3 Scary TRUE High School Reunion Horror Stories

Some people go to their high school reunions, some people don't. One thing is for certain; these stories sent by viewers probably won't make more people want to go.
Listen to these stories + more: hypeddit.com/mrnightmare
Insta: / realmrnightmare
Twitter: mista_nightmare?l...
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@officialmrnig...
If you enjoy this type of content and would like to see more of it & support the channel, feel free to subscribe and turn on notifications.
If you want to send a personal TRUE story of yours, please send it through email: [e-mail]
Anything with poorly structured sentences and grammar will not be read, so please just make them neat and understandable. Please also state how you would like your name to be credited in a video.

[@mrnightmare]

Just a little messup I want to point out to clear any possible confusion: at 16:45 I meant to say "THEY thought..." not "she thought"

[@lachellee]

I love you Mr. Nightmare 🥰🥰🩷

[@BraydenFromWiiSportsOfficial]

its good

[@random.person546]

ok lol! i was kind of confused. love you 🩵

[@itsmattgreene]

Do you have a cold Mr nightmare?

[@BaileyDawnLewis]

dw bout it, thanks for the vid

[@jilliangleason6964]

High school reunions are already a horror story in itself 😭

[@Eliyahu_777]

I am Elijah

[@BurntWaffles27]

I am Dallas

[@Wat161]

Wouldn't know it has only been 2 years since I last went to highschool

[@smily1370]

wanna hook up?

[@NikoCigoj]

I am Niko, and no i dont want to go bowling

[@Hunter_shull]

Props to that neighbor in the first story.. he probably saved her from a break-in

[@Eliyahu_777]

I am elijah

[@josephbletsas6314]

Yes and the unidentified guy in the third story too, don't know what that Claire Foster lady was planning, but it didn't seem good.

[@aallyballyy]

💯👏🏽 we need more neighbors like that! He’s a lifesaver 💙

[@nsasupporter7557]

@@josephbletsas6314yes exactly! I still have so many questions about that story… what exactly was that party that they went to and how did that other guy know that that girl lied to him?

[@zombifiedpariah7392]

​@@nsasupporter7557If you can't tell they're all in it together, there's something SERIOUSLY wrong with you.

[@grgurlesar6010]

the last story was a breath of fresh air. it was so different and memorable, wasn't predictable like many others and it was more of a bizarre mystery that actually keeps you awake at night thinking because it has no conclusion. i hope for more stories like this in the future, maybe a video of stories of this type. it was really interesting

[@nsasupporter7557]

Yes, what exactly was that story all about? He didn’t give much description… what exactly was that gathering that they went to if it wasn’t a high school reunion? And how did that other guy know that he was lied to by that girl?

[@ElGuapo408_]

@@nsasupporter7557 probably some weirdo rich people party. Where at the end of the night they kill and sacrifice somebody or eat somebody that’s why they were probably all staring at him. Like some cult 🤷🏽‍♂️🤣🤣

[@oliviamorgan1864]

@@nsasupporter7557 it could’ve been human trafficking, a weird cult initiation, etc..

[@roysailor3031]

Some “Eyes Wide Shit” shit going on.

[@reearn]

@@nsasupporter7557I reckon the reason the guy knew the girl was lying about herself was because they were involved in some sort of illegal activities such as a cartel, cult, trafficking etc and she has tricked guys like the person in the story before and he wants to save the guy from getting sucked into whatever thing everyone at that “high school reunion” were doing

[@cashverhil4883]

The 3rd story deadass is truly one of Mr. nightmares best stories in years!!!! We need more stories like this that just has a way of keeping people guessing.

[@Dark_Tales_Library]

AGREED!

[@peezy1942]

FR best story in a while

[@walterbrunswick]

That house and those sounds had freaking The Shining vibes going on 😮

[@SamsungAndIphoneuser]

What's the music/song called throught the beginning of the video?

[@matthewcassar1395]

You say it as if he wrote it himself lmao

[@magiloulou]

Man, I really like that last story. It was hard to tell where it was going, and even at the end it's still creepy and mysterious!

[@aniaadamson7970]

Any theories? Mine is cult. They asked personal questions and even in those tight knit communities there's always someone who knows its f*up and can't get out, but try to save others. The guy who warned him was on a younger side, so maybe he was also a victim of "Pheobe". Also he knew "Pheobe" wasn't her real name, and sometimes ppl in cults take up new names.

[@angel_in-black]

I just assumed she was looking to rip him off somehow and those ppl knew what she does and the questions and looks were an attempt to make him uncomfortable and leave cause they didn’t want to see her hurt another guy. Good thing it worked.

[@mercyestrada393]

I believe she was the owner of that house

[@yoboitheo334]

@@mercyestrada393I was thinking the same thing!

[@Ncc0990]

At first I was thinking one of those real life murder mystery dinner parties. She may have been the owner of the house and was planning on _using_ the storyteller as the victim. But I’d probably say a human trafficking scheme of some sort.

[@lw3269]

Who gets in a car with a random stranger? And gives them their address and phone number? Good candidate for the Darwin awards.

[@crystalm2931]

I was thinking the same thing, got in the car with a literal stranger

[@ElGaymer2001]

You hit the nail on the head with this comment

[@AS256]

not everyone is bad, of course it was just bad luck for her that the dude had immoral intentions.

[@jenniferwhite2945]

​@@AS256no not everyone is bad, but regardless... It's ridiculous to ever get in a car with someone you just had a 2 min convo with... Who couldn't give you any concrete names and admitted most ppl don't know him. Then give him your address and drink what he gave you... All the while him telling you to drink a lot... And the seal was probably broken and she didn't even pick up on it. Thank God she has smart friends and neighbors... She's as gullible/naive as an infant.

[@SaraVicious88]

For real, I can't believe there are still people that fucking stupid out there 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@IsaacPK]

That third story is probably the best one I've heard in a long time, had me on the edge of my seat and left me extremely curious

[@ElmoElmoSWAZILAND]

Same, I want to know more

[@nsasupporter7557]

@@ElmoElmoSWAZILAND yes, There are still many questions unanswered… what kind of party was that?? How did that guy know that Phoebe was lying to him? And how come she was lying to him in the first place?

[@olympia5758]

@@nsasupporter7557 Some people said it was a cult, and other people said it was a human trafficking ring. They were going to drug the guy and see him off to the highest bidder. The house was probably being rented, that's why there were no cars around, which would make it difficult to trace the guy's disappearance back to them. And as for the other guy warning him, it's known that in some cults there are still a few good people who are trapped and can't get out, so they try to warn others to stay away. I wouldn't be surprised if this story is true. Shit like this happens every day and can happen to anyone. You think it would never happen to you until it does.

[@dantheman2116]

Bro I deadass started sweating listening to that shit

[@yuliiastelmashenko8650]

​@@nsasupporter7557I'd place my bet on some kind of human trafficking auction, that's the sole thing coming to mind upon hearing the story (and boy, is it scary!)

[@jonathankozenko]

Mr. Bathroom Guy in Story #3 might be the most unsung hero of any Mr. Nightmare story.

[@Maximus5775]

Exactly 😂

[@LILCHEESE99]

"We here to eat human dawg, you should go"

[@simp_4macy212]

the person in the first story got VERY VERY lucky to have good friends looking out for her and to have a wise neighbor looking out for her too. that could have gone very differently and im glad she’s ok

[@Destroyer94100]

Glad she’s ok but getting in a car with a complete stranger and then giving them your phone number and address is actually insanely dumb.

[@gareebinsaan343]

Real horror story:- kzbin.info/www/bejne/joa3nH-pnsSihZIsi=y376NWrHek0qCP7x

[@SamsungAndIphoneuser]

What's the music/song called throught the beginning of the video?

[@davidl570]

@@dicarlospizza Well, if nothing else, the third story seems awfully fabricated. I'm trying to give that one the benefit of the doubt, but it's really hard to do---seems mostly implausible.

[@darth_kal-el]

First story was clearly a creepypasta. Made up.

[@sasqule8321]

I really liked Story 3. At the end of the story, I just kept asking questions to myself. What were the intentions of the people in the party? What was this so called party? Who was the man that helped the protagonist and why did he help him? It does a good job at making the viewer speculate. What are your theories on this story?

[@Juan.Padilla1998]

Perhaps the guy is probably a undercover cop or agent getting info about this "party"

[@EchoNarcys]

Personally, I think the most likely scenario is that the woman was "bait" for a human trafficking ring of some sort. It's very common to have women be extorted into supplying victims to these organizations. The lack of cars at this rich house and the non-existentence of the host makes me think it wasn't owned by anyone and was rather rented for the occasion. It would make sense as it would be harder to trace any crimes back to anyone. I presume that eventually they'd have tried to drug/incapacitate him in some way and send him off to the highest bidder. Granted, this may still be a stretch. I'm not sure of the location of the story or the exact "vibe" in the house. Maybe it was just a sketchy party where he wasn't welcome and he was just going to be robbed? I love stories that are left without a conclusion. Those ones are the ones that keep me up at night thinking

[@camallamadingdong69]

I think it was a cult. Sounds like everyone was skeptical of the "outsider" and that's why they were staring at him and asking really weird and personal questions. I was honestly sitting there thinking that it would end with Pheobe having brought him as a sacrifice or something lol. The guy that told him really confuses me, because anyone that chose to come to a party like that obviously didn't have good intentions, so as to why he told him to leave, I have no idea. Maybe he just came to steal the food😭😭

[@ZeniththeAnimator]

Maybe like some scientology shit

[@muza45]

@@camallamadingdong69yep it’s was some Masonic cult for surr

[@spoontoof]

that last story was probably one of the only mr. nightmare stories that left me wanting more answers. there have been stories similar to this, but this was just so weird and felt so off, it made me want to know what that party really was. good job as usual

[@wilxa]

Can u tell me the name of the vids with similar story as the 3rd one

[@spoontoof]

@@wilxa i don't really know any of the videos in specific, but thee have been a few with the classic "guy goes to party and something is off about everyone in party". the only one i can actually name is one of nightmare's older ones where a guy delivered pizza to a family gathering where everyone was wearing animal masks, and even then i don't remember which pizza delivery vid it was. but if you've been a mr. nightmare fan for as long as i am, you're bound to find some stories that are somewhat similar to this. not because they're fabricated, but because they're fairly common.

[@ziggymantis]

​@@wilxakzbin.info/www/bejne/h6TKnKiegcp6aMUsi=q7q3CqiXbcKLrfFR the first two stories are very questionable

[@SpideyWebSlinger111]

probably a cult. definitely one of my favourite horror stories from mr nightmare. it was just so different.

[@makwa2004]

The real high school reunion horror story is having to see people you hated in high school again.

[@migi3976]

It’s already happened once or twice to me so far, what’s even worse is when they act like they were your friend and that nothing bad ever happened

[@Blaze06]

Now that I read these comments I can’t wait to see the hell that might be caused during my high school reunion in the next few years lol

[@maximesaindon3552]

THIS ^. So many people in my high school were massive hypocrites or just straight up jerks. Probably why we had the highest suicide rate of any high school in the entire state.

[@nsasupporter7557]

@@migi3976yes exactly! I never understood the point of high school reunions, It’s not like those people were your family or anything… I mean, I understand that everybody’s different and some people actually do wanna see their old school mates again but it’s just not worth it. And like what you said, you had enemies in high school and they act like nothing ever happened when they see you again 🙄

[@nsasupporter7557]

@@Blaze06I graduated in 2005 and I never got anything in the mail in regards to a 10 year reunion in 2015

[@avian.shmavian]

no matter how good-looking or charming somebody is, if you're meeting them for the first time you do NOT get into a car alone with them.

[@susanpage8315]

Exactly. Ted Bundy is a good example.

[@avian.shmavian]

@@susanpage8315precisely.

[@drabnail777]

And women still wrote to him...AFTER he was convicted.

[@trekswithnick]

Take notes women

[@nataliep501]

Or let them know where you live

[@SillyLittlePookie]

Hey guys a few safety tips for things. -if someone claims to know someone in your group/school ask them specifically who and how they met. -go ask the person who they claim to know. -do no leave with someone you just met. Bad idea. If you are going to leave with someone you just met, see if you can bring two people with. If you cant, dont leave. If you are going to leave, tell every single one of your friends who you are leaving with. Even shout “HEY GUYS IM LEAVING WITH ____” to the room of people. Do not leave with someone you just met. Its better to stay by your friends.

[@glowboy6098]

That last story really does sound like get out. Even the guy in the bathroom saying you should leave is something that happens in the movie

[@Spiralredd]

Which makes me wonder who she actually was and why she brought him there of all places.

[@Juan.Padilla1998]

I really enjoyed the last story. Hopefully, Mr.. Nightmare can make three scary stories dedicated to that "reunion cult-like party" i theorize the guy who helped the protagonist is probably a undercover cop or agent getting info about this "party" and putting an end to it.

[@noahrichardson3472]

Yes, you're definately on the nose here. I was thinking something similar.

[@HalloweenHalloween-sc4jo]

How would the undercover cop know that he wasn’t one of them though? Just because the OP of the third story was most likely younger than everyone, I don’t that would be enough to convince someone that they weren’t part of whatever was going on.

[@margeebechyne8642]

@@HalloweenHalloween-sc4jo The creepy way they all kept staring at him would be my guess.

[@robwest5457]

Because everyone knew each other there. Phoebe was known for bringing outsiders and many of the regulars were getting tired of it. But because she has high status in the group, they couldn’t say much.

[@dallaz7048]

It definitely seems like he walked into a cult gathering. It would be interesting to know exactly what it was

[@lonewolfnergiganos4000]

A notification from Mr. Nightmare is like a Christmas present no matter what month it is.

[@Eliyahu_777]

I am Elijah

[@BraydenFromWiiSportsOfficial]

@@Eliyahu_777 hi elijah. Im keisuke 🤔

[@gravitythrills5414]

Actually factual

[@tigerlord9302]

Ironically he did upload one of his final videos of 2023 on Christmas Eve. 😁🎄👻🎃

[@PunmasterSTP]

It can also be like a random compliment or finding a $20 bill on the ground 😃

[@cursedcancersurvivor]

That lady in the first story breezed through so many red flags, she was speedrunning to become a skin lamp.

[@egc998]

Genuinely wondered what the gathering was actually about in the 3rd story.

[@BlackBSolz]

Right? I wish more comments talked about the stories than just sucking up to Mr nightmare I love this channel but I miss when ppl actually commented about the content 😂 but yeah it def gives me cult vibes and she was up to something sinister

[@ryanstruiksma8185]

Definitely some kind of cult

[@jadenbryant9283]

​@@ryanstruiksma8185or atleast a some type of mob

[@user-dc9oq2pr6v]

@@ryanstruiksma8185 it was a Democrat meeting

[@Maximus5775]

@@user-dc9oq2pr6v😂😂fr it was a matrix meeting

[@will4525]

The last story has to be one of the best ones featured on this channel tbh

[@HarvestHollows]

It’s already been said by many other people here, but story 3 was truly captivating. It actually felt unsettling with how many unanswered questions it just left me with. More stories shared in the style of that story would be so appreciated

[@robmack8342]

The last story was great. It gave me "Hostel" "You're Next" etc kind of vibes. Phoebe was definitely connected in with everyone there. The party seemed normal but the stares is the key. It's like they were sizing him up. A cult makes sense too. I'd love some more info on this.

[@Spiralredd]

No more get out vibes.

[@garrettbays6942]

I graduated high school over 20 years ago, and never had the urge to go to a reunion. My years there weren't terrible, in fact, I had some real nice times there, but I was not sad when I graduated. I don't keep in contact with anyone I knew there anymore.

[@bridgetbenson6291]

Same boat I'm in. Although I graduated in 2000 so covid was the excuse for no reunion. I was cool with it

[@melissagrant4178]

That how I am, I graduation in 2013 I never have any friends, so I was like I am not going to any reunion

[@garrettbays6942]

@melissagrant4178 I was lucky to have one or two, with the exception of my girlfriend at the time. We broke up about a year after we graduated. Later, my former friends and I just didn't share the same interests, and we all went to live in different areas (though unfortunately, me and my wife had to move back to this area because of lack of employment where we were living), and we just stopped talking. No loss, though, as far as I am concerned.

[@nsasupporter7557]

@@bridgetbenson6291 I never understood the point of high school reunions, especially these days now that we have social media, all you have to do is keep in touch with them on there

[@phantomvampyressshadowkiss4690]

​@@bridgetbenson6291wow I graduated in 99. Have no desire to go to any of my reunions lolz

[@phantomhurricane666]

here in england, a school reunion is just a bunch of old school friends going to the pub and discussing the old days.

[@phantomvampyressshadowkiss4690]

That's much cooler than usa reunions lolz

[@M.Aaltonen]

Now that's a high school reunion I wouldn't mind going to. Even though I don't drink.

[@skull_crusheryt6579]

Honestly going to a dive bar with some good friends would be the best reunion

[@emilkoch4098]

The person in the last story got very lucky. Great content as always man.

[@Spiralredd]

Yeah Get out literally had me and my wife holding each other from fear.

[@avantesiller9596]

The last story made me rewind 3 times, it was confusing to how it was going to end but it was worth it for sure. Thank you Mr. Nightmare!

[@boapdog]

same

[@osbaldohernandez9174]

Same

[@dxcive]

story 3 is the type of storys i love, its just so many questions like what is that party really for? is everyone in on whatever weird shit she got going on? if so whats taking them so long to execute this setup/plan, why is they staring at him ,who is da random dude & why is he so mysterious & holding back information but also being direct at the same time (if that makes sense😭) whats yall thoughts on it? personally i think its some sort of cult but i honestly have no idea what kind

[@animationlover2944]

Could be a human trafficking circle. Have you ever seen the movie hostell? Really fucked up movie sbiut a group of traveller's going to a town and turns out everyone in it is involved with getting people in so they can make money off of rich people mutilating and murdering them. Last story just reminded me of that

[@mrstravel9381]

I feel like it sounded like they were cannibals and the girl brought in “fresh meat” for the people. That’s why they were looking at him lol

[@aiyanyaqoob2203]

It was probably a cult meeting.

[@jujo2401]

the last story was the best mr.nightmare one yet. i really need an update on that one

[@emithemaster]

the last story was honestly bone chillin. this is exactly why we shouldn't trust anyone until we get to know them better through out time goes on. trust is one of the hardest things to earn, and it can end up horribly wrong if people don't take the time to get to know that person better. it was nice to watch this new video after a long and stress week of school :). keep making awesome content mr.nightmare.

[@hburke45]

There needs to be more people in this world like that wonderful neighbor from the 1st story!!! Always be aware and always help others when you can 😊❤

[@restock_1731]

That's one thing I'd never do, go to a HS reunion. There were alot of preppies, ugh. Great story telling as always. That last story was crazy, especially when the guy said get out.

[@melissagrant4178]

I never going to mine

[@Sacred_Fire]

I never went to mine.

[@nsasupporter7557]

Yes, what was that party if it wasn’t a high school reunion?

[@resetsetmefree478]

​@@nsasupporter7557it most likely was swingers. From how they described "Phoebe" it sounds like it's not the first time she was there either

[@nsasupporter7557]

@@resetsetmefree478 thank you 👍 I might need to listen to that story again, I might’ve missed some details. I forgot where he met her actually

[@arealmessagefromhell4875]

A “high school reunion” in and of itself is already scary

[@seomi.1]

thank you mr nightmare for supplying horror stories for 8 years. though i havent watched since you started, i have seen all of your videos. keep up the good work

[@Eliyahu_777]

I am elijah

[@TheDiamondCore]

Ah yes, a basic comment that doesn’t talk about anything related to the video at hand, posted quickly after the release of the video Totally not farming likes!

[@seomi.1]

@@TheDiamondCore ??? blud. how is it basic that im thanking mr nightmare. i genuinely love his stories and videos. i’m not like farming. i’m talking directly to him. i don’t care abt the likes. didn’t write anything about the stories cuz I don’t have my airpods. didn’t think i’d have to explain myself for complimenting mr nightmare.

[@TheDiamondCore]

@@seomi.1 it’s just that nearly this exact comment gets spammed by so many people the moment a new video comes out, and 9 times out of 10 it’s someone trying to farm likes. It’s fine that you enjoy his videos, I do too. But when you post a comment the moment the video releases that doesn’t touch on the subject matter of the video at hand, it comes off as like-farming even if you don’t think it is.

[@seomi.1]

@@TheDiamondCore okay???? clearly people appreciate him, and even if some of them are similar doesn’t mean they’re ’copying’ or ‘like farming’ chill out man. i appreciate his videos and that’s not a problem

[@kristyhite775]

Sitting at home sick this is exactly what I needed. Curled up in my recliner listening to the one and only Mr. Nightmare. I have my 20 year high school reunion in 4 years 2028 that really makes me feel old.

[@nsasupporter7557]

My 20 year is 2025, which is very difficult to fathom 😵‍💫

[@rominagresely526]

​@@nsasupporter7557 My 40 year is in 2028. I skipped out on the last ones, still not to 40 year either.

[@brentjohnson8057]

Omg after hearing you say that mine 2027... Life goes so fast the older you get I guess.

[@BlackSabbathfan]

Mine is 2029.

[@tyanabanana1147]

Girl mine is in 2 years lmaoo crazy how time flies!

[@eedenwalker9612]

My favorite thing about Mr nightmare is that he never changes, he knows what works and sticks with it, I've been watching him for 8 years and he still slaps!

[@goldfishsandwich9737]

The person at the third story really decided to stay for so long despite how obviously wrong the whole thing was and even had to be talked into leaving by someone else.

[@pxrkhali3363]

What do you think that party was, and what do you think the girl's intention was?

[@goldfishsandwich9737]

@@pxrkhali3363 It gives me weird suspicions of trafficking or some kind of cult of some sort.

[@pxrkhali3363]

@@goldfishsandwich9737 Yeah I was thinking cult too, I feel like if it was trafficking that guy wouldn't have advised him to leave.

[@KarRace77]

@@pxrkhali3363 I wonder if the guy was some cop undercover and that's why he told her to leave

[@ceaser273]

Idk why I feel like it was a buncha vampires lol

[@ItsRyanYT]

Been watching since I was 10 / 11 I am now 18 and Mr Nightmare is still producing bangers. Your longevity has been insane. The G.O.A.T 🐐

[@Eliyahu_777]

I am elijah

[@BraydenFromWiiSportsOfficial]

Cool. I've been watching him since I was 14 (2022)

[@Eliyahu_777]

@@BraydenFromWiiSportsOfficial I been watching him since I was young (kind of) (2016)

[@BraydenFromWiiSportsOfficial]

@@Eliyahu_777 Cool

[@mshourba27]

I’m dying to know what kind of “ party “ the last one was about if it’s a true story. Sounds like the movie hostel lol.

[@Spiralredd]

More like get out.

[@jacegallagher8589]

Had something similar to story 1 happen to me. It wasn't a high school reunion, but a reunion of other veterans from my boot camp division. The reunion was our division and our brother division, so about roughly 190ish sailors. I knew everyone in my division, but only a few from brother division. Anyways, we all got wasted of course. I was too wasted to even figure out how to get uber to get me so another "sailor" offered me a ride home. However, as we left, one of my best friends from bootcamp stopped me and told me that guy was not part of our brother division.

[@TheEvilSpiritOfBabel]

Like I legit need more of this. I avoided these scary stories at first because of jumpscares, but now I just watched almost every video because of the quality and how it is simply good! Though I will say I did not watch/rewatch the sleep paralysis ones, and that's because it really scares me, like being robbed is scary but at least you can try to do something about it. However, when it comes to sleep paralysis then no, you're forced to just live every moment of it and pray to God Almighty it ends quick... Anyways I wish you the best my friend Mr. Nightmare!

[@melissagrant4178]

I try watching spine chilling story, but it was instering, Mr Nightmare is creepy in a good way

[@Xeclius]

I'm still traumatized from that jumpscare in the sleep paralysis video 😢

[@kodoqbesar4301]

It's 4:30 AM at my place and I'm just gonna say that Mr Nightmare IMO is the Goat of scary storytelling. I subbed to Mr Nightmare in around 2015 when I'm still in middle school. Now I'm 22 and Mr Nightmare is still the Goat. Keep it up Mr Nightmare

[@theastonvillaseal585]

1 and 3 were absolutely terrifying. So many questions about that last story. What was their community doing in that house?

[@Spiralredd]

Ik like we need answers damn it and also why did she bring him there.

[@chancywancy]

Last story is PEAK Mr. Nightmare!!!! It was so unpredictable and scary I was almost biting my nails, need more bangers like that in the future!!!!

[@beautepley8352]

Mr. Nightmare if you read comments just know that I have a long drive at my job & you always upload right when I'm about to hit the road. So, thanks for putting these together. These spooky stories have my nervous system on high alert which keeps me awake when I drive...and very aware of my surroundings.

[@Push_it_in_hard]

I love how we’re getting videos way more regularly now! Thanks mr nightmare

[@Eliyahu_777]

I am elijah

[@oylumo]

@@Eliyahu_777 No one cares

[@Push_it_in_hard]

@@oylumoexactly

[@shahinarahaque2071]

The fact that just by watching Mr. Nightmare for a few weeks can make you look over your shoulders and check your windows more is just insane

[@asmodeus7672]

I love stories like the last one, it brings that eerie vibe to it which is my personal fav.

[@ninja1man4u]

So many years of videos and each one is a banger. Favorite horror Channel hands down

[@Zenitricious]

​@@Eliyahu_777i am* if you are gonna bot atleast get your grammar right

[@jadewest1712]

I love you and your videos, they are always so interesting and make me think of how screwed up people are lol

[@GamerDrewYT]

Sadly, some people are quite terrible.

[@Eliyahu_777]

I am elijah

[@sunlightangel87]

2 days before my 10 year high school reunion, one of our classmates was arrested for smothering his own infant son with a pillow because he "didn't want him anymore." After he called the police and told them what he did, he left the door unlocked for the police and just kept playing World of Warcraft with his deceased infant beside him. When the police came to arrest him, he told them to wait until he killed "this one last boss." Then he shut his game off and walked over with his hands out so they could cuff him. The baby's mom at that point had been called and their apartment neighbor, who we had also gone to school with and was in attendance at the reunion, told us that she screamed and wailed for at least 2 straight hours. This guy had always struck me as odd. He was the best friend of one of my high school boyfriends, and he was often accompanying that boyfriend to my house. I was always uncomfortable around him and he was one of the reasons that boyfriend and I broke up. I told him I'm sorry, I don't want your friend coming over. I don't know what it is but there's something really off about him. So he said fine if my friend isn't welcome here then I'm not welcome. I told him that was fine with me. This guy was a sociopath and narcissist even when we went to school together and it bewildered me that my then-boyfriend, who was his polar opposite, was his best friend. A lot of people were really wary around him and people whispered around the school that he would probably be the next mass shooter. He reminded us a lot of the Columbine HS shooters. He even would mumble that the people killed at Columbine "Probably deserved it." He's in prison to this day. He got a life sentence, but with the possibility of parole after 30 years. He should have no parole. He really seemed like the type of guy who would harm or kill people for fun. I attended school before there were mass shootings, but Columbine had happened by then, and the fact that he was sympathetic to them had always spooked me. I truly think that the only reason he didn't harm anyone or shoot up our school was because he didn't have access to a gun. His neighbor, who was in attendance at the reunion, had mentioned that he had seemed "weirdly happy and had said he was eagerly anticipating" the 10 year reunion. Which makes it sound like maybe he was planning to do something.

[@ethan-ray]

god i want closure on that last one!!! one of my favorite stories on here in a while

[@Spiralredd]

Get out followed through to the end. I wish it hadn't

[@ethanparkes8109]

9 years of a legendary youtuber keep up the good work

[@zacherypugliese6738]

Story 3: This so called (Phoebe) her actual name was Claire Foster was that she was acting weird from the very beginning and thank god younger guy warned him and told him to get out because they are probably a cult

[@starpeep5769]

tysm

[@growlithe584]

I just wanted to say that I've NEVER liked horror or scary stories/movies, until I started listening to all these Mr Nightmare videos!! His storytelling, pacing, voice, and the whole vibe of the audio is super relaxing and comforting, while being entertainingly spoopy. No crazy jumpscares or overly creepy music/sound effects, just pure storytelling vibes. I literally curl up with a heated blanket on my sofa and pass out while listening to these scary stories on autoplay like a sleep aid now. I've prob listened to 30-40 of these Mr Nightmare vids in the past few days LOL. Please keep making these for forever!!

[@andreasmakoben2455]

The 3rd story was horrifying. Sounded straight up like a cult party. Maybe he was tonight's entertainment 😳🥶

[@Spiralredd]

If that was the case wouldn't they have tried to stop him?

[@grandmaster1004]

High school reunion in itself is a horror story

[@JijiTheKat]

The third story reminds me to trust my instincts especially at a place where you feel unwelcome and vulnerable for possible negative consequences.. I’m so glad he left but why did that guy help him, and actually wanted to help him to get out of that situation? What were his intentions so many questions😳

[@DualShock4.]

Bro that third story was one of the best stories ever and got me mad crazy and trying to guess what was going to happen next.

[@abduliverse]

the last story has some "eyes wide shut" and as mentioned "get out" vibes. super creepy.

[@heatherphelps7379]

I've been binge watching his videos. I have been subscribed for years but i just am in the mood for creepy stories. Thank you for the amazing content 💞

[@Eliyahu_777]

I am elijah

[@lebowski-2386]

@@Eliyahu_777k bro

[@sketchbookofpatrick]

That last story has left me with so many questions!

[@YoutubeAccount-me3bv]

Probably a trafficking ring. Find out the names of people in a school, hire people to pretend to be those people.

[@InnocentComeng]

We need more neighbours like the one in the first story.

[@Emilaria]

If I wasn't already glad enough that I don't go to reunions, these stories make me know my decision is correct.

[@JohnSmith0909]

For some reason I got the vibes of a mass cannabal eating party from the third story. Anyone else?

[@carsxreverb]

Story 3 was a banger, great narration MR NM poor guy ended up on some “eyes wide shut” rich man’s gathering

[@DaveTexas]

Just hanging out with all the people I went to high school with sounds like horror to me. Being undiagnosed autistic back then, I was treated pretty terribly by nearly everyone because they all thought I was weird, rude, or antisocial. I had no idea how to fit in; everyone else seemed to know the rules of socializing in high school, but I felt like I was missing the instruction manual. I don’t have any desire to see those people again.

[@klarabarunovic9841]

Yeah, same... even thoigh I don't have any official diagnosis I know I'm not like most people and I don't know how to human lol

[@moomoo9973]

i basically grew up with Mr.Nightmare, so glad he's still going strong :D

[@MW93249]

Mr. Nightmare never disappoints. Thanks to him for 9 years of excellence 👏 🎉

[@shawnadennis613]

I wish everyone would stop putting this comment. No offense to you but it’s in every Mr. Nightmare video

[@Eliyahu_777]

I am elijah

[@Hentxa]

@@shawnadennis613deal with it

[@MW93249]

@@shawnadennis613 I don't comment much but oh ok

[@shawnadennis613]

@@MW93249I said no offense to you but everyone puts this comment

[@ImEmpath]

Thanks for the consistent back to back uploads Mr Nightmare been a fan since 2014 and im here 10 years later we appreciate you ❤

[@ElizabethW62]

That last story reminds me of Tom Cruise in 'Eyes Wide Shut' where he goes to the party. 👺 Thx Mr Nightmare, for keeping us entertained all these years! 👍☺️

[@thelion7929]

That last story was crazy! Thanks for the upload. It's always a pleasure listening to your unique narrations.

[@Mxtt_Hxll]

I wonder if Story 3 might’ve been some kind of cult meeting and they were gonna try and initiate her into it.

[@tannermarcus1381]

You have caught me by surprise one again, Mr. Nightmare.

[@Sniip3zEntertainment]

I’ve literally binged watched all your videos! W content can’t wait for more! ❤

[@TiannaMarie.]

We need MORE of these 😩😭😭

[@qualia8047]

I can't even imagine how horrifying these scenarios must be. 🎭 (Fun Fact. I was just listening to Mr. Nightmare stories on Soundcloud while playing video games. I love days like these.)

[@BraydenFromWiiSportsOfficial]

Fr. Some of these people's scenarios are just like, "Wow, you went through all of that shit".

[@AshtonBeamish-tx8fj]

2:17 is the most cliche thing ever "I saw you across the room and wanted to say hi"

[@destroylonely777]

ikr

[@HorrorStory3S]

This high school reunion horror story had me on the edge of my seat! The nostalgia mixed with the eerie atmosphere made it a thrilling watch. Can't wait for more!

[@AlexisAdrian00]

We need more stories like the last one; Where it keeps you invested & guessing what’s going on

[@justsomeguywithlonghair6595]

That last story, to me it sounded like a cult or something

[@Alexi-Raener93]

That's what I was thinking too.

[@ollieminecraft]

When Mr. Nightmare uploads, it's a good day.

[@paulgrimm6317]

❤❤ Your the best Mr Nightmare, it’s always amazing like I just started last night was to watch and listen to all your pod casts from the beginning to now. I always seem to pick up something I missed before ! Again thanks ❤❤

[@reedharrington6954]

The last story reminded me of eyes wide shut

[@mackenzieray3493]

The first story is honestly in my opinion the friends fault for just ditching her and going off to do whatever. If you come as a group then you should all hangout as a group or atleast include other people in conversations.

[@Indigo82790]

Love his posts, they help me relax at night lol

[@rebeccataylor5763]

Not even gunna lie, the knock at 15:14 deadass triggered my fight or flight lmao. My desk where I work is in front of a window I keep the curtains drawn over and I was boutta launch myself through it. A+ sound design. I hate you 😂

[@TheNtrLight]

The 3rd story with the pics you chose is great, give you the vibe of eyes wide shut, we need more of such ambiguous stories!

[@ll-rt8oi]

I swear, Mr Nightmare always uploads when we're about to sleep

[@ExUSSailor]

My 20 year reunion was a nightmare all by itself!

[@timothycurrence8157]

I'm literally like a kid at Christmas every time a new video drops!

[@deadlyagent9746]

Since I never had any real friends or good memories at high school, I never plan on attending any high school reunions for my town. Plus even less after this vid lol

[@KJP015]

Almost 9 years watching this guy. Mr nightmare never misses💯

[@Eliyahu_777]

I am elijah

[@ingainloggningsnamn]

So what are your theories on what that third "reunion" party was all about?

[@Tethos]

Human trafficking auction, or cult.

[@clothhhy]

What Tethos said. The guy that informed the protagonist at the end was probably someone undercover.

[@Fiona_Interrupted]

Hostel

[@Vivz-iq6hx]

Cannibals

[@tulipinavas]

honestly probably human trafficking, most logical reasoning. but, i do believe some of it could have been cult like, like a cult meeting or something

[@alicianason-yf8sc]

Such a good episode!!! I love this channel Mr. Nightmare always tells the best experiences that people go through.

[@InnocentComeng]

Kudos to that neighbour in the first story, if it wasn’t for him Miranda would have been hurt.

[@matayaarzu9776]

love getting notifications from you ❤️ just as I’m about to get into bed now I can relax and listen to your video ❤

[@ilyooo]

Literally had a stressful day at work. Always a nice surprise

[@kierrarogers4051]

Thank you Mr Nightmare for posting a new stories.Having a high school reunions should always be fun,connect with people you haven’t seen in a long time,hang out,have some drinks or something,reminiscing about the past times in high school,sports talk,school trips,concerts etc.Though sometimes there can be some people who just haven’t changed in their life.Keep it up with the awesome content,would love to see and hear more😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇

[@Shakir_Mash]

I just graduated and now I DEFINITELY don’t want to go back