🖥️ 3Blue1Brown vs AI TURING TEST!

[@varunkaranth7589]

This is fake obviously. Jabrils doesn't move his lips while speaking and Grant doesn't have any physical form

[@blapamaster]

Deep fakes my dudes , they are getting more and more real every day AI generated video looks so real this one almost got me

[@moth3562]

What do you mean fake? They very clearly talking to each other? If anything it was prerecorded and greenscreened, (voices sound different but they’re using different shirt-microphones, a bit of an outline over the tv, but they shake hands, which would be difficult to fake.

[@PydraxAlpta]

@@moth3562 woooooosh

[@moth3562]

Pydrax Alpta Oof I still don’t get it

[@moth3562]

Is the joke that the video’s AI generated?

[@Assault_Butter_Knife]

The giveaway for me was that AI often combined some calculus principle and then said that it's from essence of linear algebra, and vice-versa.

[@SandroRocchi]

Also because the AI generated the titles letter by letter, there were a few weird misspellings.

[@balsoft01]

Also it sometimes did weird stuff like inserting chapter name two times.

[@kennethburden1065]

It did that because 3blue1brown makes a series of videos on a certain topic and includes the title of the series on each video. So the “essence of linear algebra” is the name of a series he made

[@thomasesr]

All 3B1B have to do now is create several videos with the titles he got wrong, and he would be always right.

[@willful759]

Nasa wants to: Know your location

[@dimserene]

The taboos of Basel problem

[@AWESOMEEVERYDAY101]

lol

[@gJonii]

So Grant is handsome too. The world is not fair.

[@shanineedwards6894]

He's married! Lol

[@98danielray]

and he is young

[@ayushagarwal7631]

and very fit too.

[@sfs8730]

@@shanineedwards6894 wow he is married?? You got any sources?

[@martinn.6082]

Remove the timer completely!

[@roar779]

^ This

[@alephnull4044]

Not completely, but definitely a lot more time should've been given.

[@SjondeJongen]

Yes this

[@jogadorjnc]

@@alephnull4044 Yeah, like 30 seconds

[@randomguy263]

@@jogadorjnc I feel like 10-15 seconds would be good.

[@W4LL37SK83R]

I really struggled with grablige ardebran in school.

[@dragonsdream4236]

Wyatt Jackson time stamp?

[@BothHands1]

Me too

[@noahschuler6388]

9:00

[@sauce3165]

I always imagined 3B1B as Sal Khan with a cold

[@DraftyCrevice]

I'd love to see a video on grablige ardebran someday, sound really interesting.

[@nickpro8116]

Well, since there is pi_3 as the subscript, and we're raising e to that power, this probably has a lot to do with some crazy high-dimensional topology. Maybe even with quaternions.

[@sarangs8441]

Invite Daniel Shiffman for the Turing Test.

[@harshitjoshi3082]

It would be e really awesome

[@atrumluminarium]

PLEASE

[@ridhomaulana2627]

YES PLS

[@AlissonWololo]

Up

[@sayanmondal4570]

Yes

[@Witchydragon]

You're telling me 3B1B isn't a blue pi plushie toy?

[@RamkrishanYT]

Do one for linus tech tips I bet it will be a total AI win

[@Koisheep]

Now I NEED to generate the titles myself

[@rupeshmaharjan4293]

3B1B author speaks like he is still explaining mathematics. 🤣 Love his all vids though..

[@guilhermesignor8358]

or he just explain mathematics like he speaks

[@maerski5171]

i really like how Grant has been showing himself more, great vid

[@grandpawnshere2836]

ha ha ha ha ha "Will Grant pass the turing test?" I didn't know he was a robot

[@astropredo]

3B1B changed my mind! You are the man, Grant! Your Lin Alg series is truly amazing.

[@fzigunov]

1:23 - Takes a gun-shaped pi creature from his pocket

[@isaacsnowcarini4808]

Oh boy! LSTM is getting better and better From scoring so low in past challenges, it’s getting more and more accurate!! Would love to see it beating someone.. As always Jabril, amazing job! Keep doing what you do!

[@nikolayzapryanoff1032]

These are two of my eternally favorite people of all eternal time. I'm in total fucking love with this video. Seriously.

[@shanineedwards6894]

Grant

[@avi12]

Grant should make a video explaining in depth how Jabril's AI works

[@numoru]

Try a test where both you and an A.I. submit answers to a users questions/data and then see if the user thinks it was you or the A.I. creating the answer. This would be a better Turing test, because the guest know that the answers are from the A.I.

[@SkyfishArt]

The timer ruins it, he has no time to comment or even read the questions. It would be way more fun with no timer.

[@fburton8]

I'm sorry Grant, I'm afraid I can't do that.

[@MijeshDeuja]

Really fun video. Another one should be Daniel Shiffman from Coding Train.🤗

[@ranam]

I thought 3blue1brown author would be a old guy it s amazing that he is a young guy😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😁😁😁😁😁😁

[@jesust162]

At least still a guy.

[@techgo4431]

Sakthees Waran I actually thought he was young so I guess I was right maybe I am just good at telling a person age base on their voice lol

[@danielm793]

I thought he was even younger

[@JorgetePanete]

it's*

[@henloitsdiego]

Daniel M he has been out of his bachelor's for a couple years, so I'm guessing mid twenties?

[@schirmcharmemelone]

Here is an idea how to improve your turing tests: make the game pause when the player made a decision, let them talk about why they have choosen their choice. If you just keep giving the answer directly it feels rushed and the player doesn't even have time to face the camera! We were jumping through the questions with a few 'thats great' inbetween. But your viewers may not have any idea about who 3down1eye is or what are his videos. They want to talk about their choices but then the game just keeps going.

[@kevinmathewson4272]

3down1eye

[@anteconfig5391]

That makes sense. Every question should be timed but there should be a pause before the next question. Just so everyone has time to laugh.

[@zanidd]

woaah 3b1b! amazing, love his vids

[@gibemass6578]

I want a big ensemble video with the likes of 3b1b, Jabrils, Tibees, Mathologer being the Dad of the group, and minutephysics tweaking off way too much caffeine in the corner etc. Would either be heaven or hilarious.

[@theonetrueanthonylong1843]

AAAAAYYYYYYYY JABRILS AND 3B1B!!!!!!

[@travishunter8573]

This AI got so much better! Fantastic job! I remember when Dianna did it and a lot of the titles were gibberish

[@willful759]

Grablige ardebran is my favorite theorem

[@suwinkhamchaiwong8382]

8:40 for Funs

[@huhneat1076]

Video titles be like: But what's really going on here? | Essense of algebraic calculus, chapter 4 | squaring pi to get negative roots

[@gtpsleeper9]

great video again Jabrils!

[@cubbybear5326]

The collab of the century

[@t.k.-s.4212]

Watching this made me laugh so hard. Both were so sure at first, and Grant quickly understood that it's not easy. Enjoyed!

[@marco.nascimento]

what a legendary crossover

[@anteconfig5391]

lol. I'm upset at youtube for not recommending this video when it came out. I will now thank Bing for the suggestion. "Thanks Bing, you've done good."

[@cassian1879]

i didn't even know you could do things like this with AI. the future is wild man.

[@mandrake6486]

Its just based on probabilities nothing insane here.

[@Inspirateur_video]

it's actually pretty easy

[@martiddy]

This is actually the most basic stuff that AI can do, AI currently can do much more than this.

[@mandrake6486]

Vapor Wave - sama even picture analysis is more or less the same thing

[@rashidkhwaja959]

Natural language processing is one of the first things AI could do. It's not that hard. All it basically does is convert words/phrases into vectors and looks at what words/phrases are nearby in that vector space

[@dragonmanjoseph]

Love the video, keep up the good work!

[@danielrhouck]

5:36 I knew this one because I am (at least partially) responsible for the title. The original title gave away the solution by naming a different branch of math which wasn't obviously relevant, and there was a Twitter poll about whether to rename it to something much more generic, and I suggested changing the different branch of math to graph theory.

[@danielrhouck]

Other than that, a lot were easy (if you have more than 8 seconds) because it will have two different chapter numbers.

[@ladams00]

Jabrils, this was plenty of fun 😊

[@DukeBG]

Grablige aldebran is a noble and very complicated topic!

[@jumbo_mumbo1441]

I did not imagine Grant would look like that Anyways, what a humble class act. Thank you Grant for your phenomenal math videos and thank you Jabril for the amazing ML videos. 👏👏

[@weehoo999]

#1 collaboration 2018 goes to y'all

[@sortsvane]

The way you guys are referring the ai as 'he' is enough to pass the Turing test 🤣

[@dylanbaham3429]

I can't wait to learn ml! You're such and inspiration to me!

[@muhaimin244]

I felt a little bit close to grant when he said he was a slow reader. Though I know he's WAY WAY smarter then me. I don't know if there's any connection between being very good at seeing patterns and making connections, and struggling to focus on the actual words you're reading.

[@YahiaDesigner]

I don't know what "Turing Test" is doing in the title.

[@spaceowl5957]

Foxy Well they're sort of Turing testing his AI by seeing whether grant can discern between human generated titles and the AI's output. haven't looked up the definition of a Turing test, but I'm sure this isn't that far off

[@1996Pinocchio]

A turing test is a conversation between a human being and an AI (chatbot?). If humans can't tell whether they are talking to a human or a robot, the robot has succeded the test.

[@YahiaDesigner]

I know what a Turing test is. It has nothing to do with the video. You might as well say conv neural nets have passed the Turing test by identifying objects in the same way that humans do. Just because a machine is indistinguishable from a human at a certain task, doesn't mean that it passed the Turing test. The Turing test is a natural language problem.

[@1996Pinocchio]

@@YahiaDesigner I totally agree with you.

[@spaceowl5957]

Omg best collab ever

[@mihirsathe3482]

Sounds like the model really likes the phrasing "int the light of"

[@Nicbudd]

I kinda think the AI was overfitting a little just looking at this.

[@steliostoulis1875]

This is where the fun begins

[@shaillykeshari5408]

Great video :)

[@TheAgamemnon911]

Now 3B1B has to make all the videos that he guessed wrong.

[@neelotpaldutta2347]

Turing test is Grant perfect

[@kavinbharathi]

I saw other comments say the same, but I wanted to make it more obvious. _Invite Daniel Shiffman for the turning test_

[@MVTN]

I see that the LSTM is getting more points in each video, I see you are making some improvements. I have to ask, do you think that the network is really improving or is it the timer that is getting people to fail more? Amazing work btw

[@sol0matrix]

This is awesome I'm getting into Ai with nodejs and tensorflow

[@ianprado1488]

I love this video so much

[@Sahilbc-wj8qk]

Finally I see that guy I just here's his voice on his videos

[@AmCanTech]

Can you host the challenges as programs or websites too?

[@KatzRool]

Grant should have been a Pi Creature and Jabrils should have dubbed over himself.

[@mariusandersons]

best video in youtube

[@avi12]

I want to get Grant's Pi guy as a present on March 14, a.k.a Pi day

[@khurshedfitter5695]

I expected Grant to be older than that based on how much he knows. Or prolly he looks young.

[@farhannr28]

The answer is simple: Both of their voice are actually dubbing

[@readbooks6370]

This guy 3b1b has very powerful voice

[@pinkninja1410]

This is a very good video from 3blue2brown.

[@pinkninja1410]

I mean 1

[@pinkninja1410]

Fool

[@pinkninja1410]

What

[@oldbootz]

Huge 3Blue1Brown fan!

[@wotmate1440]

Top 10 Anime Crossovers

[@jerrysmith9592]

That's dope!

[@judedavis92]

It uses PyTTSx3 for the text to speech right?

[@jokeith2798]

Grants voice is all the why I came to this video.....

[@paulgarcia2887]

This is the first time I actually see him

[@veggiet2009]

What changes did you make to the bot over the physicsgirl game? I know you added the timer, but it does seem like the generation is better

[@ShaneClough]

Awesome too see Grant on this! As constructive criticism, perhaps remove the timer altogether on future videos. For most of these it was near impossible to read all the titles let alone think about which one is real. The challenge should be at the merit of the AI's "skill" and not on how fast someone can read. Still thoroughly enjoyed it though.

[@Omnifarious0]

I did about as well on Grant did. I got a few right he got wrong and also the reverse.

[@Spadalaable]

So there is an actual human behind 3Blue1Brown

[@Christian-mn8dh]

What software does he use?

[@atrumluminarium]

You can tell Grant is not a camera guy... He's barely looking at it

[@Gold161803]

You can tell he's not a camera guy by the fact that he's almost never on camera

[@purplewine7362]

@@Gold161803 lol true

[@kevinmathewson4272]

It was kind of nice, though. Grant put emphasis on the person-to-person interaction.

[@iminni3459]

Why does it only read out 2 of the 4 possible titles?

[@handsanitizer2457]

It's seems like misdirection.

[@Muskar2]

Probably to save time and make it easier. The reading is for the audience, not for Grant.

[@rodrigo_t9]

Cus theres no time to read more than two titles in 8 seconds x(

[@Goryllo]

you mean there's an ACTUAL FREAKING PERSON behind the voice of 3b1b?

[@taylortek5031]

Where are they?

[@Plaegu]

Wish Jabril would upload more😇

[@PinkShades]

You guys look like y'all are in the Matrix. I love it.

[@Jabrils]

wait.... youre NOT in the matrix??? 😦 - Jabril

[@PinkShades]

@@Jabrils I am, I just haven't figured out how to load my own training program :(

[@somethingsinlife5600]

POWERRRRR!!! POWER OVERWHELMINGGGG!!!!!

[@deathofthemagi]

This thing has come a long way since physics girl played it

[@PhilippeCarphin]

I expected Grant to look like the guy from Practical Engineering, I guess cause they have similar voices and I had only seen one of them.

[@johnchessant3012]

I want a pi creature! :D

[@DirtMaster]

a = w1 a1 + wn an + b Like if you recognise this equation

[@ribhuhooja3137]

neural networks! a1..an is the output of previous layer neurons, w is weight, b is bias, you forgot the sigmoid "squishification" function. A is the output value of the neuron.

[@ShobhitVashistha]

Could not play along, hard to read the titles on screen, too little time for any sort of deductive reasoning... take this as constructive criticism

[@flyingstapler]

I love the Kerbal Space Program music! :P

[@prfcttone]

Before I even watch this I wanted to comment because I was just talking about this with a friend of mine. Things to encompass areas of the turning test. So the first hearing of the turning test was during the watching of Ex Machina, which if you ever watch is a paranoia trip where the human ends up thinking hes the robot at some point and starts dissecting his arm to find hes, human. But things that should be involved I think. Spontaneous emotional feedback, ie a joke or something. Affection both physical and attachment. Will the machine miss or long for longtime relationships? If the machine is calculated enough, perhaps it will think it self flawed, be inspired for self forgiveness and a move toward compassion. I feel like compassion and tolerance are probably important programming. Things we take for granted, inherited from our Genes by way of our parents.

[@1996Pinocchio]

You can't programm emotions and it certainly won't develop in machines.

[@prfcttone]

@@1996Pinocchio that's not the story I recieved. You should realize that the idea of programming can be made all the way to chemical and biological platforms.

[@prfcttone]

@@1996Pinocchio chances are most of your life choices were already programmed in your dna. With only small variation in the details.

[@gitjohnson2264]

Jabrils moved his lips :o OMG bad AI

[@ivoriankoua3916]

I'm yellow and this guy is an INSPIRATION.

[@WiillZero]

"The determinant, essence of linear algebra preview Cross products in the light of linear transformations, essence of linear algebra chapter 6 Derivative formulas through geometry, essence of linear algebra chapter 8 Implicit differentiation, what's going on here?. Chapter 6, essence of calculus" HOW IN THE F*KIN WORLD WAS HE SUPPOSED TO READ ALL THAT AND MAKE COMPARISONS IN *EIGHT* SECONDS? Please. pleaaaaseeeee....

[@bluesoman]

You should make a second AI that has to guess along with the player and see who wins that.

[@HDQuote]

this is way too increadible

[@nicstroud]

I'm from the U.K. so can someone tell me where Grant's accent is from please. Previous to watching this video I assumed he was black. Does anyone else think he has a vaguely Southern, Afro-Caribbean accent or is that just my English ignorance?

[@nickpro8116]

He mentioned that he lives in the Bay Area, so he's Californian

[@mihailazar2487]

I like how robotic Grant sounds