3 Scary TRUE Valentine's Day Horror Stories

[@latimeriasdream]

That boyfriend in the second story was such a breath of fresh air considering all the stories where the narrator's significant other doesn't take their concerns seriously or is too scared to react. And the fact that he IMMEDIATELY pieced together what happened the second the tires went out and told the girlfriend to hide in the woods was such a massive relief. Happy to hear that they got married and are very happy together, that man is a keeper.

[@avspecter2268]

I’d be concerned if they were already hiding in the woods tbh. That would be a very weird position but glad he made the right call

[@Vijaythalapathy28]

He must have been listening to mr nightmare stories

[@levicool6631]

@@Vijaythalapathy28Mr. nightmare really is helping us men out

[@HappySmilingDog-d7u]

You know what would be even better - just call the police on them , they’ll have to bail

[@Bashycat]

Totally

[@EphemeralProductions]

The last story should be a HUGE cautionary tale to anyone who wants to invite people home they don’t know. ( for hookups and dating especially). You have NO idea what kind of crazy they have or how much.

[@bobdollaz3391]

Dude, No one should invite most people they DO know into their homes!

[@EphemeralProductions]

@@bobdollaz3391 I’m talking about dating and sexual wise

[@EphemeralProductions]

@@bobdollaz3391 true though lol

[@tablescissors]

If there was any truth to the tale…it almost sounded like sleep walking.

[@mustafaabdullahi4031]

He for sure missed the part where he probably caught STF 😭

[@sarahoftheshire]

I love when people say they’ll spare us the details directly before giving too much information.

[@mojo3318]

I didn't catch that.

[@reh3884]

Yes!

[@feelingtardy]

true, but he didn't describe any positions or anything so...lol

[@nicholasgalitzineismyman]

Tbh, I don't think it's that bad 🤷

[@theastonvillaseal585]

He kept it simple… also deffocation

[@luizfernandodonascimento3413]

"Im a very light sleeper, except when somebody trashes my restroom."

[@jeremyjjful]

ya right when I heard that I'm like "he didn't he that"?!

[@breerea9928]

Also she fell asleep with him at 1am but then he fell asleep with his buddy at 12am....

[@StalinLovsMsmZioglowfagz]

@@breerea9928 he's such a light sleeper, he flits right through time like a fairy

[@paigemontague4022]

@@breerea9928 Yes, I was so confused

[@ruisleipa7014]

​@@breerea9928im sayin like if ur gonna make up a story atleast make the timelines match smh

[@davidsallade2417]

Wow! The 2nd story was terrifying. Imagine being stalked by a creepy couple who had disturbing motives. At least the bf was smart to lead his girlfriend to hide in the woods.

[@GeminiladyJackson-xq6hc]

The creepy couple sounds like something from a horror movie.

[@jogermaine8600]

The worst part is that people will never believe old people aren’t naturally and automatically good. I caught an older couple rifling through my laundry at the laundromat and raised a stink. They said they were just trying to give me their dryer time (which made no sense, because I had more time on my dryer than would be left on theirs by the time they transferred the laundry) and the worker told me I was overreacting and to calm down. I rewashed everything and when I got home and started putting it away, I was missing three thongs. I tried to tell people and they were like, “Old people aren’t perverts, stop.” About two years later, the couple was all over our local news; they’d been arrested for kidnapping a young woman from a 24-hour laundromat and sexually assaulting her. The police think they might have planned to kill her but she got away and ran out onto a highway naked. I don’t think I was in danger, I think they escalated from just stealing panties.

[@reneleecy7685]

That is some creepy shit glad the women's ok n got away

[@UmarAli-tq8pl]

The story is a complete lie, lmao.

[@taracollins5597]

@@jogermaine8600 Wow, I am glad you were safe. That is terrifying that those same people were arrested for kidnapping & tormenting a girl. I agree with you in how so many people (including some COPS!) believe that 'old people are always innocent'. When I had my first car accident, I was 18 & only had my license for two months. An old lady ran a blinking red light AND a stop sign....my car was totaled, hers had a dented door & that's all. I had neck injuries & lost college class time.....yet she drove away. She never even asked if I was okay, she hollered at me to 'call the police'. There were no cell phones then, so a neighbor comes out & offers to do so. He was well-dressed yet smiled way too much.........he never called! Luckily atruck driver came by & called. The woman was 80 years old (she tells us this) & is 'worried about her sandwiches' in the car. She tells the cops I was coming awfully fast. WHAT??? I had a blinking yellow-light, she obviously never saw me as she drove through the light & sign! YET THE COP TOOK HER WORD!! Turns out he never even gave her a ticket(!!!!!!!) so my insurance company balked at paying anything! I had to sue her, which gave me no money but 'paid my hospital bill & my attorney'. That's it. One day, I Googled her rather-unique name. Turned out this bitch lived to be 100! So I do know what you mean.

[@mistybloo52]

Let the third story be a lesson to all, just cause you're alone on Valentine's Day DOES NOT mean you go and find a rando to hook up with. Be careful who you invite for a good time, noy just on Valentine's that goes for all the time!

[@AlfieTrevor4444]

They could shit and smear it on your bathroom mirror

[@MAXIMVS_XXXIII]

@@AlfieTrevor4444 Or they are possessed and they try to kill you in your sleep ... 😉

[@Cooper016]

Yep, too much shit to deal with at the end of it all. ...Sorry.

[@adamasagitprop]

5:30 A.M after the V day isn’t really V day anymore 😅😂

[@nsasupporter7557]

@@AlfieTrevor4444 right, you should never hook up with a stranger let alone sleep with them

[@Gumbo367]

That poor guy in the last story deals with a demonic woman screaming like a banshee in his face and then literally finds shit smeared on his mirror!? What a classic first date lol

[@bironjames9948]

Gotta stay away from these jezebels man

[@robertotrevino9737]

Hahaha 😂😂😂

[@miathehotdog9983]

She probably took large amounts of drugs

[@jasondyrkacz8270]

Was that woman Amber Heard?

[@Cjaiih]

🤣🤣the shit on the walls made me laugh

[@HeisenbergFam]

Mr. Nightmare is the perfect person to watch while eating

[@hugpalsyrobolk9986]

U r the best

[@missnunii]

Exactly what I’m doing rn😭

[@cyb3r.punk13]

HeisenbergFam

[@Hash9377]

Facts

[@dinogt8477]

no

[@ArjGee]

The last story left me with more questions than answers. I thought the ex-girlfriend would have something to do with the second person. But apparently they don’t. Makes no sense.

[@jeremymacnamara1587]

Lol I know I hate when the stories get so off topic. He could have just said he recently broke up with his girlfriend and didn't want to be alone on Valentine's day

[@nbsoboleski]

Yes, I thought the 2nd girl would be a disguised version of the 1st. Or that the first girl decided to stalk him on Vday and try to take out girl #2. Hahahaha, "Girl #2!" I just realized how funny that is!!

[@supersaiyangrl3]

Right lol so irrelevant

[@ruisleipa7014]

Idk who else peeped ts but the timeline of the last story was all over the place too i mean bro woke up at 3am for the first time then at 5.30, then after that episode he yet again woke up at 3am lmaooo

[@issabraham]

@@ruisleipa7014i noticed that too looks like no one else did, doesn’t add up 😅

[@ZENITH_PHOENIX]

That last story was absolutely WILD 😭😭

[@AlfieTrevor4444]

........ Creeped me out and it grossed me out

[@GhostlyVisage04]

That one left me confused

[@tafsibhuiyan8730]

Fr. Bro broke up with his gf, had a tinder match, had a good night (got laid) and his bathroom mirror had shit on them like wtf 😭

[@GhostlyVisage04]

@@tafsibhuiyan8730 yeah but why tf did she do that. I thought the story would have something to do with his ex.

[@tafsibhuiyan8730]

@@GhostlyVisage04 idk she was most likely crazy. Or maybe the girl was his ex lol

[@infernoferocious7029]

Bro Anonymous never runs out of stories, so much has happened to them and they still live to tell about.

[@clonetrooper71]

Too good lol

[@jurper5428]

😂😂😂

[@hailey1550]

I’m mad that this made me laugh out loud

[@gigglypanda714]

Best comment!! 😂😂

[@drakeparkerson1841]

Lol

[@frost_ssjknight2928]

Mr. Nightmare is the absolute best thing to listen to while reading or doing homework.

[@gemvjio1543]

Agreed

[@d3vildogg4life18]

Totally agree

[@Milothemighty10]

I always enjoyed listening to his videos while playing Minecraft. I don’t know why something about hearing him narrate stories, while I’m adventuring through through the overworld just seems right…

[@DoubleA0902]

Or having a long walk

[@Happy-American]

Ikr lol

[@user35282]

Can we just have a normal valentine’s day? With Mr. Nightmare, no way!

[@everythingpnw]

What’s Vaneltine’s?

[@igorgmd]

@@everythingpnw a day when you go out with your date or a girl.

[@everythingpnw]

@@igorgmd Yeah I know he just spelled it wrong so I was being a smartass

[@utsavghai5008]

Magic school bus

[@italktoanimalsliketheyrehuman]

​@@everythingpnw Vaneltines Day LoL 😆 Maybe it's the alternative version for people who like to do things a little differently xD😅

[@Daslickflip]

That first stalker guy is a menace! Not only did he stalk the girl.. RUSSELL STOVER?!

[@GMYellowstone]

LOL! That made my night! 🤣🤣

[@shitneyb5562]

I agree, Hottie 6969, people these days.

[@Angyal_Angyal]

Hey, I grew up on Russell Stover's. 🤨

[@tekbarrier]

The Walmart of boxed chocolates

[@jostockton.]

​@@tekbarrierthey sell them at Walmart so that's not a really good insult

[@kellysong2256]

The second story was so freaking creepy 😮 That weird couple had to have been a husband-wife serial killer team or something equally horrific

[@NinjaZXRR]

like that episode of Black Mirror Locke Henry

[@Idkwhatimdoinghere042]

I thought it was a guy cause simba is a guys name

[@mikmik9319]

probably traffickers

[@monsterhanna6691]

Exactly what I was thinking! Either that or kidnappers.

[@jbkheshster1342]

MR NIGHTMARE YOU ARE COOKIN' 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@hugpalsyrobolk9986]

Fr

[@mr.incubus24]

Being a fan of Mr. Nightmare videos, we named our channel "Mr. Incubus"

[@JJJJJJJJJ-ct5lf]

True 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤎🤎🤎🤎🤎💯🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@EndOfSmallSanctuary97]

I love how bro in the third story is all like "hur dur i don't like the bar scene at all, not my type of fun" and then goes and hooks up with some random girl he'd just met from tinder, lmao

[@peachespavalko1980]

EXCELLENT POINT!!

[@Ligierthegreensun]

How..are these even remotely related? wtf are you on about lmao. So if someone doesn’t like bars they can’t use tinder for hook ups?

[@cirnosnumberfan6449]

​@@LigierthegreensunI think they meant that bars and Tinder both have creepy people, those are my two cents at least.

[@Ligierthegreensun]

@@cirnosnumberfan6449 but the storyteller didn’t say it was about the fact there’s creepy people? He just said he isn’t a fan of bars.

[@cirnosnumberfan6449]

@@Ligierthegreensun Like I said, those were just my assumption on what OP meant.

[@Iwannaps5]

Scariest Valentine’s Day story is forgetting your wife’s gift.

[@Ami-jc2oo]

Or husband's. 😭😭 (Not married)

[@TH-hy9kr]

My husband's and kiddo's are already wrapped and stashed in a cabinet with their cards. 💌

[@MechBeDrawing]

That is a great comment 😂😂

[@vilebasterd5729]

Scariest part is having a wife.

[@nihilisticbarbie]

@@TH-hy9kryou’re so sweet. hope your husband treats you!

[@mkfan6167]

I’m literally speechless after that last story

[@truthguy6318]

I suspect that woman 'alex' has multiple personality disorder.

[@Jimnaper23]

I really enjoyed it one of my favorite stories by him so far lately

[@PremierCCGuyMMXVI]

Kinda disappointing tbh That guy got lucky finding someone else and had a great night yet she did a full 180°. I wonder what happened

[@lalaforuuu]

I’m left with more questions than anything. What caused her to have a psychotic break? Did the person ever hear from her again? Did anyone else ever meet her? Such a disturbing story!

[@SorrowAvenue]

@heyoimlucca There is no way of telling what causes a psychotic break. They can happen to anyone, anytime. She may, otherwise, be high functioning and never got tested. I mean, I was diagnosed with stuff in my early twenties that I, never in my life, would have thought I had because I don‘t see or hear shit. There are definitely those that do though and they need medication. She may have already been tested and is aware of a condition she ha and that, paired with the unusual environment, flipped a switch. If she was on medication and didn‘t take it, that was unacceptably irresponsible of her. I hope she gets the help she needs.

[@CantripCaniac]

I don’t know what kind of world I’m living in now, but having an upload once every week or two is just flat out awesome

[@sevinlove438]

Being single on Valentine’s Day has to be the scariest horror story of them all😭

[@Koa04-24]

I honestly enjoy being single around Valentine’s Day. Otherwise, you have to spend a lot of money because according to society, how else can you prove you love each other besides spending $100 on someone?

[@Happy-American]

Unless you have a crazy girlfriend 💀

[@_iceeeee]

nah that means we get to save money😂

[@zynifi]

@@Koa04-24100? That’s too little for most people, they’ll call you broke if you spend less then $2000

[@meangreenbean]

Frffrfrfrfrrrrrr

[@CAProductions051]

Let’s go Mr Nightmare uploaded! My day just got better.

[@YWN.]

let go it Friday

[@scottmcgraw3749]

In the last story, the reasons for her waking up at 3am and smearing poop all over his bathroom is because the dude took her to McDonald's on Valentine's Day. LOL. Should have gone to Wendy's.

[@Poopmummy]

😂

[@MakaveliTheDon2]

Had the McShits

[@DanteUchiha-go5dt]

Hollering 😂😂

[@codysnider7017]

Motto of the story: shit happens.

[@Prettylilygirlminecraft]

Or a nice restraunt I hate McDonald’s lol like I know nice restaurants are expensive but sometimes you can find ones that are a good deal lol heck anything is better than McDonald’s 😂

[@emithemaster]

the last story is honestly a life lesson

[@tablescissors]

If it was true.

[@emithemaster]

It was true

[@emithemaster]

@@m3mory_leak344 LMFAOOO

[@RedCommunistDragon]

Way better than Dhar Mann

[@emithemaster]

@@RedCommunistDragon yeah fr

[@theastonvillaseal585]

That last story… terrifying 😭

[@ehudzechariahschmidt7036]

Ikr. I still have a lot of questions though

[@cirnosnumberfan6449]

I honestly thought it was more funny than scary.

[@bryanzoom97]

I just kept picturing the ring girl standing in the corner 😂

[@ehudzechariahschmidt7036]

@@bryanzoom97 touche

[@FisherStahl-ll1lv]

@@ehudzechariahschmidt7036ha yes

[@tuzzerz]

That’s a wild last story

[@shawnadennis613]

Love your channel Mr. Nightmare. Dealing with stalkers is a scary thing. I had to move all the way across the country to get away from a stalker.

[@Tiger_T1]

Video topic suggestions: 1) First day on the job stories. 2) April fools day stories. 3) Funeral stories. 4) Bank stories. 5) Museum stories. 6) Easter stories. 7) Hot air balloon stories. 8) Stuck in a lift stories. 9) Car wash stories. 10) Circus stories. 11) Office stories. 12) Bowling stories.

[@lionelmessithegoatLM10]

Yes

[@dewaldsteyn1306]

Unlikely for now. These are submitted from poeple who experienced it.

[@zachary151]

ive been watching your videos since i was in middle school!! im 21 now, turning 22 on the 6th. this is like an early surprise! thanks so much all these years !!

[@sydneysirls6988]

Sameee that’s crazy lol

[@SlipSlopSlurp]

The second story, sheesh. "Get out, there's not much more time before they get here" something about that genuinely freaked me out.

[@Vito23x]

Last story is crazy, girl really faked everything to defecate on the mirrior

[@AlfieTrevor4444]

She probably had sundown syndrome

[@jorgepais2876]

"I pooped in your mirror! And, by the way, I faked the 0rg@sms!"

[@codyeaster290]

I don't think she was faking it, I think what really happened was that while the author was sleeping, she went to the bathroom and either had a psychotic break or was taking drugs, leading to what happened after.

[@shawnadennis613]

Never go on a Tinder date!! What a freak. Omg this girl is crazy. Lucky he got away safe.

[@MarvinHartmann452]

I did that mistake once. I ended up getting a restrain order because the woman I met was stalking me for months after the one and only date I've been with her. Woman can be psycho too.

[@callum5977]

@@MarvinHartmann452 🤣🤣🤣

[@SuperSix4]

I’ve had several girls just come over to my house from tinder haha. They’d never met me before either no lie. Fortunately I’m normal for their sake but yeah it’s wild

[@shawnadennis613]

@@SuperSix4 Well I’m glad you had a good experience. Be careful though you never know what you’re really getting.

[@shawnadennis613]

@@MarvinHartmann452 I know what you mean I had a stalker, not from Tinder but it doesn’t make it any less scary. I did all the things to get him to stop, but he wouldn’t. I moved on the other side of the country. He doesn’t know where I’m at now

[@chasepup8591]

Dude in the 1st story was a badass. Very few of these stories have the main guys actually charging and pinning down the stalker.

[@ejburgess]

Must be a big strong dude

[@escapetherace1943]

she's 100% still with him for that 😂

[@LastHutt]

I like how the first story actually ended up somewhat good

[@rmcar549]

On the first story, Ben is smart enough to not make contact YET! Restraining order is just a slip of paper, enforceable AFTER the perpetrator makes contact.

[@challengegamer0377]

*Me about to go to bed* Mr Nightmare: "Allow me to introduce myself"

[@DantesInferno1996]

He's not jayzs brother, lmfao wtf

[@Mrs.Macabre]

Always the best time to listen

[@_QuickSloth]

Wow you’re on a streak! Keep up the outstanding work! I enjoy all of your videos!

[@Happy-American]

Same! 😁

[@tafsibhuiyan8730]

Same! 😁

[@luvva5861]

me tooo omg i love when he posts often because i genuinely have none left to watch 😂

[@rob.parsnips]

Are you guys bots? These comments have no specificity at all

[@_QuickSloth]

@@rob.parsnips I’m not lmao, but I can bet you the first two are lol

[@tannermarcus1381]

Wow, two videos in one week? Mr. Nightmare really is something.

[@daducknfrog6673]

2nd prime incoming?

[@JoeHarryMama]

I want more

[@SpacialGuy]

​@@JoeHarryMamaOk then checkout CreepyCrist he is like mr nightmare

[@DareToBeDeviant]

I'll never understand people who confess they "can't be alone". Work on that lack of self esteem a bit first before going out to grab a random stranger. You're not abandoned either. It's all in your smooth brain.

[@radegastov1570]

Luckily these people started turning into OF simps after quarantine

[@zombifiedpariah7392]

Damn calm down, Andrew Tate. You've never felt lonely before?

[@angelchavez4245]

@@zombifiedpariah7392Comparing them to Andrew Tate seems a bit harsh. Everything they’re saying is valid. A lot of crimes would dwindle down if people weren’t so desperate for affection and would go for anyone if they meant they wouldn’t be alone. Cuz they end up easily trusting people who don’t have their best interests at heart.

[@test1122lol]

@@zombifiedpariah7392 The classic emotional move of going for the character... Your reality is a reflection of your mindset, because the mindset is responsible for the majority of your actions. ‘Heartbreak? Good, now you have an unlimited source of energy you can channel in the right direction’ - Andrew

[@monsterhanna6691]

What does self-esteem have to do with it? 😂

[@sloany222]

TODAYS MY BDAY THIS IS THE BEST GIFT THANK YOU DUDE

[@finntube8278]

Happy birthday

[@hizeslayer]

Happy birthday

[@eyelandersendersoni2317]

Happy birthday

[@freedomconrad1087]

Happy birthday

[@luvva5861]

HAPPY BIRTHDAYYYY hope your day was awesome!!

[@Jayden-lr2mm]

Bruh the last story is the most disturbing one yet. Being alone and not having much friends but to also not have anyone to date is what concerns me the most

[@rogue7723]

I thought Alex if that's her real name was the ex girlfriend in disguise.

[@Curly4000]

I prefer to being alone and having no one to date. The worst is being in a relationship and still feeling lonely

[@Amber-yq9ee]

​@@Curly4000💯%! Feeling like a single married person or dating person is the WORST! Bc u care about them & STILL are alone. Typically alone w\your thoughts & thinking the worst! 🤦

[@Amber-yq9ee]

​@@rogue7723Yeah, That's where I thought it was going too. Or something along that lines. But it took a turn towards ... I mean psycho doesn't seem quite a strong enough word honestly!

[@ArjGee]

@@rogue7723Would’ve been a great twist, but how would he not recognise her if she was his ex. And why is the ex even mentioned if she has nothing to do with the second girl? Makes no sense.

[@Cheemsinasuit]

It's always a good day when you post new horror stories, I have been a listener since I was a kid and have always tried to listen to your stories. Thank you for being my childhood

[@kierrarogers4051]

Spending Valentines with a friend,friends,or family is always something to remember for life.Yet on a specific day there can be times when Valentine’s Day can be ruined by someone or something.All three stories from Mr Nightmare are the kind of stories that make you want to be prepared for another special occasion in life.Great stories from Mr Nightmare,you sure have come a long way.

[@ZombiePanda1776]

All these Tinder stories crack me up. Like, what do you expect trying to hook up with random weirdos on an app?

[@Welsh-Trials-Enduro]

I met my partner of 2 years on tinder. Its all about how you use it and taking precautions when first meeting someone.

[@sbvReskoo]

Yea me too met my gf of almost 4 years there. There are some gems if you not fall for all the one night stands etc.

[@arianal4684]

lmao lots of people meet people on there & nothing weird happens

[@bcbritt777]

Peopel have been meeting wierdos since life began, way before the internet or tinder 😂😂 a creep is a creep and they're everywhere!

[@Redwoodtree34567]

My friend and her boyfriend met on tinder, it's been 5 years they are together, they are going to marry next year

[@GavisSilent]

he’s popping off with these uploads and i love it

[@restock_1731]

Wakeing up to someone standing in the corner motionless sounds so damn freaky. Mr Nightmare brings the horror to life.

[@jamiluismaila9406]

What Mr. Nightmare has taught me : 1. Don't go into the woods 2. Don't go near white vans 3. Don't go outside at night 4. Keep guns in your house 5. Don't live in a house with a basement, attic, and/or crawlspace 6. Don't Drive 7. Don't work especially night shifts 8. Don't live alone, always live with another person that you trust like a family member or a friend 9. Never leave your house 10. Always keep all your doors and windows locked 11. Don't go into abandoned buildings 12. Sleep with a loaded handgun or knife under your pillow. 13. Don't go on the Dark Web. 14. Don't go to school just don't

[@chickenfried12]

9:25 lol she got married during the car ride

[@mr.incubus24]

Being a fan of Mr. Nightmare videos, we named our channel "Mr. Incubus"

[@grey-spark]

At the end, she says they got married. That's why she refers to him as husband even though he wasn't at the time.

[@greatmnn3868]

Then boyfriend now husband

[@monsterhanna6691]

She said FOUR years later. 😂

[@T_The_Asogian]

"Do not drink poison just because you are thirsty." Story 3 is a perfect example of that quote. T

[@abdulqudz89]

mr nightmare never disappoints.

[@phil6899]

He forgot to read on Alex's tinder, Interests: Late night poo smearing and bloodcurdling screams.

[@sealslime5340]

😂😂😂

[@dewaldsteyn1306]

Tf

[@chasesgameroom453]

You and Chilling Scares are my 2 go to scary channels. When I'm in a scary mood, I binge y'all's videos for hours. The commentary is perfect and you and Chilling Scares have the perfect voices for these style videos.

[@mediabiasdetector]

Just got off my remote job and was looking for something to listen to while cleaning/cooking dinner your videos always come at the perfect time 🙏

[@ravenleftfoot5368]

I listen to Mr Nightmare’s stories while driving long distances when I start to get tired. Within about three minutes, I’m wide awake and continuously looking in the backseat for something scary that might jump out at me in the rear view mirror. This is even during the daytime! What a great storyteller!

[@yearlyposts]

Mr Nightmare if you’re reading to this I’ve been listening to you since I was in high school and I STILL listen to you even as senior in high school! I even got my girlfriend engaged with your videos! You always make my days better and you’ll forever will be.

[@ladyaphrodite379]

You mean *reading 😁 I'm sorry to be that person that corrects other people 💀

[@fathergabrielstokes4706]

Mr. Nightmare would make the perfect Valentine Date

[@codyswingle5222]

What

[@TheTrueMonotheist99]

Pause

[@xikaarx2026]

15:01 why he said it so directly😭

[@Slytherin-v9b]

Fr

[@mrspookytales2112]

Absolutely chilling stories! Keep them coming, you've got a new fan! 🎃😱

[@sceevz7745]

That last story went from 0-100 real quick 😭

[@AlfieTrevor4444]

Ye

[@Nullmeo]

Being single and probably destined to die alone, is ironically the thing that’ll keep me alive longer because at least there won’t be an insane girl trying to kill me.

[@TaiderineU3]

Let Story 3 be a lesson on why not to invite a random you just met to your house

[@Alex30]

Was that Amber Heard in the 3rd story?

[@freedomconrad1087]

😂😂😂

[@starjunky30043]

That's exactly what I came here to say. Bravo.

[@dodiekoehler]

Amber Turd. 😂

[@schqrr]

that last one is just crazy wtf, I thought it would just be some sleepwalking thing until the bathroom part lol

[@goldyoutube7663]

Most people here luckily won't experience these scary experiences. Because they have got no one to have Valentine with.

[@natalieotter9455]

New Nightmare Means Slowly lulling to sleep. It's my favorite thing to fall asleep too. His voice and no jumpscares just completely lulls me into lullaby!

[@colejohnnyboyjuniorgaming4479]

YES!!!! Finally a story where the trespasser gets caught by the police!!!!

[@targgerty]

Literally you posting made my entire week.

[@owenturner3625]

That last one was CRAZY! 👏🏻🔥

[@shepburn1978]

Screw being polite. When you're getting stalked, you gotta do what you gotta do

[@mhmmhm1902]

you know the day is gonna be good when Mr. Nightmare uploads

[@DantesInferno1996]

Days been done with lol but ur point still ok

[@Addie._Mal]

I have been waiting for Valentine’s Day horror stories!! Thank you Mr. Nightmare 🙏🏻

[@ikejugend]

Third story must be Johny Depp’s 😂

[@arthurchadwell9267]

Amber Turd?

[@catlover-x2l]

It could be 😂

[@thequietestengine]

'I'll nickname her "Nicky"'. Didnt expect a giggle in a Mr Nightmare video

[@Urban-Legends97]

That last story was definitely the scariest! Another great video

[@venomousnate7263]

Yup. Had a feeling some Valentine’s Day’s horror stories coming.

[@romanz5189]

Story 2 is obvious those "husband and wife" were probably some criminals who may have planned to rob that couple or worse

[@SlicketRicket]

Dear Mr nightmare, you always come through when I’m having a bad day. Thank you sir

[@lindorplays5900]

"defacated and spread it on the mirror" is crazyyyy

[@ehudzechariahschmidt7036]

The girl Alex in the last story was just bizarre. I have many questions as to what was wrong with her and why she behaved the way she did.

[@chipramos2066]

Her behavior perfectly matches that of an evil woman pretending to be good

[@SusanTurner-yo9lf]

New to Mr Nightmare and completely addicted. Even during the day though I have got to check all my windows and doors are locked!

[@Mariam.m12]

Love how consistent he is with posting makes me happy

[@christiancervantes4264]

Valentine's Day is absolutely the worst every year that some of us don't have boyfriend & girlfriend, unforgivable but most or some of them are scary, creep, sicko, stalker, etc. during Valentine's Day.

[@jostockton.]

"most" lmao

[@mane42]

Loved the second story. It's always good when the storyteller or someone they're with is competent in situations like these.

[@deeaddison4224]

I listen to Mr. Nightmare religiously 😆 I never miss a video. Super calming and I love listening to his stories when I’m doing random stuff like getting ready for work or something

[@DavidLucero-xo7fh]

The second story is one of the best stories I've heard in a while still really curious what that old couples intentions were.

[@David_R922]

Agreed. Very mysterious. I would say kidnapping for trafficking, but adult couples aren't usually intended targets.

[@TheNonameHousehold]

That woman from the last story was a drug addict, the way the situation is described is very similar to all the cases I've had to clean due to overdoses. -Tucker

[@AlfieTrevor4444]

Oh

[@Donknowww]

That makes Sense

[@ashtynadams4163]

Thank you, Mr. Nightmare! You tell the best horror stories ever!! I just got my wisdom teeth out, and this makes me feel better!!❤

[@addiktion2fitness]

For over a decade and still till this very day no one can fuck with MR NIGHTMARE when it comes to these stories!!!!!!!!!!!!nobody!!!!!!!!!!! Keep dropping these stories Nightmare we all love you bro‼️

[@CloakofFear]

The creepy couple stalking was very insane

[@andrihenrysson]

Greetings from Iceland, just your favorite Icelander strolling by. Great job as always

[@NJDJ1986]

Story 1 - let's goooo! OP caught Ben, Nikki called the police , & the police arrested the creepiest man , Ben in Valentine's Day!

[@alexm.7295]

Whoa that last one took a turn! I was not expecting that 😧😂

[@Michaelmyers.1]

The scariest thing on Valentine's day is hating yourself

[@ShukakuTheCrazy1]

16:32 shes just standing there... menacingly

[@jacobwebster4942]

For a guy to leave chocolate on the porch of your house after continuously getting left on read over and over, shit man call the police right away. There are some people out there who aren't right and have some serious mental problems. Things can go sour like that, never ever take that shit lightly....men or women!

[@leesashriber5097]

Perfect timing, as always!! Love this and thank you😊

[@joey6451]

im so happy that mr nightmares videos have gained popular again!

[@PianoDoodlesAllDay]

Hey Mr. Nightmare! I love your videos and they seriously make my day and week when you post. An idea for you is to maybe do a video about follow-up accounts from old stories! Some of them have ended cliffhangers and that would be a SUPER awesome one to watch!

[@chrollolucilfer8406]

This has to be one of the best stories in your channel

[@Nisie23]

Story 2, She should've referred to him as her boyfriend the whole time, not husband as this story supposedly happened before they were married.

[@MarvinHartmann452]

I think you have a good nose to detect made up stories.

[@nhgdd4961]

But they're married now so she is liable to mix up the terms