mohanrammishra4134]

P

[@KARAMBIRSINGHPARIHAR]

I am student and often read our Jammu Kashmir and Ladakh history Primarily Kashmir Civilsation of Shavism and Tantra. I am shocked that Nobody is talking about our ancient sanatana culture of Sharada Mata and Hinglaj Mata who are one of the important (52 shakti) peethas in Sanatan Dharma which are in "Pakistan occupied Jammu and Kashmir "was they call Azad kashmir (Pakistan)on "False Grounds"

[@vikrantsingh6711]

Dogras and J&K very well described. Thank you for putting forward the actual history of Dogra rulers.

[@binu_aikido]

When every other Podcaster is busy repeating the common narratives and copying each other for views. You Sir, are bringing unique and authentic content each time. I feel your channel is the most underrated.

[@732anoop]

Col. Raina.. Excellent discussion and for bringing clarity to the rest of the country.

[@Sadhana3662]

Col.Raina your submission of Nehru's suicidal decision to stop forces from pushing in from Uri on 10th January brings goosebumps. My late father was part of the young Indian soldiers equipped with kukris among other weapons eagerly waiting to attack.. Alas didn't happen and we inherited today's huge Kashmir problem... Dislike for Nehru due to this is among scores of 90yrs + Bharatiyas.

[@hardwarilalgangwar9344]

😊

[@nareshgulati7654]

It was 10 th Nov, not Jan I guess.

[@nareshgulati7654]

@ashwinzagr8This is also a false narrative created on hindsight. If supply lines were getting closed how could they think of sending them to farther Poonch, while Uri areas to b recaptured were nearer?

[@solitude9665]

Nehru and Gandhi are the biggest curse to Bharat Mata.

[@kndixit5637]

Super explanation

[@Madhav513]

Thank you arihant bhai . Please keep bringing these episodes more

[@abhishekkumartiwari1286]

Arihant bhai, aapke uper maa saraswati ki kripa bne rhe... Col. Raina is true gem... very informative podcast..

[@indojap1515]

Excellent episode. Thank you Col Ajay Raina ji , keep writing such books and put out the truth in public domain. You are doing brilliant job Arihant. Keep it up 👍.

[@Kimjongpun]

“22 October 1947 mein jab vo aaye aur hmare troops unke saath mil gye bcoz of same faith”☹️ We should all remember this as history has a fetish of repeating itself for those who didn’t take lessons the first time

[@Samurai016]

Brilliant podcast. Kashmiriyat means they want money property from Hindu but never wanted native kashmiri Hindus to be settled in Kashmir valley peacefully what a great farce it is.

[@nanosan5360]

That is quintessential Islam....that is what Islam is...rest is just hogwash...

[@MS-ov9sv]

I listen to so many podcasts...This is the best Guest on the topic of Kashmir....got so many facts and truth. Salute to Col Ajay Raina

[@b.k.chaudhari3053]

Sir अजय रैना आपने बहोत बढ़िया काम किया है पूरा भारत आपको जिंदगी भर ह्याद रखेगा

[@vjunloc1]

Ek number podcast, couldn't stop listening

[@ratnakarsapre9456]

JAI HIND Col. Raina Sir. and thank you for in-depth information on Kashmir. This angle of history was not known to us.

[@surendrasinghbhadauria5952]

Amazing facts brought out by Colonel Ajay Kumar Raina . Excellent knowledge and great historian in making ❤

[@biswajitnath7023]

Heart-felt thanks to Colonel Ajay K. Raina (Rtd) for this true/real narrative of J&K. Waiting for many more revelations of J&K's true history.

[@amitmahajan8613]

wow.... eye opener. need more such in depth interviews with Col Ajai Raina

[@piyaraypandita9347]

I am pleased to hear true history about Jammu Kashmir Hats off to Dear Col. Ajay Kumar Raina having depth of knowledge after having studied many books af author authors even those who have been writting with certian narrative of anti india/Dogra rule on the behest of British rulers keep Hindu Muslim rivalry live and creat certian elemebts like Jai Chands like people always because there was no counter of geo politics in the univerce the lone power in the world at those days is a realty. Please keep on writing the book about ethinic cleansing and Genocide of Kashmiri Hindus during last seven displacements particularly of 1989-90 of which you r yourself witness.

[@abbhii]

As per dis colonel revolting against puppet king of Britishers was wrong ..:D is he in his senses .. jus coz it was done by muslims its wrong

[@fatbob3256]

Absolutely fantastic podcast. Request use on-screen- maps also to explain various tactical scenarios & geographical locations. Most viewers donot know what's where & where's what

[@humblestudent633]

Also, I would request the host to ask guests for providing fundamental, baseline information to some of the specific incidents. I accept, I’m not well versed with most of the political events as a millennial.

[@AnkurRaina]

A wonderful conversation.. eye opener in many ways! Thank you col Raina

[@aumwork]

ये महत्वपूर्ण सूचनाएं मोदीजी जैसे नेताओं को आम नागरिकों तक पहुंचाने की कोई व्यवस्था अवश्य करनी चाहिए और इसका एक मध्यम हमारे विद्यालय और अध्यापक हो सकते है हर हर महादेव

[@anjlalexclusive8308]

Outstanding research based facts.Every citizens of J&K must listen to know d truth. Hats off to u sir.

[@RahulKilam]

You should invite writer and columnist Varad Sharma in your show to discuss Kashmir issue. The false narrative should be unveiled.

[@bandanamohapatra4906]

Thank you Colonel Raina ji for educating us about the cunning criminals of the world who can hide in plane sight 🎉🎉

[@Sadhana3662]

Churchill's wish to divide India into many princely states has been last week echoed by Rahul Gandhi in France where he famously explained India is just numerable princely states put together.😮

[@keerthyyalapalli7757]

The mindset of his forefathers still has it!!! O afraid to hv him as any manner of PM of the India and what circumstances may take place

[@samayturki]

Loved the conversation. Great work Arihant bhai.

[@BharatBased]

Col Raina is an eminent patriot & a proud Dogra & son of the soil. Jai Dogra Jai Hind 🚩🇮🇳

[@amantyagi251]

U mean Colonel Raina is from Dogra Regiment or Colonel Raina is from Jammu? Are folks with surname of Raina's from Jammu also. I thought folks with surname of Raina are only from Kashir. As a Tyagi myself we are in both Haryana as well as Uttar Pradesh so it is possibel for a caste to be present in newly formed boundaries of states compared to an erstwhile era.

[@BharatBased]

@@amantyagi251 yes, Raina's are majorly Kashmiri pandits but i heard him on one of his talks on Def Talks by Aadi and he mentioned he's a dogra himself. I'm a dogra myself but i was of the same perception that Raina's are pandits but it's always good to know something new.

[@BharatBased]

@@amantyagi251 he has always represented Dogras & Jammu wale.

[@ajaykrraina]

Hi guys. I am from Poonch in Jammu Province. Rainas are KPs but also Dogras from Jammu and HP. Thanks

[@amantyagi251]

Thank you both for clarifying one of my doubts. Wondering if Raina's of Jammu r Dogra Pandits? As a side note i am aware of the fact that Raina's are Sikhs also.

[@rajalakshmisundaresan9623]

Good,and thought provoking.

[@abhijitghate6042]

Arihant bhai, aap ek inspiration ho! Big fan of your work. I would like to have a video on book suggestions to read from you.

[@TD-nn4fu]

Wow, so enlightening!! A big thank you to you and our dear Coln Raina❤😊

[@meenakshiraina7236]

You must read Col. Ajay Raina's books on j&k history so much of things that we really don't know about our history

[@gauravprasad9353]

बहुत ही शानदार भाई, आप बहुत ही नेक कार्य कर रहे हैं. बहुत अच्छा लगा 🙏. बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद आपका. कोटि कोटि प्रणाम आप दोनों लोगों को 🙏. मैं गौरव बिहार से

[@th3_Northern_king]

Very informative video and this is the first tym I've watched full episode. Sir I've a question you are talking about which Pannu?

[@emperor615]

jo canada me baitha hai SFJ wala

[@th3_Northern_king]

@@emperor615 Oh wahi Pannu hai who have limited dayz

[@jasrotiashamsingh770]

Col. Raina thanks for sharing your research work n expose of false narrative. Your in depth analysis is a wonderful tribute to Maharaja Hari Singh ji

[@Bhadrakalishakti]

WOMEN all over the world are the first victims and casualties in any form of agression in times of war and even during peace!

[@TD-nn4fu]

It is a normal urge for any well meaning man to protect women from his own community, it's genetically ingrained to protect the gene pool of that community. When outsiders invade it is their main target is to rape women of that invaded land to break morals of the men of that land or area or community so that they cannot put up a front and surrender to the invaders!! Yes, women are a given casualty of War.

[@aggarwalkaoor9002]

Women and children

[@sunilfauji]

Gratitude for Col Ajay for sharing some facts even I.dont know

[@dherrajhari3177]

Ab kya? Facts fact hi reh gaye faujiji desh aapke saath Anantnag ki taaza gatna se aap armywale inn antakiyon ko nasht kardijiye phir chahe maujuda pm hee aapko kyu naa roke,humko karachi lahore nahi pakistan duniya ke Nakshe mei nahi chahiye

[@ranjitjadhav6145]

इस्लामिक जिहाद जानता है कि वीटो शक्ति और सौदेबाजी की शक्ति से लोकतंत्र का फायदा कैसे उठाया जाता है।

[@dhoonadhari]

We need to share As much as possible Comments and likes are not enough😎

[@pimlico_qld]

Absolutely mind-boggling and shameful that Britishers left a bad mess courtesy Gandhi and Nehru and bad luck.

[@kiranbhaichauhan2070]

Great job done by u sir, col. Ajay raina🎯🎯🎯

[@gagster03]

Thanks for bringing out this truth

[@mistrymanishv]

Don't know how but we need an indigenous & de-centralised distribution network very soon for the correct narrative to flow through our society because relying on a US based network for too long would be another historical blunder.

[@surendrapaga1587]

Arihanth you are doing great service. Thanks. Hats of to col. Raina for busting false narrative boldly. His book will be a great reference for future generations

[@Invincible.Indian21]

Once a Soldier is always a Soldier... Indian Army man would never betray our motherland and say always truth 🇮🇳

[@mnsexim]

इस्लामियों को कैसे बुद्धि आएगी इसके विषय में हिंदुओं को अब सोचना छोड़ कर अपने भले के लिए जो भी करना हो करना चाहिए ।

[@JitendraSharma-im7xi]

It's Call "History Pe Prakash Dalna"👍

[@rashtrabhakt3002]

ज्ञानवर्धक कार्यक्रम। धन्यवाद।

[@daneilpatro2776]

assumptions . thanks for breaking assumptions of the general populus, only after this can we build back better

[@ajanthk9531]

Plz add english subtitles 🙏 It will help increase viewership 🙏🙏🙏

[@Vinod-b9e]

Million Salutes to Colonol Raina Sahib for his hard and honest work to bring out the truth and reveal the conspiracies by sick minded communists and British.... Salute to you , sir

[@sameermalik8485]

Very good interview by Colonel Ajay Raina ji

[@amarjeetsinghkala]

Absolutely right about the St Jospeh’s Convent. The author who wrote mission in Kashmir is Andrew Whitehead

[@anshulchoudhary7669]

U are doing a great job arihant ji....Col Raina like people should be given more podcasts in ur channel as they are true.

[@shan-tb2rg]

Excellent Podcast 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@barunsharma7622]

Thanku for bringing him.. for he is stating bare facts!!

[@studboys5931]

This podcast was an eye opener for me. Thanks for this wonderful podcast ❤.

[@Bhadrakalishakti]

Vistaar SAE AUR unbiased tarah sae Col.Raina nae samjhaayaa AUR durlabh information pradaan kee sabko!

[@profrajeshmaurya5078]

Excellent discussions

[@advaitavedanta3249]

Very nice sharing of truth. Thanks.

[@suj3919]

THANKS WOW THAT'S AWESOME KEEP IT UP FOR THE SAKE OF HUMANITY LOVE KINDNESS WOMEN POWER DIGNITY FREEDOM PROSPERITY JUSTICE LIBERTY FRATERNITY EQUALITY HAPPINESS ✌️👍👌

[@ParkashSingh-hk4jz]

V truthful & daring discussion about role of British officers in creating all this mess of partition & afterward invading incidents. Intelligent Role played by maharaza Ranjit Singh in dealing world power of that times(Britishers), Role of Maharajas of J&k, Muslim league leader ship, Role of Nehru & Gandhi during 1947period. Maximum indians are still ignorant about these types of facts . Thanks a lot

[@tejabnayak2025]

Aaj pehlibaar mene dil se har waord ko suna aur apne andar sametliya.🎉🎉❤❤👩‍❤️‍💋‍👩👩‍❤️‍💋‍👩🌹🌹🌹🌹🥰🥰🥰🫂🫂🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@name-xm3jx]

great podcast for knowledge

[@Poonamkatoch940]

Big thanks to col Ajay Raina🙏🙏🙏👌👌👌👌

[@andibandi5501]

Col. Raina is too good. Fantastic storytelling!!!

[@rogermilla2358]

Hearing Col. Raina for the first time here, very interesting; for anyone else who'd like to see more podcasts with him - he has several on DefTalks with Adi Achint.

[@sivabhakthai6101]

Arihant, Your reading of the book from the author actually excites them to discuss about their book which makes this podcast conversations more interesting. Great job. On Rainaji, Thank you for your service to this nation beyond. We need to make these narratives mainstream. Jinnah being Brit operative with documented proof is a revelation to me. Kashmir problem being carefully crafted by Brits was another. We need to get our land back.

[@Matter.of.fact27]

अरिहंत भाई, 15 वीं बार सुन रहा हूं ये पॉडकास्ट, रैना सर ने पूरा इनसाइक्लोपीडिया दे दिया इसमें। आप दोनों को साधुवाद।

[@prashantkatti118]

In all of Indian history I see one thing common is no unity amongst people. That's why the British won comfortably. Biggest reason for the failure of 1857 revolution was no one supported the sepoys when they rebelled. The Sikhs, Gurkhas and Dogras fought for the British. They fought for them again in first world war 1914-18 and then again in the second world war. So when you are yourself willing to be a slave to your master then where is the fight for independence.

[@malikahmad8170]

As a Pakistani born, I totally agree with your comments, however, one should understand that India was never a unified country or a federation except the last 100 years of British rule. Again, the present boundaries of India is even larger than the British empire with the inclusion and amalgamation of States and princely areas. The reasons for Dogras, Sikhs and others fighting for Britishers was simple: they needed jobs food and money for their families. The Britishers still come to Nepal to recruit Gurkhas for the British army. During the US civil war, which was fought on the basis of slavery, the Balacks even joined the Confederate forces which was fighting against the Federal forces to preserve the institution of slavery.

[@anshulchaudhary4407]

@@malikahmad8170 check out the maurya and gupta empire

[@PramodKumarIndian]

हमारी तरह रहना है तो रहो, यह काश्मीरी का नहीं इस्लाम का सिद्धान्त है ।

[@mohanrenu6986]

Excellent podcast. So many fake narratives busted by Colonel AjayDriver Rana,but sadly only 6000+ views. This podcast should be heard by millions.

[@naveenparashar764]

Share it with your educated family members

[@shubhanshubagra5276]

Driver ? Rana ? Why so hateful ?

[@amarjeetsinghkala]

The Sikhs , Dogras and Nepalis fought for the British because the 1857 rebellion was fought under the leadership of a Mughal King.

[@gayatripatnaik3658]

Very informative episode...Bhai...🙏🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩

[@jaibharat8435]

Nice discussion ❤

[@somnathsharma8409]

Thank you Col. Raina to bring out the facts about Kashmir.

[@Naps56]

Eye Opener...fwding this to all my Kashmiri, Dogra and Punjabi friends. Tx Sir.

[@sanatan-theeternal9113]

Salute to you 🎉

[@shamsher9199]

Very nice. Hopefully 1931 will not be repeated.

[@bipashadeb8991]

Excellent talk show.

[@kamalkantsharma9588]

As the reality is coming out, it is turning villains into Heroes and vice versa.

[@pankajsathoo1256]

There was famous saying in Kashmir which goes as "Center ki chaal"

[@vm1-n9s]

बहुत जानकारी भरा podcast है, साधोवाद

[@SatishKumar-gx9zz]

Excellent performance

[@lulumohanty2991]

Indians should read all books of Col. Ajay Raina to know British role,Nehru"s foolishness on Kasmir issue.

[@Kimjongpun]

Vaad brings good content& genuine guests

[@nareshgulati7654]

Good insights Col Raina.

[@praveenbishnoi9728]

Arihant you are doing a tremendous job in educating the common man by interviewing good people like col.raina and many others, who in real sense have toiled hard to do research and brought out the facts that have been hidden all these years....keep the good work on....god bless you 👏

[@srineelimanadiminti9610]

This is a greqt conversation. Where did this gem hide all this while? Hiw come we dont know of such ppl n their wisdom?

[@yuvrajtyagi8054]

Thanks

[@yavesh4475]

Very very informative episode. Kudos to both of you.

[@GareebInsaan2020]

Eye opening podcast 👌👍

[@tapankumarpanda4689]

Nice effort❤

[@Poonamkatoch940]

Absolutely right col Raina👍

[@puneetparashar1024]

Just wow 👍👌👌🙏

[@Gopal_Patil]

On this issue need more podcast

[@amarjeetsinghkala]

Good points by Col Raina Sahib but I would like to add that the Sikhs of Kashmir also fought side by side the army and even before their arrival especially at Satarna(Baramulla) , Choora, Icchama, Attina and Kanihama. 6000 Sikhs got killed by the Tribals in Baramulla and Muzaffrabad and those who survived still rever Brig Rajinder Singh and Col Rajinder Singh Rai. But it’s really painful to see that Colonel sahab has absolutely not mentioned even one bit about the sacrifices of Kashmiri Sikhs

[@ajaykrraina]

I understand your agony but a lifetime of research can't be summed up in one single interview. If you have time, pl read Battle for Kashmir written by me.

[@MK-br3gl]

sicks did nothing

[@DHS562]

​@@MK-br3gl..but you should drink Gau mutr 😂